Free Essay

The Drain Theory

In:

Submitted By Spandana
Words 1551
Pages 7
Of all the national movements in colonial countries, the Indian national movement was the most deeply and firmly rooted in understanding the nature and the character of colonial domination and economic exploitation. This exploitation in the country started with the entry of the Company in 1757. Better late than never, this exploitation was realised by 1860. The period 1875-1905 became a period of intellectual unrest and spreading national consciousness. The main reason for India’s poverty was identified as the drain of wealth to England. The nationalists undertook a vigorous agitation to get rid of this evil. They used all forms of public communication such as speeches, letters to the British newspapers, articles in journals, correspondence with officials, evidence before official commissions and committees, private correspondence etc; to communicate this message to a wider spectrum of people. It is no doubt due to the efforts of that men that we realised “the financial, political and intellectual drain” we were subjected to. They felt that what British can do is to lend India back it’s wealth to develop it’s resources.They say that drain is not only loss of wealth but also loss of capital. Drain not only cut current national savings but even diminished the existing stock of inherited national capital. They felt that drain also hindered industrial development, india’s way to economic salvation. The nationalists laid emphasis on the question ‘What was this drain due to?’ and found out the following sources of drain.
 Inordinate employment of europeans in indian administration, army and railways
 Home charges/expenses of the Indian government in Britain: These constitute the payment of interest on indian public debt, guaranteed railways, the cost of military and other stores supplied to india, and the civil and military charges paid in England on account of India, including the cost of secretary of states establishment at the indian office and the payments of pensions and allowances to european officials of Indian government.
 Foreign capital invested in trade or industry in india
 Negative balance of trade (excess of exports over imports)
Then, ‘How was this drain to be reduced?’ The nationalists also suggested the following remedies to curb this drain.
 Indianisation of services
 Curtailment of home charges
1. Burden of public debt can be reduced by raising it in india rather than in england
2. Burden of railway debt can be reduced by cutting down the speed of railway construction
3. By purchasing government stores in india itself
4. Fair apportionment of charges between india and england

 Reducing the import of foreign capital
 Promoting indian industry, so no dependence on imports The Britishers argued that the view, excessive employment of english-men as a source of drain, was very narrow and proved the shallowness of drain theory. They felt that our nationalists were ignorant in economic matters as they forgot the fact that without the home charges, there would be no British rule in India.They commented on no evidence of ‘ surplus revenue transfer ’ from India to Britain. They told that the rapid growth of foreign trade and the rapid construction of railways are indication of India’s economic development. They tried to highlight the benefits of British rule in India such as:
 Invisible imports:
1. Shipping services
2. Insurance charges on imports and exports
3. Expenditure incurred by indian students and travellers abroad
4. Heavy imports of gold and silver
 Advantages of foreign capital:
1. Railways are constructed; Irrigation was developed
2. Establishment and development of plantation and other industrial enterprises
 India’s political connection with England enabled it to borrow from the world’s cheapest market
 Dedicated British officials and non-economic reform in the form of
1. Peace and order
2. Modern administration
3. Security against external aggression
4. Good government
They felt that India got an administration favourable to economic evolution cheaper than she could provide it to itself. The nationalists, dissatisfied with the British arguments, struggled to show proof of this ‘continuous and ceaseless drain’ with their counter arguments. They did not agree with the manipulative concept of invisible imports. Indian leaders didn’t object the employment of foreign technicians in indian factories (or) qualified teachers in the universities and they actively campaigned for increasing expenditure on the education of indian students. They agreed that this useful drain is essential. Military and civil services were for British interests but not for India’s benefits. They felt that the accumulation of foreign capital suppressed the indigenous capital, which when developed can help the Indian industry better. They said that the speedy construction of railways is unnecessary and it resulted in useless drain.They felt that because of drain there not only incurred direct loss but also the secondary injury of losing trade relations with other foreign countries. On the plane of law and order, India was not properly protected. Moreover British itself was left free to exploit it. The non-economic reforms from truly economic point of view are nothing but drain. Europeanisation of services left oun skilled labour jobless and led to irrepairable loss of knowledge and wisdom leading to our economic backwardness. Nationalists felt that the drain was much larger than it was anticipated to be. They felt that it is something more than excess balance of trade. They held the the East India Company responsible for the origin of public debt. The public debt was brought into existence during the rule of Company to meet the expenses of the wars leading to the British conquest of India and to enable India to pay the company’s dividends. Compensation paid for the shareholders for the transfer of power from Company to the Crown, cost of suppression of 1857 revolt , the cost of wars etc; all burden was laid on common man in the name of public debt. The nationalists also demanded the treatment of India as other British colonies such as USA. USA gave away interests for borrowed capital and kept profits for itself. It was paying the excess export surplus for the loans it had taken in the past, indicating that it once had import surplus. But, India had no import surplus in the past. It is paying British for no reason which is a strange phenomenon and stand still example of our exploitation. All the nationalists struggled for the impeachment of this taboo. The most famous of these men was Dadabhai Naoroji. Dadabhai Naoroji, the Grand Oldman of India, dedicated his entire life for economic analysis of the deplorable drain. He felt that drain is the natural economic result of foreign rule. It is the burden of millions and millions that are drained year after year. He says that the British must have a return for their services rendered to India, but it must let Indians have the means to pay for it. He was not in favour of political association between India and England. He always stressed on ‘the material and moral drain’ caused by the British rule in India. He condemned that if India is to be regenerated by the British, it must pay the price. He quotes ‘the romance is the beneficence of British rule, the reality is the bleeding of British rule.’ He says the whole British rule is moving in a wrong, unnatural and suicidal groove. He felt that replacing indigenous capital with foreign capital stood for exploitation, impoverishment and despoliation. For all these remarks, he was regarded as ‘disloyal, extremist’ by the British authorities. But, the people of Gandhian era held him in high respect and called him ‘The Father of Indian Nationalism’. He urged his fellow-men, especially the one’s belonging to anti-drain theory school of thought, not shift the focus from drain theory as all other economic issues are only red-herrings drawn across this path. He wanted drain theory to be the central concept of nationalist propaganda and agitation. It is this man who arrived at an inevitable conclusion that India must be politically free if this deliberate plunder and destruction is to be checked. He raised the slogan of ‘Swaraj (or) Self-government’. His qualitative leap from a belief in the lasting nature British rule over India to the demand fo independence raised tremors in the nationalist circles. It changed the political outlook of entire nation and finally led us to independence. By reviewing all this, I came to know India’s struggle for independence and the role drain theory played in leading us to this marvellous event. For any theory the British were able to suggest remedies, but not for drain theory. The speciality of drain theory is that it is so simple to understand and can be communicated very easily from a nationalist to any lay person. Our money is draining away from our land is something that anybody can understand and this made the people of our nation to raise the slogan of ‘No Drain’ and filled us with the spirit for freedom struggle.

REFERENCES:
(1) The Rise and Growth of Economic Nationalism in India, Bipan Chandra; People’s Publishing House, New Delhi, 1966.
(2) The Economic History of India in the Victorian Age, Vol-2 : From the Accession of Queen Victoria in 1837 to the Commencement of the Twentieth Century, Romesh Chandra Dutt; Published in Great Britain by Kegan Paul, Trench and Trubner, 1904.
(3) India’s Struggle for Independence (1857-1947), Bipan Chandra; Penguin Books

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Human Capital

...Brain Drain: Intentions to Migrate by Future Malaysian Professionals Abstract Globalisation has led to the fierce competition for skilled labor between firms and thus leading to intense labor mobility worldwide. Shortfall in professionals in host countries has led organizations aggressively search for foreign professionals needed to fill up the gap in their own country. Most commonly observed is the outflow of professionals from developing countries to the developed nations more often than not at the expense of the developing countries. Malaysia is one developing country which is not spared from this phenomenon that is threat to the economy. Malaysian professionals are heavily sought after because they are able to adapt themselves anywhere in the world, multi-lingual and inexpensive. Malaysian professionals are steadfastly flowing out to fill the soaring demands abroad. If this situation were to continue, Malaysia would have to endure a shortage of professionals within the country and will create the issue whether our talent pool can maintain equilibrium to support our robust industry growth. Approaches to offset this phenomenon have to be carried out immediately. Thus, this paper will examined the relationship between the push-pull factors and intentions to migrate which eventually may lead to Brain Drain. Seeing that brain drain of our Malaysian professionals will continue to go on which definitely will have an impact on our transformation, researcher believe that an intention...

Words: 9398 - Pages: 38

Free Essay

Thermo

...ME  410L  –  Pressurized  Steam  Generator  (PSG)    -­‐    Instructor:  Reza  Baghaei  Lakeh   Thermal Science Laboratory ME410L Pressurized Steam Generator (PSG) Instructor: Reza Baghaei Lakeh Fall 2010 ME  410L  –  Pressurized  Steam  Generator  (PSG)    -­‐    Instructor:  Reza  Baghaei  Lakeh   Experimental Apparatus The   Armfield   Saturation   Pressure   Apparatus   has   been   designed   to   introduce   students   to   how   the   temperature   of   water   behaves   at   its   boiling   point   with   variation   in   the   absolute   pressure.   Saturation   curves   can  be  obtained  by  the  student  and  compared  with  published  steam  tables.  The  quality  of  steam  exiting  the   apparatus  can  be  determined  using  a  throttling  calorimeter  connected  at  the  point  of  discharge.   A   bench   top   unit   comprising   a   boiler   vessel   and   pipe   loop   with   a   pressure   relief   valve   to   limit   the   operating   pressure   to   8   bar   gauge.   A   sight   glass   on   the   front   of   the   boiler   allows   the   boiling  ...

Words: 1498 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Brain Drain

...The term ‘Brain Drain’ was first coined by the British Royal Society and they used it to explain the transfer or outflow of scientists and technologists from one’s homeland to countries like The United States of America and Canada in the 1950s and early 1960s. This is normally used as another word to describe the movement of Human Capital (HC hereafter) – where the net flow of expertise was more heavily focused in one direction as compared to the other. Phase-1 (1950s to 1960s) Grubel and Scott identified that developed and developing countries are advanced in the fields of science and technology while Pierpaolo Giannocolo concluded that a lesser developed country which sends its qualified and skilled workers to these countries will not only benefit from this socially but also economically. Initially, the outflow of scientists and technologists was focused from Europe (and primarily the UK) to The United States and Canada. On the other hand, Kannappan stated that the heavy outflow of skilled labor from poor countries resulted in the nations losing their economic and productivity potentials. Similarly, according to Portes, the concept of ‘brain drain’ was mainly harmful for the native countries as it resulted in the development of the North and backwardness of the Southern countries. Phase-2 (1970s-1990s) The reviews from a majority of the scholars concluded that the concept of ‘brain drain’ is in fact not beneficial for the native country as it usually results in the host...

Words: 2382 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Madera Canyon Research Paper

...Many residents of Las Vegas know of various drainage ditches or canals dug to redirect the flow of rainwater. Not many know of a unique tunnel which lies on the border of Henderson, in Madera Canyon. What makes this tunnel unique, is its peculiar drainage pattern. Residents of the area report that every month, a strange moaning could be heard from a small concrete storm drain. Concerned, the locals in the neighborhood decided to investigate, entering the tunnels themselves and investigating its dark secrets. Aside from the teenage graffiti and debris left inside the tunnel, nothing of note was found. At around seven o'clock however, the noise ceased. Perplexing the locals to continue their investigation. Before they could re enter the tunnels,...

Words: 423 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Nursing

...Theorist Selected Description of Theory In 1860, Nightingale was considered as the first women to hold the right for publishing her theory with reference to the significance of the environment on the patient and healing. Many factors along with the patient’s connection with the environment tend to contribute to healing process and that engrosses air, light, temperature, water as well remaining clean (Parker, 2006). Her theory also states that it is the nurse’s profession to assist out the patient to consign him or her in the finest circumstances for nature to proceed (Gourlay, 2004). She trusted that the environment can circuitously and unswervingly have an effect on a patient’s health and it has enormous advantage on the healing process when restricted and dealt with patient recovery led her to trust the belief nature cures. Nightingales theory encourages that maintaining the environment, meaning the overwhelming of air pollutants, the patient must use his or her energy to help them deal with the negative effects of these pollutants which, in turn drains him or her of what is important to the healing process. It is also Nightingale’s belief, the conditions of the home, community and health care setting are very important to the health and healing process. The environment is also what can be changed and manipulated by the nurse (Parker, 2006). She believed the environment is important to the patient’s health, that nurses should support the environment to help in the healing...

Words: 457 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Tm-Sg Mosfet

...What is Drain Induced Barrier Lowering? Ideally, drain current Ids should be constant i.e. independent of Vds in saturation region. In reality, Ids increases with Vds in saturation region because of the following two regions: 1) Channel length modulation: As Vds increases, length Leff decreases, hence current increases. 2) Drain Induced Barrier Lowering: As Vds increases, Vt decreases, hence current increases. Drain Induced Barrier Lowering (DIBL) is a decrease in threshold voltage of the transistor at higher drain voltages. This decrease is the result of charge neutrality. The three electrode charges of the device viz. the gate, the source and the drain balance the combined charge in the depletion. As the drain voltage is increased, the depletion region of the p-n junction between the drain and body increases in size and extends under the gate, so the drain assumes the greater portion of the burden of balancing depletion region charge, leaving a smaller burden for the gate. As a result, charge present on the gate retains charge balance by attracting more carriers into the channel, which leads to lowering the threshold voltage of the device. The channel becomes more attractive for electrons or in other words the potential energy barrier for electrons in the channel is lowered. Hence the term “barrier lowering” is used. DIBL increases as the channel length is reduced because the source and drain form pn junctions with the body, and so has associated built-in depletion...

Words: 1109 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Mgmt 520 Week 2

...Airplanes Agency: Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Action: Notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) I do travel a lot through different airlines so reading this interests me because regular customers like us wouldn’t even notice of such problems and this could make anyone think twice before getting in an airplane. Even though this will not affect me economically, having the idea that something is wrong with the airplanes, could make me not travel and visit my family for a while. 2. Describe the proposal/change in your own words. Answer: Airworthiness Directives are required to do repetitive functional checks for blockage of the forward strut drain line, and doing corrective actions; and a one-time cleaning of certain forward strut drain lines. This repeated inspections will to detect and correct blockage of forward strut drain lines, which could cause flammable fluids to collect in the forward strut area and potentially cause an uncontrolled fire or cause failure of engine attachment structure and consequent airplane loss. 3. Write a comment which you would submit to the administrative agency regarding this proposed regulation. (For example, are you in favor of the proposed regulation or against it? Why?) If the deadline for comments...

Words: 1249 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Repairing Jobs That Fail to Satisfy

...two types of employees:- Satisfied Employees are those who can't wait for work again the next day, they love their jobs and are passionate about it and perform well on the job Dissatisfied Employee hates the very thought of getting up to face work again the next day and complains constantly about their jobs, they create a very high turnover and are usually not good at what they do. So managers have to look out for theses tell tale signs and address them as soon as possible to avoid potential problems because they are less motivated to achieve the organizational goals; this is what is happening at Drain Flow. In the long run this will affect customer service and satisfaction and reduced job performance and loyalty. According to Hawthorne's theory happy workers are productive workers, satisfied employees the ability to increase customer satisfaction and loyalty. Drain Flow surveys reflects customer dissatisfaction:- * 40% of the total survey respondents felt that their experience was not good while * 30% of the total survey respondents disclosed that they would use a competitor the next time they experience a plumbing issue Explain the advantages and disadvantages of using financial incentives in a program of this nature. What, if any, potential problems might arise if people are given money for achieving customer satisfaction goals? What other types of incentives might be considered?...

Words: 693 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Brain Drain

...International Journal of Manpower Emerald Article: Brain drain from Turkey: the case of professionals abroad Nil Demet Güngör, Aysit Tansel Article information: To cite this document: Nil Demet Güngör, Aysit Tansel, (2008),"Brain drain from Turkey: the case of professionals abroad", International Journal of Manpower, Vol. 29 Iss: 4 pp. 323 - 347 Permanent link to this document: http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/01437720810884746 Downloaded on: 12-05-2012 References: This document contains references to 35 other documents To copy this document: permissions@emeraldinsight.com This document has been downloaded 1649 times. Access to this document was granted through an Emerald subscription provided by IQRA UNIVERSITY KARACHI For Authors: If you would like to write for this, or any other Emerald publication, then please use our Emerald for Authors service. Information about how to choose which publication to write for and submission guidelines are available for all. Additional help for authors is available for Emerald subscribers. Please visit www.emeraldinsight.com/authors for more information. About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com With over forty years' experience, Emerald Group Publishing is a leading independent publisher of global research with impact in business, society, public policy and education. In total, Emerald publishes over 275 journals and more than 130 book series, as well as an extensive range of online products and services. Emerald is both COUNTER 3 and TRANSFER...

Words: 12197 - Pages: 49

Free Essay

Theories of Learning

...Edward Lee Thorndike Assuming Thorndike's revised a law of effect to be valid, do you feel classroom practice in the United States is accordance with it? Child rearing practices? Explain. Thorndike's revised lot of the facts stated that reinforcement increases the strength of a connection, where as punishment does nothing to the strength of a connection (text). What this tells me is that when someone is stating their opinion and is encouraged or agreed-upon by others this exit him on to continue and gives them confidence in what they’re saying but if they do not get a positive response. When it comes to teachers in the class room, when the student gets an answer correct they tell them good job, when they get the answer wring they say good try but do not praise them like they would if they give them the correct answer. Some teach this way and some are very bunt to say not that is wrong. The same with parenting the parents are trying to always make their child feel good and at time they do not want to tell them that they are wrong in fear of hurting their feelings so they do not react at all. Discuss Thorndike's principle of belongingness and polarity. Thorndike's principles of belongingness and polarity basically states that when elements belong together it is easier to learn and retain them than elements that do not belong together (Pritchard,2009). For example, when a child or adult is reciting the alphabet they start with a and A with Z. If a child or adult was asked to...

Words: 3341 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Explain How Theories, Such as Dependency Theory and World Systems Theory Can Contribute to an Understanding of Changing Patterns of Global Power (15 Marks)

...Explain how theories, such as Dependency theory and World systems theory can contribute to an understanding of changing patterns of global power (15 marks) The changing global power of countries can be difficult to understand as there are a variety of views and theories used in order to explain the shift. The recent developments of BRIC countries has an influence upon this and may be a reason as for why theories such as the Dependency theory and The Worlds system theory are not in line with the current patterns of global power and why they may be considered as over simplistic and ‘outdated’. Dependency theory was out forward by A.G Frank and is used in order to explain how countries maintain power through neo-colonialism- this term refers to ‘new colonialism’. This is where countries such as Ghana remain under the control of the wealthier countries, even though they are supposedly independent. Dependency theory suggests that the capitalist core, for example the USA and the UK keeps the periphery in a state of underdevelopment by exploiting its cheap resources and taking their trained skilled workers. This is often referred to as a ‘brain drain’ whereby the skilled workers are not given any opportunities in their home country; as a result they migrate to the core in order to get a job therefore resulting in a shift of knowledge from the core to the periphery. Additionally by selling expensive manufactured goods. The developing world effectively helps the developed world to become...

Words: 604 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Electtonic, Layout Cmos, Comparator, Dac

...DESIGN OF A HIGH-SPEED CMOS COMPARATOR Master Thesis in Electronics System at Linköping Institute of Technology by Ahmad Shar LiTH-ISY-EX--07/4121--SE Linköping 2007-11-07 DESIGN OF A HIGH-SPEED CMOS COMPARATOR Master Thesis in Electronics System at Linköping Institute of Technology by Ahmad Shar LiTH-ISY-EX--07/4121--SE Supervisor: Erik Säll ISY, Linköping University Examiner: Mark Vesterbacka ISY, Linköping University Linköping 2007-11-07 Presentation Date 2007-11-07 Publishing Date (Electronic version) 2007-12-07 Department and Division Division of electronics system Department of Electrical Engineering Linköpings university Linköpings Sweden Language English Other (specify below) Type of Publication Licentiate thesis Degree thesis Thesis C-level Thesis D-level Report Other (specify below) ISBN Master Thesis ISRN: LiTH-ISY-EX--07/4121--SE Title of series (Licentiate thesis) Series number/ISSN (Licentiate thesis) Number of Pages 30 URL, Electronic Version http://www.ep.liu.se Publication Title Design of a high-speed CMOS comparator. Author(s) Ahmad Shar A bstract T his m aster thesis describ es the d esign of high-speed latched com p ara tor w ith 6-bit resolution , full scale voltage of 1 .6 V and the sa m plin g frequ ency of 25 0 M H z. T he com p arato r is d esigne d in a 0.3 5 9 m C M O S process w ith a sup ply voltage of 3.3 V . T he com parator is designed for tim e-in terleaved bandp ass sigm a-delta...

Words: 6559 - Pages: 27

Free Essay

China's Wealth Inequality

...between population shifts and consumption levels. Part Three explores the theoretical underpinnings of growth-pursuant poverty reduction, namely the ‘trickle-down effect’. Attention is given to the concept of the trickle down and its intersection with Chinese domestic policy. Part Four highlights the notable divide between urban, rural, coastal and inland regards for growth and development and considers both the reasoning and implications of this dichotomy. Part Five looks at gender discrimination and the one-child policy throughout China and highlights how economic growth has in many ways exacerbated this problem. The problem of gender division is considered through the theme of rural-urban difference and how this is contributing to the brain drain effect. In order to frame the inequality debate in China, it is necessary...

Words: 2057 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Educational Preparation

...pass state licensing exams known as the National council licensure examination (NCLEX) that tests for minimum technical competency for safe entry into basic nursing practice. (AACN, 2014). They teach the fundamentals of nursing and nursing skills. The ADN programs are less expensive and can get you into the workforce relatively quickly. Many nurses begin with the ADN route because of time limitations or money, and then go back to school for their BSN. BSN programs are offered at the University level and usually require 4-5 years of education. The cost is significantly more and there are fewer programs available. The curriculum of the program includes basic fundamentals of nursing, additionally incorporating research concepts, theory, leadership, management, and public health. It also prepares the student to take and pass the NCLEX exam. When considering which educational route to take one should know that quality patient care relies on having a highly educated nursing workforce. Research has shown that lower mortality rates, fewer medication errors and positive outcomes are all linked to nurses prepared at the BSN level (AACN, 2014). Both programs produce nurses that can pass the NCLEX and...

Words: 874 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Problem Statement

...HOW TO WRITE A STATEMENT PROBLEM YOUR PROPOSAL WRITING COMPANION Compiled by Henry M. Bwisa Professor of Entrepreneurship Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology E-mail bwihem@yahoo.com Website www.professorbwisa.com November 2008 INTRODUCTION It is a constant complaint among those who evaluate proposals that the most frequent deficiency noted by them is the lack of a clear problem 1 statement to define and guide the inquiry. The issue of how to write a problem statement becomes important. WHAT IS A RESEARCH PROBLEM? Generally speaking a research problem is a situation that needs a solution and for which there are possible solutions. If a situation has no possible solutions then it makes little or no sense expending resources researching it. Take this statement, “everybody wants to go to heaven but nobody wants to die”. Dying looks like a problem that needs a solution yet there is no possible solution to it. People must die. A research on how people can live forever makes little or no sense. A research problem may be described as an incongruence; a discrepancy between what is and what ought to be. It may be also described as the gap in knowledge that needs to be filled. WHAT IS A PROBLEM STATEMENT? A problem statement is the description of an issue currently existing which needs to be addressed. It provides the context for the research study and generates the questions which the research aims to answer. The statement of the problem is the focal point of...

Words: 2640 - Pages: 11