Premium Essay

Veel D Hiv Round Up Analysis

Submitted By
Words 524
Pages 3
Julia Jarmond, an American journalist married to a Frenchmen, is working at a magazine in Paris. She is appointed to write an article about the Vel d’Hiv roundup of Jews in Paris, in 1942. While doing research she uncovers that the family apartment she is supposed to move into with her husband was directly involved in the roundup. Bertrand’s family acquired the apartment she and her husband plan to move into when its Jewish occupants were dispossessed and deported 60 years before. She makes it her mission to find out what happened to the former occupants: Wladyslaw and Rywka Starzynski, parents of 10-year-old Sarah and four-year-old Michel. As Sarah digs into the story of Jewish survival, the more she learns about her family and herself.
This film contributes to our understanding of the Holocaust because it shows viewers that the Holocaust was not an isolated incident in Germany. There were thousands of places across Europe that were touched by Nazi polices. One of the reasons I enjoyed this film is because you did not …show more content…
I found that the modern day story with the baby and marriage issues took away from the importance of the Vel d’Hiv roundup. The actors did an excellent job of portraying the emotions that a Jewish family might have had in all of the concentration camp scenes, particularly the one where Sarah and her mother are separated. I also enjoyed that the director choose to show a softer side to one of the Nazi guards. While I know that a majority of guards were cruel and mean, I liked that one of the guards seemed to be watching out for Sarah, especially after her parents had been sent to Auschwitz. Another part of the movie that I enjoyed was watching Sarah’s son learn about his mother. He had no idea about the trials and tribulations his mother had endured, and the fact that he finally was able to learn about them made me

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Veel D Hiv Round Up Analysis

...devastated that he had died. She believed that it was her fault that he was dead. She blamed herself for all of it. In the same sense, I think that Julia will decide not to abort the baby because she will know that it was her fault that she ended the life of the human inside her. Because of what Sarah went through, I think that will convince Julia too that if she lets the baby go, she is causing his or her’s death. She will understand how important it is to keep a child and let him or her live a good life, unlike most Jewish children. Sarah’s story will have a big impact on Julia. I think that she will decide to keep the baby because of hearing Sarah’s story. Julia will realize how important it is to let her child live, so that he or she can grow up and have a chance to become something in the world, unlike the Jewish children who died. Julia states, “My last chance of being a mother. I kept thinking of what Charla had said: “This is your child, too.” (167) Even though she knows that Bertrand will probably leave her, it does not matter. She needs to do what is best for her and the baby. While she has this chance to give birth to a child, she should take it. She would be better off without Bertrand anyways. He is a jerk, and she knows it. ...

Words: 535 - Pages: 3