Premium Essay

Organ Sales Wrong

Submitted By
Words 943
Pages 4
For many years the Church has tried to help as many people as possible, however, now we are realizing an epidemic that is nearly world wide of providing enough organ transfers for those who need them. Organ sales are currently illegal in almost every country, which has created a corrupt black market system. This black market system is flawed with favoring the rich, exploiting the poor, and putting innocent lives in danger. The job of the Church is to work to uphold the standards within the Bible, the standards of helping as many as possible and protecting the body as a temple. By legalizing the sale and transactions of organs, there would be a surplus of organs available to those who would usually not be able to receive them and they would …show more content…
For people living in grief stricken poverty, many of them are found to be refugees or even poor citizens that have no luck of getting a job. These individuals find themselves at a crossroad, a road that one way leads to money or the other way leads to no money. The obvious choice and their only choice is to comply with the black market of organs and sell their organs for money. Many will say “That any market based system will necessarily be exploitative of the poor since they’re the ones who’ll be most tempted to take the risks in order to get the rewards. The poor of Pakistan and China have shown willingness to sell corneas on the black market for money. A market system – black or otherwise – exploits such abject poverty” (Clark). This system that we see working behind closed doors in many poor countries, is at flaw since it favors the rich and exploits the …show more content…
Once the patient leaves the facility, the doctors and traffickers could care less if they did not survive the brutal recovery process. A 29 year old Syrian refugee, Yasser, fled from the Syrian war to Cairo in search of a new and better life. Along with many of the problems refugees face, Yasser could not find any work and he had no money. In Egypt, Yasser heard from others that organ traffickers would pay for one of his kidneys, “I was new to Egypt. I did not have any money, and I couldn’t find a job, so my only choice was to sell my left kidney” (Hamdo). An organ broker met with him and he, “Sold it for $3,000 to someone I knew nothing about. We met for no more than 15 minutes before we closed the deal” (Hamdo). Yasser’s illegal operation left him emotionally and physically damaged. Facing his new reality, Yasser explains “I will never forgive myself for what I did. It was the worst decision of my life” (Hamdo). This story is the epitome of an organ transaction between the donor, the doctor, and the broker. Both the doctor and broker do not care for the patient after the operation is over, they only care about their cut of the profit, “In a market—even a regulated one—doctors and nurses still would be using their skills to help people harm themselves solely for money. The resulting distrust and loss of professional

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Organ Debate

...2016 Section A: Essay The Organ Debate MacKay made many points to support her argument on legalizing organ sales. Her first point was that the people who are currently donating organs, need money. She stated, “In third world countries, there are people willing to do anything for money. In such extreme poverty these people barely have enough to eat, living in shacks and sleeping on dirt floors” (MacKay 121). She continues to coincide with the donors, stating that they would basically be rewarded for donating an organ to someone in need. “We pay men for donating sperm, and we pay women for donating ova, yet we expect others to give away an entire organ for no compensation” (MacKay 121). As she said, we should treat organ sales like all other sales. If the transactions for organ sales were easier and beneficial to both parties, more people would be willing and to giving their organ away. If this happened, more people’s lives will be saved. Also, with more organs becoming available, the waiting list will be eliminated. That would be a major benefit to all of the people who need an organ. Then, MacKay continues with her second point, “Under a regulated system, education would be incorporated into the application process. Before deciding to donate a kidney, the seller should know the details of the operation and any hazards involved” (MacKay 122). Many people do not fully know or understand what is going to happen when they give an organ away. If organ sales were regulated, the seller...

Words: 658 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Selling Orgen

...Selling Human Organ A farmer in an Indian village wants more than anything else in the world to send his child to college. To raise money, he sells his spare kidney to an American in need of a transplant. A few years later, as the farmer’s second child approaches college age, another buyer comes to his village and offers a handsome price for his second kidney. Should he be free to sell that one, too, even if going without a kidney would kill him (Sandel 72)? Some might object that, regardless of whether the practice already exists, it is clear that legalizing it would make it worse. Not only that, but it seems like the person would become like a marketplace selling his organs. If someone had mentioned that they want to donate their kidney to someone and dies, then it is fine. Then suppose that the person starts selling his kidney or any other organ of his body. Basically he or she is doing it for money, but what if the person's other kidney got damaged? Then what would the person do? Besides it will be a stronger cause of corruption because many people are poor and need money to feed their families so they sell their kidneys; however, this may cause future health problems to that person. Selling organs is wrong and it should not be allowed. Selling an organ is menacing, even for those organs which can be removed without killing the donor. Murphy say,“isn’s it more dangerous to have black market organ transactions?”(1). This is normally the first protestation embossed after...

Words: 1047 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Commercialization of Organ Transplants

...Commercialization of Organ Transplants Nicholas Owens Professor Kenneth Pino Business Ethics 05-04-14 I’ve recently done research regarding the commercialization of Organ Transplants. I’ve found many arguments for and against this subject. Some individuals find the act to be unethical, and other’s think it will save lives. The problem is that a new policy was proposed to allow sale of organs by consenting individuals to patients in need and to medical institutions. When it comes to the subject of human organs, there are a few ethical standards to consider. There are religious standards, social norms, ethical code, morals, and policies in which we should follow. Critics argue that permitting organs to be bought and sold is unethical. Meaning that to commercialize organs transplants would violate an ethical code and social norm. During my research I’ve found many pros and cons concerning the commercialization of Organ Transplants. One of the pros would be that it shortens the waiting time for those in need of transplants. For example, if you have been on a waiting list to receive a kidney and there are more donated organs you will receive one quicker to save your life. Another pro for commercializing organ transplants are an individual’s rights to have the freedom to do what they wish with their body organs. Some people might equate this example to abortion stating that the government shouldn’t be able to tell you what to do with your body. During NOTA (National Organ Transplant)...

Words: 1361 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Organ Sales Will Save Lives By Joanna Mackay Analysis

...In the essay “Organ Sales Will Save Lives”, Joanna MacKay argues that the sale of human organs should not be banned, but instead, regulated. The author started her argument by noting, “There are thousands of people dying to buy a kidney and thousands of people dying to sell a kidney” (McKay). Her stance in noting how many lives are lost because of this problem made a strong starting point in her argument. Joanna MacKay’s extraordinary arguments impacted my viewpoints regarding this problem and convinced me to side with her. The regulation of human organs in the United States should be considered. “About 350,000 Americans suffer from end-stage renal disease, a state of kidney disorder so advanced that the organ stops functioning altogether”...

Words: 507 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Mackay Organ Sales

...In the article “Organ Sales Will Save Lives” by Joanna MacKay, argues that governments should not be allowed to ban the sale of organs. She also argues in favor of allowing the selling of organs, kidneys in particular. MacKay starts out by providing some background information about renal disease, a kidney disease, and possible treatments for it. She writes about how it could benefit the poor by getting them some money they desperately need; she also points out how the poor might be exploited. MacKay mentions the dangers of transferring a kidney, along with how studies have been conducted showing that a person can function just fine with one kidney. She tells us that controlling the world’s organ market would be difficult, but trying to manage...

Words: 857 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Human Organ Traffic

...survival, the law prohibiting the widespread of trading human organs in numerous nations is being a controversial issue. The information from “Topics for today” (Smith and Mare, 2004) as well as reference of other resources presenting in this paper does express two different perceptions. While most of ethical and political organisations oppose to transaction human organs, I still belive that it is necessary to legalize that business with the purpose of making the best endeavor in regaining the subsistence of millions patients. Revoking the law which does forbid the patient has the right to buy flesh and people has authority to sell their organs would be beneficial besides merely saving a person’s life. First of all, both dealers are beneficiaries from the business transaction. Ross Taylor, president of the British Transplantation Society revealed a tremendous view of the people who prepare to martyr themselves. Their desperate circumstances are motivations for them to sell their body organs for justifiable even lofty intention as paying off of debts, college tuitions or even saving their families. While their donations are considered as a gift for patients’ life, they are also rescued from the impoverished situation. Simultaneously, legalization of human organs trading facilitates for the available flesh to reach the expectation of people who are waiting for transplantation. The adequate resource of human organs synonyms with millions patients are saving. By contrast, the...

Words: 1287 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Diversity

...Warning You do not have permissions to perform this activity Courses Download Save Link Courses View Syllabus English Composition II Details | This course explores various types of research writing, with a focus on constructing essays, arguments, and research reports based on primary and secondary sources. A writing-intensive course. Prerequisite: ENG-105 | Credit Hours | 4.0 | Pre-requisites | ENG-105 | Co-requisites | None | Course Add-Ons | Textbook1. Finding Purpose Through Argumentative WritingGrand Canyon University (Ed.). (2015). Finding purpose through argumentative writing.http://gcumedia.com/digital-resources/grand-canyon-university/2015/finding-purpose-through-argumentative-writing_ebook_1e.phpElectronic Resource1. The Writing Process Mediahttp://lc.gcumedia.com/zwebassets/courseMaterialPages/eng105_writingProcess.php 2. Rubric Peer Review Mediahttp://cola.gcumedia.com/phi105/rubric/rubricCompare.html 3. Flashcard DeckUtilize the flashcard deck to review key terms and definitions.http://lc.gcumedia.com/mediaElements/gcu-flashcard-application/v1.1/#/add/ENG-106 Additional Material1. Developing Academic Skills GuideReview this resource as you move forward in the course. It will be important to come back to this resource periodically.ENG106_DevelopingAcademicSkillsGuide.docx 2. Academic Writing GuidelinesReview this resource as you move forward in the course. It will be important to start your assignments. Come back to this resource periodically...

Words: 5399 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking and Ethics with Scenario

...Critical Thinking and Ethics with Scenario Part One: Critical Thinking and Ethics Stephanie Early November 14, 2014 ETH/316 Karen Harvey The skills that you cultivate as a critical thinker are intended to help you think your way through all of life’s situations. One of the most challenging and complex of life’s areas is moral issues and decisions. Every day of your life you make moral choices, decisions that reflect your own core moral compass. Often we are not aware of the deeper moral values that drive our choices, and we may even be ignorant to the fact that the choices we are making have a moral factor. Critical thinking plays a major role in assisting us in developing values, using moral reasoning, and to make ethical conclusions. The steps involved. Critical thinking is defined as having the means to articulate what you study, being open to all possibilities and able to draw your own conclusions based on what you have learned. There are six steps to the critical thinking process. The first is knowledge; you are able to identify with what you hear and read, the topic, issues, and main points. Step two is comprehension, being able to relate to the information and put it into your own words. Step three is application, taking what you have learned and apply it to an actual situation. Step four is analysis, which means breaking the information down to see how they are connected to other ideas. The final step is evaluation, this occurs when you understand with supporting...

Words: 911 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Blood for Sale

...Case Study: Blood for Sale (2.1) Question 1 Based on the case study, Sol Levin and his colleagues are the founder of Plasma International. He legalised the lucrative market referring on secure and uncontaminated blood. Regarding this question, Sol Levin’s company is running a business “just like any other business” in the country. Why did I accept this phrase? This is because one wouldn’t be able to acquire blood just like any other department stores, supermarkets, chain stores or hypermarkets as was mentioned by a woman working as a machine operator. However, I deliberate the sort of business he coordinate is open to moral criticism as well. Why is it open to moral criticism? It fosters an awareness and inequity towards the publics. The company has to realize what is right and wrong as a way to fabricate appropriate resolutions. As an illustration, it utters that the wealthy is capable to pay the monetary for the bloods without any hesitancy and live longer, where else the poverty-stricken can’t furnish to purchase the blood and they tend to live shorter. An example of a country is Africa. This manifest that there is no equality in selling the bloods between the poor’s and rich. Question 2 In my viewpoint, the Plasma International didn’t strike an unprejudiced haggle with the West Africans who donated their blood to the company. The Plasma International purchases blood at an amount of 15 cents a pint from the rural West Africans tribes. Later, they sell it to the United...

Words: 613 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Organ Transplant

...Organ Transplant in the United States Stephanie Daniels UCA Certificate of Authorship I hereby certify that I am the author of this document and any assistance I received in preparing this report is fully acknowledged. I have also cited in APA format all sources of data, data analysis, ideas, words, phrases, or sentences. I also hereby certify that I have not submitted this paper to any other professor, at Webster University or elsewhere, during the course of my educational career. I have properly cited and acknowledged material that was presented in previous papers of my authorship. Signature: __________________________________________________ Date: __________________________________________________ TABLE OF CONTENTS Page # Abstract……………………………………………………………………………………3 Organ Transplant…………………………………………………………………………..4 What Organs and Tissues Can Be Donated……………………………………………….6 Organ Transplant Cost…………………………………………………………………….10 Ethical Issues: Organ Transplant…………………………………………………………..11 Strength and Weaknesses……………………………………………………………….....14 Alternatives and Key Challenges: Organ/Tissue Transplant……………………………...15 Summary and recommendations…………………………………………………………...17 References…………………………………………………………………………………19 Abstract Organ transplant experiments began in the 1800’s on animals and humans as a need...

Words: 4065 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Organ Donation Shortage- Problem-Solution Essay

...Organ donation shortage Organ donation shortage When receiving a driver’s license in the United States, there is a section on the back in which it asks if the licensed driver would like to become an organ donor. Most people overlook this option. Nothing is really pushed forth for people wanting to become organ donors. Today in the U.S, thousands of people need organ transplants. Unfortunately, there is a growing shortage of donated organs. Many people die every year because there are not enough organs ready for transplant. Resulting, there is an extremely long waiting list of people hoping that they will be the next ones to get called to receive an organ. For a lot of those people, they die waiting on that list. If more people would become donors, there would be a lot more organs available for the ones in need. There have been many ideas on how to solve this problem. Rather it being an organ donor to receive an organ, some sort of point system, or financial incentives. (Calne, 2010) Offering financial incentives to potential organ donors, would solve the organ donation shortage in America. Organ transplantation started in the mid- 1950’s with a kidney transplant between identical twins. After the successful operation, it started the idea of widespread organ donation between two participants (Calne, 2010). Today, a living volunteer can donate a kidney, half of a liver or even a lobe of a lung (Calne, 2010). The process starts by one of two ways. If the person is donating...

Words: 2588 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Should Human Organs Play In An Open Market

...The National Organ Transplant Act implemented in 1984, prohibits the ability "for any person to knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any human organ for valuable consideration for use in human transplantation if the transfer affects interstate commerce." If human organs become a commodity in an open market, several ethical moral issues will arise. An open market is a freely competitive market in which any buyer or seller may trade and in which prices are determined by competition. One of the most highly demanded organs is the kidney but because demand is rising so high, supply is short and people cannot get what they need in time. For every 100,000 transplant operations needed each year, only 10,000 are performed. In my opinion, allowing open market organ donations should remain illegal firstly because, people could be coerced, in other words, forced by persuasion or threat to sell their organ. Secondly, the open market would discriminate against the poor who do not have the financial means to pay for a needed organ and thus will have to constantly complete against the rich. Thirdly, there is always the risk of citizens going around murdering one another to obtain an organ to sell leading into illicit trading and potentially, the...

Words: 1255 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Polis

... | |d. |Both a and b | 3. What is one of the greatest ethical questions in biotechnology? |a. |When does life begin? | |b. |When does life end? | |c. |Should sex changes be allowed? | |d. |Is it moral to transplant organs? | 4. Which president halted further stem cell research from human embryos? |a. |Ronald Reagan | |b. |Jimmy Carter | |c. |Bill Clinton | |d. |George W. Bush | 5. Injuries to the nervous system are difficult to treat because they cause impairment to ____. |a. |blood vessels | |b. |nerve cells | |c. |internal organs | |d. |organ systems | 6. ______________ research provides great prospect in improving the impairment caused by...

Words: 1751 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Auditing

...strength. Your presentation of each candidate is clear with a balanced discussion of the pros and cons of each claim. *Jenny 5806136 has requested that you respond to the Main Idea/Thesis: The memorandum should tell the reader exactly what the issue is and give all the essential information in the subject line and in the first sentence of the first paragraph. Your subject and first sentence are too general: * Transplanting Organs * The purpose of this memorandum is to inform you that the recipient of the organ transplant has been chosen. Your memo is not about organ transplants in general; it is about the decision to give a heart to Jerry. What will you say in the subject line to tell your readers exactly what the memo is about? Avoid an announcement style in your first sentence. Instead, state the topic. For example, “The committee has decided to implement three changes to improve the effectiveness of the sales team.” What is the decision that you are informing your readers of? They want to know your main idea—who will receive the organ—before they read your reasons. You can go on to explain the dilemma and the benefits for Jerry and denial of benefits for the other two candidates. I encourage you to inform your readers of the main idea—the decision—in the subject...

Words: 1934 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Africa

...Some Ethical Theories: Consequentialism: Acts are right if they have good consequences, wrong if they have bad consequences. Hedonistic Consequentialism: [Bentham] Consequences are to be judged according to the amount of pleasure and pain they include. The more pleasure (and the less pain), the better. Ethical Egoism: Consequences are to be judged according to the amount of benefit they afford to the actor. The more beneficial, the better. Each person's sole obligation is to do what will be best for herself. Consequentialist theories generally have three parts: 1)Theory of the right: an act is right iff it maximizes good. 2)Theory of what's good: Pleasure, happiness, excellence of character, wealth, power... 3) Whose good matters? Everyones (universalist). Only the actors [only mine] (egoist). Utilitarianism: (Mill) Consequentialist theory of right: actions are right if they produce the best consequences. Theory of the Good: What makes consequences good is that they include more happiness and less misery. Egalitarian Distribution: Every creature capable of experiencing happiness and misery counts equally. ' Act Utilitarianism: Acts are right iff they produce the greatest happiness for the greatest number. Rule Utilitarianism: Acts are right iff they are consistent with rules which, if followed by everyone, would produce the greatest happiness for the greatest number. Deontological Theories: (Kant) Duty-centered theories, which hold that a person's 'duty'...

Words: 991 - Pages: 4