Free Essay

The Public Realm and the Common Good

In:

Submitted By lj96
Words 1256
Pages 6
"The public realm is the connective tissue of our everyday world," as James Howard Kunstler argues in "The Public Realm and the Common Good” (Kunstler 521). Kunstler published his book, Home from Nowhere: Remaking Our Everyday World for the Twenty- first Century, in 1996. His claim is that communities of America have become very “dismal” because they are no longer functioning properly as the connective tissue (521). He believes that “when you degrade the public realm, you will automatically degrade the quality of your civic life” (523). In his essay, Kunstler also provides a second part of his two- part definition of the public realm: “the public realm is the physical manifestation of the common good” to show the necessary relationship between the surroundings and the behavior of society (521, 523). In an attempt to explain these definitions of the public realm in Kunstler’s essay, this essay will examine the relationship between “chronological connectivity,” the “common good” and “citizenship” to show the deterioration of “civic life” because “consumers” are not playing their roles as responsible “citizens” and no longer care for their communities (523, 524). The link between "connective tissue" and "chronological connectivity" are meant to support the idea that our lives were affected by others decision, and we will affect our own futures. the futures that we create will affect the future for generations to come. Kunstler's essay takes place in Saratoga Springs, New York from about 1911 to the 1990's, at and around, the Grand Union Hotel (524). This hotel was once the largest hotel which allowed people to experience the best part of the city and was thought of as the centerpiece of the town where all members of the community could meet up (524). As Kunstler expresses "where I live, Saratoga Springs, New York, there once existed a magnificent building called the Grand Union Hotel” (524). Kunstler describes how the architecture of the streets "enhanced the lives of everybody in town," and "nourished our civilization" (524, 525). The building in itself represented Kunstler's idea of "chronological connectivity." The Grand Union Hotel was a place that could be enjoyed by everyone, it not only connected the town and "citizens" to its past, but was built to be there for the future (524). He later goes on to discuss how "in 1953 America stood at the brink of the greatest building spree in history, and the very qualities that made the Grand Union Hotel so wonderful were antithetical to all the new stuff that America was about to build” (525). The Grand Union Hotel was “demolished with a kind of mad glee” and was replaced with a strip mall. Kunstler describes the new strip mall as "the anti- place" because it did not house that connection between the past and the future (525). Put soundly, he feels the consumers felt “it was okay to simply throw away the past. They, [the ‘consumers’], certainly didn’t care about the town’s past, and their interest in the town’s future was limited only to technicalities of selling dog food and soap flakes” (525). "Consumers" no longer realize how their decisions will in the long run affect their futures. Now-a-days people have become too involved with their personal lives and what they need to accomplish. We have become too caught up in the hustle and bustle of our everyday lives that we no longer see nor have time for the simple things. We have lost sight of what is most important and are too caught up in the now, that we are no longer take our futures or our childrens' futures into consideration. We have made life a race. Life is now a competition of whose business will succeed, who will earn more profit, who will rise to the top. We have become quite selfish which, in turn, has played a part in the destruction of our communities. James Howard Kunstler believes that "community, as it once existed in the form of places worth caring about, supported by local economies, has been extirpated by an insidious corporate colonialism that doesn't care about the places from which it extracts its profit or the people subject to its operations” (521). The corporate industry does not care about citizens, but only cares about consumers and the growth of their industry. Kunstler holds it to be true that modern community is worsening because consumers are taking over. In fact, in his essay, he writes "consumers, unlike citizens, have no responsibilities, obligations, or duties to anything larger than their own needs and desires, certainly not anything like the common good” (523). It is clear that because there is no longer any equilibrium, the community can not function as previously. Kunstler defines civic life as "what goes on in the public realm," and continues to convey that "civic life r vefers to our relations with our fellow human beings- in short, our roles as citizens” (523). Because there is no longer that bond between humans, there no longer seems to be a clear understanding on what "civic life" should really be. In his book Brave New World, Aldous Huxley explains that “There is no civilization without social stability” (Huxley 42). One can conclude that James Howard Kunstler thinks that in order for a community to function as a whole there must be balance and interaction between, not only the “consumers,” but the true “citizens” as well. There has been a disconnection between "consumers" and true "citizens." "Consumers" do not care about the same things "citizens" do and therefore no longer interact with "citizens." If "civic life" means that there is a nexus between all human beings, this is proof that there has been some sort of degradation of "civic life." Kunstler's definition of the public realm is that it is "the connective tissue of our everyday world” (521) and that “the public realm is the physical manifestation of this common good”(523). He asserts that “chronological connectivity lends meaning and dignity to our little lives” (524) and that “connection with the past and the future is a pathway that literally charms us in the direction of sanity and grace” (524). Referring back to the building of the new strip malls, it is evident that Kunstler believes that the new way of building homes, schools, and other buildings shows that people no longer care about the community they live in. It is also evident that he believes these same people are not worried about what their community will be like in the future. Architecture is poorly being built, because “consumers” would much rather spend the money needed to build decent housing on advertisements for things that will not have much meaning in the future. “This disconnection from the past and future ends up diminishing us spiritually, impoverishing us socially, and degrading the aggregate set of cultural patterns that we call civilization” (524). In the beginning of his essay Kunstler states that “their architectural shortcomings aside, these places are dismal because the public realm that binds them together is degraded, incoherent, ugly and meaningless” (521). All in all, Kunstler makes it clear that in order for America to improve its modern day communities, the correlation between "chronoligical connectivity," the "common good," and "citizenship" must be restored, "consumers" must regain sight of what matters most and reclaim their role as true "citizens." They must no longer care for “meaningless” objects, but in turn should take responsibility and control of the things that are longer lasting and will affect their futures, therefore being more enjoyable.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Importance Of Copyright Law

...SUMMARY Copyright law, which mostly deals with the author’s right over a particular work against the general public is said to follow the Lockean theory of Labour which states of natural entitlement to the fruits of labour. This forms the basis of the argument and further criticism in the paper titled: ‘Locke, Labour and Limiting the Author’s Right: A Warning Against a Lockean Approach to Copyright Law’. The author, Carys J. Craig forms a basic contention that the Lockean Approach to Copyright law as such focuses only on the rights of the Author in relation to his/her work, while leaving out the important element of public interest. Following the Labour – Desert theory, which plays prominent role in the Lockean Approach, the author argues that...

Words: 1870 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Intro to Polsci

...of governance in which the rulers are held accountable for their actions in the public realm by citizens, acting indirectly through the competition and cooperation of their elected representatives. 1. System of Governance – is an ensemble of patterns that determines the method of access to the principal public offices which includes but not limited to: * Characteristics of Actors admitted to or excluded from such access. * Strategies that actors may use to gain access * The rules followed in the making of publicly binding decisions Note: To work properly, the ensemble must be institutionalized – that is to say, the various patterns must be habitually known, practiced, and accepted by most, if not, all actors. Furthermore, the preferred mechanism of institutionalization is a written body of laws undergirded by a written constitution or any other informal or traditional basis. * These forms, characteristics and rules are bundled together and given a generic label e.g. democratic, autocratic, despotic, dictatorial, tyrannical, totalitarian, monarchic, aristocratic, etc… 2. Rulers – persons who occupy specialized authority roles and can give legitimate commands to others. What distinguishes democratic rulers with others are the norms and conditions of how the former came to powerand the practices that hold them accountable for their actions. 3. Public Realm – encompasses the making of collective norms and choices that are binding on the...

Words: 855 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The European Reformation

...merging forces. It was in the 1530’s that the statutes of Henry VIII began to collate an official break from the papal authority of Rome. The 16th century proved to be a boisterous period in the history of England. The uncertainty associated with the stability and religious beliefs of the government were crucial factors in the unclear identity of England until the 1600's. As is often the case with defining periods in history, timing was of grave importance as centuries of Catholic corruption collided with the beginnings of a religious debate all across Europe. The increasing need for an English heir to the throne manifested in the strong will of King Henry VIII. The English Reformation was driven by changes in government policy, to which public opinion gradually accommodated itself; it was nurtured from a political affair...

Words: 2105 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Child Rearing Interview Paper

...own. However, I was surprised to find out that his childhood was a lot like mine. Brazil is among the most culturally and racially diverse country in the world, with over 195 million people living there and a variety of child rearing practices. There is a huge margin for diversity in parenting styles among many other this, as is the common trend of this quarters class. Most Brazilians live in urban areas and tend to have diverse historical and cultural backgrounds. Through this interview, I discovered that the way Dani grew up was quite similar to those being raised in a middle-class European American family....

Words: 636 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

True Blood Summary

...Kate Finch completed a study on the popular HBO series, True Blood. The research was an analysis of the Vampire Rights Amendment through public relations in pop culture and the theme of post feminism. The research is about the view post feminism view of public relations in pop culture using True Blood as a model. It shows the use of promotion, persuasion and public relations to draw in an audience. “Views interpretations are profoundly influenced by the social discourse in which they are interrelated.” (Brunsdon and Spigel,, 2007, pg. 260) It is important cause it gives the audience a deeper view of the feminism culture in popular culture, while allowing people to people it in the form of a television show that they would be able to spot and...

Words: 1806 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Environment and Urbaization

...Environment and Urbanization http://eau.sagepub.com/ The eco-city: ten key transport and planning dimensions for sustainable city development Jeffrey R Kenworthy Environment and Urbanization 2006 18: 67 DOI: 10.1177/0956247806063947 The online version of this article can be found at: http://eau.sagepub.com/content/18/1/67 Published by: http://www.sagepublications.com On behalf of: International Institute for Environment and Development Additional services and information for Environment and Urbanization can be found at: Email Alerts: http://eau.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts Subscriptions: http://eau.sagepub.com/subscriptions Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav >> Version of Record - Apr 4, 2006 What is This? Downloaded from eau.sagepub.com by guest on August 13, 2012 The eco-city: ten key transport and planning dimensions for sustainable city development JEFFREY R KENWORTHY Jeffrey Kenworthy is Professor in Sustainable Cities at the Institute for Sustainability and Technology Policy at Murdoch University in Perth. He is best known for his international comparison of cities around the theme of automobile dependence. He has published extensively in the transport and planning fields for 26 years and is co-author with Peter Newman of Sustainability and Cities: Overcoming Automobile Dependence (1999) and The Millennium Cities Database for Sustainable Transport (2001) with Felix Laube...

Words: 11633 - Pages: 47

Premium Essay

Who Is Jacob Abbcott's Elizabeth I?

...Elizabeth I by Jacob Abbcott is a biography about the Queen of England, Elizabeth first of her name. It details her childhood, oppression by Queen Mary, and her reign as the Virgin Queen for forty-five years. It is evident from her life that while she had a long and prosperous reign as Queen, she had a very petulant character that was quite ill tempered and manipulative. While this arguably does not have an ill effect on her reign, there a numerous occasions in which her vindictive, obstinate nature has had an affect on her decisions and how she is regarded. One of the first points I would like to bring to the reader’s attention is how she acted during Queen Mary’s reign. Despite being imprisoned at Woodstock for 3 months, when Queen Mary...

Words: 610 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Buddhist Socio-Political Philosophy

...State, (London: Oxford University Press, 1962), p. 22.] The definitions of Raphael and Macler have the merit of being based on what is common to all states. There are many definitions of state. However, almost all definitions of ?State? contain four essential elements: people, territory, government, and sovereignty.[footnoteRef:8] This view is widely accepted. [8: C.C. Rode, op. cit., p. 05.] According to Buddhist Scriptures, the state is not an independent thing, such as the ruler, the government, or land; but the combination of four important elements: territory, people, government, and sovereignty or independence. The concept of the state in the Buddha?s time consisted of four elements, just as we find in the modern concept of state. The word ?state? in English is similar to, and practically identical with, the term ?Ratha? in the P?li language, which means a reign, kingdom, empire, country, or realm.[footnoteRef:9] [9: Rhys Davids and William Stede, (ed.) Pali-English Dictionary, (Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1975), p. 53.] The Buddha did not speak of an ideal government, or an ideal state, because he recognized the legitimacy of every political system. He did not regard political system as a prime factor. The spirit of the politician who exercised power was most important. The ruler of the state should run the state for the common good, benefit and happiness of people. The state, according to the Buddha, is nothing more than a place to seek truth and well-being of the...

Words: 5940 - Pages: 24

Free Essay

Baudrillard

...modernity .A sharp critic of contemporary society, culture and thought. He was born in cathedral town of Reims, France .According to Gane (1993) he told interviewers that his grandparents and his parents became civil servants. Baudrillard also claims that he was the first member of his family to pursue an advanced education and that this led to rapture with his parents and cultural milieu. His notable ideas were on hyper reality, sign value and simulacra. Baudriallard’ s published work emerged as part of a generation of French thinkers including Gilles Deleuze,Jean- Francois Lyotard ,Foucault ,Derrida and Lacon who all shared an interest in semiotics and he is often seen as a part of post structuralist philosophical school .In common with many post structuralists ,his arguments consistently draw upon the notion that signification and meanings are both only understandable in terms of how particular words or signs interrelate .Baudrillard thought ,as do many post structuralists that meaning ,is brought about through systems of signs working together .In contrast to post structuralists such as Foucault, for whom the formation of knowledge emerge only as the result of power, Baudrillard developed theories in which the excessive , fruitless search for total knowledge lead almost inevitably to a kind of delusion. According to Ritzer (2008), amongst the postmodern social theorists, Baudrillard is one of the most radical and outrageous of...

Words: 1727 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Development Communication

...resources. All attempts by successive regimes to nip the problem in the bud have failed. With the benefit of hindsight, virtually all the Nigerian leaders who have come in as physicians have left office as patients. What factors precipitate political corruption and why has corruption become endemic and intractable in Nigeria? The paper interrogates corruption in Nigeria through the prisms of Clientelism, Prebendalism, Patrimonialism, Neopatrimonialism, Soft State thesis and the theory of Two Publics. The article contends that these theories for a very long time have not only provided credible theoretical frameworks for the understanding of the development tragedy in Africa in general but also of the pandemic and seemingly insoluble problem of political corruption in Nigeria in particular. However, as a point of departure, the paper argues that rather than fattening the primordial public, the ‘robberies’ that have taken place at the civic public have further pauperized the primordial public, if fattening in this sense is taken to mean social and economic development. The paper further provides some...

Words: 8603 - Pages: 35

Premium Essay

Is Community Engagement a Solution to the Ethical Problems Associated with ‘Spin’? or Does It Just Create a New Set of Problems?

...‘Community engagement’ shows us the ways of how ethical communication can encourage individuals and groups participate and involve in political debates (Demetrious, 2012). It gives individuals in the society has the right and freedom to speak, to challenge, to provoke awareness through participation in public debate. ‘Democracy’ is the conceptual provenance of ‘community engagement’ (Demetrious, 2012). In other words, community engagement plays an important role in our democracy system. As Birch and Glazebrook (2000, p.41) state that corporate is under a great pressure to increase its profit, to keep a good relationship with its investors. Without doubt that ‘spin’ is a strategy for corporate in common use to frame information in a way that can be easily accepted by public who are related tosw. Gare also state that ‘The business community is becoming more isolated from the community at large and looking after its own interests’ (cited in Birch and Glazebrook 2000, p.41). Using the theories of the citizenship (Hudson & Kane 2000) and the communication (Habermas 1989) this essay will discuss the role and relationship of ‘community engagement’ to society and how ‘community engagement’ can be a solution to ethical problems associated with spin. The case study “The Wrribee toxic dump” will be used to demonstrate the arguments. Community engagement is a big theory that included both citizenship theory and communication theory. Hudson and kane (cited in Demetrious 2012, p.2) define...

Words: 2223 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Cybersecurity

...group on cybersecurity and U.S.-China relations, which the two authors organized and co-chaired. The research was motivated by our sense that: 1) the many policy issues involved in cybersecurity, especially in its impact on foreign relations, were already significant and would grow rapidly in importance in the coming years; 2) that such issues, if not well managed, could provide a major source of international friction, especially in U.S.-China relations; and 3) the newness of the field added a particularly complicating factor, making cybersecurity one of the most important but least understood emerging flashpoints in global security. A key aspect of the effort was to convene several dozen knowledgeable Americans from both the private and public sector, including the civilian government, military, corporate, think tank, and university communities. With such dynamic and fast-changing events playing out, the Brookings project not only sought to study the key issues in cybersecurity and how they impact U.S.-China relations, but also to break down some of the organizational and bureaucratic stovepipes that have limited leaders and expert groups as they seek to build the type of understanding crucial for developing sound policies. The working group did not seek to provide final answers to all the various questions that trouble relations in this space. Rather, participants saw a critical need first to build a framework for understanding the key trends and risks in the cyber arena, as...

Words: 17963 - Pages: 72

Premium Essay

Functions Of Religion In The Philippines

...Calvinists believed in living frugally and to be away from worldly consumptions. Investment became a holy creed. Therefore, Weber was able to prove his point that religion in this case, Calvinism had an influence on economic development. Political debates, economic situations and gender norms will always religious behaviour. Religious symbols ad rituals are often integrated with the material and artistic culture of the society. FUCNTIONS OF RELIGION According to Emile Durkheim, religion does serve for the society irrespective of the beliefs and practises carried out by people. 1) It gives meaning and purpose to life – it has for sure helped in ancient times to understand the functioning of the world in one way if connected to the spiritual realm. However, still...

Words: 1010 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Oop Concepts

...familar with the following OOP concepts; classes, objects, attributes, methods, types. If not, then this article might not be in your realm. I'd suggest starting with the basic concepts of C++ before you attempt to understand the more indepth concepts that I'll be discussing in this article. When we speak of OOP concepts, the conversation usually revolves around encapsulation, inheritance and polymorphism. This is what I will attempt to describe in this article. Inheritance Let us start by defining inheritnace. A very good website for finding computer science definitions is http://www.whatis.com. The definitions in this article are stolen from that website. Definition: Inheritance Inheritance is the concept that when a class of object is defined, any subclass that is defined can inherit the definitions of one or more general classes. This means for the programmer that an object in a subclass need not carry its own definition of data and methods that are generic to the class (or classes) of which it is a part. This not only speeds up program development; it also ensures an inherent validity to the defined subclass object (what works and is consistent about the class will also work for the subclass). The simple example in C++ is having a class that inherits a data member from its parent class. class A { public: integer d; }; class B : public A { public: }; The class B in the example does not have any direct...

Words: 482 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Corruption in Government

...Corruption in Leadership: Public Service and Government Cynthia Klecha Abstract Corruption throughout the world is extensive. Corruption is defined as the twisting of integrity. A corrupt individual is an opponent of the truth; their virtues and ethics are deficient. In the United States, people in all positions of private district, public assistance, and government bureaus have been entangled in varieties of corruption. Corruption crimes include bribes, insider trading, patronage, embezzlement, electoral fraud, kickbacks, unholy alliances, conflicts of interest and several others. Corruption is a weapon that demoralizes the credibility of public institutions. It attacks the morality of justice and damages society. Effective law enforcement is essential to corroborate anti-corruption efforts. Law enforcement agencies are constructing anti-corruption teams to detect and punish any public or government official, along with any public servant who violates corruption laws. Introduction Corruption throughout the world is extensive. Corruption is defined as the twisting of integrity. A corrupt individual is an opponent of the truth; their virtues and ethics are deficient. Corruption is a weapon that demoralizes the credibility of public institutions. Corruption attacks the morality of justice and damages society. Corruption crimes include bribes, insider trading, patronage, embezzlement...

Words: 4681 - Pages: 19