Free Essay

Psychoanalysis of Characters

In:

Submitted By samirehman20
Words 1902
Pages 8
Psychoanalysis of characters When people think of psychoanalysis, usually one name comes to mind. This would be Sigmund Freud. Freud, along with Carl G. Jung and Alfred Adler, has impacted the history of psychoanalysis. Further, he has influenced the lives of the men and women during the early 1900s. In critical theory today: a user friendly guide, Tyson explains the critical theories of psychoanalysis and Marxism. It’s all about the studies of human behaviors for example, human mind, especially inner experiences, thoughts, feelings, emotions, fantasies, and dreams. I have chosen one book and a movie. In a book, it talks about James, who is a main character of the story. He was really confused about his identity because he was a black and his mother was a white. In a movies, they showed the racism and differences create between students in their childhood. Both of these based on true stories. I would compare these character with Marxism and Freud’s theory. A Black Man's Tribute to His White Mother is the autobiography of James McBride. It is also a tribute to his mother. It starts of the narrator James’s mother Ruth, who describes her early life with her family. She was born in Polish Orthodox Jewish family that was immigrant to United States. She had a repressed childhood in Virginia. She was sexually abused as a child from her father. In critical theory today: a user friendly guide, Tyson defines Fear of abandonment—“the unshakable belief that our friends and loved ones are going to desert us (physical abandonment) or don’t really care about us (emotional abandonment)” (Tyson 16). Tyson also comment on this definition if fear of abandonment is my core issue, I am liable to develop fear of intimacy as a core issue as well. “When we look at the world through a psychoanalytic lens, we see that it is comprised of individual human beings, each with a psychological history that begins in childhood experiences in the family and each with patterns of adolescent and adult behavior that are the direct result of that early experience” (Tyson 12). According to psychoanalytic theory, family is very important as we are a product of the role we are given up in family complex. Her father was an Orthodox rabbi named Fishel Shilsky. Ruth says he was as "hard as a rock. As mention in critical theory today: a user friendly guid, Traditional gender roles cast men as rational, strong, protective, and decisive; they cast women as emotional (irrational), weak, nurturing, and submissive” (Tyson 85). Mamah never felt love or affection from Tateh (the Yiddish word for father). Mamah was mild and meek, in part as a result of polio, from which she suffered her entire life. She was a patriarchal woman. For instance, Tyson explain it clearly that by patriarchal woman I mean, of course, a woman who has internalized the norms and values of patriarchy which can be defined, in short, as any culture that privileges men by promoting traditional gender roles (Tyson 85). They had arranged marriage. When Tateh failed as a rabbi, he opened a grocery store in Black area. Tateh, was racist, and overcharged his black customers. Ruth resisted her father's prejudices and sympathized with the black people in her town. This violation resulted not only in a loveless father-daughter relationship, but also in Ruth's overall low self- esteem. Despite the horror of the relationship with her father, she points out that she also has vivid positive memories of her childhood, particularly of the preparation for and celebration of Jewish holidays with her mother. After graduating from high school, Ruth moved to New York City and began working in her aunt's leather-goods factory. After that, she fell in love, and in 1942 she married a black man named Andrew McBride. By the time Ruth learned that her mother had died, she had been disowned, considered to be "dead" by her Jewish family. She converted to Christianity to deal with her feelings of grief and guilt, and ultimately found a new life in the religion. She and Andrew raised seven children. Andrew McBride died when Ruth was still pregnant with James. Then Ruth remarried a man named Hunter Jordan, who became like a father to James, and gave Ruth four more children.
While growing up, James McBride never knew where his mother had come from. When he asked her if she was white, she simply replied that she was "light-skinned", triggering a long-standing confusion about his own racial identity. Ruth's statement that "God is the color of water" succinctly captures Ruth's attitudes toward race and religion. Ruth believes that race occupies a secondary role to goodness and achievement. She believes that no matter one's race, hard work determines worth. She believes that God loves all races equally, and that goodness and devotion, not a certain race or class, make people worthy of God's grace. James's early life coincided with the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s, and he encountered the symbols and rhetoric of black power. This societal force left him conflicted over love for his mother and the desire to feel solidarity with his peers and neighbors. James discusses the sense of aimlessness he experienced in college and in the professional world. He remained certain of his passion for both writing and music, and eventually realized they were not mutually exclusive professions. His mixed race kept haunting him, manifesting itself in his behavior in the workplace and in his personal life. After floundering around in various jobs, never completely satisfied, James realized that his professional crisis related to his identity crisis. In pursuing her past, visiting Suffolk, and interviewing his mother, he offers the reader a stunning window into the life of a woman and a family that suffered and triumphed, transcending divisions of race and religion in favor of love, family, friendship, and community - powers that bridge the basic human desire to understand how another has come to be the way that they are.
Based on actual diary accounts of several teenagers following the L.A. riots, “Freedom Writers” is the story of an idealistic teacher’s attempts to make a difference in the lives of her at-risk students. The movie Freedom Writers takes place in Long Beach, California. A young teacher, Erin Gruwell, takes her first job at Wilson High School. Most of the students that attend Wilson High are gang members and juvenile delinquents where not even the teachers have faith in them. At first the students hate being in the classroom and don’t listen to anything Mrs. Gruwell tries to teach them. Most of Mrs. Gruwell’s students are more concerned with their place in the war that is happening between the races than sitting in a classroom. However, she finally captures their attention by talking about the Holocaust. She then asks them to write in a journal every day. The students start off defending their violent actions in the war, but slowly start talking about their families and more personal problems. The classroom eventually becomes a home to them and the students become a family. It is a place where they can be themselves. The students finally get a voice when they put their journals together into a book, called Freedom Writers.
There are a couple of historical events discussed in this movie. The one covered the most was the Holocaust. They took a trip to a Holocaust museum where they learned many different things about the Holocaust and the camps. They were able to learn all about a specific child, what happened to that child and whether they lived or died in the camps. Then they read the book Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl. The students also had a chance to talk to Holocaust survivors and listen to the story of Miep Gies, one of the people that helped hide Anne Frank and her family. This experience really made them think about how the violence in their own lives was starting to get out control. That was the real turning point in the movie. They also discuss the Freedom ride, a bus that drove around town where blacks sat in the front and whites sat in the back. They also watched an interview of one person that rode on the bus and offered to get off the bus first even though there was a crowd of people waiting for them. He was badly beaten when he got off the bus. This story really affected the only white kid in class. He could relate to that person because of the courage that person showed by getting off the bus first. The white kid showed courage by staying in the class even though the other kids showed nothing but hatred towards him at first. This is what inspired the title they gave the book the kids wrote, The Freedom Writers. The school didn’t support the students anyway. Even though, the teachers didn’t want to help the students in anyway succeed and their families didn’t care about schools. The only thing their families care about how to win the war for their race. For Marxism, “the family is not the source of the individual’s psychological identity, for both the individual and the family are products of material/historical circumstances” (Tyson 64). The family unconsciously carries out the cultural “program” in raising its children, but that program is produced by the socioeconomic culture within which the family operates. In this movie, each student’s character reflects the Marxism. How they grew up and involve in gangs. Mrs Gruwell helped the students with personal problems and talked to them like people. Also she listened to what they were saying and wanted to learn more about students. She spent a lot of her own money on books and trips that they took and it got the students interested in studies. The students didn’t have a voice before, and they always did what they were told to do. In the school, teachers did not want to deal with them and in the world they were fighting and killing. Writing gave them a way to say what they really felt and shows their overcoming obstacles and fears in their lives to succeed. In conclusion, Ruth - The central figure of the memoir, she is the tough but big-hearted mother of James and eleven other children. A Polish Jewish immigrant, she is spiritual, intelligent, determined, practical, and brave. She stresses the importance of work, school, and God. She chose an unconventional life, and succeeds in it because she has the grit and conviction to endure hardship. According to psychoanalyst, Freud “ The unconscious is the storehouse of those painful experiences and emotions, those wounds, fears, guilty desires, and unresolved conflicts we do not want to know about because we feel we will be overwhelmed by them” (Tyson 12). In the movies, as shown all characters went through different strategies and struggle for what they didn’t know directly oppose to Marxism ideology. For Marxism, “an ideology is a belief system, and all belief systems are products of cultural conditioning. For example, capitalism, communism, Marxism, patriotism, religion, ethical systems, humanism, environmentalism, astrology, and karate are all ideologies” (Tyson 56).

Work cite McBridge, James. The color water. New York: the Berkley Publishing Group, 1996. Print. Tyson, Lois. critical theory today: a user friendly guide. New York: Tylor Francis Group, 2006. Print

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Italian Essay

...Psychoanalytic literary criticism Psychoanalytic literary criticism refers to literary criticism which, in method, concept, theory, or form, is influenced by the tradition of psychoanalysis begun by Sigmund Freud. Psychoanalytic reading has been practiced since the early development of psychoanalysis itself, and has developed into a rich and heterogeneous interpretive tradition. It is a literary approach where critics see the text as if it were a kind of dream. This means that the text represses its real (or latent) content behind obvious (manifest) content. The process of changing from latent to manifest content is known as the dream work, and involves operations of concentration and displacement. The critic analyzes the language and symbolism of a text to reverse the process of the dream work and arrive at the underlying latent thoughts. Freud wrote several important essays on literature, which he used to explore the psyche of authors and characters, to explain narrative mysteries, and to develop new concepts in psychoanalysis (for instance, Delusion and Dream in Jensen's Gradiva and his influential readings of the Oedipus myth and Shakespeare's Hamlet in The Interpretation of Dreams). His followers and later readers, such as Carl Jung and Jacques Lacan, were avid readers of literature as well, and used literary examples as illustrations of important concepts in their work (for instance, Lacan argued with Jacques Derrida over the interpretation of Edgar Allan Poe's "The Purloined...

Words: 520 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Psychoanalysis In John Updike's 'A & P'

...What is you topic and your tentative thesis? My main topic or main focus is psychoanalysis which involves the readers to question the actions of either the author or the characters in the story. In this case I decided to explore the actions of the characters in the story and their motivations. I have to question the characters actions and evaluate what might had been going through their minds that lead them to their final decision. I have research Freud and Erickson to back up my arguements. My thesis statement still needs work but here it is: One can argue with the help of psychoanalysis the reader can find an explanation for the characters motivations, actions, and emotions presented in these stories "A&P" by John Updike and "The Rocking...

Words: 421 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Fgff

...Psychoanalysis and literature What psychoanalysis and literature have in common, and what psychoanalysis can contribute to literature: Psychoanalysis is a "talking cure"; language and narrative are fundamental to it. In a sense psychoanalytic therapy is the re-narratization of a person's life.As psychoanalysis deals with language and with interpretation, it introduces a significant approach to the hermeneutics of suspicion, the idea that there are motives and meanings which are disguised by and work through other meanings. The "hermeneutics of suspicion" is not limited to psychoanalytic thought but is found in structural thought generally -- the idea that we look, to understand action, to sub-texts, not pre-texts.Psychoanalysis deals with motives, especially hidden or disguised motives; as such it helps clarify literature on two levels, the level of the writing itself, and the level of character action within the text. A 'companion' level to the level of writing is the level of reading; both reading and writing, as they respond to motives not always available to rational thought, can be illumined by psychoanalytic thought. Psychoanalysis deals with many basic elements which we might think of as poetic or literary, including metaphor and metonymy; Freud deals with this particularly in his work on the interpretation of dreams, and Lacan sees metaphor and metonymy as fundamental to the workings of the psyche.Psychoanalysis opens the nature of the subject: who it is who is experiencing...

Words: 366 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Psychoanalytic Theory

...the way in which a movie could be interpreted as a desire or a dreaming process. Moreover, in the second part of the essay, the correlation which Psycho has with psychoanalytical procedure is explored, in an effort to discover its kind and if it is actually the first psychoanalytic movie. Following a short presentation of the main plot, it is necessary to examine the nature of the Oedipus complex and how it is applied to the movie. Despite the fact that it remains the central psychoanalytic idea in the film, is not the only Freudian reference; the movie could also be interpreted through “ego, superego and id” psychoanalytic aspect. Finally, it is imperative to “dissect” the two protagonist characters and the famous murder scenes under the psychoanalytic perspective. CINEMA AND PSYCHOANALYSIS Cinema is considered to be among the most important institutions of the post modern society,...

Words: 3841 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Dolls House

...Ibsen's Hedda Gabler - Use of Theme, Setting, and Time in Hedda Gabler Hedda Gabler, by Henrik Ibsen, is a work about a woman who manipulates the fates of others in order to fulfill her own desires. The title character...[ view ] - Pursuit of Freedom Depicted in Henrik Ibsen’s Hedda Gabler and Albert Camus’ The Stranger - One’s own Freedom is what one desires to control the most in life. Yet in both Henrik Ibsen’s Hedda Gabler and Albert Camus’ The Stranger, Hedda and Meursault do not have this influence over themselve...[ view ] A Psychoanalytic Reading of Hedda Gabler Rate This Paper: 1 2 3 4 5 Submit Length: 786 words (2.2 double-spaced pages) Rating: Red (FREE) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - A Psychoanalytic Reading of Hedda Gabler Attempting a psychoanalytic reading of a given text is a bit like attempting to understand a city by examining its sewer system: helpful, yet limited. There are several reasons for using psychoanalysis as a critical literary theory; the critic might be interested in gleaning some sort of subconscious authorial intent, approaching the text as a "cathartic documentation" (my own term) of the author's psyche; the method might be useful in judging whether characters are well-rendered, whether they are truly three-dimensional and, therefore, worth our while as...

Words: 1350 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Karen Horney

...On the 16th of September in 1885, Clotilde and Berndt Wackels Danielson, a ship’s captain, became the proud parents of the one and only Karen Horney, a pioneer in the field of psychoanalysis (Boeree, 1997). She along with her brother, also named Berndt, and five step-siblings described their father as an authoritarian who ruled with an iron fist and held a strong religious code of ethics; so much so that he was given the nickname of the “the Bible thrower” (Boeree, 1997). Her mother Clotilde, (also known as Sonni) on the other hand, was the complete opposite of her father and was 19 years his junior. Her childhood was one of contradicting perceptions. Horney portrayed her father as a harsh man who favored her brother Berndt more than he did Karen. This representation of her father, however, is negated by the fact that her father would continuously bring her back small trinkets from his excursions around the world (Boeree, 1997). Not only that, but he also allowed her to accompany him on several of his voyages, which considering the time in which they lived in, when women were still inferior to men, was quite odd. Whether this perception of her father is correct or incorrect, ultimately Karen’s viewpoint would end up having the bigger impact, leading her to the very deep-seated relationship she held with her mother; a closeness that resulted in her nickname as her mother’s “little lamb” (Boeree, 1997). Horney spent...

Words: 3121 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Dr Jekyll And Mr Hyde Character Analysis

...In Robert Louis Stevenson's novel The Strange Case Of Dr.Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, his characters relate to Freud's psyche. Freud made these things that connect your personality, they are the Id, Ego, and Superego. Id does whatever it wants at that time without thinking about the consequences. Ego means the part of the personality that maintains the balance between the id and superego. The superego dictates our belief of what's right or wrong and is represented by an angle on your shoulder. The characters in this book represent Freud’s psychoanalysis by the way that they act and look in this novel in many different ways. The character that relates to the id's Mr.Hyde he represents this because he is extremely evil. Mr.Hyde absolutely...

Words: 514 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Philosophy Of Horror

...Much of this application to psychoanalysis is focussed on the use of monsters to showcase unconscious desires, which produce many of the instinctual feelings of wish-fulfillment. Carroll uses the example of vampires, who carry attributes of bloodsucking, which he substitutes for the sexual desire of seduction (169). While this explains the attractiveness of horror, it differs from the previous application of horror and religious feelings. While the explanation of horror’s attractiveness is explained by the awe of the unknown, this differs because the application of psychoanalysis is based on the desires of the known, however unconsciously. Similar to the previous criticism Carroll used in his application to cosmic fear, the application of psychoanalysis served to be limited in its scope, not being comprehensive to the genre as a whole (171). For example, while the vampire example works in an unconscious application to seduction, other monsters like the Blair Witch does not exhibit sexualized characteristics as she is not seen throughout the movie. Despite Carroll discounting the use of psychoanalysis as a comprehensive answer to the horror paradox, its application did identify aspects of art-horror like the creatures being a manifestation of what is culturally repressed (174). In other words, the use of psychoanalysis failed to generalize the horror audience as being attracted to horror due to their unconscious...

Words: 824 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Women in Psychology

...find to be interesting Anna Freud, she was the creator of child psychoanalysis, Anna also completed the work which was a contribution of child psychology and also an understanding. Anna Freud, born on December 3, 1895, and her parents were Sigmund and Martha Freud. Anna had five brothers and sisters in which she was the youngest of the siblings. Anna’s relationship with her father was close, but with her mother and five siblings her relationship was tense. Anna attended a private school; she decided she was learning in that type of setting. Most of Anna’s education was from her father and his friends (http://psychology.about.com/od/profilesofmajorthinkers/p/bio_annafreud.htm). Anna began working as an elementary teacher, after completing High School. Anna also translating her father’s work into German, she became interested, “ in child psychology and psychoanalysis” (http://psychology.about.com/od/profilesofmajorthinkers/p/bio anna freud.htm). Anna’s hard work was influenced by work her father did, but the field of child psychoanalysis was created by Anna. Anna started her psychoanalytic practice the year of 1923, which was located in Province of Vienna, Austria. Later on Anna Freud served, “ chair of the Vienna Psycho-Analytic Society.” Anna had a large influence on Erik Erikson, during the time she had spent in Vienna. Erik Erikson expanded on the field of ego psychology and psychoanalysis. Anna fled to London with her father, shortly after (1938), the Gestapo...

Words: 1404 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Phychoanalysis of Hamlet

...Psychoanalysis of Hamlet’s Subconscious Psychoanalytic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamlet In the first half of the 20th century, when psychoanalysis was at the height of its influence, its concepts were applied to Hamlet, notably by Sigmund Freud, Ernest Jones, and Jacques Lacan, and these studies influenced theatrical productions. Freud suggested that an unconscious oedipal conflict caused Hamlet's hesitations. (Artist: Eugène Delacroix 1844). In his The Interpretation of Dreams (1900), Freud's analysis starts from the premise that "the play is built up on Hamlet's hesitations over fulfilling the task of revenge that is assigned to him; but its text offers no reasons or motives for these hesitations".[83] After reviewing various literary theories, Freud concludes that Hamlet has an "Oedipal desire for his mother and the subsequent guilt [is] preventing him from murdering the man [Claudius] who has done what he unconsciously wanted to do".[84] Confronted with his repressed desires, Hamlet realises that "he himself is literally no better than the sinner whom he is to punish".[83] Freud suggests that Hamlet's apparent "distaste for sexuality"—articulated in his "nunnery" conversation with Ophelia—accords with this interpretation.[85][86] John Barrymore's long-running 1922 performance in New York was characterized as "revolutionary in its use of Freudian psychology; in keeping with the post World War I rebellion against everything...

Words: 4481 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Challenging Freudian: Hobson and His Neurophysiological Substrate for Dreaming

...dream theory in such an extent that the marching on neurophysiological hypothesis has inevitably brought up an uncomfortable disturbance among psychoanalysts. Dating back to twentieth century, Freud reached to the field of mental functioning based on his clinical observations of dream cases. As his censorship-disguise notion becomes outmoded along with the advancement in brain science, the contemporary Freudian psychologist, Mark Solms comes to the rescue. He tries to validate the theoretical inference that Freud has sketched with the newly released experimental data, drawing mainly from brain imaging and lesion study. In spite of the ongoing attempt to bring psychoanalysis back to its prominent role in dream study, Hobson stresses the fact that no amount of tinkering is going to improve the erroneous Freudian psychoanalysis. Formative Approach in Activation-Synthesis Hypothesis Intended to build up a universally applicable dream theory, Hobson has made a radical change in emphasis, from content analysis to formal analysis. This paradigm shift of focus has substantially differentiated Hobson’s theory from the previous psychoanalytic approach to dreams. It substitutes the need for interpretation of every single...

Words: 2562 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Women in Psychology

...Women in Psychology Traci Boyzuck PSY/310 May 19th, 2014 University of Phoenix Women in Psychology When it comes to the history of psychology and the individuals that helped the science become what it is today, many people think of the men that pioneered the discipline. When asked about an individual that has had an impact on psychology the average answer will be that of a man’s name, perhaps Sigmund Freud or Carl Jung; but there have been many women who have taken the reigns and added a great deal of information and insight when it comes to the use of psychology. One of those women is Karen Horney, a woman who gave much insight to many areas of psychology during her time. Karen Horney was born in 1885, in Hamburg, Germany. Her family was an upper middle class family, her father a sea captain and her mother a more free-thinking woman that encouraged her daughter to follow her dreams and pursue her medical career, which was slightly unusual in that time.(Smith, 2007) Karen Horney was dedicated to her studies, she was once quoted as saying “if I can’t be pretty, I decided I would be smart.” Karen started her academic career in medical school in 1906, in 1909 she married a law student named Oskar Horney whom she had three daughters with. (Eckardt, 2005) In 1926, Karen left her husband and later in 1930, she and her daughters moved to the United States, it was here that she became close friends with individuals who were seen as prominent intellectuals, and this is when...

Words: 1601 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Intro to Personality

...Introduction to Personality Deanna Guarino-Embry PSY/405 August 12, 2013 Les Binnix Introduction to Personality The fluidity of personality makes the subject difficult to pinpoint and define. The perception of personality continues to fill psychological literature and study with widespread research and theory. Personality is the continuous presentation of attributes and distinctions that contribute to variety in human thought and behavior (Feist & Feist, 2009). To enable more precise understandings of such differences and distinctions, psychological theorists develop explanations and parameters from various contexts. Psychoanalytic, humanistic and/or existential, dispositional, and learning theories help psychologists account for why and how people develop such individual and specific characteristics. They study these characteristics and the significant affects that the characteristics have on human development, as well as, the whole of human nature. Personality Defined According to Feist,& Feist (2009) personality is a global concept referring to a relatively permanent pattern of traits, dispositions, or characteristics that give some degree of consistency to a person’s behavior. Feist & Feist (2009) also wrote "Although no single definition is acceptable to all personality theorists, we can say that personality is a pattern of relatively permanent traits and unique characteristics that give both consistency and individuality to a person's behavior...

Words: 1571 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

My Psychoanalytic Views of Two Short Stories

...Psychoanalysis In order to understand the true meaning of some stories we must understand the what psychoanalysis is. Psychoanalysis was thought up by a man know as Sigmund Freud also know as the Founding Father of Psychoanalysis. Being a major cocaine addict, his theories were often ridiculed and were thought to be perceived as hallucinations as a result of the cocaine use. Freud’s theories however sparked an all new era of Psychology. Although Freud’s theories seemed very radical, when put into life situations they actually make perfect sense. Psychoanalytic Literary Criticism refers to literary criticism or literary theory which, in method, concept, or form, is influenced by the tradition of psychoanalysis begun by Sigmund Freud. Psychoanalytic literary criticism is a very common method of analyzing stories such as The White Heron by Sarah Orne Jewett, Young Goodman Brown by Nathaniel Hawthorne and The Masque of the Red Death by Edgar Allen Poe. Sylvia, a shy girl, who is rather naive and innocent. For most of her life has been sheltered from the atrocities of life. Being shielded from the outside world she hasn’t come to the conclusion that people can be bad. However this changes when a handsome and mysterious stranger wanders in her area. At first she intimidated by the man but is very eager to assist the man and wants to make a good impression. When finding the heron true changes begin to form in Sylvia. In sparing the heron she is more confident in her decision...

Words: 1454 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Against Dualisms: a Response to Henry Sullivan*

...for the psychoanalysis of literary characters. While there is much to ponder in Sullivan's essay, there are two points, both involving dualisms, that I would like to discuss. In the first case, Sullivan argues insightfully and convincingly against an absolute distinction between how we know and think about fictional characters and how we know and think about real people. In the second case, however, Sullivan insists on an absolute (Cartesian) mind-body dualism as a cornerstone of psychoanalytic theory. I would like to repeat and extend Sullivan's argument in the first case, but refute it and deny its validity in the second. First dualism: Fact/Fiction Sullivan cites as representative of a certain widely-shared approach Maud Ellmann's insistence that there is an important distinction between a “human being made of flesh and character made of words” (5), a distinction that allows us to make one kind statement about the former but not the latter. Ellmann is not alone in making the real-life/fictional distinction a fundamental matter of ontology. We are all familiar with arguments like hers, having heard * For a response to this response, see “Don Quixote & the ‘Third Term’ as Solvent of Binary Dualisms: A Response to Howard Mancing”, by Henry W. Sullivan, Cervantes 19.1 (1999): 177-97. -F.J. 158 19.1 (1999) Against Dualisms: A Response to Henry Sullivan 159 them often enough specifically with respect to Cervantes. The case made in terms of fictional characters here is...

Words: 7711 - Pages: 31