Premium Essay

In Defense of Polygamy

In:

Submitted By vinhnguyen317
Words 1337
Pages 6
Name________________________________________Date_________________

In Defense of Polygamy
By: B. Aisha Lemu
B. Aisha Lemu was born in England and became a Muslim while in college. She is Director General of the Islamic Education Trust in Niger State, Nigeria. Reprinted here is part of a talk she gave (and part of the discussion that followed) at the International Islamic Conference held in London.

Perhaps the aspect of Islam in respect of women which is most prominent in the Western mind is that of polygamy. Firstly let me clarify that Islam does not impose polygamy as a universal practice. The Prophet himself was a monogamist for the greater part of his married life, from the age of twenty-five when he married Khadija until he was fifty when she died. One should therefore regard monogamy as the norm and polygamy as the exception. One may observe that, although it has been abused in some times and some places, polygamy has under certain circumstances a valuable function. In some situations it may be considered as the lesser of two evils, and in other situations it may even be a positive beneficial arrangement. The most obvious example of this occurs in times of war when there are inevitably large numbers of windows and girls whose fiancés and husbands have been killed in the fighting. One has only to recall the figures of the dead in the first and second world wars to be aware that literally millions of women and girls lost their husbands and fiancés and were left alone without any income or care or protection for themselves or their children. If it is still maintained that under these circumstances a man may marry only one wife, what options are left to the millions of other women who have no hope of getting a husband? Their choice, bluntly stated, is between a chaste and childless old maidenhood, or becoming somebody’s mistress—that is, an

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Latter Day Saints Controversy

...men. Warren Jeffs hid from the authorities underground but was later convicted of two counts of rape by accomplice (Anderson, 741). During his trial, a photo was shown to the jury of him and his twelve-year-old bride on their wedding day. There were also allegations that there was a sex tape made with this child while others were in the room observing (HLN, 2013). Looking at the trial and offenses from the defendant’s side, we can see why Warren Jeffs might believe these laws are trying to stop his religious practices. There has been a sizeable negative stigma on Warren Jeffs and his followers. Their beliefs have been controversial since the beginning. Their family religion Christianity and even closer Mormons, reject the teachings of polygamy. Warren Jeffs and his followers truly believe in these practices and when they are questioned they protect what they base their beliefs on. From their perspective, which is to say our society is wrong, polygamous marriages are holy and sacred, and monogamous marriages are what really are breaking the sacred canopy that should exist. Along with that, who is to say that a thirteen-year-old is not mature enough to handle a sexual relationship? Our laws state that the youngest age of consent is sixteen, yet the brain is not fully developed until the age of twenty-five. If the argument the government is really trying to make is maturity, then why is the age of consent not twenty-five? Looking at the trial through the sacred canopy’s telescope...

Words: 2304 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Same Sex Marriage

...Historically marriage is seen as a heterosexual privilege, not even interracial marriage was acceptable and many people continue to believe this, regardless of the many changes in today’s world. Times have changed and advocates argue same-sex couples deserve right to the same benefits of marriage appreciated by heterosexual couple, and by denying same sex marriage is unconstitutional discrimination. On the other hand the oppositions argues changing the acceptable definition of marriage as between heterosexual couples will weaken an already threatened institution and by legalizing same-sex unions will introduce legalization of polygamy, incestuous, and non-traditional unions the right to marry, which seems to be a little extreme. Glen Lavy, JD, senior counsel with the Alliance Defense fund, argued in May 21, 2008 Los Angeles Times Op-Ed, “ The movement of polygamy and...

Words: 671 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Ethics

...r{,r,, ^'r\. J. L !--.,,r'*- A 4l^ 4^ *- rwc,\ l*"d , Cr^V*Voa^{Y /Aotql [ss^'/> ?**, o^ft*^Na JJ rrr! alt i , 3 cz €);o\t -', , l)*s*xY YUrrur(J Susan Moller Okin "ls Multiculturalism Bad for Women?" Ethics in Society and Profe.ssor o,f.Politiin Western Political Thought andJustice, cal Science atStanford rJniversity, isthe authorofwomen Cender, and the FamilY. Susan Moller Okin, the Marta Sutton Weeks Professor of arise between acceptance of diversity In this article, Okin explores some of the tensions that the rights and well-being of women' (a key telnA of multicultural'ism) and concern for ' As You Recd, Consiiler This: ,'Eeminism" .and "multicultur rtlism" 1. fine each of these terms? aTe two key terms in okin's arlrcle' How does she de- originallypublisheditlheBostonReview,october/November199?'ReprintedinsusanMollerOkin'IsMulticulc' Nussbaum (Princeton: PrinceMatthew Howard' and Martha turalism Bad for women? edited by Joshua cohen, Press, 1999). ton UniversitY Chapter 7 . Gender 287 2. Why, according to Kymticka, do certain minority groups deserve special group rights? 3. \Mhat is the liberal response to Okin's crlttque?'Nhatrejoinder does Olcrn offer to this response? Until the past few decades, minority groups-immigrants as well as indigenous peoples-were typically expected to assimilate into majority cultures. This assimilationist expectation is now often ...

Words: 6045 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

Polygamy

...Running head: POLYGAMY Polygamy: The impact on Arab families in Israel Laura Kline Pennsylvania State University-York Dr. Darling HDFS 315Y Abstract Polygamy is a common form of marriage for Bedouin-Arabs in Israel. The unique structure of this form of marriage can create problems for wives and children. It can benefit the family members as well. There are multiple factors that can influence whether being in a polygamous family is advantageous or detrimental to those family members. The reasons behind polygamous marriage are examined as well. The marriage practice known as polygamy is viewed many different ways in different societies. In societies such as our own, polygamy is seen as a taboo that is not widely understood or accepted. In fact, in the United States polygamy is not legal and polygamous marriages are not recognized. Polygamy is a general term that refers to the two types of polygamous marriages. Polygyny refers to the marriage of one man to two or more women, which is the type of polygamous marriage this paper will cover. Polyandry refers to a rare type of marriage in which one woman marries two or more men. Some other societies view polygamy as an acceptable and sometimes necessary form of marriage. One of these societies is the Bedouin-Arabs in Israel, where polygamous marriages are common. These polygamous families are Muslim. The Islamic faith encourages men to have two or more wives if they can sufficiently support them (Al-Krenawi...

Words: 2719 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Barriers to Critical Thinking

...Enculturation, or the acquisition of traits and beliefs through family, friends, and geographical location, is a barrier to an individual’s ability to think critically. Enculturation occurs when an individual is influenced by their surroundings, and cannot critically think through situations that they disagree with. Examples of enculturation include cultural differences, such as polygamy; an individual who does not believe in polygamy may not be able to critically think about the topic. I would recommend that all individuals explore different cultures and perspectives. I have found that an open mind towards new and unfamiliar perspectives allows an individual to openly ingest new ideas. Self-concept, or the self-image that an individual holds of their self, is another barrier to critical thinking. Items related to self-concept are associations that an individual creates with a product or a cause. While associating with a product or cause is not a barrier, as examples of self-concept include individuals who buy a certain brand of vehicle, or an individual who associates themselves as an advocate of a particular dog breed. The barrier to critical thinking occurs when the individual cannot disassociate themselves from the associations they have made. A personal example of this is my association to Pit Bull advocacy groups; I own a Pit Bull, and I personally feel they receive an undeserved and uneducated negative stigma. While I associate myself as a Pit Bull owner, and believe they...

Words: 422 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Polygamy Case Briefs

...PA 499 Unit 5 assignment Case Briefs Debbie McQueen August 30th, 2015 State v. Holm Supreme Court of Utah 137P.3d 726 (2006) Facts: Rodney Holm an active member of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, legally married Suzie Stubbs in 1986.  He later entered into marriages with Wendy Holm and Ruth Stubbs, Suzie’s 16-year old sister.  The marriages to Wendy and Ruth were solemnized in religious ceremonies only and not otherwise registered with the state.  Before reaching age 18, Ruth Stubbs conceived two children with Holm.  The state of Utah charged him with violating the state’s bigamy law and with having unlawful sexual conduct with a minor.  After being convicted, he appealed on the grounds that his conduct was not bigamy and that, in any event, the bigamy law was unconstitutional under state and federal law. Issue: Whether Rodney Holms was appropriately convicted for bigamy and unlawful sexual conduct with a minor? Whether Holm’s behavior violated Utah’s bigamy statute and whether the statute is constitutional? Rule: A person is guilty of bigamy when he knowingly has a husband or wife or the other person has a husband or wife and that person intends to marry another person or cohabits with another person. Utah code section 76-7-101 Analysis: Holms was guilty of bigamy because he purported to marry Ruth Stubbs, after he was already married. The “purports to marry” language under the bigamy statute is broad enough to include...

Words: 822 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Lat1

...Research suggests that many same-sex couples face obstacles in society because, they are often denied the ability to foster or adopt children, and do not receive equal rights when compared with heterosexual married couples. Annotated Bibliography (1)Alexander, L. J. (2013). Arkansas Department of Human Services v. Cole: Another step toward same sex marriage in Arkansas? Arkansas Law Review. Vol. 66 (Issue 2), p527-547.The article focuses on the judgment of Arkansas Supreme Court case in Arkansas Department of Human Services v. Cole; the Arkansas Supreme Court ruled that the Arkansas Adoption and Foster Care Act of 2008, known as “Act1”, was an unconstitutional violation of the fundamental privacy rights granted by the Arkansas Constitution. The source is relevant to my thesis statement because it provides the legality of the law. The author pointed out that the election of November 2008, 58 % of Arkansas voters cast ballots that prohibit a person who cohabited “with a sexual partner outside of a marriage that is valid under the Arkansas Constitution and the laws of Arkansas” from adopting or fostering children. The source of the article was from the Arkansas Law Review 2013, vol. 66. The author, LaToya Alexander, is a teaching assistant at the University of Arkansas. She received her Juris Doctor at University of Arkansas School of Law. According to the case the Arkansas Supreme Court decisions suggest that the Arkansas judiciary is taking a more liberal approach to...

Words: 2959 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Jedasdfdvzdvzdv

...Impossibility of performance as a ground to avoid the contract: critical analysis based on Indian case law ANAND J NAIR 3 BA LLB ‘C’ 1316211 SCHOOL OF LAW, CHRIST UNIVERSITY Submitted to- Ms Jayanthi Bai H.L IMPOSSIBILITY OF PERFORMANCE. INTRODUCTION In some cases, a contract can be ended even before the parties have the chance to fulfill their contractual duties and responsibilities.   This is known as “contract termination” or “termination of contract”, and can be based on many different grounds.  Some common grounds for contract termination may include: * Fraud:  Fraud is a deception deliberately practiced in order to secure unfair or unlawful gain .  As a legal construct, fraud is both a civil wrong (i.e., a fraud victim may sue the fraud perpetrator to avoid the fraud and/or recover monetary compensation) and a criminal wrong (i.e., a fraud perpetrator may be prosecuted and imprisoned by governmental authorities). Defrauding people or organizations of money or valuables is the usual purpose of fraud, but it sometimes instead involves obtaining benefits without actually depriving anyone of money or valuables, such as obtaining a drivers license by way of false statements made in an application for the sameContracts can’t be based on deception or fraud (such as fake documents, etc.) * Mistake: when a party enters into a contract, without the knowledge of the law in the country, the contract is affected by such mistakes but it is not void. A contract is...

Words: 2254 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Relativism and Morality

...itself is whether an action is right or wrong that depends on the moral norms of the society in which it is practiced. What may be morally right in one culture can be viewed as morally wrong in another. In saying this, I do not believe that it will ever be possible to accomplish moral standards equally universally to apply to all people at all times. Different societies with their differences on moralism make it impossible to resolve moral disputes or to reach an agreement on ethical matters. The moral standards that each society practices really can only be judged by their own society. The areas that Lenn Goodman discussed is genocide, politically induced famine (depravation), germ warfare, terrorism, hostage taking, child warrior, polygamy, incest, slavery, rape, and female genital cutting. Lenn Goodman first discusses “Genocide, Famine, and Germ Warfare.” I agree with the statement that because murder destroys a human subject, it is wrong. I believe all societies know murder is wrong in of itself generally speaking. On the other hand, I believe warfare is at times a necessity to protect the greater good. Although I feel it should be the last resort as many innocents are affected by the after mass devastation and many lives are lost. Before warfare is initiated, I think there certainly needs to be a genuine reason such as another country trying to take over our country by committing murder in any form, as it affects everyone as...

Words: 2824 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Yuma Territorial Prison

...Florence, Arizona. The abandoned building had a very important role to the Yuma community shortly after. A local high school district was in need of facilities, between 1910-1914 they used the prison’s hospital and other facilities as their high school. This was the reason behind their sports team’s name being the criminals. The prison was also used for distressed families and hobos during the great depression. During World War II, the Main Guard Tower was used as an observation tower by Civil Defense. Between the time the Territorial Prison was built and the time it was finished being used as...

Words: 858 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Legalization of Same-Sex Marriage

...Should Same-sex Marriages be Legalized? Kristina Linthicum PHI 200: Mind and Machine Instructor Michele Clearman-Warner May 5, 2011 Should Same-sex Marriages be Legalized? In recent news articles, it is being said that the legalization of same-sex marriages is imminent. But the biggest debate about the issue is should it be legalized? While there are many points that are for and against the issue, one thing remains. This is a legal issue on whether the law should be changed. When deciding whether a law should be changed, it should be viewed in a legal manner. Here is why same-sex marriages should be legalized in the United States of America. Part I: Thesis The United States of America was based on freedom. While each freedom was not spelled out in the constitution, it is something that can not be refuted. The Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines to marry as “to take a spouse or to unite in close and usually permanent relations” (Definition 2). While it is socially more accepted now than ever for same-sex couples to live together and even have children together, why are they being held back in receiving the freedom and benefits every opposite-sex couples receive? The right to be able to marry should be equal whether in same-sex couples or opposite-sex couples. Finkelstein (2011) points out that “marriage strengthens commitment between couples and therefore brings stability into the lives of those who enter in it”. If same-sex couples are able to cohabitate...

Words: 2266 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Marriage Divorce

...Leah Woodard APA THEO 202 B31 Anthropology: Marriage and Divorce The issue of marriage and divorce has become a very serious in America today, which is not exclusive to unbelievers. The percentage of Christian divorces is almost as high as those that are not believers. The question that can be asked is “Why?” My personal belief is that we as humans are suffering from a heart defect, which has caused a love deficit in our lives. Especially in the area of our personal relationships, with the primary being marital relations. We missed the glory that God wanted for the union of men and women. We are seeking to fix our heart defect with “love” from human relationships. This is the wrong way to fill our love defect. Only the Father, Son and Holy Spirit can and will do this for us. Keeping that love relationship in the center of your life will help and heal want needs healing. In today’s society too often, marriage is entered into with the idea of, “If this doesn’t work we can always get a divorce.” That way of thinking should be the first clue that you are not mature enough to be getting married, let alone it is not a loving thought for the other person. It is self-centered thinking. According to the Evangelical Dictionary of Theology, “Biblical teaching on marriage is epitomized in the statement,’ For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and they will become one flesh’”(Gen.2:24).(Elwell 2001) Marriage is an...

Words: 1299 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

A Day in the Life of a Kurd

...actual physical evidence of such. Being of a patrilineal lineage, the family centers around a male head and his immediate family. Depending on what type of nomads their family is, dictates what kind of patrilineal family they are. Xani is where the extended family lives under the same roof or in the family compound during their seasonal movement. Seminomadic households my share the same tent or compound which is called a Zoma. A zoma includes not just the extended family but the unmarried children, married male children with their families, any unmarried sisters as well. Although all of these people must be in relation to the male head of the family in order to stay in the Zoma. This sort of lineage depends on the mutual support and defense....

Words: 1908 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Right to Be Happy

...The Right to Be Happy By Michelle Evans English 101, Section QC Nov 7, 2014 Although DOMA (Defense of Marriage Act) has been overturned, there is however a lot more work to be done as far as equal rights for gay families all over the U.S. The Defense Marriage Act was originally passed in September 1996 and repealed in June 2013. This was wonderful news for the LGBT Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual & Transgender) community; however they are faced with a few more hurdles. Conservatives are now trying to make it impossible for same-sex couples to be able to adopt, essentially ruining any chances of having a family of their own. Two steps forward, 3 steps back… For decades, the laws against marriage equality have been tight and not in favor for same-sex couples. Conservatives felt and still feel that marriage should only be between a man and a woman and that being gay was not only a sin and an abomination, but also a lifestyle choice. It is also believed that gay unions should not have the same benefits as heterosexual ones. In the case of United States vs Windsor where two women whose marriage was legalized in New York, one of the parties passed away and the IRS denied federal estate tax marital deduction for the surviving spouse. The U.S. Supreme court found that DOMA violated the guarantee for equal protection and due process under the U.S. Constitution (Polikoff).Currently thirty-two out of fifty states now legalized same-sex unions. Unfortunately to this day...

Words: 1192 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Love

...Protestants, adults 55 and older, Southerners, and men. The groups showing the most ambiguity about such a same-sex marriage law, with between 51% and 53% in favor and 43% to 45% opposed, include Midwesterners, nonwhites, and adults aged 35 to 54. No Shift Since Court Decisions in General Support for Legalizing Gay Marriage In the same poll, Gallup asked a separate half-sample of Americans whether they think marriages between same-sex couples should be recognized as valid, with the same rights as traditional marriages. The 54% saying they should be recognized conforms with the 53% expressing the same view in May, and prior to that in November 2012. This is the first update of this Gallup trend since the Supreme Court struck down the Defense of Marriage Act in July,...

Words: 5897 - Pages: 24