Free Essay

Animals in Disgrace

In:

Submitted By Rika1992
Words 1226
Pages 5
Coetzee uses animals in his novel Disgrace to become metaphorical images of the characters and in some way the characters become animal-like characters. It also reflects the struggles that they go through in the post-colonial era.
Animals are significant in the novel Disgrace become metaphorical to the people in the novel and how their situations that they find themselves in change them to become the animals. A certain situation can make them result into a certain animal, but they also change from one animal to another animal, depending on what curve ball life troughs at them.
According to Patton (2009) it is clear that from the beginning of the novel David Lurie has a strong distinction between humans and animals. He believes that “We are from different order of creation from the animals.” (Coetzee: 1999, 74). Humans are not equal to animals in any way, humans have a soul that is not bound to them, before we are born we were already a soul, and when a person dies his soul leaves his body, where as an animal’s “souls are tied to their bodies and die with them.” (Coetzee, 1999, 78).David believes that animals do not have a proper soul, but his seeing changes and by the end of the novel, he finds that humans are equal to animals. He is in the room, the room where he and Bev organize the death of the animals, and David comes to a realisation and he thinks to himself “here the soul is yanked out of the body…” (Coetzee: 1999, 219).
According to Meier (2006): David Lurie explains in the beginning of the novel that his sexual intercourse with Soraya is like snakes, which can be seen as a negative image, that partake in intercourse. He describes his symbol to sex as “lengthy, absorbed, but rather abstract, rather dry, even at its hottest.” (Coetzee: 1999, 3). Later again David when he has intercourse with Melanie he describes her as a rabbit and himself as a fox, “like a rabbit when the jaws of the fox close on its neck.” (Coetzee: 1999, 25). These images he uses is negative towards himself and it is seen clearly that he does not really care for Melanie or Soraya, but when his trail at the university is over and the students question him he becomes the defenceless animal, “They circle around him like hunters who have cornered a strange beast and do not know how to finish it off.”(Coetzee:1999, 56).
Even though he dislikes animals in the beginning, it is clear that David Lurie takes on metaphorical roles of different animals in the novel. Some of the animals he portrays is negative at first, but it progresses to a stage where he is not the hunting animal, but the hunted animal. The two sheep Petrus buys in order to slaughter for his party becomes a metaphorical image of David Lurie and Lucy Lurie (Wright; 2008). David Lurie also becomes a “dog” in the sense that he becomes the lowest denominator, since dogs are seen as “ground-level” animals, animals that are in the position of complete humiliation (Coleman: 2010). He has so much disgrace in his life, because of all the wrong he has done, therefore he can be seen as a dog.
Lucy has a great love of animals, she has a kennel on the farm and has a friend, Bev Shaw, who works at the animal clinic and there are geese and ducks that visit her on the farm (Goossen: 2007). Lucy becomes a metaphor of animals as well, a metaphor of a sheep: “Sheep do not own themselves, do not own their lives. They exist to be used, every last ounce of them, their flesh to be eaten, their bones to be crushed and fed to poultry. Nothing escapes, exept perhaps the gall bladder, which no one will eat. Descartes should have thought of that. The soul, suspended in the dark, bitter gall, hiding.” (Coetzee: 1999,123). So Lucy is also a sheep, she took her slaughter, rape, her abuse and now she is still living in the “shadow of the attack,…” (Coetzee: 1999, 124). She took it without any rebellious behaviour, accepting her fate just as sheep accepts their fate. This can also be seen as Lucy accepting the changes in South-Africa, she is willing to take part in the transformation, by not telling the police of the rape (Patton; 2009). Lucy becoming a dog: When David shows Lucy his disapproval of Bev and Bill Shaw, Lucy responds that she wouldn’t "want to come back in another existence as a dog or a pig and have to live as dogs or pigs live under us"(Coetzee: 1999, 74). This can be seen as foreshadowing, because after her attack later in the novel, she tells David that she will marry Petrus and she will accept that she will have nothing, “No cards, no weapons, no property, no rights, no dignity.”(Coetzee: 1999, 205), she will live life “like a dog” ( Pölling-Vocke: 2004).

Animals also become metaphors to minor characters in the novel. According to Herron (2005), Soraya is a protective mother, when David Lurie goes to visit Soraya at her house he awakens animal instincts in her, "what should a predator expect when he intrudes into the vixen's nest, into the home of her cubs?" (Coetzee: 1999, 10).According to Coleman (2010), Pollux, a young man that is seen as a child, but he is not a child, is described, by David Lurie, as a jackal, “He is like a jackal sniffing around, looking for mischief.” (Coetzee: 2000, 208). According Meier (2006), Melanie is a hunted rabbit, she can’t escape the constant chase that David does to catch her and when he catches her she breaks in his jaws, he makes her feel lifeless when she is with him. According Wright (2008), Petrus introduces himself as the “dog-man”, he looks after the dogs and because of the segregation era he is still treated as a dog by others.

The metaphorical images that are given to the characters can be seen as what they become, because of what they are going through in their lives in the post-colonial era. They allow themselves to surrender to the animals in them, by becoming like animals.
Resources:

Coetzee, J.M. (1999). “Disgrace”. London: Vintage.

Coleman, D. (2010). “The “Dog-Man”: Race, Sex, Species, and Lineage in Coetzee’s Disgrace”. www.jstor.org/stable/25733433

Goossen, F.N. (2007). “The Importance of Animals in Coetzee's Age of Iron, Disgrace and The Lives of Animals”. http://igitur-archive.library.uu.nl/student-theses/2007-1128-201145/UUindex.html

Herron, T. (2005). “The Dog Man: Becoming Animal in Coetzee’s Disgrace.” http://research.uvu.edu/albrecht-crane/3090/herron.pdf

Meier, K. (2006). “Animals in J.M. Coetzee’s Disgrace”. http://www.greta-olson.com/docs/term-paper-final-corrected.pdf

Patton, P. (2009). “Becoming-Animal and Pure Life in Coetzee’s Disgrace” http://www.ariel.ucalgary.ca/ariel/index.php/ariel/article/download/3891/3828.
Pölling-Vocke, B. (2004). “The stylistic purpose of animals and the disgrace of a nation in J.M. Coetzee’s “Disgrace“. http://www.hockeyarenas.com/disgrace.htm
Wright, L. (2008). “Disgrace as J.M. Coetzee‟s Tempest”. http://eprints.ru.ac.za/1040/1/Disgrace.pdf

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Disgrace Essay

...English 2210 9 November 2012 In Disgrace by J.M. Coetzee we are introduced to David Lurie, the protagonist and narrator of this novel. David Lurie is a 52 year old divorced man, who lives in Cape Town, South Africa, as a respected romantic poetry professor at a university. His life is full of sexual, non-committed relationships. After being accused of inappropriate behavior with a student, Lurie loses his job at the university and must move in with his daughter, Lucy, in the country. Throughout the novel we see many references to animals, especially in relation to Lurie. Because he is the narrator of the novel, these animal references lead the reader to believe Lurie is describing himself through these animals. Lurie uses descriptions of animals as a way to describe how he feels about himself. We see Lurie go from a sexually charged predator, to a strange beast who has been hunter, to a dog-man, and then finally to a helpless dog who is ready to be put out of his misery. David Lurie is a predator at the beginning of the novel. He is a man searching for sex, and for the most part he is successful at it. His first sexual interest he introduces us to is Soraya, a prostitute who he has been going to see for a long time. Lurie describes them having sex by comparing them to snakes engaged in intercourse, "lengthy, absorbed, but rather abstract, rather dry, even at its hottest" (Coetzee 5 ). Being the narrator, this shows the reader how David views himself, as well as Soraya...

Words: 1194 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

David Lurie- Not so Disgraced

...Sarah Kaminski Biddinger Essay 2 July 3, 2012 David Lurie- Not so Disgraced David Lurie, a twice-divorced man and communications professor, is the antagonist in the novel Disgrace by J. M. Coetzee. In the beginning of the novel, Lurie believes he has found the key to a successful relationship with a woman- hiring a prostitute once a week- but when his favorite prostitute leaves the brothel he seeks companionship in another place. After having relations with one of his students he is found out and asked to resign from the university and moves away from Cape Town to be in isolation with his daughter. He refers to this period as being in “disgrace” and that because of what he lost back at his home in Cape Town he is now expected to be in this state of disgrace. Lurie, although at first resistant, becomes at home with his daughter Lucy in this small country area- giving the impression that he is in fact a changed man. On the contrary, after he leaves for Cape Town he resorts back to his old ways of going to a prostitute for an intimate connection. For a person who had not seemed to change at all, one would consider Lurie a static character, although this is not the case. David Lurie is a realistic, growing, and dynamic character that effectively paints the picture of how “old dogs” can still, in fact, learn new tricks. In the first few chapters of the novel, Lurie is represented as a man who seeks to control and to display his power. In the first chapter he uses...

Words: 1305 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Disgrace

...Duy D. Ly 04.16.2009 Professor Rooney Post-Colonial Literature Disgrace, J.M. Coetzee In Disgrace, race plays a predominant role in the novel. Disgrace is set in post-apartheid South Africa and, although apartheid has ended, traces of racial conflicts still haunt the land and its people. In the novel Coetzee emphasizes the racial tensions and the interaction between whites and blacks when Davis Luries arrived in Salem. Disgrace can be interpreted in many ways regarding racial perception, but there is no doubt that Coetzee’s purpose is to raise the question about the new South Africa and the white people within it. The book portrays a brutal picture of life in post-apartheid South Africa, the fate of the two white characters (David and Lucy) on the land, lost with dignity and freedom. Disgrace depicts a white father and daughter’s journey though life while losing everything under the racist black rule. Disgrace is written in a direct, unique style using clever word choices. An example of the racial nature of this book is when David Luries stated, “English is an unfit medium for the truth of South Africa,” (Coetzee, P.117). It is as if David was referring that English is not the type of language for Africans. David Luries lives in a dark world with dark desires. His frequent demand of sex leads him to his downfall. Melanie is a prefect example of David’s desire. “She is wearing black tights and a black sweater. Her hips are as slim as a twelve-year-old’s”(Coetzee...

Words: 1093 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Power in Relationships in Disgrace

...Disgrace Essay: Question 2 “Disgrace can be seen as an exploration of the relationship between the powerful and the powerless.” Set in post-apartheid South Africa, amidst a large scale shifting of power in many forms countrywide, Disgrace can very much be seen as an exploration of the relationship between the powerful and the powerless. Disgrace delves into power dynamics in various, contrasting relationships, and explores these dynamics between people of different race, gender, generations, positions of authority, and even those between humans and animals. During the course of the novel, various questions surrounding power in interpersonal relations are raised, and by the conclusion of Disgrace, Coetzee leaves us with profound thoughts and suggestions on which to dwell. In just about every relationship in Disgrace, the themes of dominance and power are present, albeit to varying degrees. There are four main relationships to which the subject of power is central: those between Lucy and Petrus, the rapists, and her father, and that between Melanie and David. Analysing these relationships with reference to Hegel’s view of “history being determined by a cycle of domination and counter-domination in which individuals who strive to fulfil their need for recognition are entrapped” (Marais 2008:35) greatly enhances the understanding of power and its context within the various relationships in Disgrace, especially with regard to Lucy’s decisions after her rape, and to Lucy’s...

Words: 1334 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Why This

...Britanee Windom Scott Inguito English 1B 5/18/2013 Essay #5 The novel Disgrace by J.M. Coetzee is story about having good morals and karma. The main character David Lurie is a middle aged man that is in a sense going through a mid life crisis. Lurie thinks of himself has am accomplished man and typically feels he has control in his life when it comes to finances, professional, and his personal life. However, after having an affair with a student, Lurie begins have a hard time controlling aspects in his life that he was once took for granite. Some concepts that Lurie comes to realize throughout the novel Disgrace are the amount of violence he faces, two sides to justice, and accepting old age. As David Lurie comes upon different trials and tribulations his character changes over the course of the novel and by the end Lurie finds closure in the unknown. David Lurie’s has a real problem with the idea of aging gracefully; he has a wont to feel like he’s still got it, as a result this notion of youth controls him. Lurie is pretty obsessive about aging to the point that it sometimes clouds his judgment and deep down it depresses him. “Overnight he became a ghost. Then one day it all ended. Without warning his power….. If he wanted a woman he had to learn to pursue her; often in one way or another, to buy her. (p.36)” Lurie pursues all the wrong women or resorts to buying women all so that he can feel young again. The wrong choice in women is extremely apparent when goes after one of...

Words: 984 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

American Bulls Vs Pitbulls

...Never judge a book by its cover. One should never prejudge the value or worth of someone or something by its outward appearance alone. Every individual needs its own merits. We are constantly stuck challenging the beliefs of others due to this foolish action. Don’t bully my breed! The only thing they fight is discrimination. American Bullies and Pit Bulls are the most misunderstood, misinterpreted beings around. One cannot judge these animals for how they are portrayed. One does not know the lives they’ve lived! Each knows its own pain and renunciation. I have loved American Bullies and Pit Bulls since the day I laid eyes on them. I have been raised around both these breeds and many others. I never believed they could harm me in anyway. These animals are unique, you have to look passed the stereotypes and breed. Your beliefs should be based off what you know for a fact and hands on experience, not what you hear. I challenge the belief that these animals could actually harm someone or be aggressive....

Words: 655 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Lumber Room

...as ironic and pointless but somehow comic. He used it in order to deride the human vices and to show inefficiency of actions of moralistic, hypocritical persons. Munro was killed on the French front during the First World War. His sister in her Biography of Saki writes: “One of Munro’s aunts, Augusta, was a woman of ungovernable temper, of fierce likes and dislikes, imperious, and moral coward, possessing no brains worth speaking of, and a primitive disposition.” Naturally the last person who should have been in charge of children. The character of the aunt in the Lumber – Room is Aunt Augusta to the life. The text tells us a story about a small boy Nicholas, who was brought up by his tyrannical and ungoverned aunt Augusta. He was "in disgrace" as he had refused to eat his wholesome bread-and-milk that morning. When children were taken to Jagborough sands Nicholas made some attempts to get into the gooseberry garden. As a matter of fact, he had no intention of trying to get into the gooseberry garden, but it...

Words: 2123 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Japanese Internment In Canada

...“I have to pay taxes, but have never been allowed to vote. Even now, they took our land, our houses, our children, everything. We are their enemies.”(1) This is a perfect quote by the Japanese Centennial Project to represent the mistreatment of the Japanese Canadians in Canada. Between the years 1941 and 1949, the Japanese people of Canada had their belongings taken, and were relocated to internment camps in the interior of British Columbia. Where they would be forced to stay for the entirety of the war. The human rights violations, hardships in the camps, and the redress that came too late made the Japanese Canadian internment a national disgrace. The internment began after the Japanese attack on Hong Kong and Pearl Harbour....

Words: 1355 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

How Does J.M Coetzee Present David Lurie and What Do We Learn About Him?

...How does J.M. Coetzee present David Lurie in chapter one and what do we learn about him? Coetzee’s novel Disgrace appears to be centred around an immature, arrogant, self-centred David Lurie. In the novel as a whole but particularly chapter one Coetzee demonstrates, through Lurie, the loss of power due to age and the loss of ‘white rights’ as the novel is set in South Africa after the apartheid. The loss of power links with Tennessee Williams’ play ‘A streetcar named Desire’ as both the protagonists demonstrate the loss of power and their unconventional coping strategies. Coetzee shows the reader the negative impact breaking away from the norms of society can have upon an individual. I think David Lurie is a character with whom the reader should sympathise with as he does not know who he is which may be what causes him to act in an irrational way. Furthermore I believe Coetzee aims to make the reader feel detached and uncomfortable in the first chapter thus reflecting Lurie’s feelings about this ‘new world’. The theme of age and maturity is presented heavily throughout the novel. Growing old appears to be an unfortunate thing in the novel as Coetzee claims ‘for a man of his age’ Lurie has ‘solved the problem of sex rather well’. The beginning of this statement gives a disparaging view of again and could cause the reader to believe that growing old is something we should resist. However this is contradicted by the second part of the sentence as it gives the impression that...

Words: 1330 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Mule Kille

...protagonist. The story finds place in America, probably in the southern states in the beginning of the 20th century, approximately. The reason I think we’re in the begging of the 20th century, is because of the slaughterhouse. I believe that before the start of the industrial revolution, most animals would be slaughtered at home. In Jim Heynen’s “Progress” we see a few similar things as is “Mule Killers”. Just title “Progress” is similar to what happens in “Mule Killers”. In “Mule Killers” we see how generations pass things on, but still changes are made. On the farm where feelings weren’t allowed, a son got tired of it. He wanted to change that. In “Progress” we also see a grandfather passing things onto youngsters. In both scenarios progress is a positive thing. Progress in of course also a positive word. The painting “The train passes by” from 1906 is quite the same as the two texts. It’s in the start of the 20th century, and it is about progress and modernity. B The two texts have nothing in common. “The ecchoing green” is a positive poem, who sees humans as a good thing in those days. Unlike “Lady Chatterley’s lover”. The text finds humanity as a disgrace. Humans...

Words: 363 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Persuasive Essay On Cloning

...The scientists who have previously cloned animals have received low success rates, therefore why should we try cloning humans? Is human cloning really even worth it? Scientists aren't even sure what precisely will happen if they do clone humans. If scientists would clone a human, the clone’s life will be unfair, influenced, and tampered with. He/ she would not have an option to live his/ her life their own way. Cloning humans is wrong and unnecessary, and should be banned and made illegal. Identity is being an individual and not like someone else, and also it is what makes someone special from everybody else. If the human race clone humans, identity will be lost, and then people will not have that trait, skill, or look that makes them unique. “The real beauty of humanity lies in the differences we witness amongst each other. Cloning would kill the surprise element” as found on Health Guidance website. Clones would suffer from a lack of their own identity. They would think they have to live up to be exactly like their "parent". Clones will look like their donor, but will turn out to be like someone else on the inside. They can't be the same when they grow up....

Words: 1097 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Richard Kuklinski

...Diaz Andrea Diaz Mrs. Lepage English Language Arts A30 January 25, 2016 Wild Geese In the beginning of the novel, we learn that Caleb was “below medium height, with tremendous shoulders and a massive head but a dwindling lower body” which causes the reader to believe that Caleb Gare probably does not control his family but he finds a way to manipulate, exploit and degrade his family physically, spiritually and mentally. The control Caleb and Amelia have over their children is vividly realistic but is portrayed in completely different ways; Caleb through his greed and need for control and Amelia’s desire to conceal her past. Caleb Gare believes that he is so powerful, that if he wishes something will not happen, or if he simply ignores it, that it will just go away. This is shown with Caleb and his crops. He has become so involved with them, that anytime weather might affect them, he thinks that if he ignores it, it will “skip” his home. “‘Hail,’ said Caleb almost under his breath as he came out of the barn. He would not admit it aloud. It might pass over”. When Caleb says this, not only does the reader think he is crazy, but his family does too “ There’s going’ to be either a cyclone or hail, or both – and he thinks that by his not letting it come, it will not come. So he leaves the lambs in the pasture”. With just this one incident of the...

Words: 957 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Tortoise and the Hare

...The Tortoise and the Hare By Janet Stevens Playwright Michael Nguyen Characters: Narrator: Tells the story of The Tortoise and the Hare Tortoise: Considered the underdog and the slowest animal in the forest. Always hardworking and puts his effort and time into preparation for anything. Hare: He boasts that he is the fastest animal in the forest. Hare is very prideful which one of his flaws is. Teases Tortoise for his slowness. Crowd 1 and 2: Often teases Tortoise for his slowness as well during the race. Is very surprised to see Tortoise win and apologizes to Tortoise but celebrates his victory. Settings: The setting takes place in two places. Each scene has the whole stage. The first scenery is just outside of Tortoise’s house where Tortoise challenges Hare to race. The second is at a racing course. The Narrator will stand on side stage. Outside of Tortoise’s house when Tortoise was about to go out for a job but encounters Hare jogging on the street. The NARRATOR is sitting on the side of the stage. NARRATOR: This is a story about the Tortoise and the Hare. Both the Tortoise and the Hare are great friends however Hare would always tease poor Tortoise for being as slow as he is. One day Hare notices Tortoise going out for a jog but laughs at him for his speed. HARE: (Laughs and points at Tortoise) You are so slow, I cannot stop laughing. (Laughs harder) TORTOISE: Hello Hare! I’m just...

Words: 786 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Does Shakespeare Reinforce or Question Contemporary Attitudes to Cultural Outsiders in 'Othello' and the Merchant of Venice?

...outsider is a person who does not belong in a particular situation, organisation or community. This definition relates to both Othello and Shylock as throughout the play we see them as victims of prejudice and injustice because of their cultural differences. In the play Othello, Shakespeare expresses the culture outsider, Othello himself in this instance. As a moor. The term Moor means a person or persons of an African descent. During the renaissance time period there were various stigmas attached to 'moors' and other cultural outsiders. Leo Africanus wrote a book named 'the history and description of Africa (1526)' where he portrayed Moors as being extremely prideful. 'Subject unto Jealousy; who would rather lose their lives than put up any disgrace on behalf of the women.' This is ironic and would lead one to believe Shakespeare reinforced Africanus' ideology in the tragic ending of Othello. Shakespeare also reinforces contemporary attitudes to Jews through the protagonist Shylock. During the 1600’s Jews were extremely disliked and according to Peter Gintro were ‘usurious, cunning, malevolent and potentially murderous’. A stereotype of the Jewish community originated from medieval and again is ironically attributes we see surrounding Shylock. One way Shakespeare reinforces and challenges contemporary attitudes to cultural outsiders is through Othello’s character. Othello is a Moor and Shakespeare presents him in a way which...

Words: 1099 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Dont Judge People Based On Their Customs In To Kill A Mockingbird

...house and Aunt Alexandra denies her request, she explains why she said no, “Jean Louise, there is no doubt in my mind that they’re good folks. But they’re not our kind of folks” (Lee 299). Aunt Alexandra’s statement displays her true feelings. She believes in social classes, and if a family is viewed as lower than her’s she does not think she should befriend them. Aunt Alexandra is somewhat judgemental and tends to avoid change in her ways of living. The Ewells live much differently than anyone else in the county. When Scout attempts to convince her father to let her get out of attending school similar to the Ewells, Atticus briefly describes how the Ewells live, “Atticus said the Ewells had been the disgrace of Maycomb for three generations...They were people, but they lived like animals” (Lee 40). This excerpt explains why the Ewells act recklessly and make their own rules, instead of following the...

Words: 417 - Pages: 2