Free Essay

Why Did Prohibition Last so Long?

In:

Submitted By xride09
Words 1017
Pages 5
Why did Prohibition last so long? 30 Marks
Prohibition of Alcohol in America was introduced in 1920 with the 18th amendment of the constitution and was finally revoked in 1933. Prohibition was always considered a failure, due to the way it was policed, the fact the American people at the time liked to drink and the fact that alcohol was very easily accessible. Therefore the fact it lasted thirteen years, despite it being obvious within the first five that things were not working, seems incomprehensible. There are a number of factors which worked together to make prohibition last as long as it did. The most important being morale reasons behind introducing it at first, but the popularity of prohibition, the time it to repeal a law and the fact it didn’t really affect people’s lives too much also had an effect.
Firstly, a reason why prohibition lasted so long was due to morale reasons. Reasons that were used to get the law passed in the first place still stood and people sympathised with them. For example many women’s groups saw alcohol as a means by which men oppressed them, and also though that the money spent on drink could be better used amongst the family with raising children and other general necessities. This attitude didn’t stop during the prohibition years as people were still drinking and hence propaganda regarding prohibition still bore the pictures of families with mothers and children longing for their husbands/fathers to support prohibition. Also drinking alcohol at home was still permitted with numerous alcohol companies such as Budweiser still advertising in newspapers. The Woman’s Temperance society played a big part in this. It wasn’t just the domestic morals which were attacked by prohibition it was the industrial ones too. Big businesses saw drunkenness as something that led to danger and more importantly inefficiency in the work place, particularly in large factories where hazardous machinery was used. For example the Rockefeller Corporation and Heinz supported prohibition in the interest of greater workforce efficiency.
Secondly, another reason why prohibition lasted so long was due to little opposition. People and groups with anti-prohibition attitudes were very unorganised with their rallies, parades and protests. Only two major protests took place, a parade in Baltimore and a march in New York which resulted in very little awareness in regard for abolition prohibition. Also it was the norm for American politicians during the time to declare weather they were ‘wets or drys.’ Many politicians did not want to be seen as ‘wets’ as it would harm their political identity and careers. WW1 also played a part in the retention of prohibition. Grain was needed to make alcohol, however during the war grain as needed to provide food. People believed that through prohibition, they were being patriotic as it would help out the soldiers. Correspondingly many Americans had anti-German sentiments due to the war and as a result boycotted the German Brewing companies such as Ruppert, Pabst and Lieber.

Lastly, an additional reason why prohibition lasted so long was due to prohibition as a base for crime and profit. In towns people wanted their saloons back, so the gangsters gave them speakeasies – select drinking clubs and night clubs. The gangsters provided the best quality liquor and they charged huge prices for it. They were soon fighting each other for control of this flourishing illegal trade. The reason why so many gangsters were able to get away with illegal activities was down to corruption. They were simply able to bribe policemen, judges and politicians. Gangsters were making so much money that they could easily afford small bribes in order to continue their bootlegging. Gangsters would also tamper with the ballot boxes to ensure that their own people got elected as officials and judges. A few large monopolies used prohibition to make enormous profits. These organisations were able to influence politicians through bribes and therefore control prohibition. A famous millionaire through bootlegging was George Remus who bought up various breweries on the eve of prohibition for the manufacturing of medicinal alcohol. He then arranged for 3000 gangsters to hijack his products and divert them to cities. He made $5 in 5 years. The nature of corruption enabled prohibition to continue as it meant officials could earn quick money and the gangsters could continue to run their operations.
In conclusion it is evident that prohibition lasted 13 years due to many factors. Through prohibition supporters, such as the women, who also had their own support groups involved, as well as religious groups, big business owners and the gangsters, it can easily be seen that they played a key role in affecting the length of the prohibition. Other factors such as the people's sentiments towards alcohol during the First World War, the positive effects of prohibition as well as the 'laissez-faire' government, who played no intervention in battling the illegal manufacturing and selling of alcohol by gangsters, also played large roles. The fact that there was little to no interference on the people who opposed the prohibition's part also helped in elongating the prohibition. However, when analysing the different factors, it can be suggested that the greatest factor was the morality of it. Morality involved what the society believed was the right thing to do and what was not, and can be seen as the foundation for almost all supporters. Religious groups, as well as the many religious supporters, were for prohibition because they believed alcohol led to 'sin' and 'wrong-doing', suggesting that they believed that the prohibition was the right thing for society as it would stop people from sinning. Other factors such as the impact of the First World War also had to do with morality, as many believed the prohibition was the right thing to do for their soldiers. Woman and families also link with morality, as they saw the prohibition as a means of mending family conditions affected by alcohol, as well as putting an end to abuse and oppression by men. Overall, I believe morality was the key factor in elongating the prohibition.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Word for Words

...products whose drawbacks far outweighed their usefulness. Finally, three weeks ago, Flip got angry at his computer and threw it on the floor. The motherboard and several other components were fatally damaged, so that Flip no longer has a working computer. End of story. Flip was an imprudent and irresponsible computer owner. He made several bad decisions. It would clearly have been better had he taken care of his computer, not installed harmful software, and never thrown it on the floor. This would have been better for the computer, for Flip, and even for society, for Flip would have been a more productive citizen with a working computer. So a question naturally arises: how might we prevent people from behaving like Flip? A solution fairly thrusts itself on our imagination (or at any rate, on the imagination of those who take their cue from modern politics): we could send the police after Flip, to drag him off and throw him in jail. That would send a message to other would-be computer abusers. What are we to think of this plan? Of course, as things stand, Flip will not be sent to prison because he has violated no law. But that just invites the question: Should Flip’s behaviour be against the law? It is clear enough that the behaviour was foolish and without redeeming social value. So why...

Words: 2041 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Smuggler Nation Analysis

...I know not why we ought to become flushed to admit," John Adams composed, "that molasses was a key fixing in American autonomy." After getting a charge out of many years of remiss requirement of obligations on molasses and different imports, pilgrims were insulted and shocked when the British, in 1763, at long last quit fooling around about gathering the expenses. "The production of requests for the strict execution of the Molasses Act," Massachusetts Gov. Francis Bernard reported back to England, "has created a more noteworthy caution in this nation than the taking of Fort William Henry did in 1757." Steep levies were seen as a strike keeping pace with a famous slaughter. In "Smuggler Nation," Peter Andreas relates the well-worn story of American...

Words: 1247 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Legalization of Cannabis

...on the commodity. Listing arguments that support the claim that by legalizing this commodity not only crime rates in general, but violent crime rates, will drop noticeably if not substantially providing a savings in the cost of enforcing and prosecuting such crimes. And, that by decriminalization, the federal government can regulate this commodity much like alcohol and tobacco providing new sources of tax revenue. A History of Cannabis The best way to understand the public image that cannabis has today is by looking at how we understood it yesterday. Starting from the first piece of legislation in 1906 and coming to present day medicinal approval in a small portion of US states. This will hopefully address the questions of “Why the war on drugs?”, “Why this particular commodity a drug...

Words: 5829 - Pages: 24

Free Essay

Dfsdf

...Year 10 Revision Timelines: The Roaring Twenties Women Before First World War * Women could not vote. * Middle/upper class women did not work but had the role of mothers and housewives. Working class women had low paid jobs such as factory work and cleaning. * Women usually wore full length dresses, wore no make up and had their hair tied back in buns. * Divorce was very rare and so was sex before marriage. * Women did not smoke or drink in public. * They had to go out with a chaperone (a family member) when they met their boyfriend. How did the First World War change the lives of women? * During the war, women began to work in areas like heavy industry. They proved they could work as well as men. By 1929, there were 10 million women workers; a rise of 24% since 1920. * Working gave women independence and they began smoking and drinking in public. * Women were given the vote in August 1920 but few were chosen to be actual politicians. * Production of consumer goods such as vacuum cleaners and washing machines meant women had more time for leisure activities. * Flappers emerged in the 1920’s = women from middle and upper class families from the Northern States. They cut their hair in short bobs, wore make up, short skirts and bright clothes. They also smoked and drank in public, went to speakeasies, danced the Charleston with men and listened to Jazz and drove cars and motorbikes. * BUT many groups, particularly...

Words: 6533 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Tnc: Related to Culture Based on Lorax Movie

...who at first tries to seduce a woman who was in secondary school named Audrey. So, in conjunction with the birthday Audrey, he tries to realize the dream of Audrey to see the real tree it is Truffula tree. Then, with strong effort, he meets with someone who still keeps the last seeds, The Once- Ler. He is the people who are liable to destroy the truffula tree because of greedy but he aware of their mistake and he assumption that it is too late to back. But, The Lorax person who are the guardian of the forest try to realize The Once- Ler and always said one day someone will realize that the important of trees in the life. After hearing the grief story of The Once- Ler, Ted aware of the great responsible that must be done is not just a gift for a loved women but outside of the framework of the seeker is trying to convince and enlighten the public to preserve the environment. Secondly, the character of the cause of environmental damage. The Once-Ler, it is the name of causes of environment damage. At first he was just a child out of the village migrated to other places to be a successful entrepreneur in the field of fashion and so on. Started with he goes one destination truffula forest, the trees suitable for his product. His offense is cutting down trees called The Lorax (God Forest) who loved the environment to prevent forest god but got ignored warnings by Once- Ler. So he is bothered by The Lorax so got quiet life but after the events of Once-Ler saved in the forest, Once-Ler...

Words: 833 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Paper

...Hadith"  before this one to better follow and appreciate this essay.  NOTE for fellow Muslims: Because this topic involves what is haram (prohibited) and halal (permissible) in Islam, every Muslim MUST do his/her own due diligence and conscientiously reach own position/decision in regard to personal practice. In doing so regarding this matter or any other aspect of life, Muslims should seek guidance from the Qur'an and the Prophetic legacy.  Each hadith is properly referenced, but for internal reference within this essay, in the sequence presented, each hadith is numbered with # H-.  Some of the references in this essay are from secondary sources. As the draft takes it final shape, original sources would be gradually cited and replace the secondary source citations. [pic] "There is nothing prohibited except that which God prohibits ... To declare something permitted prohibited is like declaring something prohibited permitted." Ibn Qayyim[1] [pic] I. Introduction The Qur'an categorically prohibits riba. However, since there is no unanimity about the definition or scope of this prohibition, we will use the original term riba throughout this essay. In the Qur'an it is specified: Those who devour riba will not stand except as stands one whom the Evil One by his touch hath driven to madness. That is because they say: "Trade is like riba but Allah hath permitted trade and forbidden riba....

Words: 15428 - Pages: 62

Premium Essay

Moonshine in Appalachia

...Life My sister recently shared with me a little known fact of our grandparents’ lives in Kentucky as young parents. They were involved in the illegal manufacture and sale of alcoholic spirits, also known as moonshining (Brown). Having known our grandparents to be very peaceful, law abiding citizens in their elder years, I find this revelation of illegal activity oddly fascinating. I want to understand how and why our grandparents got involved in moonshining which is a key element of our family’s heritage as Scottish immigrants to the United States. The production of illicit whiskey has been an integral part of American history since the early days of our country. Stiff taxation of alcohol and ingredients for the manufacture of alcohol by the British government angered colonists who were seeking economic freedom (Carr 16). Having then gained their freedom from taxation without representation from the British government, US citizens were furious when the fledging government imposed a tax on home distilled spirits (Carr 20, Abramson and Haskell 413). This began a long term battle between the United States government and her citizens over the manufacture, transportation and sale of alcohol (Carr 20). In order to understand how my grandparents came to be involved in this battle over the home production of liquor, we must examine the history, culture and economy of Appalachia as it pertains to moonshine. Some history books credit the colonists with introducing the craft of distilling...

Words: 2910 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Pneumonoultramicroscopicsilicovolcanoconiosis

...language published in a dictionary, the Oxford English Dictionary. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, it is "an artificial long word said to mean a lung disease caused by inhaling very fine ash and sand dust."[1] Silicosis is a form of occupational lung disease caused by inhalation of crystalline silica dust, and is marked by inflammation and scarring in the form of nodular lesions in the upper lobes of the lungs. It is a type of pneumoconiosis Statement of the problem 1. What is the couse of Pneumoconiosis? 2. How can it be prevented? 3. What are the symptoms? 4. How can affect in our body? 5. What are the treatment? Statement of the Hypothesis HO1: .A pneumoconiosis cause by inhalation of every fine silicate or quartz dust which is found in volcanic ash. HO2: Pneumonoultramicroscopicsilicovolcanoconiosis is fairly easy to prevent. Most countries do not have any volcanoes or any other places where silica dust exposure is likely. In case you live in one of the countries that does, here are few ways how to prevent this disease: Do not go in or near an active or non-dormant volcano. Do not expose yourself to silica dust for long periods of time. If or long periods of time, cease breathing. If you are in or near you do happen to be exposed to silica dust for a long period an active or non-dormant volcano, cease breathing. Avoid a place or places that contain volcanoes. Do not inhale volcanic...

Words: 3268 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Progressive Movement

...dark impression it left on the United States.  There were many events that ultimately led to the infamous incident that is most often associated with the Great Depression, a decade long period of hardship.  The stock market crash was an event that majorly impacted the United States and jolted the country out of prosperity.  Thankfully, the country was fully restored in 1939 with the beginning of World War II and the assistance of the New Deal.     There were many factors that contributed to the crash of the stock market.  First, the businesses began to suffer, thus affecting the banking system.  Unfortunately, the American people were unaware of these issues, which only fed to the...

Words: 1811 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Prohibition Era Research Paper

...The prohibition era describes a moment in American history where the consumption of alcohol beverages was banned between the years 1913 and 1933. During this time the American congress dismissed all alcohol selling and consumption activities in various states in the U.S. following the requirements of the 18th amendment[footnoteRef:1]. The amendment was approved by the United States congress in the year 1917 and declared the manufacturing sale and transportation of alcoholic material in the country as illegal. The ramification of the amendment was approved by over two thirds of the American congress. Prohibition was to initiate one year later. The prohibition law was perceived as an act of social engineering that could spell out various implications to the American public. What was not understood was whether the governments and citizens were ready to deal with the prohibition. Before the prohibition many Americans labelled themselves as wet or dry. [1: Parramore, Thomas, et al Norfolk: The first four centuries (Charlottesville: University Press of...

Words: 4687 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Nascar

...History of NASCAR Did you know NASCAR was started because of a historical event in America’s history? The reason I have chosen this project because I grew up watching NASCAR every Sunday, and helping with my dad’s best friend’s race car. The thing I was trying to accomplish in this project was to get a better understanding of the background and history of NASCAR. The process I took in accomplishing my goal was writing a rationale, writing down research questions, and finding Wisconsin’s state standards that I would meet in my project. What I hope that the reader takes from this paper is all of the things that helped NASCAR get started, what they raced on back then, and how NASCAR changed over time. In this paper you will read about the prohibition, Bootleggers tricks and advantages[, Bill Frances Sr., history of NASCAR, Technological advancements, racing legends, aerodynamics, How NASCAR got so big and Wisconsin’s traditions. NASCAR has an interesting background. It all started with bootleggers racing from town to town delivering their moonshine without getting caught. NASCAR is linked to American history and it comes with some interesting tales. This paper will tell you everything you need to know about NASCAR and aerodynamics of the car. Some things that this paper will contain are famous drivers and their impact on NASCAR, how safely has changed over time, how NASCAR got started, what NASCAR drivers first raced on and why it changed over time, how NASCAR fit its time period...

Words: 2703 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Marijuana Speech

...Majoint,, spliff , blunt, dub, L, ganja, grass, pot, bud, and mary jane.     Now, why are these words thought to be "bad".   Why are we taught from such a young age that marijuana is bad.   Why are we able to go into any store and buy tobacco, which kills 400,000 people annually; alcohol, which kills 100,000 people annually; and caffeine, which kills 2,000 people annually.   According to the New England Journal of medicine, you would have to smoke 1500 pounds of marijuana in under 15 minutes to OD.   Marijuana was prohibited in 1937, but marijuana prohibition isn’t working. Today between 95 and 100 million Americans admit to having tried it and nearly 15 million have used it within the past month.   Some people believe that marijuana is bad and does damage to the body but alcohol and cigarettes are more dangerous. Alcohol has a high level of sulphate and can cause alcohol poisoning. Cigarettes contain over 4,000 chemicals including 43 known cancer compounds and 400 other toxins. Marijuana is not 100% free of chemicals but it more natural because it is from the earth and contains only 100 chemicals. ill be discussing marijuana legislation first wat is marijuana and hw does it affect humans? second when and why did marijuana become illegal? and why states are legalizing marijuana for medical purposes. using these points i intend to inform you about marijuana and the movement to legalize it.   according to the national institute on drug abuse, a survey shows that over 98 million americans...

Words: 1517 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Marijuana

...in school forced me to decline. Many of my peers were not as strong and fell into peer pressure. The smell of marijuana on the way to school became a familiar scent. As I got older and began to explore the City of Brotherly Love I learned that Philly is drug infested. I’ve met a lot of good people who have fallen into addiction. Their drug usage impedes their everyday life. I have a friend who I went to high school with. My friend was a top athlete and scholar. After a terrible car accident he developed an addiction to prescription pain killers. He ran from doctor to doctor trying to keep his fix alive. The process lingered on for a couple years, One day I asked him why he didn’t get help or try to stop. His main argument was that he wasn’t doing anything illegal like crack or heroine, so he didn’t think he had a problem. His argument got me thinking about the government and how they dictate what medications are okay and not okay for people to take. After that I began to understand and defend the use of certain narcotics. Twenty-three states and the District of Columbia have legalized medical marijuana is. The sale of marijuana helped them generate revenue, decrease the abuse of other substances and lower crime rates, three things Pennsylvania needs. Decrease the use of other substances In the widest of terms,...

Words: 3874 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Legalizing Marijuana

...is a substance that has become very much a part of American culture. By definition, marijuana derives from the Indian hemp plant thought to have originated in the mountainous districts of India, north of the Himalayan Mountains (http://encarta.msn.com/dictionary_1861628419/marijuana.html). Nearly 95 million Americans have either used marijuana occasionally or regularly (Belville, 2009, p.60). Marijuana’s history is long and extensive. Marijuana comes from a Mexican word meaning “Mary Jane”. Marijuana has been grown for medical use for thousands of years. It is an established scientific fact that marijuana is not toxic to humans; marijuana overdoses are nearly impossible, and marijuana is not nearly as addictive as alcohol or tobacco (http://www.alternet.org/drugreporter/60959/?page=2). Today in the United States there is an ongoing debate whether marijuana should or should not be legalized. Legalizing marijuana can cut the cost to the government for the on-going “war on drugs”, be used medically in numerous proven ways, and eliminate the failure of prohibition. Cost of the “War on Drugs” In the United States, all levels of government (federal, state, and local authorities) participate in the “War on Drugs.” More than thirty years after the “War on Drugs” was declared, billions of dollars are spent every year on a losing battle. On the law enforcement side alone, taxpayers are spending $41.8 billion a year (Whitty, 2007). The cost to put a single drug dealer in jail...

Words: 1606 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Marjuana Legalization Research Paper

...Abstract: The prohibition of marijuana has been a heated debate for years. This paper will examine the question of whether or not it will be beneficial to the population as a whole, smokers and non-smokers to legalize marijuana. This paper will begin by giving a historical overview of marijuana and how it became illegal. Then, it will attempt to examine and illustrate the many valuable, and beneficial qualities that marijuana has. Relying on the facts found to ultimately come to a conclusion on whether or not legalization would positively effect our country. Introduction Background Information The legalizing of marijuana for both recreational and medical purposes will have significant benefits for smokers and non-smokers, the economy, and the population. Currently any production, sale, distribution, or consumption of the drug marijuana is illegal in forty-eight states in the nation. Legalizing marijuana in this situation would mean executing the same or similar laws as are imposed on to alcohol. “On November 6, 2012, Colorado and Washington became the first states to legalize the sale and possession of cannabis for recreational use since the Marijuana Tax act of 1937 when they passed Colorado Amendment 64 and Washington Initiative 502” (Szalavitz). The few states that have legalized marijuana are instituting practices to integrate the substance into society. To continue, consumption of marijuana would be illegal as well as the purchase of the substance by minors...

Words: 3369 - Pages: 14