Free Essay

Criminal Justice System Assessment

In:

Submitted By snakedoctor551
Words 1511
Pages 7
Running head: CRIME DATA COMPARISON PAPER

Crime Data Comparison Paper
Willie Clark
University of Phoenix

Crime Data Comparison Paper In this paper, I will take a caparison look at the crime index for two metropolitan areas in the United States using statistical information provided by the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Uniform Crime Report posted yearly will display the two geographical areas I choose to compare for the study is Memphis and Nashville TN. I will compare the violent crime of murder rate for Memphis versus the Property index rate for burglary for Nashville and how the two, which are just two, and half-hours apart vary so differently. A little history on the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting or UCR created in 1992 and the International Association of Police Chiefs is credited for its influences dating back to the 1920s to push for complete crime statistic yearly in order to combat the increasing crime rate. In the Uniform Crime Reporting system, there are seven main categories identified, manslaughter and non-negligent murder, burglary, aggravated assault forcible rape, larceny, arson, and motor vehicle theft. The Uniform Crime Report first was in January 1930, the UCR reported 400 cities throughout 43 states, covering more than 20 million individuals, approximately 20 percent of the total United States population. The city of Memphis is in the southwest portion of the state of TN. The city has a population as of September 2009 of more than 672,046 residents. The total of violent crimes overall for that reported year was 1,945 incidents. The crime index I choose for this city was Murder. Memphis over the years has made many headlines as one of the most violent cities to live in the United States. As recently as several years ago, the city was labeled the murder capital of the United States. It was reported that as of September of 2009 that the City of Memphis ranked in the top 20 cities at number 13 with a 20.5, which represented 132 murders. This has been a substantial drop in number from 2005 through 2008, which were 154,160,164 and 138. The city I choose to compare for this paper is Nashville, which is located in the middle of the state of Tennessee and is the state’s capital. The city has a population as of September 2009 of more than 602,181 residents. The total number of violent crimes overall for that reported year was 1,395.6 incidents as compared to Memphis. Nashville over the years has not made many headlines as Memphis has and is considered one of the fastest growing cities to live in the United States. It was reported that as of September of 2009 that the City of Nashville ranked outside the top 20 cities at number 25 with a 12.6. City officials of Memphis say the city's high crime rate is highly exaggerated because of the unfair reporting used to report crime. Memphis residents believe that there are many flaws in UCR system and that they are not being represented accurately or the years. Memphis is regularly listed among the most violent cities to live because of past statistics. Other cities have different reporting methods, criminal statutes vary from state to state, and some places do not report according to standard practices. According to The Commercial Appeal, another problem arises when city rankings are confused with metropolitan crime numbers. A cluster of wealthy suburbs, which tend to have less street crime, does not surround Memphis, unlike other major cities. Other discrepancies surface, which several crimes are committed in one incident. While Memphis reports each individual crime, some cities report only the worst offense (Commercial Appeal, 2009). The murder rate of Memphis was played out for the Media unlike Nashville in the Art and Entertainment Channel show called “First 48”, which followed the cities with the highest murder rates. Recently because of the negative attention, the show contract with city was not resign due to the overwhelming negative attention of Memphis being crime ridden. Nashville though smaller city size has a much larger metro area of 1.6 million versus Memphis area of 1.2 but has lower reported crime (Hendron, 2009). Over the last 10 years the statistic show a increasing drop in violent crimes in Nashville while Memphis remains almost even during that period. Today Memphis is considered one of the most deadly cities to live in (UCR, 2009). The next property index crime I choose for this region is burglary for Nashville as compared to Memphis TN. The number of reported property crimes in Nashville for 2008 through 2009 was 32,275 reported crimes and 28,911 reported crimes. Out of those reported crimes, the burglary offenses committed for Nashville for 2008 was 6,312 and for 2009 was 6,264. Burglary offenses for the past 10 years in this region have continued to increase with the size of population. The burglary statistic for Memphis from 2008 through 2009 shows a slit difference when compared to Nashville. The stats show that in 2008 the reported property index crimes 53,870 with burglary offenses number of 13,879. The following year for 2009 Memphis reported total property index reports 47,158 with al number of burglary offenses of 13,935. When you compare the two cities property index, statistics they are not too far apart in numbers. The crime rate for those offense roughly drop 100 reports in each year for each city. With these startling numbers, many residents of Nashville believe that their city crime rate in Murders and burglary will continue to rise and resemble the city of Memphis (UCR, 2009). I think of the politics of the need to "under report" all crime---particularly violent crime. In 2007, Nashville law enforcement reported 22,000+ thefts. Most criminologist scoff at this number, when statistically factored to a population of 542,000. Internal controls in law enforcement screen out many of the serious thefts, on the basis of known origin of theft, e.g. relatives, pre-emptive action on known theft occurrences, etc. a good deal of "see, but, don't see" is essential in many law enforcement agencies. Unfortunately, this is very true in Nashville and in its law enforcement agency. Nashville has experienced lags, as has some other cities in Tennessee, in funding dollars/officer in policing. Ultimately, the number of residents an officer is charged to protect affects his ability to adequately police that statistical charge. In theory, it is easier to be responsible for 2.03 citizen’s officer than to be responsible for 3.87 citizen’s officer. How does Nashville want resources spent in protection---and where? The "squeaky wheel gets the grease" is not always applicable in Nashville. Generally, crime can be targeted as an expected occurrence in certain given areas. Apparently, in Nashville, this is an ever-fading assumption of the past that keeps rearing its ugly head. One theory that must be considered for the good of our society is the crime rate for both cities are the poverty level and gun control laws. It tends to be seen that one closely follows the other especially examining these two metro areas. Memphis has one of the highest crimes in United states compared to other metro area it size, while Nashville is not too far behind on the national average. It is easy to determine that unfortunately the chance of a property or a violent crime happening is one in 10. Nashville violent crime rate does not compare to Memphis and has seen a drop in violent crimes in the last 10 years. Surrounding metro areas of Memphis does not come close to the crime index rate of property and violent crimes combine. It is clear to see that the comparison is Memphis crime index in property and violent crimes committed over a ten-year period remain steady and outweighs Nashville. Something has to be done more than compiling statistic on the increasing crime rate (Conley, 2009). If our society attacks the problem of poverty, gun control and economics our society might be able to put a substantial dent in the crime rate across the board. Only time will tell if the current crime rate will continue to rise while we as a society continue to drag our feet. Reporting crime accurately is beneficial but should not be the focus of our nation.

References
Conley, C. (2009, June 29). Memphis a Victim of Crime Reports. The Commercial Appeal. Retrieved from http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/2009
Glazer, Sarah. "Declining crime rates: does better policing account for the reduction?" CQ Researcher 4 Apr. 1997: 291+. General OneFile. Web. 30 June 2010.
Hendron, J. (2009). U.S. "Murder Capital “a tricky Figure... ABC News website. Retrieved from http://abcnews.go.com/US/story
U.S. Department of Justice. (2009). Federal Bureau of Investigation. Retrieved from http://www.fbi.gov/publications.htm
Freeh, L. (1994). Violent crime in the U.S. Vital Speeches of the Day, 60(14), 418. Retrieved from Academic Search Complete database.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Assessments of the Criminal Justice System Structures

...Models of Criminal Justice When discussing larger issues such as The Criminal Justice System of America, so often that larger issue is comprised of a myriad of contributing issues that must be addressed. All too often these issues cross the boundaries of the codified models. When we approach the laudable goals of crime control, specifically the burden to keep our citizens safe from criminal abuses, we speak of appropriate penalties for breaking laws, deterrents and “the repression of criminal conduct” (Neubauer & Fradella, 2014, p. 19). The tenets of the due process model are also very worthy. As a reasonable person, I value the protection of individual rights, specifically since it figures so largely in Scripture. As an example, in Proverbs 31:9 we are told to “defend the rights of the poor and needy” and Leviticus 19:15 tells us to “not be partial to the poor or defer to the great” (English Standard Version, 2014). I also think that a person’s circumstances should factor into the evaluation of the offense and that just as God’s redemption is available to all who choose to receive it, so, too, redemption, or rehabilitation, should be offered more often than it is denied. The Question of Balance in the Criminal Justice System One of the hallmarks of the United States justice system is supposed to be its systems of checks and balances with important contributions from citizens of the community, both in our style of government as well as in our criminal justice system. The degree...

Words: 1071 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Risk Management

...Economic Times, 2012). Risk management will also include identifying the various risk of an organization within a risk assessment, to assessing the risk and potential threats it may pose to an organization. Risk management will have different approaches to assess the risk; each organization will have different levels and types of risk. An organization without the knowledge of the potential threats will not adequately respond in the case of an emergency or crisis. Planning for the Risk and Identify Resources An organization will face various risk; these risks could be cyber crimes, terrorism, natural disasters, and accidents within the workplace, lawsuits, and physical crimes. An organization will face some risk, and some organizations may never have to face a risk; however, the organization that faces the risk will need to have a way to respond to the risk. For example the criminal justice system faces a potential threat with the legal responsibility of providing the necessary response, which faces a greater risk in an illegal situation. A possible risk for the police department is a riot; this situation will require employees to respond with the training that he or she receives. Each branch of the criminal justice system will need a plan on how to assess the risk as it occurs. For example, a police department has the responsibility of responding to each criminal activity including terrorist threats. The police department will need to have a plan in place to assess the situation...

Words: 1466 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Criminal Profiling: the Public Face of Forensic Psychology

...Criminal Profiling: The Public Face of Forensic Psychology Jason Evans Brandman University Table of contents Abstract 3 Introduction 4 Literature review 4 Discussion 7 Personal interest in the topic 10 References 11 Abstract The utilisation of psychological concepts has been extended in many fields in seeking to enhance understanding of human behaviours. Forensic psychology is one of the various psychological filed which have developed out of the necessity to apply psychology in different fields. This article discusses the element of forensic psychology in relation to the various issues arising within the field. A discussion of the various issues highlights ethical aspects as the main causes of many challenges faced in the field. The complexity of the setting under which the psychological practice is conducted makes the topic become one of the interesting psychological segments that can be studied. Introduction Forensic psychology can be defined as the utilisation of psychological concepts, skills, and insights in seeking to enhance the understanding of various elements of legal and criminal justice systems. Within the context of the subject various psychological and legal aspects become combined in seeking to understand the functioning and operations of criminal systems (Davies & Beech, 2012). This approach to criminal justice involves various activities involved in the delivery of justice, ranging from the enforcement to treatment of suspects...

Words: 2200 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Corrections

...1970's as a way to offer offenders, especially those leaving jail or prison, residential services in halfway houses. The first state community correction programs began in Oregon, Colorado, and Minnesota as pilot projects with very little government-funded support. They diverted nonviolent offenders in selected pilot project areas from jails and state prisons into local alternative punishment programs. The programs were referred to as "front-end" sentencing because they allowed judges to sentence offenders to a community-based punishment rather than jail or prison. Rehabilitation programs were the preferred punishment option. In the late 1980's, prison systems across the country began experiencing serious overcrowding of facilities. The overcrowding served as a catalyst for lawmakers to develop new options for sentencing criminal offenders. Nineteen states have now enacted various community correction programs. Community correction programs provide many communities with local punishment options as an alternative to prison or jail. These sanction programs are lower cost alternatives to increased prison...

Words: 1097 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Guenther Criminal Justice Analysis

...In 1976, a scholar on crime and justice by the name of Guenther offered a compelling assessment of the state of the criminal justice system. The argument he presented is one in which the criminal justice system came to reflect a system that was inherently “unfair, harsh, and biased”. From the perspective of Guenther, this system could no longer be considered a Criminal Justice System and instead should be viewed as a Criminal Processing System. Upon further analysis, it can be found that The criminal justice system is unfair, harsh, and biased because of the relationship between social, economic, and political isolation, the politicalization of crime, and perceptions and stereotypes. The criminal justice system must be accountable, transparent,...

Words: 1020 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice Trends Evaluation

...CJA 394 WEEK 1 Criminal Justice Trends Evaluation Criminal Justice Trends Evaluation John Doe CJA 394 October 01, 2001 Jane Doedy Criminal Justice Trends Evaluation The criminal justice system is forever adjusting to protect and serve a changing society. The paper evaluates, identifies and assesses recent future and current trends affecting the criminal justice system. Lastly, it defines the values of the system in a changing society. Recent trends affecting the criminal justice system are related to gender and racial barriers. According to Roslyn Muraskin and Albert R. Roberts (2009 ), assessments of statuses of women and minorities in police work shows that there are obstacles in official and informal structures of police work organizations related to gender and race. Regardless of assessment studies, which show that women are effective patrol officers, organizational principles of law enforcement has repelled the combination of women into patrol officers for more than 20 years. There are three kinds of organizational resistance to slowing down staffing and preservation of female patrol officers. The first organizational resistance is called Technical Resistance. Technical Resistance comprises of failure to adjust police uniforms, gear, and tools sufficiently for women, and constant issues on physical testing, and firearms during their drills, and preperations. The second organizational resistance is named Political and Cultural Resistance. According to Roslyn Muraskin...

Words: 1573 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Victim and Crime Evulation

...Victim and Crime Evaluation Larry Fulse CJA /354 May 5, 2014 Joeseph Caulfield The Criminal Justice system today is our scale of judgment. It plays a major part in how we live and how we continue to live among all the dangers, evil and corruption that surrounds us. Without it there wouldn`t be the fine line of right and wrong, there wouldn`t be justice. Those that are considered victims in our criminal justice would turn and become the aggressors and the criminals if we didn`t have a Legal System, and we would live in a world of chaos. Many individuals each have a role to play in our Criminal Justice System; there are the criminal and the victims who create the unfortunate events to which justice has to be served and then there are the defense attorneys and the prosecutors who do their best to upload the justice system and make sure that justice is served. What are the goals of sentencing associated? A defense attorney is a hired contractor, charged with representing individuals or entities in criminal or civil matter. People and organization facing criminal charges or being sued civilly hire a defense attorney to ensure their legal rights are properly protected and guide them through the legal counsel, is ethically and professionally required to watch over only the interest of his clients, within the boundaries of the law. He is legally and morally considered an “officer of the court,” and is required to refrain from lying or misrepresenting the facts of the...

Words: 1160 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Ultimately, Actuarial Principles and Methods Are Incompatible with Aspirations Towards a Youth Justice System Which Is Rooted in the Complex Dynamics and Systemic Inequalities Which Characterise Many Young People’s Lives.

...intervention to control and prevent future risks of offending. Actuarialism was defined by Feeley and Simon (1994) as being a defined approach to crime control and management which dispenses with concerns about the meaning or motives behind offending and replaces these with an emphasis on ‘technologies’ of ‘risk minimization’ and the elimination of potential threats to social order. The Risk Factor Prevention Paradigm (RFPP) uses risk assessment and survey to identify factors in the key domains of a young person’s life that statistically increase the likelihood of offending or decrease its likelihood (Case, 2007. p. 92). Youth justice today is increasingly dominated by risk management however it has been heavily criticized. In this essay an explanation will be given of what the risk factors are, what the RFPP is and how actuarial practices are based on this methodological approach. It concludes that a focus on actuarial principles in the current youth justice system works against the fundamental principles of individualization in the criminal justice system . Society has become increasingly concerned with risk and the management of it. It is defined as being an uncertain prediction of future behaviour with the possibility that the behaviour will be harmful or negative. The National Crime Council’s Document Tackling the Underlying Causes of Crime (2002) provides five categories of risk factors which are quantified as contributing to anti-social behaviour. They are as follows: Neighbourhood...

Words: 2006 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Personal Narrative: Criminal Justice Internship

...I’m currently a senior studying criminal justice at the University of Baltimore (UB). To satisfy a requirement for my degree program, I was required to secure an internship in my major. I believe this is an excellent way for me to gain experience as well as practical knowledge of the day to day operation concerning criminal justice work. My internship search began at the beginning of my senior year, without much success. I searched online job websites, made phone calls and reached out to family and friends. However, after attending an internship workshop at the college and looking through the literature that was handed out, I reached out to some of the agencies. I filled out an application with the Department of Juvenile Services (DJS) and waited for a reply. I checked my emails daily during winter break and finally received a response from the coordinator of volunteer services at DJS. Things started to move and to say the least, I was excited. After filling out many forms and taking care of the necessary background checks, I was offered the internship. After...

Words: 635 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Effect of Intervention Programmes on Youth Crime

... MANDEEP K. DHAMI and GREG MANTLE Darrell Fox is Consultant Social Worker, Havering Youth Offending Service, London Borough of Havering; Mandeep K. Dhami is Lecturer in Criminology, Institute of Criminology, University of Cambridge; Greg Mantle is Reader in Social Work, Institute of Health and Social Care, Anglia Ruskin University Abstract: This article explores the diversionary measure of restorative final warnings within the context of the youth justice system. We examine the philosophy and rationale of the new era in cautioning and discuss the potential practice implications since its implementation in 2000, under the statutory legislation within the Crime and Disorder Act 1998. To date there has been very little research or academic debate on the new system of police cautioning of youth. Additionally, as final warnings develop a greater association with restorative justice practices, we explore how this ‘pre court’ intervention has the potential to broaden oppressive and discriminatory practices within the youth justice system in relation to particular societal groups. We will begin by explaining how police cautioning of youth has changed with the implementation of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 and then explore contemporary police practices and outcomes regarding youth and the restorative final warning scheme. We will highlight the conflicting nature of the new scheme which requires voluntary agreement throughout its statutory process to ensure successful completion. We...

Words: 5918 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Data Collection and Research Testing

...Survey Research and Data Collection Testing Dustin Sparks CJA345 March 14, 2016 Susan Wind Survey Research and Data Collection Testing “Survey research is a commonly used method for collecting information about a population or a research area of interest.” (Week 3 Podcast) In this paper we are going to discuss the different ways of collecting data, as well as how reliability and validity play a part in the research methods of criminal justice. We will also discuss the advantages and disadvantages of certain survey distribution techniques, and how reliability and validity are important. Also in this paper, I will show you the importance of a police officer and their role in collecting data. There are many different ways that data is collected in the criminal justice system. Examples of these are with surveys and questionnaires, and Sampling. These are used to gather information about the area and the people in it. Surveys are made with premade responses to the questions asked. Questionnaires are made with open ended questions. “Questionnaire development is made of a series of steps. The first step would be deciding what information you are trying to receive, identify the participants taking the survey, selecting the methods of reaching the participants, question development. There are many advantages and disadvantages when it comes to the different forms of surveys. There are in Person, Telephone, Computer-Based, and Focus Group Surveys; just to name a few types....

Words: 1418 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Globalcrimeissues

...paper will describe worldwide what criminal justice systems are doing to address the criminal issues identified. This paper will find a new story covering a terrorism- related crime that occurred in the last two years that had a worldwide impact. Discussion on how globally criminal justice system handled the crime and my opinion on the effectiveness of the systems response and it will include suggestions for future interventions to combat or prevent these crimes. In the last two decades, the world economy has globalized, so has its illicit counterpart. The global impact of transnational crime has grown to a massive level. Criminal groups have developed new technologies and adapted parallel network structures that are difficult to trace and stop that it has expanded their activities. The result has been an unparalleled of international crime (The "International Crime Threat Assessment). Here in the United States we have hundreds of individuals who enter illegally daily. These individuals bring with them drugs, firearms, contraband, and human trafficking of people, which hits the streets of the communities and businesses. These crimes are not a local problem they are an international issue also, which have become a worldwide threat. There are numerous crimes that fall under the umbrella of transnational crime, which includes some of the crimes that were mentioned earlier. These crimes have a significant impact on the Criminal Justice System and how plans are developed to combat...

Words: 1425 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Boob

...ONE OF THE NATION’S LEADING INNOVATORS IN DELIVERING EVIDENCE-BASED SOLUTIONS FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND HUMAN SERVICES TURNING LIVES 1 Yolo County, CA: EBP brings measureable, positive outcomes 2 King County, WA builds new system for Mental Health RX: the PRIME 4 Assessments.com selected to direct $1.2M statewide juvenile project in CA 4 News in Brief 5 Spotlight on ADC staff: Brian Richart is new ADC President 6 EBP – Recent Research: Exploring the Black Box of Community Supervision 8 Upcoming Events Winter 2010 | QUArterLY neWSLetter CURRENT NEWS AND trenDS AROUND supervision, and accurately and objectively identified higher risk juveniles who most need and can most benefit from rehabilitative treatment. Monthly statistics tell the story. In April 2007, the department was managing a caseload of 400 juveniles with a staff of 10 supervising field officers and an outpatient treatment budget of $120,000. Today, the total caseload is down to about 280, as the department has done a better job keeping very low risk youth out of the system altogether. Of those youth who do enter the system, some 150 low risk youth are supervised by 1 1/2 officers with diversion programs and minimal supervision, while the remaining officers are managing the 130 moderate to high risk juveniles (a 38% reduction in individual case load size) and providing individualized treatment through programs such as FFT (Functional Family Therapy) and T4C (Thinking for a Change)– cognitive behavioral programs...

Words: 3942 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Uuuu

...many, but not necessarily all, of the dynamics of the criminal justice system apply to various racial and ethnic groups. 3. Leinfelt, F. H. (2006). Racial Influences on the Likelihood of Police Searches and Search Hits: A Longitudinal Analysis from an American Midwestern City. Police Journal, 79(3): 238–257. 4. Office of Justice Systems Analysis (1995). Disparities in Processing Felony Arrests in New York State: 1990–1992, Office of Justice Systems Analysis, New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services. 5. Sabol, W. J., and Couture, H. (2008). Prison Inmates at Midyear 2007. Washington, D.C. Bureau of Justice Statistics. 6. U.S. Census Bureau (2007). 2006 American Community Survey. Available online at: http://www.census.gov/acs/ www/index.html. 7. Sabol and Couture, op. cit. 8. U.S. Census Bureau, op. cit. 9. Bonczar, T. P. (2003). Prevalence of Imprisonment in the U.S. Population, 1974–2001. Washington, D.C.: Bureau of Justice Statistics. 10. Snyder, H. (2006). Juvenile Arrests 2004. OJJDP Bulletin: Washington, D.C.: National Disproportionate Minority Contact Databook. 11. Federal Bureau of Investigation (2007). Crime in the United States, 2006. Washington, D.C. 12. Spohn, C. (2001). Thirty Years of Sentencing Reform: The Quest for a Racially Neutral Sentencing Process. In W. Reed & L. Winterfield (Eds.), Criminal Justice 2000 (Vol. 3, pp. 566). Washington, D.C.: National Institute of Justice. 13. King, R. (2008). Disparity by Geography: The...

Words: 1453 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Criminological Perspectives

...critically discuss whether victims are at the heart of criminal justice (CJ) considerations for policy reform. It will consider a number of theoretical perspectives, including victimology and critically discuss how the needs of victims of crime, including the services available, are tackled through a criminal justice response and the demands of the victim movement. The essay will demonstrate the impact of politics upon policy and practice initiatives on both a national and local level. Furthermore, there will be a discussion predominately about how probation policy and practice can appropriately respond to the needs and diversity of different victim groups, whilst touching briefly on other criminal justice agencies. To allow this assignment to be focused it will also concentrate largely on issues surrounding women as victims of domestic violence and examples within Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) communities. The 1985 United Nations Declaration of Basic Principles of Justice for Victims of Crime and Abuse of Power broadly defined the term ‘victims’ as: Persons who individually or collectively, have suffered harm, including physical or mental injury, emotional suffering, economic loss or substantial impairment of their fundamental rights, through acts…that are in violation of criminal laws operative within Member States. (cited in Goodey, 2005:10) While Goodey suggests that victims are ‘now at the heart of criminal justice considerations for policy reform’ (2004: 4), the development...

Words: 5339 - Pages: 22