Free Essay

To What Extent Is Negative Heritage a Benefit to Society

In:

Submitted By wwwqqqfff
Words 2163
Pages 9
8-week Pre-sessional Research Essay

15th August 2012

To What Extent is Negative Heritage a Benefit to Society?

UCL Language Centre
Student: QIFAN WANG
Tutor: MARK BAILEY
Date: 16/08/2012
Word count: 1854 words

Introduction

Cultural heritage, including monuments, groups of buildings and sites, which are of outstanding universal value from the point of view of history, art or science(1972, UNESCO Convention World Heritage), is inherited from past generations, maintained in the contemporary era and bestowed for the benefit of future generations. While seemingly uncontroversial and due to its significant position and profoundly influential value, human beings are exploring ancient civilization and preserving cultural heritage. However, we should recognize that not all heritage represents a positive memory , the uncritical interpretation of heritage is indeed omit negative factors of the past. In order to distinguish heritage more thoroughly, we use the term “negative heritage” which is defined as sites that may be interpreted by a group as commemorating conflict, trauma and disaster (Rico 2010), more specifically, Meskell deems that negative heritage is a conflicting site that becomes the repository of negative memory in the collective imaginary (Meskell 2002, 558). Unlike other heritage which can win widespread appreciation and permanent admiration, negative heritage refers to death, wars, religious conflicts and culture clashes. Controversies of negative heritage are often more salient than its values. This essay critically discusses to what degree negative heritage impacts society positively. First, the background of negative heritage will be demonstrated via introducing a famous example of negative heritage, then the reasons why negative heritage has a beneficial impact on society will be explored by analysing the example, finally the development of negative heritage in remote areas will be discussed.
Background

The amount of negative heritage is very large, since the history of human beings is also the history of their conflict. It is widely spread in every country, for example The World Trade Centre site, which was built in the original site after destroying in the September by terrorists. It has now become a contemporary negative heritage which will be a reminiscent of intentional destruction, political issues and death. The Hiroshima Peace Memorial is the site which recorded wars weapons of mass destruction and identified as a permanent witness to the disaster that occurred when the atomic bomb was used as a weapon for the first time in the history of mankind by Japan (ICOMOS 1996). Obviously, negative heritage is generally associated with a significant historical event, which conveys great significance and influence. A site which witnessed one of the biggest disasters of human beings is the Auschwitz Concentration Camp.

Auschwitz was an small town with charming castles admired by visitors. However, it was gradually transformed into a slaughter field. In 1940, this village became the largest centre that suffered from mass extermination of European Jews. Moreover, prisoners and slave labours from different countries were imprisoned there. According to Hayes, it became the capital of holocaust and regarded as the biggest killing chamber among the long history of human beings. It is reported that, between 1940 and 1945, at least 1100000 Jews were sent to this camp by Nazi, including 150000Poles, 23000 Roma, 15000 Soviet prisoners of war, and an enormous number of people from other nations in Auschwitz.(Bialecka 13).

The Auschwitz Concentration Camp was listed on the World Heritage List by UNSECO in 1979, when the amount of heritage in 1979 on this list was only one thirtieth of the current amount. It is the only concentration camp on this list until now. Hence, with a purpose of emphasizing the significance and outstanding universal value of this site, the UN named the anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz as Holocaust Remembrance Day, the name of this site has been linked with failure of humanity and described as one of the best example of extreme racism and become a special code in civilisation (Bialecka). No other heritage like Auschwitz has such a shocking meaning. Actually, compared with other historical heritage, the impact of Auschwitz just had started prior to the end of the Second World War. However, UNESCO was aware of the importance of a site which had a consecutive and tremendous impact. The value of Auschwitz does not merely present huge numbers of casualty, a period of Indelible past and various fields of education, it is also a new understanding of human beings' interpersonal relationship.

Arguments Admittedly, negative heritage is a symbol of sadness, hatred and error. To some extent, overemphasizing the importance of it is a repetition of our negative past. For the youths, they do not have the ability to distinguish the right from the wrong; neither do they know the memory that Auschwitz heritage conveys. In view of Bialecka, over one million people visit Auschwitz each year, and over 60% of which are school-aged youth, whose age are mainly between 14 to 16(Bialecka). Youths of this age group often lack basic knowledge and historical context of these events; therefore, they treat this learning experience superficially. They will just visit the camp alone without following expositors or joining a structured tour. Furthermore, it is quite hard for them to obtain some profound revelation, also they will have trouble in analysing the nightmare of Auschwitz intellectually. It is obvious that forcing the latter generation to accept negative information does not mean that they have identified the past mistakes human made and can benefit from it. Hence, it is believed that the educational value of negative like Auschwitz is overstated.

On the contrary, some believed that the educational value of negative heritage is underestimated. “Dark tourism”—tourism to sites related to death and disaster in negative heritage(Lennon and Foley, 2000) is not a new phenomenon, it has caught increasing attentions by researchers in recent years. In view of John cultural heritage is to warn people of those past tragedies and to prevent these events from recurring(John 2000). Nowadays, some scholars prefer to adventuring and imitating. Some good knowledge should be taught to these scholars so they can go on the right track.

Also, after visiting negative heritage, most people will become depressed basically due to dark atmosphere within the site. Besides, most negative heritage museums exhibit weapons, torture instruments, photos and relics of victims. On one side, it is the survivors in disasters that should be respected and avoid too much exposure. However, most survivors’ pictures or video interviews are often used for propaganda, which will increase the pain of the survivors. For example, a survivor once worked in Auschwitz and he was asked to talk about his experience to visitors, which some people think is not humane at all.

Bialecka once discussed about this issue in related to emotional response. In her opinion, few people, especially the young, are clear of what they are going to see and have a correct cognitive preparation. As a result, they tend to be more fearful beforehand and unwell after visiting. She also emphasized the importance of education to the young, she thinks that teachers’ help and explanation can help them alleviate and become more relax. New policy should be implemented in order to protect the privacy of the survivors, such as three dimensional method, which will the mainstream in the future (Lennon 2000). Negative heritage will not generally refer to death, the museums has now switched their focus on educating the youths and relief the survivors.

Descendants of the Jews will come every year and donate a staggering amount of money to help boost local community. There is no denying that Auschwitz has become only the economic pillar within this region.

Evaluation

Negative heritage embodies a contradiction between the desire to forget and the need to remember (Mills 2008:81). The drawbacks of negative heritage are the negative past; these sites witnessed racial conflict and elimination, religious strife, political persecution and wars. Forgetting the bad memory is an instinctive choice, because good things are more appealing to human, but human beings cannot develop correctly without past failures. The educational value of negative heritage is to warn mankind to avoid making the same mistakes. Most of negative heritage do not have a good look, but they are more helpful than other common sites, where people would directly ponder the past, instead of only a trip.

As mentioned before, the school-aged youth took up 60% of the total visitors and the educational value of the heritage to the young is to guide them to know about the past and bear their responsibilities and challenge anti-semitism, racism and prejudice within society, However, the fact is that many young individuals treat this learning experience superficially. As a result, there is delay to publish appropriate guidance and present educational value in negative heritage. Though guides in sites can help visitors recollect the past, historical preparation before visiting is still essential.

However, a case in point is that contemporary political issues seem to sway negative heritage. It is said that the United States wants to highlight the significant of the liberation and build a monument in Auschwitz. However, the Russia government thinks this action will damage the original site and a new monument does not convey the history of Auschwitz. Besides, China opposed that the Hiroshima Peace Memorial should be listed as heritage, since the nomination of Hiroshima was actually a strategic military base that represented the Japanese invasion and the war crimes committed in China (UNESCO 1996, Annex V; Utaka 2005). Many political factors influence the historical position of negative heritage, so take these factors into consideration will help us understand negative heritage more comprehensively.

Conclusion This essay has mainly discussed the drawbacks and benefits of negative heritage. The educational value which can make people fully understand history and cherish the peaceful age is widely recognized. However, the prosperity of negative heritage tourism proof economic value is still tremendous. Although there are multiple tough issues in negative heritage, humanity can tackle these issues and solve them by advanced technologies and conceptions in the future. Youngsters should be educated and guided when visiting these negative heritage. In spite of adventurous they are, some basic historical knowledge should be taught in advance to prevent their loss, depression and hatred after visiting these historical heritage. They should be taught that everything has two sides, those slaughter or murders are all the past time, nowadays, they should cherish peaceful and happy life. The most important thing is that people can benefit from these negative heritage and learn from them, reminding themselves of cherishing the current peaceful life that their ancestors gave.

To make a final conclusion, the benefits of negative heritage overwhelm its drawbacks, and negative heritage will get more and more attention and appreciation in the future. The main purpose of these negative museums should not pay too much focus on propagandizing its tragedy and bloody. More attention should be paid on emphasizing its educational value and the importance of our harmonious life.

Moreover, the aim of these negative heritage is to prove that all goodness will beat over evil at last. The evil will finally be criticized and looked down upon. The countries should pay more attention to their development instead of endless fighting or wars. It is human being's will to long for a peaceful and harmonious life. All human beings should unite as one, there is no enemies within one species. 1854 words

Reference List

Bialecka, A 2010, European pack for visiting Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial and Museum: guidelines for teachers and educators, Council of Europe, Strasbourg.

Cohen, E 2011, ‘Educational dark tourism at an in populo site: The Holocaust Museum in Jerusalem’, Annals of Tourism Research, vol. 38, no.1, pp.193-209. Retrieved August 8, 2012, from University College London Library & Electronic Resources.

Dunkley, R, Morgan, N & Westwood, S 2011, ‘visiting the trenches: Exploring meanings andomtivations in battlefield the tourism’, Tourism Management, vol.32, no. 4, pp. 860-868. Retrieved August 8, 2012, from University College London Library & Electronic Resources.

Gilly, C 2010, ‘Shining a Light on Dark Tourism: German Bunkers in the British Channel Islands’,Public Archaeology, vol. 9, no. 2, pp64-84. Retrieved August 8, 2012, from University College London Library & Electronic Resources.

Lennon, J & Foley M, 2000, Dark tourism, Continuum, London.

Meskell, L 2002, ‘Negative Heritage and Past Mastering in Archaeology’, Anthropological Quarterly, Vol.75, no. 3, pp. 557-574. Retrieved August 8, 2012, from University College London Library & Electronic Resources.

Murray, WF, Zedeno, MN, Hollenback, KL, Grinnell, C & Breast, EC 2011, ‘The remaking of Lake Sakakawea: Locating cultural viability in negative heritage on the Missouri River’ American Ethnologist, vol. 38, no. 3, pp. 468-483. Retrieved August 8, 2012, from University College London Library & Electronic Resources.

Rico, T 2008 ‘Negative Heritage: The Place of Conflict in World Heritage’, Conservation and Management of Archaeological Sites, vol. 10, no. 4, pp.344-352. Retrieved August 8, 2012, from University College London Library & Electronic Resources.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Disadvantages Of Social Capital

... however, the same ties that benefit members of a group can result in negative outcomes such as the exclusion of outsiders, excessive claims by insiders, restrictions of individual freedoms, and perpetuation of backwards norms etc. (Quibria, 2003, Eriksson, 2011). Social capital as a function (Coleman, 1988) can establish chances for network members; though, this is normally supported on religion, ethnicity, language, and career....

Words: 1373 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Cultural Diversity

...cultures, races, and ethnicities should have the chance to be understood and accepted for who they are, rather than what the media portrays them as. So many people are discriminated against because of a story in the news that has absolutely nothing to do with them as a person, but just relates to someone else from the same group, and therefore those people are generally discriminated against as a whole. This class has really helped to open my eyes to the true level of diversity in the United States today, and how much we could learn from each other if we just took the time to stop and accept each other. Another thing that I learned about in this class that pertains to my cultural history is the fact that so many people that immigrated to the United States from Ireland were discriminated against severely throughout history. I knew little about it before, but never really understood the full extent of the discrimination and hatred that was held towards the Irish immigrants until now. As diverse as society is today in the United States, I believe that by the year 2050 there will be at least one type of every culture from around the world found in the United States. I believe this because every day there are more and more immigrants coming to the United States for one reason or another, be it freedom from religious persecution or simply looking for better opportunities than what is available in their home...

Words: 1212 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Ielts Writing Band 9.0 - Simon

...Simon luôn được biết đến với phong cách đơn giản và hiệu quả. Những bài học thầy viết luôn gần gũi, dễ hiểu và dễ áp dụng đối với mọi học viên. Tương tự là những bài essays thầy viết mẫu. Chúng đều tương đối đơn giản, nhưng lại cực kỳ xuất sắc và đều đạt mức band điểm 9.0. Dưới đây là tổng hợp 18 bài essays mẫu của thầy Simon cho Task 2. Các bạn nên đọc và phân tích kỹ từng bài viết này để học được cách viết sao cho đơn giản, mạch lạc và kiếm được điểm cao nhất. Chúc các bạn học được nhiều điều từ những bài viết mẫu này. Trần Quang Thắng Tác giả: Simon Website: www.ielts-simon.com Người tổng hợp: Quang Thắng Website: www.ielts-quangthang.com Some people believe that hobbies need to be difficult to be enjoyable. To what extent do you agree or disagree? Some hobbies are relatively easy, while others present more of a challenge. Personally, I believe that both types of hobby can be fun, and I therefore disagree with the statement that hobbies need to be difficult in order to be enjoyable. On the one hand, many people enjoy easy hobbies. One example of an activity that is easy for most people is swimming. This hobby requires very little equipment, it is simple to learn, and it is inexpensive. I remember learning to swim at my local swimming pool when I was a child, and it never felt like a demanding or challenging experience. Another hobby that I find easy and fun is photography. In my opinion, anyone can take interesting pictures without knowing too much...

Words: 6043 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

Impact of Festivals and Events on a Destination

...(1993). In recent decades, a substantial amount of research has been carried out to examine the impacts of tourism on a destination and, to a lesser extent, events and festivals. Through this work, both positive and negative impacts of events and festivals on a destination have been discovered. Indeed, it is the expected benefits of events, whether economic, social, political or environmental, that is the principal drive underpinning the support for and increasing popularity of events and festivals at the local, national and international scale. Getz also believes that “local and regional events, including business events and conferences can increase visitation and expenditure, reduce seasonality, revitalize the economy, encourage repeat visitation and heighten regional awareness. Added to this, events and festivals can also provide the stimulus for additional infrastructure development in the local area and building community pride” (1993). On the other hand, events almost inevitably incur cost or have negative consequences that, to a lesser or greater extent, serve to reduce one’s net benefit. Unfortunately, these negative results can give rise to problems for the host community who may wish to host the event again. With this being said, event mangers should carefully plan an event in such a way that benefits are optimized and negative impacts are minimized. Event Planning and Management Developing a successful event, whether it is a local, special, business or major...

Words: 2035 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Foreign Investment in China

...INSTITUTIONS AND DEVELOPMENT By Mary M. Shirley 1 1. THE CHALLENGE OF DEVELOPMENT Developed countries are the exception, not the rule. Billions of dollars of aid and countless hours of advice notwithstanding, most countries have not been able to foster sustained growth and social progress. Increasingly research has shown that weak, Cross-country missing or perverse institutions are the roots of underdevelopment. regressions persistently demonstrate large and statistically significant correlations between institutional variables and growth, and in horse races between variables, an index of institutional quality “trumps” geography or trade as an explanation for growth (Rodrik, et al. 2002). To meet the challenge of development countries need two distinct and not necessarily complementary sets of institutions: (i) those that foster exchange by lowering transaction costs and encouraging trust, and (ii) those that influence the state to protect private property rather than expropriate it. 1 The first set of institutions includes contracts and contract enforcement mechanisms, commercial norms and rules, and habits and beliefs favoring shared values and the accumulation of human capital. Among the second set of institutions are constitutions, electoral rules, laws governing speech and education, and legal and civic norms. Today’s underdeveloped countries must acquire these institutions under particularly difficult conditions -- in a global market competing with already...

Words: 6045 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

Diversity

...Keller graduate school of management, Gm591 Mamun Chowdhury (Research question: How do differing perspectives affect out views of workforce diversity?) Introduction: Diversity relates to gender, age, language, ethnicity, cultural background, disability, sexual orientation or religious belief, including that people are different in other respects such as educational level, job function, socio-economic background, personality profile, marital status and whether or not one has family. Diversity and demographic differences can impact individual behavior by creating conflict in the workplace. The success of an organization depends on the workforce of the organization. A workforce made up of diverse individuals from different backgrounds can bring the best talent to an organization. Today, there are more and more ethnic people joining the workforce of the United States. Since the United States is considered the land of opportunity, more people from different backgrounds have migrated to our country over the past 100+ years to obtain work. Now, due to an increase in globalization and companies becoming more diverse, we are seeing even more people of ethnic backgrounds relocating to the United States for opportunities. With the increase in education, this is bringing forth many individuals of whom tend to have a great deal of input into organizations that otherwise would not have happened. These individuals bring a vast array...

Words: 3529 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Midterm Review Questions

...MGT 300 Midterm Review Questions Chapter 1 1. What is organizational performance and what is its relationship with efficiency and effectiveness?  Organizational performance: a measure of how efficiently and effectively managers use organizational resources to satisfy customers and achiever organizational goals. Efficiency: A measure of how well or productively resources are used to achieve a goal Effectiveness: A measure of the appropriateness of the goals an organization is pursuing and the degree to which the organization achieves those goals. 2. Explain the following terms: strategy, low-cost strategy, and differentiation strategy Strategy: A cluster of decisions about what goals to pursue, what actions to take, and how to use resources to achieve goals. Low cost strategy: a way of obtaining customers by making decision that allow an organization to produce goods or services more cheaply than its competitors so it can charge lower prices than they do Differentiation strategy: To deliver to customers new, exciting, and unique products 3. What does the managerial function of organizing involve? What is its outcome?  Organizing: structuring working relationships so organization members interact and cooperate to achieve organization goals. Outcome: The outcome of organizing is the creation of organization structure Organization structure: a formal system of task and reporting relationships that coordinates and motivates organizational members so they...

Words: 3544 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Dsddddd

...(PERIODICALS, DIRECTORIES, GUIDES, BOOKLETS / BROCHURES, MAPS, ETC.). | 10 | 3 | ANSWERING THE QUESTIONS: | 11 | 3 | CONCLUSION | 15 | | | | | | | | | | INTRODUCTION Ecotourism is: "Responsible travel to natural areas that conserves the environment and improves the well-being of local people." (TIES, 1990)  Ecotourism is about uniting conservation, communities, and sustainable travel. This means that those who implement and participate in ecotourism activities should follow the following ecotourism principles:   * Minimize impact. * Build environmental and cultural awareness and respect. * Provide positive experiences for both visitors and hosts. * Provide direct financial benefits for conservation. * Provide financial benefits and empowerment for local people. * Raise sensitivity to host countries' political, environmental, and social climate. Ecotourism is a growing segment of the national tourism industry that is making significant positive contributions to the environmental, social, cultural and economic well-being of destinations and local communities. Offering market-linked long-term solutions, ecotourism provides effective economic incentives for conserving and enhancing bio-cultural diversity and helps protect the natural and...

Words: 2783 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

‘‘the Positive Impacts of Mega Events Are Often Exaggerated’

...indirect audiences. Mega events offer the opportunity to project a desired image of a host country going far beyond the event itself, enabling a country to communicate assets that can be attractive for tourists. Getz, (1998), p.242 defines mega events as “Planned occurrences of limited duration which have an extraordinary impact on the host area in terms of one or more of the following: tourist volumes; visitor expenditures; publicity leading to a heightened awareness and a more positive image; related infrastructural and organisational developments which substantially increase the destination’s capacity and attractiveness”. Although the notion of events has been known for a long time, it is their scale and strategic use in late modern society that make them appealing for host places, media, researchers, visitors and others. Especially in tourism, mega events have attracted considerable interest. Roche (1994:1) states that ‘mega events are short term events with long term consequences for the cities that stage them’. Most of the numerous studies which have already been conducted on the nature of tourism determinants, such as that of Solberg and Preuss (2006), have found that the hosting of mega events tends to increase the number of arrivals of foreign tourists to the host country. More recently, however, a number of authors have been relatively sceptical, having come to regard past ex ante studies of mega events as having been too optimistic. In particular, Maennig, et al. (2009)...

Words: 2936 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Values

...to be included with the statement of the organization's vision. Dr. John Johns, in an article entitled "The Ethical Dimensions of National Security," mentions honesty and loyalty as values that are the ingredients of integrity. When values are shared by all members of an organization, they are extraordinarily important tools for making judgments, assessing probable outcomes of contemplated actions, and choosing among alternatives. Perhaps more important, they put all members "on the same sheet of music" with regard to what all members as a body consider important. The Army, in 1986, had as the theme for the year "values," and listed four organizational values-loyalty, duty, selfless service, and integrity-and four individual values- commitment, competence, candor, and courage. A Department of the Army pamphlet entitled Values: The Bedrock of Our Profession spent some time talking about the importance of values, and included this definition: Values are what we, as a profession, judge to be right. They are more than words-they are the moral, ethical, and professional attributes of character . . . there are certain core values that must be instilled in members of the U.S. Army-civilian and uniformed soldier alike. These are not the only values that should determine our character, but they are ones that are central to our...

Words: 5029 - Pages: 21

Free Essay

Islamaphobia and Europe

...increasingly pronounced. None more so than relations with European Muslims. This paper will examine identity politics as it relates to European civilization formation, looking at how Muslim political aspirations compare with those of other minority groups, as well as the changing face of Muslim political organizations and their role in changing perceptions. In determining the extent of Islamic challenges in Europe, it is important to understand how Muslim desires for identity recognition and respect compare to similar desires by other minority groups, as well as what constitutes equality in the contemporary epoch. Attitudes towards race and identity have developed beyond a mere colour blindness, towards a what has been termed “positive racial explicitness,” that is, taking pride in previously marginalized identities or in creating new identities as “a way of negotiating a position of equality and dignity” in today’s world. This hasn’t been limited to ethnic minorities either, but can be viewed in the identity politics of LGBT and feminist movements, especially in places where class politics have declined in salience. What is it that these movements expect and aim for? Iris Young described the ideal of equality as not simply being permission for minorities to follow the norms of dominant culture, but rather that “a positive self-definition of group difference is in fact more liberat[ing].” This leads to two interrelated conceptions of equality as they relate to the effective exercise of...

Words: 2304 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Diversity in Us Workforce

...challenges that managers confront in seeking to establish and maintain a legal and ethical workplace. This article first provides a general introduction to Civil Rights laws in the United States; and then furnishes a detailed legal analysis of age discrimination laws in the United States. Data dealing with the aging of the workforce, the unemployment rates of older workers, as well as the number of age discrimination lawsuits in the United States is furnished. Persistent racial inequality in employment, housing, and other social domains has renewed interest in the possible role of discrimination. Contemporary forms of discrimination, however, are often subtle and covert, posing problems for social scientific conceptualization and measurement. WHAT IS DISCRIMINATION? Discrimination is treating, or proposing to treat, someone unfavorably because of a personal characteristic protected by law. According to its most simple definition, racial discrimination refers to unequal treatment of persons or groups on the basis of their race or ethnicity. In defining racial discrimination, many scholars and legal advocates distinguish between differential treatment and disparate impact, creating a two-part definition: Differential treatment occurs when individuals are treated unequally because of their race. Disparate impact occurs when individuals are treated equally according to a given set of rules and procedures but when the latter are constructed in ways that favor members of one group over...

Words: 3054 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Racial Profiling

...still persists in our modern society in some form or the other. The United States of America is no stranger to incidents where these objectionable incidents are recorded widely, and it is not just relegated to poor neighborhoods and other similarly shady areas. Rather, it has become a permanent feature in the corporate world, Government and other similar places where these sorts of differentiations would be least expected. One community that has always been constantly repressed is the African American community. Their forefathers were brought to America’s shores as slaves, in times when slavery was still tolerated. To this day, many people in America still consider them as alien to their land. This of course leads to a host of problems across America that shows up when African Americans across the country are questioned about their fortunes. This sort of discrimination is often encouraged by many people that rather disturbingly have a lot of authority and power in making and implementing laws. Their argument is that discriminating and acting against the Black community is a viable way of making sure that Crime is kept in check. Distinguishing between color, creed, religion and race should be resigned to history. How many wars have we fought? How many lives cut short owing to this hate and fear? We of all societies should be able to recognize and judge that this kind of discrimination leaves us no better than wild animals, always afraid of what they don’t understand and ready...

Words: 2288 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Values&Ethics

...VALUES AND ETHICS INTRODUCTION Values and ethics are central to any organization; those operating in the national security arena are no exception. What exactly do we mean by values and ethics? Both are extremely broad terms, and we need to focus in on the aspects most relevant for strategic leaders and decision makers. What we will first discuss is the distinctive nature of ethics for public officials; second, the forces which influence the ethical behavior of individuals in organizations; and third, explore the actions strategic leaders can take to build ethical climates in their organizations. THE CHARACTER OF VALUES AND ETHICS Values can be defined as those things that are important to or valued by someone. That someone can be an individual or, collectively, an organization. One place where values are important is in relation to vision. One of the imperatives for organizational vision is that it must be based on and consistent with the organization's core values. In one example of a vision statement we'll look at later, the organization's core values - in this case, integrity, professionalism, caring, teamwork, and stewardship- were deemed important enough to be included with the statement of the organization's vision. Dr. John Johns, in an article entitled "The Ethical Dimensions of National Security," mentions honesty and loyalty as values that are the ingredients of integrity. When values are shared by all members of an organization, they are extraordinarily...

Words: 4898 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Case

...Sustainability 2010, 2, 3436-3448; doi:10.3390/su2113436 OPEN ACCESS sustainability ISSN 2071-1050 www.mdpi.com/journal/sustainability Review What is Sustainability? Tom Kuhlman 1,* and John Farrington 2 1 2 Agricultural Economics Research Institute, Wageningen University, P.O. Box 29703, 2502LS The Hague, The Netherlands Institute for Rural Research, Geography and Environment, University of Aberdeen, Elphinstone Road, Aberdeen AB24 3UF, Scotland, UK; E-Mail: j.farrington@abdn.ac.uk * Author to whom correspondence should be addressed; E-Mail: tom.kuhlman@wur.nl; Tel.: +31-70-3358-232; Fax: +31-70-3615-624. Received: 17 September 2010; in revised form: 15 October 2010 / Accepted: 19 October 2010 / Published: 1 November 2010 Abstract: Sustainability as a policy concept has its origin in the Brundtland Report of 1987. That document was concerned with the tension between the aspirations of mankind towards a better life on the one hand and the limitations imposed by nature on the other hand. In the course of time, the concept has been re-interpreted as encompassing three dimensions, namely social, economic and environmental. The paper argues that this change in meaning (a) obscures the real contradiction between the aims of welfare for all and environmental conservation; (b) risks diminishing the importance of the environmental dimension; and (c) separates social from economic aspects, which in reality are one and the same. It is proposed instead...

Words: 6817 - Pages: 28