Premium Essay

Encountering Social Class Differences at Work

In:

Submitted By jamesdowling
Words 21937
Pages 88
ENCOUNTERING SOCIAL CLASS DIFFERENCES AT WORK: HOW “CLASS WORK” PERPETUATES INEQUALITY

Using a microsociological lens, we develop a theoretical framework that explains how social class distinctions are sustained within organizations. In particular, we intro- duce the concept of “class work” and explicate the cognitions and practices that members of different classes engage in when they come in contact with each other in cross-class encounters. We also elucidate how class work perpetuates inequality, as well as the consequences of class work on organizations and those at the lower end of the organizational hierarchy. By examining microlevel interactions and how they become institutionalized within organizations as prevailing rules and practices, we contribute to both institutional theory and the sociology of social class differences. We encourage future research on social class and discuss some of the challenges inher- ent in conducting it.

Several contemporary developments—includ- ing the financial crisis of 2008 (Rajan, 2010), the shrinking of the middle class (Leicht & Fitzger- ald, 2007), and the rise of the “new poor” in America (Cohen, 2010)— have reinjected the is- sue of social class differences and inequality (Stiglitz, 2012) into contemporary discourse. Within organization studies, however, social class has received only scant consideration (cf. Castilla & Benard, 2010; Dacin, Munir, & Tracey, 2010; Scully & Blake-Beard, 2006). While two re- cent exceptions report the consequences of class differences on individual behavior at work (Coté, 2011; Fiske & Markus, 2012), this work does not theorize about how organizational members interact in the face of these differ-

The authors contributed equally to the preparation of this manuscript. We are grateful to our talented and fearless friend and colleague, Lindsey Pilver, for bringing us

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Sociology and Divorce

...more than just a homemaker. These various private tensions may seem very personal. These dilemmas are all related to a bigger world called society and this is known as the sociological imagination. Sociological imagination suggests that people look at their own personal troubles as social issues and, in general try to connect their own individual encounters with the workings of society. The personal problems are closely related to societal issues such as unemployment, marriage, war and even the city life where the private troubles and the public issues become clearly apparent. With the understanding of the sociological imagination, I began to notice the daily choices I make, the classes I attend, the way I was raised by my parents, the group of people I choose to hang out with, the things I like to converse about with others are all somehow affected by public issues and what society tends to make us believe is right. There are many areas in my life where I feel that I am greatly affected by various sociological theories such as events dealing with gender and sexuality, family and culture, ethnicity and race, and social class and work.  Even though our country supports equality in gender, differences still exist. This issue of gender and sexuality of our society has had one of the biggest impacts in my life since I was raised with five brothers. Since birth, I was immediately...

Words: 2152 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Memo

...stereotype and family expectations can work together to impose an ideal of success on young Asian American women. The model minority stereotype generalizes that all Asian Americans are smart, respectful, and hard working individuals who are able to work from the bottom-up in achieving the American Dream. The purpose of this study is to understand how parenting styles and the model minority stereotype shape self-esteem of Asian American women. This project defines self-esteem as an individual’s assessment of self-worth that encompasses positive or negative beliefs and attitudes about the self. “The looking glass self,” pioneered by Charles Horton Cooley, explains how individuals’ self-esteem can be formed through the eyes of family members. Depending on individuals’ assessments of how others perceive them, people feel pride or shame, which contributes to their sense of self-esteem. I will use open-ended questionnaires to interview Asian American women to explore if parents uphold values of the model minority stereotype and how these standards shape the perception of self. I hypothesize that the model minority stereotype and family members who uphold the stereotype contribute to negative images of self in Asian American Women. Furthermore, I expect that even though most students understand that the model minority stereotype is unrealistic, the stereotype will still mold female Asian American college students’ emotional well-beings, social, academic, and career lives. A total of...

Words: 696 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Predict Irrational

...Irrational provides an exciting perspective on the field of behavioural economics. Ariely presents his own theories and research on various aspects of human behaviour. He explains the fundamental differences between traditional economics and behavioural economics in a way that is easy to understand. Traditional economics assumes that people are rational, whereas behavioural economics stresses that they are irrational. Ariely’s primary focus in the work is this debate between rationality and irrationality. The entire book is written in the first person using an informal tone. The casual tone can be justified as the book is aimed at the general public, as opposed to other researchers and academics. However, given the scientific nature of the information he is presenting, the informal tone also causes his findings to lack assertiveness. Keeping in theme with the informal tone, Ariely uses many anecdotes to convey his findings in a way that is relevant to, and can be understood by, the reader. The anecdotes help the reader grasp the concepts with greater ease, but the addition of personal stories further detracts from the assertiveness of his research. At the risk of losing some readers, it would have been preferred for Ariely to use a more formal approach to match the serious content of his work. Clearly, Ariely aimed to reach a broader range of readers who would not normally study behavioural economics. The book is geared mainly at an American audience. The research is conducted in...

Words: 693 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Personal Narrative: My Thematic Pathway

...This is a lesson I learned from my entry-level music class while I was a John Jay student. Today I can say, there is a huge difference between who I am and who I was in two years ago. I am very calm and I tend to be more productive and confident when I have to handle multiple things. However, I used to be very impulsive and a little bit of disorganized. My time management skills were extraordinary terrible, and I could not properly handle the vast amount of problems by myself. I had a bad temper because I usually held overwhelming pressures from my family's high expectation. Moreover, I didn’t actually know how to calm myself down to release my tensions and pressures, and I couldn’t find people to talk to. I unintentionally brought myself into a condition of anxiety and nervousness. In essence, I was like a workaholic that I have foolishly...

Words: 1147 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Biological Experiences Affecting Adult Learners

...all have different biological, psychological and sociocultural backgrounds. Biological development influences adult learning due to some health limitations (Cercone, 2008). The biology of aging and learning styles contribute to the uniqueness of the adult learner (Cercone, 2008). Psychosocial development theory examines personal and interpersonal lives. Lupton (2007) found that adult learners had different characteristics and life circumstances that influence their educational pursuits. According to adult learners are different from traditional college students because they have responsibilities such as jobs and family which may interfere with the learning process (Cercone, 2008). Sociocultural approaches emphasize the interdependence of social and individual process in the co-construction of knowledge. According to sociocultural learning and development take in socially culturally shaped contexts John-Steiner and Mahn...

Words: 1256 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Psychology 101

...statement: “Without awareness and knowledge of race, culture, and ethnicity, counselors and other helping professionals could unwittingly engage in cultural oppression? What led me to become a counselor? What were my first experiences of people of color (or of Whites)? What did I learn from my family about cultural diversity and differences? What are my stereotypes and biases about individuals from other groups? Identify Mark Kiselica’s emotional roadblocks to developing cultural competence. How come Mark Kiselica over-identified with people of color? What influenced Derald Sue to go into multicultural psychology? Compare and contrast the journey's of Mark Kiselica and Derald Sue CHAPTER 2 What challenges do you think counselors face in gaining cultural competence? Would you be willing to explore your own racism, sexism, heterosexism, able-body-ism as it relates to cultural competence? If so, why? If not, why not? What is worldview? How does your worldview influence how you relate to other people, institutions, nature, time, etc.? As a counselor, how would you implement the Multidimensional Model of ultural Competence into your work with clients? What are some culturally appropriate intervention strategies and techniques thatyou can use when working with diverse clients? If you have used interventions in the past, please discuss your success or failure with your interventions. Why might some organizations resist becoming multicultural in nature? Why is...

Words: 1389 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Formalist Essay - Counterparts

...Joyce’s short story “Counterparts” illustrates a world filled with anger and disillusion by displaying a main character that exhibits the anger and disillusionment he is encountering in many aspects of his uninspiring life. Farrington, the main character, is portrayed as a bottom of the barrel type of man. Working as a “scrivener”, the text depicts as a trivial employee by others around him, particularly his superior Mr. Alleyne, and receives no appreciation for his work (71). Farrington reacts to this display by Mr. Alleyne of intolerance for subordinates by drinking his sorrows away, regardless the cost. Although powerless, Farrington continues to demonstrate what in his subconscious society expects of him by buying rounds of drinks at the pub, even though he has to pawn his watch to do so. He is again forced into his disappointing reality with complete disregard of his existence by societal beings outside his middle class circle. Farrington’s marriage is without deviation from every other facet of his life, with an often absent wife, whom routinely degrades the so called man of the family. The text does bring to light other notable premises such as the repression of women’s role in society at the time by belittling their role in the story, the division of cultures encountered by emphasizing the difference in Northern Irish, British, and Irish cultures, or even the paralysis of a community faced with remaining a colony or nationalizing, all of which are valid arguments....

Words: 1010 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Personal Reflection Paper

...Personal Reflection Paper BSHS 345 August 26, 2014 Personal Reflection Paper Invidious comparison is the act of comparing one person to others according to their class, race, sex, or religion. This act can have a negative effect on people who are aware of it. Growing up in California, where the predominant Hispanic races were of Mexican and Central American origin, I was constantly compared to those Hispanic backgrounds. This was frustrating because I am Colombian and the Colombian Culture is very different from the Central American culture. My mind could not understand why people would compare me to them if I am South American. The traditions, food, music, slang, and even accents were different. American non-Hispanic people would call me, among many other things, a “dirty Mexican” or “wet back.” This was extremely frustrating because neither one of my parents hopped the border nor were they dirty. My young mind did not know how that these people were just ignorant so my frustration turned into anger and total repulsion of races of those other backgrounds and countries. A sense of insecurity and even self-hate would overcome me. I did not want to be Hispanic, I wanted to be white, and I wanted to be accepted. My way of seeing things changed in 2006 when the Immigration Equality Movements became popular. Latino activists would speak at events and in a sense give the people a sense of empowerment and hope. Attending these events made me feel proud of my Hispanic heritage...

Words: 1021 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Macro-Environment Factor in Emerging/Developing Market

...your opinion, what is the most relevant macro-environment factor (legal, political, cultural and economic differences) for an international business when choosing to internationalise into an emerging/developing market? Discuss any international business concepts or theories that could be used to help justify your answer. In the past few decades internationalisation has been a phenomenon in being a main subject in international business research. Globalisation has allowed countless commercial opportunities to occur over the border of their national country by maintaining competition and the continuing growth of international firms (Tikhonova, 2012). In foreign countries, legal and political systems as well as the economy are essential to have knowledge in as it explains how political systems, laws and regulations and economic differences affect international business opportunities. Although these factors are vital in understanding the foreign environment, it is not as broad as culture. Culture is a factor that includes several aspects that range from different dimensions which on a broad level includes linguistic, regional, religious and ethnic dimensions (Reference for Business’s website, 2014). Fundamentally for an international firm to endure success in emerging markets it is relevantly important to have full understanding of consumers and their cultural differences. In order for a firm to reach their full potential and succeed in an emergent market they need to have the...

Words: 1834 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Silent Voices

...many intricate roles. These roles are often unnoticed or are part of an unspoken code. Women have played a major role in the development of greatness, but will often go unrecognized for their input, effort and involvement. Many times the role of a woman asked her to take a back seat to men’s work and not be in the fore front. It was not important for women to be educated, for they were not made to be leaders, creators, commanders or organizers. Sister Flowers by Maya Angelou and I Want a Wife by Judy Brady bring light to the dynamics of a woman and the many facets of a woman. Whether of a high or low class the, fortitude of a woman is astounding. In this ever changing world, women have begun to evolve and smile at the ratification of the positions that they have long held. These essays provide us with a piece of history that shows the growth and development that women are making to get the recognition that is their-due. Sister Flowers by Maya Angelou is a descriptive essay told through the eyes of a young girl named Marguerite who has admiration for a woman in her community that is full of grace. The presence, stature and charisma of this woman was enough to put her in a class with the elite. This woman was different from the others within her community and due to education. Sister Flowers words and language supported that image. As she would often have conversations with Marguerite’s mother that would be very shameful to her, due to her mother’s lack of knowledge...

Words: 1369 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

International Students: Bridging the Gap of Two Cultures

...International Students: Bridging the Gap between Two Cultures Irma Ahmad Wan Norhaizar Harun Nurisyalliena Ishak Universiti Malaysia Perlis (UniMAP) Abstract Cultural differences play an important role in the academic environment. It is often being overlooked by university, society and even among the international students themselves. When dealing with international students, there is an overlap between perception and acceptance towards readiness and adaptation to the cultural differences. International students’ readiness and ability to adapt with local cultural has influenced on how the university and society view and accept them. In this paper, it explores the understanding and challenges for international students to adapt themselves in UniMAP. It also looks on the effectiveness of university effort in building an inclusive academic environment for its international students. Introduction The Ministry of Higher Education of Malaysia has taken a big step in becoming a hub for the international students. The aim is proven by the number of international students in Malaysia. As for the year 2008, it was reported that 16,991 students from foreign countries are studying here (Bernama, Dec 3 2008). In order not to be left behind, University Malaysia Perlis (UniMAP) has adhere to the Ministry Of Higher Education aspiration by taking 168 international students that come from various countries namely China, Yemen, Iraq and Pakistan. 74 of them are the undergraduates’...

Words: 3481 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Process Essay

...PARAGRAPH DEVELOPMENT ( English II, 4:00-5:30 p.m.) Submitted by: Skibba, Dominic U. BSA-1 (Block 1) Submitted to: Mrs. Rochie Montes English 2 Teacher How to Maintain Friendship (Process) In our lives, there are many people who are surrounding around that is being attached to us and these people are what we called friends. A friend can be classified into two: a friend with benefits and the other one is called a true friend. A friend with benefits is type of a friend which is there beside you when they can get something from you or taking advantage on you while a true friend is there beside you most especially when you are in down or in times of problems and struggles you are encountering. A true friend will never, ever leave you no matter what happens! It’s not important whether he is miles apart from you, as a true friend will always have you in his heart forever. So distance should really not matter. A true friend will always believe in you even though you no longer believe in yourself. He will always bring out the best in you. A true friend will not need any explanation as he will always understand. And most of all, a true friend is someone who is willing to share his time with you. Maintaining the relationship with this kind of person is a must because having him in our lives is a great help for us in facing challenges and difficulties in life. Following the proceeding steps will definitely last your relationship...

Words: 2990 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Nightline Summary

...Korean-Americans were shut out of the mainstream media. Abelmann highlights that they were “merely a particular niche, with a few exceptions such as the lawyer Angela Oh's brief appearance on Ted Koppel's Nightline.” The author argues that once the riots began, the initial lack of media coverage put Koreans in a position with no security or support from the general public. In addition, the media did not highlight the diversity that Koreatown portrayed. Abelmann emphasized that “media discussions have largely neglected class distinctions among Korean-Americans. The media failed to appreciate the tremendous income and educational inequality among Korean-Americans.” This misrepresentation showed the public that Korean immigrants were all successful; therefore, after the riots, many assumed that Koreatown could rebuild itself with its affluent individuals. This led to a lack of support for the city’s economic reconstruction after the...

Words: 1536 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Welcome to the Table

...In social psychology there are many aspects of the things that we do in our daily lives that have been scientifically investigated through scientific method for the sake of getting to know human behavior and to put reasoning behind the thought, feeling and behavior of human beings as they are influence by our environment and others, basically why we do what we do. Social psychology looks at a wide range of social topics some of which are perception, behavior, conformity, aggression and prejudice to name a few. This paper will highlight a few of the terminologies and theories in this discipline also give overview to some of these afore mentioned topics. Starting with the terminology used in social psychology we look at the concept of self, it is stated in the text Introduction to Social Psychology self-concept “is the collection of things you know about yourself—such as your overall cognitive understanding (learned beliefs, attitudes, and opinions) about yourself” (Feenstra, 2011). Looking at this statement, it can be determined that the ideas learned throughout life about one’s self is a product self-concept. Self schema is what is understood and gathered from self-concept. Text defines self-schema as “organizing this information, affecting how we view the world and takes in information” (Feenstra, 2011). What are gathered from a person as far as the sports they may play, going to church and time spent with my family are all things that can attribute to ones self-concept...

Words: 3379 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Related Lit Study Habits (Eljay)

...habits survey was that more than 30 years ago still rings true today-students fail because they do not know how to study. The best advice he can give is to develop sound study skills. He said that a student should make sure that he/she has a good study environment, a good desk, a sturdy chair, good light, comfortable room temperature and a quiet atmosphere. That means he/she should eliminate all external and internal distractions. Second, get a good overview of the assignment before starting the work. Know what skills, facts and ideas that are expected to master and the ground that are expected to cover. Start with most difficult subjects first, while the mind is freshest and most receptive. In his experimental study on the effect of learning, Winter stated that the first and probably the most important thing needed was to acquire the habits of studying effectively. Effective methods of study consisted basically of those fundamental principles which under laid efficiency. Doing one’s work regularly, staying at it until it was done and not getting behind in it should be the general guides for successful study as well as in any field of endeavor. It was assumed that the pupils had ability enough to cope successfully with the academic tasks. The success of the responses to the task depended in great measure to their efforts. As postulated by Credé and Kuncel (2008) in their research at the University of Albany said that Study habit, skill, and attitude inventories and constructs were...

Words: 5431 - Pages: 22