...believe that describing the genesis of moral reasoning in this way provides no information about the content of our moral beliefs now. While our capacity for moral reasoning may have evolved for the purpose of informing our otherwise unjustifiable acts with a sense of objective certitude, it is not hard to imagine that this capacity, once evolved, would be capable of much more than simply rubber stamping mankind's collective genetic predisposition. In this paper, I will use the example of an evolutionary explanation against intentional killing for personal gain to argue for the existence of a disconnect between evolutionary biology and ethics. Ruse and Wilson might argue that human beings evolved with a genetic predisposition against murder for convenience. It is easy to see how this might be true. A person who kills others for convenience must live apart from society and apart from potential mates or else must be killed by society. This epigenetic rule �predisposes us to think that certain courses of action are right and certain courses of action are wrong (180).� These motivate ethical premises which �are the peculiar products of genetic history� and can �be...
Words: 1900 - Pages: 8
...Gattaca is a dystopian film directed by Andrew Niccol. It is set in the 'not-too-distant future' where discrimination is based on your genetic makeup and has become the defining factor of your societal class. Symbolism was constantly used throughout the film by Niccol to convey the main idea of genoism, the discrimination based solely on one's genes. Through bars, DNA, and glass symbols, the main character Vincent is shown to be oppressed and excluded due to his ‘invalid’ genes. Dialogue and camera work were also used in order to deepen the audience’s understanding of the genetic discrimination in the film and to comment on the dangers of genetic engineering. Genetic discrimination, through prejudiced stereotypes based on an individual’s DNA, is depicted by Niccol as misguided, unjust and dividing within a society. Your genes become your destiny. The genoist society in Gattaca rejects the desires and dreams of invalids like Vincent. Niccol uses the recurring symbol of bars to show how Vincent was excluded from society for being an invalid. An invalid is someone who does not have genetically engineered genes and is therefore considered to be of a lower class...
Words: 1157 - Pages: 5
...the preparation for man's first journey to Saturn's moon, Titan, is in progress. Among the people vying to leave Earth and explore Titan is someone who goes by the name of Jerome Morrow. He is fully qualified for this job: he has the right genetic material that puts him a cut above all the rest in terms of mental and physical skills. The catch is that Jerome Morrow is really Vincent Freeman, an "in-valid" with defective genes, who has managed to infiltrate the elite space agency by faking his identity---right down to the nucleic acid level. Vincent routinely obtains blood, hair, and urine samples from the real Jerome Morrow (Jude Law) to pass identification and screening tests. The real Morrow is not able to realise his potential since he was crippled in an accident, and therefore needs Vincent as much as Vincent needs him. Throw in some sibling rivalry between Vincent and his "valid" brother, a murder sub-plot, and a love interest for Vincent, you end up with Gattaca. The story is essentially about how Vincent overcomes the programming in his in-valid genes and competes against the best in the "valid" world. The scientific premise, like in most science-fiction movies, combines a mix of truth and fiction. In the movie, the alleles from parents are so chosen that the combination produces the optimal arrangement in terms of the child's genotype. But we know enough right now to realise that even in situations where there is a great degree of genetic predisposition, it is quite...
Words: 523 - Pages: 3
...Kimmelman Jonathan, Baylois Francois, Grass Kathleen, (2006) “Stem cell trials: Lessons from gene transfer research”, 23-26. When I first heard of stem cell research I wondered how the government could refuse Stem cell research, something that holds the cure for diseases like Alzheimer’s , Cancer or even HIV/AIDS. I didn’t know the background story and how stem cell research borders on the morality of what is ethical and what isn’t. Is it acceptable to save one life but kill another? The critics and the religious minded who believe life begins at conception see this as murder, while proponents praise it as innovative and groundbreaking, in helping save millions of lives. This Cutting-edge new experiment challenges and goes against numerous religions that oppose killing human life, which makes it so controversial. The issue of stem cell research largely involves the destruction of five to seven year old embryos, and raises the morality of this experiment. It questions our principals and makes us wonder are we really sacrificing a life or saving one? You have to choose between two wrong things. While there is immense excitement among scientists and people of the possibility of the millions of human lives stem cells can save there is also a great safety concern as well. Stem cell research has always been a very relevant topic. Over the last decade politicians, Scientists and theorists have debated on the medical advancement of stem cell research, its regenerative medicine...
Words: 1082 - Pages: 5
...Karren 1 Camille Karren Mrs. Robertson English 5A 12 December 2012 Human Therapeutic Cloning Should Be Permitted Human therapeutic cloning has the ability to greatly improve the quality of life. Cloning could be the answer to the end of your pain and suffering, but before you can understand it’s benefits, you have to know the process therapeutic cloning itself. Therapeutic cloning is a procedure in which cells, typically skin cells, are taken from a patient and inserted into a fertilized egg whose nucleus has been removed. Scientists then extract stem cells from the egg, and use those cells to grow tissue that are a perfect genetic match to the patient. It is a break-through in science and the key to curing many diseases including Parkinson's and Alzheimer's disease. Elizabeth Foley explains why human cloning should not be banned due to, “the primary objections to human cloning appear to be unfounded, based more on morality, theology, and fear than objective data.” The potential medical benefits of genetic engineering are far too great to let moral concerns about embryonic cell use get in the way of curing diseases. Human therapeutic cloning should not be banned from society because countless lives can be saved through transplantations and genetic research. Therapeutic cloning is the cloning of human tissues for research and transplant, and shows much promise in organ transplantation. Much needed organs grown from stem cells from the patient’s own genetic...
Words: 806 - Pages: 4
...of DNA profiling are credited to Sir Alec Jeffreys, of Leicester, England in 1977. He and his coworkers were studying ways to resolve immigration and paternity suits by detailing the genetic links between individuals. He soon realized that his discovery could establish the identity of a person and called his technique genetic fingerprinting. Dr. Jeffreys demonstrated that a genetic fingerprint is specific to each individual and the pattern does not belong to any other person on earth except for identical twins. Jeffreys’ techniques were put to the test when law enforcement contacted him to assist in 2 local murder cases. He was asked to compare semen samples from the two murders to the blood sample of a suspect who had confessed to one of the crimes. Dr. Jeffreys’ tests determined not only that this suspect was not the killer, but also that the killer committed both murders. Law enforcement then had over 4,000 submit samples, which were tested using Jeffreys’ process. A local man, Colin Pitchfork, had avoided the dragnet by having a colleague submit samples on his behalf. A local overheard a conversation in a bar where the colleague admitted being paid by Pitchfork to impersonate him and have his own blood tested in place of Pitchfork’s. This led to the arrest of Colin Pitchfork. Dr. Jeffreys then compared Pitchfork's DNA with the DNA of the semen samples found on the two victims. It was a perfect match. Instead of going to trial, Pitchfork pled guilty to both rapes and...
Words: 2409 - Pages: 10
...immigration disputes. After finishing his doctorate, he moved to the University of Amsterdam, where he worked on mammalian genes as a researcher, and then to the University of Leicester in 1977, where in 1984 he discovered a method of showing variations between people's DNA, formulating and developing genetic fingerprinting. Jeffreys says he had an “eureka moment” in his lab in Leicester after looking at the x-ray film image of a DNA experiment on 10 September 1984, which surprisingly showed similarities and differences...
Words: 1617 - Pages: 7
...Gattaca is a great science fiction film, and it was quite realistic. Gattaca deals with a future where parents tell the genetic traits of their child. Vincent Freeman has always fantasized about traveling into outer space, but is grounded by his status as a genetically inferior "in-valid." He decides to fight his fate by purchasing the genes of Jerome Morrow, a laboratory-engineered "valid." He assumes Jerome's DNA identity and joins the Gattaca space program, where he falls in love with Irene. An investigation into the death of a Gattaca officer complicates Vincent's plans. At Vincent's birth, a DNA test says that he has a 99% chance of developing a heart defect and dying before he is 30. This leads him to live a life with the fear of dying early. He is denied the chance to achieve his dream which is of being a space pilot. He doesn't even have support from his parents. His father once told him that the only time he was going to see a space shuttle would be if he were cleaning it. But Vincent refuses to accept his defeat, and finds a way to change his future. He has a deal with a crippled Valid, Jerome, and uses his genetic identity. Vincent finds all the substances used for DNA testing, and layers his biological fragments that make up Jerome on top of his own identity. He applies for the space programme using the wrong identity. The film is somewhat slow moving and deals with the human relationships between the ones with perfect genetics and the ones without perfect...
Words: 737 - Pages: 3
...that will also be able to reproduce. Organisms of the same species are similar but not identical. The differences that occur both between different species and within the same species are called variation. An animal that is the offspring of parents from two different species is called a hybrid, and it is unable to reproduce. When genetic information are passed on to an organism from its parents the information are said to be inherited. Most cells have a nucleus, which is a part of the cell that controls it. The nucleus contains chromosomes which are huge molecules of DNA found inside the nucleus of the cells. A chromosome consists of a string of genes. A gene carries an instruction. It’s the section of a chromosome that controls inherited characteristics of an organism and carries genetic information. Each gene is a length of DNA. DNA is a long coiled molecule which can unzip and copy itself when a cell divides. It also carries the genetic code and makes up the chromosomes. Sex cells-egg: In female the sex cells are called eggs. Eggs are produced in sex organs called ovaries. Sex cells-sperm: In males the sex cells are called sperm. Sperm are produced in sex organs called testes. Sex cells are also called gametes. They contain half the genetic information for a new organism. The process of fusing a male gamete with a female gamete is called fertilization and the fertilized egg contains information from the father and...
Words: 3796 - Pages: 16
...people.’ Discuss. 17 Essay 2: ‘The characters in Gattaca are too caught up in private dreams and personal ambitions for genuine relationships to be possible.’ Discuss. Essay 3: “That’s how I did it, Anton. I never saved anything for the swim back.” ‘Vincent defies and transcends his destiny and, in doing this, inspires others.’ Discuss. Essay 4: ‘Gattaca shows that categorising people into a hierarchy of castes, into ‘superior’ and ‘imperfect/inferior’, is both false and dangerous.’ How? Essay 5: ‘Gattaca shows that the rights of a person surpass the need for control within a society.’ Discuss. Essay 6: ‘Gattaca’s director, Andrew Niccol, said: “I would hate for anyone to look at my film and think it is advocating that you never tamper with genes, because there … will be many positive things to come out of this … science in terms of curing diseases”.‘ So what is Gattaca condemning? Essay 7: ‘Gattaca presents a world destroyed by the pursuit of perfection.’ Do you agree? Essay 8: ‘The society of Gattaca works to repress rather than to enhance the potential of human beings.’ Discuss. 22 27 31 36 40 45 50 Essay 9: “I belong to a new underclass, no longer determined by social status or the colour of your skin. No, we now have discrimination down to a science.” Does Gattaca show discrimination to be a science? 53 Essay 10: ‘Gattaca depicts a world that seems totally scientific and rational, yet passion still prevails.’ Discuss. Practice topics 57 61 © Insight Publications 2010 ...
Words: 1591 - Pages: 7
...while doing his paper round and took it home in his bag. He relates that he started to dissect it on the dining room table before Sunday lunch, causing a foul smell throughout the house after he ruptured its intestines. Jeffreys was a pupil at Luton Grammar School and then Luton Sixth Form College. He won a scholarship to study at Merton College, Oxford on a four-year course, where he graduated in 1972 with first-class honors in biochemistry. Jeffreys completed his doctorate, or DPhil as it is known at Oxford, on the mitochondria of cultured mammalian cells, as a postgraduate student at the Genetics Laboratory at the University of Oxford. After finishing his doctorate, he moved to the University of Amsterdam, where he worked on mammalian genes as a research fellow, and then to the University of Leicester in 1977, where in 1984 he discovered a method of showing variations between individuals' DNA, inventing and developing genetic fingerprinting. Jeffreys says he had a "eureka moment" in his lab in Leicester after looking at the X-ray film image of a DNA experiment on 10 September 1984, which unexpectedly showed both similarities and differences between the DNA of different members of his technician's family. Within about half an hour, he continued, he realized the possible scope of DNA fingerprinting, which uses variations in the genetic code to identify individuals. The method has become important in forensic science to assist police detective work, and it has also proved useful...
Words: 1806 - Pages: 8
...cells, and fixed patterns of cell divisions, migrations, and deaths generate individuals of invariant anatomy (Sulston and Horvitz, 1977; Kimble and Hirsh, 1979; Sulston et al., 1983). Thus, specific developmental events can be examined reproducibly and at the resolution of single cells. In addition, the short generation time (3 days at 20%) and large brood size of C. elegans facilitate genetic manipulations (Brenner, 1974; Herman and Horvitz, 1980). We describe here the isolation and characterization of mutations that prevent the initiation of programmed cell death in C. elegans, causing cells that would normally die to survive instead. These mutations define two genes, ted-3 and ted-4, that may be involved in determining which cells express the fate of programmed cell death. Summary The wild-type functions of the genes ted-3 and ted-4 are required for the initiation of programmed cell deaths in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. The reduction or loss of ted-3 or ted-4 function results in a transformation in the fates of cells that normally die; in ted-3 or ted-4 mutants, such cells instead survive and differentiate, adopting fates that in the wild type are associated with other cells. ted-3 and ted-4 mutants appear grossly normal in morphology and behavior, indicating that...
Words: 10807 - Pages: 44
...is the key role in determining who becomes a serial killer; childhood trauma is not an excuse. Although some people say there is no scientific evidence, scientists are now believing that psychopathic behaviour can be found in genes as “research shows that there may be a genetic factor that results in a behavioural predisposition to violence.” There are certain genes that have been found to be related to violence, and one in particular that is called the MAOA (monoamine oxidase) gene “which link to violence and aggression.” (Desroches, 2013). Scientists are finding that “these aggressive genes can be passed down through generations.” The MAOA gene is very rare, but the MAOA-L gene is very common, “about 40% of the population have it”. Something else that serial killers can have is XXY syndrome, which “only affects males.” “It was thought to create over-aggressive males who lacked empathy. Behavioural disorders, admission to psych hospitals and criminality are more frequent in XXY males.” (Raven, 2009). For this reason, genetics is significant in determining who becomes a serial killer. Serial killers are born and not made because the human evolution shows that everyone is born with the tendency to murder, and psychopathic behaviour can be found in genes. Despite the fact that childhood experiences can be very influential to a serial killer, signs of psychotic behaviour have occurred in killers from very young ages as forensic psychologists have investigated. The way to stop murderers...
Words: 606 - Pages: 3
...society breaks them down, but others argue that mental illness is the only reason that these monsters turn to cruelty and insanity. Psychologists, criminologists, and scientists searched to answer the question of why serial killers commit these mass killings and how they became such violent humans. What is left are two ideas, are serial killers born with predetermined genes/mental illness that plays an integral part in creating their homicidal tendencies or do psycho killers become murderous through their surroundings and society as children? It is important to understand how killers become such vicious individuals in order to help stop the influences that cause these monster....
Words: 1642 - Pages: 7
...Many stories are read about family members being killed and never resolved. Every year over 58 percent of family murder victims are females, according to police. Over 30 percent of victims were slain by family members. On Thursday August 4, 1892 a bloody-minded murder occurred. It seems obvious that Lizzie Borden daughter of Mr. Borden and step-daughter of Abby Borden committed this crime due to mental issues, family feuding, and evidence toward murders. Recently, a few studies have examined and found out that 2,823 adults have experienced a parent’s death which will cause difficulties later in life. For example, Lizzie didn’t have a mother guidance her life might have had turned out different if she hadn’t lost her mother at a very young age. Losing a parent at any age can be trauma traumatizing and devastating, studies show it can cause depression and loneliness. In some cases the person may...
Words: 697 - Pages: 3