Free Essay

The English Patient

In:

Submitted By myko85
Words 1457
Pages 6
The English Patient takes place during World War II, a time during which nationalism was rampant and one’s national identity was of primary importance. An isolated derelict Italian villa, the setting of the story, houses four survivors that have banded together in an effort to start the process of healing while leaving the war behind. The war-weary survivors bond together under a common goal to redefine their identity while attempting to transcend nationality. Despite their best efforts, they ultimately fail as the rest of the world imposes the idea of national identity upon them. Ondaatje uses the theme of nationality and identity to create an inescapable maze that binds the characters to the war so that when the survivors finally leave their sheltered villa they soon find themselves once again in the roles expected of them in their respective countries. Hana, the first character introduced in the novel, is portrayed as a twenty year old caught between the roles of adolescence and adulthood. She contributed to the war effort by enlisting as a nurse and devoted herself to helping others. After three days on the job she loses her innocence, gives up hope on returning to her life before the war, and sheds her identity when she cuts “her hair, not concerned with shape or length, just cutting it away – the irritation of its presence during the previous days still in her mind.” The fact that she “never looked at herself in mirrors again” suggests that Hana is not sure of what she has become. This thought is reinforced when Hana sees her reflection in a mirror a year later and fails to recognize the image: “Hi Buddy, she said. She peered into her look, trying to recognize herself.” Hana exhibits maturity through her actions as a good nurse. She quickly learns to not become emotionally attached to her patients and calls all of them “buddy” and immediately detaches herself from her patients after their death: “Hello Buddy, good-bye Buddy. Caring was brief. There was a contract only until death.” While Hana asserts an adult side through her actions as a nurse, she is a paradoxical character in the sense that she still clings to childish behaviors. An example of such behavior is her idolization of the English patient as a “saint…a despairing saint” while Caravaggio questions why she bothers to care for the English patient. The idolizing of an older, more experienced person is a trait often found in young children. Another instance of Hana exhibiting her childlike identity is when she plays hopscotch in the villa: “She leaps forward, her legs smashing down, her shadow behind her curling into the depth of the hall. She is very quick, her tennis shoes skidding on the number she has drawn into each rectangle, one foot landing, then two feet, then one again, until she reaches the last square.” Her playing hopscotch in the dark after having taken care of the English patient suggests that while Hana may show a mature side during the day, she reverts back to her childish self at night once she is alone. Ondaatje repeats this conflict many times throughout the novel to emphasize Hana’s erratic, unstable character, the result of a young girl forced to a level of maturity beyond her age. Kip, the last person to enter the villa, is an Indian Sikh who works in the British army as a sapper. Kip is perhaps the person with the most conflicted identity in the group. His brother is an anti-western nationalist that would rather be jailed than join the army, a contrast from Kip who voluntarily enlists. His attempt to assimilate into British culture can be seen with his adoption of the nickname given to him by the British soldiers “Kip” as opposed to using his native name, “Kirpal Singh.” Despite his eagerness and belief that that he can transcend racism, Kip has a hard time gaining acceptance by the British because of his nationality. Ondaatje often reminds the reader that Kip “was the only Indian among the applicants” and that he was “[a]n Indian boy.” Although Kip shows his devotion to the British by joining their highly dangerous elite bomb sapper unit, he never manages to overcome discrimination and his “brownness” is mentioned throughout the novel. Kip is clearly aware of his status as an outsider and even during the intense moments of bomb disposal, he knows that although “he was for now a king, a puppet master, could order anything, a bucket of sand, a fruit pie for his needs,” the men who obeyed his orders “would not cross an uncrowded bar to speak with him.” After the death of his mentor, Kip becomes even more detached and “reenlist[s] into the anonymous machine of the army” causing him to disembark in Italy. He soon arrives to the villa and after living with Hana, Caravaggio, and Almásy, all of whom seem to disregard national origins, Kip slowly begins to regain confidence and a sense of community. After a few months in the villa the survivors get together to celebrate Hana’s birthday, symbolizing Kip’s acceptance. Here Kip reaffirms his belief that he can surpass racism while creating a separate identity as a lover with Hana. However, the outside world moves on and reinforces the idea of national identity by dropping an atomic bomb on Japan. Upon hearing this news, Kip imagines “the streets of Asia full of fire. It rolls across cities like a burst map, the hurricane of heat withering bodies at it meets them, the shadow of humans suddenly in the air.” Kip realizes that this act of extreme violence, the bombing of Japan, was in part motivated by racism and that the West would never have released such a destructive bomb on a white nation. Kip soon understands that he would never be able to escape the racism and contempt with which the West regards him with. With this revelation Kip completely succumbs to the labeling of nationality that he earlier desperately tried to overcome by leaving Hana because he links her, as a white person, with the racism of the West. He deserts the British army, returns to India, and takes back his old name. He eventually becomes a doctor, the occupation expected of the second born in India. With her patient dead and lover gone, there is nothing left for Hana at the villa and she soon finds herself back in Canada. The English patient, later on known as Almásy, lived and worked in the desert prior to the war. In the desert Almásy and his group of international friends were removed from the politics of Europe and thus for a time were able to transcend the labels of nationhood. Hungarian by birth and educated in England, Almásy decides to recreate his identity by shedding “the clothes of his country” in the desert, where one’s character is considered more important than one’s place of birth. It was here that Almásy “came to hate nations” and came to believe that “[w]e are deformed by nation-states.” Eventually, the war forced the politics of Europe, along with its belief of national identity, onto the desert causing the forced disbandment of the Geographical Society, which can be seen symbolically as the end of Almásy’s dream. The force of nationality not only ends with the destruction of Almásy’s dream, but also eventually causes the death of Madox, his best friend, and his lover Katherine. Because Almásy’s gave the British soldiers his name, they did not believe him since “everyone with a foreign name who drifted into these small oasis towns was suspect. She was just seventy miles away and they wouldn’t listen.” Instead, the soldiers imprisoned him simply because Almásy’s name denoted a connection, albeit imaginary, with the enemy. The characters’ failure to recreate their identity while transcending nationality due to the pressures of war and national identity is repeated many times throughout the novel. Kip, who joined the British army out a sense of loyalty, is unable to cope with the bombing of Japan. He abandons everything he has believed in prior to the war and returns to India, eventually embracing the path that is expected of him in his culture. Hana, unable to recreate a new identity in Europe after having lost her father, her child, and lover, eventually returns to Canada. Almásy, the one who hated nation-states and wanted to have nothing to do with the war, is unable to save Katherine and eventually takes sides. By using the theme of nationality of identity to bind the characters, Ondaatje does a wonderful job of showing their attempts and failures at recreating their identity without the influence of nationality.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

English Patient

...1 In memory of Skip and Mary Dickinson For Quintin and Griffin And for Louise Dennys, with thanks ‘Most of you, I am sure, remember the tragic circumstances of the death of Geoffrey Clifton at Gilf Kebir, followed later by the disappearance of his wife, Katharine Clifton, which took place during the 1939 desert expedition in search of Zerzura. “I cannot begin this meeting tonight without referring very sympathetically to those tragic occurrences. “The lecture this evening ...” From the minutes of the Geographical Society meeting of November 194-, London I The Villa SHE STANDS UP in the garden where she has been working and looks into the distance. She has sensed a shift in the weather. There is another gust of wind, a buckle of noise in the air, and the tall cypresses sway. She turns and moves uphill towards the house, climbing over a low wall, feeling the first drops of rain on her bare arms. She crosses the loggia and quickly enters the house. In the kitchen she doesn’t pause but goes through it and climbs the stairs which are in darkness and then continues along the long hall, at the end of which is a wedge of light from an open door. She turns into the room which is another garden—this one made up of trees and bowers painted over its walls and ceiling. The man lies on the bed, his body exposed to the breeze, and he turns his head slowly towards her as she enters. Every four days she washes his black body, beginning at the destroyed feet. She wets a washcloth...

Words: 83532 - Pages: 335

Premium Essay

English Patient Chinese Takeaway

...Mg Rover Collapse Seminar 1: The English Patient and the Chinese takeaway: examining social responsibilities in the MG Rover collapse 1a. Main Stakeholders: -   Phoenix Group -Longbridge site owners - Employees (6500, at Longbridge -Around 9-12,000 employees from West Midlands -BMW/shareholders from BMW -financial industry in general -Unions -Local communities -Chinese state owned Shanghai Automotve Industrial Corporation (SAIC) -Chinese company Nanjing Automotive -Deloitte -Creditors -Media -Government -British Tax Payers -Competitors -Suppliers of Longbridge Theory Mitchell's framework of stakeholder salience: ‘Determines the importance of stakeholders and categorizes them on the basis of salience, defined with regard to the attributes Power, Legitimacy and Urgency’ (Grisseri & Seppala, 2010) Stakeholder Power Legitimacy Urgency ‘Phoenix Group’ H H H Employees at Longbridge L H L BMW /Shareholders H H H Deloitte L H L Unions MG Rover customers (dealers) L L L SAIC H H H Nanjing Automative M M M/H British Government M/H H M/H Creditors Competitors of MG Rover Media H H M/H Local Community L L/M L Suppliers of Longbridge L/M L/M L 2. MG Rover's actions in the case in terms of Carrol's Pyramid of CSR (responsibilities and ranking, appropriate or inappropriate in this situation, could it have done more to treat its employees ethically?) Theory Carrol's Pyramid of CSR: ‘Corporate social responsibility includes the economic...

Words: 289 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cabin Fever Patient Zero Analysis

...Cabin Fever: Patient Zero Since I love watching movies, I decided to find a movie on Netflix that relates to diseases and I found Cabin Fever: Patient Zero. Cabin Zero is about a group of friends taking their soon to be married friend to an island for his bachelor party. When arriving to the island, they realize there was no one on the island but them. They were perfectly fine with that. By being on the island by themselves, gives them time to bond together. Most bachelor parties consist of all men, but this one was three men and a woman. All four of them grew up together. As soon as they have arrived on the island, the groom and his best friend decided to set up the tent and start grilling; while the groom’s brother and his girlfriend decided to go scuba diving. While scuba diving they were having trouble seeing water creatures. The decided to go a little bit deeper. While doing deeper into the sea, all they saw was dead creatures. The fish looked...

Words: 888 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The English Patient and the Chinese Takeaway Examining Social Responsibilities in the Mg Rover Collapse?

...Essay No.1. Small economies in the increasing globalisation I have chosen Luxembourg as a country with a small economy and a member of BENELUX regional block. My essay consider issues of Luxembourg relations with countries from NAFTA trade block and how Luxembourg can take advantage of technological development in the contexts of market globalisation. Luxembourg’s economy is small, stable and high-income. Luxembourg’s economic success has made it one of the wealthiest countries in the world, with a per capita income that routinely ranks in the world’s top three. Canada is a member of NAFTA and it’s relations with Luxemourg are strong. Canada and Luxembourg have developed a partnership based on shared values and ongoing political dialogue on major international issues. Canada and Luxembourg have signed numerous bilateral agreements and treaties, including an Agreement regarding the Sharing of Forfeited Assets (2001), a Convention on Double Taxation and Tax Evasion (2000), an Audio-visual Co-production Agreement (1996) and a Convention on Social Security (1990). Canada and Luxembourg's long-standing friendship has also resulted in a strong economic and trade partnership. In 2011, Canada's exports to Luxembourg totalled CAD 89 million. During the same period, Canada's imports from Luxembourg reached CAD 115 million. Canada and Luxembourg also enjoy a thriving investment relationship built on natural synergies in our high-performing sectors. Luxembourg's cumulative direct...

Words: 852 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Dream Job

...books because doctors are required to know well about the human body. Also, I have to study English very hard because most of the medical terms are in English. In order to become a doctor, I have to make a constant effort. There are few things for me to work on. First, I have to love and serve for those who are sick. Doctors need to give extra care for their patients because they need to know well about each patient. Second, all doctors have to be diligent. If the doctors are lazy, and do not care to know about the patients, they cannot help them to become healthier. There are many other things for me to work on, but I think these two are the most important things for me to become a good doctor. My dream job is a doctor because I want to help sick people to become healthier. I can also help my parents when they are sick. To become a doctor, I have to read a lot of books because doctors are required to know well about the human body. Also, I have to study English very hard because most of the medical terms are in English. In order to become a doctor, I have to make a constant effort. There are few things for me to work on. First, I have to love and serve for those who are sick. Doctors need to give extra care for their patients because they need to know well about each patient. Second, all doctors have to be diligent. If the doctors are lazy, and do not care to know about the patients, they cannot help them to become healthier. There are many other things for me to work on, but...

Words: 794 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Informed Consent Case Study

...me to a Cantonese patient and informed me on his inability to speak English. I was not however made aware of the fact that he was unable to understand English as well. As I walked in the room, it was just me and the patient. As per normal procedure, I began by introducing myself and continued with the assessment and vital signs. “How did you sleep last night?” is a question I ask during assessment, however when I asked my patient this question, he seemed to have a puzzled look on his face. As having previously dealt with patients, I understood that it was quite possible he did not want to talk to me, felt annoyed and just wanted to go back to sleep. However, after doing assessments, I concluded...

Words: 2028 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Rn Language

...Registered Nurse Language Laura Lynch Nevada State College ABSTRACT This paper discusses the significance of utilizing standard language and writing skills as it relates to multiple tiers of communication required in the nursing profession, as well as the importance of maintaining these elite level communication skills. In addition, this paper also includes a comparison between two minority authors that argue for the importance of their respective Chicana and black, “native tongues “. The pros and cons of their arguments is contrasted against authors’ Allen, Chapman, O’Connor and Francis (2007), whom address the significance of language and writing within the area of professional nursing that upholds the elite verbal and written communication standards practiced in nursing today. The Communications and the Language of Nursing The language spoken in the profession of nursing requires a wide spectrum of core communication skills that provide a verbal bridge of common understanding of illness, healing, wellness or prevention. These skills require the continual change and transformation of the nursing profession’s language. From the perspective of the patient’s bedside and nurse-to-nurse communications, through the nurse to the specialist, the criteria for common core can be acknowledged. Additionally, the personal slang and reflections of self identification shared in Anzaldua and hooks’ essays demonstrates the immediate need for the requirement of a common core language...

Words: 1581 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Persuasive Letter

...hospitalizations, and increase tax dollars. The frustration of being misunderstood when trying to communicate is something that everyone has experienced. It is a very helpless and frustrating feeling and when on vacation we have all experienced this communication breakdown. Imagine this same frustration and helplessness when you are unable to receive the correct healthcare or because of a language barrier you were unable to understand the medical professionals and could not follow through with your own treatment. Many of the hospitals in our area feel that by providing an interpreter there will always be clear communication between the staff and patients. This is not so. We deal with many different cultures on a daily basis and are hard to communicate effectively. The words we use can mean something different to patients of other cultures and as nurses we need to remember this ("Cultural barriers to effective communication", 2010).   The potential for misunderstandings increases when the languages are different, and translation has to be used to communicate ("Cultural barriers to effective communication", 2010).   There have been many times when non health care...

Words: 947 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Vulnerable Population in the Workplace

...Hispanics and Health Disparities Francesca Novelli University of Phoenix Palomar Medical Center is in the heart (Escondido) of North County, San Diego California area. According to Hispanics Now Largest Group in Escondido, Hispanics account for 46% of the population in Escondido, California (Jones & Lee, 2010). These statistics do not differentiate between illegal and legal residents. Therefore the majority of patients at Palomar Medical Center are Hispanic. Even though the majority of our patients are Hispanic this does not equal an easier rode to healthcare recovery for this vulnerable group. The Hispanic population in the Unites States is a major vulnerable class relating to healthcare access and treatment. They are faced daily with health disparities and need time, education, and encouragement for their path to wellness. According to U.S. Census Bureau as of July 2011 there are roughly 52 million Hispanics living in the United States. This makes people of Hispanic origin the nations largest ethnic or race minority. The definition of Hispanic or Latino is “a person of Cuban, Mexican, Puerto Rican, South or Central American, or other Spanish Culture or origin (Hispanic/Latino Heritage Month, 2012). Among Hispanic subgroups Mexicans ranked the largest at 63% in 2010. The percentage of Hispanics who lacked health insurance in the U.S. was 30.7%. By the year 2050 there is an estimation...

Words: 1312 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Organizational Barriers to Healthcare

...further discuss ways to decrease barriers to mental health care for this minority group to assist the facility strive for cultural competency. Acosta (2003) noted in his project on a model mental health program for Hispanics that language barriers and lack of health insurance are the two major barriers to receiving mental health care for Latinos. There are no nurses, social workers, physicians, and psychologists at this facility who speak Spanish. However there are several Spanish speaking patients at both the civil side and forensic unit. The facility has to rely on interpreters whose services can only be obtained through a state established help line that can be very difficult to access. Lack of Spanish language resources for a Mexican patient who speaks no English can negatively impact care. Mental health services at this facility can be obtained either through the civil side or the forensic unit. The county psychiatric crisis unit is operational twenty four hours to receive and assess patients for future admission to...

Words: 1323 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Medical Language Interpretation Paper

...This paper will explore the Diane Mathis’ experience with non-English-speaking patients. I will compare and contrast the range of medical language interpretation and describe what is considered the “best practice”. Also, I will describe at least two scenarios in situations in which patients are non-English speaking and qualified language interpretation is not provided. I will highlight the key ethical principles to be considered and the implications for the patient in each alternative. Finally, I will discuss how the scenario relates to my own health profession's code of ethics. As the population of non-English speaking migrants continue to flood United States, the need for increasing medical language interpretation is vital in order to facilitate the communication...

Words: 513 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Communication Theory Paper

...concentrates on providing care for patients that has workers compensation and personal injury cases. This office has two psychologists, one who is the main administrator and owner of the clinic, psychological assistants, internist, orthopedist and neurologist. Aside from the doctors there are two types of managers; general and back office. Two medical billers, three collectors, four transcriptionists who work on a part time basis, a front receptionist, and five back office workers who assist with interpreting for non-English speaking patients. About 90% of the patient population is referred for treatment for their injury on the job and 10% are personal injury cases. 75% of the patients are non-English speaking patients. There are a few basic steps on how this clinic is being run. The first step is for the patient to be referred by either their attorney or primary treating physician, in some cases directly from the insurance carrier. Then the patient gets seen by the doctor and the doctor will dictate a report that gets transcribed. Once the report is transcribed, it is given to the billing department to get sent out to all parties involved. After that the file will go to the collections department to try and collect a payment for the services provided. Those payments are what keep the business intact. However, not everything always runs smoothly due to miscommunication between the administrator, managers, employees, and the patients, which cause complications within...

Words: 786 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Continuum of Care Presentation Thesis Statement

...American-born parents. The authors advise using professional translating services in hospitals and clinics to reduce communication barriers and improve health care.   Flores, Glenn. Language Barriers to Health Care in the United States. The New England Journal of Medicine. Volume 355:229-231 (July 20, 2006), Number 3. http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/355/3/229 This article discusses the grave medical miscommunications and the increased incidence of adverse clinical consequences that occur when untrained, ad hoc interpreters are used in health care settings. Despite the growing number of people who have limited English speaking abilities in the United States, many patients who need medical interpreters have no access to them. The provision of adequate language services results in optimal communication, patient satisfaction, outcomes, resource use, and patient safety. A 2002...

Words: 958 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Essay

...lexicon includes a) the type of verb, b) the thematic roles that are assigned to its arguments, c) what is the hierarchy of the arguments (with the associated theta-role), d) whether they assign case to one or more arguments. It is crucial when learning a foreign language to realize that while the meaning of the verb, namely the event type and, as a consequence, the theta-roles assigne by it can be the same in L1 (our native language) and L2 (our foreign language), the hierarchy of the arguments may be very different. Let us make a very well-known example of the Italian – English contrast: (1) a. b. John likes potatoes. A Gianni piacciono le patate. Like and piacere express the same kind of event. It is a psychological state (of pleasure) which has two theta-roles: the EXPERIENCER of the pleasure and the THEME of the pleasure. In both languages the EXPERIENCER is animate and the THEME is not animate. But in English the EXPERIENCER is the subject while in Italian the subject is the THEME. Notice that this does not even imply that the word order is different in the two...

Words: 3083 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Personal Ethics

...These three terms can be tied together to define one’s own personal ethics. Values are learned as a child that parents teach, morals are developed from what is taught, and ethics is how a person behaves when faced with a difficult situation. An individual’s beliefs will continue on throughout life and be incorporated into their everyday lives. Ones personal ethics can be different from the next. What one may see as right, another may view as wrong. Medical professionals have established ethical standards that guide their everyday practice. This paper will discuss the writer’s personal worldview and how these are incorporated into her daily practice as a registered nurse caring for burn patients. Professional Moral Compass According to Webster’s New Millennium Dictionary of English[->0], a moral compass is, "anything which serves to guide a person’s decisions based on morals or virtues" (2012). This writer considers moral compass to be conscience. This is based on what was learned and instilled while growing up. These include integrity, caring, excellence, attitude, and courage. This writer was raised to be honest, sincere, dependable, reliable, considerate and fair to others, to strive for excellence in all aspects of life, to maintain a positive attitude, and to stand up for what is right. These values guide the writer’s personal...

Words: 1050 - Pages: 5