Premium Essay

Mentor Mentee Relationship Analysis

Submitted By
Words 1008
Pages 5
Mentoring relationships can be tricky. From creating the right mentor-mentee pair to considering liability issues to ensuring the success of a mentor-mentee relationship, this process is highly individualized and intricate. Mentoring is further complicated when considering creating mentor-mentee pair across different backgrounds: socio-economic, racial, ethnic, gender and sexual identity and such. In this reference guide, I shall focus on exploring issues related to intra- and cross-racial mentoring, from things to consider before making matches to carrying out certain initiatives to ensure a successful mentor-mentee relationship/mentorship program.
Before we delve into other details, the one thing the three documents analyzed for this report …show more content…
In “Same-Race and Cross-Race Matching,” a study published by NorthWest Regional Educational Laboratory, the publishers assert that many studies have shown that, “matching by race, however, was not associated with youth-reported levels of emotional support or youths’ satisfaction with their mentors.” A great mentor-mentee relationship is a product of carefully executed matching. “In fact, the findings suggest that the effect of race on relationships are subtle and act in combination with other factors (such as gender and the mentor’s interpersonal style) to shape the ultimate influence of mentoring.” Hence, there is no direct correlation between intra-race matching and a successful mentoring relationship. Instead, several other matching criteria ought to be employed when matching mentors and mentees. Some alternatives for matching could be “shared interests” like academic interests or fervor for sports. “Many programs, for example, believe that having at least some kind of “similarity” between the mentor and youth is an important criterion… Other common criteria include the mentor’s attitudes and temperament, special needs of the youth matched with special talents of the mentor, and the geographic proximity of the mentor and …show more content…
It is vital that America’s history of systematic oppression and discrimination be kept in consideration when making matches. Additionally, being aware of racial; ethnic and cultural similarities or dissimilarities; internalized racism and its effects on young mentees; racial and ethnic identities of both mentors and mentees and the cultural competency level of the mentor all be evaluated and adequate trainings and development initiatives be administered if

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Case

...CPA Program The practical experience guide and logbook If you require further information about the practical experience requirement, or would like to notify us of a change, please contact CPA Australia: practicalexperience@cpaaustralia.com.au or contact your local office – details can be found on the inside back page of this guide. Disclaimer The material used in this booklet has been designed and prepared for CPA Australia’s practical experience requirement. It provides tailored guidance for mentors who are registered in CPA Australia’s practical experience requirement. The booklet and contents should not be used for any other purpose. CPA Australia, the publisher and the author of this booklet take no responsibility for any loss incurred by any person who relies on guidance offered in this booklet. Legal notice Copyright CPA Australia Ltd (ABN 64 008 392 452) (“CPA Australia”), 2010. All rights reserved. Save and except for third party content, all content in these materials is owned by or licensed to CPA Australia. All trade marks, service marks and trade names are proprietory to CPA Australia. For permission to reproduce any material, a request in writing is to be made to the Legal Business Unit, CPA Australia Ltd, 385 Bourke Street, Melbourne, Victoria 3000. CPA Australia has used reasonable care and skill in compiling the content of this material. However, CPA Australia and the editors make no warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of any information in these...

Words: 15775 - Pages: 64

Premium Essay

Metoring Concept Analysis

...Running head: MENTORING IN NURSING: A CONCEPT ANALYSIS Mentoring In Nursing: A Concept Analysis Leslie R. Dick The University of North Carolina at Charlotte Introduction Mentoring can be dated as far back as the Ancient Greeks. Young athletes were trained by their more experienced superiors. Homer is most famous for our initial understanding a mentor when he tells of Odysseus leaving his infant son with a companion, Mentor, when he left on his Odyssey (Gentry, Weber, & Sadri, 2008). Mentoring is a relationship between two people which lasts over an extended period of time. One of the people, the mentor, is more experienced and considered senior to the mentee and is trusted by the mentee. The mentee is less experienced, although not necessarily younger, than the mentor. Mentors can play an important role in our lives. They share knowledge, experience, and wisdom, and they critique us and give honest feedback. Positive, competent mentors develop relationships with their mentees and are focused on their growth. They are also generous and professional in their collaborations. The benefits of mentoring relationships include increased self-confidence and retention, strengthened professional relationships and increased skill levels. These consequences of mentoring improve the health environment for all. Through this concept analysis, I hope to show the attributes associated with mentoring as well as provide related terms that will provide a further understanding...

Words: 2164 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Leadership

...consideration. It is likely that most, if not all, individuals will form one of these mentor-mentee relationships during some point in his or her professional career. There are several advantages, as well as possible disadvantages, to forming one of these relationships. When thinking of mentoring, a one on one relationship usually comes to mind; however, multiple-mentor relationships make another valid option available. In any mentoring relationship, there does come a great deal of responsibility. You are responsible for molding that person. Mentoring is a growing trend among working professionals; it has many benefits, and will help individuals gain success, and provide a fulfilling role for the mentor. Disadvantages/Problems Unfortunately, not all mentor-mentee relationships assist in the professional development of an individual. Occasionally, but not always, there can be problems in a mentoring relationship. There is always a chance that personalities and communication styles may not mesh, or poor advice be given by the mentor (Nolinske, 1995, p. 40). Creating an environment in which the mentee is evaluated based solely on his or her skill level and aptitude can also create a problem. The pureness of this environment can become compromised as personal relationships of favoritism or disdain are developed (Nolinske, 1995, p. 40). There is also the chance that the fine line between the mentor and mentee can be crossed, which can result in inappropriate behavior and an overall unhealthy...

Words: 1884 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Hris Module

... Edi ti on Elements of Effective Practice for Mentoring™ Newly revised edition, which includes evidenced-based operational standards Sponsored by Introduction As a strategy for helping young people succeed in school, work and life, mentoring works. It helps give young people the confidence, resources and support they need to achieve their potential. But, the fact is this: these positive outcomes are only possible when young people are engaged in high-quality mentoring relationships. The Elements of Effective Practice for Mentoring holds the key to success in producing high-quality relationships. The new edition of the Elements provides six evidence-based standards for practice that incorporate the latest research and best-available practice wisdom. It also reprises advice that appeared in earlier editions on program design and planning; program management; program operations; and program evaluation. We believe adherence to the Elements will ensure that mentoring relationships thrive and endure. They include measures that any mentoring program in any setting can implement, as well as measures that any agency can incorporate within the mentoring element of broad-based, positive youth development programming. This means that community-based, corporate-based, school-based, faith-based and Internet-based mentoring programs can use the Elements to meet the specific needs of the young people they serve and the milieu in which they operate. And, it means that afterschool...

Words: 7208 - Pages: 29

Free Essay

Evolution of Mentoring

...THE EVOLUTION OF MENTORING By: Patrick Delaney Mentor was first documented in Greek mythology. Mentor was with whom Odysseus trusted to run his household and see to his son’s education when Odysseus went off to fight the Trojans. Many things have changed in the three thousand years since. Mentoring has evolved from the traditional one-on-one relationship to eMentoring. This paper will look at the different types of mentoring relating to leadership and how it has changed over the years. Mentoring is a process for the informal transmission of knowledge, social capital, and the psychosocial support perceived by the recipient as relevant to work, career, or professional development. Mentoring entails informal communication, usually face-to-face and during a sustained period of time, between a person who is perceived to have greater relevant knowledge, wisdom, or experience (the mentor) and a person who is perceived to have less. There are two broad types of mentoring relationships: formal and informal. Informal relationships develop on their own between partners. Formal mentoring, on the other hand, refers to a structured process supported by the organization and addressed to target populations. Traditionally, mentoring was a formal one-on-one face-to-face relationship between an older more experienced person and a young person with no experience. At one time, the term 'apprentice' was commonplace in various trades, most commonly in blue collar industries; however, apprenticeships...

Words: 2256 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Career Development Part Ii-Development or a Training and Mentoring Program

...turn, implies that there have been measurable changes in knowledge skills, attitudes and for social behavior. In order to build an effective and efficient training program the very first component is to do a need assessment which serves as a foundation for the entire training effort. A needs assessment is comprised of training and development phase and the evaluation phase. There are four levels of analysis for determining the needs that training can fulfill which are: Organization analysis, Demographic analysis, Operations analysis and Individual analysis. Taking a closer look at Organization analysis – focuses on identifying where within the organization training is needed. Demographic analysis - helpful in determining the special needs of a particular group, such as workers over 40, women, or managers at different levels. Those needs may be specified at the organizational level, the business-nit level, or at the individual level. Operational analysis – attempts to identify the content of training what an employee must do in order to perform competently. Individual analysis – determines how well each employee is performing the tasks that make up his or her job. Needs assessment is done in order to find out what sort of learning is necessary for employees which helps when designing the training program making certain there is updated and appropriate information upon...

Words: 1454 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Coaching and Mentoring

...but also rewards. There have been many attempts at defining the concept of mentoring, but for Nathalie Gehrke, author of “Towards a Definition of Mentoring”, none seem to fully embrace the essence of the concept. Gehrke started out with this initial definition: “A mentor acts as a coach, much like in athletics, advising and teaching the political nuts and bolts, giving feedback and rehearsing strategies” (Gehrke, 1990, p.190) .The best way to define a mentor is to experience the mentor/protégé relationship The relationship with the mentor inspires employees to seek new questions, not answers. Loading...The greatest gift a mentor can do for a protégé is offer a “new and whole way of seeing things” (Gehrke, 1990, p.192). Mentoring is a fluid and ever changing concept. There are no rules to define it. The insights, knowledge and services provided by the mentor are nothing short of a gift. The nature of the mentor-protégé relationship is something of a phenomenon (Gehrke, 1990). This relationship encourages more than just a worker to worker bond. Families and even Loading...communities arise out of the mentor-protégé relationship (Gehrke, 1990). The words fellowship, community and heritage are apt descriptors of the mentor...

Words: 2710 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Mentoring Program and Its Impact on Employee Job Performance

...…………………………………………………………………… …..8 2.3.1 Frame of reference………………………………. ……………………………8 2.4 Sample and sampling methods……………………………………………………9 2.5 Instrument selection ………………………………………………………. …….9 2.6 Variables ………………………………………………………………….......... 9 2.7 Hypotheses ……………………………………………………………………….9 2.8 Statistical tools ………………………………………………………………………...10 2.9 Required resources……………………………………………………………….10 References …………………………………………………………………………...11 - 1. Introduction 1.1 Preamble A mentor is an individual, who is more experienced and helps another individual in career advancement, development and general guidance about personal life. The Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary defines a mentor as "a trusted counselor or guide." An individual always seeks guidance from his mentor before taking any descision related to professional or personal life, however what level of guidance is taken from the mentor depends on the relationship between the mentor and the protégé, one who seeks guidance from the mentor. Changing trends regarding managerial learning...

Words: 2503 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Mentoring

... CONTENTS Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 4 What is Mentoring? .................................................................................................................. 5 Why a Mentoring Program? ..................................................................................................... 6 The Benefits of Mentoring Programs ....................................................................................... 7 Steps to a Successful Mentoring Program............................................................................... 9 Choosing a Mentor................................................................................................................. 15 Roles and Attributes of the Mentee and Mentor..................................................................... 16 Mentoring for EEO Groups..................................................................................................... 18 Other Ways of Mentoring ....................................................................................................... 19 Mentoring Without a Program...

Words: 6709 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Reading

...Purpose – There is considerable literature about the impact of mentoring on the mentees but little is known about the effect of the mentoring relationship on the mentor. This paper aims to address that gap. Design/methodology/approach – Interviews with 15 mentors and survey responses from 128 mentees are used to examine a formal mentoring programme. Most emphasis is on the perspective of the mentors, raising questions about how they view outcomes for themselves and their mentees, as well as the effects of mentoring on the workplace culture over time. Questions about the mentoring relationship, including gender differences, are analysed against the background of a decade-long organisational change strategy. Findings – Mentors report significant benefits for themselves and the mentee as well as the organisation itself as a result of their participation. The findings suggest that a long-term mentoring programme for women has the potential to be an effective organisational change intervention. In particular, men involved in that programme increased their understanding and sensitivity regarding gendering processes in the workplace. Practical implications – The importance of the impact of mentoring programmes on the mentors is an under-investigated area. This study suggests that programme design, together with careful selection and targeting of mentors, enables mentoring to become a critical part of a culture change strategy....

Words: 7775 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

Mentoring

...termed as mentor – to a comparatively less senior person in the organization. Through mentoring professional knowledge and experience is transferred to a less experienced person (Hirschfeld, Thomas and Lankau, 2006). The goal of mentoring is to assist the mentee in personal and professional development. Learning and development in organizational contexts is closely associated with the concept of mentoring. Mentoring brings the values and practices focusing on continuing education and links integrated transmission of knowledge through a special link between two persons. Mentoring is an interpersonal relationship providing support, exchange and learning, in which an experienced person invests its ability and expertise to promote the development of another person to enable him to acquire skills and achieve career goals (Holmes, 2008). The mentor is an experienced person who has the confidence and wisdom to promote the transfer of its assets to others less experienced. A mentor is motivated and willing to offer their skills, knowledge and vision of life to a younger member of the organization to support attainment of personal and professional development goals (Gentry, Weber and Sadri, 2008). The mentee is a person in search of personal and professional fulfillment. The mentoring relationship is characterized by openness to others, reciprocity and volunteerism. An important distinction to be recognized is that a mentor is distinct from a coach. In contrast to a coach, a mentor is usually...

Words: 2878 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

APA Ethical Violations Summary

...efficacy and safety (Hoop et al. 2008). In addition, the relationship between a mentor and mentee can be a complex one. Furthermore, good communication throughout the preparation of a dissertation it is important to avoid setbacks. In this ethical analysis, we will discuss the APA Ethics Violations, we will evaluate...

Words: 726 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Research Spotlight on Peer Tutoring

...practice gives students the opportunity to understand better the material being studied. What does the research say about peer tutoring? In reviews of peer tutoring programs, researchers found: * When students participated in the role of reading tutor, improvements in reading achievement occurred * When tutors were explicitly trained in the tutoring process, they were far more effective and the students they were tutoring experienced significant gains in achievement * Most of the students benefited from peer tutoring in some way, but same-age tutors were as effective as cross-age tutors (Burnish, Fuchs & Fuchs, 2005; Topping, 2008)  Some benefits of peer tutoring for students include higher academic achievement, improved relationships with peers, improved personal and social development as well as increased motivation. In turn, the teacher benefits from this model of instruction by an increased opportunity to individualize instruction, increased facilitation of inclusion/mainstreaming, and opportunities to reduce inappropriate behaviors (Topping, 2008). There is an old saying: “To teach is to learn twice.”  Peer tutoring is a beneficial way for students...

Words: 6206 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Cmlm Assign

...CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY INTRODUCTION - Definition of coaching - Definition of mentoring - Application Part A) Identify the process steps need to be taken to assess the learning needs of the organisation * Step 1: Perform needs analysis * Needs Assessments * 1) Organisation Analysis * 2) Task Analysis * 3) Individual Analysis * Step 2: Identify priorities and important * Step 3: Design Phase of training and development * Step 4: Implementation * Summary Part B) Identify and compare the costs and benefits that introducing a coaching system would involve * Cost * Benefits * Benefit 1: Recruitment and retention * Benefit 2: Continue Learning * Benefit 3: Several Skill Acquisition Part C) Identify KPIs that they should expect to achieve through the implementation process Part D) Identify the key stakeholders that will need to be involved in the process and how their support can be built. Part E) Case Study Example – ASDA Recommendations and conclusion EXECUTIVE SUMMARY High performance and contemporary company need to acquire a much broader set of skills if they are to survive in the world of modern business. The pace of change is unpredictable fast, partly driven by the advances in information technology and the pervading influence of globalisation – has become relentless. The complexity of work has increased while career paths have become less obvious due to the flattening...

Words: 4320 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Job Training

...reporting their strengths and weaknesses while achieving job satisfaction and minimizing stress in the work place. Job satisfaction is the most noticeable work mindset observed in the work and organizational culture. These concepts also receive much notice within the more particular work-family culture. We find that on the job training is the most preferred method training in the United States, predominantly for employees starting their professional careers. There are potential issues with this method, as people do not possess the needed skills to properly teach and educate fellow employees on what is required for the job. The most rewarding method, mentoring which is designed for a specific purpose by an organization, usually to train a mentee while stimulating professional growth with trust being a major weakness if not granted. The least preferred method, lecturing which works in certain setting. A major weakness is losing your audience as you may have a lecturer that can put you to sleep which can hurt employee progression. Introduction There are companies that consistently fail due to improper training methods or no training at all. Having job satisfaction is what organizations...

Words: 2218 - Pages: 9