Free Essay

The Debate over Socialized Healthcare

In:

Submitted By Ramlad1
Words 1888
Pages 8
The Debate over Socialized Healthcare The topic of socialized healthcare has been a hot topic for awhile, with both sides having great arguments it’s hard to make a decision. Both sides should strive to meet in the middle, so less people will suffer the consequences of not having healthcare. No matter what side people take it is obvious that a change needs to happen. Our current health care system is a mess, and no one is benefiting from the system, expect for the greedy drug and insurances companies. The current health care system needs a change, and to change we need to identify the problems and come up with sustainable solutions. One side of the debate believes that socialized healthcare is the solution to fix America’s health care crisis, and wants everyone to receive care. The other side believes that socialized healthcare is not the solution. If people wanted health care they should pay for it. The start of this debate stems from current issues on health care in the United States.
With health insurance becoming increasingly unaffordable the overall health of USA has gone down. “The cost of health care keeps rising 7% each year” (Collins, R,2011, paragraph 2), with costs rising health insurance coverage is going down, making it more difficult for people to pay to get treatment. Without the right medical help and check ups its hard to sustain a healthy lifestyle to prolong life. “People shouldn’t have to pay to live a healthy life” (Davenport, K, 2012 para.3), as a society Americans should care about its citizens and help them live a healthy life. “To many US citizens die because they don’t get the care they need” (Davis, J, 2012, para 1), it is not fair to people to die just because they don’t have insurance. Even if people are insured they may not be able to go to the doctor as much as they would like because it costs too much, “40% of insured American did not fill a medical prescription or skipped a medical appointment because they couldn’t afford the care”(Collins R, 2006, pg.1). The current healthcare system makes it impossible for people to receive care, which is not fair to the majority because the health care system risks the health of Americans over money. Another issue that has caused the debate is the quality of care people receive. As a country if we are spending so much money on health care it would be logical to believe that we have the best health care in the world, but that is wrong. The US average quality of health care is a little below average. If better care was given to patients “16% of deaths in hospitals,” (Davis, J, 2012, para. 2) wouldn’t happen over medical mistakes. Also people wouldn’t “receive treatment for conditions that didn’t need it” (Moyniham, R., 2012, para.3), because doctors would better understand how to help their patients, because of this people pay for unnecessary treatments. If quality of health care went up cost and deaths would go down. The quality of the care is also jeopardized for people because medical providers are too concerned over coverage and insurance. Doctors and patients should only have to worry about the care being provided not coverage. Problems with the health care system are very concerning to Americans. “64% of Americans that have insurance are not satisfied with the current health care system” (Langer, G, 2012, page 11). Americans agree that a fundamental change needs to occur, so improvements can take place in providing care for everyone. Americans want to take back control of the health care system, people want “quality care over coverage” (Pibel, D, 2006 pg.3), they would much rather have no health care plan and receive care. The American people also want the government to step in and set regulations to help keep costs down, but they do not want the government to take complete control. By voicing their opinions of a balance of quality care and affordable care to politicians, Americans make it very clear they want a change to occur. They believe the lives of people shouldn’t be risked because companies are greedy; there shouldn’t a price to live a healthy life. Every person should have the right to health care, weather they are rich or not. The cost of health care has become a burden for many. People do not want to skip out on having coverage so they endure the high rates and poor care. “Half of all bankruptcies are caused by medical bills” (Banks, J, 2006, para, 3), this astonishing number should be enough to make law makers and health care providers reevaluate the cost of health care. In the next couple of decades the cost of health insurance will “cost more than the median income of an American household” (Young, J, 2012), which is unacceptable because almost all American will be in debt. “One in Five Americans are paying off debt” (Collins, R, 2006, para.4), with the way health care is going down, soon everyone will be in debt. “Millions of Americans are already paying off 100,000 dollars in debt” (Pibel, D, 2006 para.1), in the next few years that amount will go up if changes don’t occur. Also people who do have healthcare are not the only ones suffering, “a survey shows that cost was the leading reason why people did not get health care.” (Young, J, 2012) These people go on there day to day lives hoping to not get sick because they will end up picking up the tab for it. Everyone rich or poor should be able to afford health care, so they can lead better lives. Having health care should not be a luxury it should be a common right. All most all industrialized countries have realized that having health care services should be a common right, except the USA. The United States is falling behind the rest of the world, as a society we view our selves as being ahead of the curve, but in this case we aren’t anywhere near becoming world leaders in universal health care coverage. The United States “tied with Hungry and Slovakia as having the highest infant mortality rate in the industrialized world” (Aher, J, 2012, para.4), also the “United States ranked 37th out of 191 nation for having the best health care services” (Murray, C, 2010, para.3). The horror of how poor Americas health care is doesn’t end there the “ the US ranked 43rd in female adult mortality, 42nd in male adult mortality, and 36th for life expectancy” ( Murray, C, 2012, para.4), these staggering numbers should make US lawmakers realize why everyone needs health care services. By being able to provide everyone with health care we will be able to compete with industrialized countries that do have health care for all their residents. Providing health care for all residents is important, so the US can change the health care system. Certain residents suffer more than others because their health requirements are not being met. Women in particular suffer more than men because it is harder for them to receive proper healthcare, which is sad because “women utilize healthcare more then men because of their reproductive services, so women should receive more care” (Smith, J, 2012, pg.3). Women need this care so they can lead better lives for their kids and families. “6.9 million women are in need of some sort of medical treatment that can be life saving, but are not receiving the treatment” (Caine, L, 2011, para.7), because of lack of money, or proper care. Women also found it “difficult to find health care during pregnancies” (Garson, A, 2010, pg. 3). If it were easier for women to have babies it could prevent other things such as birth defects or even abortion, because women wouldn’t have to worry about the health of their child. It is important that the US help women, and provides them with better care, so they can have babies and not worry about terminal illness such as cancer to affect them. That is why the US should have socialized health, so all its residents can lead healthy lives, no matter what gender. Another group of residents that suffer due to not having health care coverage are minorities. “There is a huge gap between the quality of care between whites and minorities” (Collins, B, 2011, para3), that is partially due to their economic status. Since health care is so expensive it is hard for these already struggling people to pay the cost of insurance. Due to this “minorities die earlier and suffer from health conditions longer” (Roelofs, T, 2011, para.1). It is not far that just because of their economic status they have to have poor health care. Health care shouldn’t only be available to Caucasian people, but everyone. That is not the only bad thing affecting minorities, “infant mortality among minorities is higher because they cannot afford good health care” (Roelofs, T, 2011, para 2), not only do they suffer but their children do as well. The cause of all this is not because they do not want to provide their own health care, they simply cannot. “Wages for low income/ minorities are stagnating and health care cost are rising” (Young, J, 2012, para.2), they can’t keep up with all the increases, because they have other monetary responsibilities. Money is not the only reason why minorities lack good health it is also their lifestyles. “Minorities tend to have bad health because not having enough exercise or availability to healthy food” (Roeloffs, T, 2011, para 4). They live in areas which are mostly urban so there are not any farms to provide healthy food. Also they may not have safe play grounds, parks, and gyms available because the areas they live in are dangerous. Having health insurance should not have anything to do with your economic status, everyone should be treated equal. Minorities are not the only US residents without good health care, young adults are suffering as well. Typically young adults are either put off from their parents insurance or it coverage is not extended past a certain year, leaving them without health care coverage. “Young adults between the age of 19-25 use their parents worked based coverage” (Singletary, M, 2012, para 2) when this coverage runs out the kids are left in a tough spot. They usually just graduated college or are currently students, so they will not be able to afford the high costs of health care coverage. “Two and five young working age Americans are uninsured” (Collins, R, 2006, para 5), with so many without insurance, their needs to be a way to help them get coverage. The other problem is “Young adults that do have their own coverage will skip appointments and filling prescriptions to avoid a costly bill” (Singletary, M, 2012, para 12). Health care coverage is needed when people are young, so that when they do get older their health will not be as poor. By the US having socialized health care young adults can be independent because they won’t have the burden of relaying on their parents for help, or breaking the bank because of a costly health insurance bill.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

An Optimistic Comparison of British National Healthcare and the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act

...An optimistic comparison of British National Healthcare and the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act During the past 5 years we have heard a great deal of rhetoric regarding socialism and healthcare as a result of the passing of the Affordable Care Act, particularly in how ACA compares to socialized medicine in England and the UK. The concerns of the people regarding socialism are important as our country is founded on capitalist principals, and to change those principals requires a complete shift in our thinking. A close look at the systems in question reveals important aspects for consideration; indeed it is important to be aware of the potential future of the ACA. While the English National Healthcare System and the Affordable Care Act have similarities, funding and administrative differences mean that while the ACA could become socialized, it does not currently fit that label. The primary concern of the American people concerning the ACA is, understandably, how this system will fit into the capitalist system that we are so very proud of and whether it will be the start of our nation moving toward complete socialism. Merriam-Webster defines socialism as “any of various economic and political theories advocating collective or governmental ownership and administration of the means of production and distribution of goods”. In other words, the state controls business and commerce directly rather than through governmental regulations. Social services...

Words: 1072 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Health Care Systems

...Healthcare systems have been debated for years in the United States, and have led us to fall behind the race for affordable high quality health insurance for all our citizens. To be able to comprehend how this can be achieved, we must examine various other systems and see how they are implemented. For over a decade the front runner in universal healthcare has been France. This country is truly a measuring stick for others who want to provide universal healthcare, and I believe for the United States in this particular situation should be the country that we want to imitate the most. Solely by imitating we cannot really achieve our main goal, we must put effective legislation into effect and provide our citizens with ample information to get them knowledge about this system. I truly believe by proposing a plan similar to French and examining the reasons through a consequentialism point of view we can understand why healthcare is a right that others should not interfere with. Having that kind of view brings on a heavy burden on trying to explain what is the morally correct right for healthcare, in answering the question in simple terms the moral right way to provide healthcare is through a comprehensive system that allows all resources to be available to those who need. This brings the very tough dilemma of how we can provide that many resources to our entire population. To answer that and the distribution of our new drug we will examine the French system of healthcare. To determine...

Words: 1049 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Biomedical Ethics Term Paper: Socialized Health Care

...Andrei Panait 9758402 PHIL235 November 20, 2012 Biomedical Ethics Term Paper: Socialized Health Care While many countries today have some sort of public health program, their effectiveness is not conclusive and there is undoubtedly a great deal of controversy regarding all aspects of socialized modern health care. In North America but more so in the United States, there is a deep-rooted stigma associated with all things that relate to socialism, most likely due to history and the negative reputations of most countries with this sort of economic system. Capitalism does seem to fit the American way of life and even some aspects of human nature as we are generally competitive and compelled to have freedom of choice. However there is another aspect to human nature that drives us towards more collectivist ideals and it is found in our compassion, caring for others, unity and social solidarity. When exploring these issues the most important problems seem to occur at the extremities of the spectrum and in similar ways. Capitalism has allowed people to gain absurd amounts of wealth, often through corruption and deceit, and that wealth gives them unimaginable power while socialism tends to be corrupt and oppressive. This leads us to the obvious deduction that no system is perfect, whether it is a public or private health care system, a capitalist market or a democratic government, some might seem foolproof in theory but all have their flaws in practice, probably due to...

Words: 1267 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Universal Healthcare

...National healthcare has been a debate for many years. Several countries provide healthcare for their population. There have been attempts in the US to emulate this program. Several presidents have tried this, but all failed. Recently, President Obama was able to get a bill through a bi-partisan congress requiring all US residents to have some sort of healthcare. While this is not a single payer plan, it can be viewed as a step in the right direction. There were millions in the US without access to affordable care, and now they can at least get a plan that covers basic healthcare. As the years have gone by there have been issues with the program, and how it was implemented. Healthcare is something all should have access to, but the government...

Words: 2134 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Business

...In the US, healthcare has always been a controversial issue. On March 23, 2010, President Barack Obama signed into effect the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare. This law the President signed puts into place comprehensive healthcare reforms that will affect the next 4 years and beyond. Some of the large reforms that will happen are benefits for women, strengthening Medicare, holding more insurance companies accountable, and young adult coverage. Women will be benefited from the Affordable Care Act by having preventive services covered and having more insurance options. Young adults will benefit from the Affordable Care act because coverage will be available for children up to 26 years of age. By far, the largest thing that goes into effect started this year, which states that every American will have access to affordable healthcare insurance options. The Act ensures that low income and middle-income families get tax credits that cover most of their insurance coverage cost. Also, more low- income people will receive Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act. By establishing these reforms, specifically the later one, millions of people who were not insured previously will be receiving healthcare. The health Insurance Marketplace was created for people to be able to compare their different health plans, see if they receive tax credits pertaining to the Affordable Care Act and private institutions. Healthcare in the United States is spread out over distinct organizations...

Words: 1565 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Sb8-10

...6FRunning head: HEALTH CARE ACCESS SB 810 THE CALIFORNIA UNIVERSAL Health Care Access SB 810 the California Universal Health Care Act Polly Ankenbauer Grand Canyon University Health Care and Economic Analysis HCA 255 Barri Mallin August 12, 2011 The purpose of this assignment is to choose a legislative proposal regarding health care access and discuss the current program as well as ways the new legislation will improve access. The proposal chosen for this assignment is, State Senate Bill 810 authored by Senator Mark Leno; a Democrat from the city of San Francisco and presented in March 2011 as The California Universal Health Care Act. This landmark legislation establishes a modern universal health care system to cover every California resident with comprehensive benefits for life, building upon the well-tested principles of our popular Medicare program that American seniors have relied on for decades. SB 810 provides universal care without increasing overall health care spending in California (One-care 2011). Currently residents of the state of California are either privately insured through employer benefit, private pay, or enrolled in either the Medi-cal or Healthy Families Program and a large percentage are without health insurance. SB 810 is a “Medicare for All” style single-payer health care reform plan. Single-payer is a term used to describe a type of financing system. It refers to one entity acting as administrator, or “payer.”(Mclaughlin & Mclaughlin...

Words: 1402 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Health Insurance

...Executive Summary The health care in the United States has often been credited with being some of the best money can buy, though with the caveat that it does not provide health care to all its citizens, and millions are left with woefully little or no health care coverage. However, in Canada, universal health care serves its entire population, though there is also criticism that the care it does provide lacks the quality of the most expensive health care services in the U.S. This paper will examine the truth behind the quantity and quality argument between the universalized health care in Canada and the health care system in the U.S., while also taking into account the recent reforms made to the U.S. system and how it impacts such a comparison. Canada and the United States Comparison of the health care systems in Canada and the United States are often made by government, public health and public policy analysts. The two countries had similar health care systems before Canada reformed its system in the 1960s and 1970s. The United States spends much more money on health care than Canada, on both a per-capita basis and as a percentage of GDP. In 2006, per-capita spending for health care in Canada was US$3,678; in the U.S., US$6,714. The U.S. spent 15.3% of GDP on health care in that year; Canada spent 10.0%. In 2006, 70% of health care spending in Canada was financed by government, versus 46% in the United States. Total government spending per capita in the U.S. on health...

Words: 4813 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Health Insurance Persuasive Essay

...medicines and doctor bills. With the Government providing free healthcare to all legally employed citizens with some stipulations; this would only help boost the economy by providing more jobs, lower health care premiums and lower expenses for small business owners. Having a free health care system in place could have many great benefits for the United States. When a person is sick and unhealthy the last thing they should have to place their focus on is how a bill will be paid. The cost of these expenses are completely overwhelming to the middle class everyday working families. Our healthcare system has evolved throughout the history of the United States, Americans first promise of health care started out with a simple article written by our founding father. Within the Preamble to the Constitution is an introductory, succinct statement of the principles at work: “ We the People of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America” (‘Preamble| Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute’). Within this quote “to promote the general welfare” is a demand for the government to provide for the welfare for its citizens. Although this topic has been a debate for many years, in 1965, President Johnson made a promise...

Words: 2459 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Social Theories

...In a way, communism is an extreme form of socialism. Many countries have dominant socialist political parties but very few are truly communist. In fact, most countries - including staunch capitalist bastions like the U.S. and U.K. - have government programs that borrow from socialist principles. "Socialism" is sometimes used interchangeably with "communism" but the two philosophies have some stark differences. Most notably, while communism is a political system, socialism is primarily an economic system that can exist in various forms under a wide range of political systems. Comparison chart | |Communism |Socialism | |Philosophy |From each according to his ability, to each according to |From each according to his ability, to each according to| | |his needs. Free-access to the articles of consumption is |his contribution. Emphasis on profit being distributed | | |made possible by advances in technology that allow for |among the society or workforce to complement individual | | |super-abundance. |wages/salaries. | |Economic System |The means of production are held in common, negating the |The means of production are owned by public enterprises | | |concept of ownership in...

Words: 3092 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Hsm 310 Project

...improve these particular issues. The Universal Health Care system is used in Canada; this provides coverage to all the citizens of Canada (Canadian Health Care, 2007). It is executed on either a territorial or provincial basis, staying within the guidelines that have been made by the federal government (Canadian Health Care, 2007). The United States on the other hand has a hugely private system, with multiple payers, leaving the US citizens no choice other than to pay out of one’s own pocket in order to obtain health insurance, also Americans are not fully insured or even partially insured like the citizens of Canada are (Canadian Health Care, 2007). Each country spends a large amount of funding for their health care systems. Canada had spent over eleven percent of its overall GDP on health care, the United States on the other hand had spent 17.4 percent of its overall GDP this year (United North America, 2013). On the other hand, Canada has been shown to spend much less of the GDP on their health care, but it still has been shown to be superior to the U.S. on two of the more common health care measures, such as the infant mortality rate and the life expectancy rate (United North America, 2013). Each country is very different from each other, but they also both have similar problems with the management of their health care systems. Canada guarantees that all their citizens...

Words: 3083 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

You Are the Ceo of a 100-Bed Community Hospital in Rural Alabama. the Newly Hired Pharmacist Refuses to Dispense Emergency Contraception Based Upon Religious/Moral Grounds.

...[pic] Title: Total and State Medicaid Spending Growth FY 2000 - FY 2012 Description: With the expiration of federal stimulus funding in 2011, state spending on Medicaid is projected to rise 28.7% in 2012, while overall Medicaid spending will increase 2.2%. Source: Historic Medicaid Growth Rates, KCMU Analysis of CMS Form 64 Data; FY 2008, 2009 and 2010, KCMU survey of Medicaid officials in 50 states and DC conducted by Health Management Associates, 2011. Topics: Medicaid / CHIP Included in these Slideshows: KFF.org Data Spotlight Slide Date: October 28, 2011   Introduce the issue. Describe the problems in the U.S. healthcare system and how we might use another nation's healthcare system for reform. Evaluate how a new system would improve access to care, quality of care, and the efficient utilization of resources. Define the problem. a. High insurance premiums and out of reach for many American who remain uninsured. b. Drug companies are widely perceived as greedy and insensitive. c. Differences in prescription patterns related to insurance coverage. d. Medicaid patients are more likely to be prescribed generic drugs than patients who have commercial health insurance. e. Unethical behavior by the insurers that shows many institutions have violate fundamental values. f. Negative relationship between the insurers and physicians, personal-satisfaction ratings for health insurance plans, public concern about HMOs in particular and the health care...

Words: 4716 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

House

...Ballesteros noted in her latest study on urban housing subsidies that, despite policy changes through the years, the public sector housing program still does not address the problems on scale. Ballesteros explained that subsidies for housing programs, whether through upfront grants, government direct funding, low interest mortgages, tax exemptions or underpriced risk insurance, could have been put into more efficient use by the government. “Overall, direct subsidy to the low-income housing sector has been limited,” said Ballesteros, adding that in an effort to reduce losses from financial transactions, government has further restricted financing to the low-income sector through lower exposure of funders and the higher loan ceilings on socialized and low-income packages. Fiscal costs greater concern Ballesteros stressed, however, that an even greater concern than subsidy flows are the fiscal costs associated with losses incurred by government financial institutions (GFIs). She noted that in the mid ‘90s, the main administrator of government-subsidized housing finance programs, the National Home Mortgage Finance Corporation or...

Words: 2914 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Page

...Internet. We experience it subtly and overtly in all cultures and across nations in incidents ranging from ethnic slurs to hate crimes to violence carried out in the name of ideology. Such incidents of violence tend to be easily seen as they fall within the public domain. Less visible, however, but often more devastating, is the domestic violence that occurs within the family and often against women. The International Council of Nurses (ICN) (2001) notes in a summary of research done on four continents that as many as 20 to 50 percent of all women in the studies reported experiencing partner violence. But what are the links among domestic violence, health care profession, nurses, and ethics? In moral philosophy, there is a long tradition of debate on whether true moral dilemmas can exist, some arguing that it will always be possible to decide which obligation should prevail. On this concept regardless of the abstract possibility of an ideal resolution and the pragmatic reality that decisions are made and people have to live with them. An ethical dilemma presents a choice that must be made between two mutually exclusive courses of action, each of which is perceived to rest on a moral obligation that carries significant weight for the actor confronting the dilemma. According to Draucker (2002} addresses intimate partner abuse as repeatable and increasing patterns of violence against women by men in their attempts to gain power. She notes that because this abuse occurs in a continuing...

Words: 14007 - Pages: 57

Premium Essay

Obamacare Disparities

...the impacting the Medicare, Medicare patient services and employees. Most of the people in the island think that the Affordable Care Act is giving more security and help to address the existing disparities in the healthcare system. With the new Patient Protection & Affordable Care Act, the insurance companies can no longer drop the coverage if one becomes sick, bill individual into bankruptcy because of an annual or lifetime limit, and they will not be able to discriminate against anyone with a pre existing condition. Most of the Medicare and Medicaid community suffers do to the imbalance in our healthcare system this situation affects the quality of care and places a financial strain on the government, individuals and families, employers and employees, and public and private providers. Most of the Medicare beneficiaries have to enroll in the MA program to help them to succeed and receive the adequate treatments without MA to help the disadvantaged seniors on the island, Puerto Rico's elderly citizens will be forced to turn to Mi Salud in larger numbers. Although Mi Salud is scheduled to receive an average of $690 million annually during the next five years, the widening deficit in MA funding is likely to create a net negative impact on federal funding for healthcare in Puerto Rico. The Health care Policies and Issues Ethical concerns and issues The Affordable Care Act (ACA) policies are intended to give patients more access to health care without any restrictions as...

Words: 10927 - Pages: 44

Premium Essay

Healthcare

...care delivery system To evaluate why the system has been resistant to national health insurance reforms To explore developments associated with the corporatization of health care To speculate on whether the era of socialized medicine has dawned in the United States “Where’s the market?” 81 26501_CH03_FINAL.indd 81 7/27/11 10:31:29 AM 82 CHAPTER 3 The Evolution of Health Services in the United States Introduction The health care delivery system of the United States evolved quite differently from the systems in Europe. American values and the social, political, and economic antecedents on which the US system is based have led to the formation of a unique system of health care delivery, as described in Chapter 1. This chapter discusses how these forces have been instrumental in shaping the current structure of medical services and how they are likely to shape its future. The evolutionary changes discussed here illustrate the American beliefs and values (discussed in Chapter 2) in action, within the context of broad social, political, and economic changes. Because social, political, and economic contexts are not static, their shifting influences lend a certain dynamism to the health care delivery system. Conversely, beliefs and values remain relatively stable over time. Consequently, in the American health care delivery experience, initiatives toward a national health care program have failed to make significant inroads. However, social, political, and economic forces have...

Words: 18336 - Pages: 74