Premium Essay

Single Payer Research Paper

Submitted By
Words 1509
Pages 7
Single-Payer a Nightmare for Quality Care Single payer is a great idea in theory, however, in reality, it adversely affects the quality of care patients receive which can change health outcomes. While the cost of care is a problem for a lot of middle and lower income Americans without insurance the system we currently have in place provides them with access to one of the best medical systems in the world. We could fix the issues with our system using free market principles and removing government from the doctor’s office, which will drive down costs and improve the quality of care patients receive, when they go to see a physician. According to Pearl, a lot of the cost issues can be fixed by organizations embracing new technologies, the government …show more content…
According to Credo, a Brookings Institution report, which looked at how the poor utilized health care in 1964 before Medicare was passed and found the poor utilized services 20% less before enactment by the federal government, which may support the claim that financial pressures place a limit on consumer behavior and not health (“Right to Health Care”). Battistella reports in his talk about his book to Cornell faculty and students that the health care industry is the most backwards industry in the US economy because of having little or no transparency for consumers and the contention which has existed between organized medicine and health care administrators because doctors have always wanted to be the judge of patient care not administrators. If we adopt modern managerial best practices, consolidate the industry, and develop new technology for the industry, we can see an end to what has long been noted as the, “cottage industry,” with a large number of small companies which need to be consolidated, where quality control and productivity have been laxed creating …show more content…
The American system would suffer from increased wait times and a worse quality of patient care, then they do now with the enactment of a single payer style system affecting our current system’s excellence. According to an article published in the Atlantic by Khazan, if we were to enact a single payer program we could see 57 million more Americans going to the doctor and 4.7 million going to the emergency room (ER) which is a good and a bad thing, because if we look at the Canadian system 33% of their patients wait upwards of 6 or more days to see a specialist and one in ten will spend upwards of eight hours to receive care in the ER (Khazan). According to Credo, The Association of American Medical Colleges predicts a doctor shortage of 63,000 due to the implementation of Obamacare imagine more people gaining health insurance. The British National Health Services discovered in a report that it was in dire need of new doctors with 2.71 doctors for every 1,000 people which is the second lowest of all European countries (“Right to Health care”). The way in which our current system works payment provides a form of rationing which limits wait times and provides people with the top notch care they expect in the process because consumer controls are in place, unlike in Canada, which has enacted a single payer program trying to help people when in fact it does the

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Single Payer System Research Paper

...What is a Single-Payer System? “Single-payer national health insurance, also known as “Medicare for all,” is a system in which a single public or quasi-public agency organizes health care financing, but the delivery of care remains largely in private hands. Under a single-payer system, all residents of the U.S. would be covered for all medically necessary services, including doctor, hospital, preventive, long-term care, mental health, reproductive health care, dental, vision, prescription drug and medical supply costs (PHNP 2015).” According to the ObamaCare Facts article; “Since 1984 Australia has had a Medicare for all system that is publicly funded with a private option on top of that. The cost is a 1.5% income tax levy. There is an exception...

Words: 1192 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Single Payer Cost Of Care Research Paper

...Single-Payer the Only Way to provide Quality Care Single payer is a great idea which positively affects the quality of care patients receive which can change health outcomes for millions of Americans by providing piece of mind whenever a person goes to see a doctor. The cost of care is a problem for a lot of Americans with and without insurance and the system Americans currently have in place provides people with too little, too much, or no access to one of the best medical systems in the world. Americans could fix the issues with our system by adopting a national single payer program, which would drive down costs and improve the quality of care patients receive, when they go to see a physician. Doctor Fredrick Dodge Mott, was the Chief...

Words: 1650 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Single Pay System

...PubHealth129- Final Paper TA: Vinne 12/12/12 Single-Payer Systems The United States health care system and the health coverage it has for its citizens are both unmistakably flawed. While our country offers many means of achieving health insurance like private, employer, and government assisted, twenty percent of citizens still do not even have health insurance. This means that these people are not getting coverage on their medical bills, and are therefore a lot less likely to visit the doctor until there is no choice. Even people who do have health insurance in the United States still do not get the affordable, comprehensive coverage they should. Compared to similar industrialized nations, we are far behind their level of comprehensive and affordable services. These countries often have what is called a single-payer system. The single-payer system is a health care plan that funds every person’s medical expenses from the same pool of money. The challenges of implementing the single-payer system are going to be from political barriers and transitioning the United States from a mixed insurance system. There are both advantages and disadvantages to this type of insurance mechanism, but this method has proven to have worked. There is no reason not to implement this advantageous system in America. Right now the insurance industry in the United States is not only complex, but inadequate. There are tens of thousands of different health care organizations; HMOs, private billings...

Words: 1351 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Questioning Assumptions About Healthcare Systems

...of Medicine report identifies six major areas of medical waste: unnecessary services; inefficient delivery of care; excess administrative costs; inflated prices; prevention failures; and fraud (http://www.iom.edu, 2012). Americans spend twice as much on health care per capita than any other country in the world. In fact, according to a series of studies by the consulting firm McKinsey & Co, the US spends more on health care than the next ten biggest spenders combined: Japan, Germany, France, China, the U.K., Italy, Canada, Brazil, Spain, and Australia (http://www.mckinsey.com, 2008) Introduction Most industrialized nations have single payer systems. Many argue that such a system would eliminate the convoluted paperwork and corresponding costs associated with administrative work. Why has there been such resistance to a single payer system in the U.S.? The issue of an uninsured population continues to be a major problem in the United States. Throughout every campaign, politicians pledge...

Words: 1033 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Healthcare

...Medicaid, the federal government and state are lacking to meet the increasing costs. In the United States, the health care costs are a lot higher than other advanced nation. According to The Common Wealth Fund, the number of uninsured went from “39.8 million to 43.6 million,” a 9.5 percent jump, from the year 2000 to 2002. (Davis, 2004) “Rising health care costs are a problem for all Americans, but they weigh especially heavily on uninsured and “underinsured” individuals, who pay much of the cost of their health care directly out-of-pocket.” (The Common Wealth Fund, 2004) The higher the costs are to patients, will result in the underuse of suitable care and cause a great financial burden on the sick. After some thoroughly research, I have found that the Single-Payer Health System is the way for the future in the United States. We are no longer able to afford and/or tolerate careless spending on care that is not beneficial to patients or the repeat of over costly and unnecessary procedures. Below is a chart from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, showing the number of persons without health insurance coverage by age group: United States, 1997-2008. (2009) Table 1.1a. Number of persons without health insurance coverage, by age group: United States, 1997–2008 Year Number in millions: all ages Number in millions: under 65 years Number in millions: 18–64 years Number in millions: under 18 years 1997 41.0 40.7 30.8 9.9 1998 39.3 39.0 30.0 9...

Words: 2040 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Single Payer Health Care System

...Single Payer Health Care System Purpose – The focus of this research is to identify, analyze and evaluate a type of health care system called Single Payer Health Care System by finding answers to the following questions. Health care is one of the basic necessities that a government should provide to its citizens. Single Payer Health Care systems are catered towards the well-being of its citizens that regard people’s health as their main priority. What is a single-payer health care system? Single-payer national health insurance, also known as “Medicare for all,” is a system in which a single public or quasi-public agency organizes health care financing, but the delivery of care remains largely in private hands. Under a single-payer system, all residents of a country would be covered for all medically necessary services, including doctor, hospital, preventive, long-term care, mental health, reproductive health care, dental, vision, prescription drug and medical supply costs. The program would have a single public system of administration, eliminating the present highly expensive multiple, fragmented, and duplicative system operated by different government agencies and private hospitals. The whole operation would be paid by a combination of present Medicare and Medicaid expenditures, existing state and local expenditures for health services, mandated employer contributions, and additional tax revenues equal to the amounts now spent by citizens out of pocket, savings obtained...

Words: 2570 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

The Fate of Uninsured Veterans

...Policy Analysis Paper The fate of uninsured Veterans: A policy Analysis University of Mississippi Medical Center School of Nursing Define the problem and assemble the evidence Too many Veterans in the United States lack health insurance and are ineligible to receive care provided by the Veteran’s Health Administration. According to American Community Survey (ACS) conducted in 2010, one in 10 of the nation’s 12.5 million veterans under the age of 65 is uninsured. A veteran is defined by federal law as any person who served for any length of time in any military service branch. Contrary to the presumption of most, not all veterans qualify for free healthcare through the Department of Veteran Affairs. The Veterans Health Administration (VHA) operates as a branch of the Department of Veterans Affairs and is the largest health system in the nation. It is recognized for its commitment to providing high-quality population specific healthcare. The VHA also works closely with academic medical centers across the nation. Haley and Kenney (2012) identify eligibility for health care provided by the VHA as being on veteran status, service-connected disabilities and income level. Other factors include demographic location and cost sharing requirements. Health insurance coverage for veterans as with other groups of nonelderly adults has heavy dependence on access to employer sponsored insurance (ESI) and the costs of obtaining it. It must also be considered that the majority of...

Words: 6628 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Could Healthcare Reform Improve Its Current Overburdened Healthcare System?

...Introduction United States has one of the highest GDP among developed nations yet it fails to deliver a widespread and affordable health care to its citizens. Will health care reform be able to deliver quality services at affordable cost with its existing workforce crisis in the healthcare system? Number of uninsured Americans has significantly increased, mainly due to aging population and income change. The prevalent issue of America’s healthcare system is insurance coverage, access to healthcare. Americans believe this issue should be prioritized, and it is the direct responsibility of federal government to ensure medical care for those citizens that lack insurance. This essay include history of United States healthcare system, its evolution and how healthcare providers can contain costs of healthcare and provide quality and access to healthcare for everyone. From the beginning of 2014 Affordable Care Act by Obama government is trying to solve the enduring issue of American healthcare system. It is a step in the right direction but this reform is facing lots of resistance from Republican Party, that this reform will put country in debt stress. Many Americans are concerned with quality and access to healthcare with the influx in number of insured entering the healthcare system which is already facing the workforce crisis. United States Health care History Healthcare in United States is enduring issue and it is very sensitive subjects for Americans. United states...

Words: 2652 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Healthcare

...care U.S vs. Canada” There are two different ways in which to approach the concept of universal health care one system can be described by aspects of Canada and another system can be described from modeling the current U.S system. The current President and his administration will deal with the daunting task of creating a universal health care plan and making health care affordable for the average American. In their quest to create a universal health care plan they may look towards our friends north of the border. Canada has implemented a Universal health care plan that has been running for several years, abet its health care system is not perfect; it is important for the United states listen to its neighbors and research the possible downfalls. This research paper will discuss the possibility of using the Canadian Health care system as model to improve universal health care in the United States. Many ask how Canada Manage to offer such a comprehensive health care system does. The answer to this question isimply put is money. Health care in Canada is funded by publically funded health care system. The Canada Health care act created five provisions that each provinces and territories would have to meet in order to retain federal monies. These provisions included: • Public Administration: All administration of provincial health insurance must be carried out by a public authority on a non-profit basis. They also must be accountable to the province or territory, and their records...

Words: 2177 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Taxation and Sme Perfomance

...IMPACT OF TAXATION ON PERFORMANCE OF SMALL AND MEDIUM ENTERPRISES IN MUKONO TOWN COUNCIL BY WOLIJJA ROSERN REG. NO: 10/U/7704/EKE/PE A RESEARCH PROPOSAL SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF ARTS AND SOCIAL SCIENCES IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF THE DEGREE OF BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS OF KYAMBOGO UNIVERSITY JULY 2013 DECLARATION I………………………………… hereby declare to the academic board of Kyambogo University that this is my own work from my effort and that it has never been presented to any university or any institution of higher learning for the award of a diploma or a degree. Signed: ……………….. Name: Date:…………………… APPROVAL This is to certify that this research proposal by………………………………………………. ……………………………..Reg.No……………… carried out under my supervision. I recommend that it is now ready for submission to the academic board, Kyambogo University with my due approval. Signed: …………………Date: …………………….. MS University Supervisor Signed:………………… Date:…………………. Ms.……………………….. Supervisor DEDICATION I wish to dedicate this piece of work to my father Mr.………………..and my mother Mrs.……… who saw enlightenment in education and sent me to school. I also dedicate this report to my Supervisor Mr.………………………… who has struggled much so that I bring out good presentable...

Words: 10001 - Pages: 41

Premium Essay

U.S. Compared to Canada

...Abstract The purpose of this researcher paper to compare health care systems in three highly advanced developed countries: The United States of America, Canada and Germany. The first part of this research paper will focus on the portrayal of health care systems in the above-mentioned countries, while the second part will examine, evaluated and compare the three systems. Finally, a synopsis of recent changes and proposed future reforms in theses countries will be provided as well. The U.S. Health Care System in Perspective According to (The World Bank Group, 2012), the United States is one of the wealthiest nations in the world. The U.S. health care delivery system is complex and massive. It is ran by the government and financed through general taxes. 49.9 million Americans were uninsured in 2010 and 256.2 million were insured (Stark, 2012). The U.S. health care delivery is divided into many sub systems: Managed Care, Military, Vulnerable Populations and Integrated Delivery. Managed Care seeks to achieve efficiency by integrating the basic functions of healthcare delivery. It is the most leading health care delivery system in the United States and is available to most Americans. Employers and government are the primary financiers of managed care. The Military medical care system is available free of charge to active duty military personnel of the U.S. Army, Navy, Air Force and Costal Guard. Certain uniformed nonmilitary services such as the Public Health Services and...

Words: 664 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Income Tax Administration and Performance of Small Scale Enterprises in Uganda

...ABSTRACT   The research study was aimed at establishing effect of Income Tax Administration on the performance of small Scale Enterprises. Using Gulu Municipality as a case, in all Small Scale Businesses which were selected were analyzed and supplementary data was got from the respondents. The objectives of the study were to examine the Income Tax Administration, to examine the Performance of SSEs in terms of Growth, Profitability, and Survival, to find out the relationship between income tax administration and the performance of SSEs.   In the methodology the researcher used research design, study population, sampling procedures which included sample design and also sample size, the data sources like primary data, secondary data, data collection methods and other methods of collecting data.    Presentation, interpretation, and the discussions of the findings basing on the responses from the respondents of the questions and the findings were tax payers don’t get tax education, make little profits from their business among others Summary, conclusions, recommendations of the findings of the research analysis the findings of the study and draws summary of the main findings of the study and finally the research draws and gives recommendation and further research. CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND 1.1 - Introduction This chapter covers the introduction, background of the problem, statement of the problem research objectives, research questions,...

Words: 7597 - Pages: 31

Free Essay

Charter Schools Essay

...schools are. There is no tuition to attend a charter school, and it is freely available to any student who wishes to enroll. Charter schools are legally obligated to state and federal academic standards. Charter schools can make a difference in the community by having an arranged schedule for students, parents, and educators to follow. Parents, who work during school hours and have no one to pick up their children from school, can have their children attend evening, or weekend classes to make up for lost time in school. Students who are struggling with their academics can take weekend, or summer school classes to enhance their learning abilities. With evening, weekend, and summer school classes, teachers can have more time to grade papers, create lesson plans, and receive more pay. Osborne says in his article that “These changes in charter schools are constructive for everyone”. (Osborne, D 2012). Ninety percent of people today chose...

Words: 962 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Healthcare Bill

...amount of social media to air their views and ideology to the American public. While the Republicans spread doubt and fear about the bill, the democrats, conversely, overselling the probable effectiveness of Obamacare. With all this information swirling around the national discussion it is difficult to know exactly what’s true about the bill and what isn’t. Perhaps the most important consequence of this political battle is that currently 500,000 government workers are out of work and not being paid while this shut down plays itself out. This furlough is not only hurting those workers and their families but also proving to have negative implications for the national economy and world stock indexes as uneasiness about the future increases. This paper will discuss the major events of the healthcare debate over the past 20 years that have brought us to this point of unprecedented government gridlock. The modern healthcare debate started in the early nineties with the presidential election of Bill Clinton....

Words: 1824 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Universal Healthcare for Illinois

...hope to see it in action soon. Funding is a major issue since all citizens of Illinois will be covered by the plan. There are specific provisions included within HB0942 which range from medical services to long term care to job placement for anyone affected. Overview of the Problem Today, many Illinoisans are facing an enormous problem: the rising cost of healthcare. Currently, our state’s medical care cost, as of all America, is outrageously expensive while the quality of care is inadequate compared to other countries around the world. Using the latest statistics by the Physicians for a National Health Program Illinois (PNHP), approximately 1.8 million of the 13 million citizens of Illinois are lacking healthcare coverage ("A Single-Payer Statewide," 2013). It is very clear that the system the state is currently using is not working. For this reason, a new bill is in the process of being passed. The rising cost and lack of access to healthcare is causing a huge dilemma for the uninsured and the underinsured citizens living in Illinois. This problem has been created largely in part by the for-profit insurance companies that currently run the healthcare market across the nation. The PNHP estimates that nearly 31% of Illinois’ healthcare budget goes directly to administration of doctors and hospitals who directly deal with the bureaucracy of...

Words: 3383 - Pages: 14