Premium Essay

Restraint In Health Care

Submitted By
Words 740
Pages 3
2012). The death of a patient during a physical intervention in a health care environment adds an element of irony that makes the phenomenon all the more difficult to understand by people. It serves to say that a reduction in the number of restraint incidents would undoubtedly lead to a decrease in the exposure to the risk of patient death and staff injury (Duxbury 2014). An examination of patient deaths during restraint between 1979 and 2000 concluded that downwards pressure on the chest to hold a patient in likely position should be avoided (Bowers et al. 2012). It is perhaps expected that both staff and patients tend to view restraint negatively. staffs view restraint as a necessary part of their job, but one they would like to reduce …show more content…
Contrary to this background, efforts have been made to increase the active use of de-escalation interventions and to reduce forced measures in managing of patients’ aggression and violence (Kaunomäki et al. 2017). The specific strategy or strategies adopted by staff to resolve any particular incident will depend on a range of factors. One factor influencing choice of approach is the attitudes and beliefs of staff about the causes of aggression, and the most suitable ways of responding to aggressive incidents, and the Expert view globally is that the use of controlling strategies should be reduced in favour of greater employment of interpersonal approaches in the first occurrence (Pulsford et al. 2013). Staff attitudes and beliefs have been identified as one influence defining the response of mental health staff to aggressive and violent incidents, and whether staff use interpersonal or controlling methods when responding to specific incidents. (Pulsford et al. …show more content…
For patients, manual restraint can lead to feelings of anger, fear and panic, and a sense that their concerns had been overlooked prior to the incident or that their behaviour had not necessitated the use of restraint (Bowers et al. 2012). Qualitative study by Hinsby & Baker (2004) with patients and staff in a medium secure unit showed that the patients put more emphasis on external and situational causative factors for aggression than staff (Pulsford et al. 2013). studies have sought to establish the views of patients in a high secure setting regarding patient aggression (Meehan et al. 2006). Patients who took part in a focus groups believed that the reason of aggression could be found in the physical environment of the ward, boredom and the lack of meaningful activities, superior and controlling attitudes and interactions by staff, and the controlling use of medication. They also proposed that patients’ illnesses could be a factor in their responding aggressively to situations, but believed that they tried hard to control their behaviour. When considering ways of handling aggression, respondents had mixed views, recognizing that controlling strategies were appropriate in some cases where patients were attacking other patients, but also stressing the value

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Nursing Interventions for Patient Safety

...Interventions for Patient Safety The evolution of nursing is one that is rich in history and clinical practices and has existed for hundreds of years for health care issues. This author has work experiences from 1978 to 1996 as a nurse and nursing consultant in long term care and has a personal interest in how the use of restraints has evolved to a patient focused and caring approach that has reduced the rates of restraint use and patient injuries. Nursing evidence based practices for patient safety evolves from current technological advances, research and nursing theory. The purpose of this paper is to address how nursing clinical practices evolved for the use of patient restraints in health care facilities. Identification and Discussion of Health Care Issue The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) defines a physical restraint as “any manual method or physical or mechanical device, material, or equipment attached or adjacent to the resident’s body that the individual cannot remove easily which restricts freedom of movement or normal access to one’s body” (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2001). Physical force can be human, mechanical devices, or a combination. Some Items that can be used to physically restrain people include bed side rails, waist belts, vests or jackets, hand mitts, arm and leg restraints. This author has witnessed wheel chairs being tied to hallways handrails; patients tied into wheel chairs with sheets; bed sheets wrapped tightly...

Words: 2118 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Nursing Sensitive Indicators

...this case in identifying issues that may interfere with patient care. Nursing-sensitive indicators are determinations used to delineate the excellence of nursing interventions and positive patient outcomes. This is not a new concept. In the 1800’s, Florence Nightingale, a promoter of outcomes, revealed such indicators when she revealed her statistical findings of soldier’s mortality rate associated to environmental conditions during the Crimean War (Fee & Garofalo, 2010). Over the past decades, various studies world-wide have been conducted on the connection of nursing quality indicators and their outcomes. The American Nurses Association (ANA) recognized these studies were an important focus in evidenced-based practice among the nursing profession; and in 1998, they established a program for implementing, developing and storing these nursing-sensitive indicators, known as the National Database of Nursing Quality Indicators (NDNQI) (ANA, 2014). The NDNQI serves as a valuable resource for hospitals nationwide at the acute level for administrators and nurses alike to compare various indicators and outcomes with that of other facilities to determine best practices for patients and staff. In the case of Mr. J, it is clear the nurse caring for this patient had little or no knowledge of indicators of restraint prevalence. However, my initial concern after reading this case was why this patient was in restraints to begin with. There is no indication that this patient was...

Words: 1263 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Organizational Systems and Quality Leadership

...complex healthcare systems. Hospitals, a primary care delivery portal within the health system, are inundated with patients requiring higher acuity care. Nurses must be prepared to recognize patients’ health care needs and provide quality patient care outcomes. The knowledge of nursing sensitive indicators can be helpful in providing the care which meets quality standards. Nursing sensitive indicators rely on evidence-based practice. The American Nurses Association created a repository for implementing, developing, and storing nursing sensitive indicators in the National Database of Nursing Quality Indicators, or NDNQI. The nursing sensitive indicators are a set of standardized performance measures intended to help hospitals assess the extent to which nursing interventions have an impact on patient safety, quality, and the professional work environment (Erickson, J. 2011). Nurses directly impact these measures and when evidence-based practices are adopted, patient care improves as shown in historical outcomes data. In the scenario of Mr. J there were multiple failures to recognize and use nursing procedural sensitive measures to improve his safety, quality of care, and patient satisfaction. Although Mr. J had mild dementia, he was appropriately responsive, cooperative and was not a danger to himself or others. Evidence based practice does not support the use of restraints in Mr. J’s current condition. According to the ANA, restraints should be used only when there are no other...

Words: 1617 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

James Lomax Chapter Summary

...Author James Lomax is the Associate Chairman and Director of Educational Programs at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston Texas. Lomax gives us the background of the late 1700s, when physician Philippe Pinel introduced his revolutionary concept of releasing restrained patients. He explains that before the 1700s, patients with mental health disorders were seen as possessed by a demon or worse. Richard Noll, PhD, a clinical psychologist and author who received his doctorate from the New School for Social Research, gives us more detail about the health care system during the time of Pinel, painting an image of cruel and inhuman treatment of patients. When Pinel took over a mental health hospital in France that was known to be the worst in the...

Words: 418 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Ethics of Chemical and Physical Restraints

...Ethics of Chemical and Physical Restraints Ethics of Chemical and Physical Restraints A restraint is the use of some kind of equipment or drug used for the purpose of restricting a patient from free will movements. There are times when using restraints would seem like the best thing to do for a patient, but in-fact it could be quite the opposite. Agens Jr., J. (2010). The use of restraints is mostly used to deal with an agitated patient, mainly can be found in residential-care facilities. Those 65 years and older have been reported to have higher restraint use rate in residential and acute care facilities. Many have been found with at least two different types of restraints at the same time. Mott, S., Poole, J., & Kenrick, M. (2005). How often restraints are used often will depend on what kind of restraint is used and the setting that it is being used in. According to Agens Jr., J. (2010) that in the health care facility setting has reported a 7.4% to 17% restraint use ten years ago, and a decade before that it was 28%-37%. Thanks to the Department of Health and Human Services and the new rules that the CMS put into effect in 2007, restraint use is down about 5%. The use of Chemical restraints is a bit higher than physical restraints that reached upwards to 34% in the long term care facilities. However, there is some hope that this number will decrease because of the US government regulation. Chemical and physical restraint use has been known to cause many hazards...

Words: 1347 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Rtt 1 Task 1

...RTT 1 Task 1 Many factors come into play when determining what contributes to quality care of patients in a healthcare setting. The use of nursing sensitive indicators assists healthcare workers in providing the highest quality of care possible to their patients. When these indicators are used, and followed by those providing care, higher standards are met, allowing for patients to receive a much higher quality of care while being involved in the healthcare system. A. Nursing Sensitive Indicators By learning and understanding nursing sensitive indicators, a nurse is given the opportunity to identify factors that may affect the quality of care being delivered to a patient. In the scenario given, Mr J., a 72-year-old rabbi with dementia, has fractured a hip following a fall in his home. He has been given pain medications, which have made him sleepy, but he is still able to communicate effectively. Mr J’s daughter has come to visit, and found him lying in his bed, on his back, restrained. The first nursing sensitive indicator that could be implemented by the nursing staff is regarding the use of restraints. The use of restraints in this case is most likely unnecessary. Although the patient has previously been diagnosed with dementia, he is able to recognize his daughter upon her arrival, and notify her of his need to use the restroom. Regarding the use of restraints, patient restraint should be considered when a careful assessment establishes that the patient is a danger...

Words: 1104 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Restraints

...Working on an acute inpatient psychiatric unit in the City Health Care System is not a job for the faint of heart. On a daily basis nurses have to choose between whether a patient should be left alone to commit, self-harm, harm to others or be place in four points restraint. This ethical dilemma can lead to several hard consequences. The primary nurse rapport that was built with the patient has now been diminish the patient trust no-ones and continues to decompensate. In my conversation with some of the patients in regards to care and treatment, proved that the health care system that was supposed to help and protect this population failed in such endeavors. This system was cited by many to be broken, cruel and misrepresented. One patient quoted “being in restraint reminds me of my miserable past, my stepdad got revenge by tying me to my bed as a form of punishment for standing up to him whenever he physically abuses my mother.” In my capstone project I will try to provide an alternate to the frequent use of restraint by designing and incorporating music as an outlet for expression. In this project I will try to show the effect therapeutic music and involving the patient in the selection process can reduce the violence, self- harm and subsequently the ultimate use of four- point restraints. Music is an ancient art that has soothed minds for centuries. Music helps people regain inner peace and is the voice that binds people together. It has been used to treat the sick since...

Words: 501 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Mentally Ill Inmates

...Introduction 3 Population of Mentally Ill Inmates in the Correctional Facilities 3 Mentally ill inmates: The Cost 4 The Treatment of Mentally Ill Inmates 6 Selection Process for Mentally Ill Inmates 7 Isolation and Restraints 9 Conclusion 11 References 12   Introduction When a person thinks about a correction facility many only think that there is only regular criminals that are perfectly well, but what they neglect to know is that it is also housed with mentally ill inmates as well. Many of the people has been brained washed by media and movies that prisoners are to be normal criminals who have done things wrong in which has lead into a correction facility but what the fail to publicize is that they are also house by people who are not mentally stable, and who may receive different treatment from regular inmates. Correctional facilities have many types of inmates and undergo various dilemmas therefore they must try to deal with the cost of the inmates, provide different treatment and must undergo special screening in order to determine if they are ill or not. Population of Mentally Ill Inmates in the Correctional Facilities The country that has the greatest rate of adult imprisonment is the United States; it has 2.2 million presently in the correctional facilities (Annaceri, 2007). Individuals with psychological problems have been progressively more imprisoned within the last three decades, most likely the consequence of the deinstitutionalization of the state psychological...

Words: 2481 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Quantitative Research

...Qualitative Research Report Grand Canyon University NRS 433V: Introduction to Nursing Research February 27 2011 Critique of Qualitative Research Introduction Restraints are methods used in the medical field in an effort to restrict the movement of a patient in order to protect the safety of the patient, other patients, and caregivers. Since the onset of the use of restraints, this practice has been an ethical issue and topic for discussion. Further, it continues to be a concern in the health care industry because of the physical, emotional and psychological freedom involved. A study conducted by Hantikainen and Kappeli (2000) interviewed 20 skilled and untrained nursing staff from two nursing homes in a German speaking area in Switzerland. The authors concluded that there is no clear agreement on the definition of restraints and, as such, this lack of clarity translates to the nursing staff inconsistency and corresponding defensive behavior. Further, they felt the crucial component of establishing “restraint-free care” is nursing staff’s understanding of the impact of their personal perceptions of their thinking on their application of restraint policy. The intent of this qualitative research study was to discover nursing staff member’s perceptions on the use of restraints and how these insights affect their decisions at bedside (Hantikainen and Kappeli, 2000). This paper will review the above research article to critically analyze: the introduction and...

Words: 1678 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Health and Safety in Health and Social Care

...Health and Safety in the Health and Social Care Workplace INTRODUCTION (300 words) This essay will look at three different learning outcomes, each using a specific case study for illustration. The first part will focus on the issues relating to health and safety legislation and how these are implemented in the work place. The Health and Safety can trace its origin back to the year 1833 when The Factories Act led to the creation of the first factory inspectors and whose role was initially tasked with only preventing injury amongst child workers (Jarvis, 2011). This has significantly developed, since then, into a ‘must-have’ policy at work places not just here in the UK but throughout the European Unions (EU). The case of North Staffordshire combined NHS Trust (NSC) which will be discussed in some detail is living proof that Health and Safety, if managed effectively, could lead to better outcomes for all stakeholders. The second part of this essay will focus on the practicalities and the implementation mechanism of Health and Safety at work or lack thereof and the consequences that an organisation which transgresses may suffer for non-compliance as seen in the case of South Birmingham Primary Care Trust. To this end, issues such as lifting and handling heavy loads as well as other dilemma faced by organisations in relation to health and safety will be explored with a view to grasping the implications not only at individual levels but also at corporate level. The final...

Words: 3670 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Article Critique

...HSC 300 Article Critique 6 Warning Signs of Nursing Home Abuse & Neglect May 30, 2015 HSC 300 – Legal and Ethical Issues and Health Professions Dr. Louis Yu 6 Warning Signs of Nursing Home Abuse & Neglect 6 Warning Signs of nursing Home Abuse & Neglect, by Consumer Justice Group (2015), is an interesting article about what senior citizens may experience if they are residing in a nursing home. In Chapter 13 - Patient Abuse, of Legal and Ethical Issues for Health Professionals, Pogzar mentions how serious senior abuse is in America. According to Pogzar (2013), “Most states have enacted statutes mandating the reporting of senior abuse. Seniors often fail to report incidents of abuse because they fear retaliation and being believed. Undue pain, abandonment, and premature death should not happen to senior citizens that are living in a nursing home but it does happen often. The article gives 6 warning signs to be aware if an individual has a loved one in a nursing home or assistant living facility. The most common is weight loss, bruises, bedsores, falls, staff inattention and restraints. Negligent nursing homes often do not have the sufficient amount of staff members to care for their resident. The staff may not provide or ensure that the resident is getting the proper nutrition needed and the most medication of the elderly affects their appetite and they do not want to eat. Bruises are obviously another...

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Nurs 440 Workplace

...paper is the examination of the vulnerable population of the mentally ill. Second, this paper will review the goals and agenda of Healthy People 2020 as it applies to mental illness. Third, this paper will review my work place assessment for barriers for the care and treatment of mentally ill patients. Finally, this paper will review a short presentation I gave to co-workers in an effort to aid in better treatment for the mentally ill. Recent figures suggest that in 2004, approximately 1 in 4 adults in the United States had had a mental health disorder in the past year, most commonly anxiety or depression ("Healthy People 2020 ", n.d.).. It is estimated that only about 17% of U.S. adults are considered to be in a state of optimal mental health ("Healthy People 2020 ", n.d.). An estimated 26% of Americans age 18 and older are living with a mental health disorder in any given year, and 46% will have a mental health disorder over the course of their lifetime ("Healthy People 2020 ", n.d.). Mental health disorders often have a serious impact on physical health and are associated with the prevalence, progression, and outcome of some of today’s most pressing chronic diseases including diabetes, heart disease, and cancer. Mental health disorders can have harmful and long-lasting effects—including high psychosocial and economic costs. These effects apply not only for the people living with the disorder, but also for their families, schools, workplaces, and communities. For these reasons...

Words: 1547 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Seclusion in Mental Health

...intervention regulated by Mental Health Act 1986 (New South Wales Government, 2012). In the light of advocate for the person’s rights, privacy, dignity or self-respect for individual with brain- affected illness the practice of seclusion is the current main concern of mental health. According to the prescribed article, this issue was raised again as a main focus of ACT forum reviewing on the achievement of seclusion reduction, the barriers of elimination of this practice and experts’ opinions regarding alternative interventions (Peake, 2013). The negative impact of this practice on health care providers and mental health service recipients has been acknowledged. However, seclusion receives wide support from health care providers, particularly nurses as a necessary behaviour management therapy (Happell & Koehn, 2010). Many efforts have been made to reduce the use of seclusion but elimination of the practice is still controversial. This essay will discuss the use of seclusion as an intervention of maintaining safety in psychiatric setting and the detrimental impact of the practice on the individuals involved and, at the same time examine on better alternative measures and the opportunities to eliminate the practising of the intervention in different mental health care settings. Aggression and violence that leads to the consequence of injury to self or other and damaging property are considered as destructive, challenging, behaviours in mental health setting, where zero violence...

Words: 1863 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Associate Degree Nursing Versus Baccalaureate Nursing

...economical way of becoming a registered nurse in a short period of time” (Raines & Taglaireni, 2008). “Achieving an Associate Degree in Nursing might alleviate the nursing shortage in a shorter amount of time” (Seago & Spetz, 2002). A diploma nursing program is a three year program based out of a hospital setting and focuses mostly on nursing education and skills provided at a hospital (Hood, 2010). “The typical focus of Associate Degree nurses is on substantial clinical experience and technical nursing skills needed to provide nursing care for explicit patient situations at the bedside” (Starr & Edwards, 2010). All of these programs take the Nursing Licensure Examination for Registered Nurses (NCLEX-RN). “Associate Degree Nursing skills focus around being a caregiver, counselor, and educator” (Hood, 2010). When working in a hospital setting there is a lot of education to patients provided along with giving the nursing care. “Associate Degree nurses provide care to individual clients with common, well-defined nursing diagnoses while considering clients’ familial relationships” (Hood, 2010). Experienced and talented nurses who have their Associate Degree in Nursing can be in management and leadership roles and that has been found to be true in nursing homes (J. S. Hayden, personal communication, October 6, 2010). So some nurses who may not want to further their education can still get management positions in a geriatric facility that do...

Words: 1135 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Rtt1 Task 1

...facility. The Process is aspect of policies and procedures at the facility and Outcomes are determined when greater levels of nursing care and quantity are involved with better patient outcomes (ANA, 2015). Nursing-Sensitive Indicators The scenario paints a picture of multiple areas that should be approved on and addressed by management. The use of restraints, as described by the scenario, indicates a clear lack of knowledge in regards to nursing-sensitive indicators, the use of restraints and subsequent pressure ulcer formation is directly related and reflects on all 3 aspects of the indicators. The American Nurses Association, ANA, recommends that restraints only be used when no other viable options are available and this is also the case with the organization that I am involved with as a RN, Seton Health. While reading the scenario, it did not mention patient behavior that would justify the use of restraints; there is no mention of medical or behavioral interference that could possibly require the need to use restraints. The patient is elderly, has a history of mild dementia and a fractured hip, none of these should require the use of restraints but they all create conditions that place the patient at higher risk of developing secondary injuries due to being confined to a bed. The scenario of a patient with dementia is familiar to me, taking care of these patients can be stressful and place greater pressure of nursing staff and these patients...

Words: 1321 - Pages: 6