Premium Essay

Who Is Responsible for Ms. Liebeck’s Injuries?

In:

Submitted By le1972
Words 1609
Pages 7
Who Is Responsible For Ms. Liebeck’s Injuries?

When customers order a cup of coffee at McDonald’s, they would expect to have a hot full flavor cup of coffee. However, that was not a case. On February 27, 1992, one of the McDonald’s customers ordered a cup of coffee for herself. Yet, that cup of coffee was not just hot, but it was extremely hot. As of result, she was hospitalized for eight days and suffered third degree burns over her inner thighs, perineum, buttocks, genitals, and groin areas. How could she get burned that bad from a cup of coffee? What was the temperature of the coffee at the time of this incident happened? What kind of cups and lids McDonald’s served their coffee in? Both the lady and McDonald’s have strong reasoning behind their respective cases but ultimately who is responsible for the incident that occurred?

Her name is Stella Liebeck, she was seventy-nine-year-old. She was sitting in the passenger seat when her grandson drove his car through a McDonald’s drive-thru window for her to order a cup of coffee. After receiving the order, the grandson pulled his car forward and stopped for his grandmother to add sugar and cream to her coffee. While parked, Ms. Liebeck placed the cup between her knees and attempted to remove the lid from the cup. As she tried to remove the lid, the contents of the cup spilled onto her lap. The coffee was at 185 degrees Fahrenheit at that time of the incident since McDonald’s served its coffee far higher than the temperature of typical home-brewed coffee. The coffee was hot enough to cause third degree burns all over her bottom. While she was hospitalized for eight days, Ms. Liebeck informed McDonald’s of her accident and requested that McDonald’s pay for her medical expenses; approximately $11,000. However, McDonald’s refused to pay for her request. Left with no other choice, Ms. Liebeck filed a

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Product Liability Management

...Product Liability Management Victor Adejayan Dr. Dianne Barrs Strayer University LEG 500 September, 2012 Product liability is the responsibility of a manufacturer for injury or loss caused by its product (Dictionary.com). Product liability serves to protect the public but it is may turn out to be very expensive to organizations. Management has the duty of making sure that organizations’ resources, especially funds and reputation, do not suffer unnecessary attrition and damages through the implementation of effective, affordable product liability programs. It is important to have people in management that possess the skills such needed to solve liability issues in the legal arena, most importantly before they occur.The challenge of the manager is fulfilling his/hers responsibilities by generating profit in business while protecting the interests of otherstakeholders, such as, employees and customers. Though the savvy manager cannot stop people from having the intention and grievances to sue the organization, they can reduce the motive of prospective plaintiffs and in event of a lawsuit happens; effective product liability management mitigates the negative effects on the organization. Management has the duty of making sure the product liability policies and programs of the organization is clear, concise and precise so that the interpretation thereof cannot be turned to work against the organization. Most lawsuits that are directed at organizations arise...

Words: 1890 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Frivolous Lawsuits

...Frivolous Lawsuits: A Comparison of the McDonalds Case and the Pearson Case Michelle DeWald University of Maryland University College Introduction “When there are too many policemen, there can be no liberty. When there are too many soldiers, there can be no peace. Where there are too many lawyers, there can be no justice.” - Lin Yu-Tang Chinese Writer and Inventor Suing companies in hopes of accumulating big money is popular in today’s society. However, many people get immensely creative with their claims, creating lawsuits over ludicrous motivations. Many cases endure for years or longer. Nevertheless, the costs involved in defending a claim can be exorbitant. Unfortunately, despite every precaution, we live in a society where anyone, any business can be sued for anything. Solely because a lawsuit has been filed, however, does not mean the case has merit. This paper discusses two legal cases related to frivolous lawsuits. The first lawsuit was filed against the McDonald’s Corporation by Stella Liebeck in 1994. The second lawsuit was filed against Custom Cleaners by Roy L. Pearson, an administrative judge, in 2007. Both cases are notable and played a major role in guiding small and large companies in their responsibilities to their customers, reducing the risk of litigation, and protecting their assets to avoid unnecessary liability. Both cases will be analyzed by comparing and contrasting the facts, law, and merit. In addition, this paper will examine ethical issues...

Words: 2650 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Liebeck V. Mcdonalds

...The Case of Liebeck V. McDonalds Business Law & Ethics University of the People Term 4, 2017 The Case of the Really, Really Hot Coffee In 1994, 79 year old Ms. Stella Liebeck purchased some coffee from the drive through window at the local McDonalds restaurant. The coffee was heated to the usual high temperature of 88c. When Ms. Liebeck subsequently spilled her coffee on her lap and received burns on her legs and groin area. She was hospitalized for 8 days and underwent skin grafts to repair the 3rd degree burns she received. Third degree burns are significant injuries where permanent damage is done to the skin, underlying muscles and nerves. It often causes life long chronic pain in the area due to the nerve damage. Ms. Liebeck...

Words: 1467 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking in the Legal Environment: Torts and Product Liability

...well as their employees and customers. There are lessons learned from the cases reviewed this week for managers related to critical thinking based on the two cases that are the focus of this paper, Liebeck v. McDonald’s and Pearson v. Custom Cleaners. . Liebeck vs. McDonalds As a very controversial tort case, Liebeck vs. McDonalds was a closely followed by the news and legal community. This case has been used as an example demonstrating a need for tort reform in the legal system. It started out seeming a simple frivolous lawsuit that was going to waste the court’s and jury’s time. It seemed clear that Liebeck was negligent in not exercising caution in handling her coffee but in the end, it was “found that MdDonald’s was 80% responsible for the incident, while Liebeck was 20% at...

Words: 3185 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Law Essays

...The law, nature, sources and importance This discussion is going to focus on a number of issues. Firstly, an outline is going to be given on how the law affects business in a country. From there the importance of business law is going to be deliberated, followed by the nature and sources of law. Finally, a discussion is going to be made on how the law can be improved in a country. The law has many impacts on business. In this discussion the writer discusses three ways in which the law affects business. Generally the law affects business in the following ways: * Protecting the interests of the investors * Protection of the provisions of business contracts * The law regulates the business environment * The law provides guidelines in the employee- employer relations * There are laws on tax * It promotes transparency. Regulating business environment and operations The law provides guidelines and standards in which all businesses must operate. This protects the business from crumpling as much as protecting the consumers. For examples there are laws that require the business to comply with international practices. For example the companies must declare their business deals with the international partners. The government needs to find out if the partnership is in the interest of the investor. Another example of this relates to the need of all business in the country to get registered. In registering businesses certain details are required. This ensures that...

Words: 22656 - Pages: 91