We all have our opinion, some good some bad, some of them are right and some of them are wrong, some people speak it outloud and others hold it in. But whatever your opinion is it don't matter to me, I won't think differently of you, so I expect the same from you. First things first my opinion in James Thirst short story, The Scarlet Ibis, is that the brother did it. Thers is just so much evidence from the story that point too brother and there is no way you could say he's not guilty. There are some good things that brother does but the bad outweighs the good.

First off brother really did not show that much love to brother to Doodle. He would always gripe about taking him every where he went and stuff. If you really loved someone you would