Free Essay

Losing Faith

In:

Submitted By AshleyRae
Words 1770
Pages 8
Ashley Freeman
Dr. Wallace
English 1302
29 November 2013
Losing Faith
There were a lot of Jewish people who had a large faith in humanity or in what we all called God and Elie Wiesel was one of them. Their faith in humanity ended up being lost during the second Great War, which is commonly known as War World II. Though, after the war and after they were saved by the Allies, little by little their faith in humanity and God slowly came back. Even the truest believers, like Elie Wiesel, can lose their faith in all of humanity and even who they call God, but once you are shown even a slightest bit of kindness, you can gain it all back.
In the very beginning of Elie Wiesel’s novel, Night, based off his experiences during the World War II, all he wanted was someone to help him in his studies of the Kabbalah. Even though his father thought him to be too young that did not stop Elie from pursuing his dreams. He ended up finding a teacher for his studies of the Kabbalah in Moishe the Beadle. Elie was not the only Jewish child whose studies meant a lot to him. David Weiss Halivini was another child who had big dreams and an even larger faith. He had a dream of being a rabbi of a small village in the Carpathian Mountains (Fox). Though he had to put his dreams on hold after the Germans came and put his family into the ghettos, just like Elie’s family. Also like Elie, he continued with his studies, not wanting to put his dreams on hold because he was moved into a ghetto. Not only did Jewish families have a strong faith in humanity, but Germans who were a part of the Hitler’s army had a strong faith in the war. In the book and movie, The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, Bruno’s mother had an extreme belief that all Jewish people were bad and that the German soldiers were doing a great thing. She did not care that she had to move her children away from their friends and school for her husband’s job, since he was a soldier. In the movie, The Pianist, Wladyslaw Szpilman still had faith that there was good people out there that would help him survive. Back to Elie’s life, he started to lose his faith in the labor camps.
The first time Elie faith was failing him was his father and his first day in Birkenau, when they both thought that they were about to be cremated. This was the first time he had ever felt anger towards the Almighty. During his time in Auschwitz, he ceased praying; he still believe that God existed but he did not believe in his absolute justice anymore. Another strong reason for the depletion of his faith was when he and some other prisoners saw the hanging of a young boy. A lot of the prisoners asked where God was, since he had allowed the hanging of the little boy to happen. In David Weiss Halivini’s case, he started to lose his faith after he was separated from his family in Auschwitz. The work was hard on a boy and his faith started to fade. When Bruno’s mother realized what was happening to the Jewish people in the concentration camp by their house, she did not want to believe it. She did not think that even the Jewish community should be burned to death; and her faith was completely gone after her son Bruno snuck into the camp and was by accident gassed to death. During The Pianist when Wladyslaw was hiding in that house and the German soldier had found him, he was scared. After Wladyslaw had showed the soldier where he was staying and the soldier had left, Wladyslaw cried himself to sleep because he thought the solider was going to turn him in. In another true story, a son of two Jewish people who lived and survived during the holocaust tells of what happened to his parents. Menachem Daum talks about how his mother lost her faith. Fela Nussbaum Daum tells her son how she had a strong faith in God as she was pulling into Auschwitz. She had arrived with her sister and an infant son. To save her life, she would have to give up her child instead of going into the gas chambers. Giving up her child made her lose her complete faith in humanity and she never recovered from that (Abernethy). Betty Gold, another survivor from the holocaust, who had watched her own cousin kill her child to keep the Nazi soldiers from finding them, which had also happened in the movie The Pianist. After the war, she had ended up losing her faith. She just could not figure out how there could be a God who would allow the massacre of her Jewish community (Fillmore). Another true story was of David Bram. He was a non-observant Jew and he did not have a strong belief to begin with to lose (Fox). Once winter had arrived for Elie, he ended up having to go to the infirmary where the doctor had to perform surgery. He stayed in the infirmary until someone told him that the Russians were coming. His father and Elie left with the rest of the camp; and his faith was still low.
David Bram, who left his family to work in hope of seeing them again, work hard at his job the Nazi’s gave him. “He survived the Poznan, Breslau, Gross-Rosen labor camps; and Auschwitz-Birkenau, and Ebensee concentration camps.” The reason why David worked as hard as he did in hope of seeing his family again but he ended up gaining faith in God and in May 1945, he was liberated by United States troops (Fox). The way that Betty Gold had gained her faith back was through the way of marriage and children. She was raised in the Orthodox tradition and returned to her faith as a Conservative Jew (Fillmore). Now, she feels free to talk about what happened to her and her family during the war. Another true story was Menachem Daum, whose mother never regained his faith. His father, Moshe Yosef Daum, had never once lost his faith in God. He believed that you no matter need faith in life to live, even with all of the unanswered questions that they had (Abernethy). In the movie, The Pianist, Wladyslaw had gained a new faith in German humanity because Captain Wilm Hosenfeld had helped keep him alive. Wladyslaw had tried to go and save him after the war, but he could not find out where the Russians took them. Captain Wilm Hosenfeld had ended up dying in the labor camp he was taken to after the war. The Boy in the Stripped Pajamas, is a book and movie in which Bruno’s mother, and even his father and sister, who would never believe that war was justice since Bruno ended up dying in a Jewish concentration camp. David Weiss Halivini’s faith was easily gained back when he saw a guard eating a sandwich wrapped in a piece of the Jewish religious text. He had asked the guard nicely for the bletl and was given the page. David and some of the others prisoners study the page in secret every night. Not only did that page help David gain his faith back but the bletl gave all of them the energy to continue to work in the labor camps. Even after more and more people out of his group were dying, he was asked if he still believed in God. David’s answer was yes because without God, this war would be even crueler than it already was (Fox). Even after the Elie was saved by the American troops in Buchenwald, he still did not have his faith back. Now, after he has wrote his novel Night, he has been interviewed by many people, Robert E. Douglas Jr. is one of them. They always asked him if he has gained his faith back. Elie’s answer when Robert asked him was that he was still questioning his faith. He knows that his relationship is different now, he does not have the same relationship before the holocaust but he still has questions. Where they used to be why he would pray, these now do not have any answers. The answers have to come from God and not from men, which was what Moishe the Beadle tried to tell Elie at the beginning of the war (Douglas).
Even though there were a lot of Jewish people who had a strong belief system before the Great War and they were not the only who believed in God and humanity. The Germans also believed in God and humanity, but they thought that the war was a completely justified. During the war, a lot of Jewish and non-Jewish people lost their faith in what they were fighting to achieve. Whether it was for there to be no more Jewish people on this earth or to still believe in God and humanity, they were not going to stop trying to win. After the war, some gained their faith, while other are either still questioning or they were never going to believe in God again. Just because someone had the strongest belief system before the war, that war was so cruel that it would be hard to still have that faith; but no matter what all they need to do is try and maybe they can gain a little of that faith back. Bibliography:
Abernethy, Bob. "Holocaust Survivors: The Search for Faith." PBS. PBS, 20 Apr. 2001. Web. 15 Nov. 2013. .
The Boy in the Stripped Pajamas. Dir. Mark Herman. By John Boyne. Screenplay by Mark Herman. Perf. Asa Butterfield and Jack Scanlon. Miramax Films, BBC Films, Heyday Films, 2008. DVD.
Douglas, Robert E., Jr. "Elie Wiesel's Relationship with God." Elie Wiesel's Relationship with God. Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements of the Humanities Sufficiency Program Worcester Polytechnic Institute, n.d. Web. 15 Nov. 2013. .
Fillmore, Janet. "A Voice Unsilenced: Holocaust Survivor Betty Gold Tells Her Story so Young People Understand." Cleveland.com. Northeast Ohio Media Group LLC.. 7 Nov. 2008. Web. 27 Nov. 2013. .
Fox, Josh. "Survivors Preserving the Religion During the Holocaust." 2000 Holocaust Remembrance Project. N.p., 2000. Web. 14 Nov. 2013. .
The Pianist. Dir. Roman Polanski. By Wladyslaw Szpilman. Screenplay by Ronald Harwood. Perf. Adrien Brody and Thomas Kretschmann. R.P. Productions, Heritage Films, and Studio Babelsberg, 2002. DVD.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

I Believe in God

...different views about God and gone through different paths that can lead us to different beliefs about this subject. Although I’ve had a tough childhood I believe in God. In the past and even now, I still ask myself how God can take away the people who you love and care for the most. I lost my older brother five years ago. I remember losing faith in God, hating and yelling, why he would hurt me and family like this? What did we do to deserve something like this? Throughout time I learned that we all have different fates, and what we go through makes us what we are today. God has made me a stronger person, I understood that everything we go through can either break us or make us. The wound of losing my brother may never heal, but believing in god and in heaven has me at peace. I believe that once we pass we go to heaven. This gives me a certain kind of peace and hope of one day seeing my brother again. Today, and always I live to make my brother proud, I live day by day and make the best of it every day. You never know when you can lose someone or have your own life taken away. God has written a story for each one of us, we just have to believe and have faith in...

Words: 294 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Hero Quotation Analysis

...Hero Quotation Analysis Pi Patel’s love for religion is strange but at the same time commendable. My personal views on religion are neutral in the sense that it doesn’t bother me as long as it’s not affecting me. Others can believe whatever it is that they need to believe, as long as they don’t harm anyone and are not forceful towards others with their beliefs. In the quote I chose from part one of Life of Pi, Pi talks about the lack of freedoms religion seems to have: “I know zoos are no longer in people's good graces. Religion faces the same problem. Certain illusions about freedom plague them both.” (Martel 14). I’ve always seen religion exactly like that, freedomless and restricting of its believers. I came to this by observing the difference between the people in my life who have a strong connection to go compared to those who don’t. At only a few months old I was baptised. My parents themselves are not very religious, both growing up in catholic families and going to catholic schools they chose to leave religion behind them with school. My grandparents on the other hand and devout Catholics, mother’s mother lives for the church, lives for God and lives for the Bible. Being baptised wasn’t something that bothered me until I became old enough to know what it meant. At church, I was accepted but I was unable to do the things everyone else around me was doing because I hadn’t had my first communion. That rule made me uncomfortable, it sparked my dislike for church. Over...

Words: 708 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Tanya Luhrmann's The God Delusion

...I am a student at Carleton College, and for a class I was asked to read a section of your novel The God Delusion. I have read sections of it before during personal crises of faith, and you’ve made some fascinating points, there is one, unfortunately, that I feel must be addressed and reconsidered. The idea that religion is a form of mental illness. With that argument were two faulty points that could be reworded or reconsidered. The idea that religion arrived through a neurological accident that genetically drifted throughout the population. That your view is inherently true, and without question the best and and most logical. First, your view of the cause of religion. I admit that I cannot argue against your view’s possibility, but that it is unlikely and relies on faulty reasoning. If religion evolved as an accident, as all other biological processes did from a purely scientific standpoint, then the fact that it took up a major biological dominance over the population is highly unlikely to be caused by genetic drift alone. While it is possible, you seem to ignore the possibility that religion has a survival benefit for...

Words: 1178 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Assumption

...we all know that there is evil in this world. It does not matter if you believe the people are evil or if you believe that evil is a supernatural force in them. When Jesus cast the demon out of the man he was talking to evil. He was talking to someone other than the physical man that he was speaking to. Evil to me can be both the person and the supernatural force that can take that person over. Watching this video of 9/11 and the way it affected people was very touching and at the same time very irritating to me. I am a Christian and I do believe in evil but once something like this happens it shows that even the people that think that they have so much faith can lose all that faith that they think that they had in a split second. I know that this was hard and I know that I cannot relate with these people as far as losing a loved one in this catastrophe but out of this catastrophe you can relate it to everyday things that happen. It might not be as EXTREME but it does fit. To hear someone say “this is the best reason to not believe in God” saddened my heart but also made me think about how many people say that after every bad and evil thing that happens. God is not the reason that any evil thing happened. It was said perfectly by an agnostic man in the video. He said “God is not the one who pushes people off of a cliff with his finger. It is our Game and we are the ones moving the pieces”. This video helped me see the diverse perspectives of evil in all the different...

Words: 714 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Realities of War in Birdsong

...Jack Firebrace, sending him for a court martial instantly, after a minor offence. Faulkes makes use of short, curt sentences in Wraysfords initial dialogue like “I doubt it.”This suggests harsh qualities, reinforcing the opinion that Stephen is a cold, removed character. Faulkes shows that Wraysford’s character softens towards his men, particularly the tunnellers, feeling empathy with their strange, but no less difficult path. This is shown in the contrast between the early parts of the novel where Stephen is almost exclusively referred to as “he” or “Stephen” and the later chapters where Stephen is referred to in a group with the tunnellers or other soldiers, making use of the pronoun “they” or “we” more often. Faulks presents Stephen as losing some of the isolated exterior by the end of the war that was the defining feature of his character at the beginning, This is shown in Stephen’s attachment to Jack Firebrace, presented by Faulks in the end tunnel scene. The strength of this partnership is shown in Stephen’s persistent attempts to keep Jack alive, when he could have saved himself far more easily had he been alone. Captain Weir copes with the war through the use of heavy drinking. This is first shown when Jack Firebrace is escorted to Wraysford and Weir’s quarters by Sergeant Adams for his court martial. The character notices the “almost empty bottle of whiskey”, inferring that Weir drinks...

Words: 1179 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Praiside Lost

...because God incorporates the contradictory notions of both faith and reason into the law by which he says Adam and Eve must abide. God first commands Adam to not eat of the Tree of Knowledge; this commandment is governed by a required faith on Adam's part in God's righteousness alone. Secondly, God (through implication) commands Adam to live according to his capacity to reason rationally. It is made clear to Adam that the first commandment, having to do with faith, is the primary commandment, since it is the only one God articulates. But, when Adam passes the information on to Eve, he does not make this distinction as clear. He also further convolutes the distinction with other things he says. Thus the order of importance of the two contradictory commandments is lost when told to Eve. Then, In book 9, Satan takes advantage of Eve's lack of information by presenting Eve with a situation wherein the conclusion that rational reasoning would produce is at odds with the conclusion that a blind trust in faith would produce. Eve cannot abide simultaneously by both of God's commandments in this situation. By eating the fruit from the Tree of Knowledge (as Satan tells her to), Eve is guilty of losing faith, which initiates the "original, mortal sin" (9,1003-4). However, acting reasonably is what Adam tells her is otherwise valued by God and is generally the human connection to the divine. Therefore, while Eve is guilty of losing faith (which she understands as one of God's commandments), she...

Words: 1704 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Cutlure and Developent

...Thomas Mr.Paulk Introduction to World Religion 16 May 2013 A leap for some faiths, but many Canadians are losing their religion Dakshana Bascaramurty, Glory Galloway & Les Perreaux (“The Globe and Mail,” May 8, 2013). Brampton is located west of Toronto, which is known to have one of the largest Muslim population and increasing. In 2011, the National Household Survey released data that identified 3.2 percent of the Canadians residents as Muslim, with two percent of the population increasing since 2001. The younger Muslim make up only 60% and increasing slowly in the population. Before 1971, there were 2.9 percent immigrants that resided in Canada and 33 percent resided between 2001 and 2011. Even though the population for Muslim, Hindu, Buddhists and Sikh religion are increasing, there are still 24 percent of the population that do not belong in any form of religion. The Christian and religion are decreasing slowly in Canada. But that did not stop Mariam Butt who is a residence of Brampton. She began practicing her faith at the age of 17. Living as a Muslim in Brampton made it easier for Mariam to practicing her faith. She stated, “When I did start practicing I was comfortable because everyone was your own in a way so you weren’t judged as much.” The director of the Centre for Studios in Religion and Society at the University of Victoria, Paul Bramadat, agree that the Christianity faith is slowly decreasing and the other religion are slowly increasing, but Canada’s...

Words: 617 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Fear And Trembling Kierkegaard Analysis

...Faith isn’t simple, or at least according to Søren Kierkegaard it isn’t. In his work Fear and Trembling Kierkegaard asserts that people view faith as something effortless and undemanding. If they saw the act of having faith for what it really is – an extreme undertaking requiring one to believe in the absurd while simultaneously ignoring all things rational – then they would regard individuals who complete deeds resembling Abraham’s on Mount Moriah in the same way they regard the doings of characters like Agamemnon, but they don’t. Part of the reason why this occurs is that nearly every one of the individuals condemning Abraham does not completely understand faith and what it requires of those who choose to fully engage in the task. This is...

Words: 849 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

How I Feel About Moms That Stay Home

...HOW I FEEL ABOUT MOMS THAT STAY HOME Shane Sorensen Professor Barbara Hammons CHDV 115 6-10pm Mon, Wed HOW I FEEL ABOUT MOMS THAT STAY HOME Being a stay at home mother would seem like such a wonderful thing to enjoy, but in a world with many expectations and economic demands, it looks as though homes these days are missing one important ingredient, the mother. The mother is such an important role in a child’s life that without her needed nurturing, the child’s life could change dramatically for the worse. In what ways are mothers important? That’s what I would like to discuss, because there are many benefits to having a stay at home mom. The first way that comes to my mind is that the bond between mother and child is vital to the child’s mental, physical, emotional, and spiritual growth. First, let’s focus on their mental growth. Picture a child waking up every morning to a different face, never being able to bond or create a foundation for himself/herself. When that child gets into school, and tries to solve a problem, or fix a dispute between a friend, what if they don’t have the coping skills to work at that problem or relationship when they know that things in their own life are never routed or fixed steadily,(they won’t feel the importance of having steady lasting relationships etc.) they’ll never be able to develop the important skills like problem solving and bonding. Now I would like to focus on the physical aspects of a child’s growth...

Words: 1181 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

American Grace Summary Notes

...American Grace: How Religion Divides and Unites Us Robert Putnam & David Campbell Summary Points: Changes in American Religiosity & Tolerance (Chapters 3, 4, 5, and 15)   Chapter 3 & 4: Religiosity in America Lifecycle, Generational, and Period Effect Change   Ø Most  people’s  religious  views  and  habits  are  formed  fairly  early  in  life.  All  of  us  tend  to  evolve   in  fairly  predictable  ways  as  we  age,  following  what  social  scientists  call  life  cycle  patterns.   These  patterns  produce  a  kind  of  life  cycle  escalator  toward  greater  religiosity  as  an  individual   ages.     Ø However,  people  born  and  raised  in  different  eras  get  onto  that  escalator  at  different  levels.   People  raised  in  a  less  religious  era  may  never  become  as  observant  as  people  raised  in  a  more   observant  time…  Such  a  difference  between  people  born  and  raised  in  different  eras  is  termed   by  social  scientists  a  generational  effect.     Ø Both  generational  and  life  cycle  patterns  involve  change,  but  in  pure  form  they  produce  very   different...

Words: 4184 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Comparing Parker's Back And The Rabbi In The Attic

...Pollack’s “The Rabbi in the Attic”, Rabbi Heckler’s presence is a nuisance to those around him. The leaders of the synagogue want this man to be forgotten. They think his mind is gone, perhaps from before the moment he comes into the position as Rabbi. Over time, his outbursts and rigidity show even more and the leaders fear he is losing more of his mind. Although, what they do not realize is that he is only reacting to the lack of attention to the Jewish laws. The students and congregation are becoming more and more lax in their studies and faith and Rabbi Heckler recognizes what is happening and attempts to force change upon them. His extreme ways push the leaders to go out searching for someone to take his place. This search leads them to Marion Bloomgarten. Marion, having just gone through ordination, had dreams of becoming a great leader, bringing peace to the people. She is not as stern or strict in her thinking when it comes to the laws of Judaism. Of course she holds onto the standards of observing Yom Kippur and the Sabbath, but she does not see the need for seemingly frivolous, archaic laws that seem to have no bearing on the Jewish faith. ...

Words: 606 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Goodman Brown And The Minister's Black Veil Character Analysis

...who sought to purify the Church of England. They are a strong religious group who migrated to the America’s to escape religious persecution in what is know as the Great Migration to create land where they could be religiously free. In these Puritan societies they emanated a strong sense of faith but although they were strict and harsh, the Puritans did indeed embody many admirable traits. In Goodman Brown and The Minister's black veil one exemplary trait that is demonstrated through their writings is the puritans being very persistent in keeping their faith. Both characters in these texts the show the struggle of keeping faith after being exposed to evil side of mankind but are still able to look up to God. Another trait was how the Puritans were very aware and valued God’s presence in their life as seen in Narrative of the Capacity, From of plymouth plantation, and Burning of our house. Lastly, another laudable trait the Puritans depicted was...

Words: 1617 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Rationalization of Belief

...“It is fashionable to wax apocalyptic about the threat to humanity posed by the AIDS virus, “mad cow” disease, and many others, but I think a case can be made that faith is one of the world’s great evils, comparable to the smallpox virus but harder to eradicate. Faith, being belief that isn’t based on evidence, is the principle vice of religion.” - Richard Dawkins Many other philosophers and professionals of academia criticize religion for its reliance on faith. More specifically, they condemn the act of using faith to reason –rationalizing actions based on something other than evidence or proof. My argument does not necessarily confine itself to the focus frame of religion, but more generally, I argue that it is justified to form beliefs that are not grounded in sufficient evidence. I will use my initial motivation for this topic as an appropriate introduction for this argument. Throughout the semester I was genuinely intrigued by the atheistic arguments of astounding philosophers –most notable and influential on my own beliefs were the ideas of Hume, Dawkins, Clifford, and even Nietzsche. In light of this and the logically superior option to argue against the existence of God, … I did. In fact, I was four pages into what was shaping out to be the best paper I’ve written since my secondary school thesis on underwater basket weaving. At some point, however, I could not continue writing. I had no passion, desire, or any sense of purpose while trying to grind out...

Words: 1528 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Animal Farm Hero's Journey

...Faith is what drives people forward. It causes ambition within people, and for some, it’s what they rely on. Whether it be religion, other people, or just a lifeline to keep them from failing, these are the things that give them hope to go on, to keep fighting. It allows them to believe that they can fight the standards set against them by society, that they can fight the intensity of the world around them, and that they can fight the ideas thrust upon them, because the can, in fact, think for themselves. Often, it’s this hope that allows people to see through the lies told to them by the masses. It gives them a light at the end of the tunnel, and holding on to that is what keeps everybody going. Knowing that one day things will work out, and...

Words: 1300 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Silas Marner

...goes from being a humble, trusting man, to a man who locks himself up with his money, away from other people, where he can no longer be hurt. This is because of the significant events that happened to him previously. At the beginning of the story, when Silas Marner is still at Lantern Yard, Marner is described as having a “defenceless, deer-like gaze”. This deer-like gaze portrays a soft, quiet, trusting creature. At this point, Marner has complete faith and trust in his friend, William Dane. He also has complete trust in God, and in people in general, to know what is right and wrong, good and bad. When Marner is first accused of stealing the money he said nothing but “God will clear me.” He believes that even if nobody realises that he didn’t steal the money, God will show them, God will protect him. Then, when he finally realises that he has been set up by his ‘best friend’, he states that “There is no just God.” By saying this, he realises that everything he believed in was a lie. That he could no longer trust God or man. Losing belief in the only two things you believe in, made Silas Marner the bitter man we see at the beginning of chapter 1. After being found guilty by the citizens of lantern yard, Marner tries to carry on with normal life in disbelief at what has just happened. Shortly after this, Marner’s fiancée, Sarah, announces the breakup. Only a month later Dane and Sarah get married. Knowing that he had lost everything, Marner moved on. Now his once trusting, friendly...

Words: 311 - Pages: 2