Free Essay

Ethical Research

In:

Submitted By guillj5
Words 1066
Pages 5
Ethical Research
Research ethics not only protect the rights of human subjects but also encompass a broader range of principles. The notorious Tuskegee study in Alabama that began in 1932and ended in1972 studied black men with syphilis. The study violated ethical principles in that informed consent was not obtained, confidentiality was violated and treatment was withheld when it became available. The study is well known, because of the tragedy it caused for many people and also because of the sheer lack of ethical consideration shown by the scientists concerned. The United States Public Health Service conducted a study for that began in 1932 and lasted until 1972, not the six months that was expected and is described as "the longest non-therapeutic experiment on human beings in medical history" (Brunner, 2009).
The Tuskegee Syphilis Study was conducted from 1932 to 1972 around Tuskegee, Alabama. Six hundred poor, and mostly illiterate, African-American males, 400 of whom were infected with syphilis, were monitored for 40 years. Free medical examinations were given; however, subjects were not told about their diagnosis. Even though a cure (penicillin) became available in the 1950s, the study continued until 1972 with participants being denied proper treatment or given fake treatments and placebos, instead. In some cases, when subjects were diagnosed as having syphilis by other physicians, researchers intervened to prevent treatment. Many of the subjects died slow and painful deaths of syphilis during the study, which was stopped in 1973 by the U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare only after its existence was publicized and became a political embarrassment.
Congressional intervention eventually led to the publication of the Belmont Report in 1979, which is now required reading for everyone involved in human subject research. The
ETHICAL RESEARCH 3
Belmont Report identifies three basic ethical principles regarding all human subject research: respect for persons, beneficence, and justice.
Respect for persons requires medical researchers to obtain informed consent from their study participants, which means that participants must be given accurate information about their circumstances and treatment options so that they can decide what will happen to them. Beneficence means the all test subjects must be told of all possible risks as well as benefits of the treatment they agree to undergo. A great deal of research in the social and behavioral sciences, however, involves minimal risk procedures, such as gathering and reporting on aggregate data using surveys and interviews. Some research involves manipulations and deception, both of which are permissible if investigators provide justification for such measures in the protocol. The protocol should also contain adequate debriefing procedures when the research involves deception. The context of examples such as the Tuskegee Study and experiments, injustice is obvious. In non-medical research, however, the issue of justice presents in more nuanced ways. Lawrence O. Gostin, a professor of global health law at Georgetown University, speaks to an ethical duty to research subjects that goes beyond non-harming. "In thinking about justice toward subjects, researchers need to consider equitable selection so that individuals are chosen on the basis of factors clearly relevant to the problems being studied. Researchers also need to consider equitable distribution of advantages to research subjects and others who could benefit from the knowledge gained by the research" (Gostin 1991ical principles. In this study, the ethical concerns are invasion of privacy, lack of informed consent, and a failure to protect against deductive disclosure of identity.

ETHICAL RESEARCH 4
The principle of justice is actually two-fold. Individual justice means that a doctor or researcher cannot administer potentially helpful treatment to some favored class of participants while offering riskier treatments to anyone else. Societal justice maintains that research participants must be selected fairly and randomly, without consideration of any economic, social, and gender class. Obviously, researchers in the Tuskegee Syphilis Study violated all three of these principles, as participants were lied to about their condition, lied to about the treatment they were receiving, and selected based on race, gender, and economic class.
Conclusion
Although the Tuskegee Syphilis Study was conducted in a period of history when blacks were not viewed as equal to whites, today's society can learn many lessons and apply many changes to the wrongful acts that were committed. Today, we have various laws that will help to prevent such criminal acts from occurring. Many new laws and new procedures were formed as a result of offenses such as the Tuskegee Study. Educating future generations about incidents like this will help to ensure that history does not repeat itself. Educating patients about their rights will enable and empower them to require nothing less than the best medical care possible from their healthcare professionals. The Tuskegee Syphilis study has left us with unpleasant memories of how doctors neglected the oath they took to save lives, and went on to experiment with human lives as a mere means to an end. One of the reverberating consequences of this study is the legacy of distrust which has elicited: it is still having negative consequences on medical practice in America and around the world. Although President Clinton apologized in 1997 for the atrocities committed against blacks by white American doctors in Tuskegee for forty years, it
ETHICAL RESEARCH 5 remains doubtful whether it has helped to douse the feelings of mistreatment and distrust that many blacks have towards whites around the world today.

ETHICAL RESEARCH 6
References
Brunner, Borgna: The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment. Retrieved April 6, 2009, from Tuskegee University Web site: http://www.tuskegee.edu/Global/Story.asp?s=1207586
The Center for Disease Control and Prevention. U.S. Public Health Service
Syphilis Study at Tuskegee: The Tuskegee Timeline. Retrieved April 6, 2009, from Center for Disease Control and Prevention Web site: http://www.cdc.gov/tuskegee/timeline.htm
Tuskegee Patient Medical Files. Retrieved April 7, 2009, from The National Archives
Web site: http://www.archives.gov/southeast/finding-aids/tuskegee.html
Gostin, Lawrence. 1991. "Ethical Principles for the Conduct of Human Subject Research: Population-Based Research and Ethics." The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 19 (3-4): 191-201.
Clinton, Bill. 1997. “Remarks by the President in Apology for the Study Done in Tuskegee”.
The Centre for Disease Control and Prevention. http://www.cdc.gov/tuskegee/cldintonnp.htm
American Medical Association. 2012. “Code of Medical Ethics: Informed Consent”. http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/physician-resources/medical-ethics/code-medicalethics/ opinion808.page

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Ethical Considerations in Marketing Research

...Ethical Considerations in Marketing Research There are many ethical considerations taken into account when performing primary research. In specific, the most important factor is the rights of the respondent. The issues concerning respondent’s rights which the marketing researcher should keep in mind while performing his job are as follows (Kimmel & Smith, 2001): 1. The information collected relating to the marketing research from a respondent should not be abused for any other purpose. In order to prevent this, the staff conducting the marketing research must be selected carefully. 2. Harassing or forcing respondents to participate in survey or answering certain questions on the questionnaire is not good professional practice. Instead, the researcher should explain why the particular question is necessary, and leaving it to the respondent to consider if he/she wants to answer them. For instance, questions relating to income of the respondents are always regarded with anxiety, and an explanation may be given before asking the question as to why it is necessary. 3. Researchers should sustain anonymity of respondents. Sustaining anonymity minimises respondent’s anxiety and decreases the fear of losing social status. If a firm breaches anonymity, it will negatively affect the firm’s credibility, reputation and public image. “The respondent is viewed as a loser, while the client pays a toll in terms of higher costs such as possible legal actions and a damaged reputation...

Words: 457 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ethical Research In Human Development

...Why is ethical and accurate research so important when studying human development? Ethical research in studying human development is important because it is working with other human beings. The research that is being done, and how it is being done, should have the participants’ best interests in mind. Research must also be accurate because as a tool for studying development it needs to be as realistic as possible so that it can be applied correctly to the span of development. What are teratogens and how do they impact development in the womb? Teratogens are any agent that can potentially cause a birth defect or negatively alter cognitive and behavioral outcomes. They include drugs, incompatible blood types, environmental pollutants, infectious...

Words: 1140 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Ethical Dilemma on Medical Research

...ETHICAL DILEMMA ON MEDICAL RESEARCH (HUMANS AS SUBJECTS) I am in favor of the medical research on humans/infants that could save or benefit future generations. For as long as the researcher would strictly adhere to three principles to ethically conduct a research on human subjects it would always be fine for me. The first principle is, the researcher must believe that the human subject in the experiment has at least the same chance of doing as well as a patient in standard therapy. Second, human subjects must be selected equitably in the sense that the researcher must avoid vulnerable populations, such as the very sick and the poor. I believe that using money as an inducement is unethical. Third, a researcher still has to have informed consent or to have a document and a process where he/she explains the procedure, the risks and the benefits to the subject – to the guardian given the subject is infant. The researcher must understand that the informed consent document does not evidence either that the participant is informed or that he/she consents. There is an ethical duty on the researcher to make sure that the subject understands the process and risks and is not coerced into giving consent. I definitely condemn medical researcher who believes that his/her work is so important that it justifies compromising the human subject. The abovementioned principles must be upheld at all times within such kind of research. Researchers for thousand years have abused human subjects to obtain...

Words: 286 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Ethical Issues in the Conduct of Research

...Ethical Issues in the Conduct of Research Presented By Group III: Ganaden, Mj Aguila, Janet • Three parties involved in research situations: • Each party expects certain rights and certain obligations toward each other. • Secure permission before conducting the study. Send Letter of Request/ Appointments to respondents ahead of time. Establish good linkage/ network. Know study objectives Ensure that only the real respondents are included in the study. Verify the list of respondents. Keep duplicate copies of all documents. Conduct ocular inspection. Protect the confidential informations. Obliged to be truthful Right to be informed Right to privacy Cooperate with the researcher Respect the purpose of research Must be available at the time of data gathering Assure the availability of facilities. If encounters conflict, resolve conflict Obligation to the researcher to ask that he objectively seek out truth. Obligation not to misrepresent the findings of a study Open relationship between both parties. Source: youtube.com Unethical Research Methods Sample Letter Permission LETTERHEAD INSIDE ADDRESS, NAME OF COMPANY, and POSITION OF THE RECIPIENT DATE SALUTATION BODY TEXT REQUEST PERMISSION TO CONDUCT RESEARCH CALL TO ACTION COMPLIMENTARY CLOSING, SIGNATURE, and TYPED NAME NOTATION BY THE PROFESSOR Common Difficulties Difficulties Non-availability of the respondent Unwillingness to...

Words: 295 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Research Summary and Ethical Considerations

...Running head: Research Critique, Part 1 Research Critique, Part 1 Grand Canyon University: NRS-433V Introduction to Nursing Research May 20, 2012 Research Critique, Part 1 Advanced Care Planning (ACP) is a huge part of healthcare. Dying is a part of life, but that doesn’t make the subject any less scary. Just because healthcare professionals handle end of life issues on a regular basis, doesn’t mean that they are immune to the sensitivities of the topic. End-of-life decision making is the process that healthcare providers, patients, and patients’ families go through when considering what treatments will or will not be used to treat a life-threatening illness. (Thelen, 2005) Many nurses who deal with death and decision making burn out. Hospice staff, because of their work with the terminally ill, are considered a high-risk group for burnout. Often, the reason behind the decision to leave or take a sabbatical from hospice work is that the staff member reached the limits of his or her capacity to care and “couldn’t take it anymore.” (Keidel, 2002) A qualitative study done, on anticipating emotion, related to ACP, was chosen to be critiqued, due to this highly sensitive topic in the healthcare industry. The subject this study was critiqued on, were, the problem statement, purpose and research question, literature review, and conceptual/theoretical framework. The clinical problem, addressed, is that end of life discussions between healthcare professionals and clients...

Words: 915 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Research Summary and Ethical Considerations

...in adult population, it includes hypertension, high cholesterol, diabetes and it also could lead to depression and low self- esteem. (Mayoclinic.org, 2014). The school based programs can play important role to prevent/ reduce these issues because school environment has important influence on children’s life and they spent many of their waking hours at school environments. School nurses has tremendous opportunity to make changes in the area of overweight and childhood obesity and many school nurses are not utilizing the situations because of the different reasons. This study addresses school nurse’s perceived barriers to weight-related issues. This paper will focus on the background of the study, method of study, results of the study, ethical considerations and how this study results applies to the nursing. A qualitative approach with the use of focus groups and discussion is how data was collected for this study. There were twenty two school nurses from three different school districts, ranging from suburban to rural areas for a total of seven focus groups. Each focus group session was led by a facilitator who introduced the topic questions, encouraged discussion, clarified responses and a second facilitator took detailed notes on the discussion. Additionally all focus groups were either videotaped or audio-taped for later review or transcription. Once all information had been reviewed and transcribed, identified themes were organized and evaluated. Researchers used NVivo8...

Words: 783 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Nrs-433v Week 2 Research Summary and Ethical Considerations

...NRS-433V Week 2 Research Summary and Ethical Considerations To purchase this tutorial visit here: http://mindsblow.us/question_des/NRS-433VWeek2ResearchSummaryandEthicalConsiderations/2853 contact us at: help@mindblows.us NRS-433V Week 2 Research Summary and Ethical Considerations Select either the qualitative or quantitative study method for this assignment. In an essay of 750-1,000 words, summarize the study, explain the ways in which the findings might be used in nursing practice, and address any ethical considerations associated with the conduct of the study. Refer to Resource Research Summary and Ethical Considerations Guidelines for suggested headings for your paper. Prepare this assignment according to the APA guidelines found in the APA Style Guide, located in the Student Success Center. An abstract is not required. NRS-433V Week 2 Research Summary and Ethical Considerations To purchase this tutorial visit here: http://mindsblow.us/question_des/NRS-433VWeek2ResearchSummaryandEthicalConsiderations/2853 contact us at: help@mindblows.us NRS-433V Week 2 Research Summary and Ethical Considerations Select either the qualitative or quantitative study method for this assignment. In an essay of 750-1,000 words, summarize the study, explain the ways in which the findings might be used in nursing practice, and address any ethical considerations associated with the conduct of the study. Refer to Resource Research Summary and Ethical Considerations Guidelines for...

Words: 1969 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Animal Testing: Scientific Research vs. Our Ethical Values

...Animal testing is a lot more common than we think, testing cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, vaccines for humans, and many more products. But as human beings with a large emotional capacity, there’s always something in us that tells us this isn’t right. Animal testing is a controversial topic, particularly amongst animal rights activists. Animal Testing is used when scientists aren’t sure if the substances used in the materials could cause harm to human beings. While animal testing may provide reliable scientific research, our ethics as human beings proves there are more reliable ways to obtain research, without harming animals. Scientists have been using animals for testing for a very long time, and no one doubted it. Until we saw pictures of these animals, dogs, cats, bunnies, rats most famously, primates, and many other species of animals that we bring into our home, feed and call our family members being tortured, burned with chemicals, and injected with toxic substances and many other forms. Animal testing is rarely performed with the comfort of the animals in mind. Rodents are forced to live in crammed conditions and larger animals are forced to live in spaces so small that they aren’t able to stretch their legs. This causes extreme physiological stress on the animals, causing test results to be inaccurate. Experts say that 90% of tests that prove to be safe on animals turn out to be dangerous to humans. Additionally, animals are often tested for things are not related to...

Words: 1553 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ethical Guidelines to Be Complied by Psychologists in Research and Analysed the Issues as Well as Importance to Conform Why It Must Be Followed at All Times.

...explore the ethical guidelines to be complied by psychologists in research and analysed the issues as well as importance to conform why it must be followed at all times. Ethical guidelines have become a vital part of modern psychology with regards to extensive reviews of the researches before it can be implemented, as noted in (The Ethical Principles for Conducting Research with Human Participant). The purpose of these guideline is to protect research participants, the reputation of psychology and psychologist themselves. At the outset, researchers must obtain the informed consent all participants to encourage consensual agreement. However, some areas of the research are left untold due to validity of the outcome. Therefore, it can be claimed that it does not always occur. The participants must have a debrief at the end of research to have a good frame of mind and to remove any worries with sense of dignity and views. For example, subjects of Milgram (1963) were offered a good aftercare indicating no further harm to all learners. Researches must ensure participant are protected to avoid causing distress. However, this has not always been the case in some researching. For example, It could be debated in Bandura et al. (1961)- Bobo Doll experiment. that aggression could have profound effect in the child’s life when it being learned. Ideally, there must be a degree of honesty to all participant about the actual research however some section of the research may be left...

Words: 660 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Report on the Ethical Issues Involved in Marketing Research Base on the Casro Code of Standards and Ethics for Survey Research

...REPORT ON THE ETHICAL ISSUES INVOLVED IN MARKETING RESEARCH BASE ON THE CASRO CODE OF STANDARDS AND ETHICS FOR SURVEY RESEARCH The Council of American Survey and Research Organizations (CASRO) were founded in 1975, which represents over 300 companies and market research operations in the United States and abroad. The philosophy of CASRO is to “require their members to adhere to the CASRO Code of Standards and Ethics for Survey Research, a tough, internationally-cited set of standards which has long been the benchmark for the industry. The Code has been organized into sections describing the the responsibilities of a survey research organization to Respondents, Clients and Outside Contractors and in reporting study results”. Here in this report, the writer would like to focus on the ethical issues that research firms often violate, and has denied to follow the Code of Standards and Ethics from CASRO. The three popular ethical issues are presented and discussed below. There are four main responsibilities in the CASRO Code if Standards and Ethics: Responibilities to Respondents, Responsibilities to Clients, Responsibilities in Reporting to Clients and the Public, and Responsibilities to Outside Contractors and Interviewers. However, the writer of this report will focus mainly on the Responsibilities to Respondent as the ethical issues of this part are now dramatically increasing. In the Section 3 of Part A – Confidentiality belong to I.Responsibilities to Respondents (CASRO...

Words: 1520 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Ethical Issues in Research

...UNIVERSITY UNIT TITLE : BUSINESS RESEARCH METHODS UNIT CODE : BCM 308 TASK : GROUP WORK STUDENT NO. NAME : NEWTON WANYAMA 12M03EBA074 : LEWIS MUNDIA 12J03ABA007 : JAMES IKUA 12S03EBA003 : MARY ODERO 12S03ABA011 : GLADYS MUMO 12J03EBA011 : PENINAH MBUTHIA : GEORGE OLIWA QUESTION : Discuss the ethical issues in research? DUE: 8 JULY 2013 LECTURER: HANIEL NJOGU MUCHIRI  INTRODUCTION When most people think of ethics (or morals), they think of rules for distinguishing between right and wrong, such as the Golden Rule ("Do unto others as you would have them do unto you’’. This is the most common way of defining "ethics": norms for conduct that distinguish between acceptable and unacceptable behavior. Most people learn ethical norms at home, at school, in church, or in other social settings. Although most people acquire their sense of right and wrong during childhood, moral development occurs throughout life and human beings pass through different stages of growth as they mature. Ethical norms are so ubiquitous that one might be tempted to regard them as simple commonsense. On the other hand, if morality were nothing more than commonsense, then why are there so many ethical disputes and issues in our society...

Words: 2373 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Ethical Standards of Research

...Ethical Standards for Human Research Human research discloses data that would benefit the populous; however, there are times when the ethical standards are violated. Furthermore, the risks and benefits to such research ultimately determine what acceptable risk is and what acceptable benefits are. Therefore, deceit in research is to be expected, considering the criterion in which deceit is acceptable is under the situational circumstances that allow researchers to deceive. Furthermore, there are times when the ends never justify the means. Meaning, putting human life in danger just to prove a hypothesis can place ethical standards for human research in question. Therefore, how much risk or how much benefit do researchers glean from deceit and from what is acceptable or not? Risk is a subject in which many people tend to avoid. Contemplation of risk often makes people uncomfortable leading to the risk involved in a situation overlooked instead of assessed. The term risk means to take a chance and many people are not willing to relinquish control to something risky or uncertain. In human research unfortunately everything is a risk, chance, or a gamble to try to find a break through solutions based on hypotheses that could improve the life of individuals and society. Even though benefits are important, the ethical aspects of human life must precedent overall. According to the National Institutes of Health (1979), “Previous codes and Federal regulations have required threat...

Words: 611 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethical Research Paper

...Personal Values and Ethical Standards Kiondra Lee BSHS/332 January 27, 2013 Kathleen Roberts Personal Values and Ethical Standards Before completing this paper, I have to make sure that I understand the difference between morals, values, and ethics. Values are something that we have learned from childhood. As a child we feed off the things our parents are doing as well as the influences of other adults surrounding us. Morals are believed to be the beliefs that we have developed based on the things that we value and how we feel that one should behave in any situation. Ethics is the way one behaves in a situation based on testing someone’s morals and values. Values are mainly established through childhood upbringing and then they are molded into citizen contribution to society. The environment where most values can be established includes home, church, school, one’s cultural background, neighbors and parties. I would have to say the values that I really up hold are integrity, openness, honesty, loyalty, respect and kindness. I guess I hold on to kindness the most because I believe in do until others as you want to be done until you, and I feel like it’s the right thing to do. Kindness also shows a sign of respect. When I think about integrity it is really a choice, which I have been rewarded for throughout the years. It encourages me to turn a negative situation into a good situation. When you have integrity u can...

Words: 1213 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Business Management

...Summary The amount of discussion and research on ethical leadership is increasing as people become more cynical about the motives, competence, and integrity of business and political leaders. Conceptions of ethical leadership include nurturing followers, empowering them, and promoting social justice. Ethical leadership includes efforts to encourage • Set an example in your own behavior of appreciation for diversity. • Encourage respect for individual differences. • Promote understanding of different values, beliefs, and traditions. • Explain the benefits of diversity for the team or organization. • Encourage and support others who promote tolerance of diversity. • Discourage use of stereotypes to describe people. • Identify biased beliefs and role expectations for women or minorities. • Challenge people who make prejudiced comments. • Speak out to protest against unfair treatment based on prejudice. • Take disciplinary action to stop harassment of women or minorities. CHAPTER 14 Ethical Leadership and Diversity 437 ethical behavior as well as efforts to stop unethical practices. Ethical leaders seek to build mutual trust and respect among diverse followers and to find integrative solutions to conflicts among stakeholders with competing interests. Such leaders do not foster distrust or play favorites to gain more power or achieve personal objectives. Determinants of ethical behavior by a leader include situational influences and aspects of leader personality...

Words: 459 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Sustainable Consumption

... Sustainability Research Institute, School of Earth and Environment, University of Leeds, UK 2 Department of Business Administration, College of Business Administration, Chonnam National University, South Korea 3 Aberdeen Business School, Robert Gordon University, UK 4 Management School, University of Sheffield, UK ABSTRACT The ‘attitude–behaviour gap’ or ‘values–action gap’ is where 30% of consumers report that they are very concerned about environmental issues but they are struggling to translate this into purchases. For example, the market share for ethical foods remains at 5 per cent of sales. This paper investigates the purchasing process for green consumers in relation to consumer technology products in the UK. Data were collected from 81 self-declared green consumers through in depth interviews on recent purchases of technology products. A green consumer purchasing model and success criteria for closing the gap between green consumers’ values and their behaviour are developed. The paper concludes that incentives and single issue labels (like the current energy rating label) would help consumers concentrate their limited efforts. More fundamentally, ‘being green’ needs time and space in people’s lives that is not available in increasingly busy lifestyles. Implications for policy and business are proposed. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd and ERP Environment. Received 12 December 2007; revised 30 June 2008; accepted 4 July 2008 Keywords: ethical; green; environmental;...

Words: 7596 - Pages: 31