1. Evaluate the position and reactions of Daniel Justin using Rest’s four-component model of morality.
Daniel is having some trouble with morality. He is overlooking the moral sensitivity of the situation by seemingly not considering what the students on the list may go through because of his decision. His moral judgement is off, and he is thinking only of his own situation. His moral motivation is nonexistent from the moment he decides to give the list no matter what Denise decides. Daniel is showing immature moral character.

2. What ethical values might have motivated Denise to take such a strong stand on the matter of giving out the email list?
Denise shows mature moral motivation by considering the outcome of a situation like giving personal information to a third party. She is morally sensitive to the needs of the people she is responsible for leading. Her moral judgement is spot on because she is considering those she represents, not her own feelings alone. Denise shows strong mature moral character.

3. Evaluate the positions of Daniel and Denise using Kohlberg’s model of moral development.
Daniel seems to show that he is at level 1 of Kohlberg's model of moral development because he is only considering obiding by his RAP boss because he is worried about the punishment it will bring him if he does not. He is self-interested, and not worried about the victims in this scenario.
Denise is at level 2 or possibly 3 of Kohlberg's model because she is considering the social norms of a situation like this. She is also considering her own authority in the matter. She goes on to level 3 because she considers universal ethics principles. She worries less about what past leaders have done in her situation and more about what the right thing to do is.

4. To whom does Daniel owe is loyalty? Explain. To whom does Denise owe her loyalty? Explain.