Free Essay

The Significance of Circumcision

In:

Submitted By mom2katientj
Words 813
Pages 4
The Significance of Circumcision In an article from the Journal for the Study of the Old Testament in June 2000, Dr. John Goldingay writes about circumcision. Dr. Goldingay is currently the David Allan Hubbard Professor of the Old Testament at Fuller Theological Seminary. He is also an author, writing several novels to include Men Behaving Badly and After Eating the Apricot. Dr. Goldingay also holds a membership on the Society of Biblical Literature and serves on the editorial board for the Library of Hebrew/Old Testament Studies (Fuller). In his article, Dr. Goldingay discusses the troubling issues behind circumcision. Why did the Lord choose to make this one sign of belief exclusive to men? Most signs of the covenant can apply to everyone, but circumcision can only apply to men. There have been many attempts to justify the significance of gender-exclusive submission. One states that when two people become “one flesh” (Gen2.24), only one individual needs the mark of the covenant. This speculation has not been convincing (Goldingay). There have been several reasons to justify the use of this practice. Possibly the reason the Lord chose this act of dedication was to ensure further offspring for his followers. By removing the foreskin it promotes fertility. With fertility, the Israelites can hope to gain economic power, status and greater achievement. Other traditional motivations include cleanliness or hygiene, it helps to avoid infection, and it symbolizes the individuals trust in the Lord. This oath would be frightening, by allowing his son to be circumcised, he trusts the procedure will not threaten the potential reproductive ability for further offspring for his bloodline. There have been many references to circumcision in the bible. While traveling back to Egypt, YHWH attempts to kill Moses. During the fight, Zipporah circumcises her son, and then touches Moses with the bloody foreskin. After Moses is touched, Yhwh leaves him alone. (Exodus 4:24-26) The question as to why Moses’ son had to be circumcised to save his life still stands. Was Moses circumcised? Was his age a factor in him not being circumcised? Abram is approached by the Lord when he was ninety-nine years old. The Lord established a covenant with him and tells him he “shall be circumcised in the flesh of your foreskins, and it shall be a sign of the covenant between Me and you” (Genesis 17:1-11). Joshua was instructed by the Lord “to circumcise himself and the sons of Israel again the second time” (Joshua 5:2). This instruction came as a result of the male children born while in the wilderness had not yet been circumcised. Many questions about the role of women in this time have been asked. Exodus again can be quoted when Zipporah took the flint rock and circumcised her son to save Moses and Israel. In today’s time, it is the mothers who bring their infant sons to the ceremonies and hold then during the rite. So possible it is the mothers who bear the greatest burden. Allowing man to bring harm, albeit relatively minimal harm, to the flesh of their flesh can be seen as a greater sacrifice for the lord. Maybe this is the role the Lord intended for women, to be the giver of the great descendants. One of the things I learned while studying this topic was how Moses may not have been circumcised but the act of Zipporah circumcising their son proved to the Lord that Moses, as well as Zipporah, was a strong believer in the word. The fact that she was strong enough to singlehandedly perform this task, and then touch Moses with his son’s blood almost anointed them. Once the bloodshed, as a sign of belief, touches Moses, he too is now protected by the act. Another thing I came to understand is woman role in this ritual. No the Lord may not have included woman as the one to undergo the circumcision, but it does affect her life as well. If the population of the world is to continue, we need to have descendants. If circumcision helps with fertility, then women do have a hand in this. The last thing I now know is why this ritual is still practiced today in the Jewish religion. Many Americans do opt for this procedure to be done on their sons prior to leaving the hospital. But members of the Jewish religion perform this on their sons at eight days old (Adler). This is continued covenant between them and the Lord.

Works Cited
Adler, Rabbi Sholom H. “The Origin of Bris Milah.” Bris Milah: Traditional Jewish Circumcision (June 2009) Circlist. Web. March 2011.
Fuller Theological Seminary. Facility: John Goldingay. Web. 14 March 2011.
Goldingay, John. “The Significance of Circumcision.” Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 88 (Jun 2000) 3+. Ebsco Host. Web. 9 March 2011.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Female Genital Mutilation Theoretical Analysis

...practice FGM are subject to a forced circumcision procedure that often leads to lifelong physical and psychological implications. As such, anti-FGM discourse universalises the image of the ‘normal” female body by framing female circumcision as a barbaric human rights violation. In doing so, the Western world often fails to acknowledge the practice’s deep rooted cultural significance that have made women “prisoners of ritual”. It will be argued that in order to adequately resolve...

Words: 1215 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Circumcision Should Be Allowed

...There is much debate on whether newborn males should be circumcised or not. For many, it is a decision made by parents and is sometimes linked to religious or cultural practices. While religious or cultural reasons for circumcision remains debatable, there is much evidence supporting significant long-term health issues for the individual associated with not being circumcised, and there are public health concerns as well. In fact, the cost of circumcisions and treating their complications are only a fraction of the cost of treating future health disparities for individuals as well as the public health issues associated with uncircumcised individuals (Baker). It has even been estimated by Dr. Brian Morris, M.D., in a Mayo Clinic article that,...

Words: 973 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Janice Boddy Civilizing Women

...Only few westerners have thus far made an analysis upon the cultural significance of female genital cutting. In her book “Civilizing Women: British Crusades in Colonial Sudan” Janice Boddy (2007) manages to explore the values of traditions for Sudanese people in the historical context of colonial influence. Despite the fact that British imperialism has put its prominent contribution into the formation of modern Sudanese ideologies, it was not powerful enough in order to modify the existed culture. Likewise, Boddy provides a clear argument by referring to parallels between critics of FGM and the British imperialists through a racial implication and tragedy of the colonized. She truly explains why the practice of circumcision is considered a spiritual celebration by the culture representatives, stating that “each sex is…ritually completed, made whole and pure…Yet the circumcised female body is more; it is a metonym and an icon for embattled local society, an oasis of reproductive continuity guarded by its own scar tissue…and the defensive efforts of local men” .(Boddy 2007:90) Thus, this interpretation gives an insight into the reasons...

Words: 1565 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Baptism Debate

...The Baptism Debate The baptism debate remains central among Christians all over the world. It is one of the aspects that is considered to be a tenet in the Christina faith yet remains controversial in terms of significance. There are those who are of the view that baptism is only meant for infants. This is seen as a way of ushering them into the kingdom of God and the Christina faith. For others however, the baptism for infants is symbolic and there is need for a person to undergo a second baptism as an adult. The second baptism is said to signify the aspect of being born again and washing off the sinful nature. This debate has been raging for many yeas causing confusion in the Christian circles. This discussion seeks to examine both sides of the debate and ascertain the Biblical position on the issue. The Concept of Baptism Perhaps before looking at the concept of infant baptism versus adult baptism, it may be crucial to look at the entire concept as a whole. Baptism as concept is an act of cleansing that is done for purposes of washing off one’s sinful nature. It was therefore done symbolically to signify that one’s past has been washed off. One was therefore considered a new creature after going through baptism . The New Testament has covered quite extensively the issue of baptism. It begins with the Jesus Christ the Son of God. He approached John the Baptist and requested that he (John) should baptize Him. When Jesus was baptized, the heavens opened and God the father...

Words: 2087 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

The Promised Land

...First, the renewal of the rite of circumcision (5:1-9) serves as a rededication to the covenant in preparation for God's fulfillment of His promises (Hill and Walton 2000:169). The testimony of Joshua's generation underscores the fact that the people of God has to undergo pain and inconvenience to demonstrate their loyalty to their God. Next, the celebration of the Passover (5:10-12) provides opportunity to affirm their faith the power of God to deliver Israel and to dispossess the enemies. Further, the enjoyment of the fruit of the land was taken in anticipation of the fuller bounty God will...

Words: 613 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Judiasm

...Chasidic Judaism Heather Ramirez University of Phoenix/HUM 130 Abstract Judaism is a Jewish religion. In this essay you will read about Judaism and how Chasidics are the most ‘Joyous’ of the Jewish society. There will also be information in this report about Chasidic Judaism and what it means to be Chasidic. When did the Chasidic Movement start, in relation to Judaism? According to Rabbi Novack, when did Judaism begin? What are the three main Holidays in Judaism? How are Bat Mitzvah and a Bar Mitzvah similar, yet so different? Why do they believe so intensely about circumcision? Are Jewish people, the chosen people of God? Comparing Chasidic Judaism to Christianity? Let us start to explore the world, and find out what Chasidic Judaism is all about. The Start of Judaism Judaism started when Moses went up to the Mount of Sinai after leading God’s people out of Egypt. According to Rabbi Novack (personal communication 2009) ‘this occurs when God gave Moses the Ten Commandments and the Torah for the Jewish people to follow.’ Since Pharaoh would not release God’s people they would endure the seven plagues. The passage in the Torah Mosheh 2: Shemot /שׁמות is the same as in the Christian Bible; Exodus Chapter 12. The list of the Seven Great Plagues as listed on Bibleplus that allowed the Hebrews to leave Egypt is as follows but ten actually occurred: 1. The plague of blood 2. The plague of frogs 3. The plague of gnats 4. The plague of flies (God makes a distinction...

Words: 2773 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Beleiver's Baptism Book Review

...Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary Book Critique: Believer’s Baptism: Sign of the New Covenant in Christ A Paper Submitted to Professor Larry McDonald In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Course Ecclesiology Theo 620 By Matt Dover September 8, 2012 Bibliography Believer’s Baptism: Sign of the New Covenant in Christ. Thomas R. Schreiner & Shawn D. Wright. Nashville: B & H, 2007. 359 pages. Reviewed by Matt B. Dover Authorship Thomas R. Schreiner is the professor of New Testament Interpretation and the Associate Dean of Scripture and Interpretation at the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. Prior to this he served for 11 years at Bethel Theological Seminary, and he also taught New Testament at Azusa Pacific Seminary. Schreiner is the author of numerous books and articles. He is also the pastor of Clifton Baptist Church in Louisville, Kentucky. Shawn D. Wright is the Assistant Professor of Church History at the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. Prior to this he served the Southern Baptist churches in New England. Wright also serves as the pastor at Clifton Baptist Church alongside Schreiner. He is also noted for writing various articles and journals. He also serves as a member of the Evangelical Theological Society. Thesis Statement The goal of this book is to recover and maintain an adequate and proper view on the role of baptism in the believer’s life...

Words: 2138 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Female Genital Mutilation Paper

...Female Genital Mutilation (also incorrectly known as “female circumcision”) is an extreme cultural practice prevalent in much of North and West Africa as well as in parts of the Middle East and Asia, in which young women and girls are forced to undergo a procedure that alters or rather, mutilates their reproductive organs. Although Female Genital Mutilation, or FGM, is seen in many cultures as a way to promote purity and chastity, this paper will argue that it is in fact a reflection of the “deep-rooted inequality between sexes, and constitutes an extreme form of discrimination against women.” (WHO, 2014) Female Genital Mutilation is defined by any procedure that alters the exterior parts of a female’s reproductive organ. The literature describes four main types of FGM. The first type is called clitoridectomy. In this process surgery involves the full or partial removal of the clitoris. A second type is called excision and this occurs when the clitoris is also fully or partially removed. In addition, the labia minora is removed leaving just the labia majora intact. Infibulation is the most severe form of FGM and occurs when a seal is formed over the opening of the vagina by removing the inner or outer labia. A small hole is left for the passage of menstrual fluid and urine. The hole is...

Words: 1791 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Water Baptism

...This Topic Important? The subject of water baptism is important for several reasons. First of all, it is a commandment of Jesus Christ and an important part of His great commission. Christ said, “… go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you” (Matthew 28:19-20). It is obvious that if we do not properly understand or practice baptism, we are in danger of neglecting a very important desire of our Lord and Savior. Understanding the Bible’s teaching concerning water baptism is also important because we have an obligation to ensure that new converts to Christ understand the biblical view of baptism and its significance to their relationship with Christ. It would be very unfortunate for any believer to experience water baptism without really understanding its meaning. Finally, it is important to discuss this issue because there are a number of disagreements within Christianity related to baptism. Some of these are relatively minor, but others are extremely important and are worth some discussion. Section A will first discuss some introductory matters regarding the meaning of the word “baptism” and the different kinds of baptism in the New Testament (NT). Section B will cover specifically what the Bible teaches concerning the purpose, recipients, and method of water baptism. Finally, Section C will address some of the more controversial issues such...

Words: 10506 - Pages: 43

Free Essay

Secrecy Surrounding the Practice of Female Circumcision in Mabvuku and Tafara Surburbs

...CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION Female circumcision is a traditional practice performed on girl children as part of initiation rituals into adulthood. This inquiry seeks to demystify the secretiveness surrounding this practice, seeking to establish the reasons why female circumcision remains a taboo subject. In doing so, the researcher will attempt to establish the local community’s perception of female circumcision and elucidate some of the reasons practitioners cite as benefits of female circumcision. The research focuses on Mabvuku and Tafara suburbs because there are people of different ethnic groups with varying customs and values that shape their behaviour and way of life. Mabvuku and Tafara have an unusually high concentration of people of Malawian, Mozambican and Zambian origin who migrated to seek work mostly before the Zimbabwean independence. Due to this diversity, women and girls who have undergone female circumcision were interviewed. Mabvuku is a high-density suburb some seventeen kilometres east of Harare. It is classified as a suburb or township of Harare, with the Harare City Council constituting local government. This inquiry is exploratory, descriptive and qualitative in nature, based on interviews with women who had undergone the practice in Mabvuku-Tafara. The inquiry can be termed therefore, a qualitative research done through a case study design. This research method is preferred because the researcher is exploring a subjective understanding of social reality...

Words: 24160 - Pages: 97

Free Essay

Augustie and Infant Baptism

...Dear Charles, Here's a possible rewrite of your thesis: "This paper will examine Augustine's teachings about 'conferred faith' upon infant during baptism. My claim is that Paul misrepresented Paul's teachings on the family's effect upon the holiness of the child." You'll find the "claim" in chapters 1-14 of Turabian's Manual, which is something that our rubric doesn't bring up, but I think it's a good technique. I notice that you have Greek written in Times New Roman font. I have seen other students do this. I have never been able to figure out how this is done. I notice that when I try to add a letter than it comes out in Latin script. These are quotations that you've pasted. This is amazing. I don't know how they do this! Let me know if you can help me! The only defect in this paper that I want to point out is that much of your paper is not really about Augustine's teaching on infant baptism. All subsequent developments of his teachings really have nothing to do with what happened in Augustine's head. Let's take Pannenberg as an example. He may have followers up there in Lutheran country where you minister. His ideas are influenced by Augustine, but Augustine was not a Lutheran. Some seem to think he was a Lutheran or a Calvinist, but they deceive themselves. You must, of course, take Paul into account because Augustine worked with Paul's writings. Paul was a source that Augustine used—or better, abused or misused, as you and argue. Students find it impossible to focus on one...

Words: 6374 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Judaism

...Part Two Write a 1- to 2-paragraph response for each of the following. 1. Describe the three major sections of the Jewish bible. Include what is contained in each section and the significance of each. As a whole the Hebrew bible is 24 books and those are divided into 3 sections; the Torah, Nevi’im and the Ketuvim. The first book the Torah is also called the Pentateuch. It contains all the rules and instructions as they were given to Moses. The five books of Moses are; Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy. The second book, Nevi’im is a collection of the Former Prophets. Here you will find stories and their teachings about the return of Israel to God. The last book, Ketuvim, contains poetry, theology and drama. The Hebrew Bible is thought of by Christians as the Old Testament. This is because all of the teachings found in it are before Jesus Christ. You can find the prophecy of Jesus’ birth in Isaiah 7:14 2. Describe the major similarities and differences between the four branches of Judaism (Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, Reconstructionist). How are these four groups distinct from one another? The similarity between all four is very simple. They are all very proud of their faith and view it not only as religion but as a life style that they identify themselves as Jewish before anything else. Each one does have strong values and want to better their religion. The differences seem to be more in where they interact with the world...

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Judaic Religion Research Paper

...consists of several different covenants. For example, Abraham made the first Covenant with God, which was symbolized by circumcision. The second covenant was between Noah and God during a flood that wiped out the world. In addition, the symbol of this covenant is still a rainbow. The Mosaic covenant goes after the Noah’s one and provides both the oral and written Torah. In fact, precisely during this covenant, the Israelites were considered by God the chosen people, who have exceptional significance for His power and revelation on the Earth. The last covenant, mentioned in the Hebrew Bible, is between the king David and God. During this covenant, the Jewish people got the royal dynasty of the kings from David’s descendants and the First Temple. In fact, in comparison with the Christian religion, the Bible also includes the same covenants, as the Hebrew one. However, all these covenants refer to the Old Testament or the time before Christ as the Christian Messiah. The New Testament enriched the ancient covenants with the new one, between Jesus Christ as the God’s Son and His omnipotent Father. National differences and racial identity do not have value after this covenant, as Christ has already saved every soul by His physical death and further resurrection. As the researchers explain, “In this model the New Covenant replaces the Old Covenant, baptism replaces circumcision, and the Gospel replaces the Law” (Poorthuis, Schwartz, and Turner, p. 410). However, Judaism does not agree with...

Words: 1697 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Contemporary Issues of Christianity Paper

...Contemporary Issues in Western Religions Harry Potter REL/134 November 20, 2011 UoP Instructor Contemporary Issues in Western Religions Religious beliefs have been the center of many conflicts across the entire world since the beginning of time. Christianity, Islam, and Judaism the major monotheist religious traditions have been at the heart of many of those religious conflicts. Historical connections and theological similarities are prevalent between the three. In parallel to the similarities exists the contemporary struggles affecting these western religious traditions. From the internal struggles within Christianity such as abortion, to its struggles with Islam and Muslim extremists, finally to the contempt against Christianity from actions of the Holocaust, each tradition faces contemporary struggles within their own right. Gaining a better understanding and insight into the historical, theological, and contemporary struggles between Christianity, Islam, and Judaism will enhance appreciation for each belief. Historical Connections and Theological Similarities: One main pillar of similar theology between Christianity, Islam, and Judaism is the belief in one god. However, each has different perspectives in relation to God. For example, Christians believe in [pic]the Trinity[pic] of [pic]God; God the Father, the Son (Jesus[pic] Christ), [pic]and the Holy Spirit[pic] ("Judaism, Islam, Christianity-Comparison", 2002-2011). Also Christians consider Jesus...

Words: 2531 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Characteristics of Judaism

...* Characteristics of Judaism beliefs, ethics, rituals and ceremonies and sacred texts have impact in many ways on adherents and provides source of purpose and identity for individuals. * Gives meaning and guidance contemporary situations therefore is considered dynamic, living religion. * Judaism is monotheistic faith, mean Jews believe only One God. * God is beyond our ability to comprehend, but God is nevertheless present in our everyday lives. * The covenant is agreement Jewish people have with God.  * Jews believe one God, no other participated work creation God only being to whom they offer praise.  * Terms of covenant are summed in Ten Commandments reveal adherents must have respectful, obedient relationship with God live harmoniously and respectfully with others.  * In return God will never abandon his Chosen people and will provide salvation. * Jewish adherents ethical beliefs are derived from the 613 mitzvoth * Orthodox Jews believe given Moses on Mt. Sinai taught to Israelites as travelled desert promise land. * Other variants believe they may have also been delivered to other divinely inspired people over time. * 248 positive 365 negative commandments have been discussed and interpreted throughout centuries by divinely inspired philosophers and rabbis so they can provide guidance in every aspect of everyday life. * many sacred writings in Judaism, all teach Judaism's adherents how to live ethical and moral...

Words: 968 - Pages: 4