Premium Essay

Organizational Structure: Comparison of Organic and Mechanistic Structures

In:

Submitted By hengshen
Words 1792
Pages 8
To achieve organizational goals and objectives, employee activities within the organization need to be coordinated and managed. To achieve this coordination, the organization must have a structure to it. Organizational structure is essential in specifying reporting relationships, delineating formal communication channels and in linking all activities together toward organizational goal achievement. There are two primary structure types; organic and mechanistic. There are four main elements to organizational structure; centralization, formalization, hierarchy, and departmentalization.

These elements often coexist in organizational structures and their configuration will determine whether an organization is organic or mechanistic. Organic organizations are less formal and more flexible than traditional organizations and are characterized by such things as flexibility, informality, and knowledge based authority. An organic structure is laid out like a network and emphasizes horizontal specialization, personal coordination, and extensive communication. Organic organizations are generally flat and decentralized, with little reliance on formal authority, which enables faster decision making. Mechanistic structures are primarily hierarchical, with an emphasis on specialization, and vertical communication. Mechanistic structures also place an emphasis on control by relying on rules, policies, and procedures in conducting operations. Mechanistic structures are highly formalized and centralized and as a result are more rigid and resistant to change. Determining which structure is best is dependent on the stage of development the organization and its industry are in. Firms in mature, stable environments may find greater success with the mechanistic structure while established firms in dynamic or turbulent environments may find greater success with the organic structure.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Business Structure

...Organisational Structure For an organisation to be successful it needs a strong organisational structure. How the organisation is set up will directly impact the success or failure of the company. They need to be structured and organised in a way that will meet their goals and needs. Even though the organisational structure is focus on the company’s goal it also dictates how to report priorities and strategies of upper management. The organisational structure is a hierarchy of people and its functions. The organisational structure tells you the character of an organisation and the values it believes in. Therefore, when you do business with an organisation or getting into a new job, it is always a great idea to get to know and understand their organisational structure. Depending on the organisational values and the nature of the business, organisations tend to adopt one of the following structures for management purposes. Although the organisation follows a particular structure, there can be departments and teams following some other organisational structure in exceptional cases. However, some organisations may also follow a combination of different organisational structures as well. Follow this, I will now refer some of the Organisation Structures used nowadays and explain how can they benefit or damage their business, referring their advantages and disadvantages. Flat Organisational Structures use a reduce number of levels, and a wide span of control, which means...

Words: 1120 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Organizationaleffectiveness

...Organizational Effectiveness To be effective and achieve its goals, an organization must successfully respond to environmental factors. How can the effectiveness of an organization be measured? Various models of determining organizational effectiveness exist because organizations face different environments, they produce different products, their organizational members are made up of different kinds of people, and the organizations are at different stages of development. Each model is most useful to an organization having a particular combination of these environmental and organizational attributes. Two different underlying dimensions may be considered to develop models of organizational effectiveness. The first is the organization’s internal versus external focus. The second dimension is the organization’s emphasis on flexibility versus control. Flexibility allows faster change, whereas control allows a firmer grasp on current operations. When these two dimensions are drawn at right angles to each other, the first four models of organizational effectiveness can be plotted. They are the rational goal, open system, internal process, and human relations models. According to the rational goal model of effectiveness, an organization is effective to the extent that it accomplishes its stated goals. For example, the formal goals of the Toronto Blue Jays are to win their division, the American League pennant, and the World Series. With an open system model an organization...

Words: 4088 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Mechanistic and Bureaucratic Organisations Will Probably Struggle to Encourage Organisational Learning. Critically Evaluate This Statement in Relation to the Mechanistic and Learning Perspectives.

...Mechanistic and bureaucratic organisations will probably struggle to encourage organisational learning. Critically evaluate this statement in relation to the Mechanistic and Learning perspectives. Brocka and Brocka (1992, pg.2) suggests that organisations are “revolutionary compared to the strict, hierarchical, authoritarian organisations that existed in the past”. Mechanistic and bureaucratic organisations follow the same traits where the structure is needed for “efficiency, conformity and compliance” (Spencer, 1994, pg.448). The revolutionary aspect to organisations is shown by introducing learning into the organisation promoting the development for “searching for information, assimilating, developing and creating new knowledge on product, processes, and services” Wang and Ellinger (2011, pg.512). According to Sun and Scott (2003 pg.202) “the terminologies organizational learning and learning organization were once used interchangeably. However, in the mid-1990s there was a bifurcation into two streams” for the purpose of this assignment the terms learning organisation and organisational learning will be used on an interchangeable purpose. This assignment will show a clear definition of mechanistic, bureaucratic and organisational learning structures of organisations. By using my personal experience, examples and the use of case studies, then linking to relevant theories an argument will be made whether mechanistic and bureaucratic organisations struggle to encourage organisational...

Words: 2759 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Accounting

... |ES |— |1, 2, 3 |— | |2. Identify the six phases of the corrective |TF |10, 11, 13, 15, 16 |8, 9, 17, 18 |12, 14, 19 | |control model. | | | | | | |MC |39, 43, 49, 51 |38, 42, 44, 45, 46, 50 |40, 41, 47, 48 | | |ES |— |5 |4 | |3. Describe the primary methods of organizational |TF |21, 26 |20, 22, 23, 24, 28 |25, 27, 29, 30 | |control. | | | |...

Words: 6915 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Conceptual Analysis and Specification of Morgan’s Metaphors Using the Cast Method

...Morgan's metaphors Morgan (1986) distinguishes eight metaphors for organizations: machine, organism, brain, culture, political system, psychic prison, flux and transformation, and instrument of domination. Each metaphor highlights other aspects of organizational life (see Figure 4.1.). For further analysis, the metaphors can be grouped into three groups: the machine group, the organism group, and the mind group. The machine group only contains the machine metaphor (Paragraph 4.3.). The organism group focuses on the dynamic relationship of organization and environment and contains the organism metaphor and the flux and transformation metaphor (Paragraph 4.4.). The mind group (Paragraph 4.5.) contains two subgroups. The first mind subgroup concentrates on the relationship between the minds of persons and the organization as a social construct; it contains the brain metaphor, the culture metaphor, and the psychic prison metaphor. The second mind subgroup focuses on coordination mechanisms and power plays, and encompasses the political system metaphor and the instrument of domination metaphor. metaphor machine highlights efficiency, quality, and timeliness of production processes in a machine made up of interlocking parts attributes, structures, and development of organizations coping with their environments; evolutionary patterns in the interorganizational ecology the logic of change of organizations that dynamically and proactive adapt to an ecological environment effectiveness of...

Words: 16192 - Pages: 65

Premium Essay

Acc 803: Leo’s Four-Plex Theater Case

...Accounting, Organizations and Society 28 (2003) 127–168 www.elsevier.com/locate/aos Management control systems design within its organizational context: findings from contingency-based research and directions for the future Robert H. Chenhall Department of Accounting and Finance, Monash University, Clayton, Victoria 3168, Australia Abstract Contingency-based research has a long tradition in the study of management control systems (MCS). Researchers have attempted to explain the effectiveness of MCS by examining designs that best suit the nature of the environment, technology, size, structure, strategy and national culture. In recent years, contingency-based research has maintained its popularity with studies including these variables but redefining them in contemporary terms. This paper provides a critical review of findings from contingency-based studies over the past 20 years, deriving a series of propositions relating MCS to organizational context. The paper examines issues related to the purpose of MCS, the elements of MCS, the meaning and measurement of contextual variables, and issues concerning theory development. A final section considers the possibility that contingency-based ideas could encompass insights from a variety of theories to help understand MCS within its organizational context. # 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. 1. Introduction The three purposes of this paper are to provide a review of empirical, contingency-based research as it has developed...

Words: 26957 - Pages: 108

Premium Essay

Organization Behavior

...Organizational Behavior (OB) is the study and application of knowledge about how people, individuals, and groups act in organizations. It does this by taking a system approach. That is, it interprets people-organization relationships in terms of the whole person, whole group, whole organization, and whole social system. Its purpose is to build better relationships by achieving human objectives, organizational objectives, and social objectives. As you can see from the definition above, organizational behavior encompasses a wide range of topics, such as human behavior, change, leadership, teams, etc. Success isn’t  a destination it’s a process.   And the margin between successes is often  small.  Ob is all about  studying  the principles of defining  nd achieving success in your organization and life. Impact of ob Organizational behavior is an aspect of doing business within large companies that many executives have overlooked. This organizational behavior impacts every nook and cranny of a company. Thinking about the organizational behavior and how people act within a company can foster new ways of managing people that can have longer-term impacts on profitability. For example, unionized work forces may have a more negative environment then non-union work environments due to the natural adversarial relationships between company management and union officials. In unionized environments many employees may feel as though their supervisor is abusing them and therefore they regulate...

Words: 2768 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Evolution of Management

...Chapter two The Evolution of Management Theory Learning Objectives 1. Describe how the need to increase organizational efficiency and effectiveness has guided the evolution of management theory. 2. Explain the principle of job specialization and division of labour, and tell why the study of person–task relationships is central to the pursuit of increased efficiency. 3. Identify the principles of administration and organization that underlie effective organizations. 4. Trace the changes that have occurred in theories about how managers should behave in order to motivate and control employees. 5. Explain the contributions of management science to the efficient use of organizational resources. 6. Explain why the study of the external environment and its impact on an organization has become a central issue in management thought. A Case in Contrast Changing Ways of Making Cars Car production has changed dramatically over the years as managers have applied different views or philosophies of management to organize and control work activities. Prior to 1900, workers worked in small groups, cooperating to hand-build cars with parts that often had to be altered and modified to fit together. This system, a type of small-batch production, was very expensive; assembling just one car took considerable time and effort; and workers could produce only a few cars in a day. To reduce costs and sell more cars, managers of early car companies needed better techniques to increase efficiency. Henry...

Words: 14749 - Pages: 59

Premium Essay

Organizational Behavior

...Motivation and organizational structure ——A study on Tongchuangtongde Company Preface * Why do we choose to analyze the aspects of motivation and organizational structure of Tongchuangtongde? At one time, employees were considered just another input into the production of goods and services. But research has shown the effect of different working environments on productivity. Employees are not motivated solely by money but it is also linked to employee behavior and their attitudes. From the interview with Mr. Chan, we have realized that Tongchuangtongde does well in motivating employees, especially intrinsically. As a result, motivation is one of our focuses. Organizational structure affects organizational action in two big ways. First, it provides the foundation on which standard operating procedures and routines rest. Secondly, it determines which individuals get to participate in which decision-making processes, and thus to what extent their views shape the organization’s actions (employee involvement). Structural inertia is one of the main resistances to change for Tongchuangtongde. The company is faced with a structural change so we’d like to look into depth on its structural redesign. So we look into motivation and organizational structure to make this report. Introduction Chan Zuohai is a young entrepreneur who started several companies on his own. The first was in 1998 Tongchuangtongde Construction and Decoration company. In 2002, he founded Tongchuangtongde...

Words: 4531 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Mgc1 Study Guide

...edge over competitors. When resources are valuable, rare, imitable, and organized, they can be viewed as a company’s core competence. Describe what Porter's Five Forces Model is and how it is used in the strategic planning process  * Rivalry * The threat of substitutes * Buyer Power * Supplier Power * Barriers to Entry The competitive environment includes rivalry among current competitors and the impact of new entrants, substitute and complementary products, suppliers, and customers, In strategic decision making, Porter’s model is an excellent method to help managers analyze the competitive environment and adapt to or influence the nature of their competition. Explain the components of a SWOT analysis  A comparison of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats that helps executives formulate strategies. Managers formulate a strategy that will build on the SWOT analysis to take advantage of available opportunities by capitalizing on the organization’s strengths, neutralizing its weakness, and countering potential threats. Understand the types of corporate strategies that organizations can use and describe them  Corporate Strategy - identifies the set of businesses, markets, or industries in which the organization competes and the distribution of resources among those businesses. Concentration Strategy - focuses on a...

Words: 3105 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Dunkin Donuts

...are responsible for the allocation of resources, hiring, training and managing teams. The roles of a district manager starting new Dunkin’ Donuts locations are no different yet they include the responsibility for a smooth start. These added responsibilities include job design, organizational design, staffing functions such as recruiting and selection, as well as the implementation of a training and performance appraisal processes. Job Design Job design aims to reduce job dissatisfaction and employee alienation by means of repetitive and mechanistic tasks. Organizations attempt to increase productivity levels, satisfaction and motivation to employees through job design. Job analysis, job description, and job specification are the three standard approaches to job design (Baack, Reilly, & Minnick, 2014). Job Analysis Job Analysis is a process, which is followed right after position identification and position building in an organization chart. It is the first step in the process of hiring a candidate as it outlines the particular task required for each position created. Two approaches to job analysis best suited for our organization would be through comparison and experimentation. By using the comparison model, positions could be defined and staffed quickly due to being developed according to currently established and satisfactory standards in our organization, as well as other industry players. The experimentation...

Words: 1545 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Case Study on Sia

...To what extent do you think that SIA enables employees to work and deal with one another in a coordination and co-operative way as they work towards the goals of the business? This case study demonstrates how its performs an effective organization management and well training system, as being one of the largest airline company with over 29,000 employees, it extents of well organization make the most effective of resources in human and fiscal resources to achieve its’ organizational goal. How did Singapore Airlines enable employees to understand their role and how it fits into the work organization as a whole (Refer to lecture One: Figure 1.2: Why organization exit) Singapore airline (SIA) has been recognize as a well reputation branding for excellence services quality and financial performance, which are the essential elements integral to SIA’s success. People work together would be more productive and efficient than working along and as result in SIA organization. 1. Increasing specialization and division of Labor, of individuals to concentrate on their expertise, become more specialized and creates value. SIA offers four classes of service – suites, first class, business class and economy class, which specialized the variety tier of customers to deliver its outstanding level of services to their target audiences and leads to customer satisfaction. 2. Using large-scale technology, aircraft investment is one of the biggest investments as a full service airline....

Words: 1037 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Personality

...Introduction * * This assignment outlines some of the key findings and managerial implications of the Author’s Self, based on the Pearson, Prentice Hall Self-Assessment question bank. The selected question areas are grouped under three main categories of ““About Me”, “Working with Others”, and “Life in Organizations”. Firstly the assignment gives and opening to what self- assessment is. Second it dives deep to discuss the three areas mentioned above in detail. The assignment is given life by charts and figures created by the author to showcase the scores obtained in the self-assessment library. Lastly a two page description is given on what steps needs to be taken in order to arrive at the desirable state, followed by a conclusion which wraps up the discussion. * Self-Assessment It is said that a person’s perception of his abilities have consequences for his actions. If Shakespeare had a low self-belief, nobody would have come to know Macbeth. According to Ehrlinger and Dunning, as cited by Martinez and Swank (2003) one possible reason why women avoid career in science is that they underestimate their scientific reasoning ability. What is Self – Assessment? Self-Assessment acts as a powerful mechanism which allows an individual to look at their own performance, form conclusions about performance levels and act on those to create a development plan. Before any individual or organization try to develop a plan for performance improvement, it is first critical...

Words: 6263 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Etisalat

...IB 2-4 Tasks 1-2 Week 1 Jones: Chapter 2 – Basic Challenges of Organizational Design Differentiation - differentiation = process by which an organization allocates people and resources to organizational tasks and establishes the task and authority relationships that allow the organization to achieve its goals à process of establishing and controlling the division of labor/the degree of specialization o necessary because of increased complexity with growth Organizational roles - - organizational role = set of task-related behaviors required of a person by his or her position in an organization à identifiable tasks and responsibilities allow for accountability o organization structure is based on interlocking roles authority = power to hold people accountable for their actions and to make decisions concerning the use of organizational resources à results from differentiation into individual organizational roles control = ability to coordinate and motivate people to work in the organization’s interests Subunits: Functions and Divisions - - function = subunit composed of a group of people, working together, who possess similar skills or use the same kind of knowledge, tools or techniques to perform their jobs à as organizations grow, they differentiate into 5 different kinds of functions: o support functions – facilitate control of relations with environment and stakeholders (purchasing, sales & marketing, public relations, legal affairs) ...

Words: 20567 - Pages: 83

Premium Essay

Controlling- a Management Guide

...the company and specifically address planning, organizing, leadership, control and the external environment. Section1 - The External Environment As a manager at Just Web Inc you will play an important role in assessing the external environment. It will be important for you to understand your role in the customer’s needs through these assessments. Theses assessments will give you a baseline to start all projects as well as recognize a need for change prior to losing market share to other ISP’s. It is written “that to remain competitive they must explicitly manage their intellectual resources and capabilities” (Zack,N.D.) At Just Web Inc we will periodically assess the external environment to stay relevant in our business plan, structure, and methodology. To complete these periodic assessments we will use the strategic management process. This process is a six step process that you will use to identify goals, complete external and internal (SWOT) analysis, formulate a strategy, implement strategies, and then evaluate the results (Robbins & Coulter, 2009). Once this plan is developed it will give a path or process for the analysis, formulation, and implementation of our plan. After that I complete it provides us with the opportunity to assess our results. This is an excellent time to involve employees so that they can participate in the change. Section 2 – Planning As a manager at Just Web Inc, you will be responsible for planning in your department. Depending...

Words: 966 - Pages: 4