Premium Essay

Leadership and Management Style Analysis

In:

Submitted By ThePoet
Words 2073
Pages 9
Leadership and Management.

.’’ The need for leaders has always been important, and it has never been more urgent. The constant, accelerating, unpredictable change in today’s competitive environment demands more and better leadership. People at all organizational levels and in all sectors want to be inspired. (Blank, Warren 2001)

In order to discuss leadership and management we must first recognize that they are in fact the two are different but linked. In essence it could be said that the managers role is to plan, while the leader inspires. The manager organizes while the leader motivates staff including the manager.

“There is (has and probably always will be) a debate about the differences and overlaps of leadership and management. Current opinion is that they are different concepts but they overlap considerably.”

(Adair, John; Thomas, Neil (Editor). p 118.)

In his book “On Becoming a Leader,” Warren Bennis listed what he considered to be the differences between the two:

Manager Leader
Administer Innovates
Maintains Develops
Focuses on structures and systems Focuses on people
Relies on control Relies and inspires trust
Asks how and when Asks what and why
Imitates Originates
Accepts the status quo Challenges the status quo
Does things right Does the right thing

As we have seen the development of leadership and management over time it could be argued that in the past the two did not go hand in hand, In the past the manager of a factory may not have given consideration what was being built or made or who was making it but in the modern economy what Druker identified was the emergence of the knowledge worker and the differences that this would mean to the modern workforce With the rise of the knowledge worker, “one does not ‘manage’ people,” Mr. Drucker wrote. “The task is to lead people. And the goal is to make productive the specific

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Brief

...|Assessor name | | |Assignment title |Leadership Observation and Reflection | | |Scenario: | | |Leaders are made, they are not born. We can learn much from observing their behaviors as well as reflecting from | | |our own experiences. In this assignment, you can choose from following options: | | |Option 1: Reflecting on your own leadership experience. It can be your team work at school or any other activities | | |in which you have led others to fulfill a particular task(s) or objective(s). You will need to analyze your own | | |leadership style and its impact. | | |Option 2: Observing and analyzing leadership styles from the staffing simulation we have done in the assignment 1. | | |In this...

Words: 1031 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Leadership Styles and Organizational Behavior

...Running head: Relating Leadership Styles to Organizational Behavior 1 By Keta Johnson A Paper Submitted to Dr. Wanda Corner In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for BTM7001: Advanced Scholarly WritingError occured in marking Attendance. Some error occurred. Please try again. Error occurred in getting Attendance data. Advanced Scholarly Writingjhkkk Northcentral University Doctor of Philosophy in Business Administration Specialization in Public Administration September 14, 2014 Running head: Relating Leadership Styles to Organizational 2 Relating Leadership Styles to Organizational Behavior Numerous studies have been conducted to demonstrate the various relationships between managers and subordinates. The purpose of this paper is to discuss a critical analysis of peer-reviewed articles in which researchers have addressed various leadership styles and how it affects employees. The literature review section will provide an analysis of the theoretical framework and case studies presented by authors. After analyzing the articles, the discussion and findings section will offer conclusions that can be drawn from the results; and also provide an interpretation of what the findings from the scholarly studies mean. The recommendations section will then identify what organizational leaders can do to address the gaps and/or the organizational leadership issues related to the literature review and discussion. Lastly, the conclusion section...

Words: 2423 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Role of Different Approaches to Management and Leadership

...THE ROLE OF DIFFERENT APPROACHES TO MANAGEMENT AND LEADERSHIP HND Business Level 5 21rd June 2012 THE ROLE OF DIFFERENT APPROACHES TO MANAGEMENT AND LEADERSHIP AC2.1: Leadership Styles Introduction Concisely, leadership refers to the process through which a person manages to influence others in a coherent and cohesive manner so that they can accomplish a certain objective. Leadership practice depends on four factors namely leader, followers, communication, and situation. To a certain extent, leadership practice is closely related to management but there are certain differences that set the two organisational necessities apart. In the traditional thinking present in all organisations, leadership separates the roles of a manager from those of a leader. The rationale behind this is that managers are people who operate under control; they administer through focusing on already existing structures and systems. However, there must be a balance between both management and leadership demands for the optimal survival of any organisation. Both leaders and managers are vital for the positive performance and success of an organisation. Leadership skills model a way forward while management skills enable arriving at a set target. This means that striking a balance between leadership and management demands in an organisation requires an effective leader to carry good management skills and similarly, an effective...

Words: 3724 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

The Relationship Between Leadership Styles and Employees Commitment

...THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN LEADERSHIP STYLES AND EMPLOYEES COMMITMENT IN EAST AFRICA BOTTLING S.C (COCA-COLA) A TERM PAPER: THE COURSE OF ADVANCED ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR AND DESIGN BY: SIRAK TEFERI ……….…. MKMW/601/06 SUBMITTED TO: TESFAYE SEMELA (Professor) The Relationship Between Leadership Styles and Employees Commitment Table of Contents 1. INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................................................................1 1.1. SIGNIFICANCE OF THE TERM PAPER ON THE STUDY OF ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAIVOR ...................................................................................................................................................................2 1.2. IMPLICATIONS OF THE STUDY TO MARKETING MANAGEMENT. .........................................3 1.3. ORGANIZATION OF THE TERM PAPER ................................................................................................3 2. MAIN BODY OF THE TERM PAPER .................................................................................................................4 2.1. THEORETICAL LITERATURE .....................................................................................................................4 2.1.1. The Concept of Leadership .................................................................................................................4 2.1.2. The Development of Leadership Theories ..................

Words: 7456 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Rough Guy

...Graduate School of Management Behaviors at Work and Psychology Organizational Behavior Segment English Track Year 2 Dr. Joseph C. Santora, Affiliated Faculty October-November 2013 Course Module Description This 12 hour organizational behavior segment of Behaviors at Work and Psychology focuses on leadership. It begins with a definition of leadership, differentiates the concepts of leadership and management, offers insights about leadership traits, and ends with a discussion about various leadership styles. Lecture, discussion, case analyses and experiential exercises are instructional methods used in this highly interactive module. Objectives 1. To establish a definition of leadership through a historical review. 2. To differentiate between the concepts of management and leadership. 3. To present trait theory and discuss various leadership traits. 4. To evaluate and analyze the different styles leaders use. 5. To apply leadership concepts through case study analyses and experiential exercises. . Session 1 Introductions: Personal and Team Arrangements Powerpoint Presentation: Leadership Activity: Moon Survival (do not complete) Case Analysis: Barry Town: A time to lead, a time to manage (read) Video Vignette: Xerox and Ann Mulcahy (do not read) Session 2 Powerpoint Presentation: Leadership Traits In-class...

Words: 285 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

A Research on the Influence of Leadership Style and Job Characteristics on

...A Research on the Influence of Leadership Style and Job Characteristics on Job Performance among Accountants of County and City Government in Taiwan By Li-Chuan Chu, PhD, and Chun-Che Lai The objectives of this paper are to explore the effect of leadership style and job characteristics on job performance and examine the mediating effect of organization commitment on the leadership style, the job characteristics and the job performance as weii as to provide the management suggestions according the research findings. The questionnaires are appiied to the accountants of county/city government in Taiwan, and the convenience sampiing is adopted. The foiiowing research findings are described after conducting the statisticai anaiyses. Firstiy, this research finds that the more idealized infiuence for the county/city mayor is, the stronger abiilty of problem soiving for the associated accountants are. in addition, the better management by exception conducted by the mayor, the more abiiity of probiem soiving for accountants exists, and therefore the higher passion of innovation happens. Secondiy, this research also reveals that the more job autonomy, job importance, and job diversity happen, the stronger abiiity of probiem solving for the accountants are. Besides, the higher job autonomy for accountants exists, the higher passion of innovation happens. The mediating effect of organization commitment was found between transformationai ieadership and job performance, it indicates that...

Words: 3181 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Leadership and Management

...The relationship between managers' leadership styles and emergency medical technicians' job satisfaction Azimeh Ghorbanian,1 Mohammadkarim Bahadori,2* and Mostafa Nejati3 1. School of Management and Medical Information Sciences, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran 2. Health Management Research Centre, Baqiyatallah University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran 3. School of Management, Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM), Malaysia Corresponding Author: Mohammadkarim Bahadori Health Management Research Centre, Baqiyatallah University of medical Sciences Tehran Iran Email: moc.liamg@htlaehirodahab Author information ► Copyright and License information ► Copyright © Australasian Medical Journal This article has been cited by other articles in PMC. Go to: ------------------------------------------------- Abstract Background/Aims Leadership plays a crucial role in many professions, especially in challenging positions such as emergency medical service jobs. The purpose of this study was to explore the relationship between managers' leadership styles and emergency medical technicians' job satisfaction. Method This is a descriptive and cross-sectional study that was carried out in 2010. The research population included 21 managers and 87 emergency medical technicians working in 23 stations in Isfahan city, Iran. The main tools used for data accumulation were the Multiple Leadership Questionnaire for evaluating leadership styles and the Job Descriptive Index for...

Words: 3344 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

None

...THE IMPACT OF LEADERSHIP STYLES ON JOB STRESS AND TURNOVER INTENTION – TAIWAN INSURANCE INDUSTRY AS AN EXAMPLE Hsien-Che Lee Department of Business Management, Tatung University 40 ,Sec 3,Chung-Shan N. Rd, Taiwan City, Taiwan ROC hclee@ttu.edu.tw Tsai-Hua Chuang Student of Graduate School of Management, Tatung University 40 ,Sec 3,Chung-Shan N. Rd, Taiwan City, Taiwan ROC teresa5797@yahoo.com.tw ABSTRACT For recent years, Taiwan has stepped into an aging society. Life insurance and retirement planning which have quite a lot to do with insurance industry are questions of interest. The insurance industry focuses on close contact among clients, sales people and managers. That is a human-oriented industry, for which the experienced leaders inspire the sales people through continuous training and encouragement and lead them by vision. Therefore, leader’s leadership type is the critical factor for the success of the organization. This research explores the relationships among leader’s leadership style, subordinate’s personality characteristic, and job stress and turnover intention. We also identify the role of the variable of personality characteristic and job stress respectively. We use convenient sampling method to collect data. In pretest, 50 copies of questionnaires are sent to employees of M insurance company, for which 46 valid ones are returned, And then, a total of 220 copies of...

Words: 5811 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Leadership Task 1

...Running Head: Leadership Skills Analysis Leadership Skills Analysis Competency 325.1 Running Head: Leadership Skills Analysis As I reviewed all the different leadership styles within our e-text I came to the conclusion that my individual leadership agenda is most congruent with the participative style. " Sharing decision making with group members and working with them side by side has become the generally accepted leadership approach in the modern organization" (DuBrin, 2009, p. 113). As a leader, I strive to make an effort to extract thoughts and opinions from my team members when making major decisions that impact the team as a whole with my chosen leadership style. Participative, also referred to as consensus, leadership allows managers to evaluate and integrate the whole picture within their role allowing for a more unified approach to decision-making. Thorough assessment of my team members’ leadership styles, I have chosen to compare the styles of Delegation and Problem-Solving. (… effective leaders who are good at problem solving,[->0] skilled at managing the balance between openness and decisiveness)”. (Beck &Yeager, 2001). Problem Solvers hope to maintain a balance between sincerity and conclusiveness. The Delegator utilizes a different leadership approach. “What leaders often...

Words: 802 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Literature Survey on Job Satisfaction

...LITERATURE SURVEY On Job Satisfaction and Leadership Berikut merupakan survei literatur tentang faktor-faktor yang menentukan kepuasan kerja. Kepuasan kerja dan motivasi dipengaruhi secara positif oleh variabel pengakuan dan penghargaan dengan dimensi sebagai berikut: peluang promosi, prosedur operasi, pekerjaan itu sendiri, pengakuan, relasi dengan rekan kerja, kepuasan terhadap kompensasi, rasa aman, supervisor, dan pengembangan karier (Danis & Usman, 2010). Kepuasan kerja juga berkorelasi positif dengan keadilan organisasional: keadilan distributif, prosedural, interaksional (Al-Zu’bi, 2010). Pada perusahaan dengan tingkat upah yang rendah dan tingkat kepuasan karyawan sedang, kontribusi faktor-faktor kepuasan kerja paling besar ditentukan oleh faktor rekan sekerja, lingkungan kerja, dan pemimpin, tetapi paling rendah oleh faktor upah dan tunjangan (Salviah, 2002). Persepsi karyawan terhadap keadilan kompensasi memiliki korelasi yang signifikan terhadap kepuasan kerjanya (Astuti, 2001) Kebalikannya dari kepuasan kerja karyawan tingkat operasional, Batthi (20010) stres ditentukan 67% oleh faktor di dalam organisasi (beban kerja, waktu kerja, kepemimpinan, kebijakan perusahaan, kondisi kerja) dan 33% faktor di luar organisasi (kondisi ekonomi, keluarga karyawan, cuaca). Selain faktor di atas, salah satu yang perlu diketahui oleh pemimpin adalah seberapa besar pengaruh kepemimpinan, gaya kepemimpinan, dan spiritualitas pemimpin terhadap kepuasan kerja. Penelitian Aydin dan...

Words: 1501 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Leadership

...Leadership Development Plan GM 592: Leadership in the 21st Century Contents Purpose of Study 3 Background Analysis 3 Literature Review 4 Benchmark Analysis 7 SWOT Analysis 8 Proposed Action Plan and Implementation Timeline 9 Potential Impact of Current Trends 10 References 11 Purpose of Study I currently work for CDM Resource Management. I am a Capital Asset Manager and currently the only one for our company, due to the number of customers we have at the time. I have been with CDM Resource Management since May 2010. During this time I assist other companies in improving their persistence rate putting them as an improved company. While I was assisting the other company I knew CDM Resource Management was going to add another company and I decided then I wanted to be a part of that company to ensure that company would be successful. While this was transpiring CDM Resource Management decided to change our positions to coincide with other positions in the industry. Being at CDM Resource Management I know there is a possibility of growth for me. In previous positions prior to CDM Resource Management I was never in a leadership role however I was in charge of various projects and even an administrative assistant group which I established at one of my previous projects. Through taking this class and other leadership type courses I expect to become an awesome leader. Background Analysis Working in oil and gas industry you are faced with many...

Words: 1916 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Impact of Leadership Styles on Quality Management in Health Care

...The Impact of leadership Styles on Quality Management in Health care Effective and strong leadership is one of, if not the most important and critical component for any organization’s success, particularly in health care facilities. Leadership also plays a major role in enhancing an organization’s competitiveness as confirmed by various academics (Rowe, 2001; Riaz & Haider, 2010). Many argue and suggest that there is a connection between an organization’s leadership style and its ability to implement and manage quality initiatives. That being said, researchers still encounter difficulties when assessing the effect of leadership styles on healthcare quality management, as most of the available theories were developed outside of healthcare setting. This paper aims to present an evaluation and a review of published scholarly articles discussing three styles of leadership and their association with quality management initiatives. The three leadership styles chosen for this evaluation are: Transformational leadership, servant leadership, and situational leadership. The paper will also describe my current leadership style, then compare it to the transformational model, and finally outline the changes I need to implement in order to incorporate its key characteristics into my own style. Research Summaries In the first article titled “Knowledge Management as a Mediator for the Efficacy of Transformational Leadership and Quality Management Initiatives in U.S. Health Care”...

Words: 1313 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Unit 4 Diagnostic Intervention - Hrmt620

...Unit 4 – Diagnostics and Interventions Name Colorado Technical University Strategic Human Capital Management HRMT620-1603A-3 May 2, 2016 Instructor Dr. Eric Riley Introduction The report being provided is an overview of the change management plan for AGC. The document will give an outline of activities that will encompass the program. All activities described have been developed based on the current state of AGC’s business events. Diagnostics and Interventions Organizations aggressively obtain and reinvest in assets. This concept is considered important to organizations for their long-term growth and to maintain a competitive advantage. The investment in human capital is often ignored. Human capital strategies have become an essential element that requires an aggressive approach to enable the organization to maintain a competitive advantage. The process of implementing a human capital management plan can be tedious but, for an organization to thrive in today's markets, it is a vital part of the business model and strategy. White states, “Human capital assessment is an increasingly essential element of organizational performance” (White, 2007). Human capital can be more valuable than the physical assets of the organization. Organizations go to great expense to train and hire associates who are trained and qualified to meet the organization's objectives. The value of implementation will become evident when efficiency, productivity, participation, and employee...

Words: 2156 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Patch 3: Leadership & Strategic Change – Case (Managing Change at Faslane)

...PATCH 3: Leadership & Strategic Change – Case (Managing change at Faslane) Consultative & Coercive Collaborative Consultative & Coercive Collaborative TASK B: Table 6: Competence Analysis of Faslane Competence Analysis | | Up to 2001 | 2002-2010 | Physical Resources | * Well-equipped infrastructure. * Concentrated on infrastructure and facilities. | * All infrastructure are properly operated, enhance operational effectiveness and cost saving. * From infrastructure focus to naval focus. | Financial Resources | * Government budget from taxpayers’ money was not used properly | * Minimized the spending without affect the operational performance. | Human Resources | * Staffs were experienced but unable to utilize properly in management. | * Experienced management team. * Encourage employees participation. | Intellectual Capital | * Home of UK’s nuclear submarines. | * Management expert turned as a home base for entire UK submarines fleet. * Holistic management style. | Source: Johnson, G., Scholes, K., Whittington, R. and Johnson, G. (2011). Exploring strategy. Harlow: Financial Times Prentice Hall. Table 7: McKinsey’s Seven S Model of Faslane (2001-2010) | Strength | Weakness | Hard Elements | Strategy | * Improved performance and efficiency, maintaining good quality services with cost savings * Speeded up decision making process by reducing the review time to 6 days | * Cost saving might cause poor...

Words: 1068 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Managing Work and People

...The Regency Grand Hotel Case Study: A Managerial and Socio-cultural Approach ------------------------------------------------- | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Executive Summary This analysis reviews the case study of The Regency Grand Hotel following a recent change in the upper management and implementation of a new organisational strategy which has led to the performance deterioration and the increase in customer complaints. The problems are analysed in light of a diverse range of theories and scholarly views regarding the impact of potential factors on organisational performance and profitability foresights. Through theoretical and empirical research, the authors have focused on leadership styles, and the cultural and societal values to analyse the problems at The Regency Grand Hotel. The analysis undertaken brought about a wider and clearer image of the situation both as a whole (macro) and in terms of dissected attributes (micro). The macro problem revolves around cultural differences and imposition of a participative leadership style that did not associate with the socio-cultural dimensions of the organisation. In essence, the case study lead to a common platform entitling that cultural backgrounds and societal factors are the most important factors to be considered before enforcing any managerial strategy. Moreover, a certain level of hierarchy is quiet indispensable in organisations...

Words: 3709 - Pages: 15