...met by the claimant in a case involving wrongful dismissal? INTRODUCTION According to Ashgar Ali Mohamed (2004), "At common law, the employer-employee relationship is contractual; the employer may terminate the contract of employment by serving appropriate notice, as expressed in the contract or implied reasonable notice. Wrongful dismissal occurs when the employee is dismissed without notice or with inadequate notice". SUPPORTING CASE: MASSEY V CROWN LIFE INSURANCE CO (1978) According to HM Revenue and Customs UK, "Mr. Massey was the manager of a branch of the Crown Life Insurance Company of Canada from 1971 until 1973; he was an employee of the company. It paid him wages from which it deducted tax, NICs and graduated pension contributions. He also made contributions to the firm’s pension scheme". Moreover, in 1973 by mutual consent "the company engaged him on a self-employed basis under a new agreement. His duties under this new agreement were almost identical to those under his previous contract of service. The only real differences were that he no longer made pension contributions and the company paid him gross without any deductions for tax etc. This arrangement continued until 1975 when the company dismissed him. Mr. Massey then claimed unfair dismissal". DECISION OF THE CASE The Industrial Tribunal decided that Mr. Massey was not employed under a contract of service and therefore could not claim unfair dismissal. The EAT upheld this decision, as did the Court...
Words: 2889 - Pages: 12
...FDA RETAIL MANAGEMENT Retail Law – LO3 Jake McBride CLC ID: 106639 UW ID: 1091947288421 Table of Contents TERMS OF REFERENCE 3 FINDINGS 3 CONTRACTS OF EMPLOYMENT 3 IMPLIED AND EXPRESS TERMS IN AN EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT 4 DISMISSAL 5 UNFAIR DISMISSAL 6 ELIGIBILITY TO CLAIM UNFAIR DISMISSAL 7 WAS A FAIR PROCEDURE FOLLWED? 8 DISABILITY DISCRIMINATION 8 REMEDIES 9 UNFAIR DISMISSAL CLAIM 9 DISABILITY DISCRIMINATION 9 CONCLUSION 10 RECOMMENDATIONS 10 BIBLIOGRAPHY 11 TERMS OF REFERENCE I work as legal advisor for a national toy chain, Playtime. I am going to produce a report examining common law and statutory issues raised by a former employee who may pursue a case for constructive dismissal. I hope to advise Playtime of any action Miss Parry may take in light of her departure from the company and will give recommendations and remedies which may apply to this scenario. FINDINGS CONTRACTS OF EMPLOYMENT An employment contract, or ‘contract of employment’, is an agreement between an employer and an employee which sets out their employment rights, responsibilities and duties. These are called the ‘terms' of the contract. (DirectGov, Online, Accessed 18/12/2010) Employment contracts do not have to be in writing, they can be word of mouth. However, every employee is entitled to a written statement containing employment terms and conditions within 2 months of starting work. The statement must contain a number of relevant details such as Hours...
Words: 2219 - Pages: 9
...Dear Siphokazi I write regarding your request for advice on your recent dismissal from the financial firm you’ve worked for the past 6 years. Dismissal is the employer’s termination a contract of employment and whilst dismissals are not uncommon practice in organisations, circumstances where one feels injustices have occurred, have grounds for an appeal through external systems (Bendix, Sonia, 2010). Most dismissal appeal cases aim to result in reinstatement, but seeing as you have interests in receiving compensation, and having the injustices of your dismissal corrected, below I shall outline steps you can take to achieve this through the CCMA or Labour Court. The two options I explains have differing weightings on their likelihood to produce justice (ie. Probable ruling in your favour) and their degree of compensation. I shall end off by advising you based on these weightings. To start the appeal process for any of the options I will suggest, you will need to send a written referral to the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA), seeing as financial institutions do not have a bargaining council of their own (Bendix, Sonia, 2010. This should be done within the 30 days from the date you were informed or given notice of dismissal, which in your case is probably when you received the outcome of your disciplinary hearing. You can find the prescribed form for referrals through this link, which once completed, should be copied for delivery to your employer...
Words: 1497 - Pages: 6
...to achieve and maintain standards of conduct, attendance and job performance to ensure consistent and fair treatment between employer and employees. Extract from (Disciplinary rules and procedures, 2004, para.60), a good disciplinary procedure should: * Be put in writing and tell employees what mistake they do. * Say to whom they apply and note them orally especially those difficult in langue problem. * All the issue will deal without undue delay and promptly. * All relevant information will be kept as confidential. * Explain to employees what disciplinary action might be taken and let them know about the authority disciplinary action decision will be act by which level of management, so make it clear to prevent unfair dismissal. * Require employees to be informed of the complaints against them and supporting evidence, before meeting * Give employees a chance to state about their cases, show evidence and witnesses, and also the right to be accompainion before any decision reached by management. * Provide that no employees are dismissed...
Words: 2573 - Pages: 11
...Security company Security company Sam‘s Termination UNFAIR DISMISSAL Report Soo Shew Yeang, Team Manager Firrst Defense— 666 forest road Hurstville New South West Australia EMAIL: firstdenfense@gmail.com 27.10.2015 Introduction SAM is an employee of a small security company. She is upset because previously she has missed some projects and right now she is working at a project new programming language which is not she is not familiar with it. As manager I have been asked to assess SAM’s difficulties and track progress of SAM at workplace. SAM has been consulting to Doctor due facing stress problem at her work. In a meeting SAM walked off because of her poor health. The medical certificate has been filed with Human resource department when meeting was going to be held with me. Decision has been decided by supervisor, my Human Resources department and me to dismiss Sam on the basis of serious misconduct from Security Company by sending a registered mail to Sam’s personal mail address. SAM took an action by filling a case of unfair dismissal with Australia Industrial Relation Commission. SAM has won case of hearing because there was no evidence related to fair dismissal process of SAM. It was being analysed that due to poor management and loopholes in the Human Resources system. SAM won case and penalty was being paid to her. Company did not...
Words: 3394 - Pages: 14
...Assignment One Part One Question Two The numbers of self employed workers has grown significantly in the last twenty years and, in 2008, amounted to approximately four million people, compared to over twenty seven million employees. Over two thirds of the self employed have no employees themselves, and are dependent upon using their own skills and labour. (Julie Bevan, Barriers to Business Start Up: A study of the flow into and out of self employment. Department of Employment Research Paper no 71) Determining whether a worker is an employee or not is the first action of any court during a tribunal. This is very important as employers have a large amount of liabilities to their employees, but not to their other workers, for example self employed or sub contractors. Certain laws are dependent on the nature of the employment for example The Working Time Regulations 1998 (2002 IRLR 96) refers in reg. 4(1), to a workers working time, whilst the Maternity and Parental Leave etc regulations 1999 only refers to employees. There are various benefits to workers being employees. An Employee pays far higher national insurance contributions than self employed workers; however this gives employees the rights to state benefits relating to sickness, unemployment and pension rights. Whereas self employed workers are not entitled to any of these benefits. Self-employed workers also have no rights to holiday pay or allowances, therefore anytime they do spend not working directly impacts...
Words: 3353 - Pages: 14
...Weekly Review Workbook for Manage Employee Relations Student Name: Student Number: Assessment Task 1 – Written Assessment - Workbook Assessment One: Manage Employee Relations Content Revision Areas for Test Chapter 1 & Lecture Notes What is Workplace Relations? 1. The working relationships between employers and employees 2. The relationship between management and labour, shaped by individual employers and employees and by employer and employee organisations and government institutions, that exist at a workplace or in an industry and influences how effectively they work together to achieve their joint and separate goals. Name the measures of an organisation’s Workplace Relations? labour turnover absenteeism rates how easily an organisation is able to recruit the employees it needs The number of official grievances registered Material ‘shrinkage’, wastage and ‘spoilage’ Days lost through industrial action What are the three views of Workplace Relations? Define them. 1) THE PLURIST VIEW 2) THE UNITARIST VIEW 3) THE RADICAL VIEW 1. THE PLURIST VIEW Conflict as inherent due to diversity of goals and can be managed and contained by rules and regulations. 2. THE UNITARIST VIEW Conflict as occasional and temporary because employees and employers share same basic goals (creating wealth & value) so relations are essentially harmonious. 3. THE RADICAL VIEW Conflict systemic & never ending...
Words: 3068 - Pages: 13
...GOOD PRACTICE IN MANAGING EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS GUIDANCE LEAFLET. Understand the impact of employment law at the start of the employment relationship Internal and external factors that impact on the employment relationship Internal: • Performance, pay and reward: employers should set clear and transparent targets in order to make it easier for employees to know what is expected of them. If these targets are followed employees can be rewarded and this should improve the relationship between employer and employee. • Management style: there are two types of manager: autocratic and democratic. Autocratic managers make decisions without involving the staff. This can be a good idea in some circumstances (for example the need to make a quick decision to avoid catastrophe or missing a deadline or target) but if this style is used all of the time it can be detrimental to staff motivation, commitment and well-being. Democratic managers involve staff with decision making as much as possible which means everything is agreed on by the majority of staff. This can lead to increased levels of motivation, commitment and well-being which subsequently could increase the profitability of the business. External: • Economic factors: slow economic growth or a downturn can make employees just thankful they have a job. This can put pressure on them because employers may decide to increase workload by making individuals do more work in the same time. With the fear of redundancy looming and...
Words: 3077 - Pages: 13
...1: Everyone has the right to fair labour practices 2: Every worker has the right to * join and form a trade union * to participate in the activities of the trade union * Strike. 3: Every employer has the right to * join an employer’s organization * Participate in the activities and programs of the organization. The right that everyone has to fair labour practices helps by protecting the employee against unfair acts/omission between an employer and employee, involving: Unfair Promotion – for instance not promoting someone who is eligible, or discriminating against certain individuals whilst promoting others. Unfair demotion – for instance demotion (even in the event where the employer has reason to terminate the contract, for instance where the employee has been performing poorly) without consultation with the employee. – Unfair Training – for instance by providing training to some employees and not to others, where there is no justifiable reason or in breach of for example a collective agreement Unfair suspension – for instance by suspending an employee for no reason, Or by suspending him or her without pay or for prolonged periods. Failure to reinstate a former employee where there was an agreement – for instance in a case of retrenchment, where the employer decides to reinstate some of the employees he or she previously dismissed, but not others. Prejudice (occupational detriment) suffered because of protected disclosure – the...
Words: 2371 - Pages: 10
...Manage people performance Assessment Task- 2 Name – Kanubhai Vinodkumar Patel Student Id - 1410250 Topic – Disciplinary process- Case study Introduction: The purpose of this report is to provide the background and reasons why the decisions by Fair Work Australia were made in Sam’s favour. It identifies areas the company needs to address and implement in order to prevent this type of situation from occurring again. Work History as Sam’s Team Manager As Sam’s Team Manager I was aware that my predecessors response when dealing with her lacked in encouragement and was poorly handled. Sam is a diligent worker however, due to the company changing programming language to one Sam was unfamiliar with she has been unable to meet specific deadlines. Time was spent with Sam trying to understand her issues and Resources relocated in order to allow Sam extra time until she was confident and competent using the new programming language. The offer of additional training was made , but no specific timelines for a performance review to discuss progress on meeting the required standard of performance were given. During the final meeting with Sam about her inability to meet her latest deadline, Sam physically struck myself and left the office. A Medical certificate was sent to the office the following day, advising Sam was unfit for work due to stress. The receipt of this medical certificate was confirmed over the phone by...
Words: 1122 - Pages: 5
...Contract And Employment Law Course Work Unit code: U15019 Stufent ID: 515346 Introduction The questions whether Clarissa can successfully sue Precision Missiles plc to compensate her for unfair dismissal will hugely depend on whether her dismissal with six months’ notice was unfair. At the same time, Clarissa’s acceptance of Flare’s offer would be depended firstly on whether there was express to “garden leave” clause and whether she can lawfully take on that offer without breaching her contract with Precision Missiles. I will try to establish the circumstances under which the garden leave clause is valid and applicable. I will then review some of previous cases where ruling in such circumstances were made with the sole aim of establishing which course of action Clarissa could take with regard to her claim of unfair dismissal and whether she can go ahead and take Flare Missiles job offer without breaching her contract with Precision Missiles plc. In this regard, I would be able to offer her better advice concerning what action she could take and the consequences associated with each action. Discussion This discussion will start with first explaining the ‘Garden leave’ clause in relation to employment contracts and proceed to explicate the extent of its enforceability. This will be with the aim of finding out whether Clarissa can be able to successfully proceed with her compensation claim of unfair dismissal and under what grounds she should do that. According to Smith...
Words: 2406 - Pages: 10
... lawful approach and rules are reasonable. It has appeared to be reasonable when dealing with both organisation formal and informal disciplinary proceedings ,clearly distinguish serious from lesser offences which are in line with the code of good practise as well as imposed penalties including the sanctions for FAIS registered employees and the consistency in the application, Having regard to the circumstances of the case, the Group reserves the right to impose a lesser or harsher sanction at its discretion However it lacks providing awareness especially the lower levels employees who has a culture of waiting for the management to inform and/or direct such employees to important work related information as the group awareness policy practise is for all employees to read through the disciplinary policy in their personal time but required to log onto the internal system ESS Employee porta for the acknowledgement of the policy for audit purposes .This practise excludes the importance of employees ‘s understanding of the contents which may impose a risk for the organi Disciplinary action will be considered in all cases where management becomes aware of an act of misconduct. Where the eventual outcome could be a final written warning or dismissal, the nature of the offence and the effect on the organisation is considered when deciding on the appropriate action. Depending on the seriousness of the offence, the nature of the disciplinary action will differ. This could include: ...
Words: 1451 - Pages: 6
...can lead to happier, more motivated and better performing employees. Reviewing, refining and implementing performance management systems are ways of helping achieve these significant benefits. What is underperformance? Underperformance or poor performance can be exhibited in the following ways: · unsatisfactory work performance, that is, a failure to perform the duties of the position or to perform them to the standard required · non-compliance with workplace policies, rules or procedures · unacceptable behaviour in the workplace · disruptive or negative behaviour that impacts on co-workers. Underperformance is not the same as misconduct. Misconduct is very serious behaviour such as theft or assault which may warrant instant dismissal. In cases of misconduct employers should seek...
Words: 2772 - Pages: 12
...STUDENT NAME (print): Manal Al Aswad | PROGRAMME START DATE: March 2014 | PROGRAMME TITLE: CHRP | COURSE LOCATION: Abu Dhabi | PERSONAL TUTOR: Tim | ASSIGNMENT TITLE: (3MER) Supporting Good Practice in Managing Employee Relations | SUBMISSION: 1ST 4th Extension (delete) | DATE OF SUBMISSION: April 20, 2015 | Before submitting your work to www.bradfield.co.uk please read the following statements and tick the appropriate box to show that you have understood and completed what is required. 1. I have read my work through and have checked it for spelling and grammatical errors using, where appropriate the spell and grammar checker on the computer. | | 2. I have written my name at the top of each page of my work and have numbered each page. | | 3. I have read the definition of plagiarism. I realise that plagiarism is cheating and can confirm that the assignment I am submitting is my own work. | | The definition of plagiarism is given below. Read it carefully and note what it says. ‘Plagiarism is the act of presenting the ideas or discoveries of another as one’s own. To copy sentences, phrases or even striking expressions without acknowledgement in a manner which may deceive the reader as to the source is plagiarism; to paraphrase in a manner which may deceive the reader is likewise plagiarism. Where such copying or close paraphrase has occurred the mere mention of the source in a bibliography will not be deemed sufficient acknowledgement;...
Words: 4212 - Pages: 17
...of the organisation may also play a part in how stringent the rules can be. These rules are unilaterally determined by the employer and can be lawfully changed by management at any time. A refusal to adhere to the revised rules amounts to a breach of contract i.e. failure to obey lawful and reasonable instructions. External 1. Statute. Statutory rights are legal requirements. All employees, regardless of the number of hours per week they work, have certain legal rights, for example: • the right to a written statement of terms of employment within two months of starting work • the right to be paid at least the national minimum wage • the right to a paid holiday • the right to Maternity/Paternity/Adoption leave 2. ACAS Code of...
Words: 3351 - Pages: 14