Free Essay

American Canal

In:

Submitted By omee001
Words 1162
Pages 5
American Canal

The All-American Canal and Its Effects on Illegal Immigration

Abstract

This paper explores three public articles and one segment of 60 minutes that explore the effects of the All-American Canal and the ongoing battle against illegal immigration. The canal is owned by the federal government and operated by the Imperial Irrigation District (IID). This paper will examines both sides of the moral obligation and responsibility of the government and the immigrants that attempt to cross the canal. Keywords: Imperial Irrigation District, responsibility

Claim:

“It is permissible for the federal government to allow the drowning deaths of illegal immigrants at the All-American Canal to continue because they aren’t required to provide life saving equipment.

Explanation of the claim: The All-American Canal is an aqueduct that conveys the last drops of Colorado River water into the Imperial Valley in California. The canal provides drinking water for 9 cities and irrigates over 500,000 acres. It was built in the 1930’s by the United States Bureau of Reclamation and completed in 1942. It’s owned by the federal government and operated by the Imperial Irrigation District (IID). Two thirds of our winter fruits and vegetables are grown using this water. The canal creates jobs in the farming industry and half of the people who pick the crops are illegal aliens who cross the canal from Mexico. The problem is the canal is 225 feet across and 20 feet deep with currents that can carry a person 8 feet per second once in the water. Since the double fences were installed on the borders of San Diego, Ca. and Mexico in 1997 border crossing there has significantly decreased and as a result the canal has become the new entry place into the U.S. Since 1997 over 850 people have perished trying to cross the canal from Mexico. They are buried in a California desert in unmarked graves.

Reasons for the Claim:
The canal is used for thermoelectric power and irrigation, not recreation or public use. The canal has been a vital source of water supply since 1942 and was never intended as a crossing point for people.
The people crossing the canal are doing so at there own risk and are breaking the law. There are signs posted at the canal warning of dangerous currents. Is the federal government responsible for protecting people breaking the law?
Providing climb out ladders and life lines would only encourage more illegal immigration. Life lines and climb out ladders would only encourage more people to cross illegally increasing the illegal immigration problem even more.
Installation of life saving equipment would cost millions of dollars and directly support illegally crossing into the U.S. This would send the wrong message to US citizens and citizens of Mexico. It’s like saying it’s alright to break the law and we’re going to help all violators do so by adding escape devices to a canal not meant for humans.
Reasons against the Claim:
The crops that the canal supplies water to be worked by 50 percent illegal aliens so it’s the main reason people cross over for employment. The federal government funded a project to have fish trapped in the canal lifted over the hydroelectric drops, the same drops that the dead bodies flow to.
The double fences that were installed in San Diego were government funded. The canal can be made safer by either installing fences or climb out ladders.
Lots of money is being made off the labor of the same people crossing the canals illegally. We spend several million dollars daily in Iraq and Afghanistan to help people who don’t want us there in the first place.
The government has a moral responsibility to help even if a crime is being committed. If we can help countries all over the world surely we can extend a hand to a bordering country as well.
Decision:
I feel the reasons for the claim are stronger mainly because the U.S. is currently dealing with a serious illegal immigration problem that’s affecting jobs, social security and the welfare system to name a few. When immigrants are willing to risk their lives to cross an irrigation canal without any safety concerns now then if safety measures are installed it only increases the immigration problem and weakens our borders even more. Border control is a serious problem that’s gotten out of control that must be dealt with harshly.
Rebuttals:
The government is not responsible for who farmers hire to work their crops. The only interest the government has is to the farmers crops getting water so they can produce goods. The project for the fish lift was approved because the fish arrived in the canal naturally and in order to survive must be lifted over the hydroelectric drops. Not to lower the importance of the people who died in the canal but they were deceased already.
The double fences were put in place to keep illegal immigrants from crossing the border and to keep drugs out of the U.S. By installing climb out ladders and life lines in the canal that would just counter the reason for putting up the double fences all together. It would only cause more immigrants to try and cross illegally. To support this installation would only promote more violations.
The people who work these crops are not forced to do so; they choose to earn a living for low wages because it’s better than what they had. The overall purpose is to help the citizens of Iraq and Afghanistan establishes a free and positive lifestyle without the threat of dictatorship. There are some who protest US involvement but they are few. The majority of the citizens welcomes the nations of NATO and supports our troop involvement.
The government has and will continue to help those who come to America legally. It is not responsible or liable for loss of life that occurs by people who attempt to enter the country illegally. Mexico is ultimately responsible to its people and its government should be working to improve the quality of life for its citizens.

References

All-American Canal, California-Mexico border Portions of the public domain text of this US government article have been incorporated into this article.
Pelley, Scott (May 2, 2010). "The Deadly Passage of the All-American Canal". 60 Minutes. http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/04/30/60minutes/main6448631.shtml?tag=currentVideoInfo;segmentTitle. http://books.nap.edu/html/biomems/jsavage.pdf John Lucian Savage Biography by Abel Wolman & W. H. Lyles, National Academy of Science, 1978. http://www.saltonsea.ca.gov/about/about.htm Salton Sea Authority | the Sea's Vital Statistics http://www.saltonsea.ca.gov/about/myth.htm Salton Sea Authority | Myths and Realities Imperial Valley Press, July 16, 2007.
"All American Canal - 60 Minutes Profile on 'Most Dangerous Body of Water in US'. National Ledger. May 3, 2010. http://www.nationalledger.com/ledgerdc/article_272631594.shtml. Retrieved May 5, 2010

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Panama Canal Expansion Project: Have American Fears Come True?

...13 January 2014 Last updated at 15:16 ET Share this pageEmail Print Share this page ShareFacebookTwitter.Panama Canal expansion project: Have American fears come true? Comments (31) By Thomas Sparrow BBC Mundo, Washington The US has a lot riding on a successful expansion of the Panama canal Continue reading the main story Related Stories Row threatens Panama Canal expansion Nicaragua canal construction delayed Panama profile More than four years ago, when Panama awarded the lucrative contract to expand its inter-oceanic canal to a mostly European consortium, the United States was not pleased. An American company whose bid was unsuccessful, Bechtel, thought the winning tender would barely pay for pouring the concrete and that the consortium would probably try to renegotiate the price at some stage during the construction process. Some might argue that those American doubts have been justified, especially in view of the ongoing economic row between the European consortium and the Panamanian government agency that runs the waterway. The spat has threatened to bring work to a grinding halt, unless the two parties manage to resolve a $1.6bn (£1bn) dispute over cost overruns. A series of WikiLeaks cables from the US embassy in Panama that were revealed by the Spanish daily newspaper El Pais in 2010 provided an inside view of the frustration that was felt in the US at not having been able to get that contract. Bechtel had been strongly backed by the...

Words: 794 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Panama Canal In American Politics

...of European countries. The Monroe Doctrine of 1823 asserted the United State’s position by warning European powers against any further attempts to colonize lands in the Western Hemisphere. The American continents are henceforth not to be considered as subjects for future colonization by any European power. With the economic growth of Latin America and the Pacific the United States began to see the need for a more efficient and secure route to the east coast. The Isthmus of Panama was identified as that route and...

Words: 1812 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Love Cana

...Viewpoint William T. Love – who made the man-made canal that he envisions linking the Niagara River to Lake Ontario, providing water and hydroelectric power for a model industrial city. Time Frame: Between 1942 and 1953 Hooker Chemical disposed of about 22,000 tons of mixed chemical wastes into the Love Canal. Background of the case Near the end of the nineteenth century, after America was once again a unified country, the entrepreneurial pioneers looked towards shipping. Many canals, such as the C&O and Erie Canals, unified American waterways to provide an efficient shipping system. In 1894, venture capitalist William Love envisioned a "power canal" (the purpose of which was to supply cheap hydroelectric power) in the Niagara Falls region of New York State. Construction began on Love's vision, but soon a depression hit the nation, and Love was left with no investors and little more than an empty ditch. "Love Canal"--as the hole became affectionately known by the local townspeople-- became a swimming hole in the summer, and an ice skating rink in the winter. This attitude towards the canal was to end by the mid-1900's. In 1942, Hooker Chemical and Plastics Corporation negotiated a deal with the current title-holders of the land, the power company, whereby the Corporation was allowed to dump any wastes into the canal. Hooker finally bought out the land, and its surroundings, in 1947. To the company's defense, [the chemicals were dug into impermeable clay soil [oec]...

Words: 478 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Hhhhhhhhhhhhh

...What major prerequisites allowed the industrial revolution to begin in Britain? Somewhere between 1740 and 1780, Britain experienced a series of rapid economic and social changes. This was to be the beginning of the Industrial revolution. Whilst this revolution would spread to other major countries around the world, it is undeniable that it all started off in Britain. There are many reasons for this, and it is important to note that there was nothing particularly unique about Britain in comparison with the rest of Europe, it was simply a combination of factors came together at the right time for Britain and allowed it to gain a head start in its own industrial revolution. One of the reasons why Britain’s industrial revolution began first actually has a large element of luck involved. Britain was very fortunate in that it had a large amount of natural resources, especially coal, that could be mined. This meant that Britain did not have to rely on foreign trade in order to manufacture their own goods, they could simply mine it for themselves. Iron was another natural resource that Britain was lucky to have in abundance. Both coal and iron would prove to be crucial in the construction of railways, which were vital for transporting resources, goods and people around the country at a much faster rate than had previously been possible. Coal and iron would also be required to build and, subsequently, fuel the factory machines that would manufacture all of Britain’s industrial goods...

Words: 1931 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

A Dangerous in City

...Bangkok Dangerous Zone Bangkok is a capital city of Thailand and very famous city for tourists all around the world. More than ten million tourists from many places around the world spend a lot of their time and money in Bangkok each year. However, there are many negative articles from tourists who used to visit Bangkok. They were complained about the security in their life, pollution in Bangkok, and protest. As a Thai citizen, I agree with them because I am the one who faced with those problems before. There are three main parts that I think it is correct to say that Bangkok is a dangerous zone, which are security in their life, pollution, and protest. When we want to travel somewhere, we always look at the previous information from Internet or another source as a guide. We need to be sure about many things before we are going to be there. In addition, a security in traveling or stay there is one of the most important to be decided whether to go or not. As many tourists were mentioned about this, so I would like to amplify in more details about this kind of thing also. In Bangkok, we will face with a low quality of transportation services. Once the tourists reach to airport, they do not have enough information to go to their destination in a blink of an eye. They will face with a fake taxi that will charge them with an unreasonable price or rob and rape them if possible.—this situation is real. Moreover, in Bangkok has many type of transportation that will give them a cause...

Words: 868 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

English

...plow would be strapped to a mule or horse. The horse or mule would pull the plow along which allow to create the rows. It allow farmers to plow their fields a lot faster and easier. The rows would be straight and spaced out from each other. Then they would use a seed drill after they had plow the fields. It would a drill a hole and planted a seed. This method was very beneficial because it help allow more plants to be planted and less seeds to be wasted. Canals were another great invention by the ancient Chinese. It would allow boats to get through the cities very easily. The canals was a water system dug by the farmers. It made travel and trade easier for the boats. In the canals, the canal pound lock was helpful for the boats. It had two walls in the canals and the walls could be raised up. The boat would sail in through the first wall. Then the first wall would be shut and then the second wall would slowly raise up. This would allow water level to equal out so the boats could safely sail through. The bridges over the canal were made with arches. Ancient China made the concept of the arch. The arch allow for bridges to be stronger and...

Words: 634 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Grobalization

...Imagine a world in which all the rivers are connected to each other. There are many rivers and they each have their own source, and they have tides and currents that come in and go out. The waters of the rivers mix and merge to such extent that the temperature and fish populations are pretty much the same no matter where you go. The people of the world use the rivers for food, water, recreation, power and transport. They go upstream and they go downstream, they build damns, boats, and irrigation systems. You can think of Globalization as this entire system of rivers, structures, people, products, ideas, and all the processes that help or hinder the mixing of the metaphoric 'waters'. Two major aspect of globalization are; grobalization and glocalization. We can use the analogy of the rivers to explore these aspects. Imagine a world in which there are only a handful of very large mountains. These mountains are the sources of water for most of the world. The water that begins in their peaks has a very powerful current as it flows in a downward motion to the rest of the world. At first in mighty rivers that are so strong they have washed out smaller mountains in their path, they have toppled water reservoir towers and engulfed lakes and eventually come together into just one mega river that reaches entirely around the world. This river then branches out into all reaches of all the lands so that there are very few places to get water other than from this mega river. Now...

Words: 1604 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

The Seventh Manmade Wonder of the World

...Manmade Wonder of the World. The building of the Panama Canal was one of the most grandiose and dramatic American ventures of all times. A shipping gateway between Central and South America had been a desire from the 1600’s, first attempted by the French in the 1880s and later completed by United States in 1914, under the direction of Theodore Roosevelt. U.S. intervention with the Panama Canal brought an end of a revolution and the birth of a new nation, the Republic of Panama, and creation of one of biggest strategic advantages that truly brought the U.S. Navy into the next century as a growing superpower. The canal was the largest and most expensive project ever attempted up to that date in U.S. history and easily changed the face of the western hemisphere, if not the world. A quick, easy and safe passage for merchant ships and navies to pass between the Pacific and Atlantic oceans had been a desire of many since early 17th century. Study after study was conducted and focused on Panama, which was a part of Colombia; Nicaragua and the Isthmus of Tehuantepec in Mexico. Regardless of the desire or need, early plans were often abandoned because the undertaking was near impossible and government politics often made negotiations more difficult. The French were the first nation to attempt the project and were confident of success after building the Suez Canal in Egypt. In 1876, the Interoceanic Canal Commission was created to head up the project and placed in the...

Words: 2097 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

The Panama Canal - from Yesterday to Tomorrow

...The Panama Canal: From Yesterday to Tomorrow By Clarence Moore North Lake College Introduction to Business Logistics LGMT-1319-73471 Professor Jeffrey Wendt April 2013 When the first European, Rodrigo de Bastidas, reached Panama in 1501, he could hardly envision the magnitude of the Isthmus’ future. As more Spanish caravels arrived, the search for gold was intensified. A shortened route from the Atlantic Ocean to the Pacific Ocean was not found by Magellan, who conceived of going around Cape Horn or passing through the Straits that were to bear his name. When sea routes were found to be to long the Spaniards turned to overland crossings, and when Vasco Nunez de Balboa first crossed the Isthmus of Panama in 1513, he initiated a ceaseless march of traffic. Panamanians are still proud of the curious Balboa who discovered the Pacific, surveyed the Panama route across the Central America Isthmus and found that there existed a difference in the levels of the respective oceans. The Conquistador Herman Cortes was certain that no natural waterway existed between the Atlantic and the Pacific, and he expressed a desire to construct a sea passageway through Panama, Darien, Nicaragua, or Tehmantepec. The dreams of the foresighted Cortes went for naught as it was almost three centuries before serious consideration was again given to the construction of an interocean waterway (Liss). From the beginning of the sixteenth century until the beginning...

Words: 2013 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

How Does Morrison Build A Canal

...Morrison are somewhat valid, but I think that the second expression is more accurate. Of course, building a canal is a difficult thing in itself that required: precise measurement taking, leveling, and calculations; adequate tools and technology; access to appropriate materials; and hardworking, intelligent, obedient, and detail oriented workers. With all of those things the canals would have been more successful like in other countries that had been canal building for decades. These men didn’t have any of those things to begin with and even after obtaining help of a notable English engineer with experience and the correct tools and materials, there were still issues sue to the men themselves. The Middlesex...

Words: 440 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How Did France Build The Panama Canal

...The Panama Canal is a canal that leads from the Atlantic Ocean to the Pacific Ocean. Lots of people thought about digging a tunnel from one end to the other. It was potential land for this but the technology wasn’t there yet and no one had the money for it. After some time, technology rose and France started the first attempt at the digging of the Panama Canal. This canal would be dug out at sea-level and go through the narrow bridge between North and South America. About halfway through the project, and a lot of digging was done, France noticed the canal was not going to work and it was a failure. Their machines did not cut through the rocky terrain, they were running out of money very quickly, and most men were getting diseases like...

Words: 2281 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Suez Crisis

...The Suez Crisis During the 1950’s, Britain’s rule over Egypt led them to gain joint control over the Suez Canal with the French. However, many Egyptians were tired of Britain’s presence because they felt as if they were second class citizens in their own country. This led to Egypt’s military beginning to pressure Britain’s armies, located in the Canal Zone, so they would leave. Not only were attacks made on the British, but also on Israeli troops along the border between the two countries. Years later, this long and negative history between the nations would eventually lead to the joint decision for Israel, Britain, and France to attack Egypt when Colonel Gamal Abdel Nasser nationalized the Suez Canal in July 1956. As a result, the Suez Crisis ensued. During the course of this paper, I will argue that the Suez Crisis had a greater impact on Britain and Frances’ power as colonizing countries as it exposed significant military weaknesses. I will first discuss in further detail what the Suez Crisis was. Then I will explain the different measures that were taken to maintain peace amongst the nations involved. Lastly, I will discuss the different outcomes Egypt, Britain, France, and Israel faced. When Colonel Nasser replaced General Neguib in 1954 he had three main goals for Egypt. These included: making Egypt independent by ending British occupation, building up the Egyptian forces for an effective attack on Israel, and building the economy by constructing a dam at...

Words: 2002 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Exploration of Risk Paper

...PROJECT PART 1. EXPLORATION OF RISK: CONSTRUCTION OF THE THIRD SHIPPING LANE THROUGH THE PANAMA CANAL Presented to: R. Hiles PM595 Prepared by: Carlton D. Clyburn Jr. OCTOBER 2012 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Introduction 3 II. Exploration of Risks 4 III. Fault Trees 4 a. Fault Tree: Project Completion Delay 5 b. Fault Tree: Changes in Cost Projections (Overruns) 6 IV. Conclusion 7 V. References 8 Introduction Construction of a third shipping lane through the Panama Canal has begun and it is a collaboration of contractors and manufacturers from around the globe working in unison to exacting concrete and design specifications. The Panama Canal’s third lane expansion involves building enormous new locks that will accommodate the new generation of shipping vessels that are about three times the size of “Panamax” ships constructed to fit precisely in the existing canal’s lock chambers. According to the vessel glossary of the World Trade Ref, the Panamax is defined as: “An ocean-going cargo vessel of the maximum size possible to pass through the locks of the Panama Canal, which are 1000ft long by 110ft wide and 85ft deep. These vessels are typically of 50,000 to 80,000 dwt, 965ft (290m) in length; 106ft. (32.3m) beam; and 39.5ft (12.04m) draft.” The new locks on the Atlantic and Pacific entrances will consist of a trio of chambers measuring 1400ft (427m) long, 180ft (55m)...

Words: 8572 - Pages: 35

Free Essay

The Definite Article

...The definite article - the The definite article The indefinite article Exercises: Articles The definite article - the The definite article the is the same for all genders in singular and in plural. the boy, the girl, the cat, the computers If the following word begins with a vowel, we speak [], if the following word begins with a consonant, we speak []. [] | [] | the following word starts with a spoken consonant | the following word starts with a spoken vowel | the girl | the English girl | the book | the orange book | the school | the old school | the unit Here a [] is pronounced at the beginning of the word. | the uncle Here a [] is pronounced at the beginning of the word. | We have listed some examples in the following table. There you can see when we use the definite article and when we don't. without the definite article | with the definite article | general words (indefinite) | general words (definite) | Life is too short. I like flowers. | I've read a book on the life of Bill Clinton. I like the flowers in your garden. | names of persons on the singular, relatives | family names in the plural | Peter and John live in London. Aunt Mary lives in Los Angeles. | The Smiths live in Chicago. | public buildings, institutions, means of transport (indefinite) | public buildings, institutions, means of transport (definite) | Mandy doesn't like school. We go to school by bus. Some people go to church on Sundays. | The school that Mandy goes...

Words: 550 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How Did France Build The Panama Canal

...The Panama Canal was one of the United States of America’s biggest projects ever built and is known by some people as one of the 7 great wonders of the world. This structure was built in 1901 and spreads over 50 miles of land. The Panama Canal was said to be impossible to build, as so many countries helped to create it. The French were the first to begin the project, but due to financial obstacles, they stopped the process. Not just this but the French did not have the technology to go any further. Further down the timeline, an American company began to build the canal, and the project was on again. One by one, 50 countries helped build this canal, going through Panama connecting the two greatest oceans together, the Pacific ocean and the Atlantic ocean....

Words: 659 - Pages: 3