Premium Essay

Native American Mascots Research Paper

Submitted By
Words 1949
Pages 8
The Chicago Blackhawks, Washington Redskins, Cleveland Indians, Kansas City Chiefs, and Atlanta Braves are all professional sports teams in America that use Native American culture to represent them through the means of tribe names, logos, and mascots. These teams have received a lot of media attention around the debate as to whether the representation of Native Americans is offensive or not. Controversy surrounding Native American mascots first came into the public eye during the 1960s Native American Civil Rights movement, where the use of these mascots was criticized for being insulting. However, the people who conceived these teams, knowingly or not, created an atmosphere of prejudice and discrimination growing the brands into multi-million …show more content…
Redskins owner Daniel Snyder, who refuses to consider a name change, points out that the team’s first roster in 1933 included four Native American players and states that, “[their] team name captures the best of who [they] are and who [they] can be, by staying true to [their] history and honoring the deep and enduring values [their] name represents.” (ESPN) Native Americans are viewed as strong and courageous with many other positive qualities. Teams choose Native Americans as mascots and role models because they are admired historically. The Cleveland Indians owner commented about their logo saying, “Logos are primarily a local matter. The local club makes decisions about its logos. Fans get attached to logos. They become part of a team’s history.” (Waldron) These professional teams have created an identity for themselves within each of their hometowns or even states. Many fans, and teams themselves, hold these characteristics displayed by teams as traditions and celebrate them to the fullest. However, what they are celebrating is not always correct and can bring a great deal of negativity toward Native …show more content…
These professional teams take Native Americans and their culture and remake them into mass consumable stereotypes. Consequently, this Native theme encourages fans to dress in fake headdress and war paint. It is a tacky, offensive portrayal of a people that is equivalent to blackface. The best example is the Cleveland Indians Chief Wahoo. Wahoo is a red-faced Indian with a feather sticking out of his head and a big cheesy smile. Again, not only is this depiction found to be stereotypical but also it enables people to dress up as Wahoo or an “Indian” which is offensive. These types of arguments however, are often dismissed because of the amount of money generated from merchandise. Capitalism is the driving force behind teams. They exploit Natives by selling misrepresentations of their cultural aspects for profit. These billion dollar franchises create a situation where once diverse cultural identities are stripped away, the only culture left to identify with is capitalist culture. This is a form of cultural misappropriation in the sports world. Natives in turn lose in which their cultural markers and are then consumed and assimilated into the dominant culture where they often feel exploited and

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Native American Mascot Research Paper

...The objectification of Native American figures, symbols, and culture is prevalent in many schools and professional sports teams across America today (Chaney, Burke and Burkley 43). Nearly 1,200 high schools and 90 colleges in the United States use Native Americans as their school mascot (Chaney, Burke and Burkley 43). Throughout football games, pep-rallies, and other school related events, fans chant Native American war chants and dress in stereotypical cartoon-like costumes (Pewewardy 181). Although some people would argue that these symbols are intended to honor Native Americans, they often portray them in an inauthentic and clichéd manner (Chaney, Burke and Burkley 43). Because of this, the barbaric, wild, and savage mascots have become a representation of the Native American...

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Native American Mascots Research Paper

...Is using Native American Mascots an Insult or Honor? The use of Native mascots by sports teams and schools has been a topic of controversy for many years. While some believe that these mascots honor and celebrate Native American culture, others believe that they perpetuate harmful stereotypes and are ultimately insulting. On the one hand, proponents of Native American mascots argue that they serve as a tribute to the strength and bravery of Native American warriors. They believe that these mascots honor the heritage and traditions of Native American people and serve as a symbol of pride and respect. As it says in the Passage Insult or Honor, “American Indian derived names, mascots, and logos have a long history in the U.S. They're used by...

Words: 354 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Native American Mascot Research Paper

...comes to Native American mascots, some people believe that they can actually be seen as an honor. Mascots are used to serve as a way to celebrate and pay tribute to the history and heritage of Native American cultures. When it comes to Native American mascots, there is no insult being described what so ever. This information provided can be supported by evidence and ideas supported throughout Native American history. In opposition to this debate, many people argue that using Native American mascots can actually be seen as an insult rather than an honor. They believe that these mascots preserve a bad image of Native American culture, which makes them out to be an inaccurate representation. According to a Native American magazine, “But...

Words: 441 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Native American Mascots Research Paper

...being a Native American who is an avid sports fan, but every time you try to watch a game, you are reminded of the racist stereotypes of your culture being celebrated as mascots. This poignant reality shows the urgency of the matter, and this issue of Native American mascots needs to be addressed immediately. The existence of Native American mascots has been a highly debated topic, ever since the Civil Rights Movement. Native activists have been fighting to change the stereotypical mascots, along with stereotypical names and logos, but have been mostly unsuccessful. Although some believe Native American Mascots honor the cultures of Native Americans,...

Words: 1142 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Native American Mascot Research Paper

...Every high school, college, and professional sport team have a mascot that represents culture of the team. Mascots been around for a long period of time now and play a big role in showing the spirit of the team and its powers. The interesting part about mascots is that the only ethnic group that is being used to represent the teams is Native Americans. Inaccurate representation of the Native people through mascots brought a big anger and contempt in Native Americans, which lead to protests and possible removal of the mascots. To make a final decision we need to take a look at this problem from positive and negative view point. When we were watching the video in class, principal of the school said, they are using Native American as a mascot to honor and remember the history and people of Native Americans. It is a great idea to educate students and remind fans that come to watch the game about the history of Native Americans. The problem with this is mascot has to entertain the crowd in order to be popular and not many people care for the history of the mascot. The Native American woman in the video said that it...

Words: 559 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Native American Mascots Research Paper

...Is Native American culture being made fun of and disrespected by team names and mascots? Many people believe that Native Americans and their culture are being harmed and offended, but others believe that Native American culture is being honored and respected. Some people think that names and mascots that involve Native Americans should be banned for those reasons, but others disagree. While mascots disrespect, mock, and harm Native American people, Native American mascots and names should not be banned because Native American culture is being honored. Team names and mascots are historically important for the teams, and gives a positive view on Native Americans. Native Americans' culture is being honored by the names and mascots. “Davis Gonzales, then chairman of the Te-Moak Tribe, sent the district a letter of support, stating in part that the marching Band of Indians "provides a positive image of our tribe. Tribes OK Use of Indians, Braves Mascots in Elko. (TCA Regional News, 2022, 08/12).. “Cambridge board member Dillon Honyoust, of Haudenosaunee ancestry, says that as a Native American, he sees retiring the "Indians" mascot as "another effort to remove or cancel the...

Words: 759 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Native American Mascots Research Paper

...afternoon in October, and for many Americans across the country, that means one thing: football. Within the crowded parking lot of FedEx Field, amidst the sea of tailgaters, a scene breaks out. On one side of the street, a group of fans decked out in maroon jerseys, red face paint, and plastic headdresses chant “Hail to the Redskins!” On the other side, a group stands holding banners and signs that read “I am a person, not a mascot,” and “”R” word = “N” word.” This scene is one that has become fairly common over the last few decades. Since the early 1960s, Native American mascots and logos have become a site for extensive debate. Although mascots are used by sports teams to create unity amongst both the team and fans, the use of Native American mascots raises questions of authenticity, representation, appropriation, and racism. At the center of these debates is one question: “Are Native American mascots a positive way to honor and include Native Americans or a harmful and negative stereotyping of Native Americans?” The...

Words: 1552 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Native American Names And Mascot Research Paper

...Do you think that Native American names and mascots are Offensive? I think that it is not offensive. There are some reasons why I think that the native americans would be offended. The native americans should be proud to have a team that represents them. I think that Native American names are an honor. Native americans should be honored to have teams that represent their bravery, courage, strength and fighting skills. When a team chooses a native american name they feel that that name represents how they are. Sports teams don’t choose their mascot to make fun of them they choose them because that’s what they feel represents their courage and strength. The only thing that should be banned is the negative stereotyping of native americans....

Words: 346 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

A Rhetorical Analysis Of Prof. Endres Ideas

...Prof. Endres displayed an above average command of the facts concerning the Utes nickname. Throughout her presentation, she was able bring up all the angles of this topic, including the history of the relationship between the Ute tribes and the university, the modern actions of students and university administration regarding the Utes nickname, and similar university mascot controversies. In no place did she show a lack of familiarity with any source texts surrounding these topics. Her command of the facts was only tempered by two aspects: her conspicuous usage of notes during the talk and her lack of reference to specific rhetorical analysis of the source texts. During her talk, she seemed mostly to be reading directly from prepared notes, rather than relating these facts off the top of her head. This did not distract from the...

Words: 1050 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Native American Pros And Cons

...said for Native American writing in the 1700-1800s. The Native Americans have consistently been overlooked and not given enough credit. Native Americans have been a part of our history for hundreds of years but we rarely see their news on the big news sources, and many of their stories do not get heard or acted upon. One headline we have seen on the news is the NFL Redskins team renaming controversy. Although we have seen and heard of the controversy in the news, it has been a long drawn out process that has not had any resolution yet. One theme often in early Native American literature as well as in...

Words: 1536 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Fdadfsadf

...TermPaperWarehouse.com - Free Term Papers, Essays and Research Documents The Research Paper Factory * Join * Search * Browse * Saved Papers ------------------------------------------------- Top of Form Bottom of Form * Home Page » * Other Topics History of Indian Mathematics In: Other Topics History of Indian Mathematics MATHEMATICS IN INDIA The history of maths in india is very great & eventful.Indians gave the system of numerals, zero, geometry & equations to the world. The great Indian mathematician Aryabhata   (476-529) wrote the Aryabhatiya ─ a volume of 121 verses. Apart from discussing astronomy, he laid down procedures of arithmetic, geometry, algebra and trigonometry. He calculated the value of Pi at 3.1416 and covered subjects like numerical squares and cube roots. Aryabhata is credited with the emergence of trigonometry through sine functions. Around the beginning of the fifteenth century Madhava (1350-1425) developed his own system of calculus based on his knowledge of trigonometry. He was an untutored mathematician from Kerala, and preceded Newton and Liebnitz by a century. The twentieth-century genius Srinivas Ramanujan (1887-1920) developed a formula for partitioning any natural number, expressing an integer as the sum of squares, cubes, or higher power of a few integers. Origin of Zero and the Decimal System The zero was known to the ancient Indians and most probably the knowledge of it spread from India to...

Words: 488 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Policy

...Justice Week 2014 is student-organized event sponsored by the New Legacy Committee, Beyond Diversity Club, Native American Club, Project Unity Club, Puente Club, and the Associated Students of Sierra College. All events are free and open to the public. Calendar of Events (For more information please contact Jennifer Kattman at jkattman@sierracollege.edu.) MONDAY, OCTOBER 13 9:30-10:50am in the Fireside Room: “Brief History of Protest Music” by Professor Jason Roberts In this presentation, Professor Jason Roberts will look at protest music from the early 1960s to the present with such artists as Joan Baez, the Rolling Stones, Marvin Gaye, Public Enemy, and Rage Against the Machine. 11am-12:20pm in the Fireside Room: “The New Native Intellectualism: Social Media, Social Justice and Native American Studies” by Cutcha Risling Baldy Cutcha Risling Baldy (Hupa, Karuk, Yurok) is an instructor and PhD candidate in Native American Studies. Her research is interdisciplinary (feminist and literary theory, politics and California Indian theory and methodology). Author of “Why We Gather: traditional gathering in native Northwest California and the future of bio-cultural sovereignty” and numerous related publications. Her dissertation (translated) is “To Grow Old in a Good Way” is about the revitalization of the Hupa Women’s Coming of Age Ceremony. Ms. Risling Baldy founded the Native Women’s Collective. 12:30-1:50pm in the Fireside Room: “Louder than Words” by Billy X Jennings Join Billy...

Words: 1898 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Native Americans in the United States

...Running Head: SCOTT SMITH ON NATIVE AMERICAN CULTURE Scott Smith on Native American Culture Scott Smith Regis University Abstract The Native American culture is explored in general terms, including their history, cultural values, and racial identity to better understand them as fellow human beings and to gain insight into how best to provide them counseling services within their cultural context. In addition, Scott Smith, a therapist-in-training, provides some of his personal feelings and thoughts about various topics pertaining to Native Americans as a cultural group within this framework and along this path of his own learning about Native American culture and how he can be the most affective therapist he can be for Native American clients. Scott Smith on Native American Culture To begin examining their Native American culture, I would like to discuss some important Native American terminology; however, I also want to note I will be presenting additional terminology as appropriate and depending on the topics I’m discussing, i.e. history, racial identity development, and so on. So what term or terms are acceptable to Native Americans when referring to them as a cultural group? Do they prefer to be called Indians, American Indians, Native Americans, Indigenous People, none of those, or some of those? For most of my life, I’ve only felt comfortable using the term “Native American” primarily because I associated the word “Indian” early on in grade school...

Words: 3409 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Native American Oppression

...Native American Oppression Santucee Bell Case Western Reserve University Native American Oppression Introduction & Focal Population Imagine living in a world that consistently devalues your existence and is heavily populated with individuals who are quick to use and abuse your resources, but are slow to share the wealth that is accumulated from those resources. How would you feel? Unfortunately, certain populations do not have to visualize the disparity that is pictured above. This is because inequity is one of the most demoralizing social issues that plague America today. The worst thing about inequity is the fact that it continues to disproportionately burden individuals who are categorize as being minority in today’s society. This is especially true for the American Indian/Alaska Native population. This population continues to be one of the most vulnerable minority groups. According to the U.S. Census Bureau’s Overview of Race and Hispanic Origin: 2010 (2011), “American Indian or Alaska Native refer to a person having origins in any of the original peoples of North and South America (including Central American) and who maintains tribal affiliation or community attachment” (Humes, Jones, & Ramirez, 2011, p. 3). 2,475,956 out of 308, 745,538 people that live in America are believed to be American Indian/Alaska Native, including those who report affiliations with tribes and South and Central American Indian groups (Humes et. al,, 2011, p. 4). This number is...

Words: 5989 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Mascots in Advertising

...AMITY SCHOOL OF COMMUNICATION AMITY UNIVERSITY, NOIDA. TERM PAPER ON: Use of Mascots in Advertising. SUBMITTED TO: PROF. Amit Kumar Dutta AMITY UNIVERSITY, NOIDA SUBMITTED BY: ABHIMANYU KARNATAK BJ&MC- II A (2011-2014) AMITY SCHOOL OF COMMUNICATION, AMITY UNIVERSITY Title USE OF MASSCOTS IN ADVERTISING Acknowledgement I put forth my heartiest thanks to AMIT SIR for giving me this opportunity to work on such an interesting topic- use of mascots in advertisement and is it degrading the status of women? The topic has been a concern and talk of every town and I am glad to have received a topic that I would enjoy working on. All thanks to sir. Thanking you for your inspiration and support Table of Contents 1) Title 2) Table of contents 3) Key words 4) Objective and purpose of the study 5) Introduction 6) Literature Review 7) Hypothesis 8) Methodology 9) Analysis of data with regards to hypothesis so assumed earlier 10) Findings 11) Inferences 12) Conclusion and result 13) Bibliography 14) Appendix Keywords Masscots - A person, animal, or object believed to bring good luck, especially one kept as the symbol of an organization such as a sports team. Brand recognition- The extent to which the general public (or an organization's target market) is able to identify a brand by its attributes. Brand recognition is most successful when people can state a brand without being...

Words: 7496 - Pages: 30