...Guidelines for Critiquing a Qualitative Research Study | Elements influencing the believability of the research | Elements | Questions | Writing Style | Is the article well written – concise, grammatically correct, avoid use of jargons? Is it well laid out and organized? | Title | Is the title clear, accurate and unambiguous | Abstract | Does the abstract offer a clear overview of the study including the research problem, sample, methodology, finding, and recommendations? | Elements influencing the robustness of the research | Elements | Questions | Purpose/research problem | Is the purpose of the study/research problem clearly identified? | Logical consistency | Does the research report follow the steps of the research process in a logical manner? Do these steps naturally flow and are the links clear? | Literature Review | Is the review logically organized? Does it offer balanced critical analysis of the literature? Is the majority of the literature of recent origin? Is it mainly from primary sources and of an empirical nature | Theoretical framework | Has the conceptual or theoretical framework been identified? Is the framework adequately described? Is the framework appropriate? | Method and philosophical underpinnings | Has the philosophical approach been identified? Why was this approach/ method chosen? | Research setting | Was the setting properly and completely described? Were the circumstances under which the data was collected described? | ...
Words: 924 - Pages: 4
...Critiquing This essay is a critical analysis of a qualitative research article, "I thought it will keep them all quiet", women's experiences of breastfeeding as illusions of compliance: an interpretive phenomenological study, conducted by Spencer et al (2014). The criteria that will be met in this essay are application and appreciation of principle of research to nursing and health care and the difficulties involved in data collection, analysis and how this can affect research outcome, demonstrating the capabilities required to review a published article. The above will be achieved with the help of step by step (Ryan et al, 2007) which will cover the writing style, Authors, Report title, Abstract, statement of the phenomena of interest, purpose of study, literature review, theoretical framework, Method, Sample, Ethical considerations, data collection/analysis, Rigour, findings/discussion, conclusions/implication and recommendation and References. The authors in this article used research question "How is breastfeeding manifest in the experience of women?" participants on this research are mothers aged from 16 years old and above who have had given birth to a healthy term babies and have initiated breastfeeding at the birth of their youngest baby and breastfed for at least eleven days. 22 women took part in this research. They agreed to be interviewed after being given information about the study by their Health visitor. Data for this study was collected from...
Words: 1544 - Pages: 7
...fundamental importance of observing of the service users communication needs in relation to pain and pain management. This interest provided a cause for this integrative literature review. Approach: Wakefield (2014) has developed...
Words: 898 - Pages: 4
...Professional Development: Critiquing Research The ability to critique (critically analyse and evaluate) research from both the qualitative and quantitative paradigms is an essential skill for occupational therapists. It is this skill, integrated with expertise gained from clinical practice that underpins evidence based practice (EBP). Although there are many definitions of EBP, Muir Gray (1997) defines it as “an approach to decision making in which the clinician uses the best evidence available, in consultation with the patient, to decide upon the option which suits the patient best." The purpose of this assignment is to enable the development of skills in critical analysis by critiquing a research article, which will contribute to further development of knowledge and skills in using EBP in clinical settings. A framework developed by Hek and Moule (2006) (see pages 3- ) has been used to guide the critique of a research article. A framework was used as Caldwell et al (2010 pg e1) argue that “ frameworks assist the novice healthcare practitioner with learning about approaches to research by giving consideration to aspects of the similarities and differences between the qualitative and quantitative research paradigms.” This framework was chosen as it is comprehensive and covers points/questions raised during the critiquing process, although it is important to remember that it is not a definitive checklist and other...
Words: 3266 - Pages: 14
...findings. This aspect of critiquing nursing research is crucial, in that it enables nurses to provide the highest quality care to their patients. There are various approaches used in the critique of a nursing article. For instance, the best approach requires an individual to begin with an introduction where the purpose of critiquing such an article is stated. They then state the job together with other details of the author of the nursing study. This is done in order to prove whether, or not, the given author has credibility in the nursing world. The next step followed in writing a nursing critique paper is commenting on the title of the article. This gives a clear outline of the topic, depending on whether it properly characterizes and covers the presented content, together with the subject matter. This step could also include details on whether the presented research is supporting a particular need in the health sector. If such an article is able to meet the key points stated above, then it will make a high quality nursing document. The third step followed, in order to write a good nursing critique paper, is ensuring that all the stated case studies have participants with great records and achievements in the medical sector. The other step that is followed, in this case, includes judging the abstract on the basis of whether it is sufficient for the research paper presented. In the absence of an introduction in the research document, observe whether the literature review presented...
Words: 365 - Pages: 2
...Annotated bibliography DiMarco, Danette. “Paradice Lost, Paradise Regained: Homo Faber and the Makings of a New Beginning in Oryx and Crake.” Papers on Language & Literature, Southern Illinois University, 22 Mar. 2005 • In this piece by Danette DiMarco he has shown the possible connections within the book to the real world. He used the character snowman and the abdominal snowman as examples in his work to get his point across; of which that is critiquing modernity's commitment to homo faber. He does this by breaking down the characters actions and critiquing them to todays societies. Wetsman, Julie Leibach Nicole. “Four Ways 'Oryx and Crake' Predicted the Future.” Science Friday • In this piece Julie Leibach and Nicole Wetsman do a really good job of taking the realistic factors out of this book and show casing them. They do this by taking things that happened in the and comparing them to similar things that happened in present time. This is a heavy thing to prove but both authors did exceptionally well in taking the text and comparing it to real life scenario/ events...
Words: 574 - Pages: 3
...Guidelines for Critiquing a Quantitative Article Write a critique on sections listed below. For each section, write a brief summary followed by a critique based on the bulleted points under each section. Introduction • Articulation or clear explanation of the research problem or issue • Identification of specific research question, and or hypothesis. Reflect on the purpose of the study. Exploratory or descriptive studies need not have an hypothesis. If research question is not identified, say so and write what you think the research question is. • What rationale for the study is offered? Does it clearly state the relevance of the study to social work practice, policy, or social work education? Review of the Literature • How exhaustive is it? Does it cover all aspects of the research problem? Does it cover information pertaining to all concepts and variables of importance? Are major studies in the field reviewed? • How current is the literature review to the date of publication? • Are the gaps in literature discussed? Methodology • Are the main aspects like research design, data source (e.g., participants) and their selection, Data collection instruments, data collection procedures, and data analysis included? Is each aspect clearly described? • Are ethical issues addressed? State if you have any question about ethical issues pertaining to the study. Results • Is sample adequately described? • Are findings clearly presented...
Words: 305 - Pages: 2
...assignment – no more than 3,300 words | Submission deadline (Date and Time)**The assessment must be submitted prior to this deadline to avoid penalty | Date: 11th December 2015Time: 9am(If the submission is via drop box, the time must be 9am) | To be completed by the student prior to submitting assessment | Assessment Title- please specify the question you have chosen | People experience distress in different ways and so attempting to measure it Is pointless | Banner ID number(this is an 8 digit number, preceded by the letter ‘B’, e.g. B00123456) | B00188060 | Have you been granted a formal extension? | YES Audrey Cund Revised submission deadline for extension: 18th DEC 15 | Contents page Page 2 Introduction Page 3 Literature search Page 5 Critical Appraisal of a Quantitative Study Page 8 Critical Appraisal of a Qualitative Research Study Page 10 Conclusion Page 12 Appendix 1 Page 15 Appendix 2 Page 18 Appendix 3 Page 21 References Critical Appraisal of Quantitative and Qualitative Nursing Research Introduction Contemporary nursing continues to not only strive for evidence based practice, which according to the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) 2008 Code of Performance and Ethics should be part of nurse’s professional responsibilities but the nursing profession should look to develop this knowledge further. Nursing research allows nurses to develop critical and questioning skills which identify the strengths and weaknesses of the research...
Words: 4972 - Pages: 20
...Critique of Research Article Name Instructor Unit Date Medical articles can be well analyzed based on the content, the reputation of the authors among other useful information. However, it is paramount that evidence based practice (EBP) be adopted when analyzing an article. According to Sackett et al (1996, pg 71-72) “Evidence based medicine is the conscientious, explicit, and judicious use of current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual patients”. The best available and current research is utilized in making a judgment about the article in question (Drisko and Grady2012). The research article, Healthcare Providers’ Intentions to Engage in an Interprofessional Approach to Shared Decision-Making in Home Care Programs: A Mixed Methods Study by Legare et al., presents views of the healthcare providers in the implementation of the interprofessional approach to shared decision-making (IP-SDM). In addition, it evaluates their intention for engaging in the program. The IP-SDM program has been gaining popularity in Canada but it is yet to be incorporated into the healthcare system (Reeves et al., 2008) Interprofessional approach entails the engagement of different professionals within the healthcare system, where all contribute towards the achievement of a common method of patient care. In addition, the aspect of shared decision-making entails the development of a system that involves the patients in determining the type of treatment that is given...
Words: 4221 - Pages: 17
...Phrase Bank for Literature Reviews Phrases for citing The research in this area has focused on… The literature largely supports… Specifically, there is evidence that… Thus the literature suggests that… Smith reports that… Smith postulates…; further, he suggests… Smith focuses on… In his discussion of x, Smith states… Investigating the relationship between x and y, Smith proposes… These ideas are first clearly conceptualized in Smith’s paper… Smith purports… According to Smith… The basis of Smith’s argument is… Similarly, Smith finds… Smith uses the example of… Smith’s and Brown’s work investigates… More recent investigations have concluded… Importantly, they argue that… Some commentators, such as Buttinski and Fyshwyfe, cite the importance of… Earlier work in this area concluded that … In discussing topic x they suggest… Many commentators (see Buttinski & Fyshwyfe) view this model as... However they note that… Phrases for comparing & contrasting This phenomena is recognized by a number of sources… There appears to be a reasonable consensus on… Several studies in this area have found…However other studies… Whereas earlier commentators support x, more recent commentators… An understanding of Smith’s theory is useful when exploring Brown’s concept of… Like Smith, Brown views topic x as… Smith’s approach is problem-centred, whereas Brown… This concept is strongly linked to Smith’s...
Words: 463 - Pages: 2
...20/06/12 A critique of a qualitative study focusing on self- efficacy of staff managing people with learning disabilities who have challenging behaviour. This essay discusses in some details a qualitative study that explores the importance of self- efficacy in staff for managing challenging behaviour (Cudre’-Mauroux, 2010). The purpose of this study is to critically evaluate the article titled ‘’Self- efficacy of staff managing people with learning disabilities who have challenging behaviour’’. A framework devised by Cormack (2000) has been used to help the process of critiquing this article. This particular framework had been chosen as it is comprehensive framework covering most points needed in the critiquing process. It will evaluate the strength and weakness of the article in a systematic way discussing the title, abstract, introduction, sampling method, data collection tool, data analysed, literature and ethical issues, result and conclusion. The evidence retrieved will be analytically discussed in regards to the usefulness to clinical practice. The title of the study is ‘’Self- efficacy of staff managing people with learning disabilities who have challenging behaviour (Cudre’-Maurox,2010). According Grinnel and Unrau (2011) a title succinctly conveys the nature of the study. The title includes central phenomenon and group under investigation which is professional caregivers and person with learning disabilities. The title describes the study accurately. The key words...
Words: 2035 - Pages: 9
...NUR: 553 Developing Research 2 To show an in-depth understanding of the research process and its components this assignment will use a study conducted by Wills et al. (2005) to critique. Within the assignment there will be a description of the qualitative methodology used, followed by a discussion of the strengths and weakness and its appropriateness and relevance of the design for the study. It will then go on to critique the title of the study, the abstract, the literature review, the method and design and the data collection section of the study. To conclude this assignment there will a brief summary. A qualitative research approach seeks to understand humans by exploring their experiences, attitudes and behaviour (Dawson, 2009). It relies on methods that allow the researcher into the personal, intimate and private world of the participants (Polgar and Thomas, 2008). Qualitative research designs allow for in-depth assessments and the opportunity to put participant’s responses in context (Parahoo, 2006). Data collection methods include in-depth interviews, observations, recordings and other documentation (Parahoo, 2006). In qualitative research the hypotheses are generated during data collection and analysis, and measurement tends to be subjective (Parahoo, 2006). The flexibility in the nature of qualitative exploration also applies to the size of the samples and the sampling techniques (Parahoo, 2006). According to Polit (2010) qualitative research is based on the quality...
Words: 1777 - Pages: 8
...I am thrilled by the prospect of studying Literature with Film as a degree. Above and beyond novels studied as part of my English Literature A-level, I have sought insight into a range of books about the Middle East. For instance, In 'The Search of Walid Masoud', Jabra Ibrahim Jabra illustrates the world of sin and corruption in the 1948 Arab Israeli War through his colloquial Arabic, detecting moods. The tone of language and themes in his novels allows one to understand the nature of the author's stance in politics and society; the social injustice triggers action for change in both a socio-cultural context and individually. The social injustice of Jabra's novel is also portrayed in Mathieu Kassovitz's film, La Haine. He portrays the social ills of modern France in a theatrical manner, captivating me like no other film. Both Kassovitz and Ibrahim introduce the inequalities of societies through different platforms. Jabra is able to express the subsequent struggle for survival in war using a piece of written and personal dialogue, while Kassovitz's directing is influenced by the reality of social exclusion and aims to make his audience aware of a city being both a prison and a refuge of three protagonists. Films add a further texture to...
Words: 628 - Pages: 3
...questions or solve problems, while on the other hand they define nursing research as a systematic inquiry designed to develop knowledge about issues of importance to nurses, including nursing practice, nursing education and nursing administration. The importance of having research carried out in the nursing field can only be emphasised as it is the key element in generating and guaranteeing evidence to guide nursing practice and improvements to care and quality of life of both clients and service users as claimed by Polit and Beck (2006, p4). However once the research is undertaken and published, great emphasis is placed in finding out or identifying the strengths and weaknesses through critique. Polgar and Thomas (2000), point out that critiquing research entails identifying the strengths and weaknesses of research publications to ensure that patients/clients receive assessments and treatment based on the best available evidence. This evaluation encompasses a responsibility of judging the validity and relevance of the published material. In addition Polit and Beck (2006, p437), argue that research critique is not just a summary of a study, but rather a careful appraisal of its merits and flaws and the heart of a research critique lies in the appraisal of the researchers methodologic decisions. Hence a good critique...
Words: 2162 - Pages: 9
...tremendous amount of research on the subject of eHealth related to our ageing society. The main causes behind the slow adoption from ageing society to new technologies, such as smart phones and e-commerce, have been researched. There is not a main common cause amongst scientists for this slow adaptation. What are the possible main causes behind the slow adaptation for the elderly to new technology? The aim of this research was to analyse and come to the most common cause indicated by several researchers as to why the ageing society is slow to adapt to new technologies. The results were quite surprising and differed from our original argument. It was assumed that the ageing society was slow to use technology because they were complacent. A literature review of a number of mainly scientific articles on the topic of the ageing society and their slow adaptation to eHealth has been done, from this we were able to conclude that ergonomics and interface problems were the most common causes. It is important to figure out the causes of the slow adaptation to find possible market opportunities and to adjust the upcoming technologies for the ageing society. Keywords— eHealth, ageing, adaptation, elderly people, ergonomics Introduction Presently Information Technology is becoming a more dominant part of our daily routines; nearly all of what is undertaken in daily life is related to an ICT application. With regards to healthcare and ICT, eHealth systems are now becoming more...
Words: 3390 - Pages: 14