...Article Rebuttal John Alton BCOM 275 Dec. 22, 2014 Lileen Coulloudon Article Rebuttal For the subject of my article rebuttal I have chosen a topic that I wanted to educate myself on by examining both viewpoints, and evaluating my own stance once I have more information. While the real topic is very broad and covers quite a few disciplines, many people now lump several issues into one big talking point called “Common Core”. As a father of two young children this issue has a very real outcome for me, and I wanted to examine why this issue was so polarizing. As defined by www.corestandars.org, Common Core is a set of high-quality academic standards in mathematics and English language arts/literacy (ELA). These learning goals outline what a student should know and be able to do at the end of each grade. To take this issue to its simplest point, Common Core achieves its goals through standardized testing. This concept was born of the desire to benchmark American students against others. I found the need to search outside of my normal newsfeeds and websites to find an article to rebut. When I found Six ways the Common Core is Good for Students featured on the neaToday website I knew the six points were thinly veiled propaganda. It had six well defined reasons that Common Core was going to do all that it promised to do, and gave examples as well as testimonials from educators who were finding that Common Core was working. Interestingly enough, several times in the article...
Words: 739 - Pages: 3
...Florida Pension Article Rebuttal Florida Pension Article Rebuttal On May 31, 2013, Florida’s Governor Rick Scott signed Senate Bill 534 into the Florida Statues. This Bill was sponsored by Senator Jeff Brandes and imposes new financial reporting requirements for local government pension plans. However in the article titled “Florida House Passes Legislation Relating to Local Pension Plans,” Mr. Volz states that “the Bill equips local pension plan administrators, employees and taxpayers with improved universal tools to evaluate the financial stability of local pension plans.” There is no proof that this Bill is improved as the evaluation tools do not accurately evaluate the financial stability of the plans. The tool is not universal, as the State Government Plan, the Florida Retirement System, is not subject to this Bill. This article was influenced by the politicians that are for this Senate Bill. Only those that had something positive to say about it were quoted in the article. The Senate President was quoted thanking Senator Brandes, Speaker Weatherford, and the colleagues in the House for helping more the reform forward (Volz, May). This article is not reliable, credible or even valid as it does not provide any evidence to back up its claims and it only presents the one side of the story. What this article does not say is the Florida League of Cities, the Florida Public Pension Trustee Association, and the actuaries of many of the states pension plans all oppose...
Words: 687 - Pages: 3
...Article Rebuttal Annie Edwards BCOM/275 September 10, 2012 Dominic deLacy Article Rebuttal Should Welfare Recipients be tested for Drugs? Author, David Vitter speculates on his beliefs that the testing of welfare recipients for drugs use is what America needs. He believes testing for drug user would “truly” help those in need of assistance from “Temporary Assistance for Needy Families” program renew welfare reform (‘Should Welfare Recipients Be Tested for Drugs?”.2011). Vitter base parts of his argument on the “Robert Wood Johnson Foundation” reporting in 2007 approximately 20% of TANF recipients report usage of an illegal drug at least once in the past year, and at least five percent admitted that they had a substance addiction, Vitter (2011). After I analyzing the reliability, credibility, and validity of the data used by the author, some information were withheld from Vitter’s writings of the “Robert Wood Johnson Foundation” also added that the use of drugs is not as widespread among TANF recipients as studies feared (Vitter, 2011). Vitter, also base parts of his argument on stats from the “Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act saying it cut welfare money by 2.5 million dollars in 2002. Those numbers is the result of putting more people to work and found that more people are taking advantage of job training programs (Vitter, 2011). Vitter put this information in hoping that the reader will make the assumption that less money, so recipients have to go...
Words: 438 - Pages: 2
...Article Rebuttal melissa thomas BCOM/275 So many today criticize same-sex couples; saying those two women or two men loving each other is unnatural or perverted. But the world we live in today is very open and free which means the people are entitled to love and marry whom ever they chose too. An article by posted Brandon Vogt stated that marriage has always meant the union of one man and one woman. Gay and lesbian individuals cannot perform the main function of marriage which is to produce children of their own. My argument is many argue that it's also unnatural because gay and lesbians can't "procreate." They have to look at other alternatives to become parents such as adoption, surrogates, or sperm donors. I ask how this is different from heterosexual couples with infertility problems turning to these same alternatives to be able to have children. A family is what you make it, what you do to create that family is the couples choice, gay, or straight. It doesn't matter if there are two dads, two moms, or a dad and a mom. Another thing I would like to address is the statement many have made about same-sex couples that do have children will make their children turn out gay. That is not even remotely true. All of my gay and lesbian friends are the product of straight parents. One of the debatable issues is legalized marriage. Brandon stated that Most of us acknowledge the fact that there should be some limitation over same sex...
Words: 734 - Pages: 3
...Week 3 Individual Assignment - Rebuttal Paper BCOM/275 – Critical Thinking Patty Haynes 07/24/13 Virginia Carter The Rolling Stone magazine has recently been met with a slew of angry outbursts and boycotting for placing the well-known, suspected Boston Bombing Terrorist, Dzhokhar Tsarnaev on its cover this month. The magazine is under scrutiny not just for placing his picture on the cover, but for how the picture portrays the suspect. Tsarnaev’s photo is a very glamorous, dreamy eyed, tousled hair, sexier version of himself in the photo. This glorified photo is exactly how The Rolling Stone portrays famous actors and rock stars that are meant to be admired. Harold Maass is the executive editor for an online forum called The Week. He currently posted an article saying that The Rolling Stone shouldn’t be chastised for their choice and it is simply a ploy to sell heaps and heaps of magazines. He states that maybe we shouldn’t be so angry at The Rolling Stone publication because the New York Times posted it on their cover first. Maass also backs up Janet Reitman of The Rolling Stone saying that the only thing that happened here was that he happened to be a huge news feature, and features make the covers of publications. He also agrees with other authors that claim this could help the American public snap out of their daydreams and see that terrorists don’t have to be dirty, rag wearing, foreign language speaking, Muslims. While all of these comments can be boiled...
Words: 674 - Pages: 3
...MODR 1730, Debate 1: June 5th 2014 Topic: Discuss that apes and other higher primates ought to be afforded limited rights; to do otherwise is speciesism. Arguments For Apes Getting Limited Rights If apes can be defined and categorized as persons, then they are to be given equal consideration and limited basic rights such as the right not to suffer from cruel treatment (i.e. in medical experiments). To argue otherwise would be speciesism, which can be defined as a prejudice towards the interests of one's own species and against those of members of other species. Main points as to why apes can be defined as persons: 1. Some scientists have linked the 5 great apes into 1 biologically similar group (chimpanzees, gorillas, orangutans, bonobos, and humans). Humans are just another type of ape. Humans and chimpanzees are 99% identical genetically (in respects to blood type, brain structure) and they demonstrate identical behavior for the first three years. 2. According to Kant, humans are self-conscious and rational, whreas animals are not and that is why we have no direct duties to animals themselves, but rather only to humans. However scientists have found that all 5 apes (this includes humans) are self aware and morally aware, as displayed in behavior. For example, if you place a dot on a chimpanzee, they are able to recognize that and realize it does not belong. This shows that they are self aware. Moreover, by observing Kanzi, the bonobo, we can see human...
Words: 1503 - Pages: 7
...Spenser Steinman Black fish http://www.ropeofsilicon.com/problem-blackfish/ Summary-This article is a rebuttle to Blackfish’s thesis. It claims that Seaworld is actually not as villainous as Black fish makes them out to be, citing a statement seaworld made about how it rehabilitates animals, is a respected zoological foundation, and donates to conservation research. Despite this, even the writer of the article points out the easily disputable and vague statements which are cited in a message from seaworld to CNN to support the idea that Seaworld is not so terrible to it’s whales and humans. This makes for a weak rebuttle. Importance-This article is a terrible rebuttal. Characteristic of it’s failure is the fact that even the author of the article could not keep a straight train of thought to cement a solid counterargument. What this goes to show is that the counterargument truly is a weak one. Perhaps one of the only good points, presuming its true, that this article has to offer is the one to do with Sea World's monetary contributions to conservation. With Sea World going down the drains due to it’s poor orca practices it will obviously not be able to contribute to conservation, as it’s money is being drained in bad publicity and lawsuits. This will have some impact environmentally presuming that Sea World really was contributing in some meaningful way. http://www.indiewire.com/article/sundance-review-blackfish-ensures-youll-never-go-to-seaworld-again ...
Words: 535 - Pages: 3
...Knowing your Audience Paper and Communication Release Kevin Danielson BCOMB/275 October 15, 2012 Steve Boylan Article Rebuttle The Article is “Really? Don’t limit freedom to marry?” This was in the Minneapolis Star Tribune on September 23, 2012. In the article On November 6, Minnesota voters will decide whether marriage should be protected in the state Constitution. “The human race's two sexes -- male and female -- have much in common, but they also differ in fundamental ways. In the bearing and rearing of children, men and women complement one another physically, socially and emotionally. Women give birth to babies, and men beget them. Mothers tend to nurture, while fathers tend to encourage risk-taking. Boys and girls need -- and deserve -- both a father and a mother to model how to live.” (Kersten, 2012 ) Rebuttal There is no documentation stating that a child needs to have one of each sex as a role model to grow up. There are many stories out there of 2 women or 2 men raising a normal health child. You may recall a young man that spoke at the National Democratic convention, by the name of Zach Wahls. This young man was raised by 2 women and now his name is a house hold name. “I'm a sixth-generation Iowan, an Eagle Scout, and I was raised by my two moms, Jackie and Terry. People want to know what it's like having lesbian parents. I'll let you in on a secret: I'm awesome at putting the seat down. Otherwise, we're like any other family...
Words: 501 - Pages: 3
...Positive: The media is sensitive and responsible Honorable Judges, Fellow classmates, Worthy Opponents. The resolution before us today, BIRT the media is sensitive and responsible is absolutely correct. So there is no confusion about the terms, I will now define them. · Media: Means of communication, such as television, music, newspapers, and the internet, which provide the public with news and entertainment · Sensitive: Feeling or responding to the emotions of others · Responsible: One that is expected or decides to respond to an action. We the negative team firmly now must believe this to be correct, and plan to tell you why. Over the past decade, this world has made extremely rapid advancements in science, technology, health, and education. Our knowledge today of this universe is like a 20 story building compared to a centimeter tall pile of paper a hundred years ago. How have humans gained such vast intelligence? From the media! Inventions such as the newspaper, radio, television, magazines have kept us up to date with important world news which could be critical if unknown. Over the past 10 years, the internet has successfully enabled us to communicate with people on the other side of the world for virtually no cost at all! It not only helps us keep in contact with friends, but brings us new ones and even finds ones lost for years! We can learn about almost anything...
Words: 1003 - Pages: 5
...Article RebuttlePage 1 Article Rebuttle: Country or City Life University of Phoenix BCOM/275 Mr. Luna August 20, 2014 City Life or Country LifePage 2 Although it may seem to many that traffic jams on every highway in the area and people are everywhere no matter if you go to the post office or take a walk down the street is a normal part of life, but thats not always the case if you havent lived on the other side. Lots of people who grow up in the country living in small towns know that the tractor holding up traffic on the side of highway twenty one in Ironton, Missouri is the only traffic jam that they are going to be in that day and probably the rest of the month depending on what season it is and if the hay is already cut. When a person is taken from his normal life, and put into an environment that is totally different than the way they were raised, it can be very tramatizing at times. Usually people will compare the contrast of city versus country life as being taken from the jungle if you were a wild animal and put into a zoo. Country living is extremely laid back and life itself seems to go a little slower than living in the city. This is because you are raised in a way that is less stressful in all aspects of life starting from childhood and working its way into adulthood. When you are being raised in the country you are taught to be a well deciplined child and are taught to respect your elders whether it be at church, school, or even at the...
Words: 886 - Pages: 4
...United States Department of Health and Human Services: As our country struggles through tough times there is no doubt we, as a whole nation, have had to make some compromises. One of the biggest, broadest issues our country has been facing is the recent budget cuts in numerous different categories including mental health care. Mental health care has gotten the short end of the stick in the last few years, and it has become a spiraling problem in the United States. Between 2009 and 2011 the United States witnessed some of the largest state budget cuts in history, and we are still suffering from the consequences of doing so. Where does a majority of homelessness, suicide, substance abuse and jail overcrowding stem from? If you take a closer look it will become very clear that cutting the funding for mental health research and treatment has left these mentally ill patients with very few options suitable enough for their varying conditions. Due to the lack of appropriate facilities needed to properly diagnose and treat mentally ill patients, jails are becoming overcrowded and homelessness is at an all-time high. The importance of mental health care is being put on the back burner while, instead, it needs to be a priority and that is why President Obama’s proposition to increase funding to aid the mentally ill in 2014 is extremely necessary. As states cut mental health care funding, prisons are becoming an asylum. There is a very common misconception among the general public...
Words: 1630 - Pages: 7
...National Republican Debate, by Jon Bona Live from a California Convention Center that Ronald Regan took a piss in. Characters: Moderator- Megyn Kelly Participants: * Dr. Ben Carson * Donald Trump * Kermit The Frog * An actual bag filled with bricks * Bill Clinton (thug) * Kanye West PROPS IF POSSIBLE: 6 chairs or podiums. A Kermit the frog doll, puppet or stuffed toy. A laundry bag filled with bricks (if we can get bricks) SKIT BEGINS WITH SPOTLIGHT ON MEGYN KELLY TOWARDS FRONT OF STAGE. ALL OTHER LIGHTS OUT. Megyn Kelly (to the camera/ audience) ladies and gentleman, thank you for tuning-in to FOX News for the twelfth, and penultimate round of the National Republican Presidential Debates. I am your host, and propaganda supporter, Megyn Kelly. We are here live from the beautiful Staple Center in Los Angeles CA, where Ronald Regan was rumored to have urinated in in 1986. All Hail Regan. (Candidates still in the dark chant): ALL HAIL OVERLORD REGAN Megyn Kelly So here’s how this is going to work folks, I will be asking questions to the candidates concerning their knowledge on both domestic and foreign issues. Each candidate is permitted 1 minute to respond, with an additional 30 seconds awarded for each phrase ending in Regan. (candidates still in the dark): ALL HAIL OVERLORD REGAN Megyn Kelly: Without further a-do lets meet the candidates fighting for a chance to rule this country with an iron fist! (lights blink on and reveal...
Words: 1254 - Pages: 6
...Prof. Sapozhnikov Response Essay July 23, 2009 The Negative Outcome of Outsourcing As I stroll around my residence, I hear words like “globalization” and “outsourcing”, while whiteness the diversity of the population within my community. It is difficult not to see products that weren’t manufactured in China, Thailand, Japan, and other countries around the world. During Early America, outsourcing of jobs for production was once not a problem and not as prevalent as it is today. As early as the American Industrial Revolution and the shift to a capitalistic society, American workers had to sell their labor in order to make a wage for their survival. As time progressed, many rules and regulations were required for the operation of the factories in order to ensure a safe working environment and conditions for the employees. Although the government came up with labor laws, deceitful employers found alternative ways to exploit their workers to make a profit. It is possible to explore a variety of different sources and see that employers in the 21st century still use tactics by which exploit American employees by using outsourcing as a means to increase their profits. In the article “New Threat to Skilled U.S. Workers”, Froma Harrop raises awareness of the problematic issue concerning the outsourcing of American jobs to other countries. To begin the article, Harrop makes references to Princeton economist Alan Blinder and Ron Hira, a professor of public policy at the Rochester...
Words: 1213 - Pages: 5