Free Essay

Emh and Behavioral Finance

In:

Submitted By liding6688
Words 874
Pages 4
Efficient Market Discussion and Understanding of Finance

As the 2013 Nobel Laureates in economic science, both of Eugene Fama, from the University of Chicago and Robert Shiller, from Yale University, have made famous contribution to the finance world. Even though their views toward market efficiency seem mutually contradictory, their theories has been highly valued by the finance academia as well as industry. This paper compares and contrasts the work of both of them and discusses how their work influence my understanding of finance.
Fama is known for his work in initiating and developing the “efficient market hypothesis (EMH).” In his paper, Fama defines “efficient market” as “a market in which prices always fully reflect available information” (Fama 1970). If prices did reflect all available information, trading rules and fundamental analysis would not help investors to constantly earn abnormal return. This proposition has been checked by others and himself in the following papers: "Random Walks in Stock Market Prices (Fama 1965)," and "Filter Rules and Stock Market Trading Profits" (Blume, Fama 1966). Stock prices react to new information so quickly that it is almost impossible to trade on that piece of new information and profit from it. Furthermore, investors cannot earn abnormal returns without taking more systematic risk. To address the different types of information that stock prices could reflect, Fama prosed three types of market efficiency: (1) strong-form, where prices reflect all private and public information; (2) semi-strong form, where prices reflect all public information; and (3) weak-form, where prices only reflect past public information (Fama 1970). Index funds, which did not even exist fouty years ago, are now very popular among investors. Its creation was a result of Fama’s notion that actively managed fund cannot beat the market. Fama’s theory has also brought great influence to the accounting and economics academia.
The efficient markets theory dominated the finance academia in the 1970s. Starting the 1980s, the question that weather stock market is as efficient as Fama described has been asked by more and more scholars. Robert Shiller is one of leading scholars of the “behavioral finance” academia. In Shiller’s view, the stock market is inefficient in terms of reflecting all information due to human behavior. In his paper, Shiller showed “excess volatility relative to what would be predicted by the efficient markets model” (Shiller 2003). As the efficient market model cannot explain the level of volatility of the stock market, Shiller claimed that the efficient markets model was not supported by the stock market fluctuations (Shiller 2003). Instead, Shiller shows that psychology can lead to market inefficiency as people are not as rational as expected by the EMH. Shiller uses “feedback models” to explain part of the excess volatility of the stock market. In his paper, he describes the model as “when speculative prices go up, creating successes for some investors, this may attract public attention, promote word-of –mouth enthusiasm, and heighten expectations for further price increases” (Shiller 2003). Shiller also claimed that if EMH is right market crashes, such as crashes of 1987, 2002, and 2008, should not have happened this often. His introduction of psychology to finance has attracted more scholars’ attention.
Even though Fama and Shiller’s theory seems contradictory, they both found that stock prices were predictable in the long run but not in the short run. More importantly, they both devoted themselves in investigating the same issue – what happens in the stock market and why it happens. Their theories have been valuable tools for people to understand the mechanism in the stock market.
Having read papers of both Fama and Shiller, the idea of “efficient market” still appears fascinating to me, acknowledging that the theory is a “half-truth.” Finance is a study of asset pricing and resource allocation. Whether the stock market is efficient affects if stocks are correctly priced and capital is allocated to the right companies or sectors. In my mind, the current stock market is semi-efficient that it did reflect information fairly quickly and it is difficult to act on the available information and profit from it. On the other hand, as all the investment decisions are made by people, it is reasonable that human beings sometime make “irrational” decisions based on the information they have, or at least “irrational” from the economic point of view. On the other hand, I agree that stock market is crucial in helping us understand the price of assets with different risks. I also agree that the overall stock market is somewhat efficient; otherwise, it will be ironic that index funds have been one of the most popular investment alternatives since its creation in the 1970s. Therefore, both of Fama and Shiller’s theory are important and useful for us to understand what happens in the stock market and why.

References
Fama, E. (1965). Random Walks in Stock Market Prices. Financial Analysts Journal, 75-80.
Fama, E., & Blume, M. (1966). Filter Rules and Stock Market Trading Profits. Journal of Business, 39(1), 226-241.
Fama, E. (1970). Efficient Capital Markets: A Review of Theory and Empirical Work. The Journal of Finance, 25(2), 383-383.
Shiller, R. (2003). From Efficient Markets Theory To Behavioral Finance. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 17(1), 83-104.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Compare the Efficient Markets Hypothesis with Other Theories of Pricing in Financial Markets

...pricing in financial markets Efficient market hypothesis (EMH) is a theory that emerged in the 1960s. It states that it is difficult to predict the market since the price has been set and reflect the current market conditions. It is a disputed and controversial theory. The theory is comparable to other theories of pricing in financial markets. Several strengths and shortcomings emerge through comparison with other theories of pricing (Blinder, et al., 2012). EMH states that no stock is a better buy when compared to others. It is the conclusion that leads to random choices. It is a vital tenet of finance theory. The EMH theory has a basis in other finance theories. It follows the classical theory of asset prices. To determine the connection, a situation where stocks are considered based on good deals. According to the EMH theory, these stocks are worth more than their relative prices. The worth of a stock is the present value of the expected dividends. In this regard, an individual will buy stocks at prices that are below this level. In essence, this is buying stocks that are undervalued assets (Kapil, 2011). Classical theory The classical theory follows the belief that the price of a stock is equal to the best estimate of the stock’s value. This equality means that the undervalued stocks are not real. It is futile to determine or find them. A stock price always equals the present value of expected dividends. Under the EMH, every instance that you sell or buy securities, you are...

Words: 2300 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Pyramid Scheme

...Financial Market Definition of 'Financial Market' Broad term describing any marketplace where buyers and sellers participate in the trade of assets such as equities, bonds, currencies and derivatives. Financial markets are typically defined by having transparent pricing, basic regulations on trading, costs and fees and market forces determining the prices of securities that trade. Some financial markets only allow participants that meet certain criteria, which can be based on factors like the amount of money held, the investor's geographical location, knowledge of the markets or the profession of the participant. Investopedia explains 'Financial Market' Financial markets can be found in nearly every nation in the world. Some are very small, with only a few participants, while others – like the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) and the forex markets – trade trillions of dollars daily.  Most financial markets have periods of heavy trading and demand for securities; in these periods, prices may rise above historical norms. The converse is also true – downturns may cause prices to fall past levels of intrinsic value, based on low levels of demand or other macroeconomic forces like tax rates, national production or employment levels. Information transparency is important to increase the confidence of participants and therefore foster an efficient financial marketplace. Financial Markets: Capital Vs. Money Markets ...

Words: 5427 - Pages: 22

Free Essay

Investor Irrationality and Self Defeating Behavior

...Investor Irrationality and Self-Defeating Behavior FIN645 Introduction For many years, finance traditionalists have held on to the theory that markets are efficient and that prices correctly reflect the information available to the market as a whole. This has come to be known as the efficient market hypothesis which was originally postulated by Eugene Fama in 1965. After a thorough statistical study of the movements of investment prices Fama concluded that “such movements were essentially random and unpredictable” (Shefrin p.75). Fama pointed out that “in an efficient market, prices correspond to intrinsic (or fundamental) value” (Shefrin p.75). In short, what the theory concludes is that it is impossible to beat the market; that no investor can ever purchase undervalued stocks or sell stocks at inflated prices. The market will always correct itself by incorporating all relevant information into the price of a security thus eliminating an individual investor’s ability to outperform. EMH has grown to become a cornerstone of financial theory and is still applied by many traditionalists when attempting to explain the behavior of financial markets. While there is much evidence in support of this theory there is an equal amount dissention. There are many who argue that there is ample evidence available that counters the central ideas of EMH and demonstrate its shortcomings such as: individuals who have shown that they can consistently beat the market...

Words: 2510 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Financial Crisis

...and Europe. The crisis has also shaken the foundations of modern-day financial theory, which rested on the proposition that our financial markets were basically efficient. Critics have even suggested that the efficient--market–hypotheses (EMH) was in large part, responsible for the crises. This paper argues that the critics of EMH are using a far too restrictive interpretation of what EMH means. EMH does not imply that asset prices are always “correct.” Prices are always wrong, but no one knows for sure if they are too high or too low. EMH does not imply that bubbles in asset prices are impossible nor does it deny that environmental and behavioral factors cannot have profound influences on required rates of return and risk premiums. At its core, EMH implies that arbitrage opportunities for riskless gains do not exist in an *Princeton University. I am indebted to Alan Blinder and to the participants in the Russell Sage Conference on Economic Lessons From the Financial Crisis for extremely helpful comments. 2 efficiently functioning market and if they do appear from time to time that they do not persist. The evidence is clear that this version of EMH is strongly supported by the data. EMH can comfortably coexist with behavior finance, and the insights of Hyman Minsky are particularly relevant in eliminating the recent financial crisis. Bubbles, when they do exist are particularly dangerous when they are financed with debt. And the housing bubble and its associated derivative...

Words: 11209 - Pages: 45

Premium Essay

Modern Potofolio

...Efficient portfolio & Stock market efficiency Prepared by: Ahmed Mohamed Ahmed Zaki Nofal Submitted to: Dr.Tarek el Domiaty Modern portfolio theory Modern portfolio theory (MPT) is a theory of finance which attempts to maximize portfolio expected return for a given amount of portfolio risk, or equivalently minimize risk for a given level of expected return, by carefully choosing the proportions of various assets. Although MPT is widely used in practice in the financial industry and several of its creators won a Nobel memorial prize[1] for the theory, in recent years the basic assumptions of MPT have been widely challenged by fields such as behavioral economics. MPT is a mathematical formulation of the concept of diversification in investing, with the aim of selecting a collection of investment assets that has collectively lower risk than any individual asset. That this is possible can be seen intuitively because different types of assets often change in value in opposite ways. For example, to the extent prices in the stock market move differently from prices in the bond market, a collection of both types of assets can in theory face lower overall risk than either individually. But diversification lowers risk even if assets' returns are not negatively correlated—indeed, even if they are positively correlated More technically, MPT models an asset's return as a normally distributed function (or more generally as an elliptically distributed random...

Words: 6257 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Market Efficiency

... 2016 Efficient capital markets Market Efficiency An efficient capital market is: “A market where information regarding the value of securities are incorporated into its prices accurately and in real time. Since the value of securities fluctuates depending on the present value of future cash flows, an efficient capital market enables these fluctuations to be reflected in the securities' current price” (Investorwords.com, n.d.). What this means is that investors who invest among the stock market try and determine if the market is efficient, and whether it accurately emulates all of the influential prominent forces that are put on prices, and affected by such forces in real time. The efficient market hypothesis (EMH) is a theory among investors that states that it is impossible to out-smart the market because the efficient market always mirrors current events and information making it impossible to veer buy stock underpriced or overpriced – prices will always reflect the fair market value based on market influences. The only way to succeed in the market is to gamble with high-risk returns (Investopedia. n.d.). How this all works is investors will buy up stock and generate cash flow into the stock market, looking for a return on one’s investment. They are not always satisfied with a return; they want to maximize the return more than their competing investors – they want to beat the market somehow. But, based on the efficient market capital theory...

Words: 1085 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Behavioral Finance

...Libre des Sciences Commerciales Appliquées Review of Literature Behavioral Finance Presented to Dr. Mohamed EL-Hennawy Group Assignment Prepared By Albert Naguib Noha Samir Wael Shams EL-Din Moshira Gamil Marie Zarif January 2012 | TABLE OF CONTENTS | | | |List of Table………………………………………………………………………….. | |List of Figure ………………………………………………………………………… | |List of Abbreviations/Acronyms ……………………………………………………. | |Introduction……………………………………………………………………….. | |2. Appearance of Behavioral Finance…………………………………………………… | |2.1. Important Contributors…………………………………………………. ………. | |3. Behavioral Biases…………………………………………………………………… ...

Words: 14092 - Pages: 57

Premium Essay

Business

...EFB335 Tutorial Two Solutions 1. There are several reasons why one would expect capital markets to be efficient, the foremost being that there are a large number of independent, profit-maximizing investors engaged in the analysis and valuation of securities. A second assumption is that new information comes to the market in a random fashion. The third assumption is that the numerous profit-maximizing investors will adjust security prices rapidly to reflect this new information. Thus, price changes would be independent and random. Finally, because stock prices reflect all information, one would expect prevailing prices to reflect “true” current value. Capital markets as a whole are generally expected to be efficient, but the markets for some securities might not be as efficient as others. Recall that markets are expected to be efficient because there are a large number of investors who receive new information and analyze its effect on security values. If there is a difference in the number of analysts following a stock and the volume of trading, one could conceive of differences in the efficiency of the markets. For example, new information regarding actively traded stocks such as IBM and Exxon is well publicized and numerous analysts evaluate the effect. Therefore, one should expect the prices for these stocks to adjust rapidly and fully reflect the new information. On the other hand, new information regarding a stock with a small number of stockholders and low trading...

Words: 2185 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Fixed Income Investment

...FINC3017 Investments and Portfolio Management Essay: Market Efficiency and Anomalies Topic:Stock price momentum: Jegadeesh and Titman (1993) Momentum anomaly and EMH Anomaly is a stock return deviation that challenge efficient market hypothesis (EMH). Jegadeesh and Titman (1993) theorise price momentum anomaly in the stock market for the first time. It contradicted to efficient market hypothesis thereby is widely debated. EMH states that no consistent excess return can be achieved since security prices fully reflect all available information (Fama 1970). Therefore, future prices cannot be predicted through technical analysis of past prices. If the hypothesis is true, passive investment strategy ought to be taken, because it is impossible to get abnormal return by aggressive trading. However, Jegadeesh and Titman show that stocks performed well over the previous 3 to 12 months tend to continue to perform well over 3 to 12 months holding periods. Buy past winners and short past losers earned statistically significant positive return of averaging 12.01% per year. Predictable price patterns and excess returns contradict the efficient market hypothesis. Investors and fund managers perform actively in pursuing abnormal profits. Literature review and the reason of anomaly A large number of literatures illustrate that momentum anomaly exist. Some important literatures are Chan, Jegadeesh and Lakonishok (1996), Conrad and Kaul (1998) and Moskowitz and Grinblatt (1999). Lee and Swaminathan...

Words: 1632 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

“When the Price of a Stock Can Be Influenced by a “Herd” on Wall Street with Prices Set at the Margin by the Most Emotional Person, or the Greediest Person, or the Most Depressed Person, It Is Hard to Argue That the

...the hypothesis. It also examines the theoretical role and motivation of analysts in creating market efficiency; lastly it looks at alternative perspectives on the pricing of securities. Introduction In 1984 Warren Buffett penned an article titled “The Superinvestors of Graham-and-Doddsville”, based on a speech he had given on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of his mentor Ben Graham’s legendary textbook, Security Analysis. In it, Buffett rejected the then growing (and now entrenched) view in academia that markets are ''efficient'' because ''stock prices reflect everything that is known about a company’s prospects and about the state of the economy.'' Warren Buffett argued against EMH, saying the preponderance of value investors among the world's best money managers rebuts the claim of EMH proponents that luck is the reason some investors appear more successful than others. (Hoffman, 2010) This report will either agree with Buffet or somewhat sit on the fence. A market is said to be efficient with respect to an information set if the price ‘fully reflects’ that information set (Fama, 1970), i.e. if the price would be unaffected by revealing the information set...

Words: 2524 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Market Efficiency and Anomalies

...FINC3017 Investments and Portfolio Management Essay: Market Efficiency and Anomalies Topic:Stock price momentum: Jegadeesh and Titman (1993) Momentum anomaly and EMH Anomaly is a stock return deviation that challenge efficient market hypothesis (EMH). Jegadeesh and Titman (1993) theorise price momentum anomaly in the stock market for the first time. It contradicted to efficient market hypothesis thereby is widely debated. EMH states that no consistent excess return can be achieved since security prices fully reflect all available information (Fama 1970). Therefore, future prices cannot be predicted through technical analysis of past prices. If the hypothesis is true, passive investment strategy ought to be taken, because it is impossible to get abnormal return by aggressive trading. However, Jegadeesh and Titman show that stocks performed well over the previous 3 to 12 months tend to continue to perform well over 3 to 12 months holding periods. Buy past winners and short past losers earned statistically significant positive return of averaging 12.01% per year. Predictable price patterns and excess returns contradict the efficient market hypothesis. Investors and fund managers perform actively in pursuing abnormal profits. Literature review and the reason of anomaly A large number of literatures illustrate that momentum anomaly exist. Some important literatures are Chan, Jegadeesh and Lakonishok (1996), Conrad and Kaul (1998) and Moskowitz and Grinblatt (1999)....

Words: 1631 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Business Finance

...Lo To appear in L. Blume and S. Durlauf, The New Palgrave: A Dictionary of Economics, Second Edition, 2007. New York: Palgrave McMillan. The efficient markets hypothesis (EMH) maintains that market prices fully reflect all available information. Developed independently by Paul A. Samuelson and Eugene F. Fama in the 1960s, this idea has been applied extensively to theoretical models and empirical studies of financial securities prices, generating considerable controversy as well as fundamental insights into the price-discovery process. The most enduring critique comes from psychologists and behavioural economists who argue that the EMH is based on counterfactual assumptions regarding human behaviour, that is, rationality. Recent advances in evolutionary psychology and the cognitive neurosciences may be able to reconcile the EMH with behavioural anomalies. There is an old joke, widely told among economists, about an economist strolling down the street with a companion. They come upon a $100 bill lying on the ground, and as the companion reaches down to pick it up, the economist says, ‘Don’t bother – if it were a genuine $100 bill, someone would have already picked it up’. This humorous example of economic logic gone awry is a fairly accurate rendition of the efficient markets hypothesis (EMH), one of the most hotly contested propositions in all the social sciences. It is disarmingly simple to state, has far-reaching consequences for academic theories and business practice...

Words: 11295 - Pages: 46

Premium Essay

Behavioural Finance

...1.- Problem statement and motivation How do Financial Markets participants make decisions? How do these decisions affect the financial markets? With the financial markets in Asia being the largest in the world, such an interesting environment with participants displaying different levels of capitalism, financial market experience and knowledge, Asia is definitely a fertile ground for the study od behavioral finance. According to conventional financial theory, the world and its participants are, for the most part, rational "wealth maximizers". However, there are many instances where emotion and psychology influence our decisions, causing us to behave in unpredictable or irrational ways. Asians in general suffer from cognitive biases, more so than Westerners, often being viewed as ‘Gamblers. Behavioral finance is a relatively new field that seeks to combine behavioral and cognitive psychological theory with conventional economics and finance to provide explanations for why people make irrational financial decisions .It calls for investigation into higher mental processes, memory, perception, problem solving and thinking .This paper looks at some of the anomalies (i.e., irregularities) that conventional financial theories have failed to explain. In addition, review underlying reasons and biases that cause some people to behave irrationally. 2.- Brief survey of the literature The following areas of research have been covered, from the mid 1980’s to the main focus of the article(special...

Words: 899 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Efficient Markets Hypothesis

...the Efficient Markets Hypothesis (EMH) states that market prices fully reflect all publicly available information (Fama 1970). The EMH has been highly influential among academics, but practitioners and regulators appear unconvinced. Investors work hard to identify mispriced stocks on the basis of public data, or pay others to do so, even though the EMH asserts that such efforts are wasted. Managers seek to boost stock prices by hiding bad news in footnotes, and regulators work hard to defeat such efforts, even though the EMH asserts that information is reflected in prices no matter how obscure its presentation. Beliefs about inefficiency play a central role in the debate over recognizing expenses for incentive stock options. Opponents of expensing argue that the resulting lower net income will inappropriately reduce market prices, while proponents argue the market does not fully recognize compensation costs reported only in footnotes. In efficient markets, however, expensing these costs has no direct effect on prices, as long as the details of the compensation are included in footnotes. The decision to expense option costs could reduce stock price indirectly, even in efficient markets, by affecting the terms of contracts between the reporting firm and other parties (Watts and Zimmerman 1986). However, few of the parties to the debate appear concerned about these effects. The academic community is showing increasing dissatisfaction with the EMH, swayed partly by evidence that prices...

Words: 6063 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Finance Description

...FINANCE 305 : ESSENTIALS OF INVESTMENTS CHAPTER 1: Investments: Background and Issues. REAL ASSETS – assets used to produce goods and services. FINANCIAL ASSETS – claims on real assets or income generated by them. FIXED INCOME (DEBD) SECURITIES – are securities that pay a specified cash flow over and specific period. EQUITY – an ownership share in a corporation. DERIVATIVE SECURITIES – securities providing pay offs that depend on the value of other assets. AGENCY PROBLEMS – conflicts of interest between management and stockholders. ASSET ALLOCATION – allocation of an investment across broad asset classes. SECURITY SELECTION – choice of specific securities within each asset class. SECURITY ANALYSES – analyses of the value of securities. RISK-RETURN TRADE-OFF – assets with higher expected returns entail greater risk. PASSIVE MANAGEMENT – buying and holding a diversified portfolio without attempt to identify mispriced securities. ACTIVE MANAGEMENT – attempting to identify misplaces securities or to forecast broad future trends. FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES – institutions that connect borrowers and lenders by accepting funds from lenders and loaning funds to borrowers. INVESTMENT COMPANIES – company that manages funds for investors. An investment company can manage several mutual funds. INVESTMENT BANKERS – firms specializing in the sale of new securities to the public, typically by underwriting the issue. PRIMARY MARKET – a market in which new securities are offered...

Words: 3207 - Pages: 13