Premium Essay

Abolishing Minimum Wage

In:

Submitted By RaeRae1309
Words 1834
Pages 8
Abolishing the Minimum Wage
ENGL 101 / Janet Stallard
Carla Woods
American Public University

Abolishing the Minimum Wage Many Americans think of the minimum wage as a means of raising the income of the working people. However, the minimum wage is not the best way to combat poverty. In fact, the minimum wage does more harm than good. The list of its negative effects is a long one: it causes unemployment; it prevents unskilled workers from getting the on-the-job training they need; it encourages teenagers to drop out of school; it promotes the hiring of illegal aliens; and it increases welfare dependency. For all of these reasons, the minimum wage should be eliminated. To evaluate the minimum wage, we must first understand why it was originally created and what its historical effects have been. The minimum w age was introduced in 1938 by President Franklin Roosevelt. According to Dr. Burton W. Folsom (1998), a senior fellow in economic education for the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, the driving force behind this new legislation was not the plight of the working poor but the political might of the highly paid textile workers of New England, who were trying to protect their jobs as they faced competition from Southern textile mills. The Southern mills were able to produce cloth of equal quality more cheaply than their counterparts in the North because of the lower cost of living in the South, which allowed Southern factories to pay lower wages to their workers. In response, Northern politicians successfully fought for legislation that would force Southern textile mills to raise wages, against the objections of Southern congressmen and many economists who warned that ”people whose skills and experience were [worth] less than whatever Congress decreed as the minimum wage would be priced out of the labor market” (Folsom, 1998). According to Folsom (1998),

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Debate Analysis

...Squared Debate Analysis COMS 305 Abolish Minimum Wage Debate I thought both sides debated the case well, and they all showed interest in the case. The main issue being debated was to abolish minimum wage which is a policy claim. All of the debaters had a clear claim which made me easily interested in both sides regardless of what side I took before the debate. The reason the claims were clear was because they each had verification proving what they were arguing. The debaters had strong poise, and both teams presented their case with assurance and compassion. They each spoke intelligently about their side. There were some key points though. One was whether minimum wages hurts or improves the lives of the poorest American families. Another was that minimum wage destroys jobs as well as job opportunities. In addition, social mobility was discussed, as well as reverse stimulus. The team that was for abolishing minimum wage pointed out that minimum wage takes away any alternatives and that alternatives force employers to treat employees well and specifically said, "most of us don't need legislation to protect us in the labor force" (Roberts). The best examples that were given was employers taking their business over seas and replacing workers with machines. For a specific example, they pointed out how Walmart no longer has baggers (Roberts). The cashiers do it. They also used the example that Hong Kong has never had a minimum wage and they rose up to be one of the most prosperous...

Words: 741 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Should Minimum Wage Be Abolished Essay

...Abolishing Minimum Wage In the news I have heard several debates about abolishing minimum wage. Minimum wage causes unemployment, poverty, and hurts businesses on achieving lower prices for the consumer. Abolishing minimum wage will create more jobs, stabilize our trade shortfalls, and adjust the differences in the cost of living correctly to help minimize poverty. There are several benefits of both abolishing minimum wage and keeping it as well. Popular economists believe thousands of jobs will be eliminated due to the high cost of the minimum wage law. For people that oppose the abolishment of minimum wages believe that this action will decrease the amount of employment available and make life for individuals who receive minimum wage impossible...

Words: 495 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Labor Market—What Novel and Not so Novel Ways Could Microeconomic Theory Suggest to Curb the Rise of Unemployment?

...novel ways could microeconomic theory suggest to curb the rise of unemployment? In both developing and developed countries, the unemployment stems from the fact that the supply of unskilled workers is far greater than the demand. To tackle this, government must tackle both: Demand Side – Besides a macroeconomic approach, such as boosting aggregate demand and economic growth, government can look to remove or reduce minimum wage. This would work best for industries where demand for labor is elastic, and firms will respond to a small decrease in wages by hiring a large number of workers. Another way to increase demand is to reduce the power of unions so they cannot bargain for wages above the market clearing level, allowing the firms to hire more. Supply Side – The number of unskilled workers can be reduced through: Education and Training by equipping unemployed with new skills to enable them to find jobs that require a higher skill level. However, the unemployed may be unable or unwilling to learn new skills. Improve Labour Market Flexibility by abolishing maximum working weeks and making it easier for firms to hire and fire workers. However, this could cause a rise in temporary employment. Improved Geographical Mobility by giving tax breaks to firms who set up in areas where unemployment is high. Alternatively, they can give financial assistance to unemployed workers who move to areas with high employment. Innovative Approach – As the aforementioned methods have somewhat...

Words: 559 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Minimum Wage

...Minimum wage legislation has been a topic of discussion for many years among economists. The first laws were introduced in Australia and New Zealand in order to protect minimum standard living for unskilled workers. At this point more than 90% of all countries have some kind of minimum wage legislation. However there are countries that do not set the minimum wage among those are: Germany, Finland, Iceland, Italy and other counties. Germany is the largest national economy in Europe. According to Central Intelligence Agency GDP of the country in 2011 is $2.94 trillion with real growth rate of 3.5%. Based on Trade Economic data unemployment rate of Germany in October 2011 was 6.5%. Despite the fact the Germany does not have a set minimum wage the average wages in western Germany is 27.9 euro per hour and 17.4 euro per our in Eastern German (source http://export.gov/germany based on data from 03/2011). The wages there are higher than average wages in European Union or worldwide. Of course there are laws of the German Government that regulate dismissal of workers/maternity leave/ vacation/health benefits; but not minimal wages. Minimum wage is set by the Government in order to protect unskilled workers. It provides employees with guaranteed minimum amount of income from their work to survive and pay their bills. It protects mostly adults from loosing their jobs to teenagers or foreigners that are ready to work for less than a minimum wage. However there are...

Words: 935 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Free Market

...1) Minimum wage: My opponent is in favour of it. There are several reasons to be opposed to it, however. One of the obvious is the fact that it can harm the economy. Businesses are expected to pay a certain amount, even if they can't afford it. This can affect how much goods they're able to produce thus hindering their ability to produce profit. Less profit can also result in less jobs available as they would only be able to afford to hire a limited number of workers. On the contrary, by removing minimum wage laws there are no such barriers to employment. Businesses would be able to pay whatever they can afford while still being fair. If an employee doesn't like the wages offered by a particular business they have a choice to not work there. They could seek out a business that pays better wages. Also, most businesses would be inclined to pay fair wages anyway; if nobody wants to work at a particular place due to bad wages then that business would risk bankruptcy. Paying unfair wages wouldn't be worth the risk for an established businessperson of losing their hard-earned business. 2) Welfare/social security: It is inevitable that in every society there'll be poor people. Both the left and right have different ways of approaching this issue. I am in favour of the right-wing view of abolishing the government social services. This has a few advantages. It, of course, requires paying taxes. With lower tax rates people would have more money to spend on other things, including...

Words: 410 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Supporting Penalty Rate Wages

...Title: Group Debate: Individual Essay Topic: Penalty wage rates for work done outside the ‘normal’ Monday-Friday working week should be abolished. (Defending) Introduction Penalty rate wage were introduced to compensate employees for working during the so-called unsocial hours. Unsociable hours of work occur during the days of the week or hours of the day when most of the people do not have to work. The idea behind the term is that there are only some times of day when others are available for social contact, and if the workers are expected to be at their workplaces at these times, social contact becomes very difficult (Bittman, 2005). Reducing standardisation of working hours makes scheduling and social coordination increasing difficult, if not impossible. The International Labour Organization (ILO) describes unsocial hours as ‘night works, weekend work and long shifts during peak periods’ (ILO, 2008). In practice, unsociable hours have been defined as anytime outside 9am to 5pm Monday (Dawkins, 1985). Traditionally, penalty payments were defended on the grounds that work at "socially unacceptable" times needs to be compensated. This was most obvious with respect to work on Sundays, the traditional day of rest in Christian societies, but this became a principle extended to Saturdays and evenings. (Visontay, 2011). Factors considered in defending penalty rates include the effects on religious, social and family life; lack of access to public transport, and the harmful...

Words: 2139 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Industrial Disputes

...mostly represented by trade unions. It is a disagreement between workers and management over pay, working conditions, hours of work, etc., especially one that includes strikes (workers refusing to work). 1 Causes of Industrial Disputes The causes of industrial disputes can be broadly classified into two categories: economic and non-economic causes. The economic causes will include issues relating to compensation like wages, bonus, allowances, and conditions for work, working hours, leave and holidays without pay, unjust layoffs and retrenchments. The non-economic factors will include victimization of workers, ill treatment by staff members, sympathetic strikes, political factors, indiscipline etc. Wages and Allowances Since the cost of living index is increasing, workers generally bargain for higher wages to meet the rising cost of living index and to increase their stan dards of living. In 2002, 21.4% of disputes were caused by demand 20.4% during 2003 and during 2004 increased up to 26.2%. In 2005, of higher wages and allowances. This percentage was wages and allowances accounted for 21.8% of disputes. Personnel and Retrenchment The...

Words: 6688 - Pages: 27

Free Essay

Discriminatory Wage Gap

...Discriminatory Wage Gap “The gap between the median wage for a man and that of a woman in 2010 was $10,784.00 per year. The gender wage gap gets larger with age and builds up over time. But for women in the final five years of their careers before retirement, the wage gap grows to a whopping $14,352.00. Over a 40-year career, the average woman will lose $431,000.00 to the gender wage gap” (Cooper 1). Does this seem fair? It seems quite obvious to the common observer that there should be equal pay across the board for the same job accomplished regardless of gender, education or any other factor one might dream up. Nevertheless, according to most research and authorities on the subject of equal pay, there is a gap between the earnings of men and women. Moreover, as one delves into the subject more thoroughly, one notes it is much more complicated than simply equal pay for the same work performed. Women are greatly affected by the wage gap over time where they lose a significant amount of money the closer they are to retirement. As of April, 2014, the Center for American Progress states that to every dollar a man makes, a woman makes 77 cents (Cooper 1). Thus, it is apparent that women are still behind the men in terms of equal pay in the workforce. While women's pay in the workforce has traditionally been less than a man’s it nevertheless has increased over the years; however, as of 2014 there still exists a pay gap which can only be addressed through legislation, enforcement...

Words: 2903 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

David Bacon Act

...University Explain what you are going to do. Will you prove a point? Will you be looking at various opposing views and weighing up the merits? Spell out exactly what you will achieve in your term paper right here. * A brief explanation of the problem * Aim of your term paper * What questions will be answered in the term paper * A brief outline of current research * Relevance of the term paper topic * The research process Introduction: Contractors bid on U. S. Federal Construction projects and most contracts for federally assisted constructions exceeding $2,000 required to pay their employees the standard wage and benefit package that workers in the area performing similar work are earning the “prevailing wage”. Prevailing Wage typically means the local union wage. In government contracting, “a prevailing wage is the hourly wage, benefits and overtime, paid to the majority of workers, laborers, and mechanics within a particular area”. The culprit of all of this is the “Davis Bacon-Act” (DBA) The act was amended several times and has been attacking by opponents claiming its racist, unnecessary, expensive and costing taxpayers and the government a lot of money. Republicans have been attacking and trying to repeal the Davis-Bacon Act on the grounds that it is outdated, expensive and bureaucratic. Their latest effort last year was claiming, the repeal will cut 2.5 trillion from the budget over the next ten years and will save 1 billion annually. Recently...

Words: 10208 - Pages: 41

Premium Essay

Business

...* Eurofound * EIRO * EMCC * EWCO |Skip to contents | | * Site Map   * Help   * Contact ------------------------------------------------- Top of Form Search Terms:   Bottom of Form You are here: Eurofound > EIROnline > 2004 > 11 > Industrial relations in Japan 2003-4My Eurofound: Login or Sign Up    Industrial relations in Japan 2003-4 This record reviews 2003-4's main developments in industrial relations in Japan, and focuses on the topical issues of migration and pensions reform. Economic developments In 2003, Japan's GDP fell by 0.1% over 2002 in nominal terms, but increased by 2.5% in real terms, which significantly exceeded the real growth rate in 2002 (a fall of 0.3%). Private demand, especially private capital investment, showed significant growth of 9.3% (after a fall of 7.2% in 2002). Due to the recovery in overseas economic conditions, Japan's exports also rose by 10.1%, exceeding the 2002 level (8.0%). On the other hand, private final consumption expenditure remained virtually flat in 2003, with only 0.8% growth on the preceding year's level (0.9%). Conversely, public demand shrank by 2.1% (due to a reduction in public works). According to the Cabinet Office's 2004 'Annual Report on Japanese economy and public finance/economic survey of Japan', Japan's economic growth in 2003 can be attributed to: i) increased private demand; ii) improvements in corporate financial positions through reduction of excessive debt and...

Words: 11733 - Pages: 47

Free Essay

Family

...parenting styles, and sometimes the lack of rest (George, 2009). Around 43% of children live within a single parent home that is at or below the national poverty level (George, 2009). Due to not being financially stable, some single parents are forced to live in low-income neighborhoods which result into poor schooling systems. More children are likely to drop out of school and to be raised in poverty. Consequently there are more like to be teen pregnancies. Around 60% of are raised by young single parents who are less likely to get married (Feldman, 2011). In addition to teenagers are more likely to raised their child without the help and support of the father, as a result most teenagers abandon their education and have to rely on minimum wage jobs for a source of income (Feldman, 2011). According to Feldman, “ The consequences of living in a single parent families depends on the financial condition of the family and, if there had been two- parents, the level of hostility that existed between them” (Feldman 2011). the majority of people think the cause is whether there were two parents at first and situation changed leaving one parent to raise the child. Additionally the economic status is a very important aspect on determining what types of consequences the child will grow up with. Consistent with Bramlett &...

Words: 630 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Income Dist and Poverty

...unequal income distribution. But for the United States, it has examining percentile distributions. The US is using five groups to show the percentage of income received. As we can see from the table U.S. Census Bureau, the proportion received by the poorest Americans has remained virtually unchanged. Most of the observed changes occurred between 1929-1970, probably reflecting the impact of the great depression and new government programs in the 1930s, as well as World War II from 1950-1980, so there was a little change in the overall distribution (from textbook). Therefore, many things can influence the income distribution, such as wage payment systems change, tax laws change, transfer payment systems change, property rights change, economic systems change and general economic conditions change. b) As we know, the income for workers, it might be wages or salaries for a month. The dividend is the income for stock owners. Interest is the income for holders of savings accounts. Individuals will have several sources of income, but labor income is the main source of income for many individuals and families. The labor income could affect by age, skill and human capital, worker preferences, and job preferences. Younger people with few skills tend to make little income when...

Words: 759 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Schukra Case Analysis

...apply cost cutting measures and cut down the numbers of non-core staff to maintain a profitable situation. Based on the economic forecast -optimum but fragile- the company could operate on a profitable level which indicates the company wants to maintain a level of production which it used to, but is worried about the future in this fragile economy. So the company decided to hire temporary / limited term staff. The headquarters of the North American branch of Schukra Inc. could not be properly operated without the support of the technical and engineering expertise of top management. So they trying to accommodate them their best in order to maintain the core function of the company. This decision is implied by two commitments: maintaining the wage rate and health and welfare benefits, and job security. To coordinate the decisions which benefit the core workers, the company decided to increase the production level by hiring temporary workers who are introduced by an outside agency. Most of the temporary...

Words: 1975 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Higher Minimum Wage

...Next month, people in SeaTac will vote on Proposition 1-- it would lift the minimum wage to $15 an hour for workers at the airport and its nearby hotels, parking lots and car-rental agencies. That’s a 63 percent increase over Washington’s current minimum wage of $9.19 an hour, the highest of any state. A year ago, Jorge Sanchez of Long Beach, California was struggling to support his family on $9.75/hour as a dishwasher at a hotel. Sanchez, 56, threw his support behind hiking the minimum wage to $13 an hour for hotel workers in this city just south of Los Angeles. But the Colombia native soon experienced an unintended consequence: The same month he got a $3.25-an-hour bump in pay, Sanchez’s employer cut his workweek from 40 to 30 hours. “Measure N was good because it raised our wages. But what the hotel did was cut our hours, so it hasn’t made a change,” he said. Unlike Sanchez, Hilton bellman Donald Blackwood still works a 40-hour week and pulls in an extra $800 a month thanks to the city’s “living wage” law. “Now, I have enough money saved up to buy a car,” he said. Both the SeaTac and Long Beach measures are part of a stepped-up effort by labor and community activists nationwide to end what they call poverty-wage jobs. In Seattle, both mayoral candidates are plugging an hourly minimum standard of $15 or more. Prop. 1 proponents say it would lift low-wage workers out of poverty and give them more money to spend at local businesses, pumping an additional $54 million...

Words: 298 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

O and B

...At Commerzbank this theory could be put under scrutiny as every worker may have their own epitome of ‘one best way” to perform a task . His other theory of a ‘fair days of work’ ,may not be successful at Commerzbank as a workers wage depends upon his performance in monetary terms . However, this principle must be viewed with a degree of caution, as the notion of this theory would exclude payments being made to new/untrained employees and trainees. As they may not generate any revenue at all or an insignificant amount for Commerzbank. According to this theory this may lead to a salary which is below the minimum wage .If this was to happen Commerzbank would be breaking the law. It is worth considering that due to the drastic change in the volatile economy employers have rights unlike in Taylor’s Industrialised time . Some people may disagree and state that due to Taylor believing that it is a mangers role ,to do the thinking and the workers to the physical aspect of the job .If a worker was slow it would be the managers duty to use their initiative, and do part of the job to pick up the pace . Instead of the manger doing the mental aspect of the task they are also doing the physical at this point. If a worker generated a vast amount of revenue for Commerzbank, but was not paid accordingly this would lead to predicaments .The firm may be unable to match the X amount of revenue to a workers salary, thus resulting in underpayments being made . Money is not the only...

Words: 515 - Pages: 3