Free Essay

Labour Relations

In:

Submitted By shaha
Words 1536
Pages 7
Employment and Labour Law

(1) The Union is concerned that the Employer is not bargaining in good faith. Legal Arguments

For Union: | * The employer failed to bargain in good faith by refusing to meet; cancelling meetings, rescheduling meetings, not giving the negotiating team any power to bargain, surface bargaining, deliberate provocation, refusing to justify a position, (Olivio, 2013) * Section 17 of the OLRA states that the parties must have the true decision maker at the table. (Olivio, 2013). The negotiating team was included more junior members of the human resource department. * Surface bargaining is evident as the employer agrees to meet and discuss the issues but a real effort was not made to reach an agreement when the employer withdrew several concessions it had made without any explanation. | For Employer: | - According to Section 17 of the Ontario Labour Relations Act, the parties must meet within 15 days after the notice to bargain has been given or they must agree on a later meeting time. (Olivio, 2013)- Section 16 of the Ontario Labour Relations Act states that once the union is certified or voluntarily recognized, it must give notice to the employer to bargain. (Olivio, 2013)- Section 65 of the Act says that if the union fails to do so within 60 days, it risks being decertified because it is “sleeping on its rights”. Also according to section 65 of the act, if the union fails to give notice to bargain for renewal in accordance with the OLRA or the collective agreement, the employer may apply to terminate the union’s bargaining rights because it has abandoned this workplace. (Olivio, 2013) |
Legal Merits
According to the facts and legal arguments provided, I believe the union might win this particular issue as the employer took part of bad faith bargaining. The employer was evident of refusing to meet with the union by cancelling and rescheduling meetings, which was a vibrant example of bad faith bargaining. Both parties should bargain in good faith and make every reasonable effort to make a collective agreement. The employer refused to make every reasonable effort to enter into a collective agreement. Both the employer and the union disobeyed section 17 of the Act in this section. As the employer’s negotiating team was changed and included more junior members, it does not follow having true decision makers at the table. The new members are not familiar of the previous collective agreement. Also, the union and the employer encountered bad faith bargaining by not meeting to discuss the bargaining. As the employer withdrew many concessions without explanation it had caused the union to act upon it. This had affected the negotiations between both parties massively. The union can definitely win this argument because their points are much stronger, as the employer started off by refusing to meet up, added junior members and failed to justify the changes made to concessions. Potential Remedies
In a situation that consists of bad faith bargaining, the remedies are; "order by court, declaration, posting decision, and monetary rewards." (Lomic, 2015) Also the union can seek a third-party determination, an interest arbitration to distinguish each party’s rights.
(2) The Employer is questioning if the strike is legal
Legal arguments For Union: | * Conciliation has taken place and not resulted in a new agreement. * Under Section 79 of the Act, more than 50% of the voters must be in favour of the strike. 89% of the members voted to strike. (Olivio, 2013) * The collective agreement should have expired for the strikes to be permitted. As the agreement expires March 1st, the employees went on strike March 2nd, which is acceptable. | For Employer: | * No strikes are permitted during the term of a collective agreement. As the collective agreement had expired on March 1st, no strikes are permitted during the term of a collective agreement. On December 7th, the union instructing its members not to show up for the next day, is a form of illegal striking, which violates the OLRA. (Olivio, 2013) * The minister of labour must have issued a decision that a conciliation board will not be appointed, a no board report should be issued for the legality of strike. (Olivio, 2013) * Also a cooling off period of fourteen days must have gone by after the issuing the no-board report. * Under Section 79 of the Act the union must have conducted a strike vote, which the earliest could be is 30 days before the agreement expires. The union voted on January 15th, which was more than 30 days before the expiry of agreement (March 1st). |

Legal Merits
I believe the strike is illegal as it fails to comply with numerous terms of the OLRA. Strike vote was taken on January 15th, 2015,which was over 30 days before the expiry of the agreement. The minister did not issue a no board report which violates the OLRA legality of the strike. A strike cannot be permitted until the expiration of the agreement, which was on March 1st. It was unlawful for the union to tell their employees not to show up on December 7th. The points are stronger towards the employers in this section, which concludes that the employees will win this argument.
Potential remedies
In result of an unlawful strike, the remedies that an employer can take are; Grevience of arbritration, breach and a conciliator must be hired to settle the differences between the parties and to come to agreeable terms. “Applying for Declaration of unlawful strikes, filing damages claim alleging unfair labour practice under s.96 of the act and disciplining the workers on illegal strike." (Olivio, 2013)
(3) The Employer would like to bring an interim injunction to stop the picketing by the tutors and systems technicians; Legal Arguments For Union: | - “The legal system in Canada recognizes picketing as a constitutionally protected freedom of expression” (Olivio, 2013). Picketers let people through if they requested to enter the building with some information about the strike.- The union engaged in primary picketing where striking workers set up picket lines outside property, which is permitted. It also falls under allied picketing, where the union demonstrates that a third party system technicians at Ex-cellent Tech had taken actions to directly assist by joining the picket lines while on duty. - There were no legal actions taken if the picketing was considered illegal; contacting higher authority. To get interim injunction, the employer has to show that it had made reasonable efforts to get the police to stop the picketing. The employer did not make a motion to the Supreme Court of justice requesting an injunction, which must have been given two days notice to the union, under section 102(8) (b) of the Courts of justice Act. | For Employee: | * An assumption of damages of property and violent behavior were mentioned, as there were two reports of cars with paint scratches by keys anticipated by picketers. * Many of these small to medium businesses are located in the office building where E-xcellent Learning is located, so this will not only affect the private college, but also anyone who uses this environment. * Under section 101 and 102 of the Courts of Justice Act, the court has the power to order a union to stop picketing, or to order the union to picket a certain distance from the entrance. * The other groups which are affected would be the tenants and clients /customers who use the same location where the picketing occurs. There were complaints by tenants who were clients of Ex-cellent Tech, complaining that there were loss of customers. |

Legal Merits Picketing is a form of freedom of expression in the legal system (Olivio, 2013). The employer can bring an interim injunction to stop the picketing by the tutors and system technicians as the union had picketed in an illegal manner. Picketing is restricted if it affects the public to go and come freely. The complaints by clients of loss of customers and the use of the same location causes disturbance to the tenants can lead to causing an injunction. Although the picketing allowed people to enter the building, it was assumed to cause damages to vehicles according to two verified reports. Furthermore, action by the police should have been taken in order to issue an interim injunction. Hence, it is proven that an interim injunction can be made by the employer as it was seen as an illegal strike.
Potential Remedies

As the picketing becomes illegal due to the legality of the strike, the court has power to force a union to end the picketing, or to order the union to picket a certain distance from the entrance. The tenants and clients /customers are affected by picketing sharing the same location where the picketing occurs causes harm to their business. The picketers should cover expenses caused by the damages to the economy and the employer should come to conclusions with the union. Both parties must agree to a collective agreement for the picketing to end and issuing an interim injunction.
References
1. Olivio,L.& McKeracher, P.(2013). Negotiating a Collective Agreement. In Labour Relations: The Unionized Workplace. Toronto: Emond Montgomery Publications Ltd. 2. Lomic P(2015) Chapter 4: Negotiating a Collecting Agreement (Class Powerpoints)

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Labour Relations

...INTRODUCTION According to current scenario, working relationships comprise the relationship between employers and employees in unionized workplaces, or those who could unionize, and laws that affects the workplace. This includes processes and rules related to collective bargaining. The government provides a fair and balanced framework of labor relations and dispute settlement. With policy development and analysis of trends and issues of labor relations, the government provides facilitation and education, dispute resolution services and information for collective bargaining. The Canadian Labour Congress is releasing this study to show just how much better the union advantage truly is – both nationally and in 30 communities across the country. This study shows that in Canada on an average, unionized workers get almost $5 more an hour than non-union workers. A union is a group of workers who come together for making collective decisions about their work and working conditions. There is a democratic union in which the members elect the leaders through voting process. With the help of collective bargaining, these leaders negotiate with the employer in terms of wages, safety, working conditions, hours, and other benefits, on behalf of the members. The rights of unionized workers may vary extensively depending on the country, region and industry. Also rules, regulations and laws can also be amazingly complex. These rights are constantly evolving, and state governments adopt national...

Words: 1566 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Labour Relations

...MANAGEMENT ADVANCEMENT PROGRAMME 120 LABOUR RELATIONS INDIVIDUAL ASSIGNMENT Facilitator : Mrs Vanessa Botha Student Name : Carine Sanama Student Number: 1311024 Date : Monday 29 June 2015 Words Count: 1189 Table of Contents i. Executive Summary ii. Introduction and Background iii. Literature Review a. Definition of Terms b. The Evolution of the South African Labour Relations : Pre and Post-Apartheid c. The right to strike in South Africa : Legal VS Illegal iv. Discussions v. Conclusion vi. References Appendix 1 I. Executive Summary The rising number of labor strikes in South Africa should be a wake-up call the government. They should take the following into consideration so the improve on the country socio-economic state: First, look at labor markets with a renewed interest to revise laws governing the role and powers accorded to collective bargaining unions with a view to streamline them. Second, revise minimum wages, wage increases and dispute resolution policies in line with the latest economic developments in the country and international standards to ensure fairness and equity. Third, ensure that negotiations involving unions that represent essential emergency professionals do not break down and go to strike since people’s lives could be at stake. Finally, deliberately incorporate wage increase policies in the national budgeting process. These reforms would go a long way in minimizing the growing number of strikes...

Words: 1508 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Labour Relations Challenges of Today

...Labour Relations Challenges of Today Currently in Canada, there are approximately 4.7 million unionized workers. Although this accounts for 31.5% of workers, this membership count has been diminishing across our Country. Employer and government pressures to accept wage freezes and reduced benefits are taking its toll on all unions in general. Some universal challenges that unions face today are listed below. 1. Competition: Global markets have put considerable pressure on unions. Many products are being manufactured in other countries for a fraction of the cost; specifically when being compared to unionized factories in a developed country with much higher labour costs. Due to minimal union presence in under developed countries and extremely low fabrication costs, foreign competition has become quite the challenge. 2. Technology: Technology has changed the content of several existing jobs. “Touch Labour” is quickly diminishing due to today’s state of the art machinery, robotics and automation. As a result, workers are forced to expand their skill levels and adapt to new roles. For example, in the mining industry, which is known to have large union membership presence, positions have changed drastically. In the 1960s it took approximately 10 men an entire week to move one ton of ore to surface. It is estimated that today, 1 man & 1 scoop could complete this task in 2 hours. This “ONE” task has eliminated how many jobs? Has caused strong unions to lose how many members...

Words: 770 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Labour Relation Assignment

...shift but, but he didn’t advise his supervisor that he would be absent. Absenteeism in the plant averages six shifts a year. The company has noticed a significant deterioration in Peter’s performance over the past four years and it is getting progressively worse. There seems to be a pattern of Monday and Friday absences and there are strong and persistent rumours from other employees and supervisors that Peter’s breath smells of alcohol on a regular basis. When Peter is at work, his mood swings are totally unpredictable. Some employees have even gone so far as to complain to management about Peter’s absenteeism, attitude and performance suggesting that his behaviour is disruptive to the entire workforce. The newly appointed Labour Relations Manager is Bob Graham. His first directive from senior management is to get rid of Peter Frost. Bob reviews Peter’s file and, to his horror he discovers that...

Words: 323 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Labour Relations

...Chapter 16: Labour Relations Labour union: an officially recognized association of employees practicing a similar trade or employed in the same company or industry who have joined together to present a united front and collective voice in dealing with management. -the purpose of unionization are to influence HR policies and practices that affect bargaining unit members such as pay and benefits. Labour- management relations: the ongoing interactions between labour unions and management in organizations -managerial discretion and flexibility in dealing with employees and in implementing and administering HR policies/procedures are reduced. Collective agreement (union contract): a formal agreement between an employer and the union representing a group of its employees regarding terms and conditions of employment. Collective bargaining: negotiations between a union and an employer to arrive at a mutually acceptable collective agreement -an organization’s labour relations strategy, one component of its HR strategy, is its overall plan for dealing with unions, which sets the tone for its union-management relationships. -union acceptance strategy- view the union as the legitimate representative of the employees. -union avoidance strategy- prefer to operate in a non unionized environment. (Walmart) -to avoid unions, companies can either adopt a: -union substitution approach- become so responsive to employees’ needs that there is no incentive for them to unionize ...

Words: 2233 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

The History of Human Resource Management

...immigrants, recruitment and management of individuals gained vitality. Managers were higher than the employees. This system created a gap between the labour force and the management. Social welfare approached in the early HRM helped the immigrants to get adjusted to their jobs and to 'American' way of life. The programs was assigned to ensured an increase in productivity. In the 1790s, employees empower considerably and increased at a quick pace .In the 1800s and 1900s the advent of Labour Union led HR department more capable in politics and diplomacy. HR department has management, labour unions, and Frederick W. Taylor's (1856-1915) theory of 'Scientific Management'. In 1902, National Cash Register was formed to handle employee grievances, record keeping, wage management and other employee-related functions. In 1913, the US Department of Labour promoted the welfare of employees. In 1920s and 30s, the impact of the Hawthorne studies enhanced the physical work conditions for employees changes from workers' efficiency to efficiency through work satisfaction. In 1938, the Fair Labour Standards Act provided security and helped increased the standard of the employees. Since then, the welfare of workers have more new and efficient laws. Therefore, human relations became a prominent feature of organizational behaviour. The National Labour...

Words: 522 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Industrial Court History

...The Industrial Court is a non-departmental tribunal from the public body with legal powers. It was initially established in 1919 to provide settlement for industrial disputes and it still provide voluntary arbitration role. It also has a constitutional power about taking decisions between trade unions and employers or the management. The Industrial court is also known as the labour court. According to the Industrial Court Act in Mauritius the Industrial court is established by section 3 of the Industrial Court Act. The Industrial Court is composed of two Magistrates who are appointed by the Judicial and Legal Service Commission. The industrial law has some other powers that is any worker facing any difficulties at work can apply to the magistrate...

Words: 1068 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Industrial Relations in India

...Industrial Relations in India Introduction The relationship between the employers, employees, trade unions and the government is called Industrial Relations. India is an emerging economy and the large informal sector poses a big challenge. 94% of our work force is in the informal sector where implementation of labour laws is difficult. Harmonious relationship is necessary for both the employers and employees to safeguard the interests of both the parties of production and all the other stakeholders. Evolution of IR in India The first phase (1947 to 1966): It was a time of import-substitution industrialization and national capitalism. Large employment-intensive public enterprises were forming and largely centralized bargaining with static real wages. The public sector unionism was growing and industrial relation was majorly Government controlled and regulated. The second phase (1967 to 1980): The employment growth was slowing down and real wages were declining. The IR system faced a major crisis during this phase. There were massive strikes, industrial conflicts, multiple unionism and decline in strength. The government was losing control over the IR system. The third phase (1981 to 1991): This was a period of ‘jobless growth’. The ‘independent’ enterprise unionism was rising and several city/ regional IR systems were operating. The government was slowly withdrawing from IR system. The post-reform decade (1992-2007): About 15% of the workforce (approximately 1.1 million) lost...

Words: 856 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Hr Negotiation Process

...1. Labour or Industrial Relations. The term labour relations, also known as industrial relations, refers to the system in which employers, workers and their representatives and, directly or indirectly, the government interact to set the ground rules for the governance of work relationships. It also describes a field of study dedicated to examining such relationships. The field is an outgrowth of the industrial revolution, whose excesses led to the emergence of trade unions to represent workers and to the development of collective labour relations. A labour or industrial relations system reflects the interaction between the main actors in it: the state, the employer (or employers or an employers’ association), trade unions and employees (who may participate or not in unions and other bodies affording workers’ representation). The phrases “labour relations” and “industrial relations” are also used in connection with various forms of workers’ participation; they can also encompass individual employment relationships between an employer and a worker under a written or implied contract of employment, although these are usually referred to as “employment relations”. There is considerable variation in the use of the terms, partly reflecting the evolving nature of the field over time and place. There is general agreement, however, that the field embraces collective bargaining, various forms of workers’ participation (such as works councils and joint health and safety committees) and mechanisms...

Words: 2478 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Rana Plaza

...Role of labour and industrial laws are of paramount importance. We know that the total economy of a country greatly depends upon the industrial sector. In addition, the growth of the industrial sector involves with some major aspect. These major aspects are the local investment policy, foreign direct investment policy, labour management etc. Besides the necessary infrastructure for investment natural resources are also important and it is very clear that if all these essential elements are not available then growth of industrial sector is unfeasible. Besides all these things labour issues are also very important. Proper management of labour is an essential matter for growth of industrial sector. Timely disposal of labour disputes are also important. We see that in most of the cases the labour law disputes do not solve with in short time. So the remedy which is essential from the case becomes delayed. The labour law is very much important in Bangladesh perspective. It is highly important for the industrial development of Bangladesh. We know that labour is a most important part of an industry. So, we can not think an industry with out labour. Labour right is most essential in Bangladesh. But the labours are in ignorance about their right. They don’t know properly about labour laws and education. It is a great problem. For this reason, they retrenched by the employee. Very often, they retrenched with out any legal process. Labour Laws in Bangladesh: In Bangladesh 47 labour laws are...

Words: 3909 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Idrl 308 Assignment 4

...issued a lockout notice to the workers at their plant on December 02, 1993, and all of the issues surrounding what happened next. The case raises a lot of questions and I will try to expand on my answers to those questions. One of the questions asked in this assignment was whether a strike or lockout ends a collective agreement. A strike or lockout cannot legally take place until a collective agreement has expired. While negotiations are taking place, there is a bridging provision that extends the collective agreement for a period of time. So essentially, after a collective agreement expires, it is still in effect as long as both sides are negotiating. A strike or lockout ends that collective agreement bridge. According to the Alberta Labour Relations Board, “the bridging provisions of Section 130 that extended the collective agreement during negotiations terminate.” “Employers may choose to lockout their employees for a short period of time as a way to end the bridging provisions of Section 130 and thereby apply additional pressure on the union to settle the dispute. Although commonly called a “24-hour lockout”, there is no minimum duration required for a lockout and, in Ironworkers 850 v. Western Archrib [1998] Alta.L.R.B.R. 90, the Board ruled the employer had entered a state of lockout without any interruption in work.” The next question asks whether an employer can unilaterally impose terms and conditions of employment once a lockout action ends a collective agreement. The...

Words: 836 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Essay

...“The last 25-30 years has seen major changes in the context of employee relations within UK organisations. The factors that have had the most significant influence on these changes are political, economic, social and technological of which I will be discussing to identify what particular influences these factors have had on employee relations over the last 25-30 years. To do this I first need to define the meaning of employee relations, which can be defined as according to Rose (2004):“the study of the regulation of the employment relationship between employer and employee, both collectively and individually and the determination of substantive and procedural issues at industrial organisational and workplace levels.” (Rose, 2004 p.8)There are a number of political factors that have had a significant influence on employee relations over the last 25-30 years such as the influence of the Conservative government from 1979-1997, which included a decline in trade unions, new acts and legislations put in place, and the emergence of the Labour government from 1997 to the present day which has also brought a number of changes to the employee relations context. The Conservative government has had a significant influence on employee relations in terms of changes to the legal framework of labour law. These changes involved the relationships between the employer and employee, the employer and the union and the relationship between the union and the membership. In regards to the employer and...

Words: 453 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Apple

...Available online at www.managementjournal.info RESEARCH ARTICLE Industrial Relations System as a Factor of Tripartite Consultation Influencing the Performance of State Corporations in Kenya Nzioki S*, Mukulu E Department of Human Resource Management, School of Human Resource Development, Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology (JKUAT), Kenya. *Corresponding Author: Email: sknzioki@yahoo.com Abstract The study sought to establish the effect of Industrial relations system in Kenya on the performance of state corporations. Methodology: Data was obtained through a descriptive design involving 279 employees both unionized and non-unionized of state corporations in Nairobi County. A structured questionnaire with likert scale questions was used to collect data from the selected subjects of the study. Interviews were also conducted with human resource managers/ employee relations officers, shop floor union officials, officers of the Ministry of Labour, officers of Federation of Kenya Employers (FKE), officers of Central Organizations of Trade Unions, Kenya. The study used the Dunlop’s systems model credited with the application of the systems approach to Industrial Relations (IR). The model explains the input acquisition, input transformation, output and feedback to explain the process of Kenyan Industrial Relations System. Finding: The study found that there existed a prescribed Industrial Relations System in Kenya, but its adherence had been faced with a lot of challenges...

Words: 6175 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

Case Study

...Keisler Drinks and Foods Incorporated (DKDF). DKDF produces a range of food and drinks products across the so-called “fast-moving consumer goods” spectrum of products. The DDI manufacturing site in southern Ireland is now also the DDI worldwide head quarters. At the DDI Irish site the firm employs around 1,300 staff. Of these 1,000 are factory-workers and 300 based in head office. The major DDI corporate support functions are located at head office including human resources, finance, marketing, sales, product development and logistics (shipping and distributions management). Most factory staff are members of the GWLU (General Workers Labour Union) whereas only about a third of the staff at head office are in a Labour Union. Union members at Head Office are represented by the Clerical and Office Labour Union (COLU). Employee Relations at DDI traditionally very good. This is partly because, in Ireland, industrial peace is managed through agreements which are negotiated within a National Programme for Economic Development framework. These programmes include major stakeholders like the large unions, employer representatives, government agencies and small firms. When issues do arise...

Words: 1501 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Globalization

...Chapter 5 COLLECTIVE BARGAINING: LEVELS AND COVERAGE* A. INTRODUCTION AND MAIN FINDINGS Industrial relations systems, operating at national, sectoral and local levels, play an important role in determining economic and labour market performance. They constitute a “web of rules” relating economic agents who, while pursuing their self-interests, generally find it beneficial to reach a degree of consent and some form of (more or less conflictual) co-operation. In providing procedures for consensus-building and conflict resolution, these arrangcments are shaped by specific national legislation and labour market conditions, and by each country’s prevailing attitudes towards work, conflict and co-operation. There are many ways to analyse systems of labour relations in OECD countries. For example, Chapter 4 of the 1991 Employment Outlook examined trade union density (the proportion of workers who are union members), and noted widely differing rates of unionisation across countries, ranging from around 10 per cent in France to over 80 per cent in Sweden. Union density is just one indicator of the character of a country’s industrial relations system. The extent to which employees are covered by collectivc agrccments concluded at various levels - national, regional, sectoral or company - is another important feature of the system by which wages and other employment conditions are set. In many countriec, workers who are not union members are in fact - through extension and enlargement...

Words: 11933 - Pages: 48