Premium Essay

Is War Worth the Cost?

In:

Submitted By martihy
Words 1290
Pages 6
Combat High

In Sebastian Junger’s essay Combat High, he uses many techniques to effectively explain and support his arguments. He does this through his vivid and detailed descriptions of his experiences and tone of concern which makes him a credible writer. The reader is able to grasp an understanding of the techniques Junger utilizes to engage the reader and support his argument. In his essay, you can clearly establish where ethos, logos and pathos are being utilized to support his argument. In the following paragraphs we will pinpoint his use of these techniques to strengthen his argument and main points.
Sebastian purposely chooses to begin with his very vivid and detailed recollections of being on a hilltop with soldiers engaging in combat. He does this to strengthen his credibility as a writer and establishes an ethical approach to his argument in the rest of his essay. He begins with “Most of the fighting was at four or five hundred yards, so no one ever got to see- or had to deal with- the effects of all that firepower on the human body” (1). This instantly sets the tone for Sebastian’s essay. You can see his beliefs and stand point are challenged being at the hilltop with these American Soldiers and it causes him to question the ethics of the soldiers. For example, he writes “They watched until he stopped moving, and then they called in that he’d died. Everyone on Restrepo cheered. That night I couldn’t sleep, and I crept out of my bunk and went and sat on the roof of the ammo hooch.” This paragraph tells us of the enemy combatant dying alongside a mountain and all the men on Restrepo cheering when the enemy was pronounced dead. Junger was disturbed and didn’t understand why they would cheer over a human being vulnerable to their attack and eventually dying a slow and painful death alongside the mountain. This reaction seems to suggest that he cares

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Analysis: Was The Vietnam War Worth The Cost

...One big questions that linger in the mind of American Citizens is, was the Vietnam War worth the Cost? The Vietnam War is one of the most controversial wars in the United State of America’s history. The Vietnam War was started when South Vietnam seceded from communist North Vietnam. When North Vietnam attacked South Vietnam this resulted in a large war causing the US to get involved which was a huge mistake. The war resulted in hundreds of thousands dying. There are several reasons why we should not have gotten involved. The first of these reasons on why the Vietnam War was not worth the cost is what the cost on America was. When America entered the war mass anti-war riots broke out over the country as many people were opposed to our military...

Words: 416 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Military Draft System

...The American military plays a major part in keeping this country the way it is. The draft system was first used in the second World War, and as modern history shows (i.e. we're not under control by Germany or Japan), the system helped win us the war. However, drafting US citizens is not a reliable strategy. Many of the "soldiers" drafted during the last 3 wars using the system barely knew how to fire a gun. They had no prior military experience, and were certainly not ready to fight an opposing country head on. The draft system is not a reliable strategy for receiving more military personnel in modern times. The draft system is expenisve and simply not worth reinstating. "Mr. Hagel introduced a bill to permanently increase the Army by 30,000 enlistees, at an estimated cost of $3.9 billion" (Reynolds 1). Of course, no taxpayer wants to spend that insane amount of money on 30,000 recruits. Additionally, soldiers are expendable. The harsh truth is the military needs so many people, because they can't be sure that every single person is going to make it back, if any. Even if we succesfully train 1,000,000 soldiers with a lower cost, casualties happen. The draft system is too expensive to train a few thousand people to fight a war....

Words: 582 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Costs of War

...Rashad AbdulAzeem Research Paper ENG 101 6383 The Costs of War The history of war in America is rich and often causes more harm than seen at first glance. The effect is greater, in its reason, costs in death, and costs economically. In this paper I will examine the causes of and effects of war. I will try and expand on the question of whether it is needed in such a time man is grossly more able to avoid it. I will try and examine who profits from it and who does not, and then find a reasonable alternative to a seemingly repetitive process. A basic look at the history of war from the beginning of man brings much to light. Wars have always had a history of rewarding the soldier directly. There was war and there was the booty of war. The soldier had always directly benefited, today however is different the soldiers do not obtain wealth from war, the majority of the profits lie in the hands of a few who will more than likely never experience the journey that follows. In many ways the spending that went into the Civil War helped to spawn the modern corporation. This was something troubled President Abraham Lincoln near the end of the Civil War. In 1864 he wrote a letter to Col. William F. Elkins, “We may congratulate ourselves that this cruel war is nearing its end. It has cost a vast amount of treasure and blood. . . . It has indeed been a trying hour for the Republic; but I see in the near future a crisis approaching that unnerves...

Words: 2098 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Rewards: The Cost Of The American Revolution

...There are many costs and rewards to war, such as amount of deaths, post independence unstable economy, freedom, no more taxes, and new government. Overall, the costs of the American Revolution were worth the rewards because, although there were many downsides the colonies figured out a way to make everything function the way they needed it too. For example, one reward was a new government, because of the American Revolution we now have a stable government within our country. As the article states, “James Madison and other founding fathers got together in Philadelphia and wrote the United States Constitution the document that is the basis of Americans government. ” This shows that there were many important people taking charge of the government so they could work out a way to have a stable government. Overall, this is a vital reward that was one of the foremost reasons for which patriots fought for....

Words: 572 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Speech on War

...Speech on war War is often portrayed as a ‘need’ and people are labelled as unpatriotic if they aren’t pro-war, but what is patriotic about encouraging our soldiers to put themselves at danger for the sake of our own nations pride? War has been something that I have always disagreed with. I have done reports and essays on this topic and hours of research as well. The motive for war is not worth overall devastation that it causes and wars need to be stopped. War has a plethora of impacts that affect whole countries and individuals. A number of problems arise when there is a war – causalities, economic and environmental problems. How can you support a cause that is the reason for so much damage of our earth and its people? Death is something we all fear for ourselves, and our loved-ones. In a war, death is always prevalent and unavoidable. No conflict between nations could be worth the lives of our people; this is one of the many reasons wars need to be stopped. For a soldier that has been deployed death is always around the corner. In World War 2 (1939-1945) an estimated 60-85 million people were killed. That's more than triple the Australia population. And that's only one war; there has almost been a war every year for the past hundred years. There have been many different causes for war, all unnecessary. The Iraq War (2003-2011) was instigated over the assumption that Iraq possessed Weapons of Mass Destruction, putting America and its Allies in danger. After the invasion...

Words: 642 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Describe the Effects of Hyperinflation on Germany in 1923

...government. Many German people were unhappy with the new system, and preferred to be united under one strong leader. During World War I, the German government had a lot of bills to pay, and little money to do it with. So they printed more banknotes, which at first seems like an ideal solution. But this means the prices will rise, which leads to a demand for more wages, so production costs of items increase, so prices rise, more wages, and so on. This is called inflation, and a particularly bad case of it hit Germany called hyperinflation. After the war, the Weimar Republic ran up a lot more costs, so more banknotes were printed, which lead to hyperinflation, when the money was worth less than the paper it was printed on. Hyperinflation affected Germany and the citizens in a massive way. Prices of food and basic supplies rose by the hour. People sitting in a restaurant found that their second drink could cost twice as much as their first. Workers were paid up to three times a day. The wages would be collected in a wheelbarrow and taken down to the shops to be spent as quickly as possible, before prices rose any further. German money became worthless paper money had no value. The people who had been saving for years were affected quite badly, their savings became absolutely worthless. People on fixed incomes, such as pensions found that they became worth nothing. However the losses many Germans gained from the hyperinflation. People with property were making money, while those...

Words: 434 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Negative Impacts Of WW1 In Canada

...War is a horrible, destructive thing. What some people do not comprehend is, in war, consequences occur for everyone. Not only are the parties involved impacted, but almost everything else is influenced by the cancerous reach of war. The influence of war isn’t a positive thing either, everything can potentially be negatively impacted by its call, and for this, no war should be considered worth the effort. A good example of this is WW1, in which almost every aspect Canadian life was influenced by the war one way or another. WW1 lasted 4 years, and in this time period over 32 countries got involved in the conflict. Out of the countries the repercussions of the War affected, the primitive and young Canada suffered great negative impacts. One can...

Words: 1589 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Clausewitz in the 21st Century

...Strategy Research Project CLAUSEWITZ AND 21ST CENTURY WARFARE BY COLONEL CHRISTOPHER J. PAPAJ United States Marine Corps DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Approved for Public Release. Distribution is Unlimited. USAWC CLASS OF 2008 This SRP is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Master of Strategic Studies Degree. The views expressed in this student academic research paper are those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of the Department of the Army, Department of Defense, or the U.S. Government. U.S. Army War College, Carlisle Barracks, PA 17013-5050 Report Documentation Page Form Approved OMB No. 0704-0188 Public reporting burden for the collection of information is estimated to average 1 hour per response, including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. Send comments regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of information, including suggestions for reducing this burden, to Washington Headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and Reports, 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, Arlington VA 22202-4302. Respondents should be aware that notwithstanding any other provision of law, no person shall be subject to a penalty for failing to comply with a collection of information if it does not display a currently valid OMB control...

Words: 7711 - Pages: 31

Free Essay

Democratic Parties

...representing the Nation’s Democrats; he recently said that he is trying to balance hard head with a big heart. (Election 2008 P.48). Obama has planed many solutions to our current issues, on the health care issue according to Democrats. Org we will join 36 industrialized nations in making sure everyone has health care, starting by fixing the prescription drug program and investing in stem cell and other medical research. America right now is at a very critical situation from whatever point we look at. We are struggling economically, which is making America suffer in many ways. We have millions of illegal immigrants who contribute so much to our nation, but yet they are in a dark shadow where we do not see a close light to this issue. The war, we’ve had so many innocent Americans fighting for our country and giving their lives I thing it’s unfair. One of our major issues is the illegal immigration, “the current system makes criminals out of some 12 million people who only want to work hard on whose efforts large parts of the economy now depend.” (Bush Baiting). We also have thousands of young people who need to go to school, because America’s youth is what going to make this country more successful. If we do not help the young people get their immigration paperwork done, then we do not know what will happen to the country’s future. According to Dream Act website, the Dream Act is a bill that applies to over 60,000 illegal immigrants who finish high school, but cannot proceed...

Words: 2256 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Le300F

...The poem I chose is “The Hesitating Veteran” by Ambrose Bierce. I believe this poem takes you through each stage of the war. Where in the beginning he had faith in the Union and what they were fighting for. But, as the war continued and men from both sides were dying in mass numbers, doubt started to creep in. Many soldiers began to question if the cause of the war out weighed the cost of the war. Was it worth to continue to see young men die and the living having to bury the dead without a proper burial? As the war ended Bierce describes how the “black chap” got his freedom but, was still not allowed to vote. Something that all free white men are able to do. But, the line that stood out to me was the last one, “I know what uniform I wore – O, that I knew what side I fought for!” I guess it stands out because it is almost as he is unsure of the war was worth it. Both sides lost so many men, one side fighting for a sovereign national government and to end slavery; while the other wanted to keep slavery and be sovereign states. "The Hesitating Veteran." The Hesitating Veteran. Accessed September 13, 2015. http://www.civilwarpoetry.org/union/postwar/bierce.html. During the fall and summer of 1918 the British Expeditionary Force would experience breakdown in review of battles and encounters to reveal British and Dominion culture. Silbey would compare the Canadian Corps, the New Zealand Division, and the Australian Imperial Force. He would describe how nationalism affected their...

Words: 391 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Economics

...|Movie |Original Year Released |Unadjusted Gross Income | |(in order of ranking) | | | | Avatar |2009 |$759,592,778.00 | |Titanic |1997 |$600, 788,188 | |The Dark Night |2008 |$533,184,219.00 | |Star Wars: Episode IV – A New Hope |2008 |$460,998,007.00 | |Shrek 2 |2004 |$437,212,000.00 | |E.T the Extra-Terrestrial |1982 |$434,974,579.00 | |Star Wars: Episode I- The Phantom |1999 |$431,088,301.00 | |Menace | | | |Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's|2006 |$423,416,000.00 | |Chest | | | |Toy Story 3 |2010 |$413,638,013.00 | |Spider-Man...

Words: 857 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The War on Drugs: a Losing Battle?

...In 1968, when American soldiers came home from the Vietnam war addicted to heroin, President Richard Nixon initiated the War on Drugs. More than a decade later, President Ronald Reagan launches the South Florida Drug Task force, headed by then Vice-President George Bush, in response to the city of Miami’s demand for help. In 1981, Miami was the financial and import central for cocaine and Marijuana. Thanks to the task force, drug arrests went up by 27%, and drug seizures went up by 50%. With that, the need for prosecutors and judges also rose which helped boost our economy (Thirty Years of America’s Drug War). Despite these increased arrests and seizures, marijuana and cocaine still poured into south Florida. At this stage, the root of the problem was the Columbian Cartels, and they weren't attacked; the DEA (Drug Enforcement Agency) soon realized that they needed to suppress the cartels. In 1982, the DEA went to Columbia to eradicate fields of marijuana and coca plants; these fields were located and burned. The hard part now, was finding the labs used to turn the coca leaves into cocaine. These labs were in very remote locations, to avoid any surveillance. On March 10,1984 the DEA finally was able to track down the chemicals used to process cocaine in one of the labs, they seized twelve tons of cocaine; it was the DEA’s biggest take down yet. Despite the DEA’s hard word and efforts the availability of cocaine on American streets remained the same. The Cartel leaders had money...

Words: 1636 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Benefits Of A Penny

...For years, there has been a heated debate about the lincoln faced one cent piece that we all know as the penny, and if it should stop being minted. There has been countless arguments about if the penny should stop being minted, people want the penny to stop being minted due to it being heavy and hard to carry, the coin itself not being worth enough, but, the biggest and the most real argument for the penny to stop being produced is this, it costs the U.S. thousands and millions to produce pennies every year, we lose this kind of money every year because it costs more to actually mint the penny than the penny is actually worth. It costs 1.5 cents to create a penny, to quote one of my sources, Penny Wise, or 2.4 Cents Foolish? by Jeff Sommer, it says, “‘From the standpoint of economics, that’s just a total waste of money,’ Mr. Velde says.”....

Words: 573 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Budgets

...nation’s understanding of national security in the coming decade. Recommendation: You should frame the debate as between two choices for U.S. defense policy. One approach would pursue relatively modest savings from additional efficiencies but stay within the parameters of existing national security strategy. The second approach would change that strategy in important ways, or otherwise seek fairly dramatic changes in how the Department of Defense goes about implementing its global responsibilities. Within that framing, you should argue for the first approach that, while difficult, is worth attempting given the nation’s fiscal plight. The risks associated with the second approach would not be worth the benefits. Background: The 10-year cuts already mandated from the 2011 Budget Control Act will reduce the budgets of the armed forces by $350 billion. These figures do not include war costs or Veterans Affairs budgets. Sequestration, like the Simpson-Bowles and Rivlin-Domenici deficit reduction commissions of 2010, would cut another $500 billion or so over ten years. Your administration’s current military plan incorporates those assumed cuts from the first round of the Budget Control Act (though not from possible sequestration). It will scale down the military from...

Words: 559 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Summary: The Great Emancipator

...INVESTIGATIVE TEAM MEETING 1 WAS SLAVERY THE PRIMARY CAUSE OF THE CIVIL WAR? During the nineteenth century, slavery was the leading cause of the Civil War, due to differing views on this subject between the Northern and Southern states. The whole debate on slavery began during the Lincoln-Douglas Debate time period when Lincoln and Douglas debated on the Kansas-Nebraska Act stating that the state could choose for themselves the position their state was in for slavery. However, he was countered on his opinion when the Dred-Scott Decision passed through court that denied African American rights to be a citizen. This divided the country into further political parties which included Radical Abolitionists and “Fire-Eaters”, two extreme groups that fought for their beliefs on slavery. These political parties drove citizens to form strong beliefs and therefore split the country into two sides – the North and the South, the Free and the Slaves States, and the Republicans and the Democrats. INVESTIGATIVE TEAM MEETING 2 DOES LINCOLN DESERVE TO BE CALLED THE “GREAT EMANCIPATOR?”...

Words: 776 - Pages: 4