Free Essay

Pros/Cons on Under Cover Police

In:

Submitted By realboy34
Words 1529
Pages 7
On July 19, an undercover police officer took the stand in a New York courtroom to testify against an alleged drug dealer named Fabian Joseph. Consistent with longstanding practice in New York City, the officer refused to identify himself by anything but his badge number. Inconsistent with longstanding practice in New York City, trial judge Dorothy Cropper barred the officer's testimony. Judge Cropper ruled that because the undercover officer had failed to show he was in particular danger of retaliation from the defendant for his testimony, he had to give his name. When he refused, she showed him the door.
The basis for Judge Cropper's ruling was the Sixth Amendment, which guarantees the defendant the right to a "public trial" at which he will be "confronted with the witnesses against him." A "public trial" means one conducted in a courtroom that anyone can enter. And confrontation means, among other things, that the defendant has a right to cross-examine the government's witnesses - which is difficult to do if you don't know their names. These rights are not absolute, but Judge Cropper ruled that the government hadn't justified either closing the courtroom or limiting cross.
The response to Judge Cropper's ruling was outrage. New York Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly excoriated the judge, and encouraged his officers to continue to refuse to give their names. The Manhattan D.A.'s office has decided to appeal Judge Cropper's ruling. Meanwhile, the usual suspects, lead by the New York Post, have called for Judge Cropper's head.
The law suggests that the NYPD's position will be hard to maintain. The facts, fortunately, suggest that it isn't necessary to close courtrooms or allow anonymous testimony to protect an officer. Moreover, when an officer is at risk, the law provides sufficient protection.
Not All Undercover Officers are in Equally Perilous Situations To understand the risks for an undercover officer, we need to understand what, exactly, he is doing. The officer in the Fabian Joseph case was not part of a years-long infiltration into the Mafia. Nor was he apparently involved in a major investigation into a drug market controlled by an organized gang watching its territory, and willing to protect that territory with violence.
In fact, most drug markets are not tightly controlled by drug gangs. Gangs are hard to maintain, and the economic rewards of controlling territory are not always easy to reap. Thus, many drug markets are open - anyone can deal, anyone can buy. These are the easiest markets in which undercover officers can operate, because there is no one keeping a watchful eye on dealers and customers, as a gang enforcer might.
Apparently, the officer in Joseph's case was involved in a standard "buy-bust" operation in an open market. Here's how it works: the officer buys drugs from a dealer, leaves the scene, and then directs a waiting team of officers to the dealer. The officers then arrest the dealer. Next, the undercover officer - from one of those famous "undisclosed locations" - identifies the arrestee as the dealer, and a drug distribution case is born.
The Sixth Amendment Rights to Public Trials and Cross-Examination
The officers in Fabian Joseph's case wanted to testify anonymously. But many NYPD undercover officers also ask judges to close courtrooms. And in fact, the combination seems necessary if an officer is really serious about protecting his identity.
If the courtroom is open and the defendant's confederates can watch the officer's testimony, then the officer's cover is blown. And if the courtroom is closed, but the defendant finds out the officer's name, that's not much better. It's not that hard to put a face to the name.
But for a judge to both close the courtroom and allow a witness for the prosecution to remain anonymous is hard to defend.
To close a courtroom, the judge needs to find an "overriding" state interest that cannot be protected by any other means. Limiting cross-examination is easier. The judge can do that to ensure that a witness is not embarrassed or endangered. Still, asking for basic personal information (such as your name) is standard during cross-examination. And the U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly said that when a question is "normally permissible," the witness needs to provide a good reason why it shouldn't be asked in a particular case.
Protecting an undercover officer's identity in your basic buy-bust is unlikely to pass either test. "Overriding" state interests usually involve rather particularized threats connected to a given defendant and a given witness. Even whether there isn't a direct threat, this test can be passed in cases involving organized crime - such as crime families, drug dealing organizations, and biker gangs. But in your typical buy-busts, which are really a tool for attacking street level dealers or disorganized open-air drug markets, it is much harder (absent a specific threat) to make the case that an individual officer is at risk. That means the courtroom will probably stay open even if the prosecution seeks closure.
There's less at stake for the defendant when it comes to the officer's name - so that requesting anonymity may be more successful. But there's also, in truth, less at stake for the officer.
Only a fraction of a police force - about 10% - is actively involved in making cases, so prosecutors, defense lawyers, and judges get to know the officers who actually have to testify in court pretty quickly. Any courthouse regular can easily find out an officer's name.
In addition, the police have no absolute right to hide the identity of an officer. And the defense bar has a vested interest in finding out the names of officers who are routinely testifying. In short, testifying under a badge number is of limited value in protecting the identity of an undercover officer who intends to operate for any length of time.
All of this would be highly problematic if an undercover officer's identifying himself in an open courtroom really put him or her safety at risk. And it does, sometimes.
When it does, there are a number of ways to protect the officer. Most obviously, the government can simply wait until his undercover assignment is over, so that he's not on the street after he has testified.
Sometimes we also go further - closing courtrooms, erecting screens, providing masks, scrambling voices, withholding information. News coverage of the big Mafia trials of the '80s and early '90s provided citizens a glimpse of all these tools.
But there is very little evidence that undercover officers in the ordinary buy-bust operation are in this type of danger. First, there is the experience in other jurisdictions. In many major cities - such as Los Angeles, Chicago, Denver, and Washington, D.C. - there is no tradition of allowing undercover officers to testify anonymously in closed courtrooms. And there is no evidence in these cities that undercover officers are exposed to greater dangers or are less effective.
No doubt, anonymity would prolong the shelf-life of an undercover buyer. But no undercover officer operates forever, at least not in any one place. And moving officers is highly effective, especially in big cities.
After all, drug bazaars are highly localized operations. From the perspective of a dealer in, say, south central Los Angeles (not far from downtown), a buyer in, say, Van Nuys (in L.A.'s San Fernando Valley) might as well be in Riga (that's in Latvia). Officers can move around a city and work effectively in an undercover capacity for years at a stretch.
A Case-by-Case Approach to Courtroom Closure and Witness Anonymity
Because organized criminal enterprises are so much more dangerous than disorganized ones, the fact that an officer is working in protected territory could well be sufficient to justify concealing his or her identity. Similarly, in such cases, a judge should be open to the possibility of closing the courtroom so that the defendant's confederates cannot sit and watch.
But most drug trials in this country take place in courtrooms both open and empty, and involve defendants unconnected from anything larger that their personal supplier and their need for a quick buck. In these cases, closure of the courtroom and anonymity of the testifying officers will rarely be necessary.
There is, finally, a broader implication if we do allow officer anonymity. Many of the battles against drugs on our streets are fought by individual officers involved in individual buy-bust operations again and again. Whatever one's view of the "war on drugs," such operations will remain a significant part of law enforcement. We should be careful before turning the men and women on the front lines of those battles into an anonymous - and therefore, necessarily, less accountable - force.
Barton Aronson is currently a prosecutor in Washington, D.C. Prior to that, he was in private practice in Washington, D.C. and an Assistant District Attorney in Massachusetts. The opinions expressed in this article are his own. Barton Aronson is currently a prosecutor in Washington, D.C. Prior to that, he was in private practice in Washington, D.C. and an Assistant District Attorney in Massachusetts. The opinions expressed in this article are his own.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Pros/Cons of Under Cover Police Work

...Police officers can be assigned to numerous lines of work within an police department. A wide range of law enforcement duties generally require the officer to wear a uniform, representing his or her status as enforcer of laws, preventer of crime, and preserver of domestic peace. However, there is one controversial line of law enforcement that restricts the use of police a uniform. Undercover police work entails the practice of remaining in disguise during investigations of criminal activity. A police officer may assume a different identity acting as an undercover agent, as a method for gaining valuable information or evidence. Undercover work is by far the most dangerous and controversial areas of law enforcement. Nonetheless, undercover work is also one of the best investigative techniques implemented by police departments. The first plainclothes police unit was organized in France during the early 1800’s. Eugène François Vidocq has been recognized as the originator of the “Brigade de la Sûreté”, or “security brigade”. In his self-titled memoir, Vidocq explains the goals of his early undercover police network: “to procure information, to undertake searches, and to obtain particulars of every description; to make nightly rounds…to assist the commissaries of police in their searches, or in the execution of search-warrants; to explore the various rendezvous in every part; to go to the theatres, the boulevards, the barriers, and all other public places, the haunts of...

Words: 1683 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The Pros And Cons Of Legalizing Drugs

...do not realize that a number of illicit drugs are actually scientifically proven to be medically useful to treat diseases. There has been numerous of arguments about the legalization of drugs and there is not a solution to this issue yet. There are actually a lot of pros and cons of legalizing drugs which most of the people did not notice of. Drugs may be advantageous in economic perspective by decreasing the...

Words: 1538 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Tallahassee vs Scottsdale

...family situations. This paper will compare and contrast the pros and cons between Scottsdale and Tallahassee, specifically, four broad categories: nightlife, climate, police presence, and beach access. Activities in a city or town make the city unique in its own way. First, the climate in Scottsdale, AZ is amazing during the peak time, which is in the summer. However, the summer won’t be too appealing for some people since it can get too hot, which causes people to stay indoors. Unlike Scottsdale, Tallahassee has all four seasons, and people enjoy the weather regardless if it’s raining or sunny than when compared to Scottsdale. Moreover, in Tallahassee, there are a lot of bugs that are present, which causes people to spray bug repellent in the summer time. Conversely, in Scottsdale, bugs are not a problem. However, both cities share…. Second, nightlife in Scottsdale is pretty significant, and people all around the Phoenix area come to enjoy the dance scene. Whether it’s hip hop, country to techno music, there are a wide variety of night clubs to participate in. On the contrary, the nightlife in Tallahassee is not as mainstream as Scottsdale. In Scottsdale, there are eleven clubs with restaurants/bars turning to a club after certain hours, which can push that number into the high 20’s. Whereas in Tallahassee, there are five clubs and their restaurants/bars do not turn into a nightclub after hours. Third, the police visibility in Scottsdale is very alarming, mainly at night...

Words: 630 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethics Paper

...health insurance industry, and decreasing health care spending in the US (Government, 2012). Many people have mixed feelings about Obama Care and how it is used in the US. In this paper, I will discuss the origins and the history of how Obama Care got started and its difficulties. Then, I am going to talk about the pros and cons dealing with Obama Care and the ways it will affect our economy. Next, I will discuss how Obama Care is funded and how there are still missing pieces that the administration needs to clear up. Lastly, I will argue how some of the American population thinks Obama Care is a scam. Then, to wrap up my paper I will be giving my opinion on this complex matter. Steps in the process of Obama Care The history of Obama Care is very complex but the name is the unofficial name for The Patient Protection and Affordable Care act, which was singed into law on March 23, 2010. The major requirements went into effect in January 1, 2014 even though significant modifications had happened before this date. Many Americans were opposed to Obama Care before it was even passed because they didn’t like the idea of the government taking over the healthcare polices. Now, I am going to describe the obstacles of Obama Care over the years in a timeline form. President Obama promised in 2009 that the act would lower costs for families but in reality, health insurance premiums rose 9% in 2011 and by a margin of 8 to 1, employers expected continued increases due to the result of Obama...

Words: 2414 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Week Two Assignment Pol 303

...Week Two Assignment Kacy Lane Klingle POL303: The American Constitution Lawrence Olson February 29, 2016 The topic I am going to cover in this paper is Privacy Rights. The one thing I will cover is the Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism or the USA Patriot Act. This Act has caused numerous concerns over the years of the federal government over stepping their bounds on their tactics of intelligence gathering after the terrorist attacks on September eleventh two thousand and eleven. This paper will discuss some advantages of the patriot act such as sharing intelligence between the federal, state, and local governments. As well it will cover harsher penalties for hackers. The paper will also cover some of the disadvantages of the Patriot Act. Such as screening peoples phone calls and E-mails possibly infringing on a persons’ Fourth Amendment rights. The first thing this paper is going to discuss is how the Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism or the USA Patriot Act. The Patriot Act helps throughout the multiple levels of the government, from federal to the local government. One way is within this act it allows the multiple levels of the government to share information between organizations. “The Act removed the major legal barriers that prevented the law enforcement, intelligence, and national defense communities from talking...

Words: 879 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Supreme Court Case: The Scottsboro Case

...Introduction Under the 6th Amendment of the Constitution the right to counsel is applied. The criminal defendants have a constitutional right to an attorney. If you cannot afford one, the government will provide you with a representative appointed by the court who is deemed necessary to handle your case. However, the 6th Amendment does not apply at the moment of arrest unless; the government has already filed former charges. The right to counsel is given at a critical stage of prosecution in which advice of counsel is necessary to ensure the dependence’s rights to a fair trial. This also always the ability for a plea bargaining to be issued if the prosecutor feels that their is overwhelming evidence and a court case should not be needed. Right to Counsel Background Powell v. Alabama (1932), also known as the Scottsboro case, involved several African American boys ranging from the ages of 13-17, whom were accused of raping two white women. The defendants were convicted and sentenced to death in a quick trial without an attorney. This took...

Words: 2135 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Candian Health Care

...administration, comprehensiveness, universality, portability, and accessibility. The funding for this service comes from taxes such as personal, corporate and sales tax as well as lottery premiums. The Canadian government is responsible for providing services to the following individuals regardless of what they require, First Nations and Inuit Peoples, veterans, active members of the Canadian Forces, member of the Royal Canadian mounted Police, refugees, and federal inmates. (Health Canada, 2010) There are two primary forms of care a person can receive. The primary source is known as provincial health insurance, this is the insurance provided by the Canadian government. Each province/territory has their own form of provincial health insurance. Every resident is eligible for this form of insurance, however they must apply for it. There is a waiting period before granted coverage, although wait times vary it cannot exceed three months. (Canadian Health Care, 2004) This form of insurance does not cover all health care needs. It does in fact cover primary care doctors, specialist, hospitals and...

Words: 1061 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Microinsurance Delivery Channels

...complies with the Arabic law. Interest rates, gambling, uncertainty of profits and losses are avoided as they are deemed unislamic.Growth rate was 5% 2004-2007 according to Swiss Re.Allianz Indonesia ‘Payung Keluarga’(family umbrella) offers a microtakaful life insurance which is distributed through MFI’s to its lenders which provides coverage in case of the death of a bread winner. According to the study done by the insurance provisions in the world’s 100 poor countries these Takaful systems as delivery channels almost don’t exist except in Indonesia and Srilanka. Tata-CRIG Micro-agents: works with the churches in South India to develop a system of micro agents. These are community rural insurance groups a partnership firm registered under the Andhra Pradesh Societies Act and comprise mainly of women. They are 5 low-income women living...

Words: 1809 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Community Policing

...Community Policing George Chu DeVry University Abstract Community policing is a philosophy that promotes organizational strategies, which support the organized use of partnerships and problem-solving techniques, to positively address the immediate conditions that give rise to public safety issues such as crime, social disorder and fear of crime. The police departments for many years have maintained a stressed relationship with the community it serves. The several police department has not aggressively pursued a positive image within the community. The community perceives the police in a negative perception. The community feels that the police department is out of touch with their needs and values. The community also feels that their respective neighborhoods are not safe and that the police department could do a better job of responding. Another community complaint is that the police department could do a better job of patrolling the communities. This research paper will be on community policing and it will weigh the pros and cons of community policing. This research paper will also address the part of how important community policing values of the community it serves. Community Policing Crime has been one of the most important and debated issues in the United States and is largely assumed to be a major problem that keeps getting worse. The media strongly portrays television crime stories through numerous productions. Productions such as, Without Trace, America’s...

Words: 2424 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Whimsley

...Whimsley3/18/13 Notes on Identity, Institutions, and Uprisings | Whimsley Whimsley …where Tom Slee writes about technology and politics Notes on Identity, Institutions, and Uprisings Table of Contents Intro  uc  ion d t Face  ook as a “free space” b Con  ect  ng Iden  ity to Ratio  al Choice? n i t n Iden  ity Cascades t Free Spaces and Screening Insti  u  ions and Challenges t t Con  lu  ions c s Intro  uc  ion d t Fin  sh  ng up what I said I’d fin  sh a cou  le of months ago, this is a shorter ver  ion of a i i i p s paper on “Iden  ity, Insti  u  ions, and Upris  ngs” with less math    at  cs, no ref  r  nces (see t t t i em i e e the link above) and more opin  on  t  ng. Also, a longer ver  ion of what I’m going to say at i ai s The    iz  ng the Web 2013 in a few days. or i There is a the    et    al side to the “Face  ook Rev    u  ion” debate about the role of dig    al or ic b ol t it tech  olo  ies in the 2011 “Arab Spring” upris  ngs, and it boils down to two ways of look  ng n g i i at things: the micro and the macro. On the one hand, we have the ratio  al choice, agentn based approach and on the other we have more tra  i  ional soci    og    al approaches based dt ol ic on larger-scale social structures. If you look at some of the key char  c  er  s  ics of the upris  ngs, it looks like a win for the a t i t i tomslee.net/2013/02/503.html 1/19 3/18/13 Notes on Identity, Institutions, and Uprisings | Whimsley micro side. The    ies, and...

Words: 8694 - Pages: 35

Premium Essay

Unions

...Table of Contents Cover page ………………………………………………………………………………………..1 Table of Contents …………………………………………………………………………………2 Abstract …………………………………………………………………………………..……….3 Background ……………………………………..………………………………………………4-5 Concept Definitions ……………………………………………...…………………….…….…5-6 The creation of Unions……………………………………………………………….…………6-7 Pros and Cons of Union Membership…………………………………………..…………….....7-9 Today’s need for Unions ……………..…………………………………………………..…...9-10 Conclusion ……………………………………………………………………………………....10 References ……………………………………………………………………………………….11 Abstract This paper will examine whether or not there exist a current need for labor unions. ? During the 1700’s to early 1800’s, men, women, and children were treated to unbearable working conditions, low wages, and long hours. Over time the workers became fed up of the abuse and decide to unite and make changes. This change resulted in the creation of labor unions. Through, the creation and use of these unions, workers have enjoyed perks such as 40 hour work days, certain benefits and better working conditions. Over the years, the labor force has undergone multiple changes. Laws were enacted to protect employees and hold employers accountable for their abuse of personnel. With the creation and passing of the multiply employment laws, one must ask, does the need for unions still exist? Do they still serve a function or have they out served their purpose? ...

Words: 2898 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Management

.............................................................. 3  County Map for Scenario A ......................................................................................................... 4  Urban Map for Scenario B .......................................................................................................... 5  . County Map for Scenario B ......................................................................................................... 6  Urban Map for Scenario C  .......................................................................................................... 7  . County Map for Scenario C ......................................................................................................... 8  Pros and Cons Summary Table ................................................................................................. 11  2. Urban Form ............................................................................................................................... 21  Issues to Consider for Future .................................................................................................... 21  Review of Scenarios...

Words: 42946 - Pages: 172

Premium Essay

Paper

...and Justice Administration, and was made a member of both Phi Kappa Phi and Golden Key International Honor Societies. Ms. Halliday has worked with and studied criminal justice issues in Australia, the United States, and the United Kingdom. Her current research interests include transnational sex and drug trafficking, and police fitness testing and standards. LEJA 518 - Issues paper: Police discretion. Gemma L. Halliday Western Illinois University “Enforcing the law without fear or favor” (Goldstein, 1963, p. 141). The very nature of police work is extremely complex in today’s society. Police officers play an important role comprising of many different tasks concerning; actually enforcing the criminal law, performing order maintenance and other miscellaneous services. It is through these duties and services that police are constantly intersecting and interacting with the community on a daily basis. Thus, they hold a very prominent and powerful position in society that requires them to protect these people’s morals, principles and values. And, the way in which police officers go about their duties and enforcing the law should reflect these morals, principles and values in an evolving, dynamic, and complex society (Jones, 2000; Gaines & Kappeler, 2003). Discretion plays a role in nearly every...

Words: 5049 - Pages: 21

Free Essay

Naxalism in Orissa & C-Garh

...IPCS Special Report 25 June 2006 LEFT EXTREMISM IN INDIA NAXAL MOVEMENT IN CHATTISGARH & ORISSA Rajat Kumar Kujur Research Scholar, JNU INTRODUCTION One of the striking features of the Naxal movement is that right from its inception it has remained a point of attention for academicians, journalists and, of course, politicians. However, for some reason or the other, contemporary research on Naxalism has so far been focused on West Bengal, Andhra Pradesh and, to some extent, Bihar, at the expense of ot her areas where the movement also has a strong presence. However, as Naxalism or the Naxal movement is a complex problem, it is necessary to look at the problem at specific levels in different regions. It is in this context a primary research on the Naxal Movement in the neighbouring states of Chattisgarh and Orissa, where the Naxal movement is placed at two different levels, is of considerable academic interest. This article is an attempt to explain the growth of the Naxal movement in the poor and underdeveloped regions of these two states. The focus of this paper is on I CHATTISGARH THE NAXAL WAR ZONE Chattisgarh, which is a part of the Dandakaranya region, has been a centre of Maoist activities since the early days of the People’s War. It was none other than the founding father of People’s War (PW), K. Seetharamaiah, who envisaged the idea...

Words: 6675 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Temporary Foreign Workers

...Temporary foreign worker program – Tim Hortons Introduced in 2002 and modified in 2007, this program allows employers to hire employees in occupations that usually require at most a high school diploma or a maximum of 2 years of job specific training. Visas maybe issued for 24 months. Employers are required to cover recruitment and return airfare costs, to ensure that suitable accommodation is available, to provide medical coverage until the employee is covered under a provincial plan and to sign an employee/employer contract. The work permit is issued with reference to a specific employer. Employees generally work in sectors such as cleaning, hospitality, manufacturing, oil and gas and construction. (Elgersma, 2007) Tim Hortons "is a company that a lot of Canadians identify with and it is very proudly a Canadian brand," says Howard Ramos, an associate professor of sociology at Dalhousie University in Halifax. "But it's also a company that is a pioneer in hiring temporary foreign workers and so for this reason I think it's important to highlight Tim Hortons as an exemplar of how the temporary foreign worker program has changed and expanded. (Davison, 2012) The temporary foreign worker program has man is a resort companies use to hiring as they will have exhausted all other avenues for finding employees locally. It is a great program mainly for foreign workers who come and work in Canada and if they like it here they can apply for permanent residency. Unlike immigrants...

Words: 2211 - Pages: 9