Free Essay

More Than One Side of History

In:

Submitted By sportschic579
Words 859
Pages 4
What do you know about Christopher Columbus? Howard Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States, there is a much greater understanding of what Columbus actually did. History needs to be through different viewpoints or the true history of life isn’t told; learners can’t perish to one view on history. Nations and communities have different viewpoints for example. Nations view history as Columbus viewed it while communities view history as the oppressed viewed it. While the views are associated with two different history writing styles in the chapter that Zinn provides, different views are essential when it comes to learning history. National collective memory is associated massively to the leader’s perspective, for example Columbus’s viewpoint; communal collective memory is linked heavily to the oppressed perspective such as the experiences of the Arawaks. The first chapter titled Columbus, The Indians, and Human Progress Zinn analyzed the untold history of what Columbus actually did back in 1492. Zinn provides us two different types of history writing. One type is the history of Columbus in Columbus’s own point of view. This is the type that students briefly learned about in high school modern history courses and of historians. Some historians basically sympathize with Columbus’s perspective. He was a hero for finding new land and supposedly bringing gold back to the King and Queen. Many students didn’t know there were other viewpoints so they believed in that one view. Zinn states, “When we read the history books given to children in the United States, it all starts with heroic adventure – there is no bloodshed – and Columbus Day is a celebration” (7). It is the utmost truth that kids enjoy the day off from school because who wouldn’t? The problem arises with the children’s knowledge about the holiday. We know that Columbus is considered heroic as Zinn points out but it is only because we are given only one side of the story. Henry Kissinger is a great example of type 1 history writing. Henry Kissinger wrote about the history of Europe in the nineteenth century in his book A World Restored. This is the first type of history writing because the history is told from the leader’s perspective. Zinn points out, “… in which he proceeded to tell the history of … from the viewpoint of the leaders of Austria and England, ignoring the millions who suffered from those statesmen’s polices” (9). After the French Revolution, the national leaders assumed there was peace but in actuality from the viewpoints of the factory workers, colored people in Asia and Africa, and women and children everywhere, there wasn’t any peace. These indigenous people and communities were a part of hunger and violence. Violence isn’t peaceful and communities suffered as a whole. The second type of history writing is of the oppressed peoples perspectives. Zinn provides us is from the viewpoints of the indigenous people. Columbus did much more than just discover land and brought back gold to the King and Queen. Zinn quotes Las Casas, “There were 60,000 people living on this island, including the Indians; so that from 1494 to 1508, over three million people had perished from war, slavery, and the mines” (7). Many of the natives of the lands Columbus took over were killed due to abuse and genocide. Only knowing Columbus’s point of view, a student would celebrate Columbus Day assuming he was a courageous man but looking at it from another historical viewpoint such as of the indigenous people, a student should think twice for celebrating a day for a man who helped commit genocide. Zinn agrees by stating, “[His] viewpoint, in telling the history of the United States, is different that we must not accept the memory of states as our own” (10). He is telling us that we as learners can’t succumb to one view on history. Columbus’s adventure wasn’t the only thing that was taught by his viewpoint alone.
Nations are larger groups of people that typically have something common. Communities are smaller groups of people that are all associated with at least one thing. Zinn tells us, “Nations are not communities and never have been” (10). Nations are larger identifiers that connect people. An example of a nation is Columbus’s perspective. Many people know his famous voyage from his own view but that isn’t necessarily what happened. Communities are smaller identifiers that connect one another. An example of a community is the oppressed perspective of Columbus’s voyage. There’s a smaller amount of people who know of what happened to the Arawaks when Columbus sailed over to what he thought was the Americas. The future goal of nations and communities should be they are equal. Schools around the world should teach students that there’s more than one view on many things but more specifically history. They learn more and they also share to other people about this new idea of realizing there’s multiple sides of history verses one side from which is being spoken by the government, conquerors, leaders, or diplomats.

Zinn, Howard. "Columbus, The Indians, and Human Progress." A People's History of the United States: 1492-2001. N.p.: n.p., n.d. 1-22. Print.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Summary Of A People's History Of The United States By Howard Zinn

...After reading Howard Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States, I have been left with many mixed emotions. I agree with points he makes and disagree with others. In a way, I think I have somewhat of a neutral opinion of him with a slight dislike. Using the victim point of view makes his work an argument rather than what you would find in a textbook, which takes into account both sides. I think his constant bashing of the Europeans and portraying the Indians as victims grew old quick, and it became harder to read since he was writing the same things. Overall, I think my personal view of him is more on the dislike side, and my view of this type of history is that it is very controversial because it depends on which side you look at. To...

Words: 441 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How Valid Is the View, All Things Considered, There Was More Uniting Than Dividing the North and the South in 1850?

...How valid is the view, all things considered, there was more uniting than dividing the North and the South in 1850? During 1850 America the gap between the North and the South was becoming more apparent. The obvious divide of social, culture and economics were forcing these sides ever further apart, sped up by the catalyst of slavery, the North and South could be described as not even one nation anymore. Yet despite these clear differences historians such as Bruce Cotton have stated that these current issues should not mask there deep uniting factors that made America such a powerful country. Their shared history, language and federal government, when considered, should outweigh these recent issues that were separating America in 1850. However as the civil war has shown these links were hidden behind the three main issues, of social, slavery and economics, dividing America in 1850. The view that the North and South was more united than divided is quite an invalid view because of the three main factors and the fact that the uniting factors could no longer hold America together. One of the key factors dividing the North and the South is the economical differences. The industrial difference is not actually a real dividing factor as both the North and the South started to industrialise and continued in agriculture, both just did such jobs on different scales than each other, with the South focused on cotton and sugar plantations with around 80% agriculture and the North focused...

Words: 1394 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Howard Zinn Analysis

...1492, but is it factual? Columbus’s discovery of the new world led to victory and havoc, even though these two words appropriately describe Columbus’s expedition, they still oppose one another. In history and life, there are always two sides to a story, two different perspectives of the same story. Therefore, there are two perspectives of Columbus’s voyage, one told by the American Pageant and one told by Howard Zinn in A People’s History of the United States , both of which in retrospect are entirely different on the way they betray Christopher Columbus. Howard Zinn’s ideology of Columbus as a villain is contradictory in nature to the American Pageant’s view of Columbus as a hero....

Words: 1184 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Joseph Ellis Founding Brothers Summary

...then coming out, the Founding Fathers were more united than ever. However, the seven had a relationship more comparable to brothers, and, like any siblings, they did not always get along. When written, the main idea of Founding Brothers had a strong purpose and a specific audience to reach, but, despite having its flaws, this book is, and will remain, a current topic for a wider audience.     Joseph Ellis began his historical education by pursuing his Bachelors from the College of William & Mary, and then going on to get his Masters and Doctorate at Yale University. He first taught at a military academy at West Point, but he currently teaches at Mount Holyoke College. Having a wife and three sons, he now contributes to many national publications on a regular basis, including, but not limited to: The New York Times, The Los Angeles Times, and The Wall Street Journal. As an American historian, Ellis has received nationwide appraisal; in fact, he won the Pulitzer Prize for...

Words: 1350 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Sith vs Jedi

...Stan Banas English 101 2/1/2016 Sith vs. Jedi Throughout history we have bared witness to many epic battles. Whether they are between nations, people or corporations there have always been great rivalries in our past and will be many more on through our future. Each contestant always has its own advantages over the other as well as the people or organizational backing them. Very commonly the supporters feel very strongly about which side they have chosen and will go to great lengths to support their claim. In the infinite battle between the Jedi order and the Sith, we face this age old dilemma of: “Who is better?” Within the Star Wars universe, Sith vs. Jedi is also often referred to as the light side vs. the dark side of the force. Nowhere in its history is one labeled as good or evil. Since the ancient Rakatan, the original users of the dark side around 30,000 BBY (Before the Battle of Yavin), the dark side was just another aspect of the force. Although in our traditional standards of good and evil, where the Jedi are known as keepers of the peace and justice, and the Sith are known to seek out galactic domination and harness there power through raw emotions such as anger, hatred, and greed, it can be argued that neither one is good or evil, and in fact each aspect are both, in fact, good and evil. The Sith were formed out of necessity from infighting within the ranks of the users of the dark side of the force. Darth Bane, around the year 1,000BBY, developed the “rule...

Words: 1022 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

A Patriot's History Versus a People's History

...A People’s History Versus A Patriot’s History Public consensus, similar to politics, varies greatly when it comes to American history, especially as it pertains to the classroom. Views about the content and historical interpretation included in history texts have reached a heightened polarization in recent years. This can be seen in the vast differences between the diatribes of Howard Zinn’s, A People’s History of the United States, and Larry Schweikart and Michael Allen’s, A Patriot’s History of the United States. While both books, prescribed by this introductory course into American History, cover many of the same topics, they clearly paint different pictures. I feel that any text seeking to represent a responsible survey of a subject, should strive to include a full range of views on a particular issue. There is no question that this requirement is fulfilled by the inclusion of both books. However, if one book would need to be selected over the other, my choice would be Schweikart and Allen’s. This is simply because I believe their book offers more facts and details surrounding the historical events in question. In an age where political perspective is often spoon-fed to us by dueling cablenews networks and political talk-radio shows, it is no wonder that our nation’s history is a hot topic for debate. A common perspective in conservative circles is that liberals seek to use the educational system to indoctrinate the nation’s youth. Although, a current issue in rebuttal...

Words: 1368 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Blah

...Lower East Side Memories
: A Jewish Place in America 
 By HASIA R. DINER The Lower East Side and American Jewish Memory I'm Jewish because love my family matzoh ball soup. I'm Jewish because my fathers mothers uncles grandmothers said    "Jewish," all the way back to Vitebsk & Kaminetz-Podolska via Lvov. Jewish because reading Dostoyevsky at 13 I write poems at restaurant    tables Lower East Side, perfect delicatessen intellectual. —Allen Ginsberg, "Yiddishe Kopf" The poet Allen Ginsberg, born and raised in Newark, New Jersey, returned in his later years to a narrative style of expression, shifting gears from the anger and fire of his early career. In this poem from 1991 he also touched down again, after a long hiatus spent exploring Buddhism and Eastern philosophy, upon some Jewish themes, as a way of remembering the world of his youth. He described that world in one poem, "Yiddishe Kopf," literally, a Jewish head, but more broadly, a highly distinctive Jewish way of thinking, based on insight, cleverness, and finesse.     That world for him stood upon two zones of remembrance. The world of eastern Europe, of Vitebsk, Lvov, and Kamenets-Podolski gave him one anchor for his Jewishness. Thai space of memory gave him a focus for continuity and inherited identity, tied down by the weight of the past, by family in particular. The other, the Lower East Side, nurtured and...

Words: 6616 - Pages: 27

Free Essay

Minipulated

...community college History 203: Fall 2014 Nikki Jones Genesee community college History 203: Fall 2014 Manipulated: African Americans and the Revolution One of the most notable intellectual paradoxes in American history is how the founding fathers could promote the equal rights of man and their perceived enslavement by the crown while simultaneously holding a fifth of their own population in bondage. Another question that plaques the history of this great nation is why abolition, or widespread emancipation, did not occur at this period in time when revolutionary and republican rhetoric existed alongside of anti-slavery sentiments. A case can be made that Americans were speaking more loudly for the end of political enslavement, rather than the freedom of slaves themselves. The exclusion of slaves from the political forefront made it easier for Americans to make these hypocritical claims. Whether or not whites were able to justify themselves the exclusion of the black community from their cries for freedom, the parallels revolutionary rhetoric had on their own condition were not lost on slaves. Many took advantage of the revolutionary crisis and ran away and joined either side in hopes to attain their own independence. There reasons that Blacks chose to join the revolutionary fight are as varied as the individuals who made them. The motives were, at times, a desire for adventure and a belief in justice and the cause of the revolution, but the more likely reasoning behind...

Words: 2286 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Encapsulating Shilo

...excellent example of the 19th Century. Melville, more known for his novels than his poetry, wrote a series of poems in which he shared his views about the Civil War. The poem is a reminder of what happened, and reminder that that are more than just two sides in a conflict. War is a tragedy that should always be a last resort, if at all. The Civil War is arguably the most defining event in American history. It certainly is in terms of defining what kind of country would exist after the war was over. If the South had won, the country would have been split into a collection of sovereign states, nothing like the indivisible nation Lincoln wanted to maintain. The United States just before the Civil War was a bomb waiting to happen. The North and South were split many topics, but the primary hot button issue was slavery. The war would end that discussion once and for all. The war lasted four years and was by far the bloodiest event in American history. More soldiers died in the Civil War all the wars America has fought in since, combined! Shiloh – A Requiem illustrates the loss and just unimaginable tragedy that was the Civil War, particularly in the Battle of Shiloh. The poem echoes the sentiment of the war, especially afterwards, when many believed the war could have been avoided, and the body count was a needless horror. “Over the field where April rain, Solaced the parched ones stretched in pain” This is a powerful piece of imagery. One can imagine the rain pouring down on the...

Words: 452 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

American Inequality and Its Origins

...A lot of great nations have rich history of their own, whether it is bad or it is good. The United States of America has great history and tradition, from the Revolutionary War to the occupation of Afghanistan. When people who write about history discuss that of the United States, they often consider how eminent this country is and the great deeds other people of that country have done. Historians who write about the history of America often write about how it has had a share of great heroes from Christopher Columbus, Woodrow Wilson, George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, etc.. Nevertheless, historians often seem to not remember to mention the real heroes of America like, for example, John Brown and the Native Americans. Much of the history that historians write about don't always show precision. Since many historians only write about one side of history, it only makes it worse by not revealing the factuality of history and creates an erroneous image of what really took place. Many of our nation's great leaders have been distinguished as individuals who have the best interest of the country and every action they take on behalf of the country befittingly. For instance, in the book, Lies My Teacher Told Me, by James Loewen, he writes, "Under [president] Wilson, the United States intervened in Latin America more often than at any other time in our history." (Loewen, 16). What reason did the United States have to start an intervention in countries that...

Words: 2024 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Birth Control

...times. While “the pill” itself was considered a brand new invention, the idea of creating a birth control pill was not. Since the old times primitive condoms were made from animal intestines and fish bladders. However, it wasn’t until after Margaret Sanger’s multiple convictions and persistent attitude, that a judge ended the Comstock era, providing Sanger with the opportunity to stress the importance of having birth control in th for of a pill to the public. In less than a decade after Sanger persuaded Pincus to begin working on the contraceptive, Pincus created a pill that tested to be 100 percent effective. However, in 1957, while the Food and Drug Adminsitration approved the pill, it was not approved as a contraceptive but rather as a treatment for women that experienced sever menstrual disorders. It was not until 1960 that the drug was actually approved as a contraceptive. Despite this, many controversies arose from the contraceptive leading to its many transformations. Because the original pill had many side effects that were largely ignored, a newer pill with a smaller dosage was created, coming with a decreased risk of developing ovarian cancer, pelvic inflammatory disease, and deficiency anemia in the users. Later on, the pill was also approved by the FDA as not just a contraceptive, but also as a treatment for acne. In the 200s, a new pill called “seasonale” was approved by the Food and Drug Administration. Unlike the second generation of contraceptives, this new pill...

Words: 3300 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Lies My Teacher Told Me

...to how history is really written in the United States and shows that it is written by the victors which is why there are so many inaccuracies in our history. The reason Loewen says as to why history textbooks are distorted is because they want to avoid controversy and don’t want to put anything in textbooks that will show the history of the United States in a bad light and want to show the United States as heroes. To make his point, Loewen emphasizes the "dark side" of U.S. history, because that's the part that's missing from our education system. So, for example, we never learned that Woodrow Wilson ran one of the most racist administrations in history and helped to set back progress in race relations that had begun after the Civil War. Helen Keller's socialist leanings and political views are omitted and we only learn that she overcame blindness and deafness. John Brown is portrayed as a wild-eyed nut that ran amok until he was caught and hung, rather than an eloquent and dedicated abolitionist who expressed some of the same views as Lincoln. Loewen's book illustrates the saying that "those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it." Ignorance of our real history also renders us incapable of fully understanding the present and coming to grips with the issues of our time. Reconstruction, which textbooks put the blame on black people for the failure to integrate with society; the Civil War, which supposedly started because the South wanted more state power;...

Words: 558 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Merchants Of Doubt Essay

...Merchants of Doubt, by Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway, is a book about the science and politics behind some of the most important scientific discussions in the 20th century. It covers the issues of smoking and second-hand smoke, acid rain, ozone depletion, global warming, and history revisionism. In each topic Oreskes and Conway delve into how these discussions and arguments took place, and the goals that were being accomplished. The section of the book which had the best resonance was the section on history revisionism concerning Rachel Carson and her work relating to DDT. The reasoning is partly a personal matter on both the concept of history revisionism and the effects of DDT. Aside from personal, the issue with historical revisionism...

Words: 1799 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Rondo Community Analysis

...of the history surrounding this city, or the communities that make it up. During orientation, Jennifer Arnolds took a group of students and me on a bus tour of the Rondo community. While on the bus I remember thinking about how I knew these buildings and physical spaces that we were occupying, but the stories that Jennifer was telling were unfamiliar to me. I-94 has been a staple in my life as long as I can remember, it’s the freeway to get to our Santa pictures in the winter, and the road that brings me home after spending the day at...

Words: 1114 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Peoples History of Us

...Kevin Gomez AP US History 26 July 2015 Summer Work Assignment 3 1) Word Bank: Furled- roll or fold up and secure neatly (a flag, umbrella or sail). 2) Droop- Bend or hang downward dimply. 3) Stern- Serious or unrelenting. 4) Bulwarks- a defensive wall. 5) Motley-incongruously varied in appearance or character. 6) Portentous- Of or like a portent. 7) Derogatory- showing a critical or disrespectful attitude. 8) Abhor- Regard with disgust or hatred. 9) Ladle- a large handled spoon with a cup-shaped bowl. 10) Excrement's-waste matter 11) Aver- state or assert to be the case. 12) Subsistence- the action or fact of maintaining or supporting oneself at a minimum level. 13) Ineptitude-a lack of skill or ability 14) Condescending-showing or implying a usually patronizing descent from dignity or superiority. 15) Feudalism- nobility held lands from the crown and were also protected by the crown. 16) Steadfast- performing the duties expected or required of one 17) Subdue- Overcome 18) Serf- an agricultural laborer bound under the feudal system to work on his lord's estate. 19) Servitude- he state of being a slave or completely subject to someone more powerful. 20) Communal- Shared by all members in the community 21) Stark- Severe or bare in appearance or outline. 22) Breadth- The distance or measurement from side to side of something. 23) Scruples- a feeling of doubt. 24) Illicit-forbidden...

Words: 910 - Pages: 4