Premium Essay

Getting to the Bottom of “Triple Bottom Line”*

In:

Submitted By kirank
Words 10518
Pages 43
In Press, Business Ethics Quarterly

Getting to the Bottom of “Triple Bottom Line”* by Wayne Norman and Chris MacDonald March 2003

Abstract:
In this paper, we examine critically the notion of “Triple Bottom Line” accounting. We begin by asking just what it is that supporters of the Triple Bottom line idea advocate, and attempt to distil specific, assessable claims from the vague, diverse, and sometimes contradictory uses of the Triple Bottom Line rhetoric. We then use these claims as a basis upon which to argue (a) that what is sound about the idea of a Triple Bottom Line is not novel, and (b) that what is novel about the idea is not sound. We argue on both conceptual and practical grounds that the Triple Bottom Line is an unhelpful addition to current discussions of corporate social responsibility. Finally, we argue that the Triple Bottom Line paradigm cannot be rescued simply by attenuating its claims: the rhetoric is badly misleading, and may in fact provide a smokescreen behind which firms can avoid truly effective social and environmental reporting and performance.

Introduction
The notion of “Triple Bottom Line” (3BL) accounting has become increasingly fashionable in management, consulting, investing, and NGO circles over the last few years. The idea behind the 3BL paradigm is that a corporation’s ultimate success or health can and should be measured not just by the traditional financial bottom line, but also by its social/ethical and environmental performance. Of course, it has long been accepted by most people in and out of the corporate world that firms have a variety of obligations to stakeholders to behave responsibly. It is also almost a truism that firms cannot be successful in the long run if they consistently disregard the interests of key stakeholders. The apparent novelty of 3BL lies in its supporters’ contention that the overall fulfilment

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Triple Bottom Line

...Executive Summary This report provides an analysis and evaluation of Triple Bottom Line (TBL) accounting. Many corporations adopt and follow the novel term, along with the public increasing public concern of social and environmental performances. The research pays attention to the arguments for and against the TBL accounting in corporate accounting reporting. Many companies concur with the significance of concept to reinforce their business, yet others hold the view that TBL is accompanied by diverse debates. The findings of this review show that TBL accounting: • Refers to a good tool of the measurement of accountability and transparency • Provides a beneficial opportunity to obtain the value of a corporate name and the market share in completion • Contributes to the reduction of production cost and the conservation of environment through making use of resources efficiently • Improves corporate management and employee productivity due to the measurement of accountability and transparency • Impacts on a core competency of business and a social situation • Adjusts a methodology to measure social and environmental performances TBL accounting with economic, social, environmental activities has been some negative thus far. However, the arguments against TBL accounting, which are related to core competency, poor societies and measure standard, are still doubtful and cannot address a strong persuasive in opposition to...

Words: 2530 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

General Management

... 10 INNOVATIVE CONCEPT IN MANAGEMENT 1. Triple bottom line The triple bottom line refers to an accounting model in which environmental and social considerations are measured along with financial performance. The concept shifts corporate responsibility from shareholders' profits to stakeholders' interests. In other words, the triple bottom line focuses on anyone who is affected by organizations decisions, rather than focusing on investors. Because it includes social, economic and environmental considerations, the triple bottom line's goal is sustainability. Socially, a triple bottom line organization is characterized by fair business practices that benefit many stakeholders while exploiting none. Economically, the "profits" from the triple bottom line, including clean air, improved safety, clean water, etc., are shared by the society, as well as internal corporate profits that keep the business running. Environmentally, a triple bottom line organization works to reduce its carbon footprint and be responsible for the entire life cycle of its products. Social and environmental issues play a greater role in consumer and B2B choices than ever before. The "Green" movement was on the fringes of mainstream culture just a few years ago. Today, global warming, eco-sensitivity, fair trade and sustainability are issues that can have a tremendous impact on businesses of all sizes. A relatively new marketing model -- the triple bottom line -- offers businesses of all sizes an opportunity...

Words: 4389 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Social Responsibility

...generations to meet their own needs” (qtd. in Werbach 8). The two terms will be used interchangeably throughout this paper, to illustrate the overall concept of companies acting in a responsible way rather than only looking out for the best interest of their company and shareholders. CSR is going above and beyond current laws and industry standards, it’s about looking at what practices the organization can do to improve the lives of their employees and the community in addition to focusing on the bottom line. Often times when people talk about CSR or sustainability they are referring to protecting the environment or adopting green practices; although that is part of it, it goes far beyond just looking at ways to conserve the environment. In his book Talent, Transformation, and the Triple Bottom Line, Andrew Savitz explains that social and economic sustainability are just as important as environmental sustainability. More organizations are looking at the so-called Triple Bottom Line – “a set of yardsticks that measures a company’s environmental and social impact as well as its economic performance” (Savitz 29). It is important for organizations to adapt and promote CSR; it can help their reputation and boost their branding (product and employer) and promoting trust (Lockwood 2). These initiatives should be a part of a company’s core business strategies, incorporated into their culture, values and mission as...

Words: 1469 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Business Ethics and Social Responsibility

...through the adoption of the Triple-Bottom-Line (TBL) concept. Any viable organisation will enhance and facilitate long-term viability and success through the critical adoption of fundamental social responsibility principles such as transparency and accountability (Benn & Bolton, 2011). For instance, in the year 2010, the international organisation for standardisation gave out an international standard, which could help other organisations in addressing and accessing their social responsibility. Further, it is through critical and careful attention to impacts on the environment and the entire society that various organisations are able to achieve their sustainability. Through such scenario frequencies, any organisation can spur growth and development within the shortest time possible. Embracing the culture of transparency and positive ethics enhances and facilitates an approach that helps in the protection of the long-term success of both the environment and organisational success (Benn & Bolton, 2011). Social responsibility Social responsibility on a personal or corporate level means having a passionate commitment to act in an ethical and sensitive manner to alleviate poverty from society without destroying the cultural values and environmental settings of the community, and ensuring economic benefits to the organisation that supports the society (Goldengate Consulting, 2012). In my view, social responsibility cuts across the ‘Triple-Bottom-Line (People, Planet, and Profit)’...

Words: 2225 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Amanco Sustainability Strategy

...Amanco Sustainability Strategy Abbas Ibrahim OCT 18, 2015 1. Is the Amanco strategy an example of corporate social responsibility or corporate self interest?  Amanco Strategy is an example of corporate social responsibility. Amanco, part of the Nueva Group based in Costa Rica, produces and markets piping for irrigation construction, infrastructure, and industry in 13 countries of Latin America. The company’s vision is “to be recognized as an organization that creates economic value by operating based on a framework incorporating ethics, efficiency and social responsibility, in a way that contributes to enhancing the life quality or life standards of people The company promotes the following values: * No discrimination * No child labor * Liberty of association * Compensation * Social security * Labor stability * Internal communication * Social responsibility projects For the Amanco Group, CSR is defined as: “being corporate citizens who interact in a responsible way with the community, contributing to its development and valuing the professional and human growth of the collaborators and the social economic environment of their businesses, while working for increased efficiency and assuring the long-term sustainability of their company for the benefit of all the stakeholders, through the correct and systematic management by objectives and measurable results. Amanco’s strategy is to conform to sustainable development principles because it wants...

Words: 1106 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Student

...business to be a more involved entity than just a products and service trader. This concept however encompasses many different ideas and different implications as to what is means to be socially responsible. Michael Porter’s article “Creating Shared Value” looks at, “the connection between societal and economic progress” (Porter). The article written by Archie Carroll and Kareem Shabana titled, “The Business Case for Corporate Social Responsibility: A Review of Concepts, Research and Practice” looks at how social responsibility can provide “incentives from a primary corporate economic/financial perspective (Carroll).” This can all be tied together with the new emerging type of corporation, a B-corp. A B-corporation is concerned with the triple bottom line; people, planet, and profit. Many businesses are jumping on band wagon of social responsibility while others are standing back to evaluate the progress of this new idea. Is there any stock in what Michael Porter or Archie Carroll and Kareem Shabana are saying? Do their ideas conflict with one another or support each other? Do B-corporations fit into this idea of social responsibility? Michael Porter article looked at the things that businesses could do to create shared value. Shared value as Porter explains means long term sustainable business that benefits multiple stakeholders. Porter’s article focused on different ways to create this shared value. He looked at reconceiving products and markets. This could mean looking at the...

Words: 1660 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Corporate Environmental and Social Management

............................................................................................. 2 I. The development of global, European and national policies relating to sustainability. 2 1. Changing attitudes of public, politicians and businesses to the environment since 1945 .................................................................................................................................... 2 2. Brundtland definition of ‘sustainable development’ .................................................. 4 3. The international and UK policies to sustainable development since Earth Summit of 1992 ................................................................................................................................ 4 4. Triple bottom line........................................................................................................ 5 II. The commercial case for considering social and environmental matters in business management .......................................................................................................................... 6 1. 2. 3. Stakeholders and how they impact on business policies ........................................... 6 Is adopting CSR policies cost-saving? .......................................................................... 7 Primark Ethical Trading ............................................................................................... 7 III. Balance between expectations of stakeholders and the social...

Words: 7353 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Home Depot

...Center for Language and Mathematics February 27, 2014 Home Depot Foundation's Sustainability Obama stated that “It is not a choice between our environment and our economy; it is a choice between prosperity and decline” (“Sustainable Development Strategies”, 2009). Sustainability means the balance of three things which are steady business, society and friendly environment. In other words, businesses must show crucial responsibility in terms of environmental impacts and social responsibilities. Consequently, businesses must utilize natural resources carefully, and the economic growth and employment rate of businesses must be increased (“Understanding Sustainability”, n.d.). Therefore, sustainability is an aim of businesses. The Triple Bottom Line or TBL is a significant tool advocating sustainability goals. The concept of TBL emphasizes three things, which are healthy communities (people), clean environment (planet) and stable profitability (profit) (“Slaper & Hall”, n.d.). In contrast with the past, many businesses, nonprofit organizations and government entities tend to follow this guideline. Home Depot is one of the best examples of companies which are following the TBL standard. Home Depot is the world biggest home improvement retailer (“​Did You Know”, n.d.). The company was established by Bernie Marcus and Arthur Blank in 1978. The first two stores opened on June 22, 1979, in Atlanta, Georgia. Today, Home Depot has approximately 2,200 branches around the United...

Words: 1929 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Csr - Samsung

...Samsung – Stages of Corporate Citizenship Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) as part of business strategy has shown increased prominence in contemporary business world. On a daily basis the roles corporations play in society are scrutinized by the media who constantly lookout to report on scandals, corporate misbehavior or, the positive contributions businesses have on society (Crane, 2008). Induced by this, corporations are facing increasing pressure to legitimate their practices and take account of the impact they have on society, which has led to the emergence of what Crane (2008) refers to as a ‘CSR Movement’. The concept of CSR emerged in the 1960/70’s as an American Doctrine that has popularized in recent decades due to the emergence of factors including globalization and the rise of global/transnational corporations (Jenkins, 2005). Attitudes around this concept have also altered from viewing CSR as a philanthropic exercise to a concept/practice necessary for corporate survival. The latter point can be supported by a numerous examples of organizations that have not complied with ethical/socially responsible standards, such as Nike, who faced numerous allegations of unethical conditions at its overseas suppliers in the 1990’s (Zadek, 2004). It is virtually impossible to define CSR due to the every-evolving nature of the concept. Various sources including academics, articles, and websites tackle, and all produce unique definitions of the concept. Crane, Matten...

Words: 4538 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

H & M: Corporate Social Responsibility

...Introduction In the past, the main goal of businesses is making profit to benefit their shareholders as explained by Milton Friedman (Humber 2002). However, the stakeholder theory by Edward Freeman asserted that businesses have responsibilities towards all of their stakeholders, which comprised of responsibilities in the area of philanthropy, ethical, economic and legal (see figure 1) (Stieb 2009). Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) refers to business practices that aim to solve environment, social and economic issues (Osagie et al. 2016, 233). Besides that, global corporate citizens should engage in activities that align with the triple bottom line theory of people, planet, and profit and the principle of UNGC (Payne 2013; Ten Principle...

Words: 1753 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Leadership

...ecology, or similar) while providing a product or service to consumers and to make a profit. This paper will also show what three resources or tools available through the Small Business Administration and SCORE would be the most useful. Analyze and describe the founding leader(s), leadership style, and major business principles of a profit-oriented entrepreneurial approach in which the primary goal is to provide a product or service to consumers and to make a profit.  The founding profit oriented leader is Jack Welch. He had a successful strategic plan with an aggressive approach to we maximize the opportunity. He will confidently say that the bottom line for most if not all entrepreneurs are to take care of their bottom line – income. Being able to make a residual income from your business makes it that much more enticing to stay in business for yourself. Jack Welch is "the celebrated leader of a global manufacturer often noted for its technological prowess, he has utilized a very human process to drive change through GE's vast organization. Having respect for the individual as...

Words: 2160 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Social Responsibility Task 1

...open its doors within the next 6 months. RYS would like to offer the community yoga classes, meditation sessions, dance classes, community events, workshops, Yoga Teacher trainings, and socially responsible retail. Objectives The main business objective in opening the studio, is to maintain and run the studio based on yogic principles, while bringing in a profit. Living in harmony with self, community, and the planet is at the core of these principles. While the exchange of money for the ancient practice of yoga is relatively a new concept, in this modern day and age the majority of teachers need to make a living and require payment for their service. This correlates to the socially responsible business principle of “Triple Bottom Line”. Triple Bottom Line refers to focusing on three factors in business: people, planet, and profit. Leadership Considerations (People) Under the “People” category there are 2 main groups : Leadership and community. Leadership includes the individuals running the studio and community includes every person or organization that has a relationship with the studio. The owner of RYS is currently looking for a studio manager. Within the job profile, the owner has utilized characteristics of socially responsible leadership. The manager is the facilitator of business between the community and the studio. The most important quality is that the manager exhibits ethical behavior. It is important to establish and maintain a culture of high ethical...

Words: 1962 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Code of Ethics Final

...Code of Ethics OMM640: Business Ethics and Social Responsibility Instructor: Erika O'Quinn 5/26/2014 Code of Ethics Perry's Outreach Ministries is a Christian non-profit organization that relies on government funding, and donations from members of the community. Perry's Outreach Ministries provides,counseling, non-perishable food items,clothing housing vouchers and childcare to the battered and abused women and children throughout the community. The overall mission of POM is to minister Gods word through Bible study, professionalism,participants rights to privacy, reliability,honesty and counseling services. The primary mission of the human service profession is to assist in the betterment of human life and necessaties of all people who may be viewed as vulnerable,oppressed, and living in poverty and unsafe environments. When dealing with the community it I crucial that a code of ethics is set into place where not only the employees but the volunteers follow and take seriously. A code of ethics for POM employee's and representatives: Employee's should obtain eduction about and seek to understand the nature of social diversity and oppression with respect to race, ethnicity, national origin, color sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, age, marital status, political belief, religion, immigration status, and mental or physical disability. Employee's and volunteers should treat colleagues and program participants with respect and refrain...

Words: 3340 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Technical Analysis of Stocks

...ANNEXURE - C “TECHNICAL ANALYSIS OF STOCKS ” This project report in the Special Studies in Finance based on the in-depth study of the project theme is submitted in February, 2014 to the Sydenham Institute of Management Studies and Research and Entrepreneurship Education (SIMSREE) , B - Road, Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the Master’s Degree, Masters in Management Studies (MMS), Submitted By NAME: VAISHALI CHANDRESH GORATELA ROLL NO. : M12020 CLASS: MMS1 BATCH: 2012-2014 Guided By MR. AMIT BOBHATE Date: Place: MUMBAI ANNEXURE – D CERTIFICATE This is to certify that this project report entitled “TECHNICAL ANALYSIS OF STOCKS” is submitted in February, 2014 to Sydenham Institute of Management Studies and Research and Entrepreneurship Education (SIMSREE) , Mumbai 400020, by Ms. Vaishali Goratela bearing Roll No. M12020, batch (2012 - 2014) in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the Master’s Degree, Masters in Management Studies (MMS). This is a record of her own work carried out under my guidance. She has discussed with me adequately before compiling the above work and I am satisfied with the quality, originality and depth of the work for the above qualification. PLACE: MUMBAI. ________________ DATE: (Signature...

Words: 13489 - Pages: 54

Premium Essay

Current Trends in Hrm

...CURRENT TRENDS IN HUMAN RESOURCES MANAGEMENT If we trace back the history of business environment, in the early years, trading patterns and markets were stable, technology was static, customers were passive, speed in getting to market was secondary, competition was limited to sectors and regions, and hierarchies were generally accepted in all walks of life. No more, since 1960’s, America and much of the rest of the world has been almost continually buffeted by change. Customers demand that businesses do it better, faster, cheaper; employees want to control more than the “Stop” button on the assembly line. The twentieth century saw nations around the world become part of the global village, with trade barriers between them reduced or removed completely. Globalization of trade and economy are taking deep roots in India. The holistic paradigm shift to a single global company has opened up new economic opportunities. Events of the last five years of the previous century have focused our attention on knowledge industries. Quality human resources have therefore become an important base with which to respond to the emerging environment. The knowledge workforce in particular has a vital role to play in the emergence of the digital economy. A look at the trends in managing people in this dynamic industry reflects that Attracting, Managing, Nurturing talent and Retaining people has emerged to be the single most critical issue in lieu of the enormous opportunities spun off by the market...

Words: 877 - Pages: 4