Free Essay

Is Suicide Justifiable?

In:

Submitted By dcoles
Words 1636
Pages 7
Is Suicide Justifiable? According to Albert Camus, suicide was considered the fundamental issue for moral philosophy. Unlike other philosophers who had written on the subject and tried to find sufficient reasons behind it to put off facing the consequences of the absurd, Camus was interested in not only accepting, but also embracing absurdity while renouncing suicide. His philosophy is profoundly evident in one of his non-fiction works, The Myth of Sisyphus, which illuminates the ethics of suicide. Through Camus’ thoughts and writings, the concept of absurdity has influenced authors around the world and has left a great impression on their writings, such as Henrik Ibsen’s play, Rosmersholm, and poses the question whether suicide is in fact justifiable. In his philosophy, known as absurdism, Camus emphasizes that "There is but one truly serious philosophical problem, and that is suicide." The goal of this idea is to judge whether or not life is worth living in a meaningless world. Camus defines the notion of the absurd as something that expresses an essential disharmony in our existence. He emphasizes that this is product of a clash and "confrontation between our man and his own obscurity" (Camus, 494) . In other words, Camus explains that we are free agents in this life, and that we live by a sense of meaning and purpose, and under this acceptance, we feel at home. However, everyone, at some point in their life, has experienced the feeling of absurdity, whether its during moments of uncertainty or depression. This is when we are unable to find our values and realize that there is no purpose to do anything we do. This gives associates us with a feeling of exile, a feeling that we do not belong in this world if it lacks meaning. Without values in our lives, the world is meaningless, and without meaning, people feel lost and exiled and tend to take drastic measures. Camus introduces us to the two possible human responses to a meaningless world. They are suicide, and hope. In his essays and non-fiction works, Camus tries to find an alternate option to running away from the absurd, which so many people do to relieve themselves of that hopeless, empty feeling whether it be through suicide or hope. By committing "physical suicide," as Camus refers to it, we are proving that life is not worth living since it holds no meaning, and by finding hope in a meaningless world, also known as "philosophical suicide," is we are using blind faith to deny that fact that this world lacks meaning. Camus rejects both of these responses to the predicament of absurdity. He feels that physical suicide is an act of cowardliness and an "unfruitful truth." By giving up your life, you are giving in to the absurdity; he encourages us to not succumb to the meaninglessness. Camus also feels that philosophical suicide is just as bad as the previous. He believes that by finding faith and fake purpose and in a meaningless world, you you are completely destroying reason. Camus comes to the conclusion and verdict that suicide is not an option. He feels that suicide is a repudiation, and that it is necessary to die unreconciled and not of one's own free will, and that by dying, we are doing nothing but eluding the problem (Camus, 494). He believes that rather than surrendering to the absurd, we should learn to live with it, embrace it, and accept it fully. With suicide being it's central theme, The Myth of Sisyphus manifests this courageous response of living in union with absurdity. This fictional story is about Sisyphus, a figure of Greek mythology, who defied the gods and was condemned to a life of meaninglessness by having to repeat forever the task of pushing a boulder up a mountain. The catch is that every time he rolls the boulder to the top, it rolls back down again. In this myth, Camus presents Sisyphus as the absurd hero, he is a metaphor for all those lives spent working at long, hard, pointless jobs in factories and offices. Camus makes a point that this story is not tragic because Sisyphus has to do the same meaningless task over again, but because he is conscious of it. This is where the torture lies. Camus explains that like Sisyphus, "The workman of today works everyday in his life at the same tasks, and his fate is no less absurd. But it is tragic only at the rare moments when it becomes conscious" (Camus). Camus makes it a point to express his admiration of the hero's hour of consciousness. For it is at this point during his task that he becomes superior to his fate. It is when absurd man stops to contemplate his life and realizes that he has created his fate, that he become "the master of his days" (Camus, 494). When Sisyphus, or the absurd man realizes what his life has come to and the control he has over it and has realized the meaninglessness of it, he has successfully accepted absurdity and has learned to embrace it. By acknowledging the absurd, you have conquered it. For when you have done this, you have found dignity and you can live life fully, with a sense of mission. For instance, every time Sisyphus has to climb down the mountain to push the boulder back up again, he can drive himself to push it harder and faster next time, or do

it with a smile on his face. The same thing holds true for the absurd workers; every day they wake up they can go to work with a new goal, such as cutting more wood or meeting a certain quota, and they can push themselves to work even harder the next day or go into work with a great attitude. By waking up each day to face work or hardships, knowing you can't win, and doing it with determination and drive, you are facing absurdity with the traits of a true hero. Ultimately, the moral of the myth is that suicide is unjustifiable. Camus feels the only way to conquer absurdity is to continue living, with an awareness that your life is meaningless, and with a sense of drive and motivation. For it is the knowledge we have of our control over our own fate that gives us the encouragement to continue to do things. This is how we can acknowledge that life is meaningless without committing suicide, and this is how we can have values in a meaningless world. Henrik Ibsen's play, Rosmersholm, is a more modern piece of literature that is based around the act of suicide. Although three of the main characters in this play take their own lives, Camus would not justify this action or the reasons behind it. The premise of this play is built around Beate, Rosmer, and Rebekka and their secrets, lies, and hardships. These characters, are absurd characters. For example, Beate, the wife of Rosmer, was convinced by Rebekka that her husband impregnated her. This extreme circumstance left Beata in a state of crucial depression, and in a cry of desperation, she committed suicide. Rebekka, another absurd character, is faced with absurdity through leading Beata to her death, through her lies to Rosmer, and through hardships aroused by her father. A build up of all this tension left Rebekka in need of relieving herself of and negating her previous wrong doings through an act of suicide. At the end of the play, during the final scene between Rosmer and Rebekka, it is clear that her motives behind the suicide consists of making amends for her earlier sins. She asks her Rosmer, "Do you know anything that might free me in your eyes?" and later that "Whatever wrongs I have committed - it is proper that I atone for them" (Ibsen, 308). After reading this, it is quite evident that the reason for her suicide was self-punishment. Rosmer, on the other hand, has problems that branch farther than the death of his wife and the lies of Rebekka. For instance, he is never able to express his full feelings to the women he loves, and he is hesitant and lacks confidence in himself when it comes to politics. In the end, Rosmer decides to commit suicide on the idea that he will be able to escape all the pressure society has put on him, and finally be able to express his love for Rebekka by becoming one with her during their death; he says, "We follow each other, Rebecca. I, you---and you, me" (Ibsen, 310). According to his philosophy, I feel that Camus would reject every reason behind suicide that each of these characters use. All of them act in a cowardly manner and let depression, guilt, and pressure get the best of them. Rather than succumbing to the power of absurdity, they should have faced it courageously like Sisyphus had. Beate should have either found out the truth from her husband or moved on. Rebekka should have come to terms with all of her sins and accepted them, and instead of her punishment being suicide, she should have pushed herself to make up for them by performing a good deed each day. Rosmer should have gained some confidence in himself and taken a chance at politics. To continue living is the best, and most reasonable way to conquer absurdity. This is the significance behind Camus philosophy. We all encounter the absurd at some point in our life, and it is up to us to make just decisions determine our own fate.

Bibliography

Albert Camus, The Meaning of Life from The Myth of Sisyphus
Albert Camus, The Myth of Sisyphus
Ibsen, Henrik. An Enemy of the People. The Wild Duck. Rosmersholm. New York: Oxford UP, 2009.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Assisted Suicide Is Not Justifiable Essay

...Imagine that you have just found out you have been diagnosed with alzheimer's and you can’t and won’t remember a lot of things. Imagine a world where you don’t remember what you ate for breakfast, alzheimer’s is an incurable disease that attacks your memories and makes you forget important stuff. Some forget who their own child is or even their spouse. Would you like to live your life not remembering what you did yesterday or would you like to be “put down”. I believe that certain instances are justifiable reasons to be killed such as the case of George killing lennie in Of Mice and Men and assisted suicide. There are also where it is not justifiable such as capital punishment. In the case of assisted suicide killing is justifiable. “You will become bed ridden, unable to walk or even turn yourself over. You will become completely dependent on nurse assistants to intermittently shift your position to avoid pressure ulcers. When they inevitably slip up, your skin develops huge incurable sores that can sometimes erode to the bone…” (Goodman). This shows that if you do not die fast that it is almost...

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Crj 320 Wk 5 Quiz 5 Chapter 8 and 9

...offender. b. organized offender. d. mass murderer. 3. Which of the following statements is not true with regard to death investigations? a. Body temperature drops 2 to 3 degrees in the first hour after death. b. Rigor mortis appears first in the smaller muscles, such as those of the face. c. After about 36 hours, rigor mortis usually disappears in the same sequence as it appeared. d. Maximum lividity occurs within 15–20 hours after death. 4. Premeditation would be a requirement in which case? a. first-degree murder c. excusable homicide b. second-degree murder d. justifiable homicide 5. Rigor mortis is at its maximum at about ____________ hours after death. a. 6 to 8 hours c. 12 to 24 hours b. 8 to 9 hours d. 36 to 48 hours 6. Deaths are classified by type as a. natural, accidental noncriminal, suicide, homicide noncriminal and criminal. b. natural, accidental, suicide, murder. c. Accidental, suicide, murder, voluntary. d. either by accident or by the hands of another. 7. A dead body that sinks in water usually remains immersed for a. 5 to 7 days in warm water and 3 to 4 weeks in cold water. b. 8 to 10 days in warm water and 2 to 3 weeks in cold water. c. 2 to 3 weeks in...

Words: 1369 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Active Euthanasia Argumentative Analysis

...There is a moral debate saying that euthanasia is not morally justifiable, and some people feel that it goes against one's human rights, people feel that it is not ethical. There are many aspects that are included in the interest that people have in this specific topic (Brock, 2012). Some feel that Active Euthanasia is wrong because one is physically committing murder, ending a individual's life, and feel that it is wrong because it is considered a crime in Canada (Jecker, Jenson,2007). Many individuals are against euthanasia in Canada, however some argue that Passive is not wrong and Active euthanasia is, however in this paper I will be arguing that the two types of euthanasia are morally justifiable (Jecker, Jenson, 2007). I argue that Active,...

Words: 1060 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Physician-Assisted Suicide - Descriptive Analysis Paper

...COMS 321 – Rhetorical Discourse 18 Jun 2015 DESCRIPTIVE ANALYSIS: LET’S CALL PHYSICIAN-ASSISTED SUICIDE WHAT IT IS I have conducted a descriptive analysis from an article written by Karin Klein, Editorial Writer of the Los Angeles Times, published on February 17, 2015. Klein tackled the topic “Let’s call physician-assisted suicide what it is”. The newly written Senate Bill (SB) 128 would “allow physicians in California to write lethal prescriptions under tightly controlled circumstances” for the terminally ill but will not call it as “suicide” nor will it be reflected as such on death certificates. Klein’s editorial is focused on the these two major flaws of the bill written for the terminally ill who are looking for a dignified way to end their life by allowing them access to lethal prescription drugs if the bill is passed. The bill is mirrored after the State of Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act law passed by its legislature in 1997. Klein’s purpose, at the time of her writing the editorial, was to reach out to the legislators and advocates of the bill, her audience, to modify the bill by naming it as it is, “a physician-assisted suicide” and reflecting it as such in death certificates. The tone and approach to her writing was straight to the point while at times satirical, stretching how the definition of “suicide” can have a different connotation in the eyes and perspectives of the advocates of the bill. Klein seeks to appeal to the writers and proponents of the...

Words: 1550 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Euthanasia

...name of euthanasia is an act of omission, being for the benefit of the individual. If the death was not intentional, it cannot be defined as euthanasia. Different types of Euthanasia are as follows: * Voluntary euthanasia: The individual who was killed had requested to be killed * Non-voluntary euthanasia: The individual who was killed made no request to be killed, and the choice for the euthanasia was either passed on to a family member, loved one or a clinical physician who has decided that euthanasia was necessary * Involuntary euthanasia: The individual who was killed had made an expressed wish to the contrary of euthanasia * Assisted suicide: The individual is provided guidance, information and the means to take his or her own life. When this is done in a hospital, it is called “physician assisted suicide” * Euthanasia by Action: The intentional action causing a person’s death, such as administering a lethal injection * Euthanasia by Omission: The individual is not provided any necessary or ordinary care such as food or water; this leads to their death of malnutrition and starvation (Gielen, Van Den Branden & Broeckaert, 2009). A common argument in connection with euthanasia is in regards to the Bible. The sixth commandment of the Bible states: “Thou shalt not kill”. The commandment does...

Words: 2414 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

When Lying Is Justifiable

...When Lying is Justifiable Lying is an inevitable behavior, although we may all agree lying is not right, we fall into this behavior many times in our lives. Everyone lies; whether it is to protect, obscure, place blame, or manipulate. As children, most individuals were taught that lying was wrong. From hearing parents say common quotes like, “the truth shall set you free”, or from the many consequences received for lying, people were meant to be have honesty enforced their minds. There is no doubt truth actually is enforced in our minds, according to a study by expert of Developmental Science, Dr. Fu Genyue, Ph.D, “Children of all ages categorize lies as lies and truth as truth” (499). Research in the medical field shows that “deception is judged as justified in some contexts involving the prevention of harm” (Freeman 2274). Of course lying is not acceptable when speaking under oath or at confessions with a priest, but lying is definitely justifiable in certain situations were it can be used as a protection factor to protect the feelings, securities, and lives of others. We are all put into very awkward situations at some points of our lives where we may feel lying to spare one's feelings was the best option. One common situation is being asked, “Do I look fine in this outfit?”. If the person does look fine it is okay to say so, but it is when that person may not that we produce what is called a “white lie”. While many people may recognize the words “white lie”, there...

Words: 1652 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia

...Assisted Suicide and euthanasia 1 Assisted suicide is a very controversial subject. Everyone has an opinion on the matter and it is likely that everyone will not agree on the matter. I have always been of the opinion that god gave us life and is the only that should take it away. However, I have never been in a terminally ill state and do not know the feeling of living everyday in unbearable pain. I can only imagine what a person is going through in this matter and can understand why they would wish to be dead. My opinion of assisted suicide being wrong is based on my moral belief and that fact that I do not think I could ever been able to commit such an act. Because of how I feel, it seems morally wrong for anybody else to commit such an act as well. Since taking my class on ethical behavior, I have come to realize that what one believes to be morally correct is not necessarily how another person may feel. This belief is called moral relativism. “Moral relativism is whatever anyone claims to be morally acceptable is morally acceptable, at least for that person” (Ruggiero, 2008). “For years, doctors have been prohibited from assisting patients in taking their own lives. Dr. Jack Kevorkian gained world attention by assisting in several suicides to dying patients; he was sentenced to over 60 years for his efforts, despite the gratitude of the patients and their families....

Words: 1094 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Philosophy

... 5 References 6 Introduction Suicide is understood as an act of ending ones’ own life voluntarily. It is no doubt a topic that has long been debated by all sorts of people since there are those who see the act as a right of any person to execute while there are others who regard the act as self murder and unacceptable on many grounds. Philosophers since the time of Plato have examined the act of suicide in trying to understand how the human behavior and the mind could function together to commit such an act of self destruction. The medical sciences, through psychology, have been trying to understand the causes that could trigger someone to commit suicide but cannot say that they are able to understand the human mind and the way it functions to eventually lead to something so horrific. The factors that lead the human mind to carry on with such an act are too many and interrelated in a complex way. Due to the complexity of the causes, people have had opposite opinions about the morality of the act with those who justify it as a freedom of act, and others who condemn it totally. Is there a middle ground to this debate? I shall analyze the topic of suicide in this essay, and try to come up with a conclusion regarding the morality of the act. Discussion According to Thomas...

Words: 1439 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Persuasive Essay On Assisted Suicide

...such thing as a life not worth living.” Assisted suicide is na escape for the terminally ill but it is not justifiable. There are many issues with suicide and a lot more issues with suicide by physician. In this paper I am going to venture into a few of these issues and show you why we should not stand behind legalized assisted suicide. As a society we operate under the Social Contract which guarantees us the rights to life, liberty and property. Not only is assisted suicide not a fundamental liberty because it harms the Due Process Clause it also is forbidden under the social contract’s “life clause.” In order for a government to be just and fair it must protect the lives of its citizens and assisted suicide in all forms harms this. In the Supreme Court case Washington v. Glucksberg the majority opinion stated “The history of the law's treatment of assisted suicide in this country has been and continues to be one of the rejection of nearly all efforts to permit it. That being the case, our decisions lead us...

Words: 578 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Voluntary Manslaughter Research Paper

...Basically there are four criteria’s that should be achieved to warrant the reduction. First criteria is the provocation must cause fear in a reasonable person. Next, the defendant should have actually been provoked. Thirdly, the defendant must have not cooled off during that period and lastly there must not be a time period between the provocation and the murder within which a reasonable person should have cool off. Provocation is acceptable if a justifiable person under same circumstances would be induced to act in a similar manner as the defendant. The amount of provocation should be found that a reasonable person would lose self-control. This is an issue that is persistent by the trier of fact, either the judge or jury in a nonjury trial, after a complete deliberation of the evidence. Some scheme of provocation that regularly arise have habitually been considered justifiable or unjustifiable by the courts. A murder that consequences from anger which is induced by a violent blow with a weapon or fist might establish enough provocation, provided the defendant did...

Words: 565 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Pros And Cons Of Utilitarianism

...Utilitarianism is an ethical theory composed by Joh Stuart Mill. Utilitarianism focuses on ideas of there being a hierarchy of pleasures in the world, that actions are justifiable so long as the outcomes benefit the wellbeing of the whole, and that in order of one to perform these actions they must become impartial spectators to the entire situation in order to make the best decision. With these concepts combined one can then see the anatomy of utilitarianism being that the happiness of the whole is considered greater than the happiness of the community so long as the happiness attained is above in the hierarchy of pleasures. Mill begins the discussion of his theory with his definition of happiness through the ‘Greatest Happiness Principle’....

Words: 1698 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Cyber Bullying Is Wrong

...According to an annual cyber bullying report, seven out of ten young people reported that they feel they are a victim to cyber bullying. (nobullying.com) With cyber bullying increasing rapidly with the growth of technology, it brings up many questions to whether or not this is an issue. Many people say things online that they would not normally say in person. These things are typically hurtful to the person on the receiving end. Is it morally justifiable to text messages or post comments online that one would not consider acceptable to say in person? Many would argue that is morally justifiable because cyber-bullying does not inflict any physical harm, and it is not as harmful to somebody saying things through technology as it is in person....

Words: 2018 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Tyler Clementi Case Study

...Tyler Clementi Case - What Punishment Is Justifiable? Monday, Apr. 2, 2012 You've probably heard about the case of Tyler Clementi - a freshman at Rutgers University who committed suicide after his roommate, 18-year-old Dharun Ravi, secretly filmed and broadcasted Tyler having a homosexual encounter with another man. Three days later, Tyler committed suicide. Now, convicted of invasion of privacy, bias intimidation, witness tampering, and hindering arrest, Dharun faces 10 years in jail or deportation (Dharun, although living his whole life in the US, is technically native of India). He will be sentenced in May. What punishment do you think fits the crime? How is it fair, and if so, why? Does it bring justice to Tyler? Does it serve some...

Words: 442 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

None

...What does H.R. 218 permit? Police officers losing their lives in the line of duty because, of not knowing what to expect from emergency calls and even a non-emergency calls. They don’t know if the person whom they are about to confront is armed, on drugs, or plan to get revenge on a police officer because of personal issues in the past. H.R. 218 permits qualified police officers from carrying a concealed weapon with the exceptional of officers who’ve retired and have at least fifteen years of service experience (Law Enforcement Officers Safety Act 2004). 3) What is meant be suicide by cop, and what is two-step investigative process that must take place to determine when it has occurred and to analyze the phenomenon? Suicide by cop is defined as an act motivated in whole or in part by the offender’s desire to commit suicide that results in a justifiable homicide by a law enforcement officer. Meaning...

Words: 670 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Bullying Should Not Be Taught In Schools Research Paper

...According to julie Hilden, “Public school students do not shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.” Holden's point is that they are allowed to post freely but not every school follows that law. Another example is when Kelly Wallace state's, “monitor students' online interactions off-campus to protect them from dangers such as bullying, drug use, violence and suicide.” What Wallace really means by this is schools are working on trying to monitor students more which means more kids will be disciplined for reasons that may seem unfair but, under certain school regulations will be completely justifiable. Students should be allowed to exercise their freedom of speech. Students are given detentions for saying anything disrespectful or inappropriate during school hours. That is justifiable reasoning behind the...

Words: 551 - Pages: 3