Free Essay

Knowledge and Reality

In:

Submitted By naiha
Words 678
Pages 3
Events on Mars would have transpired differently if Gallinger had stopped to question his assumptions more. Perhaps the Martian population may not have been saved from extinction, he may have come across the prophecy earlier, and he might not have even brought the prophecy to light at all.
If Gallinger had stopped to analyze Braxa’s feelings for him the Martian population may not have been saved. That night when Braxa entered his room, her attention and fascination with Gallinger, along with her willingness to sleep with him made him think that all these events had only occurred because Braxa was in love. Had he taken the time to think, he might’ve realized that before that night Braxa had shown no interest in him nor did she show any afterwards. No proclamations of eternal love had been made by either party, and Gallinger could have easily moved on from Braxa, reevaluating the circumstances to be just a casual fling. This then would have had a large impact on the Martian future. With no emotional attachment to Braxa, Gallinger would’ve finished his work and headed back to Earth, never knowing about his unborn half-human half-Martian child. He wouldn’t have preached his words to the elders, in order to save them from extinction. In fact, he might have been wholly unconcerned with their existence overall. However, Gallinger could have tried to convince the Martians to let them be examined by human doctors to see if it was possible to save the Martian’s existence, but perhaps he might not have done it with the same determination and vigor as had he had when he was trying to save Braxa and his child. Gallinger’s assumption that Braxa was in love with him, and he was in love with Braxa had one of the biggest impacts on the story.
M’Cwyie asks Gallinger if he wants to see the “explicitness of the doctrine of Locar in its fullness” and when M’Cwyie simplifies this to the “Dance of Locar”. Gallinger assumes that M’Cwyie has trouble with the translation. He thinks that she does not know how to describe the dance correctly, when in fact she is telling him the significance of dance. If he had taken what M’Cwyie had mentioned more seriously, he may have gone back and analyzed the “Dance of Locar” more clearly, and may have become more aware of the prophecy. However, seeing as both of them were still learning the other’s language there could be a lot lost in translation. But Gallinger, as a world famous interpreter, should have paid more attention to what she was saying, and should not have immediately presumed that it was a because of M’Cwyie’s inadequate language skills.
When Braxa approached Gallinger in his bedroom that night, and told him about the sterility that had taken over, he assumed that both men and women were sterile. If he had stopped to analyze, and think that perhaps that it was only males or only the females that were sterile he wouldn’t have taken the risk of sleeping with Braxa at all. There was no proof that it was either, so perhaps it wasn’t a good idea to take that risk. Of course, there was no way that Gallinger could have known that Martians and humans were compatible. Considering there was so much that he didn’t know, it would have been better not to take the risk at all, and then there would be no pregnancy, and the “The Promise of Locar” may have not gone through, despite Braxa’s attempts. Questioning assumptions makes the greatest difference. If Gallinger had questioned his assumptions more often, so much on Mars would have gone differently. The prophecy may not have been discovered, and Braxa’s love- or lack thereof-may not have driven Gallinger to attempt suicide, and perhaps Mars’ population would have been doomed to extinction. Gallinger’s self-righteousness and his immediate notion that whatever he was thinking was always correct, would have made a world of difference.

I have neither given nor received unauthorized assistance on this assignment.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Matrix of Mind Reality

...Matrix of Mind Reality Enoch Tan – Creator of Mind Reality Discover The Greatest Secrets Of The Mind And Reality That Will Get You Anything You Desire, Almost Like Magic! If you want to FINALLY experience the COMPLETE Manifestation of All the Miracles, Success, Wealth, Health, Love and Happiness that you have always dreamed of… then register as member of Mind Reality now! Go here now to discover how to become a Mind Reality Member: ==>http://www.MindReality.com/specialoffer.html © Mind Reality Introduction Preview more of Secrets of Mind and Reality through the Free Newsletter: http://www.mindreality.com/secrets.html Mind Reality contains Universal Secrets that govern every area of life and reality. The deeper the knowledge, the more powerful the knowledge. The more powerful your knowledge, the easier it is to achieve success, because deep, powerful knowledge is the key to inspired thinking and finding intelligent solutions to problems. This book answers a great many questions that you've always been curious about such as: What is the nature of all reality and how the universe really works? Why gaining understanding and truth will get you everything you ever wanted? Why purchasing spiritual knowledge will tremendously accelerate your progress in life? And plenty more incredible knowledge inside.... The VERY reason why I created this free ebook with SOME of my articles is to give a preview of the immense QUALITY and QUANTITY information on Mind Reality. What you get...

Words: 11649 - Pages: 47

Premium Essay

Descartes Is Real

...Descartes: Can this be real? Am I in a dream? This must be real since I have conscious thoughts that I can manipulate. I remember everything in life and who I am, but I can not use any of my senses. They would have deceived me anyways, they have done so in the past and will so again. What is this? Socrates: You are not dreaming, for I am here as well. As for reality, I believe reality is twofold. Matter and a spirit reality. Based on the information I have gathered and from listening to you, it seems our minds have been separated from our bodies. Do not feel discouraged for this is a good thing. The body constantly has to deal with sensory appetites, which is like you said deceitful. Our body is not our true self. Our true self is our mind...

Words: 1069 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Plato's Cave

...Explain the analogy of the cave in Plato’s republic (25 marks) Plato, 428-347 B.C., was an Athenian philosopher who lived in Ancient Greece. In 407 B.C. he became a pupil and friend of Socrates. After living for a time at the Syracuse court, Plato founded (c.387 B.C.) near Athens the most influential school of the ancient world, the Academy, where he taught until his death. The “Republic” is one of Plato’s greatest books that he has written. Plato’s presents one of the most famous analogies in philosophy: the cave. This analogy illustrates the effects of true knowledge. True knowledge moves the philosopher through life without any distractions, which in due course brings him to the Form of the Good. He tells the Allegory of the Cave as a conversation between his teacher Socrates who inspired many of Plato's philosophical theories and Glaucon. In the dialogue between Socrates and Glaucon, Socrates asks Glaucon to imagine a cave, in which prisoners have been kept since their childhood, and each of them is held where they are all chained so that their legs and necks are unable to turn or allow them to move. This leaves them in a predicament where they’re forced to look at a wall in front of them. Behind the prisoners is a fire and between the fire and the prisoners is a raised walkway (bridge), on which people can walk. These people are shadow play, and they are carrying objects, in the shape of human and animal figures, as well as everyday items. The prisoners could only see...

Words: 1315 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Critical Thinking

...work of older men in our families, other folk in the neighborhood, and those no longer with us. Their labor-intensive road map provided us the basic knowledge from which to begin developing our own methods and skill sets to answer new types of questions related to daily life in Arkansas. However different the scope of questions we began to ask ourselves are from the questions early philosophers asked, we share in learning from and building on the methods and teachings of men before us. Some of the earliest philosophers, such as Plato incorporated similar questions about reality and truth as the pre-Socratics collective, however, based their inquiries within the natural world and used reason as the methodological vehicle. Because this type of thinking was contextualized outside of supernatural forces and myth and magic, the pre-Socratics collective are often times considered the first scientists of Western culture who laid the earliest foundations shaping the study of metaphysics and epistemology (Chaffee 230). This way of thinking sought to answer similar questions as those based in religion and myth, but sought answers through observations and analytical reasoning within the natural world. Generally, this way of thinking embodied the nature and scope of knowledge, theories of knowledge, and the extent to which knowledge about any subject and physical entity can be known. The pre-Socratic collective formed a bridge between a cultural consciousness based in beliefs...

Words: 1938 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Realities Two Way Street

...Realities Two-Way Street Ignorance is bliss. This phrase, however comforting, is a provocative statement to the debilitating state of society and the human state of mind; the dual-edged comment is represented in both Plato’s Allegory of the Cave and the Wachoski brother’s The Matrix through universes, similar to our own, where people are in strong states of illusion and ignorance. Both have a character, which is brought to the “light” to realize this false reality and to liberate everyone else to a better reality, the “real” reality. Situations can arise where having knowledge of it can seem detrimental, however, our very existence as human beings is to live a life of bettering ourselves and the species in general through knowledge both good and bad, and the actions that take place from knowledge. People do actions and make decisions based on history from what he has done wrong or from what he has done correctly and on this basis it is a stepping stone that either good or bad having knowledge of the past, complete knowledge, helps to mold the future positively. Although blissful, avoiding reality will never be a positive action with even in modern days something such as Facebook has become our matrix keeping people away from the outside, not personally and physically interacting with others or now having games that are virtually realities allowing someone to be something else but does not benefit the world in any way. The lack of benefit world is where virtual reality does its...

Words: 1102 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Soc230

...traditions of scientific research. -Ex. Copernician revolution, Newtonian dynamic (new version of the world-the change of paradigm ) -Ex. Theory of light -today (in the 1960): light is photon. Ie. Quantum-mechanical entities( Planck Einstein) -In the 19th century, light was transverse wave motion (young and Fresnel ) -during the 18th century, light was material corpuscles (Newton) -in each case, research proceed accordingly -Understanding assumptions -Ontological: what reality is -Epistemological: how to access to knowledge, how knowledge is defined -Define valid knowledge at a time- it is always link on social conventions. Knowledge is never pure knowledge. It is link to the time of what is the social context. -upon which, research problems and analysis are designed (the questions that we asked are always link to the two term) -accepted view of science, of scientific knowledge at a time and scientific methods -Competing paradigms -competing visions at any time -winner: never explain all the facts to which it is confronted but -Do the job more effectively, seems more promising recognized as an acute one. -More successful in solving a problem that is recognized as an acute one -becomes normal science (based on underlying accepted assumptions about...

Words: 3428 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

True Knowledge

...and that there perfect forms can be the object of true knowledge. Through out his work Plato makes the distinction between objects that are real and concepts that exist in our minds. To better understand this we have to look at the characteristics that Plato bases knowledge on. Throughout this his works, Plato was always concerned with one thing, which was epistemology. Epistemology deals with the possibilities and limits of human knowledge. It tries to answer such questions as: is the world as people perceive it the basic reality, or do people perceive only appearances that conceal basic reality? Knowledge may be regarded as having two parts. There is, first of all, what one perceives using the five senses. Next there is the way these perceptions are organized by the mind to form ideas or concepts. The problem is that epistemology is based on how philosophers have understood the relationship of the mind to the rest of reality. Through the Theory of Forms, Plato links mind and reality. For the average person, common sense says that there is a real world of perceivable objects. These objects can be analyzed and understood. Philosophers have not let the matter rest there. Plato thought that the real world consisted of universal ideas, the world that people actually see is given form by these ideas and is thus less real because it is always changing, but the ideas are eternal and unchangeable. Plato says that knowledge must be certain and unquestionable, it must be infallible...

Words: 728 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Scientific Point of View (Imaginative Case)

..._______________________________________________________________________________ CANDIDATE NUMBER: 130168 Term Paper COURSE NAME: Philosophies of Social Sciences COURSE NUMBER: TØL 4003 December 6th 2013 EXAM PAPER DUE DATE: EXAM: Term paper AIDS ALLOWED: Any Comparison of how the analytical and system perspective look at reality, using a case as example: replacing the propane gas system used for the furnaces in Frito Lay to use Natural Gas Introduction Frito Lay (FLD) is a cooking company that makes fry chips, which form part of the Pepsi corporation cluster. Pepsi is one company that is totally committed to be on the track towards sustainability, considering area of protections as water treatment, Greenhouse gases (GHG) emission, sustainable agriculture, water recycling, social responsibility and others with the intention of increasing revenues while reducing the environmental impact that it causes. And FLD as part of this group has been thinking of the opportunity to implement some sustainable features within the company that are to strive for the same objectives. One of the strategies that they considered is about replacing the propane gas that they are using as the combustible with natural gas1, which in some way is more ecofriendly to use, due to the lower level of CO2 emissions that the burning produce. However, to be able to take the decision if the replacement should be done or not, there are many factors to consider, like, how viable...

Words: 4948 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Descartes - Meditation on First Philosophy

...How Descartes Use Methodological Skepticism to Articulate a Foundationalist Conception of Knowledge Descartes is the first modern philosopher who rejects Aristotelianism and starts foundationalism, which is of great controversy but extreme importance in modern philosophy. In Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes utilizes methodological skepticism to present the foundationalist conception of knowledge, in which a belief can only be considered knowledge when it is based on basic principles, or principles that are justified without appealing to any external ideas or facts. Under the methodological skepticism, a person can test a belief by asking the question “Could it be false?” If the answer is “Yes,” the belief is not necessarily true and is not considered knowledge. This is the perfect tool for presenting a foundationalist conception of knowledge, unless there is an omnipotent being who can deceive people to think wrongly about these basic principles. Therefore, the existence of an omnipotent God and proof that God is not a deceiver is then presented in order to reject all doubts about the foundationalist conception of knowledge. A foundationalist conception of knowledge is a conception of academic discipline: one can only trust real knowledge that is based on basic principles. If a principle is wrong sometimes or is possibly wrong, it is not basic. If the principle is self-evident, showing its own truth, or is justified without appealing to any external ideas or facts...

Words: 1257 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Rationalism

...“Meno’s Paradox” that, “one logically cannot inquire productivity into what one does not already know” (Meno 58). Then Socrates continues to make Meno question his own beliefs when the slave recognizes the answer to geometrical problem. Socrates proceeds to confirm with the concept that the sole is immortal and the slave was “recollecting” knowledge that the soul already had. In Plato’s Meno his argument was with “recollection doctrine” of knowledge was already having the concept to begin with and people were just “recollecting” prior knowledge. Plato continues to argue rationalism through Phaedo with the Socratic Method. Plato uses his arguments in Phaedo using Socrates’ voice and other characters to explore rational arguments. It is only when the philosophers realize the truth, is when they will know the true knowledge, even if they didn’t exactly see it. There are different forms of recollection for example one is mathematics. Unlike rational objects, which Plato describes this is not a legitimate form of knowledge. All knowledge is innate, the concept that knowledge originates in the mind. The soul just has to seek for that knowledge. On the other hand, Descartes believed that if one didn’t have the concept of time, space, and numbers, one couldn’t have those experiences. In the first meditation, he uses an example of a painter that uses colors to represent the general things, and that other certain things that are similar are true. Descartes’ example of the painter shows...

Words: 719 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How Do We Know?

...think about it. How do we acquire knowledge? How do we know something to be true? Is it through experience or does it come from another realm in which we previously inhabited? Is everything we know and will learn in the future already mapped out for us? Throughout history man has sought out to answer these deeper questions and through philosophy they have begun to open their eyes to the universe in which we live. Answering question after question each philosopher perfecting the former theory and all of it leading up to the ultimate question the purpose of life. Epistemology is a form of philosophy that comes from the greek word for knowledge “episteme” and “logos” meaning explanation (chaffee 229) this encompasses the nature of knowledge and justification. It is through epistemology and metaphysics that philosophers attempt to othe answer questions like: can we ever really know anything? what is the difference between belief and knowledge? Can there be different “truths” for different people. or is “truth” the same for all? Pre-socratic philosophers used these ideas to lay the foundation for philosophy as we know it today. Plato, a student of Socrates, and as an ancient Greek philosopher he not only preserved Socrates teachings for future generations but also contributed original ideas on a wide range of issues such as morality, politics, metaphysics and epistemology. (chaffee 239) When trying to define ‘reality’, he proposed that reality is the eternal realm of the forms...

Words: 1390 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Allegory Of The Cave

...What is knowledge? Where did it come from? Knowledge is the familiarity gained by sight, experience, or report. Rationalists believed that there is an innate knowledge. We have ideas on certain things before we experience them. On the other hand, Empiricists believed that knowledge comes from experience. Whenever we experience something, there we get the knowledge. According to Plato, we have innate ideas. They are buried in the depth of our soul. Senses are only used to jog are memories about certain things. In the Allegory of the Cave, it shows that we, humans, are contented on what we see. We lack courage to know and explore reality. We are blinded by the things perceived by our senses. In contrast to Plato’s theory, Aristotle believed that...

Words: 396 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Phil 201 Study Guide 1

...Study Guide: Lesson 1 What is Philosophy? Lesson Overview Welcome to this introductory course in philosophy. For our first lesson, we are going to examine the question: What is philosophy? There are 4 ways you can get to know what a discipline is: define it, describe it, contrast and compare it with other disciplines, and finally experience it. In this first lesson, we will aim to accomplish the first 3 of these activities. The rest of the course will be an exercise in experiencing philosophy. Tasks View and take notes of the presentation, “Misconceptions about Philosophy”. Read and take notes from chapter 1 of Prelude to Philosophy: An Introduction for Christians, “What is Philosophy?” As you read, make sure you understand the following points and questions: • List 4 reasons students often presuppose a low view of philosophy. o They think you have to be super intelligent to do philosophy o Most students study it late in their academic development o Most people do not think philosophy is practical o They do not know what it is or how it can benefit them • Know Socrates’ quote: What is the unexamined life? What did he mean when he said it wasn’t worth living? o Socrates was saying that the unexamined life is when people go through the motions of life without making the effort to reflect and think about what life is about. When Socrates says the unexamined life is not worth living, he is saying that we are...

Words: 944 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Towards a Non-Western Perspective on Scientific Knowledge

...This article from PPST Bulletin is made available on-line by Samanvaya (www.samanvaya.com). All the rights of the article rest with the authors and any enquiries and clarifications may be directed to them. These are made available in an as-is basis, please report any mistakes to knowledge@samanvaya.com. TOWARDS A NON-WESTERN PERSPECTIVE ON SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE I The available studies on the phenomenon and institution of science suffer from a curious limitation. It is as if all those who analyse the subject were overawed by the grandeur of modern science, and their studies were in the nature of tributes laid at the feet of this great saviour. All analysis starts from the assumption that modern science is a set of value-free theories that uniquely explain reality. After the scientists in the early 20th century started overhauling their theories in a big way, it was granted that the value-free theories of science that explain reality may do so only partially at a given time, but as science progresses, its theories explain more and more of reality and the process converges towards the ‘ultimate’, ‘unique’ law that explains everything. Committed to this idealist picture of a unique value free science, the philosophy of science is reduced to a set of attempts at finding the epistemological criterion, internal to science, that allows the scientist, unencumbered by any extraneous considerations, to choose the true theory out of a competing set; the sociology of science is reduced to...

Words: 4795 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Knowledge Claims with Ontology and Epistemology

...Knowledge Claims Knowledge issues emerge from knowledge claims. These are claims about what we know. Researchers examine the knowledge claims about social world (Crotty 2003). They are of an ontological nature (the reality and character of things) and epistemological nature (how the knower discovers the knowledge about the reality). Ontology and epistemology Before researchers embark on their journey to explore social phenomena, they need to clarify what their ontological and epistemological stances are. Just as every project has its start and finish, so does academic research. The first stage of academic research is for inquirers to ask a research question, answers for which will be learnt using proper research methods. Researchers can go about answering the research question quantitatively, qualitatively or utilizing mixed methods. It is believed that while undertaking academic research, ontologies and epistemologies, also called paradigms, must be defined separately from research methods, although these constituents are interlaced and they shape each other (Crotty 2003; Guba and Lincoln 1994; Poetschke 2003; Scotland 2012; Grix 2002). The word ontology is derived from two Greek words meaning being and word. Ontology deals with the world and the question whether the reality exists regardless of our knowledge about it or not. There are two contrasting philosophical traditions: positivism looking at reality as being real, true and concrete and interpretivism looking at the...

Words: 1059 - Pages: 5