Free Essay

Plug Plot

In:

Submitted By leahj174
Words 909
Pages 4
Study sources B and D

Compare these sources as evidence for the causes of the Plug Plot disturbances in 1842.

Both sources B and D have a shared view on the fact that many people were provoked by the reduction of wages made by their employers which they believed to be deliberate as without the correct finances they were unable to survive and provide for their families. This was one of the main reasons why the rebelled against the poor factory conditions as employers thought it was vital to reduce wages so that they could succeed with their plan of the Anti Corn Law. Source B states ‘Thousands stopped work, forcing all to join them’. They did so because of a reduction in wages, almost without notice.’ This shows that many employees were desperate to get the governments attention in order for them to get involved and increase labour wages as they had no active involvement where factory workers liberty was concerned. Source D also agrees with this at it too states ‘The Plug Plot of 1842 began with reductions of wages’ hence why many people in 1842 rebelled, in some cases, striking workers stopped production by removed the boiler plugs from the steam engines in their factories. The Anti Corn Law was first introduced in Britain in 1804, when the landowners wanted to protect their profits by imposing a duty on imported corn. Source B also states ‘This was taken as the intention of employers everywhere.’ This shows how many workers were affected by these cut backs which could have caused the plug plot disturbances as many people believed that by encouraging more people to join Chartism they could get enough names on the petition to get their concerns heard such as the 1834 Poor Law factory conditions and church taxes on Nonconformists. Farmers feared that when the war came to an end in 1815, the importation of foreign corn would lower prices. This fear was justified and the price of corn was reduces. The manufacturers in particular were concerned that the Corn Laws would result in a demand for higher wages; therefore an Anti-Corn Law League was established and set up in 1839 so that workers would be paid less. Therefore source B and D and both similar as they both state that wages were intentionally reduced because of the Anti-Corn Law League, influencing people to riot and cause the Plug Plot Disturbances in 1842.

However, sources B and D also different in the reasons why wages were reduced and why the plug plot disturbances took place. Source B states that poverty was a major reason why wages had to be reduced “At Stockport 20,000 unemployed had no resources other than plunder. A large body of rioters pillaged the workhouses and more robbed the food shops” due to 1842 being the worst year for poverty and the spread of disease due to the Great Victorian depression, poverty was a major issue for the people. Source B stresses over the plundering that took place, such as people looting and stealing clothes from the workhouses and food from the shops. A rash of strikes broke out in August 1842 leading to many workers being laid off and others suffering wage cuts affecting their lives tremendously. Strikes spread from Lancashire and Yorkshire to the industrial parts of the Midlands, as the strikers continuingly tried to gain support from different areas they pulled the plugs from boilers, therefore forcing the factories to close down as work could not continue without the machines and lack of workers that had been fired. On the other hand, Source D blames the Anti-Corn Law League as it states that they deliberately encouraged employers to pick a strike to paralyse the government and assist their case for the repeal of the Corn Laws. Also, Source D mentions that the cause for the Plug Plot disturbances was due to drunkenness. ‘Before I spoke, some of the men, who were drunk and had rioted’ Thomas Cooper mentions that the Chartists are not to be blamed for the disturbances instead it was the drunken workers causing havoc. Cooper stresses drunkenness was the cause as he did not state that it was Chartists to blame but that the drunken workers were the motive of the disturbances. Therefore sources B and D both give different evidence for causes of the Plug Plot disturbances in 1842.

The provenance of both sources also needs to be taken on hand. Source B is a magazine that was written mainly for the target audience of rich wealthy people in order to somewhat entertain them and make them feel good about themselves. The source blames the Radicals for making matters worse only to benefit themselves. Source D is a source that was written by a key witness and a participant in the Plug Plot event, Thomas Cooper in which he places the blame on other things but the Chartists, being a Chartist himself he may not have wanted to put a bad name on them but also to clear his own.

Considering both sources I believe that Source D gives better evidence as to why the Plug Plot disturbances took place as the person who writ it had a first-hand account as to what happened and due to him being a Chartist himself he would have known why these events took place. Although source D did have important information included.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Strategic Management

...- 15 * 16 - 20 * All Pages Screenwriting is a skilled trade, and a good screenplay must be molded and managed with craftsman hands. But so does a screenwriting career. It takes dedication, fortitude, and time – ten years to have overnight success - but if you’re willing to do the hard work to turn your ideas into completed screenplays as well as build a screenwriting career, follow this 20 step roadmap to screenwriting success:   Click Here to Start 1. Watch Tons of Movies Lots of them. Good, bad, old, new. All genres. Make it your quest to become exposed to all things film. It’s a badge of honor to earn film nerd status, because as we all know, “Nerds Rule the World.” The more movies you see, the easier it’ll be to identify plot points, sequences, and act breaks. You’ll even start watching the clockwhen viewing DVD’s at home, as you’ll be inundated with the desire to analyze, but you’ll know when you experienced something truly great when you stop thinking and just enjoy the ride. 2. Read Tons of Screenplays As many as possible. This helps to understand screenplay form as well as see how the pagetranslates to the screen. You get a sense of different screenwriting styles and voices, and most importantly you will be exposed to the application of clear, concise writing, while using creative brevity to maximize the visual medium. Learning how not to direct on the page and maximize white space is all part of it. Check out some websites that offer free downloadable screenplays...

Words: 3308 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Term

...Narrative Has a point Moral or lesson to be learned Chronological series of events. IE: timeline Descriptive Sensory 1. Introduction 2. Narrative a. Purpose i. A narrative essay tells a story. It can be fact or fiction, however it does tell a story. Generally speaking the story has a meaning of sort. Narratives are interesting and creative ways to teach a moral to others. In the Narrative I want a Wife, Brady tells a story when her friend, a man, came to her house and made a comment that he wanted another wife. Thinking about what her friend had said, she decided that she would like the same. (Brady, 1971) b. Plot in a chronological series of events ii. The moral of a narrative is what would drive the plot. The plot of a narrative should be in a distinct chronological order. This makes the narrative easy to understand and easy to follow. The chronological order of narratives are mostly in a timeline effect. 1st this happened, then this happened, then something else happened. Or I said this to Bob. Bob replied with this. I did this after Bob’s response. Whether it be in chronological, spatial or built oin dramatic order, the structure of narratives are always easy, and clear to follow. iii. c. Creative tension iv. A good Narrative also contains creative tension. Creative tension will allow the write to build up the reader in suspense. Sometimes, the creative tension actually compels the reader in...

Words: 701 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Seeking Justice

...Running Head: JUSTICE 1 Seeking Justice: A Film Critique Paul J Baker Jr 11-26-12 ENG 225 Instructor: Hope Umansky Justice 2 A film is a marvelous piece of art to the one who creates it. The story and plot that is told can have some profound meanings and sometimes portray things that we wish would happen. Actors come and go but sometimes they reach the level of a star. Nicholas Cage is one such star. We remember his past works in movies like Faceoff, Gone in 60 Seconds, and National Treasure. These films show this actor as an action star. You can never know if the character he is playing is going to be good or bad. However in recent years critics have stated that Cage has been lost. Performing in movies like the Sorcerer’s Apprentice has appeared that Cage was searching for something. They have wrote him off as the action star that he was but in a triumphant return in 2011, the movie Seeking Justice showed that Cage is still who we remember. This movie, because of its actors, plot, cinemaphotography, and direction bring back the action thrillers that we have been longing for. Seeking Justice is one of the best films made in 2011. “The screenplay has to come from somewhere, and that somewhere is the mind of someone who wants nothing more than to tell a story. After all, without a story, Indiana Jones doesn’t recover the Ark of the Covenant, E.T. never phones home, and Batman never catches the Joker. Every movie, from the biggest, loudest...

Words: 1560 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Theme and Elememt in a Short Story

...abstract, something broad: The theme in a story is associated with an idea that lies behind the story. Every story narrows a broad underlying idea, shapes it in a unique way, and makes the underlying idea concrete. That's how theme is created. In other words, the theme in a story is a representation of the idea behind the story. To identify a story's theme it's necessary to look beyond the plot. The plot tells you what happens in a story, but the theme tells you what the story is about. What you are required to do, therefore, in identifying theme is to answer the question, How? You should ask questions such as these: How does the writer use setting to narrow the underlying idea? How do characters make particular aspects of the underlying idea clear? How does conflict reveal the strength or worth of the underlying idea? (Clugston) The story of “A Worn Path” theme is in the strength of the woman as she faces adversity. It is from a third-person point of view, giving the reader just enough distance from the main character and her conflict, and to see aspects of conflict that she does not. The plot of the story is by Phoenix Jackson, an elderly woman who travels a familiar path through the woods to town during Christmas. She is in a hurry to get medicine for her grandson and return to him, and...

Words: 541 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Comparative Essay

...Ethan found out that Lena was the girl in his dreams. Lena had a lot of problems from the time that she moved back her hometown. Lena told Ethan her dark secrets (being a caster) and family history, the story starts with Ethan’s love for Lena and her upcoming problem, which is her 16th birthday. Which medium: the novel or the film is most effective for telling this story? We will answer this question by comparing three parallel scenes from the novel and its filmed adaptation, in terms of how well each scene develops the plot, characters and overall theme of the story. There are hundreds of famous novels, which filmmakers turn them into a movie, whether they could be an unforgettable one or a boring movie, thus it’s important for the audience and the fans to figure out which one was more effective and successful. The plot development in the novel was good enough to represent the main points to the audience meanwhile in the movie the director cut so much of the plot, which made the movie so different from the novel. One was the telepathic conversation Lena and Ethan had in the novel, which was really important since most of the dialogs of the novel were from...

Words: 1399 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

"You All Know" by William Shakespear

...problems for readers unfamiliar with the conventions of pastoral, especially those who find it just too artificial and incredible to grasp imaginatively. After all, how are we to understand the unmotivated family hatreds which launch the action? We are simply not given any sufficiently detailed look at why Oliver hates Orlando (he himself does not understand the reason) or why Duke Frederick hates Duke Senior and turns on Rosalind so suddenly or, what is most surprising of all, why the nasty people whose animosities have given rise to the plot so suddenly and so conveniently convert and become nice people just in time to wind the plot up happily under the supervision of the goddess Hymen, the Greek deity of marriage, who arrives as an unexpected but welcome guest. But these features of the plot which we might find unconvincing if we demand naturalism (that is, if we insist on treating the play as a "Hence" story) are little more than standard plot devices in "And then" stories, common in a genre like pastoral, which makes no claims to naturalistic motivation. Such plotting serves to launch and to conclude the comic confusion. The main point of the play here,...

Words: 922 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Language Development

...will give a clear correlation. If I was to investigate the  relationship of two other categories, like the eye colour and the IQ,  I believe that however interesting and amusing the results would be,  they would not provide too clear a relationship, or any conclusive  information.  The data provided gives information about 1183 girls and boys at  Mayfield High School, who have been categorized into their year  groups. These year groups begin with the students entering their  teens, and end in their mid-teenage years.  In order to be able to compare girls and boys in each year, I will  represent the distribution of heights and weights for both sexes in  each year in various forms. I plan to use stem and leaf plots, scatter  graphs and box plots, and a wide range of calculated data, like the  mean of the heights and weights, their interquartile range and their  Body Mass Index.  The data that will be represented will not be all the data provided,  as if I were to do this, then I would be plotting 2366 datum points  which would be ideal, however time does not allow for this number of  points. So, instead I will take a stratified sample of the total data  and use this sample in the investigation.  From these representations of the data, conclusions will be drawn as  to how the relationship between height and weight changes with age and  sex, but before this is done, any anomalous data points will be  considered, so that they do not affect the overall...

Words: 318 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Essays

...Name __________________________________ Period _______ Plot: Freytag’s Pyramid Gustav Freytag was a Nineteenth Century German novelist who saw common patterns in the plots of stories and novels and developed a diagram to analyze them. He diagrammed a story's plot using a pyramid like the one shown. [pic] Freytag's Pyramid: The Breakdown 1. Exposition: setting the scene. The writer introduces the characters and setting, providing description and background. 2. Inciting Incident: something happens to begin the action. A single event usually signals the beginning of the main conflict. The inciting incident is sometimes called 'the complication'. 3. Rising Action: the story builds and gets more exciting. 4. Climax: the moment of greatest tension in a story. This is often the most exciting event. It is the event that the rising action builds up to and that the falling action follows. 5. Falling Action: events happen as a result of the climax and we know that the story will soon end. 6. Resolution: the character solves the main problem/conflict or someone solves it for him or her. 7. Dénouement: (a French term, pronounced: day-noo-moh) the ending. At this point, any remaining secrets, questions or mysteries which remain after the resolution are solved by the characters or explained by the author. Sometimes the author leaves us to think about the THEME or future possibilities for the characters. You can think of the dénouement as the opposite of the exposition:...

Words: 586 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Lifa as Teenager

...R.J Meaddough, III: The Death of Tommy Grimes Setting: When and where does the story take place? Characterize the social environment. Comment on their language, hobbies, the setting and their class. In what way does the setting influence the plot of the story? Back your arguments by finding quotations in the text. Point of View and narrative technique: Which point of view is used in this story, and how does it affect the readers’ comprehension of the text? Account for the plot of the story in a chronological order. What is the effect of the extensive flash back technique that the author uses in this story? Back your findings with quotations from the text. Character characterization: Characterize the father. Among other things you should account for his values. What reasons are there to kill, according to Pa? Account for the nature of the relationship between father and son. In what way does Tommy’s father succeed as a father and in what ways doesn’t he? Back your findings with quotations from the text. The beginning and the ending: Account for what is going on in the opening paragraph, and compare this to its closing counterpart. Pay special attention to the symbols used in both sections. What development has Tommy undergone during this day? Symbols: In this text, nature is often used to describe the characters’ feelings as well as the general atmosphere. Find at least five examples of this in the text...

Words: 282 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Unit 1 Assigment 1

...case, the father is not here yet, therefore. The kid soon forgets the question and turns to other thing. In the same way, Little Tango is the first penguin in the zoo has two daddies. This is a challenge for the parents to search information inside the book to explain for their kid at home. There is a lot of way to be a family and here is a lot of way to leave family as the birds have different feather. (Claim) The story children’s book should not contains sexually and violence because their awareness will not property into the plot of story. I agree that because children’s comprehending has a limited into a point of view. They just cannot image how could it happen and they will continually be confusing themselves by the details of story. (Rebuttal) However, if the children’s story books cover with violence and sexually the kids will be having an open-mind in their perspective. They will have awareness to what is right and what is wrong in the plot. They are going to solve their curiousness by their own critical thinking way. It is possible happening to the children whom have their questioning...

Words: 688 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Unit 2 Jurney to Identity Text Analysis

...Unit 2 Journey to Identity Text Analysis |Title: Boy in The Striped Pajamas |Author: John Boyne |Publication Date: 1/05/06 | |I chose this book because (respond in at least 2 sentences): I chose this book because I heard it was fantastic and I’m fascinated with stories from the past. | Connecting with Character: Protagonist ________________Bruno__________________________________ |How do you relate to this character? | |Similarities |Differences | |Beginning: none |Beginning: We are in completely different age groups | | | | | | | |End: We are both curious and have a taste for adventure. |End: I wouldn’t have been so naive ...

Words: 394 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Conflict Between Doc Martin And Erotomania

...In the show “Doc Martin”, there is conflict between many different characters acting in the show. According to McCornack, “Conflict is the process that occurs when people perceive that they have incompatible goals or that someone is interfering in their ability to achieve their objectives” (246). The characters I will be writing about from the episode “Erotomania”, Doc Martin and Louisa, Danny and Louisa, and Mark and Julie. First, the conflict between Doc Martin and Louisa occur in several different situations. One situation is when Doc and Louisa get drunk together. They express feelings and then Doc falls asleep. The next morning when Louisa confronts Doc about his feelings, he does not remember. Doc and Louisa have avoidance during their conversation in town when Louisa just says she wants to have a drink. She doesn’t come out and say right then her feelings about Doc. According to McCornack, “Avoidance is ignoring the conflict, pretending it isn’t really happening or communicating indirectly about the situation” (255). When they talk in the town, they have some under lying tension between them. Louisa has cumulative annoyance toward Doc. Cumulative annoyance is irritation that grows towards someone else (McCornack, 255). Next, Danny and Louisa have conflict during this episode as well. Danny decides he wants to marry Louisa and move himself and her to London. A problem Danny and Louisa have is personality difference. Danny wants to go and do things, and Louisa wants...

Words: 547 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Quality Management

...Costs of Quality   1.      What are the three costs of quality? Explain each. GOOD Appraisal – Costs of activities designed to ensure quality or uncover defects; during the process Prevention – Costs of preventing defects from occurring; prior to manufacturing product BAD Failure - costs caused by defective parts or products or by faulty service Internal – failures discovered during productions (i.e. increases costs, material and products losses, scrap, downtime) External – failures discovered after delivery to the customer (i.e. returned goods, reworking costs, liability claims, loss of goodwill, penalties- loss of customer, warranty costs   2.      What is the point at which costs associated with improvement are no longer warranted? 3.      What is the costs of customer dissatisfaction? Quality Tools 1. Flowcharts - identifies the sequence of activities or the flow of materials and information in a process. a picture of the steps needed to accomplish a task. Compares and contrasts actual versus ideal flow of a process. Allows a team to reach agreement on process steps and identify activities that may impact performance. Serves as a training tool 2. Check sheets - special types of data collection forms in which the results may be interpreted on the form directly without additional processing. An organized method of recording data. Hash marks 3. Distribution Repair time (minutes) Frequency Distribution Repair time (minutes) Frequency Histograms...

Words: 324 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Oedipus Rex

...artistic ornament, the several kinds being found in separate parts of the play; in the form of action, not of narrative; with incidents arousing pity and fear, wherewith to accomplish its catharsis of such emotions…Every tragedy, therefore, must have six parts, which parts determine its quality – namely, plot, characters, diction, thought, spectacle, melody”. The work Oedipus Rex fits very well into this structure using the specific characteristics of; late point of attack, exposition, several key incidents, climax, catharsis, protagonist, antagonist, hamartia, anagorismos, metabasis, and perpetia. Aristotle’s first principle of tragedy is that of the plot. He defines the plot as how the incidents are presented to the audience in the structure of the play. This is the most important of the parts and holds the meat and potatoes of a tragedy. According to Poetics the best plots should be complex, arouse fear and pity, and involve a high degree of suffering for the protagonist. These are all seen in Oedipus Rex as there are plot twists, we learn to care about Oedipus and the decisions he makes, and finally understand his pain when he eventually claws out his own eyes. The plot of Oedipus Rex utilizes a late point of attack and exposition as it begins after many of the several key incidents in the play have already occurred, but the audience is given all the information it needs over the course of the...

Words: 892 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Trying To Get Ahead Of Ernest Cline's Plot

...The Author vs. The Reader My Experience Trying to Get Ahead of Ernest Cline’s Plot Ernest Cline’s Ready Player One gives its reader plenty of hints and foreshadowing events that nearly gives the reader full power to always be one step ahead of the plot. Throughout my experience, I was in constant battle with Cline to see if i could prove myself in a sense where either I could predict exactly what was to happen based off of what he fed me, I could not predict anything and simply let him lead me through the plot, or I thought I was getting ahead of him but he had just led me to a dead end to potentially mask another plot twist. The Wins On multiple occasions, I was able to predict the way in which the Cline would eventually take his plot. Right from Cline’s introductions and depictions in the third chapter of the novel, I easily identified that Aech would be a major ally for Wade throughout the book while I-r0k would take an antagonist role in the novel. Consequently, it came to me as no surprise when I-r0k finally turned on them and attempted to blackmail Wade in the thirteenth chapter. In between those two points in the story, I also succeeded in predicting how Morrow and Halliday had a falling out, as Cline disclosed on page 121. Back on page 55, Cline had portrayed Morrow and Halliday’s relationship as if they had...

Words: 1151 - Pages: 5