Premium Essay

Evaluation of Leadership Theories

In:

Submitted By yuezhang
Words 2023
Pages 9
Introduction

The view is widely shared that the world continues to change and the magnitude, speed, influence, as well as the unpredictability of change, are greater than ever before in today’s society (Burnes, 2009; Cameron and Green, 2015). To keep up with the rapidly changing world and enable the organizations to survive in the competitive market, undertaking the change and managing the change across the organizations has become a crucial topic (Kumavat, 2012).

Organizational leaders play an important role in managing the change, and they are encouraged to lead rather than manage (Cameron and Green, 2015). Although there are many definitions of leadership, it is possible to describe leadership as ‘a process whereby an individual influences a group of individuals to achieve a common goal’ (Northouse, 2013). It is leaders’ responsibility to identify the need for change, to plan carefully, and to lead others to implement the change in organizations.

Numerous approaches and models have already been developed, attempting to help manage change effectively. The aim of this essay is to assess the three approaches of leading change in organizations: the planned approach, Organization Development and the emergent approach. It begins with an understanding and evaluation of these three approaches. By comparing these approaches, there will be potential to get some implications for implementing the change in organizations.

Evaluation of the Three Approaches

The Planned Approach

Planned change was first put forward by Kurt Lewin to differentiate changes that were consciously embarked on by an organization from those unintended changes, for instance changes that might take place by chance, by impulse, by mistake or might be forced in an organization (Marrow, 1969). Since planned change first introduced by Kurt Lewin, lots of models have been developed. Among

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Management

...The candidate provides a reasonable description, with limited detail, of the organization and its objective(s). The candidate provides a reasonable description, with adequate detail, of the organization and its objective(s). The candidate provides a reasonable description, with substantial detail, of the organization and its objective(s). A2. Leadership Practices The candidate does not provide a reasonable description of 3 leadership practices of the primary leader of the organization. The candidate provides a reasonable description of 1–2 leadership practices of the primary leader of the organization. The candidate provides a reasonable description, with limited detail, of 3 leadership practices of the primary leader of the organization. The candidate provides a reasonable description, with adequate detail, of 3 leadership practices of the primary leader of the organization. The candidate provides a reasonable description, with substantial detail, of 3 leadership practices of the primary leader of the organization. A3. Effects of Current Leadership The candidate does not provide a logical discussion of how the current leadership has affected organizational culture. The...

Words: 1173 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Rubric

...and its objective(s). | The candidate provides a reasonable description, with limited detail, of the organization and its objective(s). | The candidate provides a reasonable description, with adequate detail, of the organization and its objective(s). | The candidate provides a reasonable description, with substantial detail, of the organization and its objective(s). |   | A2. Leadership Practices | The candidate does not provide a reasonable description of 3 leadership practices of the primary leader of the organization. | The candidate provides a reasonable description of 1–2 leadership practices of the primary leader of the organization. | The candidate provides a reasonable description, with limited detail, of 3 leadership practices of the primary leader of the organization. | The candidate provides a reasonable description, with adequate detail, of 3 leadership practices of the primary leader of the organization. | The candidate provides a reasonable description, with substantial detail, of 3 leadership practices of the primary leader of the organization. |   | A3. Effects of Current Leadership | The candidate...

Words: 1175 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

None

...the Organization A2. Leadership Practices The candidate provides a reasonable description, with substantial detail, of 3 leadership practices of the current primary leader of the existing organization. A3. Effects of Current Leadership The candidate provides a logical discussion, with substantial support, of how the current leadership has affected organizational culture. B1. Strengths The candidate provides a logical evaluation, with substantial support, of 2 of the organization’s strengths. B2. Weaknesses The candidate provides a logical evaluation, with substantial support, of 2 of the organization’s weaknesses. B3. Opportunities The candidate provides a logical evaluation, with substantial support, of 2 of the organization’s opportunities. B4. Threats The candidate provides a logical evaluation, with substantial support, of 2 of the organization’s threats. C1. Strengths of the Primary Leader The candidate provides a logical evaluation, with substantial support, of 3 strengths of the current primary leader’s leadership practices, using a scholarly leadership theory. C2. Weaknesses of the Primary Leader The candidate provides a logical evaluation, with substantial support, of 3 weaknesses of the current primary leader’s leadership practices, using the same scholarly leadership theory used in part C1. C3. Recommendation for the Primary Leader The candidate provides an appropriate recommendation, with substantial detail, of 3 theory-based practices to maximize...

Words: 273 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Social Responsibility of Business

...DEVELOPMENTAL LEADERSHIP PROGRAM Research Paper 11 An analysis of Leadership Development Programmes working in the context of development Heather Lyne de Ver & Fraser Kennedy February 2011 www.dlprog.org DLP Policy and Practice for Developmental Leaders, Elites and Coalitions DEVELOPMENTAL LEADERSHIP PROGRAM The Developmental Leadership Program (DLP) is an international policy initiative informed by targeted research and directed by an independent steering committee. DLP is supported by a global network of partners and currently receives its core funding from the Australian aid program. The views expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent those of the Australian Government or any of DLP’s other partner organisations. i Contents Page Acronyms ii Abstract iii Executive Summary iv Introduction 01 1.0 An Overview of the Programmes Reviewed 03 2.0 An Overview of the Criteria for Selecting Leadership Development Programmes 05 2.1 Does the programme articulate its understanding of leadership? 05 2.2 Does the programme have a theory of change? 11 2.3 Who is the programme aimed at? 13 2.4 What are the programme’s methods and content? 21 2.5 Impact assessment and evaluations 32 3.0 Our Opinion 38 3.1. The Developmental Leadership Program’s View of Leadership ...

Words: 29765 - Pages: 120

Premium Essay

Leadership and Management

...| Leadership and Management | | Executive Summary The assignment has shown the leadership mechanism in relation to management. Who a leader is, what he possesses within the organization, what he should do in decision making, motivating employees are the main theme of the assignment. The managers or leaders motivate the employees using which theories are also shown. Managers use performance management techniques to contribute higher performance of the employees and team. Here, the development and models of team have also been showed with the benefits of it within the organization. However, by going through the article, anyone can get an exact idea on leadership management. Table of Contents Executive Summary 2 Introduction 4 Task 1 4 1.1an analysis of the concepts of leadership and management 4 1.2 An evaluation of the key management and leadership theories 5 1.3 An assessment of the challenges of leadership and management practice 7 Task 2 8 2.1 An analysis of the key motivational theories and how they influence organizational success: 8 2.2 An evaluation of the role of leadership and management in employee motivation: 11 (Task 3) 11 2.3 An analysis of the contribution of performance management techniques as organizational processes: 11 Task 4: 12 3.1 An analysis of the development of teams: 12 3.2an analysis of the roles and models of team leadership: 13 3.3 An evaluation of the role and usefulness of teams within the organization:...

Words: 3519 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Organisations and Behaviour

...Organizations and Behavior | A Theoretical Perspective | Muhammad Ariful Islam 01-Aug-12 | Contents Introduction 3 1. Understanding of Different Approaches to Management and Leadership 3 1.1 Comparison of Effectiveness of different leadership styles in different organizations 3 1.1.1 Autocratic Leadership Style 3 1.1.2 Democratic or Participative Leadership Style 4 1.1.3 Free Rein Leadership Style 4 Table: 1 5 1. 2 The Best Suited Leadership Style in this Scenario 5 1. 3. How Organisational Theory Supports the Practice of Management 5 1.3.1 Classical Theory 5 1.3.2 Neoclassical Theory 6 1.3.3 Contemporary Theory 6 1.4. An Evaluation of Different Approaches to Management Used by Different Organizations 6 1.5. Organisations that Adopt Different Approaches of Management 8 2. Understanding of the Ways of Using Motivational Theories in Organisations 8 2.1 The Impact of Different Leadership Style on Motivation in the Periods of Organizational Change 8 2.2 An Effective Leadership Style Can Help to Achieve Organisational Objectives 8 2.3 Comparison of the Application of Different Motivational Theories within the Workplace 9 2.4 ‘Motivation can Increase Employee’s Performance’- A Justification with Argument 9 2.5 The Usefulness of a Motivation Theory for Managers 9 3. Understanding of the Mechanisms for Developing Effective Teamwork in Organisations 10 3.1 The Nature of Groups and Group Behaviour Within Organisations 10 3.2 An Analysis...

Words: 3727 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Organizational

...Organizational Behavior Faculty Name: Smita Kulkarni Room No: 114 Wing No: D Consultation Hours: between 10.55- 12.10 on Fridays Email: smita@ibsindia.org Course Objective: Semester: I The management of complex organizations requires an understanding of the nature of human behavior in corporate and other organizations, styles of motivations, personality and perceptions, company leadership, power and authority, strategies of organizational design and change, teamwork, conflict and collaboration, and culture. Organizational Behavior explores individual and group behavior within work organizations and helps students understand, describe, and explain human behavior at work Learning Outcomes: After completing the course the student will be able to:     Apply and analyze different concepts related to organizational behavior Define the purpose and nature of the field of organizational behavior Understand how to Manage individuals for high performance by developing your understanding of individual and interpersonal behavior Understand how to manage groups for high performance through an exposure to theories, concepts, and principles of OB Recommended Text Book: Organizational Behavior, Stephen P Robbins,Timothy Judge and Neharika Vohra 15e, Pearson. Suggested books: 1. Fred Luthans, “Organizational Behavior, 8e, TMH, India. 2. John W Newstrom, “Organizational Behavior – Human behavior at work”, 12e, TMH, India. Course outline Sl No. 1 Session No. 1-2 Topic / Area...

Words: 1327 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Leadership

...Report on THE IMPACT OF LEADERSHIP STYLE ON MOTIVATION IN WORK ORGANIZATIONS Submitted to: Lorin Walker, Manager and Gary Hart, Instructor for OB 689R Submitted by: Leonard Winegar April 20, 1977 i ABSTRACT This report is an evaluation of leadership style as it affects motivation and productivity in work organizations. The terms pertinent to this work are first defined. Historical and current theories are then presented and discussed. Theory understanding and implementation are essential to increase motivation in the organization. Data from leadership style studies is presented showing that situational determinants, traits, and wide style range are essential to promote motivation and effective leadership. There is no single "narrow" leadership style for all occasions rather the whole leader is needed for optimum productivity. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT...................................................................................................................................i TABLE OF CONTENTS................................................................................................................ii I. INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................................1 II. LEADERS DEFINED...............................................................................................................2 Leadership and Leadership Style Illuminated...........................................

Words: 4267 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Case Study

...if needed) --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Course Description:  The management of complex organizations requires an understanding of the nature of human behavior in corporate and other organizations, styles of motivations, personality and perceptions, company leadership, power and authority, strategies of organizational design and change, teamwork, conflict and collaboration, and culture. Organizational Behavior explores individual and group behavior within work organizations and helps students understand, describe, and explain human behavior at work. Course Objective:  The course shall be completed in 33 sessions and after completing the course the student will be able to: * Apply and analyze different concepts related to organizational behavior * Define the purpose and nature of the field of organizational behavior * Understand and learn how to Manage individuals for high performance by developing your understanding of individual and interpersonal behavior * Understand and learn how to manage groups for high performance through an exposure to theories, concepts, and principles of OB Prescribed Textbook:  Organizational Behavior, Stephen P Robbins,Timothy Judge and Neharika Vohra 14e, Pearson.      S.No. | Topic | Case | No. of Session | Concepts covered | 1 | Management Thought and OB: Definition of Management, Approaches to Management: Classical, Behavioral, Management...

Words: 1214 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Disneyland

...------------------------------------------------- | | | | Criteria | < 40% | 40 - 49% | 50 - 59% | 60 - 69% | > 70% | Evaluation and analysis(30%) | Little or no evaluation or analysis. Very descriptive. | Some identification of the different issues but limited evaluation or analysis. Discussion mainly descriptive. | Reasonable identification of the different issues. Descriptive in style but with some evaluation & analysis. Discusses the theories/models and concepts. | Identification of a range of issues with a good level evaluation & analysis. Some criticality present. Good attempt to discuss theories/models and concepts. | Identification of a good range of issues and with a high level of evaluation and analysis. Good level of criticality present. Theories/models and concepts are effectively discussed. | Appropriate coverage of theories/models and concepts with the three research strands (30%) | No or minimal relevant theory / models and concepts used. Lacking in breadth and/or depth. | Limited coverage of relevant theory / models and concepts. Lacking in breadth and/or depth in most areas. | Reasonable coverage of relevant theory / models and concepts. Lacking in breadth and/or depth in most areas. | Good coverage of relevant theory / models and concepts. Reasonable balance of breadth and depth achieved. | Very good coverage of relevant theory / models and concepts. Good balance of breadth and depth achieved overall. | Range and quality of sources utilised...

Words: 398 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Managing Projects

...Project code: 9273 M1 Report Word limit/Words Covered: 5000/5079 Research Report Title: LEADERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT ACROSS DIFFERENT CULTURES - HOTEL LEICESTER MARRIOTT, UK http://issuu.com/sanjaykumarguptaa/docs/project-report-recruitment-and-selection-process Table of Contents Introduction 1 Introduction to subject area 1 Background of the study 1 Literature Review 3 Critical evaluation of leadership theories 3 Compare and contrast of leadership style across different cultures 6 Critical evaluation of motivational theories 7 Compare and contrast motivational techniques across different cultures 8 Critical evaluation of theories for managing cultural diversity 9 Secondary research method 10 Primary research method 10 Interview 10 Findings and Discussion 11 Findings from secondary research 11 Managing diversified customers 11 Recommendations and Conclusion 13 Conclusion 13 Recommendations 13 References (Harvard Style) 17 Introduction Introduction to subject area It is a well known fact that success of the hospitality industry depends on the high quality services provided to the customer. It is the responsibility of the leaders to motivate and inspire employees to deliver a higher quality services for the success of the organization. With the increasing globalization, the leaders in the hospitality industry also come across through different challenges. Employees from diverse background...

Words: 5625 - Pages: 23

Free Essay

Design of a Training Project

...Design of Training Project Through learning the organization will implement a systematic approach in the military evaluations process. Most military personnel have had to write an evaluation for their subordinates at one time or another. This organization has a distinctive way of processing evaluations. The organization process military evaluations electronically through the Army Knowledge (AKO) Forms and verify information using the following systems; Interactive Web Response System (IWRS), the Electronic Military Personnel Office (eMilpo), which manages active, mobilized reserve and, National Guard Soldiers, and the Command Management System (CMS) which analyzes submission data and provides the command a performance and timeliness overview of subordinate elements. Technology has enhanced our organization’s efficiency and processing abilities significantly as we rely in a system of systems to process military evaluations. Our organization is seeking to change behavior with training and development; contemplating new ideas to improve behavior and have employees’ process evaluations based on one standard, using the appropriate sources. Enhanced processing is always welcomed in our organization. After training completion employees are expected to improve. The evaluations section is very hectic because the number of monthly evaluations processed. Ongoing performance improvement will ensure all systemic uses are understood as mentioned above because finding data...

Words: 1921 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

How to Motivate Fred Maiorino

...Maiorino Fred Maiorino was employed by Schering-Plough for 35 years and on July 19, 1991 he was terminated. Fred was terminated because the lack of motivation he has once Jim Reed was hired. The factors that inhibit Jim Reed from motivated Fred Maiorino are lack of leadership, lack of goals, and lack of an effective employee performance review. Leadership Jim Reed fails to motivate Fred because of the unsuccessful role as leader. A successful leader has the ability to manage and supervise the performances of their employees. (Kacmar, Carlson, Harris 2013). These authors describe several leadership styles but the most effective in motivating employees is transformational leadership style. The transformational leadership style inspires employees by establishing an atmosphere that is motivating and invigorating (Kacmar, Carlson, Harris 2013). Motivating employees initiate them to believe in organizations ambitions. The transformation leadership technique encourages and motivates employees to be mindful of the significance of their role within the company. The authors explain a transformation leader that stimulates and motivates employees has the ability to achieve astonishing outcomes and improve their leadership capability. They also assist in developing and strengthening employees. They are effective in overcoming defiance among the employees by instilling passion, strength and cooperation between employees and establishing a set of standards to follow. Leaders must demonstrate...

Words: 1888 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

C200T2

...Task Two: Leadership Practices analysis Task Two: Leadership Practices analysis C200 Managing Organizations and Leading People C200 Managing Organizations and Leading People Table of Contents Section A1 | Leadership Style and Practices | | A1 A1a | Seven Habits Profile Seven Habits Profile and Reflection | | Section A2 | Evaluation of Leadership Practices | | A2a A2b A2c A2d | Leadership Strengths Leadership Weaknesses Theory Based Changes to Maximize Success SMART Goals | | Section B | Works Cited | | B1 | Reference Page | | February 5th 2016 Managing Organizations and Leading People TASK TWO:  LEADERSHIPAND PRACTICES ANALYSIS A1. Leadership Style and Practices – Seven Habits Profile A1a. Seven Habits Profile Reflection In this paper I will reflect on my own leadership practices, starting with the results of my Seven Habits profile. Upon first viewing the results of the seven habits profile, the lowest scores caught my attention first. I saw that section 5, putting things first, was the lowest score at 10 points. I agree with the the seven habits profile, this is my biggest weakness when evaluated on the seven habits criteria. I can admit that sometimes I get lost in my work and forget about the things that really matter and the bigger picture. An article in People Management says that people who follow this habit well “recognize that not doing everything is okay. Evaluate...

Words: 1655 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Leadership Approach, Ldr531

...Leadership Approach XXXXXXXX LDR531 September 5, 2011 John Schobin Leadership Approach The purpose of this paper is to explore the situational leadership theory as an approach to studying leadership. We will also explore the participative style of leadership as well as discuss the strengths and weaknesses of this type of leadership. Finally we will examine an organizational example where participative leadership was used effectively. Situational Leadership Theory The situational leadership theory is a contingency approach to studying leadership. It helps to identify appropriate leadership behaviors when dealing with subordinates who are at different levels of maturity in relation to the task at hand. The level of maturity of the subordinate will determine the actions taken by the leader. The theory categorizes subordinates’ maturity level into four quadrants, M1, M2, M3, and M4. For a subordinate who is low in maturity (M1) the leader should use primarily task-oriented behavior and be very directive with outlining policies and procedures. The leader will also maintain close supervision to monitor the subordinate’s progress. As a subordinate matures (M2, M3) the leader can use less task-oriented behavior and incorporate some relations-oriented behaviors. These relations-oriented behaviors include support, consultation, and praise. For subordinates...

Words: 764 - Pages: 4