Free Essay

Cultural Analysis

In:

Submitted By peachworm77
Words 1510
Pages 7
Cultural Analysis Within the past decade, social media has gained worldwide popularity and has become a platform for every day communication. Users are beginning to use social media to fulfil many basic psychological needs in terms of making connections with others and finding a personal identity. The question is: How is social media affecting the way we communicate? How have critics and academics in our culture responded to the upsurge in social media? As social media continues to grow, so does the amount of research on the topic. A study on communication in social networks was conducted in 2013 by Megan Sponcil and Priscilla Gitimu in which 96 Midwestern university students answered a questionnaire inquiring about their social media usage. Questions in the “survey included the following areas: demographics, extent of usage of social media, effect on communication, and attitudes of self” (Journal of Technology 13). Studies show that those who use social media communicate with family and friends more often than those who do not (Journal of Technology 13). Social networking sites provide a channel for easy communication with all networks of friends within one medium. The authors make an unstated claim that although the communication may not be meaningful, social media allows users to stay connected to those they care about. Users of these sites have also been discovered to have a stronger sense of self concept with a .651 Pearson correlation between media use and sense of self concept (Journal of Technology 13). This implies these profiles on social media can help individuals better define who they want to be and what they want to show the world. However, these facts are valid only for college students. They didn’t have any other types of people in their study so they don’t have grounds to qualify these findings for the general population. The data makes the claim that these effects of social media are positively influencing our culture by allowing users to stay connected to those they cannot talk to every day. The authors use these findings to explain why social media has gained such popularity in recent years. This popularity is not exclusively for staying connected with friends either. A 2013 study conducted by Melissa Clark, head of Department of Management and Marketing at University of North Alabama, and Joanna Melancon head of Department of Marketing, Western Kentucky University, in which participants answered a questionnaire inquiring about relationship satisfaction, trust, commitment, loyalty, word of mouth and customer satisfaction. The results concluded that companies who actively participate in social media “tend to have better relationships with their followers in terms of customer satisfaction and loyalty” (International Journal of Marketing Studies 132). From this, we can make the assumption that when companies use social media, it helps them to connect better with their customers. However, participants in the study were asked only about companies who use social media. The data could be labeled as biased because they didn’t include data on companies who do not participate in social media. The authors might be making hasty generalizations when interpreting their findings. Popular networking sites are commonly used as a marketing tool because “social media followers perceive higher levels of relationship investment [and] report higher perceptions of relationship quality…than do non followers” (International Journal of Marketing Studies 132). This type of media has even started a new form of advertising. People follow company’s social networking sites to receive coupons and tweet their experiences. This new wave of marketing is changing the way we communicate not only as friends and family, but as consumers. Staying connected to others, however, is just the surface level of what social media does for users. These websites have been discovered to indulge many of our basic psychological needs. This past year, Louis Leung, head of the Centre for Communication and Public Opinion Survey in the School of Journalism & Communication at The Chinese University of Hong Kong conducted a study in in which 596 interviewers were asked via telephone some of their motivating factors for social media use. This survey concluded that social media has been able to satisfy “five socio-psychological needs [including] showing affection, venting negative feelings, gaining recognition, getting entertainment, and fulfilling cognitive needs” (Computers in Human Behavior 997). This claim can provide more insight as to why users feel the need to visit these sites so often. However, the reading did not cover other ways that people can fulfil these needs, therefore, it shows bias. The author makes an unstated assumption that through these forums, society has found comfort in being able to communicate their views within their network of friends. The research implies that the feedback received from friends on a number of these sites allow users to feel validated in their opinions. The benefits of social media are clear. However, this newfound popularity of online communication may be detrimental to face to face interaction. A recent 2012 study conducted by marketing researchers in Turkey has inferred that young people are spending the majority of their day on social media and actually communicate online more than they do in real life. Basing this research off a survey, they discovered the motivating factors for this excess of use can be identified as the fundamental needs for socialization and sense of belonging (Social Behavior and Personality 12). From this, we can assume that the accessibility of communication with the outside world through a simple screen has made it all too easy to fulfil these social needs. The survey is exclusively looking at adolescents’ ages 12 to 17 so these findings could not be examined on a general level. This may take away from the relevancy of these findings. The authors make the unstated claim that the innovation of mobile devices has put a toll on old fashion forms of communication. It seems it is impossible to escape from the virtual world because ‘friends’ are always posting something new on some type of social networking site. Communication is forever changed because of this. One would wonder if this excess time spent on social media is beneficial to relationships and relationship growth on these sites. Time investment in offline relationships helps growth and development so it seems logical that time spent online would help users grow closer to their network. To the contrary, a study conducted by the Department of Psychology at Groningen University would prove otherwise. After collecting a sample of 117 participants ages 18 to 63, they concluded that “time spent using social media [is] not associated with larger offline networks, or feeling emotionally closer to offline network members” (CyberPsychology, Behavior & Social Networking 253). The data suggests that the surplus of time spent on social networks is actually not contributing to any type of relationship growth between network ‘friends’. Although, it would be beneficial for them to have more participants in the study, the ages of the participants are varied, which makes the study more reliable in terms of making the results more generalized. The authors makes the claim that those who spend more time making connections offline would most likely have healthier relationships with more individuals. This evidence could be used to prove the idea that a person cannot use social networking as their only form of communication. Dohyun Ahn and Dong-Hee Shin from Sunkyunkwan University asked 300 Korean adult participants to complete an online survey asking about their social media habits. Results show that social media helps users feel more connected but does not help to avoid social isolation. Face to face communication helps people feel more connected and helps them avoid social isolation (Computers in Human Behavior 2453). This claim is unbiased because not only do they do research on social media communication, but they also include other types of communication. The sample of participants is large as well so the spread is reliable. The research demonstrates relying solely on virtual interaction with others is not a viable option for a healthy lifestyle. I can infer that social media provides an outlet for people to feel connected to their family and friends. It helps users to frame themselves into the person they want to be. It can improve users sense of belonging, well-being, connectedness. However, time spent solely on social media does not affect relationship quality with followers or friends nor can it mediate social isolation. Social media cannot replace face to face communication, but it can help users with many socio-psychological needs.

Work Cited:
Social Behavior & Personality: An International Journal 2013, Vol. 41 Issue 3, p517 12p
International Journal of Marketing Studies. Aug2013, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p132-142. 11p. 1 Chart.
CyberPsychology, Behavior & Social Networking. Apr2011, Vol. 14 Issue 4, p253-258. 6p. 1 Chart.
Journal of Technology Research. Jul2013, Vol. 4, p1-13. 13p. 5 Charts
Computers in Human Behavior; Nov2013, Vol. 29 Issue 6, p2453-2462, 10p
Computers in Human Behavior; May2013, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p997-1006, 10p
Soraya Mehdizadeh. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking. August 2010, 13(4): 357-364. doi:10.1089/cyber.2009.0257.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Cultural Crossing Analysis

...CCA Country Project China Power distance Value Power distance is the extent to which the less powerful members of organizations and institutions within a country accept and expect that power is distributed unequally (Hofstede, 2005). In high power distance countries, there is a considerable dependence of subordinates on bosses while in low power distance countries there is limited dependence of subordinated on bosses. In China, there is a high power distance; there are few people in China who are very powerful, and they’re respected by everyone. The PD index of China is 80, and that is overlapping in real life, cause there is a big power distance in China. Rituals Mao Ze Dong said there could never be too many Chinese: human resources would be China's greatest defence in the widely predicted third world war. So the population of China rose from 540 million in 1950 to over 850 million by 1970 (fig 1). http://www.bmj.com/content/314/7095/1685.short This is high PD, because he decides what the whole country has to do, and he doesn’t care about what the other people want. Population projections worried Deng Xiao Ping, who was launching his economic reform programme. He regarded the curbing of population growth as essential for economic expansion and improved living standards, so the one child family policy was introduced in 1979 http://www.bmj.com/content/314/7095/1685.short This is high PD as well, because in this case Demg Xiao Ping decides for...

Words: 347 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cross Cultural Analysis

...Executive Summary Cross Cultural Analysis for Doing Business in Israel Casey Horner March 26, 2014 Introduction This report was commissioned to examine the necessary cross cultural analysis factor and processes due to extending business into Israel, and it suggests concerns and strategies to have successful business in Israel. The following are utilized and expressed in the examination: * Hofstede’s Dimensions of Culture * CAGE Framework in context of distance * Strategy recommendations Hofstede’s Dimensions of Culture These dimensions of culture include power distance, individualism, masculinity, uncertainty avoidance, and long-term orientation. Each dimension offers insight into how the country operates in business. Below is the comparison of each dimension between the United States and Israel: * Power Distance- United States: 40, Israel: 13 * Individualism- United States: 91, Israel: 54 * Masculinity- United States: 62, Israel: 47 * Uncertainty Avoidance- United States: 46, Israel: 81 * Long-Term Orientation- United States: 29, Israel: NA (Clearly Cultural, 2013) Power distance refers to the acceptance of inequality of power or status within an organization or institution. The followers, not the leaders, define this dimension. As seen above, there is more power equality, or less distance between have’s and have not’s, in Israel than in the United States. The power equality in Israel is related to the measurements in the individualism...

Words: 918 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Cultural Competent Analysis

...it is critical to address the needs of community members where the care is being delivered, regardless of their culture. As such, cultural competence encompasses providing care that is consistent with the culture of the patient. The key point is that developing cultural competence is a continuing process, and by no means an endpoint. The word “culture” does not limit itself to ethnicity or race, but addresses disability, income level, profession, gender, age, sexual orientation, or geographic location. The key to cultural competence is to show the utmost respect and response to beliefs and practices related to health, culture and language, and diverse population groups....

Words: 439 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cultural Analysis Comparitive Paper

...ASSINGNMENT 1: CROSS CULTURAL ANALYSIS COLLOBARATIVE PAPER In this paper am discussing about the analysis and differences in culture between the United States and my country India. For this I have chosen Hofstede cultural dimensions 1. Analysis of culture between United States and India using three cultural dimensions: I have picked three Hofstede’s culture dimensions to interpret the culture of United States and India they are a. Power distance b. Individuality c. Tolerance of uncertainty a. Power Distance: Power distance is the degree to which lower level employees and low authoritative people in various business organizations and institutions believe and accept that power is not equal to everyone....

Words: 911 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Cultural Baggage Rhetorical Analysis

...In her essay “Cultural Baggage,” Barbara Ehrenreich attempts to convince readers that having no culture is better than continuing the culture of their ancestors. Ehrenreich is prompted into writing this essay because she was asked about her connections to her heritage. After searching and being unable to find a strong connection, she comes to the conclusion that the culture of none is better and then tries to convince her readers of that. However, “Cultural Baggage” is ineffective because Ehrenreich fails to fulfill her purpose of convincing readers of her claim. She fails to do so because of a lack of logos, ineffective ethos, inconsistencies in her structure, and the alienation of her readers who are proud of their culture. Because of these...

Words: 903 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Cultural Analysis of Brazil and Denmark

...the members of a community and which influence their [...] way of life” (Tayeb, 2003, p.10). Hence, the crux for every international manager is to understand the differences in the ways employees, suppliers and clients think, feel and act in different business settings (Hofstede, 1997, p.4). International managers, being capable of managing this challenge, possess a set of intercultural competencies, allowing them to turn cultural diversity into a competitive advantage (Browaeys and Price, 2008, p.215). This information pack provides substantial information about Danish and Brazilian business practices. The subsequent analysis is based upon the theories of the Dutch anthropologists Geert Hofstede and Fons Trompenaars. In particular, Hofstede’s “Uncertainty Avoidance” and Trompenaars’ “Ascription vs. Achievement” have been applied. 2. Theoretical Background Hofstede and Trompenaar are proponents of the ‘etic’ approach. They hold that culture is linked to people’s values. Furthermore they argue that these values can be transferred into universal cultural characteristics. Underpinned by empirical and experimental evidence, both anthropologists developed their set of bi-polar dimensions. According to Browaeys and Price (2008, p.92) these dimensions serve to differentiate national cultures. Moreover they provide implications on the impact of culture in business and management.   2.1. Geert Hofstede Hofstede’s work is based on research conducted at the multinational computing...

Words: 2971 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Analysis on Hofstede's Cultural Dimension

...According to Sweeney (2002), Geert Hofstede’s work on cultural dimension is considered to be very important to National Cultural attribute to a person’s value. However, in this article, the method of Hofstede's work are heavily criticised as the method used to formulate the notion are unreliable and misinterpreted as the author argues. Although the questionnaires used in Hofstede’s research were filled by 117,000 people, across 66 countries working in IBM, it is not guaranteed that these people effectively represent the national culture. Hofstede argued that values are formed in school and universities. Countering this argument the writer stated that, all schools and universities do not operate in the same standard. Furthermore, organizational culture also sufficiently influences the answers. Hence, questioning people from the same organization, performing similar job, doesn’t adequately support Hofstede’s methodology. The writer has mentioned in assumption two: the national is identifiable in the micro- local that triggers Hofstede’s argue in two ways where national culture is supposed to be carried by all individuals in a nation. Firstly, presupposition may not come with great outcome in all the time based on local sites of analysis. Apart from this, without supposition there are no valid grounds for treating local as representative of the national. Secondly, Hofstede defined occupational and organizational cultures as uniform. He also stated national culture only as average...

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

International Business Cultural Analysis Preliminary Essay

...considered a driving force behind human actions in any country of the world; it plays part in politics, economics, progression, and every aspect of a community. It is transmitted to generations and generations thereafter. I chose Japan because they appear distinctly different in business interactions than the United States, and as an accounting major, I have an interest in how various cultural traits may or may not determine a way a country conducts business in the global community. My research will include analysis of various dimensions of culture to include: communication, religion, ethics, values and attitudes, manners, customs, structures and organizations within Japan’s culture, and education. The analysis should reveal how the elements and dimensions of culture influence businesses conducted with locals of the region; how do the elements and dimensions as well as the local business interaction compare to the United States’ culture and local businesses; and, implications for United States’ businesses who wish to conduct business in Japan. Although the fore mentioned are the basis of the cultural analysis, I hope to unfold how past/ current political constraints limits Japan’s maturity within the global community, for example, the limitations imposed by the signing of Treaty of Mutual Cooperation and Security. Over fifty years ago, Japan and the United States signed the “Treaty of Mutual Cooperation and Security,” to assist in the containment of Communism that was overtaking the...

Words: 909 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Cultural Competence Model Analysis

...assuming that they are being culturally competent, and it involves the integration of cultural desire, cultural awareness, cultural knowledge, cultural skill, and cultural encounters (see Figure 1). The Process of Cultural Competence in the Delivery of Healthcare Services (Campinha-Bacote, 1998a) is a model that views cultural competence as the ongoing process in which the healthcare provider continuously attempts to achieve the capacity to productively work within the cultural context of the client (individual, family, community). This model requires health care providers to see themselves as growing culturally competent rather than already being culturally competent. This process involves the integration of cultural awareness, cultural knowledge, cultural skill,...

Words: 569 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Increasing Cross-Cultural Analysis and Action Skills

...Increasing cross-cultural analysis and action skills Jones International University September 15, 2013 Situation An American Manager asks one of his subordinates who was recently transferred from Russia if it was possible for him to start the next day one hour earlier so they could finish a special account analysis before the team meeting at noon. The Russian employee responded affirmatively but next day he arrived at his usual start time. Cultural analysis United States: According to Hofstede’s dimensions, United States has a low uncertainty avoidance index (46); therefore American society accepts ambiguous situations and handles well risk. There is a great level of acceptance for new ideas, innovative products and an inclination to try new ways. At the same time, Americans are less expressive and don’t mind ideas or opinions from others since are firm believers of the freedom of speech. Russia: Russia scores at 95 in uncertainty avoidance which means they feel threatened by uncertain or confusing situations. Russians prefer detailing planning and briefing for new ventures. They prefer to have perspective and circumstantial information before involving in any business. A high index in uncertainty avoidance also impact on the way instructions and directions in the workplace are handled and noticed. Russians expect explicit instructions and direction for any task and also will give very detailed...

Words: 457 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

A Comparative Analysis Between Aboriginal and Chinese Cultural Differences

...globalisation and internationalisation of trade in resources, especially human capital, has made managerial of culture differences ever so important as to understanding the different variables (Hofstede G, 2010). In this paper, the Power Distance Index (PDI) of both Chinese and aboriginal traditional cultural value and belief in family, social life and workplace is going to be examined under the scope of Hofstede’s dimensions. To a truthful stereotype, both culture heavily emphasis upon power distance in a form of age-grade social hierarchy, the variance in its operation however made these cultures unique. The value and beliefs of Confucianism has embedded upon every aspect of Chinese life, putting emphasis upon power and relationship (Irwin 2012) and creating a sense of family-centred communitarianism (W Li [Western Kentucky University] 2005, CHIN318 Lecture notes, 8 October). Indigenous aboriginals although maintained their traditional culture emphasis of power distance system through Kinship, but with various elements reduced due to western economic development, allowing more freedom of action ( Bruner 1956). Chinese Power Distance Index under the scope of Hofstede’s cultural variable scored 80 comparing to the world average of 56.5 (The Hofstede Centre) indicating that power are centralised amongst the highest members of the social organisation and a common acceptance of unequal distribution of power. In a stance for family relationship such a high level of power inequalities...

Words: 1519 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Cross Cultural Competence Analysis of Germany, Uzbekistan, Albanian

...Fachhochschule Köln Cologne University of Applied Sciences Faculty of Economics and Business Administration Research paper of the discipline “Cross Cultural Competence SS 2012” Made by: Brovchenko Ekaterina Dzyuba Stanislav Shushunina Tatiana 2012 Content Summary 1. Targets, tasks and problems of research During the last ten years aspects of cross-cultural competence provoke theoretical and practical interest due to international relations development. Cross-cultural competence is not restricted by discussion of different questions and problems on the international level; it becomes a part of everyday people life including education sphere. Our team has received results of survey that is carried out among students of Germany, Uzbekistan and Albania. This survey about how culture affects the requirements for teaching offers. Respondents were offered to answer 26 questions according to education aspects and personal questions. In addition we had list of statistical data that should be collected about every country. For us it was necessary to compare found date and obtained results of existing survey and then to find correlation between it. We have considered three given countries: Germany, Uzbekistan and Albania. Germany, officially the Federal Republic...

Words: 6848 - Pages: 28

Free Essay

Cultural Analysis

...Cultural Analysis History of France While the typical example of a nation-state, France carries a varied and culturally rich historical identity spawning from its centuries of growth. France’s birth as a nation, though difficult to date, seems to center around the conversion to Christianity by King Clovis in 496 A.D. following through to the later part of the century with the coronation of Hugh Carpet in 987. The Carpetian dynasty, which reigned for almost 900 years, came to an end in 1789 with the declaration of France as a nation by the people and the French revolution. In 843 A.D., the Treaty of Verdun roughly divided most of what is now Western Europe into the three territories of France, Germany, and Italy which was given to the 3 grandsons of Charlemagne. The three territories were ruled primarily in peace, France by Phillip Valois, until 1338 and the beginning of the Hundred Years’ War. Through the war, France won provinces that had been held by the Plantagenet king of England. Protestantism spread rapidly throughout the 16th century coinciding with civil wars throughout the nation due to religious differences. The king, Henry IV issued the Edict of Nantes granting religious freedom to the French Protestants, Huguenots, bringing an end to the religiously prompted civil wars. The centuries that followed, marked with territorial squabbles, diverse styles of ruling, and growth throughout the country, paled in comparison to the reign of Louis XIV. Monarchy had...

Words: 1322 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Cultural Analysis

...ENGL 103.G35 Cultural Analysis Cover Girl has always been a popular make-up company, and since they sell make-up, their main target is undoubtedly woman. In the new Cover Girl Nature Luxe commercial, they target women, especially in their teens, in multiple ways. They use a celebrity that is popular for that age group; she is wearing glamorous, sparkly dresses, she’s dancing nonstop and having fun, and they try to make the audience “join the movement.” Figure 1 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMt6TFO0zn4 Figure 1 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMt6TFO0zn4 The advertisement starts out right away with the popular music artist Taylor Swift as the only person in the entire commercial. The company makes a big emphasis on this and even puts her name in the commercial underneath the company name, seen in Figure 1, as if to highlight the fact that she’s in the commercial and wearing their product, even though it’s very clear who it is to the majority of the population. Cover Girl chose Taylor Swift to be the star of their commercial for a few reasons. They are targeting teenage girls, and Taylor is in that age range herself. She’s also extremely successful in her career and is an attractive young woman that a lot of girls wish they could look like or just be. By using Taylor Swift when she has all these qualities, it sends out a message to the watchers that if you use their product, you’ll be able to be like Taylor Swift. Figure 2 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMt6TFO0zn4 ...

Words: 1225 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Cultural Analysis

...English 1020-L22 November 3, 2013 Cultural Analysis-“From Silence to Words: Writing as Struggle” “From Silence to Words: Writing as Struggle” is an essay written by Min-Zhan Lu, in which she describes the effects, both positive and negative, she experienced while trying to obtain somewhat of a balance, between the learning techniques and language forced on to her and her sisters by their parents, and the education and language taught and enforced by their country, China. Lu describes the emotional strain, confusion, and the political persecution she experienced, beginning at the young, tender age of four years old, the year after the Communist Revolution of 1949. For many years, the only memories Lu had were of the many hardships she faced during the years of getting her education, which made it difficult to recall the benefits of her education. While writing this essay, Lu was forced to reflect over these particular years of her life and the effects it had on her, both good and bad. She finally realized that as hard as it was to endure these hardships, personal benefits resulted from these difficult times as well. Lu explains her revelation by stating, “My understanding of my education was so dominated by memories of confusion and frustration that I was unable to reflect on what I could have gained from it” (148). One of the benefits Lu gained was growth, in both her reading and writing skills, by persevering through the confusion and frustration during that time. ...

Words: 1370 - Pages: 6