Free Essay

Culture Difference on Film

In:

Submitted By ymc3174
Words 1563
Pages 7
Yamei Chen

1/16/2012

The Joy Luck Club, I’ve watched that movie many times, when I was a lot younger and also recently, because of my age, what I’ve experienced in life, each time I viewed the movie, my mind set are different as well, yet everything I watch this movie it brings tears into my eyes. When I was younger viewing the movie, which was very close to reality to what actually happen to women in China in the time, I think now when I view the movie, I’ve missed the whole point of the movie, it was really describing the relationship between mother and daughter in different time zone and culture background. “As cultural institutions, mass media often reflect some aspects of the society in which they operate. The critically acclaimed film The Joy Luck Club (1993) reflects diaspora experiences of Chinese immigrant women and depicts intergenerational tensions between Chinese mothers and their American-born Chinese daughters. It also reflects the struggles, dilemmas, and conflicts in the search for identity and self-development among Chinese and Chinese American women.” (Yea-Wen, C. (2007).
The storyline is centered upon Jing-Mei Woo also referred as June, who struggles to deal with the recent death of her mother Suyuan Woo, throughout the movie. The movie takes place at a reception held on June’s behalf before her trip to China to meet her twin half-sisters who were abandoned by their mother many years ago. June struggles with her mother’s past which she never fully understood. Though Suyuan dies before the movie begins, it is revealed that Suyuan was forced to abandon her daughters after contracting severe dysentery on her journey to escape the Japanese invasion during the Second World War. Believing she would die on the journey, Suyuan leaves them in hopes they would be rescued and returned to their father. Suyuan ultimately survives the trip but discovers that her husband was killed. She eventually remarries, moves to the USA, and has another daughter. After many years, she learns that her daughters were adopted in China though she dies of a brain aneurism without ever being reunited. Suyuan placed her hopes and dreams in June. In June’s childhood, Suyuan attempted to continuously educate her on Chinese culture.
An-Mei Hsu mother of Rose Hsu Jordan, was raised by her grandparents after her mother was banned from the family for becoming the concubine of a wealthy man after the death of her first husband. After her grandmother’s death An-Mei decides to live with her mother in the house of the wealthy man and his four wives. An-Mei’s mother ultimately commits suicide after much deception and pain was revealed. An-Mei later immigrates to the USA, marries, and gives birth to seven children. Rose Hsu Jordan is one of those seven children who is seen as passive and struggles to be heard in her marriage. After her husband files for divorce, Rose finds her voice after learning her mother’s childhood story and fights for her marriage which is ultimately salvaged. Women in that time, did what they had to do, the film also explained why An-Mei’s mom had to married the wealthy old men, being forced into anything in Chinese’s culture was a shameful thing, family wouldn’t understand and doesn’t care, women had no place or respect, anything bad happened to them, it was always the one getting blamed as well. Women had to fight for their respect and place in a family, which still happens now, and it’s just not in China, there are women here in America had to fight for their respect and a place in her in law’s family.
Lindo Jong, mother of Waverly Jong was forced into an arranged marriage at the age of 16. This marriage did not produce offspring as was demanded by her cruel mother-in-law. After much torture, Lindo was able to cleverly escape the arranged marriage without bringing disgrace to her family name or to herself. She immigrated to the USA, married a Chinese-American man and had three children. Lindo struggles with having lost some of her Chinese identity by living in the USA for so long and worries that her daughter Waverly’s Western American upbringing has caused a wedge in their relationship. Waverly is an intelligent, independent woman who struggles with constant feelings of inadequacy and criticism from her mother. She feels that nothing she ever does is good enough and therefore has a strained relationship with her mother.
Finally, Ying-Ying St. Clair, mother of Lena St. Clair was raised to believe that Chinese women should be meek and passive. Despite being quite independent and strong willed, Ying-Ying conformed to Chinese cultural expectations by marrying a man who ultimately cheats on her with several other women. Ying-Ying felt betrayed and used to a point one day she accidently drawn her own one month old son. Ying-Ying is horrified to discover that her daughter Lena has emulated her passive behavior and is also stuck in a loveless marriage with a controlling husband, everything is half and half, a marriage should be a whole, there shouldn’t be yours or mine. It is not until Ying-Ying visits Lena at her home and shares her childhood story that Lena finds the courage to demand from her husband the love and compassion she feels she deserves.
Gender and culture are entangled in The Joy Luck Club, as the viewer is transported through countries, class, and time, only to see that the bonds of heritage and family are not broken by the crossing of oceans. Connection to culture of origin runs deep among Chinese Americans (Uba,1994). In this way, The Joy Luck Club is an accurate mirror of reality, as it portrays some of the richness of Chinese American culture. From a feminist perspective, The Joy Luck Club, on its surface, contrasts traditional Chinese gender roles to that of Westernized Chinese-American women. As the second generation women describe their childhood and adulthood relationships with their mothers, the viewer sees representations of stereotypical Chinese mother-daughter interactions.
As reflected in the Chinese-American daughters’ stories, the Chinese culture the mothers attempted to pass on led to rejection and disappointment. The daughters are expected to be smart, talented, and respectful, while at the same time never having her “worth be measured by the loudness of her husband’s belch.” It would be an easy assumption, from a systems perspective, to place blame on the Chinese-born mothers for their daughters’ relational and self-concept problems. The mothers are portrayed as critical, perfectionistic, and unforgiving. The fathers of the American-born women all have a passive, gentle nature about them and did little to balance out the pervasive feminine energy. This is in direct contrast to the traditional Confucian indoctrination that was prevalent during the early lives of the mothers in which women were expected to be passive and nurture the family.
The mothers lived in Builica, China during a time of war and poverty. For each of the mothers, their childhood was filled with constant powerlessness and subjection. Yet, in a life of hopelessness each of the women find what it means to be strong in the face of gender-based oppression. Though the movie does not portray each woman’s decision to marry and come to the USA, the viewer understands that each does so with the hope of providing more opportunity for their children. The women come to the USA with high expectations about their lives, and those expectations are especially high for their daughters.
My parents decided to move to U.S. in hopes for better opportunities for me and my brother, sometimes I feel like I’ve failed my parents, I tried everything I could to satisfied my parents, I didn’t think anything was good enough, I can related to this movie 100 percent, my mom may not went thru the things these women has went thru, but she straggled in her time in China, just simply because the government didn’t like her family background, my family and I moved here when I was 13 years old, they try to remind us of who we are, trying to get us to keep our tradition, they aren’t exactly happy with my decision most of the time, I was too suborned to just did what I wanted. All mother or parents try to do what’s best for their child, when I was younger I did the same thing, I refused to listen, refused to do what was told to me. I’m older now with my own career, I travel all around the world, it really took my job to make me realized how important my family is to me, how much more I should of respected my parents.
Reference
Igeleke, E., Marie, M., Huddleston, K., & Fife, S. (2010). Movie reviews. The Joy Luck Club. Journal Of Feminist Family Therapy, 22(3), 236-241. doi:10.1080/08952833.2010.499757

Yea-Wen, C. (2007). When East is West, Examining Chinese Mother-Daughter Relationships and Cultural Values through Amy Tan's The Joy Luck Club. Kaleidoscope: A Graduate Journal Of Qualitative Communication Research, 699-120.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Film and Orientalism

...Film Final Evaluation Essay By Armando Khan Orientalism is something that has shaped the world. It has created the way we see culture. More than that it has placed culture in boxes and has probably led to the awareness of culture. By saying this I mean that the only reason we hold culture in such importance is because of difference. And that difference is caused by the wonder of orientalism. Orientalism is the portrayal off something mostly in a cultural context, in order to show a difference as well as to display something exotic. It overlooks similarities and is used to attract. This attraction comes from the exoticness for we are always attracted to something that seems distant from the mundaneness of our existences. With that being said, what also contributes to the attractiveness of orientalism is that orientalism can be seen by many as an escape. A place where taboos do not exist and one can break free of the shackles of society. Orientalism seemed to be most striking when depicted visually. Whether it be the nubile young boy on the cover of a book. Or a nude Chinese women on a placard , it was a subject of visual intrigue and something ,many in the west could not resist. This is probably why it was used in film which is what I shall get into later. Orientalism first came about with depictions of Arabic and Islamic regions. It became the norm as how this particular culture was to be viewed. This however overlooked the fact that there might have been styles that were...

Words: 2984 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

How Does Globalization Affect Canada

... and subsequently were pushed down by the others. This is true in the case of the film industry as well. It is well known that the United States has essentially monopolized the production of films, and while many countries around the world have still managed to produce their own and express their own sense of cultural identity through them, Canada has famously failed in its attempts. The Red Violin, first premiering in 1998, was Canada’s biggest budget film and subsequently greatly overdetermined by the market as a result. In comparison to the U.S, who not only averages a greater budget per film but also spends a higher percentage of that on advertising, Canada’s mere...

Words: 941 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Smoke Signals And Fast Runner: Film Analysis

...There have been a series of disagreements in the way that films represent the indigenous people of America. Indigenous people in this sense are the Indians, who are sometimes misunderstood as the foreigners. When talking about foreigners, it is the Europeans who invaded and settled in America, not the Indians. But, on many occasions this is not the case, as many of the European settlers consider themselves as the indigenous people of America (Howells and Negreiros 27). These concepts have been shown in films, where the battle for what might appear as ownership is evident. There are many films that are about the indigenous people of America, among which are Smoke Signals and Fast Runner. The films try to demonstrate and oppose the stereotypes that people have for the indigenous people of America (Knopf 193). Comparing the movies, one can see the employment of cinematic applications such as sounds and shots, editing, angle, camera movement, framing, music, and lighting, and then see how they relate or contrast. All the same, the films are...

Words: 1431 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Gods Must Be Crazy

...The film "The Gods Must Be Crazy" illustrates the stark contrast between the culture of the Bushmen and modern society through the interactions between socialized members of each of these very different cultures. The cultural contrasts are evident in the characters' actions, values and differing world views. The film paints an exceptional portrait of the differences between human cultures, as well as the belief in the superiority of one's own ethnic group, that runs common to all. The Bushmen culture is one of simplicity and contentment. The pace of life in the Bushmen culture is relaxed and slow. The Bushmen culture was one without social classes. They never punished or even spoke harshly to their children and yet the children were surprisingly well behaved. The Bushmen place the greatest value on their family and their relationship with god. The Bushmen seem to have a deep respect for all life both human and non-human. In the film, the Bushman shoots an animal with a tranquilizer dart and waits until the animal lays down to go to sleep; before taking the animal's life the Bushmen would apologize for having to kill the animal and explained that he must do it so that his family could eat. His action was important because it showed that the Bushmen hunted only out of necessity and never for sport. Although the Bushmen lived in circumstances that we think of as squalor they seemed to be very happy and completely content with their lives. The most striking aspect of the Bushmen...

Words: 1372 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Hip Hop Film Vs. Hip-Hop In Film

...silver screen has in the modern era been awarded a significant portion of blockbuster film soundtracks, showcased in films such as The Fast and The Furious series and, perhaps more relevant to this coursework: Straight Outta Compton. In order for one to make a proper distinction between the concepts of a “hip-hop film” and “hip-hop in film”, one must first understand the basic semantics of the argument proposed. The core difference lies in that the “hip-hop film” implies an overarching theme of hip-hop culture prevalent within the film, foretelling the potential viewer that the film may include forms of expression like breaking, DJing, graffiti work, and MCing. A film like Straight Outta Compton is a perfect example of a “hip-hop...

Words: 651 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Journal Review: Cross-Cultural Challenge in Product Placement

...the scene where Will Smith drink Coca-Cola in film. As a result of global flow, and access to media content and technology, the practice of product placement has become media-neutral and spread across other cultures. Due to this circumstances, there is a need to develop an expanded understanding of how non-US consumers perceive such placements. Product placement like traditional forms of advertising, transmit and reflect the important symbolic meanings and values within a culture. To add in, consumer attitudes toward product placement may also vary depending on the fundamental cultural orientations and values of a particular society. In general, there are abundant cross-cultural comparisons of advertising and promotion but little is known regarding how consumers from different cultures perceive and process product placement in their mind. Other than that, there has also been very limited knowledge on how and to what extent the medium of placement affects perceptions of the tactic. The main purpose of this research is to examine: i. US and Korean college student consumers’ attitudes towards product placements in three different media (films, TV shows, and songs). ii. product placement acceptability based on media genre and product type. Based on the above purpose, researchers have developed five research questions involve in this study. There are: i. What similarities and differences exist in the influence/attention of product placement...

Words: 3077 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Comparing Japanese and American Culture

...American and Japanese Cultures Culture plays a vital role in defining a group of people, helping to shape the way they live, the traditions they carry out, and how they’re viewed by others. That being said, cultures vary greatly worldwide; some customs that are normal to Americans may seem strange to those living in Japan such as entertainment in America and Japan, Respect for Women in American and Japanese Cultures, and The Individual in America and Japan. To begin with, American and Japanese cultures both place an emphasis on film and video as a form of entertainment. In America, it’s not unusual for the media to pay a great deal of attention to new film releases and upcoming television premiers. Similarly Japanese culture focuses on motion pictures for entertainment, mainly through the promotion of “anime,” the Japanese contribution to the animation industry. Much like animated Disney movies are prominent in American culture, anime films are a common appearance in Japanese culture. Anime films are so popular, in fact, that they’re even viewed in the United States, creating a link between American and Japanese culture. America and Japan may share similar interests regarding entertainment, but one must remember that the two countries are at opposite ends of the world, creating differences in the way people live in the two areas. Perhaps the greatest difference between Japanese and American culture is the fact that Americans seem to have more respect for women...

Words: 564 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Gungho

...GUNG HO! CULTURAL ANALYSIS Michael Hamilton MKTG 3852 – Second Summer 2012 7/22/12 GUNG HO- CULTURAL ANALYSIS Cultural differences influence how business is conducted in today’s rapidly expanding global market. These cultural barriers affect human interactions through our perspective of one another, credibility, time frames, as well as through communication. The success of international business depends upon the ability to set aside our differences, unite and strengthen one another. Many of these challenges can be seen throughout the movie Gung Ho. The movie portrays the relationship between the Japanese and Americans in a lightly comically point of view through an auto factory. However, when comparing and contrasting the interactions of these two cultures, both in and out of the film, they’re dynamics of become more apparent. The connections and exchanges between the Japanese management team and the American workers throughout the film present examples for each of the five dimensions in Geert Hofstede’s cultural dynamics analysis: Individualism/Collectivism, Uncertainty Avoidance, Power Distance, Masculinity/Femininity, and the later added Long-term Orientation. I. Hofstede’s Cultural Dynamics The results from Hofstede’s analysis for the United States and Japan are in the following table. When comparing the two we see that the Americans have a highly individualistic, male reinforced, ambiguous, society with a slight hierarchy with a weak connection to tradition...

Words: 3270 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Kung Fu Movies

...Kung Fu movies Name: Institution: Course: Tutor: Date of submission: Introduction {introduce kung Fu movies] 0.5 Kung Fu movies are part of a subgenre of martial arts films. They are set in the modern period of futuristic martial arts. Kung Fu has its origins in China, which before being modernized, was popularly known as Wuxia (Greene, 2014). This film genre is an important creation of Hong Kong Cinema. The main difference between Kung Fu and Woxia is that the former has less sword play, instead, used more armed combat. It however found its way to the West, where it was embraced in Hollywood as one of them most loved action film genres. The genre was first played on screen in the 1930s in a film known as The Adventures of Fong Sai-Yuk (Kato, 2012). The first directors choreographed the fights to become more realistic on screen. The genre reached its heights in the 1970s and overtook some of the most famous genres of the time. Today, Kung Fu has reached international audiences across the world. The genre is mainly produced Hong Kong, main land china japan and India. This paper looks at the genre as produced in these countries, contrasts and compares them. Characteristics of kung Fu movies in Hong Kong, main land china japan and India The Hong Kong Kung Fu films combine action, mainly as codified by Hollywood, and Chinese storytelling. This is interwoven with aesthetic traditions, which combine to create a distinctive form that has a wide transcultural appeal. However...

Words: 2432 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Arranged

...Differences of Traditional Conservative Culture and Western Culture Victor Pinto Hudson Community College Abstract In the film (Arranged, 2007), it tells a story of two women who are going through an arranged marriage. Arranged marriage is something that is seen in traditional cultures, not really seen in modern western culture. Modern western culture and traditional cultures are very different. Patriarchy is followed in the home of these families, where the father sets the rules. Dating is also done differently. In traditional cultures, women have arranged dates with men, whereas in modern western culture people can decide who to go on a date with. Touching is also different, women from traditional cultures are not used to being touched by other men. They have little contact with other humans, unlike in modern western culture people are used to being touched by their friends or just shake hands when you meet someone new. Differences of Traditional Conservative Culture and Modern Western Culture: In the United States of America there are many type of traditional cultures people follow. There is a traditional culture that was shown in the film “Arranged”. Then there is the modern western culture that the majority of people follow in the United States. The traditional cultures seen in the film are from the character Rachel, who followed an Orthodox Jewish culture and Nasira who followed a Muslim culture. These two cultures may seem completely different...

Words: 791 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business Communication

...‘Using Films to Learn About The Nature of Cross-cultural Stereotypes in Intercultural Business Communication Courses’ written by Peter W. Cardon from the University of South Carolina has helped shed light on ways instructors can educate their students in the classroom by using multimedia to bring awareness to cultural differences, and to help promote students to interact with one another in real-life situations, either on campus or in their careers. The author has chosen the film Slumdog Millionaire as his educational tool as a prime example to introduce Indian culture to Americans. In a business world full of communication, it is inevitable that a student will be faced to communicate with an individual with a different cultural background at one time or another. Many students sometimes do not realize how similar they really are with those who have been raised in a different culture. Peter W. Cardon feels that for students to grasp these similarities it is important to introduce real-life scenarios to bring awareness to cultural differences through multimedia. Teaching a generation that has been raised by watching TV, movies, and using their computers to become educated in certain areas students may be able understand cultural differences more effectively by displaying emotionally strong images. By doing this, students are able to visually see the communication process, cultural values, and acceptable behavior in a different culture. It is also widely known deep emotion...

Words: 530 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

International Communication

.......................... 1 DECLARATION ............................................................................................. 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS ................................................................................... 3 1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................... 4 1.1 Globalisation and hybridization explained from a cinematic perspective ...................................................................................... 4 1.2 The difference between deculturalisation, acculturalization and reculturalisation explained from a cinematic perspective.................. 6 2.1 Three theoretical approaches to the study of the digital divide explained ......................................................................................... 8 2.2.1 Culture shock explained .................................................................. 11 2.2.2 How to overcome culture shock ...................................................... 13 2.3 The role of international media in setting the news agenda of local or...

Words: 4605 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Religion In Gridiron

...If I continuously have a positive attitude towards everything life would be so much better. Although being positive in every situation doesn't help, I still try to maintain positive. From this film I have learned to care for others despite the hate towards each other. In the film the two main characters William Rogers and Kelvin Owens hated each other because they were from rival gangs. The most influential scene from the film is when Kelvin Owens saves William Rogers from one of Kelvins gang members who tries to shoot William. Kelvin overcame the fact that they were rivals and took a bullet. He did it even though he knew his own gang would hunt him down and kill him. Overcoming differences in life has been the most influential from this film. Weather we are different race, culture, or religion we must overcome diversity and treat each other with kindness....

Words: 331 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Escape on a Human Cargo

...CULTURAL DIFFERENCES PORTRAYED IN THE FILM: ESCAPE IN A HUMAN CARGO (1998) Escape in a human cargo tells the original story of an American prefab housing engineer who goes to Saudi Arabia to close a multi-million dollar deal. When he arrives he discovers that his bargain is will not be honored. The main character in the film winds up a virtual prisoner with no guarantees for his safety once the job is completed. As the plot unfolds, we are able to experience the slow realization that he is being cheated by his Arab clients, that his chances of full payment are slim and finally that his life is in danger. What is interesting about this film is that rather than being just another action movie, it’s a very scary and true story of cultural clash and a surprisingly balanced look at the uncertain justice system of Saudi courts. The following paper will discuss certain cultural differences that were portrayed in the film. Justice System: In an early stage of the film, we see a scene of a woman publically beat with stones. The characters Arab middleman later explains that she was stoned to death as a result of being suspected to have thought about adultery. Although this seems to be the normal justice system in Saudi Arabia, brutality as a form of punishment is not tolerated in North America. The film properly portrays the Americans discomfort insight of this treatment. Business interactions In addition to the differences with regards to the justice system and the treatment...

Words: 683 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

My Big Fat Greek Wedding Analysis

...Greek Wedding Analysis Our culture is a part of what makes us who we are and how we communicate with others. My Big Fat Greek Wedding does an amazing job at illustrating cultural differences and all the dilemmas that occur from them. More importantly, the film shows us that with proper communication people can find a way to get along, no matter how significant the cultural differences may be. Cultural communication barriers are seen many times throughout the film. One example of this could be when Ian’s parents were attending his wedding and mentioned they couldn’t understand anything the Greek orthodox minister was saying and were astonished at the sight of people in the audience spitting on the bride. Another example might be when Ian mentioned to Toula’s Aunt that he was a vegetarian and she insisted that lamb was not considered meat. In the film we see also many instances of misunderstandings that arise due to the differences in culture. For example, when Ian met Toula’s father for the first time, Toula’s father took it as an insult that Ian did not ask permission before attempting to date his daughter. Due to Ian’s ignorance of nurturing culture like Greek culture, Ian unintentionally angered Toula’s father by his actions. Another example is when Ian’s parents meet Toula’s family for the first time. Ian’s parents also unintentionally upset Toula’s father by acting too uptight. Greek culture is classified as a collectivistic culture, so it easy to see how acting...

Words: 309 - Pages: 2