Premium Essay

Are Judges Truly Impartial

Submitted By
Words 264
Pages 2
Can most judges be considered truly impartial? Yes, A judge holds massive power in civil law and common law. Because this power is unreasonably large compared to both the criminal defense lawyer and the prosecutor an offender has the right to trial by an impartial and unbiased judge. In most cases a judge needs to be unprejudiced and impartial. It is even proven that a judge must be the same way in their personal lives. judges must avoid words, actions or situations that might make them appear to be biased or disrespectful of the laws they are sworn to uphold. In other words, they must refrain from comments and suggestions. Outside the courtroom, judges do not socialize or associate with lawyers or other persons connected with the cases they

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Jury Trial Analysis

...Jury Trial Analysis CJA/364 Jury Trial Analysis In the United States citizens are given certain rights when they are accused of a crime and are facing a trial. They have the right to a speedy trial, this it to avoid a person being charged with a crime them spending a prolonged period incarcerated prior to conviction. They have the right to an impartial jury. Jurors are interviewed by both the prosecution and the defense to endure that the defendant is not known to them and that if the potential jurors do have any knowledge of the crime, gained via the media or sources other than personal knowledge. Defendants are also entitled to an impartial judge. Judges are held to a higher standard that than of people in other jobs. They are required to put aside personal opinions and make decisions based solely on the facts as they are presented in court. The Right to a Speedy Trial The Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution guarantees a person accused of a crime the right to a speedy trial. The Founding Father of the United States added this amendment to the Constitution for two reasons, ("The Free Dictionary", 2014). First they wanted to prevent those accused but not yet convicted of crimes from spending a long period of time incarcerated when they have not been found guilty of it yet. The second reason was the fear that if the trial was delayed the memories of witness could fade, witnesses themselves could disappear, and evidence could be lost. While both...

Words: 1282 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Jury Selection Process

...matters. A jury is ultimately selected by the judge, prosecutor and defending attorney. How they are they picked? How are they released? Maybe this paper will answer a few of these questions. The selection of a jury is the process that occurs right before the actual trial, and after the trial initiation and the arraignment and plea. Only about 10 percent of actual arraignments see an actual trial, because 90 percent of cases that are preparing for trial end up accepting a plea bargain (Schmalleher, 2009). Any one who is accused of a crime and will stand trial is allowed by the Sixth Amendment the right to an impartial jury. For a jury to be impartial, it is not always true that they have no prior knowledge of the case at all. In the case of a highly publicized trial, it can be almost impossible to find 12 people who know nothing about the case at hand or the accused. Some jurors will be excused based on how suitable they are judged to be for the case, and some may be excused because of reasons beyond their control (Schmalleger, 2009). I have been called to serve jury duty one time in my life. At the time I had 2 small children at home, one of them just being diagnosed with the Swine Flu 2 days prior. When I told the judge this, he told me not to touch anyone on the way out of courtroom, and wished my child well. It was not that I didn’t want to serve; I felt my place was with my child, and was glad the judge agreed. After the judge has done his initial weeding out of people...

Words: 1205 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Pena-Rodriguez V. Colorado Case Study

...trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him (Sixth). When looking into the Pena-Rodriguez v. Colorado case Rodriguez was finding fault with being guaranteed a fair jury. He found this fault because after he was found guilty from the trial two jurors informed Pena-Rodriguez’s counsel that one of the juror’s chosen was making racial statements regarding Pena-Rodriguez and the alibi witness during the...

Words: 691 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Judicial Branch

...Business Law I Due: Feb 4th 2010 The Judicial Branch The Judicial branch of government of the United States was set up by article III of the Constitution. The Judicial branch is given great power over the common law, but still very limited due to a complex system or checks and balances. The Federalist Papers 78-83 describes in great detail the newly proposed system of judicial government. The author of these papers was Alexander Hamilton. John Jay, and James Madison contributed to the other parts of the Federalist. The most interesting aspect of the judicial branch is the way it fits into the system that also is comprised of the Executive branch, and the legislative branch. Alexander Hamilton writes, “The judiciary, from the nature of its functions, will always be the least dangerous to the political rights of the constitution; because it will be least in a capacity to annoy or injure them”. The executive branch can be viewed as the, “sword of the community”, and the legislative has the power to create the laws the all citizens of the United States must follow (Hamilton 78). The brilliant thing is even though it seems the judicial branch of government does not carry as much power, it never states that in Hamilton’s letters due to the fact that the judicial branch is considered an “indispensable ingredient” (Hamilton 78). The power of the judicial branch may be considered not as direct as the other branches, but is still powerful nonetheless. The...

Words: 1170 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cognitive Bias In Forensic Evidence

...Slate’s notion on cognitive bias is that prosecutors will tell forensic analysts what he or she believes will be the result of the tests given, which in turn leads to analysts being unconsciously convinced. Although the work of analysts should be impartial and objective, there begins to be a tendency to look for results that support theories. Most forensic practitioners will ask several questions about the case, even the suspect’s identity, without realizing that “[e]ven the most upright analyst is liable to be subconsciously swayed when she [sic] already has a conclusion in mind” (Slate). Ira Flatow, the host of the radio show, Talk of the Nation, and author of the article, "Analysis: Finding Fault With Forensics”, notes Dr. Koehler, a professor at the University of Texas saying, “one of my concerns is the way it's described by analysts in the courtroom, the way the match evidence is described. And right now there seems to be a kind of culture of exaggeration associated with the traditional...

Words: 1057 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Sir Robert Peel

...Sir Robert Peel’s Nine Principles of Policing and Modern Day Policing Katherine R. Burger University of Phoenix Survey of Justice and Security/CJA500 John V. Baiamonte, Jr. Ph.D February 2, 2009 Abstract Sir Robert Peel was Prime Minister of the United Kingdom and has the honor of being referred to as the “father of modern policing” and the name sake of the London “Bobbies.”(Sir Robert Peel 2006) Sir Robert Peel passed away in 1855 and his nine principles of policing still govern modern day policing. Policing has changed and evolved over the years past and Sir Robert Peel’s nineprinciples still play an important role in modern day policing. The nine principles are an ethical guide for policing. Thestrong ethics that Sir Robert Peel outlines in his nine principles are still effective in modern day police work. Sir Robert Peel’s Nine Principles You can search the World Wide Webfor Anytown, USA and the mission statement for the police department will list crime prevention. It does not matter what state’s webpage or mission statement that you read. You would be hard-pressed to find a mission statement that does not include the some type of verbiagethat encompasses the meaning of preventing crime and maintaining order. The overview section of the St. Paul Police Department website states “TheSaint Paul Police Department’s mission is to maintain a climate of safety and security throughout the City.” Principle number one is the creation of a mission that exists to prevent crime...

Words: 880 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Imperialism In Colombia

...in favor of some ‘victims’, who are not the truly victims and some of them are the aggressors of those farmers and poor people; Furthermore, the real victims who suffer rapes, extortions, kidnaps and dies, were not a part of this ‘Peace’ negotiations. An important example and a real victim is Sara Morales, she is an ex-member of the FARC who was a direct victim of this conflict. When she was 11 years old, she was recruited for the FARC and she was forced to live a heartbroken live. When she was in this group she suffers many kinds of violence, she was raped multiple times and almost oblige to abort her babies. Today, she is fating against these peace process in Colombia, because she states that not only her aggressors, as well the aggressors of many women that when trough for the same horrible live as she, can be free of their punishments living a real justice in a side and cover the reality with their ‘Justice’. After the overthrow of the plebiscite by the Colombian people, a new agreement was released by the Colombian president, “The agreement now offers some clarity over what to expect as rebels accused of various offenses, including war crimes and drug trafficking, go before a special court.” (NY Times) This is not an unbiased decision, because they are using a special court for these criminals and not judging them as delinquents, that is what they truly are. Most people who steal, kill, or broke the law have an impartial judge and they get punished for their crime by going...

Words: 1613 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Juvenile Crime Statistics

...Running head: JUVENILE CRIME STATISTICS PAPER 1 Juvenile Crime Statistics Paper CJA/374 JUVENILE CRIME STATISTICS PAPER 2 Juvenile Crime Statistics Paper Introduction Juvenile crime statistics is truly misunderstood by today’s society. The general public pushes for harsher punishment when in reality juvenile crime rate has actually decreased. This paper will summarize the “Juvenile Arrests 2008”. This paper will further discuss the overall decrease in juvenile arrests, the increase in drug offenses and simple assaults, implications for juvenile females and members of ethnic and racial minorities, an increase in juvenile female arrests and a decrease in arrests for juvenile male offenders for violent crimes, as well as what assessment are used to track juvenile arrests in order to measure the amount of juvenile crime as well as its trends. The Overall Decrease in Juvenile Arrests Overall Review Data from 2008 shows that juvenile arrests for violent crime declined between 2006 and 2008. According to Puzzanchera (2009) “In 2008 there were 2.11 million juvenile arrests, which is 16% lower than the arrests in 1999” (p.3). In 2008 juvenile arrests for forcible rape was at an all time low since 1980, aggravated assault arrests were also at its lowest since 1988. However, juvenile arrests for murder were at its low in 2004, but increased from 2005 to 2007. Further, the Property Crime Index decreased by 20%, larceny-theft by 17%, murder by 5%, motor vehicle theft by 50%...

Words: 1423 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Alternative Dispute Resolution

...Alternative Dispute Resolution Name: Institution Affiliation: Introduction Alternative dispute resolution is a method for settling parties' disagreements outside of court's antagonistic setting. Today, ADRs are greatly compelling to the point that courts frequently oblige parties to seek after this plan B before disputing their cases. Both arbitration and mediation may be court-requested. Settling one's dispute through components outside to the court structure may spare one time and cash. In the last twenty-five years, since Australia held onto multiculturalism as an approach, issues of intercultural correspondence have ended up more noticeable in the working environment. On the other hand, until as of late, little had been composed on these issues, and even now, numerous authoritative managers have no preparation. They as well have no learning of how to manage correspondence problems, despite the fact that most workplaces are staffed by individuals of diverse cultures. The report examines these three issue areas and shows that a considerable lot of the difficulties confronted by migrants in the workforce are caused by the absence of awareness of, and preparing in, intercultural correspondence. Why clients should be encouraged to use ADR and Implications Clients ought to be encouraged to make use of these alternative methods for solving conflicts for a number of reasons. ADR can permit access to justice. Case in point, as there can be cost and...

Words: 3050 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Stereotyping In Adnan Syed

...After further investigation, it was provided that the only corroborating fact between these three trials was “that it involved a Pakistani male charged with murder where the victim was known to the defendant”. Although the Judge might have removed those with implied bias from the jury, he had failed to account for present bias in the court itself. Vicki Wash had spread misinformation and used clear Islamophobia towards Adnan Syed in place of proof without repercussion from the court. Not only did this continue throughout his trial, but was done by multiple prosecutors in Adnan's case. Both Casey Murphy and Kevin Urick claim his actions were brought forth due to his honor being “besmirched” (timestamp 12:32). This word has a direct derivative from the term “honor killing” a phrase which means the murder of a girl performed by a male member of the family. This act was commonly performed in Middle Eastern or Indian subcontinents. Once more a direct acquisition against...

Words: 667 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Why Accounting Fraud? & Possible Solutions

...Why Accounting Fraud? & Possible Solutions Brian Faanes Rasmussen College Author Note This research is being submitted on 9-12-2011 for Wendell Ellis A140 Financial Accounting 1 course at Rasmussen College by Brian Faanes Most accountants and auditors want to be accurate and honest when it comes to the recording of financial records and statements of the company or firm they work for. However, because of tight relationships between accounting firms and their clients, auditors may unintentionally distort the numbers. In this research paper let us examine some of the conflicts with current accounting practices and possible solutions to improve the corporate accountability and the financial reports they convey to the public and investors. There have been a number of accounting fraud sandals in the last decade, some of these companies include; Enron 2001, Worldcom 2002, Tyco International 2002 and locally, Tom Peters Company 2008. As a result of these most recent accounting frauds, congress passed the Sarbanes-Oxley act in 2002. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act * Applies to publicly traded companies * Established the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB). The PCAOB is a private sector, nonprofit corporation that oversees the auditors of public companies. The PCAOB protects the interests of investors by helping ensure fair, independent audit reports. * Requires that external auditors report to an audit committee, rather than to an organization’s management...

Words: 1556 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Criminal Justice

...com/list_7774779_role-duties-district-attorney.html#ixzz1tRSozElQ Read more: Assistant District Attorney Job Description | eHow.com http://www.ehow.com/about_6678588_assistant-district-attorney-job-description.html#ixzz1tRTlS8rU Read more: Assistant District Attorney Job Description | eHow.com http://www.ehow.com/about_6678588_assistant-district-attorney-job-description.html#ixzz1tRTwBvmX * Read more: Assistant District Attorney Job Description | eHow.com http://www.ehow.com/about_6678588_assistant-district-attorney-job-description.html#ixzz1tRU8Bc2n Police Investigate Filing of Criminal Complaint After an alleged crime is investigated, the police initiate the criminal procedure by filing a complaint with the Magisterial District Judge (MDJ) in the area that the crime occurred. Once the complaint is filed, the MDJ will issue either a summons or a warrant of arrest, depending generally on the seriousness of the offense alleged. If issued a summons, the defendant will be notified of the date of their preliminary hearing in the summons. Preliminary Arraignment If a warrant of arrest is issued by the MDJ, or if the process was initiated by a warrantless arrest, the defendant must appear before the MDJ for a preliminary arraignment. The defendant will be provided with a copy of the...

Words: 10970 - Pages: 44

Premium Essay

Shield Of Government Essay

...threats. While the country requires defense from those forces who’d wish destruction upon liberty and freedom, it also has an equal need for a type of police system to protect each inhabitant of the country from one-another. In addition, a government must guarantee that the correct amount of policing occurs. Due to this, it will need to identify laws to clearly state the ideal amount of policing that must occur, it must also include ample ways to apply said laws. Furthermore, to assure that rights and liberties are sustained perfectly, the assessment of the amount of policing required must be impartial. Due to citizens failing to be neutral in the presence of any type of incident, the government will require a type of judiciary system. (The Federalist Papers #10, #51, and #78 pg.10) Liberties, rights, and laws are the items with which a judiciary system assesses and concludes if policing was truly necessary and correctly applied. (Locke’s Political Philosophy (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) pg. 11-18) Government’s sole and central purpose is to protect its citizens’ liberties and rights from those who seek to take them. First, a governmental structure acts as a shield. A shield that protects its denizens from varying threats be it both internal and external. To elaborate on internal issues, the government must furnish checks and balances between the different departments of government. (Locke’s Political Philosophy (Stamford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.) pg.11-18) Should any...

Words: 917 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Aquinas Ideas Of Divine Justice

...God’s grace. In Dante’s The Divine Comedy, the nature of justice seems to be impartial and unexempt from anyone. Specifically,...

Words: 1369 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Right to Counsel

...RIGHT TO COUNSEL 1 Originating when the sixth amendament was ratified on December 15, 1791 the right to council in the United States was born. This amendment states the following. “In criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the state and district where the crime was committed. Also, the district shall have been previously determined by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation. To be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defense” (Amendment 6, 2009). Development of the Right to Counsel The Constitution specifies that the accused possess the right to counsel however, there is no specifications which states that counsel will be available from the government for the individual who have been accused. In most cases, only individuals who are afforded the employment of an attorney would have the indulgence of being represented by one. The right to counsel is a service no longer just limited to adults or to individuals who have financial means of being able to retain attorney but any individual who requests representation. At one time, the right to counsel was a service that was offered to those individuals involved in cases being tried within a criminal trial; however, this is no longer the scenario. Right to counsel can be for any case; criminal, family...

Words: 1188 - Pages: 5