Free Essay

Ncaa Scam

In:

Submitted By rscott
Words 1434
Pages 6
Ryan Scott
Dr. Dunn
ENG 100.12
Proposal
11/13/13
Pay for Play? Define Problem: Last year the NCCA signed a 14-year, $10.8 billion dollar contract with CBS and Turner Sports to allow them to broadcast the annual March Madness of college basketball on their channel. The Bowl Championship series of college football also signed a $125 million dollar deal with ESPN (Ford 1). Depending on how deep of a run you make in March Madness or a big win in a highly anticipated BCS bowl game, teams could potentially bring in millions of dollars to their university. But the men and women who are the ones on the field putting their body and wellbeing on the line are the same ones who see absolutely none of that money. How can this even be possible? College athletes, who put in just as much time if not more than an actual job, receive no type of money for the amount of revenue that they bring in. Sure they get an athletic scholarship that pays for most of their schooling but, not for everything outside of that. There is more to college than just books and schoolwork. People still need to buy food, pay bills, gas, and just everyday essentials. When writer William J. Ford asked senior guard Gary Clark from Wake Forest University about the topic he said “At a lot of schools, players come from underprivileged families. I know we are getting a scholarship, but some folks don’t have cash to get something to eat when the school cafeteria is closed, or money to buy a used car,” he continues. “I am not saying we should get paid with a full-time salary, but a stipend would be nice” (Ford 1). Just recently former Tennessee running back Arian Foster revealed to the public about how he received a little money while playing his senior year of college football. He didn’t use it for diamonds, clothes, or a new car, but for the simple fact that he needed the money to get by. Arian stated “My senior year [2008] I was getting money on the side, I really didn’t have any money. I had to pay the rent or buy some food…You’re not going to convince me that there is something wrong with it” (Rosenburg1). You can’t be angry at someone who took a little money when he needed it most. To put it in a good perspective for you, if the NCAA were to charge only $10 per person per football game (which is way lower than the actual price) and on average 46,000 people attend each game, then you would already be making back the athletes scholarship with tons left over in ONE game. To say the NCAA is not one big money hungry scandal would be a lie. So much revenue comes in off these athletes and they don’t get to see one cent of it. Even trying to make their own profit, by selling their own jersey, with THEIR name on it causes uproar with the NCAA. Former University of Georgia wide receiver A.J. Greene was suspended for four games after he sold one of his game worn jerseys for $1,000. Soon after Greene was suspended, ironically the University of Nebraska auctioned off a game worn jersey by star QB Taylor Martinez for $1,000 (Ford 1). It’s idiotic and ridiculous that the NCAA can profit off of these players but the players cannot profit for themselves. Something needs to be done to stop the exploitation of these players.

Solution: The solution to the NCAA not paying student athletes might sound very irrational at first, but in the end makes perfect sense. If Division 1 programs continue to claim that they cannot pay college athletes, then they should stop giving out athletic scholarships. They always boast about how they make tons of money each year but then can’t pay the players at all. Picture it as a very expensive restaurant where only the owner makes the money and the cooks and waiters work for free. By taking away athletic scholarships, student athletes would now be employees to the school and by choice, students as well. They would have four years of athletic eligibility and whether or not they wanted to take classes to receive a degree would be there choice. In Frank Deford’s article on the situation, he thinks taking away athletic scholarships would “eliminate all the fraud attendant to “student” athletes getting into college and staying eligible” (Deford1). It would take all the stress of school work away and allow them to focus on furthering there career in sports.
Most athletes on a full ride know already if they could become a professional in their sport or not. Michigan State Law Professors Robert and Amy McCormick explain how many college athletes never receive a degree any way because they go professional before they have the chance to (Cooper 1). With this said, why shouldn’t we allow them to start their career as early as they can? By being an employee first it would allow the athletes to be paid and ultimately terminate any flaws people might think the NCAA being scandal. It sounds bizarre that someone would give up a fully paid scholarship to a great school, but in the end athletes like Johnny Manziel would be making well into six figures ($225,000) every year still in college and exceed the amount they would have received originally from the schools scholarship (Gregory 1). Those student athletes who still wish to receive a scholarship may, but they will be in the same boat as they are now and not receive any kind of compensation for their contributions that they bring to the university.
Audience: The audience that I am targeting with this proposal is all current college athletes and future college athletes
Rhetorical Strategy: The purpose of this proposal is to help college and future college athletes be informed about what they are missing out on and the reality of what the NCAA is doing. The NCAA is getting away with a scam that has been going on for years and years with no change in site until now. The older generations are finally figuring out what is going on here, but younger generations are still being sucked into these universities because they have no idea about the situation. They get offers left and right from big time schools and are so wrapped up in the moment, they don’t take a second to think about it. I think that a small but informational pamphlet would be great for my audience. It will let them know about a situation they are most likely unaware of. When college coaches are recruiting and selling them these great stories, I doubt they mention anything about how they make a killing of their athletes.
Areas of Research: The areas of research that will be used are scholarly journal entries and my personal interview of Mathew Gorski.
Conclusion: College athletes dedicate their entire life to their sport for the years they are there. They bring in millions and millions of dollars to their universities each time they step on the playing field. They do all the same work as the pros, just without all the millions coming back to them. No college kid in this country should have millions of dollars because that would only lead to chaos, but why can’t they have any type of compensation? If the colleges cannot pay the players any type of money, then they should reconsider even having a sports program. Saying that they can’t give the athletes any type of money is a lie and injustice to the players.

Works Cited
COOPER, KENNETH J. "Should College Athletes Be Paid To Play?." Diverse: Issues In Higher Education 28.10 (2011): 12-13. Academic Search Premier. Web. 11 Nov. 2013.
Deford, Frank. "Bust The Amateur Myth." Chronicle Of Higher Education 58.17 (2011): A8. Academic Search Premier. Web. 11 Nov. 2013.
FORD, WILLIAM J. "Even Playing Field?." Diverse: Issues In Higher Education 28.6 (2011): 11-12. Academic Search Premier. Web. 11 Nov. 2013.
Gregory, Sean. "Should This Kid Be Making $225,047 A Year For Playing College Football?." Time 182.12 (2013): 36. Academic Search Premier. Web. 11 Nov. 2013.
ROSENBERG, MICHAEL, MARK BECHTEL, and JIM GORANT. "Shell Game." Sports Illustrated 119.13 (2013): 19. Academic Search Premier. Web. 11 Nov. 2013.
ZIRIN, DAVE. "The Shame Of The NCAA." Nation 296.13 (2013): 24-26. Academic Search Premier. Web. 11 Nov. 2013.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Hard Body Research Plan

...Eshon Howard Bus 339 Marketing Research Hard Body Research Plan Victor Olufeso Introduction The Hard Body Haulers is a local moving company that is not experiencing consistent growth in revenue. The company was founded in 2008 and is located in Cleveland, Ohio; one of the fastest shrinking cities in terms of population in the United States (http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/39/3916000.html, 2006). This along with the high number of home foreclosures in the area indicates that people in the area are relocating to other dwellings. In contrast, the level of people unemployed in the area indicate that people do not have the discretionary resources available to them to hire a mover and are instead utilizing do it yourself alternatives (http://www.cleveland.com/datacentral/index.ssf, 2011). Moving costs are expensive to consumers in a recessive economy. Much of the cost of that the moving companies incur are fixed costs in the form of equipment such as vehicle maintenance, packaging supplies, and lifting equipment. Secondly, there is a high cost insurance and licensing requirements that every moving company must have in order to be in compliance with the State of Ohio (http://www.puco.ohio.gov/puco/, 2011). The availability of the moving company can also increase the costs considering that most moving companies are busiest on the last ten days of the month (Cohn, 2010). Finally, moving can be a very time consuming process. So moving companies generally charge on an hourly...

Words: 1428 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Pay for Play

...Pay for Play Short Paper Timothy McGee Southern New Hampshire University January 10, 2015 There are many ways one could answer the age old question should college athletes be paid. The bigger question should be why are student athletes not being paid. I stand firm on the issue that student athlete's should be compensated for the work they put in for the University. I am a former student athlete and I feel strong about the situation because I have seen thing behind the curtain that the normal American public does not see. If people really knew what it was like to be in the shoes of a student athlete they would probably choose to go to school without sport. The lifestyle of a student athlete is demanding. Do to NCAA rules student athletes are unable to work during the school year due to compromising tactics like receive an increased amount of money because you play for a respected program. Many athletes have lost money from being taken advantage of by agents, coaches, and lenders all looking to cash out when the athlete play professionally. There are many rules to keep student athletes in a system where they basically have no control over there future. For example if a student athlete wanted to transfer to a different college they would have to sit out one academic semester no matter the circumstance. If a student athlete wants to transfer the coach can keep them from going to certain programs. Some coaches have the right to even protect players while there still...

Words: 1195 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Inclusion Activities Workbook

...Office of Human Resources Diversity & Inclusion Activities Diversity and Inclusion activities are simple ways to get people talking and listening to one another. It is only through understanding each other that we truly gain knowledge and can move forward together. While we can’t always walk in someone else’s shoes, we can take the time to inquire about how the shoe fits and if its path is smooth or riddled with pebbles. Social Justice • PO Box 6031, 412 Knapp Hall • Morgantown, WV 26506 • 304-293-8948 http://socialjustice.ext.wvu.edu/ Objectives Office of Human Resources There are many reasons you may choose to use and icebreaker or activity: to warm up or relax your group, to bring your group back together after a break or intense session, to introduce the next segment or to present your group with challenges that, as a team (together or divided into small groups or teams), your group must either overcome or address. Age & Appropriateness Icebreakers and activities are adaptable to your group and situation. When considering an icebreaker or activity, be sure to keep specifics about your group in mind, such as age and meeting focus. Please don’t overlook an icebreaker or activity because you think the group is too mature for it. Many groups, once aware that it’s ok to relax and have fun, will enjoy the experience of “being able to let go,” if only for a moment. Icebreakers Icebreakers are exercises that are intended to help a group of people begin the...

Words: 5524 - Pages: 23

Free Essay

White Collar Crimes

...Running head: White Collar Crimes in Basketball White Collar Crimes in Basketball By Willis Blake Jamie Orejan Saint Leo University MBA 510 9-26-08 One of the largest NCAA money fraud schemes in NCAA basketball history occurred in Atlanta, GA on December 2005. A report filed with a federal court in Texas regarding the investment scam indicates that nearly $6 million in assets were connected to Horizon Establishment. In December, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filed an emergency action in federal district court against Travis Correll & CO Inc. Most of the NCAA violators were coaches, players, and sports agents. These three SEC basketball colleagues were my friends. I worked side by side with Travis Correll in many of the Division II SEC Basketball games across the Southeast Region. The Southern Conference fired Travis Corell in the shakeup stemming from allegations of a multimillion-dollar investment fraud scheme. John Guthrie, the SEC Supervisor of Basketball Officials for more than two decades, was fired for unspecified reasons the day Correll resigned. The NCAA also released referee Jason McNeil that same afternoon. Correll’s firing in December stemmed from the Securities and Exchange Commission filling suit in Texas alleging he and others sold interests in purported foreign and international bank deposit programs promising risk-free returns of 4 percent to 12 percent. Travis Correll got this idea from Charles Ponzi who duped thousands of New...

Words: 671 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Smith V Store

...Week 2 Smith v. Store Smith was a part-time checker for a store. During one particular sale, she and a customer, had a disagreement about the “sale” price of a particular item; the customer left her merchandise at the counter and went to check the listed price on the shelf. While waiting for the customer to return, Smith voided out that sale and put the merchandise aside in order to continue helping the other customers in line. When the customer returned, she accused Smith of taking $10.00 that she had left on the counter with her merchandise. Smith denied even seeing the money. The store manager searched Smith’s coat pockets and did not find any money. He then balanced her cash drawer, and it balanced perfectly. The customer was still convinced that Smith had taken her money and continued to cause a loud scene. The store manager asked a female employee to accompany Smith to the washroom in order to strip search her for the money. Smith was asked to strip down to her briefs, and there was no sign of any money. The customer claimed that she had between $500-600 dollars in her purse; she wouldn’t count it out, but she maintained her belief that Smith had stolen her money. Smith quit her job soon after this incident and filed charges based on invasion of privacy against the store. FACT: A customer accused Smith of stealing money from her while she was retrieving a price for an item. Smith was searched, then taken into the restroom and strip searched. ISSUE:...

Words: 352 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Zimbardo and Milgram

...Critical Thinking Questions Zimbardo and Milgram Excelsior College SOC 101- Introduction to Sociology Module 2 - Assignment By: Tammy S. Wood Due Date: Sunday March 13, 2016 Professor: Charles Seagle Zimbardo and Milgram Experiments In this critical thinking assignment questions will be addressed that pertain to the Stanford prison experiment and the Milgram Experiment. The Milgram experiment participants were selected after responding to an advertisement to take part in a study at Yale University. The participants drew lots to find out who would be the "learner" and who would be the "teacher". Electrodes were placed on the learner and the teacher would ask questions, if question was answered incorrectly the learner would receive an electric shock. With each wrong answered the "learner" would receive a higher volt of shock("Milgram Experiment (Darren Brown),"n.d.). The Stanford Prison experiment participants were recruited by an advertisement placed in the newspaper offering male college students fifteen dollars a day to participate in a study of psychology of imprisonment. Participants were divided up into groups of two one group being the guards and the other group being the prisoners("Zimbardo shows how most evil comes from hierarachy," n.d.). The Stanford Prison experiment purpose was to understand the development of norms and the effects of positions, social expectations, and labels that are endured in a prison environment. Yes, this experiment is...

Words: 862 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Steve Prefontaine the Legend

...Steve Prefontaine the legend Introduction Many people have never heard of Steve Prefontaine. These people are not ignorant, they just have not followed Americas distance running. In distance running Prefontaine, better known as Pre, is truly a legend. The people that knew Pre could see the passion and desire in everything he did. Not many people have heard of Steve Prefontaine because of his short life-span. He was only 24 years old when he passed. The purpose of this paper is to inform you on who Steve Prefontaine really was, and what he achieved as a high schooler and in his college years. Methodology When I was first given this assignment, my mind started racing on who I thought was a leader and a catalyst for change. Everyone started calling out who they wanted to do and slowly but surely every famous person I knew was taken. I was really stumped and started researching “leaders” on google but everyone who came up didn’t seem interesting enough. My AVID teacher Mrs. Swain asked me what I enjoyed doing and I replied with running and she brought up Steve Prefontaine. She brought me up to speed about him and it got me interested how he for the longest time he held the record in every distance track race. As I began researching about him, most of the cites said the same thing: He held the record in every distance track meet and died at age 24. So for a while I couldn’t find out more information on him. In the article “The Legacy of Pre still lives on” gave me Pre’s...

Words: 1976 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Last Shot - John Feinstein Book Report

...Book Report Last Shot By: John Feinstein Stevie Thomas and Susan Anderson were winners of a 14 year old and under writing contest sponsored by the USA Basketball Writers Association. As top prize for their success of winning the contest they got to go to the NCAA Men’s Basketball Final Four held in New Orleans. At the final four they would get to meet and interview players from the four universities competing in the event. In addition, Stevie and Susan had their picture taken for the cover of the Workers Journalist. Duke, St. Joes, Minnesota State, and Connecticut were the schools fighting for the NCAA Men’s Basketball championship. Susan did her report to win her contest on Coach K for Duke. Susan lived in North Carolina and was a big Duke fan. Stevie who hated Duke, wanted St. Joes to win the hoops tourney. Stevie gave his report on the Palastra; the infamous basketball arena located in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. When Stevie and Susan arrived in New Orleans where the final four was taking place, they were given media passes to the event. Stevie and Susan went to the CBS station to conduct interviews with players and coaches. Upon arriving at the station, Stevie and Susan saw Chip Graber. Chip, who was Stevie’s favorite player on the Minnesota St. roster, was having a conversation with someone. Stevie and Susan hid to listen in on the conversation. It turned...

Words: 583 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Should College Athletes Be Paid

...Introduction Opening Comment: Image that you just scored the game-winning basket in the NCAA basketball tournament championship. Your shot just helped the school get tens of millions of dollars. Now by a show of hands, how many of you think that you should earn a share of that money? Central Idea: One of the most controversial and prominent topics in sports today is whether or not schools should pay their student-athletes to play their sports. I am going to argue as to why they should not be paid to play. Preview of Main Points: I will talk about five key reasons as to why collegiate athletes do not deserve to be paid to play. These are because of already established scholarships, would lead to decreased competition, the fact that there isn’t enough money for schools to give out already, a removal of innocence would occur, and recruiting would suffer among schools. Transition: First, I will explain why collegiate athletes already receive enough money from scholarships and free tuition. Body I. Tuition and the “Student” A. Already receiving thousands of dollars from athletic scholarships 1. According to a Parade Magazine article, Division I student athletes can receive between $20,000 and $50,000 per year. 2. A study done by a Big 10 assistant coach calculated that if the dollar value of the college’s tuition, room, and board is divided by the NCAA-mandated time limits for football practice, an in-state student athlete is getting...

Words: 1044 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Engaged Citizen

...responsibility is an integral and vital part of an organization and company’s global stratagem and approach. The NCAA, though it is a college-based organization, is also a non-profit association of more than 1000 organizations, institutions, and conferences relating to athletics. The NCAA does a prime job of executing their social responsibility goals and strategies, which is what has contributed to their success and global recognition. Strategic and calculated social responsibility, even more so on the corporate level, is able to play a vital role in any organizations strategic management. Social responsibility enhances the relationship between the organization and the interested party, who are almost always the fans, but can also include the media and local community partners. The NCAA takes much pride in their fans, in the media, and also in their community partners, but they also take pride in those who are employed by the sports industry. The NCAA has already placed an importance on social responsibility, on a national level, by implementing a program that looks to assist current assistant basketball coaches, who ethnic minorities, in their preparation to become head coaches. This program is one of many efforts to increase the racial and ethnic diversity in the coaching arena of National Collegiate Athletic Association coaches. (www.etd.ohiolink.edu) The MIAA, a division II NCAA conference, has a student-athletic advisory board who organized a conference-wide food drive as part of...

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Essay on College Athletes

...bringing up a burning question in college sports: should college athletes be paid? Some believe that it is essential for them to be paid for their hard work and dedication. Others believe that they are already relieved of future college debt, so why give them more? Each spectrum of this argument provides clear and concise evidence making it difficult to decipher which route may be the most reasonable. College is an expensive endeavor and student-athletes already gain a financial advantage and significantly larger benefits over the majority of the student population. The NCAA has always been considered an amateur league. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, an amateur is defined as, “one who cultivates anything as a pastime, as distinguished from one who prosecutes it professionally; hence, sometimes used disparagingly, as = dabbler, or superficial student or worker.” In 1957 the NCAA came to the conclusion, after years of avoiding the pressure, to subsidize and grant athletic scholarships. As young sports fans we aspire to be like our favorite athletes, but in reality only a small fraction of these students become professional level athletes after   their college careers conclude. College athletes are taking advantage of the financial opportunities that any other college student would be ecstatic to have. “Collegiate sports is not a career or profession. It is the students' vehicle to a higher education degree” (Horace 17)....

Words: 2066 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

UNC Asheville: A Short Story

...Giles breaks the press with incredible skill, but the goes to the basket too out of control and looses it out of bounds with twelve seconds left. “Remember, I got this” said Kyle. Kyle in bounds the ball to his point guard Ryan Archie, Winthrop holds its soft press and Ryan breaks it but with only four seconds left. “Trailing” said Kyle, and Ryan tossed the ball back setting a mini screen that was just close enough to illegal but remaining legal. Kyle launches a deep three. Three, two, one. The shot sinks at the buzzer. “ THE BULLDOGS ARE HEADING TO THE BIG DANCE” screams the bulldogs radio announcer Doug Patterson. Confetti, the big stage and the trophy ceremony came next and man did they deserve all of it and the thrill of getting to the NCAA tournament for the first time since all the way back in 2016. The Big South commissioner Fred Anderson handing the trophy to Kyle and the rest of his team says “ Congrats on all you have accomplished in this great season.” Kyle smiled and said “ Oh we're not done yet” said Kyle. “ The odds may be heavily stacked against us, but I think we can overcome the adversity. I mean, we have done it all year.” Coach Carter, the next day at practice acted as though the bulldogs hadn’t won anything yet, and that's how they wanted it. “ We score the most points in the country, assist on the most baskets in the country, we defend the best in the country and yet we’re still the number sixty-four overall seed. I don’t know about all of you but that pisses...

Words: 1480 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Essay

...College hoops' black coaching issue Myron Medcalf [ARCHIVE] ESPN.com | July 18, 2013 When a national sportswriter calls to talk about minority hiring in college basketball, folks of all races seem to get nervous. As I sought feedback following last week's release of the "2012 Racial and Gender Report Card: College Sport" by Central Florida's Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sport -- the report excludes historically black colleges and universities -- which states that the current pool of Division I African-American head coaches (18.6 percent through the 2011-12 season) is at its lowest mark since the 1995-96 season, people weren't sure what, if anything, they should say. Multiple administrators passed on the opportunity. The NCAA wanted to see my questions, and then it wanted a pre-interview phone conversation before it ultimately emailed its responses. The coaches who talked on the record always ended our chats with the same concern: "I didn't say anything that will make me look bad, right?" Shaka Smart Andy Lyons/Getty Images To reach Shaka Smart's level, black coaches often have to overcome certain labels. I don't blame them. It's an incendiary issue, because we're uncomfortable with race as dialogue. It's still a subject that makes athletic directors -- 89 percent of whom are white at the Division I level, per the report -- squirm. Minority coaches speak cautiously, because they don't want to be labeled as rebels or militants. That hesitancy is...

Words: 8597 - Pages: 35

Free Essay

Final Four Media Coverage

...Every spring avid sports fans look forward to the biggest college basketball tournament of the year, most commonly known as March Madness. This competition consists of both men’s and women’s NCAA basketball teams who compete in hopes of making it to the respected and heavily televised Final Four. The Final Four is the last game for each remaining team before the National Championship game, where the two deserving teams are matched up against each other. This series of competition creates a rich supply of content for sports media networks to influence viewer’s values and attitudes. Networks have become increasingly knowledgeable and schematic in using sport entertainment as a way to promote their ideologies, values, commercialization and interpretations of sport.         Studies have found that people turn to sports in the media for entertainment. The different forms of media are evolving and moving in a more prevalent direction than they have been in the past. With the explosive growth of internet users in the past decade, media companies have created a domain where they can input their interpretations of sporting events and coverage. These domains have become dominated by the 18-34-year-old demographic (Kian, Mondello & Vincent 2009) who use websites such as ESPN, the most widely used website for obtaining sports related news (Lefton, 2006 as cited in Battenfield, Redmond & Ridinger 2014), and Sports Illustrated to read about upcoming games, watch live coverage, or get the low...

Words: 4713 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Playing with the Boys

...Cassandra Halsted Mr. McKee English 190 7 March 2014 Playing with the Boys Sports have been a tremendous part of society all over the world for hundreds of years. From ancient competitions such as the first Olympic games in Greece, to modern exhibitions like the World Series or the Super Bowl, sports are a cherished and important tradition to many. Women were excluded from the first Olympic games in 776 B.C. They held their own games to honor the goddess, Hera, ruler of women and earth (History of Women). This is where separation and inequality first began for women in the competitive and discriminatory world of sports. In almost every modern sport, women are forced to play under different rules, lighter or smaller equipment, and receive less pay or less support for their hard work and dedication. Women have spent hundreds of years defending their rights, and they should not be taken away when it comes to the sports scene. Women deserve every ounce of respect as men in any and all categories, including athletics. There is no denying there are certain differences between a man and a woman's body. Generally speaking, men are taller, faster and have more upper body strength than women (Caitlin). But these differences in anatomy do not merit sports fans to ridicule or make a mockery of women's athletics. Women's sports have often been the butt of jokes and the object of derision, despite the fact that female athletes put every ounce of dedication into their sport as their male...

Words: 770 - Pages: 4