Free Essay

Heathcliff and Catherine Love

In:

Submitted By MayTaher
Words 961
Pages 4
“She was much too fond of Heathcliff. The greatest punishment we could invent for her was to keep her separate from him.” How far is Nelly’s comment a fair summary of the relationship between Catherine and Heathcliff and the problems it contains?

In Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights, the theme of love is central; particularly the love between both Catherine and Heathcliff. Bronte’s illustration of the love between the two protagonists transgresses beyond the “normal”, romantic love previous authors, such as Jane Austen, would portray. Emily Bronte’s love uniting both Catherine and Heathcliff contains undeniable gothic conventions alongside the idea of idolised romance; she has created a love story which includes aspects of passion, lust and suffering. Nelly, commenting on the relationship between Catherine and Heathcliff, states “She was much too fond of Heathcliff. The greatest punishment we could invent for her was to keep her separate from him”, suggesting that the intense love they had for one another will forever be problematic.

It is important here to focus on Nelly’s use of the adverb “too”, as it describes that Catherine’s love towards Heathcliff goes beyond average. When having to choose between Heathcliff and Edgar, Catherine concludes “I’ll try to break their hearts by breaking my own”. For Heathcliff, Catherine refuses to eat or sleep and also willingly exposes herself to a chill when she is feverish. Here, Catherine’s love towards Heathcliff has resulted in a form of mental anguish, a gothic trope. Not only this, but it also suggests that the greatest love story within Wuthering Heights is explored through acts of violence, another gothic trope. It is also due to Catherine’s immense love for Heathcliff (alongside social position and stability) that she chooses to marry Edgar; she will “aid Heathcliff… with [her] husband’s money”. Unfortunately, Catherine’s act of “kindness” could not stop Heathcliff from hearing her say “it would degrade me to marry Heathcliff”, which resulted in him running away. This leads Catherine to stay out in a storm all night, causing her to be sick in the morning. The storm here, a form of pathetic fallacy, could be used to represent the tension between the two, whilst her sickness is another gothic trope possibly used to portray her to be “weaker” without her soul mate. However, Catherine is also seen to tell Nelly, “I am Heathcliff - he’s always, always in my mind - not as a pleasure any more than I am always a pleasure to myself - but as my own being”, further emphasising the fact that she was “much too fond of Heathcliff”. This means that, if her love for Heathcliff is as real as she describes it to be, choosing to marry Edgar is a mistake.

Moreover, we could also argue that Nelly’s punishment, “to keep her [Catherine] separate from him [Heathcliff]”, can be seen as a catalyst to the problems within Catherine and Heathcliff’s relationship. In chapter six, we find that Catherine and Heathcliff have run to Thrushcross Grange, and once there, see Edgar and Isabella fighting through one of the windows. Here, the window could be a form of separation, exposing the opposite rather than the truth, as it is seen to parallel the two civilised Linton children with the “wild” Catherine and Heathcliff, with the use of paralleling being an additional gothic trope. Moreover, through the use of the parallels, Bronte is not only juxtaposing the social status of the children, but also how their relationship is perceived - Edgar and Isabella fight, whilst Catherine and Heathcliff cannot bear to be apart. Nonetheless, following this we find Catherine to be “trapped” at Thrushcross Grange, as she has been bit by the Linton’s dog, a violent act with dark undertones. Once returning home to Wuthering Heights after a number of weeks without Heathcliff, we recognise that she has transformed from a “wild wick” into society’s ideal woman, as illustrated by her new dress. The dress, valuable economically and socially approved, must be sacrificed (or dirtied), if she wants to be as close to Heathcliff as she was before. This therefore describes how keeping Catherine separate from Heathcliff at Thrushcross Grange created a number of problems in their relationship, whilst also foreshadowing how some of these problems, such as having to be approved by society, will repeatedly come between Catherine and Heathcliff love for each other.

However, Jay Clayton (who specialised in Victorian Literature) contradicts the belief that the separation tore the two apart; he states “Catherine’s declaration of love attempts to recover a lost state of being even as it claims that this lost unity will endure forever… Catherine and Heathcliff’s tragic tale depend on their being separated”. Possibly, as Clayton suggests that the love between Catherine and Heathcliff “depends on their being separated”, Nelly’s punishment of separating the two acted as an incentive to further evolve the love they have for each other. When Heathcliff sees a changed Catherine return from Wuthering Heights, he tells Nelly to “make [him] decent”. Heathcliff chooses to change for his relationship with Catherine, however due to his low, immutable status in society, only receives more hate from Hindley - he sees Heathcliff to be only a “brute of a lad”.

In conclusion, it is accurate to say that Nelly’s comment on Catherine and Heathcliff’s relationship, “She was much to fond of Heathcliff. The greatest punishment we could invent for her was to keep her separate from him”, describes it to be complicated. As stated before, the lovers’ relationship thrives on uniting both love and punishment to form a torturous love towards one-another. As a result this emphasises how, for their love to succeed, it must be problematic; and for that reason the punishment Nelly invents for both Catherine and Heathcliff will always encourage their relationship to grow further.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Sweet Revenge

...man named Lockwood who lives in house owned by another man named Heathcliff. Lockwood wants to know more about Heathcliff so he asks the maid to tell him about Heathcliff. The maid, Nelly, begins a long story starting with Heathcliff’s childhood. A man named Mr. Earnshaw had one son, Hindley, and one daughter, Catherine. One day Mr. Earnshaw took a trip to Liverpool. He came back with a young boy, Heathcliff. Although Hindley did not like him, the daughter Catherine approved of him. Catherine and Heathcliff spent every day playing with each other and eventually grew to love each other. When they became older, Catherine decided to marry a man named Edgar Linton instead of Heathcliff. Heathcliff was so mad that he left the house, called Wuthering Heights, for three years. He returned soon after Edgar and Catherine got married. Heathcliff is still infuriated and wants to get revenge on everyone who did not treat him well. Hindley started drinking heavily after his wife died from giving birth to his son Hareton. Heathcliff gives money to Hindley to gamble with. When Hindley died, Heathcliff inherited Wuthering Heights. In order to get back at Catherine for getting married, he marries a woman, Isabella, who lives four miles away at a place called Thrushcross Grange. Soon after, Catherine gives birth to a daughter, also named Catherine, but dies giving birth. Isabella moved to London because Heathcliff did not treat her properly. While she was there, she gave birth...

Words: 1276 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Wuthering Heights Review

...Emily Bronte’s novel, Wuthering Heights, is a proverbial soap opera stew, filled with love, lies, and deceit intertwining two families that reside only four miles apart across the moors in ever-seemingly dreary northern England. The two main characters, Catherine and Heathcliff are born to be together, but destined to be apart. Although truly happy and hopelessly in love with Catherine during the bright times in his life, Heathcliff couldn’t withstand the cruel, evil grip of jealousy and revenge that consumed him, eventually dragging all of those individuals associated with him, as well as his own being, to a dark demise. Wuthering Heights is unlike any other story that I’ve come across, and it is difficult to put a specific category label on it. Thrilling, tragic, damp, and dark, filled with villains and heroines, Bronte never clarifies who said villain or heroin is, seemingly purposefully changing the proverbial mind with each turn of the page. From the moment young adopted Heathcliff becomes friends with Catherine, it’s apparent that he is sincerely happy as he and Catherine’s love grows with each innocent tryst among the moors, ever growing from friendship into love. Catherine gives us a glimpse of that love and adoration when she states, “My love for Heathcliff resembles the eternal rocks beneath…He’s always, always in my mind: not as a pleasure, any more than I am always a pleasure to myself, but as my own being” (Bronte, 1847, p. 64). The...

Words: 1722 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Dysfunctional Love Wuthering Heights

...Heights is a love story has been one of the most popular debates. In contrast to what others may belief, Wuthering Heights is indeed a love story. It may not be the usual happy ending love story; however, it is one with a dysfunctional love. The love between Heathcliff and Catherine was intervened by pride and ego. Although the characters expressed their love for each other various times, it is them who deprived themselves from happiness. The novel well interprets the the dysfunctional love of the characters, giving it an ultimate twist to the love story. Towards the beginning of the novel, Lockwood’s unexpected stay at Wuthering Heights triggers an emotional breakdown in Heathcliff. During the night of his stay,...

Words: 871 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Wuthering Heights

...Relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine in Wuthering Heights The central theme of Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte is the relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine. The problem of the bond between Heathcliff and Catherine and its significance remains the central mystery of the novel till the very end. In fact, the novel is a revengeful love story of Heathcliff. Catherine is the daughter of Mr. Earnshaw and Heathcliff is a pickup boy by Mr. Earnshaw from the slums of Liverpool. Mr. Earnshaw treated Heathcliff like his own child. As children, Cathy and Heathcliff seem to represent the spirit of freedom rebelling against the tyrannical authority and religious bigotry of Hindley and Joseph. Their love was infinite which draws them together irresistibly. Heathcliff repeatedly calls Catherine his soul. Catherine and Heathcliff love is based on their shared perception that they are the same. Catherine famously declares, “I am Heathcliff,” while Heathcliff upon Catherine’s death, wails that he cannot live without his soul, meaning Catherine. Both Heathcliff and Catherine love each other profoundly. Yet some ambiguity is noticed in both Cathy’s speech and action. Cathy and Heathcliff are creatures of the wild moorland where conventional social standards are meaningless. After meeting with Edgar Linton, Cathy develops an interest towards him. She now seems to be equally interested in Edgar and Heathcliff. But there remains a striking contrast between them as far as looks...

Words: 565 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Wuthering Heights Heathcliff Cruelty Quotes

...Wuthering Heights, cruelty serves as a crucial motivator. When Heathcliff feels hurt because of Hindley Earnshaw's treatment of him, Heathcliff lashes out at Hindley and his child. When Catherine, Heathcliff’s childhood love, marries another man, Heathcliff becomes angry and hateful. He begins to become motivated by his hate and he becomes feared for his cruelness. In Wuthering Heights, jealousy and a need for revenge drives Heathcliff's feelings of love to turn into feelings of cruelty. Although several other characters in Wuthering Heights are described as cruel, Heathcliff's cruelty fiercely contrasts theirs because he willingly acts on it. Hindley's treatment of him and Catherine's decision to choose Edgar over himself directly cause...

Words: 799 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Vocabulary and Main Characters of Wuthering Heights

... sanctimonious, sanguine, trepidation Chapters XXI-XXXIV: parlor, sally, irresolute, mortification, evince, ardor, obstinate, disposition, folly, entreat, compunction, peruse, jubilee, reconcile, buoyant, lamentation, asunder, moors, haggard, pettishness, scruple, wan, reproach, supplicate, trifling, spurn, vexation, grovel, ostensible, perish, injunction, repulse, cunning, feebleness, pacify, acquiesce, farthing, destitute, sulky, soliloquy, vile, preclude, devastate, fortnight, skirmish, ingenuity, morose, obdurate, perversity, reprovingly, paragon, disparagement, antipathy, potent, shun, admonition, contemptuous, hue, incarnate, compliance, sexton, dismal, expostulation Main characrers Heathcliff - An orphan brought to live at Wuthering Heights by Mr. Earnshaw, Heathcliff falls into an intense,...

Words: 1216 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Destructive Love In Macbeth And Bronte's Wuthering Heights

...The theme of destructive love within the relationships in the story’s Shakespeare's Macbeth and Bronte’s Wuthering Heights are presented through sexism, jealousy, and betrayal. Destructive love can make a possible prosperous relationship. Destructive love can ruin the trust that is needed to have a well structured relationship. Love can make people do very horrific and evil things as the story Macbeth reveals in a very dark and fearsome way. Macbeth’s actions out of love for Lady Macbeth caused him to lose his sanity. Evil has the power to corrupt everything it touches, and Macbeth has become evils servant. Women are manipulative to men, women always strive to get what they want by being evil and malicious. In ( Macbeth 7.1) lady macbeth wants to have King Duncan murdered but she claims she cannot come to kill Duncan herself because in sleep he looks to much like her father. Lady Macbeth asks Macbeth to commit the murder of King Duncan because she can not bring herself to do it. Lady Macbeth then calls Macbeth a “Coward”, Macbeth then replies “ I dare do all that to become a man”. (Macbeth 1.7.2). Macbeth loves her husband although now that she has control over him she has started to become very wicked. Lady Macbeth is very strategic when it comes to the murder of King Duncan....

Words: 1253 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Why Is Chapter 9 Wuthering Heights a Pivotal Chapter

...the novel. In chapter 9 Catherine speaks to Nelly. Believing they are alone, Catherine explains to Nelly that she is engaged to Edgar Linton and that she couldn’t marry Heathcliff due to the fact he would degrade her and he wouldn’t be able to financially provide for her: he is rough and poor, Cathy states "It would degrade me to marry Heathcliff". Catherine decided to marry Linton due to his wealth and high social class "he will be rich, and I shall like to be the greatest woman of the neighbourhood". Catherine, like most of the Victorian society, views marriage as a social contract and not the ultimate commitment between lovers "you would love him without that, probably; and with it you wouldn’t, unless he possessed the four former attractions", she also chose Linton because he was the ideal man- handsome, young, cheerful and rich. Heathcliff overhears the start of the conversation between Nelly and Catherine, then disappears, therefore he fails to hear Catherine tell Nelly that she is truly in love with him. If Heathcliff had stayed and carried on listening to what Cathy had to say, then he would have understood how much she loved him, which potentially could have altered the novels overall plot. In chapter 9 we learn Catherine's true feelings. Catherine expresses to Nelly that her love for Linton will fade overtime for the reason being "he won't always be handsome, and young, and may not always be rich". On the other hand her love for Heathcliff is eternal. When the two...

Words: 611 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Paper

...from Wuthering Heights and its occupants in these first few chapters? 5. Describe Heathcliff. 6. What glimpses from the past does Lockwood get when he discovers Catherine's books? 7. Whose ghost visits Mr. Lockwood? What is Heathcliff's reaction to the ghost? B) Chapters 4-8 1. Who is Nelly Dean? 2. What do the gifts that Hindley and Catherine ask their father to bring them reveal about their characters? 3. What are Heathcliff's origins? 4. Why does Hindley despise Heathcliff? 5. Characterize Catherine. 6. Compare and contrast Catherine's and Heathcliff's reactions to the Lintons at Thrushcross Grange. 7. Why did Edgar get applesauce dumped on him? 8. Catherine is pained by Hindley's punishment of Heathcliff, yet she continues to entertain her guests. What change does this reveal? 9. What does Heathcliff begin to plan? 10. Who is Hareton Earnshaw? 11. How does Frances' death affect Hindley? 12. Edgar gets a good look at Catherine's "other side." What is his reaction? C) Chapters 9-10 1. Who saves Hareton's life? 2. Why does Catherine accept Edgar's proposal when she knows Heathcliff is a part of her soul? 3. Why does Heathcliff disappear? 4. How has Heathcliff changed during his absence of three years? 5. Who is Isabella, and what does she think of Heathcliff? 6. How does Heathcliff begin his revenge on Hindley (and ultimately gain control of his land)? D) Chapters...

Words: 2830 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Wuthering Heights Ap Essay

...“spiritual reassessment or moral reconciliation” evident in the ending and explain its significance in the work as a whole. Wuthering Heights depicts the story of a vengeful man who exists solely to make those closest to him suffer. Heathcliff, a dark and evil character, is stripped of his other half, his true love, Catherine, at the young age of 12, and dedicates the rest of his life to seeking revenge on those who hurt him. At Catherine’s death, Heathcliff goes mad and wishes that her spirit will haunt him on earth. Heathcliff’s insanity and cruel nature stem from his preclusion of marrying Catherine, and her eventual death. In Charlotte Bronte’s Wuthering Heights, Heathcliff’s spiritual reassessment comes at the end of his life, when he finally realizes his love for Catherine is more powerful than his need for vengeance. Heathcliff’s love for Catherine was so passionate that it drove him to absurdity at the event of her death. He was brought into the Earnshaw family as an orphan who had nothing, and so grew up with Catherine playing in the Moors together. Then, at age 12, they were separated and were not allowed to play together again. Heathcliff seemed as a normal boy until this moment, which was the first spark of his devilish ways. Catherine was married to a quiet, mild Edgar Linton, whom she married for wealth...

Words: 622 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Wuthering Heights

...Mr. Lockwood, the new tenant, talking with his property owner, Mr. Heathcliff, about Thrushcross Grange. After becoming snowed in, at Wuthering Heights, Lockwood stumbles upon Catherine Earnshaw’s diary. Through the diary, he discovers a bit more information about Mr. Heathcliff. After reading the diary, he falls asleep and awakes to a pecking at the window. After suspecting that the pecking was just a branch on the window he arouses, puts his hand through the window to grab the branch. Only what his fingers clenched were the cold fingers of an ice cold little hand. The pecking was the ghost of none other than Catherine Earnshaw, she begins to cry out “Let me in. Let me in.” He replies, “Who are you?” She responded “Catherine Linton.” Confused and expecting the ghost to be Catherine Earnshaw he became frightened and begins to pull her wrist back and forth on the broken pane until it began to bleed soaking his bedclothes in her blood. Lockwood convinces Catherine to let go, blocks the whole in the window with books, and tells her he will not let her in even if it had been twenty years. Morning she said, “It is twenty years. I have been a waif for twenty years.” (p.23). Lockwood screams out it fear and Mr. Heathcliff enters the room to see the problem. Lockwood tells Heathcliff of the little fiend that had gotten in the window and how he thought she was a changeling and had a wicked soul. Heathcliff becomes and angry and says, “What can you mean by talking in this way...

Words: 2136 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Wuthering Heights Anaylsis

...Hareton Earnshaw and Catherine. As the novel progresses, we see love develop between these two characters that is best explained by how they are brought together, the problems that their relationship poses and how this relationship affects the other characters in the novel and the plot of the novel itself. The first way to understand this relationship is to examine how these two characters are brought together. In the novel, there is a real sense that fate has a lot to do with the union between the lovers, as Catherine and Hareton are reunited at the symbolic Penistone Crags. Catherine has a burning desire to go to the crags, the symbol of maturity, natural erotic desire and wild temptation. She asks Nelly and her father “Now, am I old enough to go to Penistone Crags?”(Brontë 147) As Catherine reaches teenage years, she desires to travel outside of Thrushcross Grange and ascend the large Penistone Crags, which are close to Wuthering Heights and Hareton. Catherine and Hareton spend the whole day near the Crags until Nelly fetches them. Brontë then describes the interaction between Hareton and Catherine as joyful, describing that “Her hat was hung against the wall, and she seemed perfectly at home laughing and chattering, in best spirits imaginable, to Hareton, now a great, strong lad of eighteen, who stared at her with considerable curiosity and astonishment” ( Brontë 149). This quote shows how there is an underlying connection between them; Hareton and Catherine begin to show similar...

Words: 1226 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Wuthering Heights

...T/Thurs 7: 00 25October2012 Heathcliff And Catherine: A tale of two loves Catharine and Heathcliff’s passion for one another show how a love too great is developed throughout the novel, Wuthering Heights. The bond between Catharine and Heathcliff remain the primary mystery until the very end of the novel. Environment of the Yorkshire moor and both being raised as siblings at the same dwelling place, gives them both a greater chance to develop their romantic love affair. Their love exists on a higher or more spiritual plane in which eventually spirals out of control, leaving both Catharine and Heathcliff devastated. Heathcliff was a wearisome orphan, living in the slums of Liverpool who was brought home by Mr. Earnshaw when they were just mere children. Starting at an early age, they both shared a unique bond between one another that nobody else could explain. It is never entirely clear whether their love for one another is romantic or the love of very close siblings. Their recklessness and destructive passion are unable to penetrate the eternal love they share. Heathcliff repeatedly calls Catherine his soul; and Catherine states: “I am Heathcliff, he’s always in my mind; not as a pleasure, any more than I am always a pleasure to myself, but as my own being” (Pg 80), which shows their shared perception that they are identical. After experiencing a luxurious and pleasant stay at Thrushcross Grange, Catherine’s character significantly changes. Catherine began to be drawn to the...

Words: 537 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Opposing Forces of Wuthering Heights

...The opposing forces of Wuthering Heights. Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights can be seen as one of the most influential works of fiction produced during the Victorian age. In Brontë’s novel, the reader will encounter many oppositions across several elements of the story. These oppositions play a vital role in the development of both the characters and the plot and have been discussed by many critics. According to Melvin R. Watson, as he describes in his article “Tempest in the Soul: The Theme and Structure of “Wuthering Heights,”” a most influential theory is that of the opposing forces of calm and storm developed by Lord David Cecil (Watson, 88). This theory, however, does not completely encompass the multitude of opposites found in the novel. The oppositions found in Wuthering Heights all serve specific roles in the development of the characters and the plot of the novel. The universe of the opposing forces of the calm and the storm that can be found within Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights is one that encompasses many elements of the story. At the very start of the novel, the narrator, in the form of Mr. Lockwood, gives the reader a detailed description of the house he is about to enter: Wuthering Heights is the name of Mr. Heathcliff’s dwelling. ‘Wuthering’ being a significant provincial adjective, descriptive of the atmospheric tumult to which its station is exposed in stormy weather. Pure, bracing ventilation they must have up there at all times, indeed: one may guess...

Words: 2424 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Childhood of Heathcliff

...The Childhood of Heathcliff (chapters 4 to 17) The story begins thirty years before when the Earnshaw family lived at Wuthering Heights consisting of, as well as the mother and father, Hindley, a boy of fourteen, and six-year-old Catherine, the same person that he had dreamt about and the mother of the present mistress. In that year, Mr Earnshaw travels to Liverpool where he finds a homeless, gypsy-like boy of about seven whom he decides to adopt as his son. He names him "Heathcliff". Hindley, who finds himself excluded from his father's affections by this newcomer, quickly learns to hate him but Catherine grows very attached to him. Soon Heathcliff and Catherine are like twins, spending hours on the moors together and hating every moment apart. Because of this discord, Hindley is eventually sent to college but he returns, three years later, when Mr Earnshaw dies. With a new wife, Frances, he becomes master of Wuthering Heights and forces Heathcliff to become a servant instead of a member of the family. Heathcliff and Cathy continue to run wild and, in November, a few months after Hindley's return, they make their way to Thrushcross Grange to spy on the inhabitants. As they watch the childish behaviour of Edgar and Isabella Linton, the children of the Grange, they are spotted and try to escape. Catherine, having been caught by a dog, is brought inside and helped while Heathcliff is sent home. Five weeks later, Catherine returns to Wuthering Heights but she has now...

Words: 721 - Pages: 3