Free Essay

Let Them Eat Dog Essay

In:

Submitted By wasayshahid
Words 1015
Pages 5
A Man's Best Friend
A man's best friend is one that is always there for him through tough obstacles and hardships in life. George Orwell once stated, "All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." The relationship humans tend to have within the animal kingdom is not as civilized as it should be. When looking at it from a moral and religious perspective, humans should treat all animals equally. Statistics have shown that in developed countries such as the United States, animals such as dogs are treated far better than other animals. The question then arises, why do dogs get treated more diligently while other animals with the same mental capacity get slaughtered and consumed? By looking at "Let Them Eat Dog" by Jonathon Foer, the perception of why one should not think of dogs as superior animals and why the idea of consuming a dog should not be looked down upon in society will be thoroughly analyzed and examined.
People in the United States think it’s morally wrong to eat dogs since it is a household pet. The same people who don’t eat dogs, eat other animals such as pigs, chickens, and cows, which is questionable because they still devour animals that are necessary to the environment and society today. In "Let Them Eat Dog" by Jonathon Foer, the author gives logical reasons on why we should eat dog, and why it is not harmful to the society in any manner. It's legal in 44 states to eat dog, and dog meat poses no greater health risk than any other meat. The problem arises is that a dog is labeled as a "man's best friend". Therefore, it is merely wrong to even think of eating a dog in the United States. Because pets such as dogs and cats are considered to be valuable in an average American Household, statistics show that 3 to 4 million dogs and cats get put down every year. Furthermore, the brutal killing of cows and pigs in slaughter houses would decrease as well if it wasn't looked down upon to eat dogs.
Eating dogs would be economically and ecologically be beneficial for us. It would be economically beneficial for us because it would create business and there would be more meat in the industry. It would be ecologically beneficial since millions of dogs get put down yearly and we don’t do anything with their meat. If we consumed dog meat it would cause us to decrease slaughtering other animals for their meat. Due to reasons, including economic and ecological benefits, consuming reasonable dog meat would be safer and more beneficial to today’s society. Though people despise even thinking about consuming dog meat, it would be better for the society to do so because they are environmentally benefiting the world.
Dogs and pigs are similar in many ways. Both animals have the same level of intelligence, a handful of similar characteristics and a few traits in common. In 'Let Them Eat Dog" by Jonathon Foer, the author argues that pigs can basically do everything that dogs do, yet pigs are still treated unfairly compared to dogs. "They can't hop into the back of a Volvo, but they can fetch, run and play, be mischievous and reciprocate affection. So why don't they get to curl up by the fire? Why can't they at least be spared being tossed on the fire?" (428). Pigs are treated unfairly when compared to how similar they are to dogs. Both animals deserve to be treated fairly by all people, despite of their appearance. It is true that dogs are treated more fairly than pigs because they look better and are labeled as “man’s best friend”, but it is not necessarily true that they deserve that extra attention. Dogs and pigs both deserve to be treated equally because they share many similar traits and qualities.
People often argue they don't eat dog because they have "significant mental capacities". In "Let Them Eat Dog" by Jonathon Foer, the author states if that’s the reason then it would exclude severely impaired humans. Which concludes humans consuming less impaired humans. No human would even consider eating another human being due to their low IQ level. So the question that arises is why would one eliminate the idea of eating a dog due to its intelligence. Evidently, humans don’t stop from eating other animals that have the same intelligence as dogs, so they no reason to not consume a dog. "But unlike all farmed meat, which requires the creation and maintenance of animals, dogs are practically begging to be eaten" (429). With that being said, dogs are eaten all over the world in places such as the Philippines, Korea, China, and even Europe. Those countries keep dogs as pets just like the United States. The difference is it is not looked down upon to eat them in their society. They understand the value of meat and take full advantage of the situation. The problem with Americans is that they see dogs as “mans best friend” which is the fundamental reason they do not consume dog meat. They feel some kind of guilt building up in their body if they even think about doing such a deed because it seems so unjustified and wrong.
Overall, the American society should definitely look into the fact that consuming dog meat can be beneficial to their culture. Because many Americans who own pets such as dogs believe that those animals are a “man’s best friend”, they do not think about consuming them. However, in comparison to animals such as pigs and other farm cattle, dogs are equally as valuable. They should be consumed if the people feel like it is a necessary deed. The American society needs to understand that it cannot put special labels on animals they like and animals they don’t like. All animals need to be treated fairly and the actions need to be justified.

Works Cited
Foer, Jonathon. “Let Them Eat Dog”. 75 Readings Plus. Ed. Santi Buscami. New York: McGraw. Hill, 2013. 428-430. Print

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Pets

...Contrast essay by Louise Hensley I love both my pets! Sosha which is a red-nosed Pit-bull, and then there is Lilbit and she is a German Shepard. These two breeds of animals have their own special unique qualities of their own. As for the Pit-bull breed they are known for their intelligence, strength, and loyalty. They have also been marked for centuries now for their violence and aggressiveness towards people and other animals. They get their name from the Molossian family of dogs, which bear the name from the Molossi Tribe, which is a group of people who lived in Ancient Greece, and they favored the use of robust, muscular dogs in warfare. They are reknowned for their fierceness, and for the ability to intimidate the enemies of the tribe. The Greece later began to sell these dogs to Rome which they used to cross breed with their counterparts from the year 50 A.D to 410 A.D. and then was used for entertainment in the arenas and coliseums of Rome. Once in Rome the British dogs were sold to the Englishman, when they left to go back home the Englishmen took their dogs with them and this is how they ended up in the United States. Even though Sosha is a Pit-bull, she is nothing like they say, she is very well trained and mild mannered. Lilbit is a German Shepard and their breed is known for their largeness, intelligence, strength, and their ability in training. They were used to work in the fields for sheep herding. Also, because of their intelligence and obedience training they...

Words: 712 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Amur Leopard Research Paper

...the African Wild Dog. They populate various spots of southeastern Africa. The human settlements in developing countries there tend to be heavily dependent on agriculture. This is a problem. The African Wild Dog sees the livestock in these settlements as easy prey, which is an opportunity they act upon. Humans don?t like it when other animals eat their food, so, BANG! They shoot them. Or kill them in some other fashion. However, the same livestock initially came from the wild, where the dogs hunted. As a result, the African Wild Dog is running out of prey to eat, and what remains is being warded off. As they grow desperate for food, they are liable to eat anything they think could be edible, things they normally would choose not to eat. With viral diseases being a prevalent natural threat in the area, the dogs are far more prone to infection as they weaken and attempt to push their boundaries, or reclaim the ones we took. This has all reduced the African Wild Dog population to a range between 3,000 and 5,000, though it is difficult to be precise. The World Wildlife Fund has been working to control the situation and help the dogs survive in an ample habitat. They have attempted to reduce the amount of hunting done in particular areas that the African Wild Dog roams, as well as come up with more efficient, non-lethal methods to keep the dogs away from human settlements. The situation isn?t in dire straits just yet, but they?re still on the endangered list, so let?s hope that this...

Words: 802 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Annie Dillard's Essay 'The Deer At Providencia'

...In the essay “The Deer at Providencia,” Annie Dillard illustrates her confusion and awareness of suffering that occurs around her in the world. Dillard begins the essay with explaining her trip to Ecuador, she and three other North Americans went on this trip. (MS 7) On this trip, Dillard realizes the suffering through a deer; thus, the meat of an animal begins to get tenderer the more you let it suffer. (MS 4) The village people tied up the deer so it gets tenderer, but in doing this they make it suffer. Dillard also experiences suffering through a burnt man. (MS 3) Throughout the essay, Dillard uses imagery, tone, and parallelism to describe her awareness and confusion about suffering. (MS 2) Dillard portrays excellent imagery in the narrative...

Words: 1074 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Botoy

...do we let fears control our lives? I never thought I would ever get over my own fears. These fears made my childhood very difficult and hard to deal with. However for me as a young child, I was afraid of dogs, falling, and the darkness. Being afraid of dogs was one of my biggest fears. One day I was walking down the street from school and I felt like I had walked upon one of the biggest dogs I had ever seen. The dog stood behind a gate taller than I. It looked at me standing there nerves and shaking. As I look at his sharp teeth and him foaming at the mouth as if I was a full course meal. As he started to bark I felt something warm run down my leg. Every time a dog would bark at me I get scared. Another big fear of mine was a fear of leaves. There are a lot of things out there to be afraid of, and there seem to be phobia about falling of the of the roof or a bridge. As I got older, my parents told me to look down whenever I was surrounded by leaves and jump up and down and crash them all. And it would be just like killing them. It took me a long time to get over my fear but it worked. I am also afraid of the dark. I could not sleep in my room without leaving the light on. When I went to sleep in the dark, I started to imagine things like monsters and other things that would scare me. To me a monster was something that would eat you alive and not care. I was afraid that it would write my parents a note with my blood on the wall, and tell them that...

Words: 453 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Rough Draft

...Breaking up Essay We have been together for a long period of time but it is not working out. I have tried and tried to make things better between us but it seems it is not working. Even other people with common sense know that we are not compatible with each other. You have oppressed my decisions and never talk about our problems and that is what causes our relationship to wither away. Therefore, we should separate and meet other people because obviously going down the drain. You have given me stress. You have never iron my clothes. You have never washed the dishes. You never let me watch my shows. You have eaten my dog. We have tried to talk to the psychiatrist about your problem but you never cooperated. You are a smelly donkey who never cares about others but yourself. I have token you to the mental hospital but you always run out. I have brought you to the doctor and I would tell him “My girlfriend is broken can you fix it?” I have given you sleeping pills to calm yourself down but you never took them. I have tried to give you your shot but you would try and stab me with it. I have tried to keep you still by massaging you with a rock. After many times of being not respected for all I do I decided to break up. After breaking up with you I get to buy a new dog, eat without being harassed, watch TV without someone screaming, and finally sleep without being woken every 10 minutes. And now I am only going to trust my new dog, Chico, as my new...

Words: 284 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Docx

...Running head: Vietnamese and English idioms related to the word “Dog”: Vietnamese and English idioms related to the word “Dog”: A contrastive Analysis Student: Nguyen Le Hoang Yen Class: 4A08 Ho Chi Minh City University of Pedagogy Contrastive Analysis Instructor: Mr. Nguyen Ngoc Vu December 31, 2011 Abstract One problem which makes a lot of people have difficulty in communicating with one another is to use idiomatic expressions. As far as you know, idiomatic expressions make English become colorful and full of vitality, so they are often used very much in the native speakers’ speech and in the writing such as news, songs, movies, etc. on the television. However, these idioms are sometimes are not easy to understand and study their meanings, so I decide to study them by studying Vietnamese and English idioms containing the word ‘dog’ and one another reason for this topic to study is that I really like lovely dogs. In my studying this topic, there are two parts such as theoretical background and Vietnamese and English idioms related to the word ‘dog’ which is the main part of my topic. Theoretical background Idioms versus proverbs Idioms and proverbs are frequently used in the daily speech, so we can not find the differences between them clearly. However, we can distinguish idioms and proverbs by basing on some criteria. Idioms * It is a fixed group of words. e.g. the idiom ‘chó chui gầm chạn’ has the same meaning of the word ‘hèn hạ’ (disgraced)....

Words: 4421 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Never Be the Same

...Nicholas Campbell 9/24/12 Essay 1 English 101 One of the biggest, and most emphasized themes in “We3” is that of human qualities existing in non-human characters. We see three animals that have been altered with by the government and turned into killing machines. However we see many things that indicate that despite their human capabilities, they still show many qualities of regular animals of their respective species. One of the clearest examples of this is in the second chapter on the twenty-ninth page. Here we see 1 after he and 2 attacked, and ultimately killed a human and his dog. They attacked after the man shot 3, and the dog tried to protect his owner. 1 went immediately for the human while 2 took care of the attacking dog. In these panels, we see 1 practically beating himself up for what he did. He is sitting there with his eyes closed and his head down, which is typically pretty clear body language for somebody that is sad or upset about something. This goes along with the theme I mentioned earlier because people don’t usually think of animals as having the capability to be upset about their actions. Remorse is ordinarily thought of as being a quality that us humans have, but one that animals would not possess. In the panel 1 continues to repeat “Bad dog, bad dog, bad dog” which shows that he is disappointed in his own actions and that it is bothering him that he had to do what he did to the man. It is the only thing that is on his mind, even when...

Words: 1049 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

If the Death of Candy's Dog Was Right or Wrong

...In this essay I’m going to be talking about the death of Candy’s dog was right or wrong. The death of Candy’s caused a major controversy between the readers and some of the characters in the book. In my opinion I strongly believe that the death of Candy’s dog was right, due to the fact that the dog is ‘no good’ to the farm and even to candy as Carlson stated. Evidence to support this is that Carlson said ‘the ol’ dog jus’ suffers hiself all the time’. This connotes that the dog is old, exhausted and in pain,(which means it suffering) so it would be only be in the dogs best interest by putting it out its misery as it would eventually die soon. If I had a pet and it was elderly and diseased, I would have it put to sleep because I’m only doing it in my dog’s best interest. However, many readers could argue that it was wrong to kill candy’s dog as it was candy’s dog, so candy should make the decision of killing his dog. Even though candy was being reluctant to killing his dog, the final decision was his and no one to make it for him. For instance, after the dog was shot candy told George that he "ought to have shot that dog myself”. This implies that, after the dog was shot candy realised that he shouldn’t have let a stranger like Carlson kill his dog that he has been with for a long time, because he has “had him since he was a pup”. Also, It foreshadowed the end of the story, which was that George would shoot Lennie instead of letting a "stranger" (the other ranch hands, namely...

Words: 1082 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Eating Sugar

...Engelsk – Essay Task A The text Eating Sugar is a shortstory written by Catherine Merriman. The story takes place in a forest in Thailand during the Song Khran, which is the Thai New Year holiday and it takes place in April. The story is about an English family of three: Alex, the father, Eileen, the mother and Suzanne, the daughter. Alex and his wife Eileen had travelled to Thailand to visit their daughter Suzanne, who is an English teacher. They went inside a forest to look for a market, but the market was no longer there when they got there, so they decided to go back, but instead they got lost. Alex and Eileen were both afraid, especially when four Thai men showed up in the forest, but their daughter Suzanne were just calm and mature. She took care of her parents and talked to the natives they met in the forest, trying to get her and her parents a ride back to the city. There is definitely something about role reversal here, which Catherine Merriman also says. “There had been a role reversal here. Suzanne, their brace twenty-one-year old daughter transformed [...] to a competent, patient encouraging parent. He (red. Alex) and Eileen her anxious, fractious dependent charges.”[1] Alex is the only man in the family (at least that we know of). When a man is alone with his wife and daughter, of course he feels like he needs to protect them from every possible danger. That is also why Alex wants to seem tough on the outside, not showing that he is afraid, even though he...

Words: 1178 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Socialist

...her distinguished teaching career. Her books include Philosophy in a New Key: A Study of the Symbolism of Reason, Rite, and Art (1942), Feeling and Form (1953), and Mind: An Essay in Human Feeling (1967). In the following essay, which originally appeared in Ms. Magazine, Langer explores how language separates humans from the rest of the animal kingdom. She contends that the use of symbols – in addition to the use of signs that animals also use – frees humans not only to react to their environment but also to think about it. Moreover, symbols allow us to create imagery and ideas not directly related to the real world, so that we can plan, imagine, and communicate abstractions – to do, in essence, the things that make us human. 1 gesticulate the point. He would make his wishes known, give warnings, perhaps develop a social system like that of bees and ants, with such a wonderful efficiency of communal enterprise that all men would have plenty to eat, warm apartments – all exactly alike and perfectly convenient – to live in, and everybody could and would sit in the sun or by the fire, as the climate demanded, not talking but just basking, with every want satisfied, most of his life. The young would romp and make love, the old would sleep, the middle-aged would do the routine work almost unconsciously and eat a great deal. But that would be the life of a social, superintelligent, purely sign-using animal. 5 To us who are...

Words: 2742 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Speaking for Ielts

...Vocabulary for IELTS Speaking: Part 1 SPEAKING PART 1: 1. DESCRIPTION QUESTIONS: (Strategy: divide into 2 or 3 parts) Sample answer Tell me something about your hometown? Well as you can probably guess I come from Taipei and I have lived here all my life, although at the moment I’m studying in another city – Taizhong. I suppose if I had to describe Taipei, the first thing I would say is that it’s very crowded, maybe even one of the biggest cities in Asia I guess. It’s so congested that even the locals have problems finding their way around! Another significant characteristic is that it offers splendid examples of contemporary architecture. Actually some of the renowned landmarks are in the middle of Taipei, such as the Taipei 101, the second tallest building in the world. | Well, the main thing you need to know is that…(1) + (details)… On top of that I can also add that (2)…+ (details)… Something else that I need to say is that (3)…so actually…(detail) Starting-off Ok, then; actually; alright; well, you know; Point 1 The first thing I’d like to mention is … The main thing you need to know is … I’d like to begin by highlighting the fact … Point 2 In addition I suppose I should say … Another interesting point … Not only that, but _______is also exceedingly ….. Point 3 And I shouldn’t forget to mention that… I guess I could also say that (it’s) sort-of …….. Finally I’d also like to mention …….. Practice: Tell me something about your...

Words: 3222 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Personal Responsibility

...telling us to get out of bed to get ready for work or to go to class. On the other hand, personal responsibility is the acceptance of failure to accomplish the task that we are obligated to. As a college level student, we know that part of our responsibility is to read assigned materials, complete task on time and take part in classroom discussions at the very least. Failure to complete these tasks ultimately could result in dismissal from a chosen program and a delay educational goals. One strategy for overcoming the pressures of student life is time/self-management. At the college level the student is held accountable for his or her education. This means no excuses. It does not matter that the dog “ate your homework”. Had you made time to feed the dog he may not have chosen to eat the homework instead. Time management does not mean to give all your energy and focus to only working on school assignments. It simply means to designate time for completing these tasks. Creating a to-do list whether it be on notebook paper, post-it notes, or using my personal favorite, apps on cell phones are great ways to keep account of what needs to be completed and allows you to organize and prioritize your task. “We tend to give top priority to what we enjoy studying, yet the courses that we find most difficult often require the most creative energy” (Ellis, 2011)....

Words: 1009 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

How Children Should Be Raised

...text. Taking your starting point in one of the texts, discuss how children should be raised. Texts Page 2 1. Sophia Chua-Rubenfeld, "Why I love my strict Chinese mom", a newspaper report by Mandy Stadtmiller from The New York Posl website,2}ll Kate Loveys, "Let them eat pizza: Parenting guru's recipe for bringing up children", a newspaper article from The Daily Mail website, May 16,20lI . 2. . 5 a J "Summerhill's General Policy Statement", an extract from A.S. Neill's book Summerhill a radical approach to child reåring, 1960 7 B Write an essay (700-1000 words) in which you analyse and interpret Debi Alper's short story "How Lucky You Are". Your essay must include the following points: - the main theme - a characterization of Max and Ishraqi - the way the short story is structured - Max's relationship with his parents - the setting Têxt Debi Alper, "How Lucky You Are", a short story, 2010 Page 8 Side 2 af 12 sider A TEXT 1 SoPhia Chua-Rubenfeld Why I love mY strict Chinese mom 18-year-oldSophiaChua-Rubenfeldsayshermother,s..toughlove',parentingmethods opportunities' an independent thinker who makes the most of new raised her to be tive essaY, "WhY Chinese Mothers t Journal earlier this month' the ids' "how Chinese parents raise such...

Words: 4822 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

Time Capsule

...what life was like in the year 2013/2014 for me. My daily routines would start like this: I would wake up at 7am to start my routines. This includes cleaning my house, taking my two dogs outside, eating and doing my school work. While doing my school work I would listen to love songs from the 80’s to relax and concentrate (Perry, 2014). At present, I am enrolled into Kaplan University online pursuing my Bachelors in Psychology. During my day, I have to read my books and post to the discussion boards and comment to two classmates’ posts with minimum 250 words. I also have to attend one seminar a week for one hour online with my classmates and the Professor. During the ten week course we have three essays due, so I am constantly working on them early. Once my school work is over, however, I spend my time surfing the internet such as, Facebook, Yahoo mail, and playing games online. On the weekends I am more active with working out and walking, and spending time with my family. I believe to have a positive balance in my life is by staying in shape (Perry, 2014). In 2013/2014, in our society we judge people by the way they look, I have heard people say if you are fat that means you are poor. When I asked what they meant they stated the reason people are fat is because they are lazy and they eat cheap food that is filled with fat. They also stated they are fat because they do not care for their body. People also think that if you are thin, you will be liked and respected, if...

Words: 1275 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Reseach Paper

...RECRUITMENT TO POSTS IN GRADES 17 & 16 UNDER THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, 1971 ENGLISH ESSAY Maximum marks: 100 C SS .C O M .P Note: Write an essay in ENGLISH on ONE of the following: 1. Man as part of a design infinitely vaster than himself. 2. Knowledge demands love as its complement. 3. The amusement mania. 4. The art of feature films made in Pakistan. 5. Art and Religion. 6. Education of freedom. 7. Brain-washing. 8. The lessons of the past. 9. Requisites for social progress in Pakistan. 10. How words change our lives? 11. Man is condemned to be free. 12. Leaders and followers. K Time allowed: 3 hours ENGLISH ESSAY EXAMINATION 1972 Maximum marks: 100 C SS .C O M .P Write an essay in English on One of the following: 1. Relevance of Islam to Science. 2. The sanctity of law. 3. Competitive results of planned economy? 4. The sick soul. 5. The strategy of political warfare. 6. “If’ in History. 7. Psychology and its social meaning. 8. Reverence for life. 9. International morality. 10. The divided self and the process of its unification. 11. Statesmen and Diplomatists. 12. The foundations of the feature. K Time allowed: 3 hours ENGLISH ESSAY EXAMINATION 1973 Time allowed: 3 hours Maximum marks: 100 1. (a) Make an outline for writing an Essay in English on One of the following subjects: (b) Write the Essay on the subject you have selected more or less on the basis of the Outline you have...

Words: 4558 - Pages: 19