Premium Essay

Illness In Prisons

Submitted By
Words 793
Pages 4
Both my articles discuss some aspect of the impact mentally ill inmates have on not only the prison system but crime as well. In each article, researchers study ways to positively improve the prison systems and with the dealing of the mental ill inmates. Improving our prisons on how they deal with mentally ill inmates and how to prevent such problems from occuring by improving the prison climate and treating the root problems of society instead of the symptoms we are viewing in the prisons.

How is this issue discussed in academic research as opposed to the mainstream media?
The Article discusses and studies whether or not "prison climate/environment" has a negative impact on inmates mental health. Researchers conduct multiple studies of …show more content…
Inmates were selected if they had a diagnosis of a mental illness prior to imprisonment, during, and if they displayed symptoms of mental problems. Inmates with substance abuse as the primary focus was not included in the study. Focus groups, individual interviews, and other reporting methods were used during the studies. Data from the studies was compiled to develop the conclusion of the study.
How effective does the evidence seem in each source and why
The researchers used multiple studies in three different countries from compiled by over two hundrend years of data. although the number particpated in the study is small compared to the amount of people in prison throughout the three countries it gives a insight on the effects of prison climate and inmates mental health. Additional studies can build off this study to hopefully develop a better solution to how inmates with mental health issues can recieve better treatment and prevent mental health related problems.
What solutions, if any, are proposed for the issue in the …show more content…
(2015). The influence of prison climate on the mental health of adult prisoners: a literature review. Journal Of Psychiatric & Mental Health Nursing, 22(6), 413-422. doi:10.1111/jpm.12231

How is this issue discussed in academic research as opposed to the mainstream media?
This article re-visits a study that was conduct in 1939 by Lionel Penrose which is now called Penrose's Law. It discusses the impact that decreasing mental health facilities has a negative impact on crime as the numbers increased. Main stream media like to discuss the problem's in the prison system regarding mentally ill inmates and what the prison is failing to do. In the article we learn that this problem starts before any criminal reaches the prison system and that prisons can not take all the blame.
What evidence is used in each source?
Researcher re-visits Lionel Penrose's study conducted in 1939 to determine if his findings holds true today as they did back then. Rseources use the Norway prison system to conduct the study and the impact of crime when mental health facilities are decreased.
How effective does the evidence seem in each source and

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Mental Illness In Prisons

...Mental illness has become an epidemic in the prison system. Most offenders with mental illness go untreated, and those who do receive treatment often get it in the form of forced medication. Some prisons have implemented treatment plans for inmates to try to treat any mental illness or substance abuse problems. Unfortunately, the staffs in the prisons are inadequately trained to detect those who need help and in turn prisoners are not given the proper coping tools or medications. Most of these reform programs are designed for short-term prisoners and focuses on a 9-month plan. The individual is then released with the high rate of returning to prison within the next 3 years. How can we correct how mental illness is treated in the correctional...

Words: 1553 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Mental Illness In Prison

...ages of 27 and 60 years old. My audience is somewhat informed on the topic of mental illness, but not on how mental illness affects the prison population. They are either related to me or are friends of mine. Topic: Mental illness is a serious problem among inmates throughout our prison systems. General Purpose: To persuade Specific Purpose: To inform the audience that mental illness is a real problem throughout the prison system and that through a combination of Christian faith-based therapeutic programs, a larger variety of prescription drugs, and their personal...

Words: 1107 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Mental Illness In Prison

...Following the mass draining of state hospitals in the 1960’s and 70’s, along with the failed plan of “community-based care”, thousands of mentally ill people were left without care (Lyons). This policy has left lasting, harmful consequences in its path. Notably, it provoked a crisis in the nation’s mental health system and provides part of the explanation to why our prison system is overwhelmed with those suffering from severe mental illness. Though mental illness does not discriminate, the mental health care system, the prison system and their complicated interconnections do. Poor folk and minorities with mental illness are less likely to be able to access and receive proper psychiatric care. As a result, these folk are more vulnerable to receiving primary support from jails and...

Words: 430 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Mentally Ill Offenders

...Mentally Ill Offenders Introduction Mental illness in prisons has been sort of a pandemic for correctional systems in the United States for over the last 10 years. The number of men and women who come to prison with some form of mental illness continues to grow by the day. Offenders who do not come to prison mentally ill, will most likely release from prison with some type of mental illness at the end of their prison sentence. This paper will discuss how this population of offenders adapts when they come to prison, and how there viewed by the community. This will be examined here along with some insights on what should be done along with why this topic was chosen. Schizophrenia Many mentally ill offenders come to prison with a variety of disorders schizophrenia, manic depression (bi-polar) or major depression (Schizophrenia.com - Crime, Poverty Violence., n.d.). Schizophrenic inmates probably account for the largest segment of offenders who enter the correctional system every day and have a difficult time adapting to the confines of a correctional environment. By definition schizophrenia is an inability to think, process emotions where people tend to behave in an unacceptable manner because their mind is not able to react to the stimuli from every day life; the name schizophrenia comes from the Greek root "split mind" (Skitzophrenia., n.d.). Hallucinations, hearing voices, paranoia are just some of the...

Words: 2082 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Prisoners with Special Needs

...2016 Sherri Webster Special needs, mentally ill, and substance-abusing prisoners affect the jail and prison systems at a state and federal level in a multitude of ways. One of the main issues within prisons is the fact that their mental health services can be seriously inadequate and lacking the proper staffing, all while operating in facilities that are not equipped to handle such prisoners, on top of a limited amount of programs to even help these prisoners with their problems. If these prisoners are not cared for properly, it could lead to deteriorating conditions for the prisoners. State and Federal Levels are Affected Jails and prisons are not meant to be home to the mentally ill, yet, when someone who is mentally ill commits a crime and cannot receive help outside of jail or prison, that is where they end up. Schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and major depression are just a few mental disorders that can plague prisoners in the criminal justice system. One of the main issues with prisoners having these mental health issues is the fact that prisons are not sufficiently capable of dealing with the increasing amount of prisoners coming into the system with mental health disorders (Human Rights Watch, 2016). Human Rights Watch (2016) goes on to state that “Unfortunately, prisons are ill-equipped to respond appropriately to the needs of prisoners with mental illness…Many seriously ill prisoners receive little or no meaningful treatment” and also that “Twenty-two out of forty...

Words: 1110 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Inmates Should Have Good Mental Health In Prisons

...health programs. This issue has been heightened by two mentally ill inmates who committed suicide by hanging themselves in the prisons over the past sixty days. In addition, a mentally ill inmate was raped in another prison. Also, an inmate suffering from mental illness murdered a staff member last week. My responsibly is to design...

Words: 725 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Mentally Ill in Prison

...Mentally Ill in Prison PSCH/610 Mentally Ill in Prison Abstract The increase in incarcerated individuals with mental illness in the preceding decades has made the prison system a prevalent mental health provider even though they are not prepared or equipped for such task. Prison life is tough on an individual’s mental health; overcapacity, lack of privacy, violent behavior, lack of activity, inadequate health services, seclusion from family and friends, and the insecurity of what life holds after prison contribute to the inmate’s mental health. Inmates whose judgment is altered or impaired by depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, and other severe mental illnesses are impacted more severely by the tribulations of prison life. Inadequate mental health services is also something mentally ill inmates face, this absconds them undertreated or mistreated. Numerous prisoners do not receive proper psychotropic medication due to the lack of mental health services and care, further impairing their capability to function. The security mission of prisons tends to overlook mental health considerations. Prison rules and codes of demeanor teach staff about security, safety, supremacy, and power. Coordinating the needs of the mentally ill with prison regulations and goals is almost impractical. Factors of the sources and effects of the concern between prison and mental illness will be observed in this research proposal. Reforms will be provided to improve mental health...

Words: 4562 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Mentally Ill Inmates In Prisons

...are held in prison or jails are getting more suicidal thoughts than ever. Just by being there by themselves they drive themselves crazy. Being trapped in those cells make them hallucinate things. A lot of these inmates are being held in solitary confinements, being mistreated, and the population in the jails and prisons are made up of mentally ill offenders. Many of the mentally ill offenders in prisons and jails are being mistreated. A lot of them have experienced shocking, physical and sexual abuse from other prisoners. Many of them across the United States are subjected to routine physical abuse from guards. A lot of these offenders leave sicker than when they entered. From all of these daily abuses a lot of them have died in prison for this cause. What some of these jails do wrong is that they are not required to report the use of force by guards. Inmates are being put in the state psychiatric hospitals due to the mental illness they have. One of the cases that happened in Michigan (2005) was this man...

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Mentally Ill Prisoners

...mental illness influencing their criminal behavior. Often when the mentally ill are tried, their illness is not discussed in court. Since the court system does not take mental illness into account, they get incarcerated instead of being institutionalized. Mentally ill prisoners are more likely to be treated more harshly by correctional staff in jail due to their conditions. The harsh treatment of mentally ill prisoners can be combated by improving correctional officer behavior, counseling prisoners to deal with trauma, and correcting prisoners' morals in life. Most mentally ill criminals go to prison instead of a mental hospital due to their illness not being identified or even...

Words: 905 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Just Mercy Analysis

...Just Mercy Essay Mental illness has been a big issue in the United States, over the past century or maybe a little less than a century. Some believe that we use mental illness as excuse to put people in prison to keep us, while some people believe the opposite of that. Bryan Stevenson tackles this issue in his book of Just Mercy. He also tackles what the contributing ideas or factors to the large numbers of mentally ill people in prison. Stevenson’s points support what he says, a story that supports his points is a case that happened recently in Michigan. Stevenson talks about mental illness and how big of issue it is when it comes to prisons. Stevenson addresses this issue by stating that, “fifty percent of prison and jail inmates in...

Words: 898 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Myth of Mental Illness

...In the introduction handout, Thomas Szasz is quoted from his book The Myth of Mental Illness as arguing that “mental illness is not an illness at all but merely a failure to cope with normal life”. Even though people who commit a crime should be punished, those who have a mental illness should be treated with a slight difference compared to those who are of competent mind when they commit their crime. It is said that the population of those with a mental illness is higher in prisons than in the general population which is most likely due to the fact that people with mental illnesses are more likely to participate in an act of violent assault or sexual assault than people who do not have a mental illness. (Paraphrased page 9) The insanity defense became popular especially after high profile cases such as Daniel M’Naughten, John Hinckley Jr., and many more. With this defense becoming more common, those opposed to the defense began to make it stricter to use it because some felt it was a “copout” and that it is often abused. One way in which they sought to make the insanity defense stricter is by requiring that for the defense to be used, the perpetrator must not be of sound mind meaning they must not understand the act that they had committed and/or they must not be able to understand that the act was wrong (morally and legally). On the other hand, those who support the insanity defense believe that there are actually not that many cases in which a defendant claims the insanity...

Words: 826 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Special Needs Inmates Research Paper

...is a law that prison should abide by attending to special needs inmates, it will be heartless to mistreat or not tend to an inmate because of something he/she cannot control....

Words: 1348 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Deinstitutionalization Vs Incarceration

...If a society is to be judged how it treats its most disadvantaged members, then the United States is in a very lowly state. In the United States we incarcerate over 356,000 individuals diagnosed with mental illnesses a year. This is a ten fold the number of people receiving treatment in psychiatric hospitals, around 35,000 (Frances). Leaving us with the question when did suffering from a mental illness become a crime worthy of incarceration? The question no longer remains as to if the system is broken, as indicated by recent report from the Treatment Advocacy Center and the National Sheriffs’ Association, which surveyed sheriffs and prison administrators, which concluded on three main points. Mental illness among prison populations are growing...

Words: 1531 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Hallucinations In Prison

...at T1, in the week following admission into custody. However, this was found to be higher among those with mental illness than those without. (OHR, 2010, p.50). This illustrated that prison has a more negative impact on those with mental illness even in its early stage. Prisoners were later asked about their perception about the quality of prison life. They were asked to request this with 112 MQPL in which, they would express their agreement and disagreement. The findings reveal that ‘58% of prisoners...

Words: 438 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ann. Bibliography

...The purpose of this assignment is to create an APA formatted reference list for eight articles from reputable sources, and a one paragraph summary for each article selected, and a brief expression of intent on the selected articles. As clearly noted in Creswell (2009) literature review provides the ground work for a preparation of another scientific work. Creswell further notes… “ this literature review passage should summarize large groups of studies instead of individual ones”( Creswell, 2009, p.104). Rhodes, A.L. Total Confinement: Madness and Reason in the Maximum Security Prison (2004) is a book written by Dr. Lorna Rhodes. Her study explores, examines, and recognizes what life is like inside confined walls of solitary units inside prisons. Her study provides not only the image of solitary confinement- but the sense of loss and liberty of humanity when an offender is faced with long periods of extensive isolation from all; but those who feed you (correctional officers). Dr. Rhodes- explores and discusses the challenges that are faced both by the front-line-staff and offenders. Such as, psychological, emotional, and physiological changes- and provides her academic perspective with a scientific response. Rationale for Selection There are a lot of research currently available in-regards to isolation of offenders, and the biological effects on human body, mind, and perceptions. This study is valuable to my research even though the findings are not as scientific as...

Words: 1850 - Pages: 8