...No. 1339 Information Sheet August 2001 Should I Lease or Buy? Steven W. Martin, Fred Cooke, Jr., David Parvin, and Scott Stiles I NTRODUCTION For many farms, machinery expense is the largest single production expense (Massey). Under current farm financial conditions, producers must search every avenue for opportunities to minimize costs and maximize returns. Producers have three basic options for meeting machinery needs: purchase the needed equipment, lease the needed equipment, or custom hire. Custom hire may work well for certain jobs, but often does not allow the amount of control many operations require. Like purchasing, leasing allows the producer to maintain control of the timeliness and quality of the work conducted on his or her farming operation. Therefore producers should evaluate leasing versus purchasing based on the economic opportunities that each provides. OVERVIEW Most leases consist of four basic components: • Periodic payment • Length of lease • Amount of use (hours, miles, etc.) • Residual Under a standard lease agreement, the lessee (farmer) agrees to pay the lessor (bank, credit corporation, dealer, etc.) a specified amount (payment) at certain intervals over a certain length of time. Three-year leases with annual payments are very common, but any arrangement is possible. The lease will generally specify the amount of annual use permitted under the base contract. Tractor leases often range from 300 to 1200 hours of annual use. The amount...
Words: 3737 - Pages: 15
...Contents Lease Vs. Buy Laid in Excel Spreadsheet1 Advantages to Lease Vs. Buy 2 Advantages of Using a Longer Time Table Rather Than Shorter 3 Real Estate Depreciation 4 Works Cited………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….……….5 Excel Spreadsheet Showing Table and Work. Advantages of Lease Vs. Buy The decision to lease or buy equipment or real estate is very important one. One of the most obvious draw backs to leasing versus buying is that, at the end of the lease, the organization does not own the equipment or real estate. The primary advantage to leasing is that it conserves cash for other business operations. Additionally, leasing allows the organization to expense some of the maintanence costs and provides superior tax benefits. Leasing allows for the organization to more efficiently keep up with technology advantages. In reference to real estate, the lease offers the option to change locations if necessary. Moreover, many of the maintenance costs fall on the owner and not the leaser. (Park, 2011) Advantages of Using a Longer Time Table Rather Than Shorter Particularly with real estate investments, a longer period than the four years used in this scenario might prove to be more accurate. While the real estate market is not particularly good now, a change in that area might make the initial investment actually have returns. The cyclical nature of this particular market may contribute to a more favorable outcome in the lease versus buy examination...
Words: 409 - Pages: 2
...Leasing vs. Buying a Vehicle The great debate to lease or buy a car? Which one of the two options is the smarter or he better choice? The answer to this question is both and neither are the best options. Confusing one may think so, however, the best way to get to the answer is to ask yourself what is important to you. Every person is different with different values and priorities that determine for them whether leasing or buying is the answer. There are people who desire to drive a new vehicle every few years with little or no maintenance costs. Some people have a strong desire to own the vehicle, as opposed to lower upfront costs with no ownership. One of the two of the biggest temptations for many people to lease verses buying are that the monthly costs to lease are cheaper than the monthly payments to buy a car. The other is that they are able to have a new car every 2-3 years, as opposed to the people who purchase. People who purchase generally hold on to the car for an additional 2 years after the last car payment. Let’s review the pros and cons of leasing. The advantages of leasing are it offers lower monthly payment and the ability to drive a new car with all the new bells and whistles every 2-3 years (ehow). There is a tax benefit of paying lower taxes since the individual is paying the taxes on the monthly payments verses the full value of the car. From the two examples so far it appears that leasing is a great situation, and everyone should lease; once...
Words: 1172 - Pages: 5
...obligation to pay. The two complement each other. It is clear that the two elements cannot be dissociated, for the contract of purchase and sale is essentially a bilateral contract, as it gives rise to reciprocal obligations. (Pio Barretto Sons, Inc. vs. Compania Maritima, 62 SCRA 167). Neither is the delivery of the thing bought nor the payment of the price necessary for the perfection of the contract of sale. Being consensual, it is perfected by mere consent. Contract to sell exclusive right and privilege to purchase an object. a bilateral contract whereby the prospective seller, while expressly reserving the ownership of the subject property despite delivery thereof to the prospective buyer binds himself to sell the said property exclusively to the prospective buyer upon fulfilment of the condition agreed upon, that is, full payment of the purchase price. Absent a proviso in the contract that the title to the property is reserved in the vendor until full payment of the purchase price or a stipulation giving the vendor the right to unilaterally rescind the contract the moment the vendee fails to pay within the fixed period, the transaction is an absolute contract of sale and not a contract to sell. (Dignos vs. CA [1988]) * The contract of sale by itself is not a mode of acquiring ownership. The contact transfers no real rights; it merely causes certain obligations to arise. BARTER The only point difference between contract of sale and...
Words: 3885 - Pages: 16
...LEASE OR FINANCE?? In today’s competitive economy, a vehicle is no longer considered a luxury anymore, but rather a necessity. There are not very many cities in the U.S. where you can live without car. I live in Orlando, Florida and dependable transportation is a mandatory expense. If you want to buy a new car, the cheapest way to buy a car is to pay cash for it. By paying cash you will avoid any finance charges. However, there are not very many people have thirty to fifty thousand dollars to spend on the vehicle. Lease or finance are two main options if you don’t have a lot of cash available to spend on the car. I have chosen the BMW and Infinity dealership to do my analysis. I picked two similar cars form the both dealerships: X5 xDrive35i Sport Activity from BMW and Infiniti FX50 from Infinity dealership. After analyzing financing and leasing options, there is no clear answer on whether to finance or lease a vehicle. It basically all depends on how much money you have, how many miles you drive, how long you want to keep your car for and etc. BMW offers 0.9% APR for 24 month and 3.9% for 25-60 month with $0 down payment to finance the X5 xDrive35i Sport Activity. The price of the vehicle is $57,700. It’s approximately $1,700 per month for 36 months. The lease option is $699 per month for 36 months with $3,000 down payment, $725 acquisition fee, and $4,424 cash is due at signing. The total lease payment is $25,164. At the end of the lease, lessee will be liable for disposition...
Words: 1443 - Pages: 6
...3303 | CAPITAL LEASE vs. OPERATING LEASE | | Dr. Serge Ryno ACCT 3303 December 2, 2011 Capital Lease vs. Operating Lease Firms often choose to lease long-term assets rather than buy them for a variety of reasons including the tax benefits that are greater to the lessor than the lessees and leases offer more flexibility in terms of adjusting to changes in technology and capacity needs. Lease payments create the same kind of obligation that interest payments on debt create, and have to be viewed in a similar light. If a firm is allowed to lease a significant portion of its assets and keep it off its financial statements, an examination of the statements will give a very misleading view of the company's financial strength. Consequently, accounting rules have been devised to force firms to reveal the extent of their lease obligations on their books. There are two ways of accounting for leases. In an operating lease, the lessor (or owner) transfers only the right to use the property to the lessee. At the end of the lease period, the lessee returns the property to the lessor. Since the lessee does not assume the risk of ownership, the lease expense is treated as an operating expense in the income statement and the lease does not affect the balance sheet. In an operating lease, a company pays a periodic fee for the use of some benefit. The benefit can be tangible, such as office space, or intangible, such as a patent. The company acquiring the lease takes no ownership...
Words: 1490 - Pages: 6
...Leasing vs. Purchasing Leasing vs. Purchasing Purchasing or leasing a large asset is vital to the company’s financial bottom line. Businesses need to make ideal decisions based on what will help the growth of the company. Having a set financial plan in place that reviews not only the benefits but, also the losses will help determine if purchasing or leasing would be most beneficial for a company. Many factors will be addressed including taxes and time and money. Lease Decision Factors that should be consider before making a lease decision are the same factors that need to be evaluated to make a purchase decision. A plan should be put together addressing the following factors. What is the timeframe needed is it short or unknown, how soon would the item or be needed. I the space, item adequate, or will there be the cost associated with making the space or item adequate. Flexibility for growth and possible costs associated with expanding space or equipment in present location. Physical space location considerations, ability to grow, or possible relocation costs and travel time. Services needed for space or item or services close enough, cost for services that need to be implemented, networking, electrical, parking and security. Understanding cost such as “design fees, construction, moving expenses, and furnishing in addition to operating expenses”. (University of Missouri System, 2013) Funding type & availability needs to be determined with the company’s business officer...
Words: 904 - Pages: 4
...Burlington Northern Railroad Company: Equipment Leasing To: Rob McKenney Vice President & Treasurer BNRR From: Paul Weyandt Director of Equipment Finance BNRR Date: July 15, 1990 Subject: Lease Vs Buy Option for Auto Racks Equipment This memo is in regard to the recent proposal of leasing or buying the bi-level and tri-level Auto Rack equipment for Burlington Northern Railroad Company. As indicated before, this equipment is a great investment for our company as it exceeds our company’s 20% hurdle rate and therefore investing in them would be a great decision for the company. Hence this memo will seek to explain the optimal way to finance this investment; in other words, this memo will try and demonstrate the most beneficial way to value the auto racks in terms of whether to lease them or own them. In terms of financing the deal, the company has 3 options. 1) Owning. 2) Leasing. 3) Seasoned Equity Offering. For the Owning option, BNRR would need to raise 22 million dollars to buy the equipment, which will put immense pressure on company’s books. The loan amount will be spread across 15 years and the estimated age of the equipment is 22 years old. Some of the disadvantages that I see with this plan are: • The company is already highly levered with long term debt representing 76% of its total capital structure. We’ve maxed out our debt capacity availability and therefore adding more debt to our books is not recommendable. • Railroad...
Words: 1129 - Pages: 5
...DRA Assignment 2 – Recreational Properties 1) FRAMING THE DECISION 1.a) Decisions a) He can exercise the option and buy the land. In this case, the possible decisions are: a.1) Sell the land without any development a.2) Develop the land with a development cost of £ 5 million and the sell it for a higher profit b) He can avoid to exercise the option and invest in another investment that will give to him a certain profit. c) Try to negotiate an option extension in order to be able to delay his decisions until the suit is settled and the risk of not getting the lease does not affect his decision anymore. d) For the purpose of this analysis we are assuming that the price of the option will remain constant. Otherwise another possible decision that Anders may make is whether to sell the option to third parties and eventually recover part of his investments. 1.b) Factors of uncertainty a) Legal suit outcome: the payoff of his decision is subject to the outcome of the lawsuit that may not allow the development of land parcels on East side of White Mountain. b) Reputation: the success of his initiative and the consequent return on his investment are conditioned by the popularity that the location will have, as for instance the quality of the snow and of the ski runs. Due to their nature, these are unpredictable factors that Anders cannot control. 1.c) Objective The objective of Recreational Properties is to maximise the payoff coming from this investment as well as minimising...
Words: 1914 - Pages: 8
...Lease Finance Lease Finance • Lease is contract between the owner of the asset (Lessor) and the user (Lessee) of the asset, wherein the Lessor gives the right to use the asset to the Lessee for a consideration (Lease Rentals) over an agreed period of time (Lease period or tenure). • At the end of the lease period, the leased asset reverts back to the Lessor, unless the lease is renewed for another term. • Leasing separates the ‘Ownership’ and ‘Usage’ of the asset as two separate economic activities. Leasing 2 Leasing, Hire Purchase, Instalment Sale • Leasing: – Lessor retains the Ownership of the asset & claims the benefit of Depreciation. – Lessee claims the Lease Rentals as tax-deductible expense. • Hire Purchase: – Ownership passes to the Hirer (user) on payment of the last Instalment (on payment of Capital & Interest) and takes benefit of Depreciation and tax-deductibility of the Interest component of the Hire charges. • Instalment Sale: – The legal ownership passes as soon as the 1st instalment is paid. The balance amount is treated as a secured loan and Interest portion is Tax-deductible Leasing 3 Basic Types of Lease • On the basis of the extent to which the risks and rewards incidental to the ownership of the leased assets lie with the Lessor or the Lessee, lease can be classified as: Finance Lease Operating Lease Leasing 4 Finance (or Capital) Lease • Non-cancellable for a specified period called the PRIMARY LEASE Period- usually 5-8 years. • Leased Asset...
Words: 2584 - Pages: 11
...MANDATES Piec vs. Caisse d’economie polonaise (p. 59) 01-Jul-92 Date of Bad Boy’s forged mandate 15-May-92 Bad Boy gets mandate from Grandma 03-Jul-92 Grandma dies 11-Aug-92 Bad Boy gives forged mandate to bank Bad Boy comes to Canada 18-Aug-92 Bad Boy withdraws $26k payable too cash Grandma = Stephania Wojcicka Bad Boy = nephew Tadeusz Wojcicki Niece (Margaret Wojcicka) is executor of will Facts | * Three mandates: 1. Gma goes on extended trip, gives power of attorney for banking matters to Bad Boy 2. Niece has mandate as executor of the will (mandate only kicks in when Gma dies) 3. Bank has mandate for Gma’s finances * Grandma’s bank account summary: $5 membership, $1k term deposit, $26k term deposit (can’t take out until 26-Oct-92 or wil receive no interest) * Bank didn’t k6now Gma was dead when Bad Boy removed funds | Question | 1. Was bank guilty of not [2138] exercising prudence and diligence for its [2130] mandate? 2. Does the valid mandate authorize the bank to give the term deposits (no) 3. What effect should be given to the letter of july 1st (none) 4. Did the bank owe obligation to grandma, and not rely on the letter (yes, 2138) | Ratio | 1. Argument: Bank is a special type of agent, v. strong fiduciary duties; if they’ve been defrauded they are 100% liable. Answer: Bank should have been more [2138] prudent and diligent; it wasn’t prudent cash out the account, and the bank wasn’t diligent in its duty...
Words: 3405 - Pages: 14
...Lease Vs Purchase Paper Team B FIN 370 March 12, 2015 Davidson Jansen Lease Vs Purchase Paper Leasing versus purchasing advantages and disadvantages When equipment is leased one of the main advantages is that the equipment is kept up –to-date. For example, if a company lease a car for two years, once the contract is done, the company can lease or buy a newer car with newer technology. Another big advantages for leasing equipment in the business world is the predictability of monthly expenses. A lease comes with a pre-determined monthly line item which is most helpful during the monthly budgeting. One of the biggest disadvantages of leasing is the fact that at the end a company will end up paying more for the product or equipment (Alexander, 2015). When a company purchase equipment the biggest advantage is the availability to deduct the full cost of the equipment on the company’s taxes. Another big advantage is that freedom of maintenance choice. When an equipment is leased the leasing company has a say on how the equipment must be maintain. The biggest disadvantage of purchasing equipment is once the equipment is outdated you are stuck with it (Alexander, 2015). Compare Factors Involved in Leasing and Purchasing Equipment According to Principals and Practices of Public Procurement (2012), it is important to conduct a cost/benefit analysis when determining whether to lease or purchase equipment. Factors to consider when conducing this analysis includes determining...
Words: 388 - Pages: 2
...Lease versus Purchase Paper FIN/370 Lease versus Purchase Paper There are many factors to when one is considering buying or leasing equipment, building or automobile. And the most important primary factor is, should one lease or buy? Lease means to rent the equipment, building or automobile with the option to own the property. While purchasing is to own the equipment, automobile or building. One has to consider how long one is keeping the asset of property, and which option fits one’s needs. There are advantages and disadvantages with both options, and it depends on one’s business or life situation and making the right choice to buy or lease in that given situation. Factors Involved According to BizFilings (2012), when an organization is deciding to lease or purchase assets then there are factors to consider. One way to compare the two would be to do a cash-flow analysis. When doing the analysis one should take into consideration the following factors: 1. Terms of the lease 2. The cost of capital 3. Federal income tax rate 4. State income tax rate 5. Purchasing and financing terms 6. The value of the asset as well as the span it is useful 7. Any other expenditures associated with the lease or purchase During the decision making process, it is also important to consider cash flows and the net advantage of leasing or “NAV”. NAV is defined as, “The money that would be saved by leasing an asset instead of buying it, not taking into...
Words: 609 - Pages: 3
...Lease versus Purchase FIN/370 March 30, 2015 Russel Riggs Lease versus Purchase Buy or lease equipment? This question is based and depends on the business “status”, which means that depends on the business capital budget, projections in short/long-term and the necessity of the equipment. Leasing business equipment and tools preserves capital and provide flexibility but may cost you more in the long run, (“NOLO”, 2014). On the other hand, buying equipment means ownerships and tax breaks make buying businesses equipment appealing, but high initial cost mean this option is not for everyone, (“NOLO”, 2014). At the moment to grow a business it will need tools in order to function properly and generate good profits, thus the business must analyze the initial investment that is required, the tax rate and the equipment’s time period of use to do not affect the business finance founds. May the business lease if it is necessary to change constantly the equipment or may the business buy the equipment because it will be until it gets old. Further in this essay we will explain different point of view with its respective example to consider whether to buy or lease. Both leasing and purchasing products has its place, but it is important to determine which path to take for each situation. A lease “permits the firm (lessee) to use the asset without acquiring title, which is retained by the owner (the lessor).”(Titman, Keown & Martin, 2014) Then in order to use the asset the lessee...
Words: 731 - Pages: 3
...Week 7- Leases An agreement whereby the lessor conveys to the lessee in return of a payment series the payments the right to use an asset for an agreed period of time. Step 1 Define a finance lease Lease Risks and rewards has the ownership being transferred Where ownership being risks and rewards Step 2: Discuss risks and rewards Risks: Insurance, maintenance, potential drop in residual value Rewards: use of assets, potential increase in residual value Who bears? Who enjoys? URV MLP MLP MLP Minimum lease payments All minimum payments required by the lessee to the lessor 1. Rental 2. GRV * Guaranteed residual value * The asset will buy the asset from the lessor 3. BPO * Bargain purchase option * Gives the right to lessee to buy the asset that lower than market value MLP = CI 1-11+In +(GRV+BPO1+in) URV * unguaranteed residual value 3 types of leases * Direct finance * Manufacture/ dealer * Sales & lease back Lessor 1. Initial recognition DR Lease receivable xx CR asset xx 2. Subsequent measurement Lease receivable = Pv (MCR) + PV( URV) 3. Subsequent measurement Lease schedule Lessee 1. Initial recognition (Sales & lease back) DR cash xx CR lease asset xx CR deferred gain (L) xx *Deferred gain needs to be amortized 2. record lease Dr increase...
Words: 402 - Pages: 2
