...Way of War The novel Carnage and Culture written by Victor Davis Hanson whom is a military historian and professor at California State University gives a new perspective on why the West always wins their wars. Hanson states his theory that the West always wins their fights because of the influence of their culture. He continues to explain this theory of the Western way of war with a coherent argument. Although Hanson uses examples of battles in which do not quite fit his argument, the background of the nine battles he uses support his claim; thus, making his theory agreeable overall. Furthermore, the title Carnage and Culture best illustrates Hanson’s theory on the western culture. The reason being why the west always wins their wars is due to the culture- “The Western Way of War”. This culture follows with characteristics in which represent the West: being freedom, individualism, civic militarism, superior weapons, organization, discipline, morale, initiative, flexibility, and command. All of these characteristics are shown through the West in the battles fought against the Non-West. Hanson talks about nine different battles in which helps back up his theory. Western warfare, a common foundation and continual way of fighting, that has made Europeans the most deadly soldiers in the history of civilization. With this being said, Hanson believed that with the western culture, the armies produce better quality arms and soldiers. Culture being such a big part of the Western...
Words: 1298 - Pages: 6
...paper will examine two distinctive traits; resilience and discipline; and how it forged the culture of the Okinawa people. I. History A. The Ryukyu Kingdom occupied a distinct position to the south of Japan. B. Sho Shoken was indeed an important figure to solidify the culture or Okinawa. II. Battle of Okinawa A. The Battle of Okinawa begins on April of 1945 testing the strength of the Okinawan people B. After the war, Okinawa begins to integrate with the U.S. Military forces. III. Beliefs A. The religion of the Okinawa people consists of early Chinese and Japanese influences. B. In ancestor worship, the core of this religious practice is the ancestral shrine. IV. Culture A. Customs 1. Okinawa’s customs have survived throughout the ages; including distinctive modernization. B. Courtesy is one of the most prominent traits instilled within Okinawan culture. B. Centenarians 1. Okinawa is home to the most documented centenarians in the world. Conclusion: In closing, the Okinawa people have endured many hardships that would have crumbled their society as a whole. From the times of the Ryukyu Kingdom until the present time, Okinawa’s rich history consisted of facing adversity when uncertainty presented itself. Okinawa’s resilience to such adversity is a testament to their beliefs and customs they still hold today. The Battle of Okinawa literally destroyed the Island followed with its residents. As seen over time, the...
Words: 2233 - Pages: 9
...A Line in the Sand - The Alamo in Blood and Memory is a historical book by noted historians Randy Roberts and James Olson. It serializes a comprehensive account of the Alamo, a battle between Mexican forces led by General Antonio López in the predawn moments of March 6, 1836. All the people behind the walls of the Alamo lay dead, including Travis, Bowie, and Crockett. The trio has since been immortalized in Texas as heroes of freedom who stood for political and nationalistic values in the wake of Mexican incursion. Alongside their heroism are a overabundance of myths that surround both the Mexicans who put them to death and the real motive of their sacrifice. The book presents a rarefied, evidenced view of the battle to fill the current void whereby the interpretation of Alamo has been left, to quote the authors, “to Walt Disney and John Wayne”. Author Information...
Words: 1143 - Pages: 5
...The Hero as a Reflection of Culture Belen Lowrey Abstract: In works of literature, a hero is a man to be admired and emulated. For this reason, the hero always demonstrates the embodiment of the ideals of the creating culture. Historical events and social conditions of different cultures cause different attributes to become valued in leaders. These cultural values are reflected in both the actions of a hero and in the heroic motivations. This paper focuses on the heroes of the Iliad, the Aeneid, Beowulf, and The Song of Roland and examines how historical events and cultural circumstances shaped the portrayal of the heroes in these works. Sabiduria, vol.1,1 Hero as a Reflection of Culture 1 Every culture has heroes. In works of literature, is an individual to be admired and emulated, and because of this he is the embodiment of the greatest virtues of the culture that created him. The ideals of every culture were shaped by the social conditions of the time and therefore different attributes became valued. To different degrees, the hero in a work is a result of not only the culture from which the hero comes, but also the culture of the author. Cultural values are reflected in both the actions of a hero and his motivations. As heroes, Achilles, Aeneas, Beowulf, and Roland reflect the values of the societies that created them. One of the oldest works of ancient literature is Homer‟s Iliad. Homer‟s works are dated to between 900 and 750 B.C. (Krieger,...
Words: 3619 - Pages: 15
...Beowulf, the aspect of attaining glory throughout one’s life is an integral part of their culture. Warriors battle to protect their land, serve their king, and to be remembered and have their legacy carry on after they have died. People such as these worked their entire lives, and dedicated them to serving their country and king as a way to attain glory themselves. The comitatus, or the bind between a king and his people, shows that the people of Beowulf’s time fought together, as one united people, and that even kings were willing to lay their lives down in the line of duty to protect their nation and to attain the...
Words: 784 - Pages: 4
...literature, history, philosophy, and fine arts including: music, art, dance, and drama. A haka is a traditional dance performed by Maori men and women. Maori haka is performed for many reasons, celebrating success, welcoming distinguished guests, or as a pre-battle challenge (Maori, People & Culture n.d.). Before the White Men also known as the pakeha descended upon Aotearoa, now known as New Zealand, everything was passed orally from one generation to the next, this meant legends, rituals, songs, dances, beliefs of any kind were passed from father to son and mother to daughter. According to "Maori People & Culture" (n.d.), The most recognized of those traditions is the “Haka” - a war dance and a traditional genre of Maori dance. Warriors before a battle, in an effort to show their strength and in hopes of intimidating the enemy performed the Haka. Every part of the body meaning the hands, arms, legs or even eyes and tongue were used to demonstrate and give representation to the many types of instruments and emotions, connected to a specific occasion. According to Armstrong, (2005) in his book Maori Games & Instruction “It is disciplined, yet emotional. More than any other aspect of Maori culture, this complex dance is an expression of the vigor, passion and identity of the race. It is at its best, truly, a message of the soul expressed by posture and words.” Key elements in the Maori haka are pukana, the dilating of the eyes, whetero, a protruding tongue which...
Words: 737 - Pages: 3
...Does Alexander the great live up to his name? Alexander the great was not great because he was selfish and a self centered leader. He also killed multitudes of people that he didn’t have to kill, but he did anyway and even ruined culture. Alexander killed thousands of people in battles and that's understandable they were fighting against him as he was trying to conquer places. But he also killed many innocent people and even children. In document E it states soldiers & civilians killed in major battles were 100,000 that's only 4 major battles but in total he fought 5 battles he could have killed many more civilians than only 100,000. In Document C it states that he crucified 2,000 military age men even though they did not have to join the...
Words: 389 - Pages: 2
...still stupid? The threshold between courage and stupidity is crossed many times throughout life and almost everyone has their own opinion on the topic. Some people would tell you that the difference between them is ignorance while others would say it is the amount of thought given to the act before you attempt it. Some good examples of this would be charging into a battle. Charging into a battle could be many things but two of them are courage and stupidity. While some may charge into a battle for glory and fame others will take the risk and consider it to be worth it for the sake of others. It really is your own opinion whether either of those circumstances is one or the other. Going into the battle for glory and fame is usually seen as a stupid act as you will only be remembered if you are successful in battle. Even then after you die who will really remember who you were, what you did, and why you gave up your life. The people who are remembered are those who win and get to write the history of what happened. Something else to take into account when deciding if something is courageous or not is the culture of the people. In today's society the human life is valued above all else and almost all of us would rather flee than fight to preserve life. Many of the different civilized societies throughout today's world do not allow one human to take another human's life, the same goes with taking your own life....
Words: 983 - Pages: 4
...Correlation vs. Causation from the High- to the Late- Middle Ages (1000-1500) A comparative book review of Castles, Battles and Bombs: How Economics Explains Military History by Jurgen Brauer and Hubert van Tuyll and Battle: A History of Culture and Combat by John Lynn Nicole Campagnola 0774953 HIST*2040 (DE) W13 Professor Davison March 31, 2013 Despite proven facts and primary sources, historical investigation always has an element of subjectivity. Each historian has a different perspective, and focuses on different events and principles. Different historians and authors will often reflect upon the work of their peers, so an educated reader has the opportunity to decrease bias by expanding the list of sources that information comes from. Information that is accurately cited from appropriate sources does not always have a concrete and inarguable conclusion. There will always be differentiations based on the perspective that the author is striving to communicate, and the original intent behind their research. Castles, Battles and Bombs: How Economics Explains Military History by Jurgen Brauer (an economist) and Hubert van Tuyll (a historian) focuses on historical events with the foundation of economic principles, and uses these principles to explain past military decisions and strategies. Battle: A History of Culture and Combat by John Lynn argues that most historians have mistakenly defined styles of warfare and resulting successes based on technological...
Words: 3169 - Pages: 13
...Reflecting on my resources, are the original questions I asked remain valid? As I review the Indian culture, there is a large wealth of information relating to all aspects of their society. A general concept of Indian warfare has evolved that is not unique to the understanding of historians. As much as the Indians were a part of Pontiac’s War and the Fort Pitt Campaign, the British were equal partners in the event. The Battle of Bushy Run becomes a case study in how the British military was evolving while the Indians were failing to adjust to a changing enemy that was slowly learning how to fight like the Indians and improve upon their military. This is the culmination of approximately 100 years of conflict with another almost 100 years of...
Words: 277 - Pages: 2
...The english language is one of the hardest languages to learn because of its multiple roots of different languages.Before the english that we speak today was spoken,older versions of it had been spoken by the people before us.Since 450,the english language had begun its transition,including the culture of the time periods starting with the Anglo-Saxon. Years before the era of the Anglo Saxon had begun,the royal families of the Danish (the Danes)and the Scandinavians(the Geats),had inhabited the Southern part of Sweden when they had decided to invade the island of Great Britain and settled.This migration had brought several Germanic languages together that formed Old English. Hundreds of years ago,the novel Beowulf was written by an unknown...
Words: 1341 - Pages: 6
...teaching are recent U.S. history and history of popular culture. Olsen got his Ph.D. in history at State University of New York in 1972, currently teaches at Sam Houston State University, and had won many research awards. Some of the books the two professors’ co-author on including My Lai: A Brief History with Documents, John Wayne American, and Where the Domino Fell: America and Vietnam. The book A Line in the Sand focus on the Battle of the Alamo on March 6th, 1836. The book also talks about the Battle of San Jacinto on April 21st, 1836 that concluded the Texas Revolution. After the battles and events that lead to it, the book then shift its focus on how the quote “Remember the Alamo” lives on through history in different perspectives and interpretations of the Alamo. How the memories changes as time continue to move forward till this day. Although there are no clear thesis of the book, the authors are trying to convey to the readers about how historical memories of the Alamo changes over time. It all depend on...
Words: 836 - Pages: 4
...Many people believe that Alexander the Great is one of the greatest military geniuses that ever lived, and due to his destruction to cultural and religious sites throughout the empire, others have characterized him as a destroyer. He never lost a battle and Greece itself was never invaded during his rule. Alexander’s rule as king started in 336 B.C., he vowed to conquer the largest empire in the ancient world and complete the plans of his father. This mission included many battles along the way and also laid the foundation for new political systems, as well as spread Greek ideas, culture and life style to most of the places he conquered. New empires developed and the Hellenistic Culture together with the Roman Civilization and Christianity...
Words: 371 - Pages: 2
...want to hear them. They don’t want to talk to them. They just want to look at them,” suggesting that the Indians were on display for the Americans. By saying that they only want to look at them, he shows that the Americans had little interest in learning about the Indians’ lives and cultures, but rather wanted to marvel at them like animals, stripping them of their humanity. The Indians were forced to reenact the deadly battles daily for the entertainment of the Americans, though many of the actors actually participated in the real battles. This would most likely have been difficult, degrading, and embarrassing for the Indians. Their victory in the Battle of the Little Bighorn demonstrated the American’s justification for American conquest and their reenactment of these battles meant they were submitting to these views. The show often featured fictional events that further stereotyped life in the Wild West, such as Native American attacks and train robberies. The show also featured skill acts such as sharp shooting, roping, and riding, and related these skills to survival in the Wild West. Buffalo Bill’s audience preferred happier endings so, overtime, he changed the outcomes of the battles they reenacted, including changing the...
Words: 1554 - Pages: 7
...invade and conquer Roman territory in Africa, which ultimately lead to the creation of a Vandal kingdom in Africa . On one hand in the Eastern half there was Gaiseric, leader of the Vandals, conquering through Spain to Africa, and on the other hand in the Western half there was Alaric I, leader of the Visigoths, moving to Rome itself. The resources of Eastern Rome were spread thinly, in an attempt to deal with their problem of barbarians so they weren’t able to assist the West when their problem became more prominent. One of the major battles known for leading to an increase of barbarian influence within Rome was the Battle of Adrianople in 378 C.E. This battle, as observed by Zentner, was a decisive Visigoth barbarian victory that could have been easily prevented. Roman Emperor Valens could’ve waited for reinforcements before engaging the barbarians but he rushed in for personal glory . Directly as a result of this emperor Valens died in the battle and the Romans lost two-thirds of the army...
Words: 1099 - Pages: 5